SPP 2013 DC Case Status.pdf

) )SPA 2013 DC STATUS OF CASES

As of May 06, 2013

MUN. / CITY / PROVINCE

SPA2013 TITLE O F THE CASE

----------------- -^------------------------

STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS

1. Cordova,Cebu

II

13-001(DC)

Mayor Adelino B. Sitoy

vs.

Rex Ong Salud a.k.a. W akee Salud

Resolution (SD) - x^x the instant Petition is GRANTED. Accordingly,\the COC of respondent Rex Ong Salud is hereby CANCELLED

w1 MR (to the Resolution d lted Dec. 26, 2012) filed by respondent-movant on January 10, 2013

Resolution No. 9614 - xxx In view of the foregoing, there being no order or resolution emanating from the higher courts restraining the implementation of the aforementioned final and executory decision, the Commission RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to CANCEL the Certificate of Candidacy filed by and REMOVE from the Certified List of Candidates the name of Rex Ong Salud a.k.a. Wakee Salud as Mayor of Cordova, Cebu in the May 13, 2013 NLE for failure to comply with the qualifications of an elective local official/ Let the Law Dept, implement this Resolution

December 26, 2012

January 15, 2013

2. Councilor District 6,

Quezon City

I

13-002(DC)

In Re: Petition to disqualify Ma. Theresa E. Gana as candidate for councilor of District 6, Quezon City

Nino A. Holgado

vs.

Ma. Theresa E. Gana--------------------1------------------------------------

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISM ISS this

case for being M OOT and ACADEMICJanuary 10,

2013

)MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE

SPA2013 TITLE OF THE CASE

\


3. Lone District of Camiguin

II

13-003(DC-F)

Pedro P. Romualdo

vs.

Homobono A. Adaza

For: To Deny Due Course or To Cancel COC

I Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby 'DISMISSED

Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

\

\

January 21, 2013

February 07, 2013

4. Bacolod City, Negros Occidental

1

13-004(DC)

In Re: Petition to declare candidate Julius S. Sayson as nuisance candidate

in the coming May 13, 2013 Midterm Election

Jude Thaddeus A. Sayson

vs.

Julius S. Sayson

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby GRAFTED. JULIUS S. SAYSON is hereby declared as NUISANCE CAN D ID A TE and his Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Mayor of Bacolod City, is hereby ordered CANCELLED

January 29, 2013

5. Dingras, llocos Norte

1

13-005(DC)

i

Erdio E. Valenzuela

vs.

Marynette R. Gamboa

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to GRANT the Petition. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Mayor of Dingras, llocos Norte filed by the respondent Marynette R. Gamboa is hereby DENIED DUE C O U RSE AND CANCELLED for misrepresenting her eligibility to the position for which the Certificate of Candidacy was filed, pursuant to Section 78, in relation to Section 74, both of the O EC and Section 40 (e) of the Local Government Code

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY this Motion for Reconsideration for LACK OF MERIT. Consequently, March 6, 2013 Resolution of the Commission First Division is hereby affirmed

March 06, 2013

April 19, 2013

1

Page 2 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) )MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE


V


6. Science City of Munoz,

Nueva Ecija

II

13-006(DC)

Ester Abrina Lazaro

vs.

Jerry Urmatan Lazaro*

\\Order {SD) - xxx the Commission (SD) hereby orders as follows: 1. To NOTE the Manifestation/Motion To Withdraw Petition" filed on Oct. 24, 2012 with attached Sworn Affidavit of Withdrawal of COC dated Oct. 15, 2012; 2. To CO NSIDER this instant petition withdrawn as prayed for by the petitioner Ester Abrina Lazaro assisted by Atty. Francisco B. Sibayan, counsel for petitioner; and 3. To CANCEL the CONFERENCE scheduled on Nov. 9, 2012

November 06, 2012

7. Dipolog City, Zamboanga

del Norte

II

13-007(DC)

Julius B. GajoViera

vs.

Cecilia G. Jalosjos-Carreon

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Course to Respondent Cecilia G. Jalosjos-Carreon's Certificate of Candidacy

January 24, 2013

8. First District of Quezon

City

I

13-008(DC)

Rita Katherine D. Crisologo

vs.

Albert Crisologo

Resolution (FD) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED. Respondent Albert Crisologo is hereby declared as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and his Certificate of Candidacy for Congressman of District I, Quezon City, for the 13 May 2013 NLE is CANCELLED

January 31, 2013

9. Libon, Albay

1

13-009(DC)

John Vasquez Dycoco

vs.

Domingo B. Samson

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS this case for LACK OF MERIT

January 10, 2013

10.

*

Lone District of Bacoor,

Cavite

1

13-010(DC)

Jessie B. Castillo

vs.

Leonardo C. Castillo

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to G RANT the instant petition. LEO NARDO C. CASTILLO is hereby DECLARED as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE and accordingly, his C O C is hereby CANCELLED

Order (FD) - xxx hereby DENIES said motion for the

December 11, 2012

i

Page 3 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

)M U N ./C IT Y /PROVINCE

SPA201x3

\

TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS\

\

1

following reasons: 1. Failure to pay the corresponding fee for filing a motion for reconsideration; and 2. Lacking the number of copies required by the rules / The motion for reconsideration will still be denied for being pro-forma

January 22, 2013

11. Tubao, La Union

I

13-011(DC)

^ Wilfredo S. Garcia

vs.

Wilfredo G. Garcia

Resolution (FD) - xxx resolves to G R A NT the instant Petition. Respondent Wilfredo G. Garcia is declared as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE, accordingly, his Certificate of Candidacy is hereby DENIED and CANCELLED

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED for lack of merit

January 29, 2013

May 03, 2013

12. Cortes,Bohol

I

13-012(DC)

Atty. Claudita M. Gifard

vs.

Roberto L. Tabanera

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition dated 29 October 2012

March 21, 2013

13. Pagalungan,Maguindanao

il

13-013(DC)

Giamaludin Nor

vs.

Mohammad S. Andoy

Resolution (SD) - xxx resolves to uphold the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent MOHAMMAD S. ANDOY for the mayoralty position in the Municipality of Pagalungan, Province of Maguindanao

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED

January 16, 2013

April 24, 2013

14. TurtleIslands,

Tawi-Tawi

II

13-014(DC)

Mibaral M. Tang

vs.

Mardan M. Julkanain

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISM ISSED for lack of merit


January 16, 2013

February 21, 2013

r

MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE

SPA2013 TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS

DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS

\15. I Turtle

Islands, Tawi-Tawi

\\ 1

\ft\

13-015(DC)

Mibaral M. Tang

vs.

Rodolfo M. Velasquez

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to G R A NT the Petition dated 08 October 2012. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent RODOLFO M. VELASQUEZ is hereby EXCLUDED for failure to comply with Section 73 of the OEC

January 22, 2013

\\

\

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT respondent Rodolfo M. Velasquez Motion for Reconsideration (Of the Resolution dated 22 January 2013), SET ASIDE the Commission (First Division) Resolution dated 22 January 2013 and G IVE DUE CO URSE to respondents Certificate of Candidacy. The Law Dept, is hereby DIRECTED to endorse the records of this case to the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, Committee on Bar Discipline, for their appropriate action against Atty. Carlo B. Gomez

April 05, 2013 \\

16. TurtleIslands,

Tawi-Tawi

II

13-016(DC)

Mibaral M. Tang

vs.

Sarajul M. Jihim

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISM ISSED for lack of merit


January 21, 2013

March 13, 2013

17. TurtleIslands,

Tawi-Tawi

1

13-017(DC)

Mibaral M. Tang

vs.

Taha S. Sadalani

Submitted for resolution

18. Quezon City

II

13-018(DC)

Herbert M. Bautista

vs.

Romeo Romy S. Acebedo

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the. May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 3. Acebedo, Romeo Sanchez - Mayor -

January 11, 2013

Page 5 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

)MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE


DATED/PROMULGATED

\REMARKS

Quezon City xxx \19. Province of

Agusan del Norte

II

13-019(DC)

In Re: Petition for declaration of George M. Lumongsod as a nuisance

candidate for Governor in the Province of Agusan del Norte in the May 13,

2013 Elections

Ma. Angelica Rosedell Amante-Matba

vs.

George M. Lumongsod

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 23. Lumongsod, Jorge Maceda - Governor - Agusan del Norte xxx

January 11, 2013

\\a

\

20. Province of Surigao del

Sur

II

13-020(DC)

In the matter of Petition to declare Iberet Murillo Correos as nuisance

candidate

Manuel O. Alameda, Sr.

vs.

Iberet Murillo Correos

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED

January 02, 2013

21. Province of Surigao del

Sur

II

13-021(DC)

In the matter of the Petition to declare Edwin G. Deligero as nuisance

candidate for the Office of Governor of Surigao del Sur

Johnny T. Pimentel

vs.

Edwin Deligero

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS this Petition for LACK OF MERIT

i

April 01, 2013

Page 6 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

)MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE


\


22. Leyte, Leyte

II

13-022(DC)

Andres Nautilus P. Salvacion

vs.

Arnold James M. Ysidoro

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition v is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit \


%\

March 12, 2013

March 27, 2013

23. Marcos, llocos Norte

II

13-023(DC)

Salvador S. Pillos

vs.

Arsenio A. Agustin

Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the petitions are hereby DENIED for lack of merit \

Resolution (EB) - xxx the MR of Petitioner Stewart D. De La Cruz in SPA No. 13-024 (DC) is denied fdy lack of merit. On the other hand, the Motion for Reconsideration of Petitioner Salvador S. Pillos in SPA No. 13-023 (DC) is granted; consequently, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Arsenio A. Agustin is hereby CANCELLED and DENIED DUE COURSE

January 28, 2013

April 23, 2013

24. Marcos, llocos Norte

II

13-024(DC)

Stewart T. De La Cruz

vs.

Napoleon A. Duldulao

Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the petitions are hereby DENIED for lack of merit

Resolution (EB) - xxx the MR of Petitioner Stewart D. De La Cruz in SPA No. 13-024 (DC) is denied for lack of merit. On the other hand, the Motion for Reconsideration of Petitioner Salvador S. Pillos in SPA No. 13-023 (DC) is granted; consequently, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Arsenio A. Agustin is hereby CANCELLED and DENIED DUE COURSE

January 28, 2013

April 23, 2013

rPage 7 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

)M U N ./C IT Y /

PROVINCESPA2013 TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS

\


25. South District,

Cebu City

1

13-025(DC)

Ronald O. Diola & Tisha Aisha Y. Gonzalez

vs.

Augustus Jun G. Pe, Jr.

Petition for Disqualificaation and/or To Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC

Resolution (FD) - \x x x RESOLVES, to GRANT the Petition dated 10 O&tober 2012. ACCORDINGLY, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Augustus Jun G. Pe, Jr., is hereby DENIED and CANCELLED

Order (FD) - xxx MRs elevated to en banc \

Omnibus Motion filed W pets-movants on April 29, 2013 ^

\

February 01, 2013

March 12 & 17, 2013

26. Bacacay,Albay

II

13-026(DC)

In Re: Petition for denial of due course to Certificate of Nomination and

Acceptance

Luis B. Hefti

vs.

Orlando Binamira

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent Binamiras Certificate of Nomination and Acceptance and UPHOLD his status as an official nominee of the Nacionalista Party in the 13 May 2013 Elections

January 21, 2013

27. Tayum,Abra

II

13-027(DC)

Placido Eduarte, Jr.

vs.

Jose Marie Brillantes y Mailed

i

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is GRANTED. The Certificate of Candidacy of JOSE MARIE M. BRILLANTES for Mayor of the Municipality of Tayum, Province of Abra is hereby DENIED DUE CO URSE and CANCELLED

Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant motion for reconsideration is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the January 28, 2013 Resolution of the Commission (SD) is hereby REVERSED and SET ASIDE

Manifesttion filed by petitioner through counsel on April 22, 2013 (no majority votes re Resolution April 12, 2013)

January 28, 2013

April 12, 2013

r Page 8 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) ' )



\STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS

28. Province of Zamboanga

del Sur

II

13-028(DC)

Antonio H. Cerilles \

vs.

Dominador G. Jalosjos, Jr.

Resolution No. 9612 - xxx/ In view of the foregoing, the Commission RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to CANCEL the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Dominador G. Jalosjos, Jr. as Governor of Zamboanga del Sur in the May 13, 2013 NLE/ Let the Law Dept,

implement this Resolution

January 15, 2013

29. 2na Dist. of Zamboanga

del Sur

II

13-029(DC)

Antonio H. Cerilles

vs.

Marjorie N. Jalosjos

Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit

OrCJer (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

February 01, 2013

March 13, 2013

30. 2na District of Cebu City

II

13-030(DC)

In Re: Petition to declare Bert L. Abella as nuisance candidate for the position of Member, Sangguniang Panlungsod

of the 2nd District of Cebu City in the upcoming May 13, 2013 Elections and

To Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC

Nendell Hanz L. Abella

vs.

Bert L. Abella

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates' Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 2. Abella, Bert Leo - Member, S. Panlungsod (2nd Dist.) - Cebu City xxx

January 11, 2013

31. Lakewood, Zamboanga

del Sur

II

13-031(DC)

-i----------------

Canuto Cavan Enerio, Jr. and Roger Bonghanoy Polinar

vs.

Jean Paul Villaflor Jalosjos

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit

February 01, 2013

r Page 9 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

MUN. / CITY PROVINCE



32. Tanjay City, Negros Oriental

II

13-032(DC)

In Re: Petition to Declare Edwin S. Teves a nuisance candidate and to

deny due course to or cancel his COC for Mayor, Tanjay City, Negros Oriental,

pursuant to Section 69 of the OEC

Lawrence S. Teves \Edwin S. ^evesResolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED, Edwin S. Tevess Certificate of Candidacy is hereby CANCELLEDwith Separate Concurring Opinion of Comm. Padaca

March 21, 2013

33. 1s' District of Palawan

II

13-033(DC)

Roberto V. Rodriguez

vs.

Randy M. Rodriguez

Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the consolidated cases are resolved as follows: In SPA No. 13-033 (DC), the petition to declare Randy M. Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is hereby DISMISSED. However, Randy M. Rodriguez is ordered not to use and place 'Toto" as the nickname to appear in the official ballot/ In SPA No. 13- 105 (DC)(F) the petition to declare Roberto Toto Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is also DISMISSED

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Omnibus Resolution dated January 28, 2013 is REVERSED and SET ASIDE. Accordingly, respondent Randy M. Rodriguez is declared a NUISANCE CANDIDATE. Consequently, his CERTIFICATE OF CANDIDACY is hereby CANCELLED

January 28, 2013

w / SPA 13-105

May 02, 2013

34.

i

SantiagoCity,

IsabelaProvince

II

13-034(DC)

Re: Petition for declaration of candidate as a nuisance candidate

Armando S. Tan

vs.

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is GRANTED. Respondent MARK ALVIN A. TAN is hereby DECLARED as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE and accordingly, his COC is hereby CANCELLED

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and

January 04, 2013

January 11, i

) )

MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE

SPA2013 TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS


\\\

Mark Alvin A. Tan to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 35. Tan, Mark Alvin Arquero - Mayor, - Santiago City, Isabela xxx

2013 \

35. Province of Abra

1

13-03 A (DC) ^

Eustaquio P. Bersamin

vs.

\ Joel B. Bersamina

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 10. Bersamina, Joel Bicera - Governor, - Province of Abra xxx

January 11, 2013

36. Bulakan,Buiacan

1

13-036(DC)

Patrick Neil F. Meneses

vs.

Emmanuel N. Meneses

Resolution (FD) - xxx the petitionis hereby GRANTED. Respondent Emmanuel N. Meneses is hereby declared as NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and his Certificate of Candidacy for Mayor of Bulakan, Buiacan, for the 13 May 2013 National and Local Elections is CANCELLED

January 21, 2013

37. Ramon,Isabela

1

13-037(DC)

Derrick M. Vizcarra

vs.

Wilfredo L. Tabag

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS this case for LACK OF MERIT

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration filed by petitioner Derrick M. Vizcarra is DENIED. Accordingly, the Resolution of the Commission (FD) promulgated on 23 Janaury 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED

January 23, 2013

April 23, 2013

38. Tineg, Abra

1

13-038(Dc)

In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or to Cancel COC for

Mayor of Cita Acosta Crisologo in the Municipality of Tineg, Abra

Corinthia Dannang Crisologo

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED

April 10, 2013

1


\M U N ./C IT Y /

PROVINCESPA2013 TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS


\\\ vs.

Cita Acosta Crisologo\

39. ^Tineg, Abra

\\ 1 \

\

13-039(DC)

Corinthia Dannang Crisologo

vs.

Cita Acosta Crisologo

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to GRANT the Petition. Accordingly, respondent Cita A. Crisologo is hereby DECLARED a nuisance candidate pursuant to Section 69 of the OEC

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to AFFIRM the First Divisions ruling declaring Respondent Cita Acosta Crisologo a nuisance candidate

January 22, 2013

March 22, 2013

\\\\a

\

40. Tineg, Abra

II

13-040(DC)

In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or To Cancel COC for

Mayor of Clemencio P. Ramirez in the Municipality of Tineg, Abra

Edwin B.Crisologo, Sr.

vs.

Clemencio P. Ramirez

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit

Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. Accordingly, the Decision of this Commission dated 16 January 2013 stands

January 16, 2013

March 22, 2013

41. Tineg, Abra

I

13-041(DC)

In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or To Cancel C O C for Mayor of Cromwell S. Luna in the Municipality of

Tineg, Abra

Edwin B. Crisologo, Sr.,

vs.

Cromwell S. Luna

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. The assailed Resolution of the Commissions First Division dated 29 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRM ED IN TOTO

i

January 29, 2013

April 05, 2013

Page 12 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) ) \\

MUN. / CITY / PROVINCE


DATED/PROMULGATED

\

REMARKS

42. Second District,

Agusan del Sur

II

13-042(DC)

Rodolfo Galido Plaza

vs.

Mauricio Cuevas Plaza, Jr.

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 29. Plaza, Mauricio Jr. C. - Member, House of Representatives (2nd Dist.) - Agusan del Sur xxx

January 11, 2013

\\\

43. Province of Agusan del

Sur

1

13-043(DC)

Victor Galido Plaza

vs.

Mariano Curato Plaza

Submitted for resolution \\

44. ZamboangaCity

II

13-044(DC)

Marinao Isabelle G. Climaco-Salazar

vs.

Romeo Garcia Jalosjos

Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESOLVES, to CANCEL and DENY due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE

January 15, 2013

45. SantiagoCity

1

13-045(DC)

In Re: Petition to Deny Due Course and To Cancel COC of Samuel

Docsam Navarro

E. Orestes S. Ferrer

vs.

Samuel Docsam" Navarro

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to G R A NT the Petition dated 10 October 2012. ACCORDINGLY, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Samuel Navarro is hereby DENIED and CANCELLED

January 15, 2013

rPage 13 o f 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

)\

)

M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE


\


46. Cortes, Surigao del

Sur

1

13-046(DC)

William M. Angos

vs.

Senonina P. Cuanan

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, td D ISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT '

Resolution (EB) - xxx Petitioner William A. Angos Motion for Reconsideration dated 11 March 2013 is hereby DENIED for lack of merit and the\ Resolution dated 30 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED. Consequently, Respondent Senonina P. C iianan may be validly substituted in accordance with the provisions of Section 77 of the OEC \

\

January 30, 2013

April 23, 2013

47. Province of Kalinga

1

13-047(DC)

Allen Jesse C. Mangaoang

vs.

G. Farnaw A. Claver

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition for LACK OF MERIT

Order (FD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc

January 10, 2013

January 22, 2013

48. San Fernando City, La Union

II

13-048(DC)

Gerald C. Tabac

vs.

Reynaldo T. Jucutan

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Reynaldo T. Jucutan is hereby CANCELLED

Order (SD) - Acting on the Motion for Issuance of Certificate of Finality filed by pet through counsel on April 18, 2013, praying that a Certificate of Finality be issued on the Resolution promulgated on Jan. 23, 2013 for the instant case, the Commission (SD) hereby DIRECTS Atty. Jado Rafael A. Bognedon, counsel for the respondent, to file his comment on said motion

January 21, 2013

April 23, 2013

rPage 14 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

) V )

MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE


\


49. Taytay,Rizal

I

13-049(DC)

Janet De Leon Mercado

vs.

Jessica Janet C. De Leon

Resolution (FD) V- xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the petition praying to declare JESSICA JANET C. DE LEON as nuisance candidate

Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant MR is denied for lack of merit ^

December 19, 2012

March 14, 2013

50. Lone District of the City of

San Jose del Monte,

Buiacan

II

13-050(DC)

In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course To or Cancel COC of Imelda A. Papin as Congressional

Candidate in the Lone District of the City of San Jose Del Monte, Province of

Buiacan

Arangkada San Joseno Political Party represented by its Secretary General,

Mr. Zosimo B. Lorenzo

vs.

Imelda A. Papin

Resolution (SD) - xx^the Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Imelda A. Papin is hereby G RANTED. Accordingly, her Certificate of Candidacy^is CANCELLED

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby GRANTED. The Resolution of the Commission (SD) dated 31 January 2013 is hereby REVERSED and SET ASIDE

January 31, 2013

April 18, 2013

51. Silang,Cavite

I

13-051(DC)

In Re: In the matter of the Petition to Declare Pablito V. Angcaya as nuisance

candidate

Armando A. De Castro

vs.

Pablito V. Angcaya

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the Petition and DECLARE respondent PABLITO V. ANGCAYA as a nuisance candidate. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent is hereby CANCELLED

January 22, 2013

i

Page 15 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) 1 )MUN. / C IT Y /

PROVINCESPA2013 TITLE OF THE CASE

\


52. SanPascual,Batangas

II

13-052(DC)

Antonio Jordan Tabares, Jr. \\

vs.

Antonio Dimayuga

\

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to GRANT the instant Petition. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Antonio Dimayuga is hereby CANCELLED

Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant motion is hereby GRANTED. The January 28, 2013 Resolution of the Commission (SD) is hereby REVERSED and SET ASIDE

January 28, 2013

May 02, 2013

53. Lone District of

Marinduque

1

13-053(DC)

Joseph Soccoro B. Tan

vs.

Atty. Regina Ongsiako Reyes

'Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent REGINA ONGSIAKO REYES is hereby CANCELLED

Order (FD) - xxx MR filed by respondent through counsel elevated to en banc

March 27, 2013

April 16, 2013

54. SanPascual,Batangas

II

13-054(DC)

Antonio Jordan Tabares, Jr.

vs.

Ma. Brenda Kenrick, alias Ma. Brenda Dimayuga

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED

January 21, 2013

55. Bayugan City, Agusan

del Sur

1

13-055(DC)

Ferdinand Marcus Martir Banosia

vs.

Analiz Efren Sevandal For: Annulment/Render Void and consider as not filed COC Due to Late Filing

Resolution (FD) - xxx resolves to DENY the petition for LACK OF MERIT

Resolution

I ) )




56. 4m District of Quezon Province

1

13-056(DC)

w/SPA13-057

Wigbferto R. Tanada, Jr.

vs.

Alvin J^hn S. Tanada

\\9

\

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISM ISS the two Petitions, SPA No. 13-056 (DC) and SPA 13-057 (DC) for LACK OF MERIT

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration dated 18 February 2013 is PARTIALLY GRANTED. The Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-057 (DC) is DENIED for LACK OF MERIT. However, the Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-066 (DC) is GRANTED. Accordingly, Respondent Alvin John S. Tanadas Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Member of the House of Representatives for the 4th district of the Province of Quezon is hereby CANCELLED

January 29, 2013

w /SPA 13-057

April 25, 2013

57. 4m District of Quezon Province

13-057(DC)

Wigberto R. Tanada, Jr.

vs.

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISM ISS the two Petitions, SPA No. 13-056 (DC) and SPA 13-057 (DC) for LACK OF MERIT

January 29, 2013

w /SPA 13-056

1w/SPA13-056

Alvin John S. Tanada Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration dated 18 February 2013 is PARTIALLY GRANTED. The Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-057 (DC) is DENIED for LACK OF MERIT. However, the Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-056 (DC) is GRANTED. Accordingly, Respondent Alvin John S. Tanadas Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Member of the House of Representatives for the 4th district of the Province of Quezon is hereby CANCELLED

April 25, 2013

rPage 17 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

\I ) )


SPA\2013 TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS


\\

58. District 1, Province of

Albay

I

\3-058\DC)

IVictor S. Ziga

Edgardo T. Vosotros, Atty. Arsenio N. Base, Jr.

Atty. Julian C. Cargullo

vs.

Edcel Burce Lagman, Jr.

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Instant Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel Certificate of Candidacy dated 08 October 2012 for LACK OF MERIT

Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is denied for lack of merit

January 30, 2013

April 25, 2013

\\i

59. Indang,Cavite

II

13-059(DC)\

\

Perfecto V. Fidel

vs.

Lineth Espineli Abutin

Urgent Petition to Disallow Improper, Misleading and Confusing Registration of Last Name of Candidate and to Correct Comelec Official List of Candidates Names to Appear on the Official Ballot

Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is GRANTED. Respondent LINETH ESPINELI-ABUTIN's use of the last name FIDEL to appear on the official ballot is hereby DISALLOWED. The Election Officer of Indang, Cavite is hereby DIRECTED to correct the Official List of Candidates who filed their Certificate of candidacy for the May 13, 2013 National and Local Elections to reflect the correct last name of respondent as ESPINELI-ABUTIN

January 11, 2013

60. 4tn District of the Province ofCamarines

Sur

I

13-060(DC)

Gilmar S. Pacamarra, in his capacity as registered voter of Precinct 7A,

Barangay San Antonio, San Jose, Camarines Sur

vs.

Ariel Aga A. Muhlach

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel the Certificate of Candidacy of the respondent Ariel Aga A. Muhlach for LACK OF MERIT

Manifestation with Motion (To Withdraw Petitioners Motion for Reconsideration) filed by counsel for petitioner Gilmar S. Pacamarra on April 29, 2013

January 15, 2013

Page 18 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

\MUN. / c / r / / PROVINCE



\

* 1 .\

\1\

Sasmuan,Pampanga

II

13-061(DC)

Nardo M. Velasco

vs.

Pedro L. Velasco

Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is DENIED for lack of merit

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED. The Resolution of the Commission (SD) dated January 28, 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED

January 28, 2013

April 24, 2013

\\

\\

62. \ First District i of Quezon \ Province9\

1

13-062(DC)

Romeo Laguador Villenas and Raffy Rosal Fernandez

vs.

Wilfrido Mark Me. Cormick Enverga

Pauline Ann Carpio Villasenor, Petitioner-intervenor

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition

Order (FD) - xxx MRs elevated to en banc

January 15, 2013

January 29, 2013

\\

\ 9\

63. Tangalan,Aklan

1

13-063(DC)

In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancel Certificate of Candidacy of Noel

Teston y Delos Santos as Mayor of Tangalan, Aklan for the 2013 National,

Local and ARMM Elections

Gene Torre Fuentes

vs.

Noel Teston y Delos Santos


64. 1st District of Bulacan

I

13-064(DC-F)

Ma. Victoria R. Sy-Alvarado

vs.

Sahiron Dulah Salim


1

Page 19 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) )



DATED/PROMULGATED

V

REMARKS

65. Province o f Bulacan

1

13-065(DC-F)

Wilhelmino M. Sy-Alvarado

vs.

Ernesto D. Balite

Resolution (FD) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED. Respondent Ernesto D. Balite is hereby declared as NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and his Certificate of Candidacy for Governor of Bulacan for the 13 May 2013 National and Local Elections is CANCELLED

Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. Accordingly, the Decision of this Commission (First Division) dated 29 January 2013 stands

January 29, \2013

\

\M arcli22,

201^a

66. Province of Bulacan

II

13-066(DC-F)

Daniel R. Fernando

vs.

Josephine Cagiwa Lopez

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit

January 'l6, 2013

67. Province of Bulacan

II

13-067(DC-F)

Daniel R. Fernando

vs.

Jayson Olarte Ocampo

Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent JAYSON OLARTE OCAMPO as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration dated 25 February 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 01 February 2013 is hereby AFFIRM ED

February 01, 2013

April 23, 2013

68. Viga,Catanduanes

II

13-068(DC)

Gilbert C. Olfindo

vs.

Abelardo M. Abundo, Sr.


January 02, 2013

r Page 20 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

)MUN. / C I T Y / PRO VINCE


\


69. Mayantoc,Tarlac

II

13-069(DC-F)

lluminado E. Pobre, Jr.

vs.

Marciano Dela Cruz Pulido

Resolution (SD) - xxx the p^ition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of MARCIANO DELA CRUZ PULIDO is hereby CANCELLED

*t

January 16, 2013

70. Fifth District of Manila

I

13-070(DC)

Richard C. Ibay

vs.

Jose Antonio L. Ibay

Resolution (FD) - xxx resolves to GRANT the instant Petition. Respondent JOSE A N TO N lb L. IBAYs Certificate of Candidacy is hereby dlENIED and CANCELLED \

9

January 31, 2013

71. Ternate,Cavite

I

13-071(DC)

Jayson D. Cabana

vs.

Francisco L. Cabana, Jr.

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition dated 11 October 2012 for being M OOT and ACADEMIC. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Francisco L. Cabana, Jr. is hereby CANCELLED. Let a copy of this Resolution be FORW ARDED to the Law Dept, of the Commission with regard to the finalization of the Official List of Candidates for the 13 May 2013 National, Local and ARMM Elections

January 15, 2013

72. CaloocanCity

I

13-072(DC)

Dionisio F. Guillarte

vs.

Fred Naim Bello

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 45. Bello, Fred Naim - Mayor - Caloocan City xxx

January 11, 2013

73. CaloocanCity

II

13-073(DC)

In Re: Petition to declare as a nuisance candidate, Luis San Pedro Razo,

candidate for the Position of Mayor of Caloocan City in the 2013 National and

Local Elections, denying dife course

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013

January 11, 2013

Page 21 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

\J

\I )

m un . / c / r r /PROVINCE


\


and/or cancelling his COC

Laura Bucao Vital

vs.

Luis San Pedro Razo

Elections: xxk 53. Razo, Luis San Pedro - Mayor - Caloocan City kxx

*

\74. Cabagan,

Isabela

1

13-074(DC-F)

Rodolfo B. Albano, Jr.

vs.

Francisco B. Flores, Comelec Cabagan, Isabela, Represented by EO Josephine

Z. Mallannao

Resolution (FD) -W x x the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for LAC^K OF MERIT

Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED for utter lack of merit. The assailed Resolution is AFFIRMED en toto

January 22, 2013

April 24, 2013

75. Pililla, Rizal

1

13-075(DC)

In the matter of the disqualification of Tomas N. Aguirre, as candidate for Municipal Councilor of Pililla, Rizal

Eduardo Z. Vidanes,Brgy. Quisao, Pililla, Riza

vs.

Tomas N. Aguirre

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to D ISM ISS the instant Petition for utter lack of merit

April 25, 2013

76. Sipalay City Negros

Occidental

II

13-076(DC)

Rodolfo Divinagracia

vs.

Oscar Chua Montilla, Jr., Ma. Gina Montilla Lizares

i . . . . . ...

Resolution (SD) - xxx in view of the foregoing, the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ENY the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to AFFIRM the Second Divisions ruling

January 28, 2013

April 23, 2013

r Page 22 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

\ )

/Wl/W. / C /7T/ PROVINCE



77. 2na District of the

Province of Cagayan

II

13-077(DC-F)

In Re: Petition for declarations Sherwin Calimag y Cabasag a .lia . Win as nuisance candidate for the position of Congressman for the 2nd

District of Cagayan\

Baby Aline Vargas-Alfonso ^

vs. ^

Sherwin Calimag y Cabasag

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates' Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 12. Calimag, Sherwin C. - Member, House of Representatives, (2nd Dist.) - Province of Cagayan xxx

January 11, 2013

78. Calbiga,Samar

1

13-078(DC-F)

Santiago B. Abelido

vs.

Nicasio Cas Labalan Abaigar

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the instant Petition to Deny Due Course/ Cancel COC. Accordingly, the COC filed by Nicasio Labalan Abaigar for the position of mayor in Calbiga, Samar is hereby CANCELLED for containing false material representation pertinent to residence

Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED, for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution of the First Division is hereby AFFIRMED

January 28, 2013

May 03, 2013

79. Toledo City, Cebu

II

13-079(DC-F)

Lina Dela Pena Jalover, Georgie A. Huiso, and Velvet Barquin Zamora

vs.

John Henry R. Osmefia

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the Petition for LACK OF M ERIT


April 03, 2013

April 25, 2013

fPage 23 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

;M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE



80. Toledo City, Cebu

II

13-080(DC-F)

Noe BVNeo and Cecilia Apurado ' Edoloverio

vs.

Antonio P. Yapha, JR.

V

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Due Course filed by Petitioners Neo and Apurado and DECLARES that Respondent Yapha is qualified to run for Vice Mayor of Toledo City, Province of Cebu in the 13 May 2013 Elections

w/ MR filed by petitioners

January 24, 2013

81. Candijay,Bohol

I

13-081(DC-F)

Sergi^G . Amora, Jr.

\ vs.

Christopher B. Tutor


January 29, 2013

82. Balabagan, Lanao del

Sur

II

13-082(DC-F)

Edna Ogka Benito

vs.

Amer R. Sampiano


83. Sevilla,Bohol

1

13-083(DC-F)

In Re: Petition to Cancel COC of Juliet Dano y Bucag for the position of

Municipal Mayor in the Municipality of Sevilla, Bohol on the ground of material

misrepresentation

Marie Karen Joy Digal y Bungagong

vs.

Juliet Dano y Bucag


r Page 24 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

) )




\

84. Pavia, Iloilo

1

\ 13-084 ' (DC-F)

\\

\\

In Re: Petition to declare Michael Jimena Gorriceta a.k.a. Michael J.

Gorriceta as nuisance candidate for the position of Municipal Mayor of the

Municipality of Pavia, Iloilo and to Deny Due Course to or Cancel his Certificate of Candidacy as a nuisance candidate

Michael Barrido Gorriceta

vs.

Miichael J. Gorriceta

Order (FD) - xxx the instant Petition for Denial/ Cancellation of COC of Michael Jimena Gorriceta is hereby DISMISSED for being M O O T and ACADEMIC

April 25, 2013 \\

\\9\

85. 5tn District of Cebu

II

13-085(DC-F)

In the matter of the petition to deny due course or cancel the COC of Gilbert

Wagas as Congressional Candidate in the 5th District of Cebu

Joel Quino

vs.

Gilbert W agas


86. Ginatilan,Cebu

II

13-086(DC-F)

Dean Michael P. Singco

vs.

Patrocinio 'Pat" R. Singco


Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant motion is DENIED en toto

January 16, 2013

April 24, 2013





\87

\\

Estancia,Iloilo

II

13-087(DC-F)

Rene S. Cordero

vs.

Mario B. Golingan


Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration dated 06 February 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 16 Januar 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED

January 16, 2013

April 05, 2013

\

V

\

First District of Antipolo

City

II

13-088(DC-F)

In the matter of Petition to declare Danilo Uding Zaratan Aquino a

nuisance candidate and his COC be denied due course and be cancelled

Prudencio Marco Aquino

vs.

Danilo Zaratan Aquino

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED. Respondent Danilo Zartan Aquino is hereby declared a NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and consequently, his CERTIFICATE OF CANDIDACY for the position of Member, Sangguniang Panlungsod, 1st Dist., Antipolo City, Rizal is hereby ordered CANCELLED

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (Second Division) dated 21 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED

January 21, 2013

April 05, 2013

\\

89. Guinsiiiban,Camiguin

I

13-089(DC-F)

Joanne Marie C. Rubin

vs.

Saturnino S. Lumba

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition dated 06 October 2012 for LACK OF MERIT

January 15, 2013

90. MambajaoCamiguin

I

13-090(DC-F)

Ma. Victoria J. Jansol

vs.

Roberto L. Odarve

Resolution (FD) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent ROBERTO L. ODARVE as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit

April 16, 2013

91. Carles, Iloilo 13-091(DC-F)

Petition for Disqualification of Rodolfo Dumayas as candidate for Sangguniang

Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petitions for Disqualificationof respondents* Rodolfo S. Dumayas

January 21, 2013

Page 26 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)



DATED/PROMULGATED

\REMARKS

IIBayan Member of the Municipality of

Carles, Iloilo as provided under Rule 25 of the Comelec Rules of Procedure as

amended by Resolution No. 9523

Alvin V. Barnes vs.

Rodolfo Dumayas

and Arnel T. Francisco to run in the 13 May 2013 elections as Sangguniang Bayan Members of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo are DISMISSED and their Certificates of Candidacies are UPHELD

\\

\\

\92. Milagros,

Masbate

II

13-092(DC-F)

Florence P. De Jesus

vs.

Luz Cleta R. Bakunawa

Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel the COC of Luz Cleta R.

Bakunawa

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent LUZ CLETA REYES BAKUNAWAS Certificate of Candidacy


March 07, 2013

March 27, 2013

93. Carles, Iloilo

1

13-093(DC-F)

Petition for Disqualification of Arnel Francisco as candidate for

Sangguniang Bayan Member of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo as provided under Rule 25 of the Comelec Rules of Procedure as amended by Resolution

No. 9523

Alvin V. Barnes

vs.

Arnel Francisco

Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petitions for Disqualification of respondents Rodolfo S. Dumayas and Arnel T. Francisco to run in the 13 May 2013 elections as Sangguniang Bayan Members of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo are D ISM ISSED and their Certificates of Candidacies are UPHELD

January 21, 2013

)MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE


\


94. EasternSamar

II

13-094(DC-F)

Hon. Conrado B. Nicart, Jr.

vs.

Alfredo C. Hobayan

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition i ^ DENIED for lack of merit '

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. Accordingly, the Resolution of the Honorable Commissions Second Division promulgated on 28 January 2013 stands ^

January 28, 2013

April 23, 2013

95. Mambajao,Camiguin

II

13-095(DC-F)


vs.

Pacundo Ebarle

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit \

*

January16,2013


1

13-096(DC-F)


vs.

Isabelo P. Paraiso

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT

January 11, 2013


1

13-097(DC-F)


vs.

Gil G. Fabe

Resolution (FD) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent GIL G. FABE as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit

May 03, 2013


1

13-098(DC-F)


vs.

Renato L. Tamayo, Sr.

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition dated 09 October 2012 for LACK OF MERIT

January 15, 2013

Page 28 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

MUN. / C I T Y / P RO VINCE


\



11

13-099(DC-F)


vs.

Jim S. Dagondon

Resolution \(S D ) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISMISSED\for lack of merit

i

January 16, 2013


II

13-100(DC-F)


vs.

Danilo M. Pabillan

Resolution (SD4 - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for sack of merit

\

\

January 16, 2013


1

13-101(DC)


vs.

Diosdado B. Aranas


March 21, 2013


II

13-102(DC-F)


vs.

Pepe E. Pabillore


January 16, 2013


1

13-103(DC-F)

Ma. Luisa D. Romualdo

vs.

Angustia H. Jadman

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition filed against respondent Angustia H. Jadman for LACK OF MERIT

January 11, 2013

rPage 29 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) )





I

13-104(DC-F)

Roldan A. Chan V

vs.

Antonio D. Gultiano\

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for LACK OF MERIT

March 21, 2013

105. First District of Palawan

II

13-105(DC-F)

Randy Toto Rodriguez \

vs. ^

Roberto Toto Rodriguez

Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the consolidated cases are resolved as follows: In SPA No. 13-033 (DC), the petition to declare Randy M. Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is hereby DISMISSED. However, Randy M. Rodriguez is ordered not to use and place Toto as the nickname to appear in the official ballot/ In SPA No. 13- 105 (DC)(F) the petition to declare Roberto Toto Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is also DISM ISSED

January 28, 2013

w /S P A 13- 033

106. South Ubian, Tawi-

Tawi Province

I

13-106(DC-F)

Mustapha J. Omar

vs.

Gamal S. Hayudini

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES as it hereby RESOLVED, to DISMISS the petition filed against respondent Gamal S. Hayudini for LACK OF M ERIT

January 31, 2013

107. Tandubas,Tawi-Tawi

I

13-107(DC-F)

In Re: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel COC

Albert H. Kahong

vs.

Mindalyn Idlana Abubakar

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the petition praying to disqualify respondent Mindalyn Idlana Abubakar

January 15, 2013

Page 30 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)



\


108. MabalacatCity,

PampangaProvince

II

13-108(DC-F)

\ Noelito B. Castro

vs.

Noli M. Castro*

Petition to Beclare Respondent, Noli M. castro\a nuisance candidate

\

Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent NOLI JUN M. CASTRO as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE is hereby DENIED for utter Jack of merit

January 11, 2013

109. Cortes, Surigao del

Sur

II

13-109(DC-F)

Senbnina P. Cuanan

' vs.

Alfonso G. Cuanan

Petition for Cancellation of COC

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is GRANTED. Respondent Alfonso G. Cuanan is hereby declared a NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and consequently, his CERTIFICATE OF CANDIDACY for the position of Mayor of the Municipality of Cortes, Surigao Del Sur is hereby ordered CANCELLED


January 16, 2013

February 14, 2013

110. Oras,EasternSamar

II

13-110(DC-F)

Noel Ramonito M. Montallana

vs.

Aldin M. Montallana

Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition of NOEL RAMONITO M. MONTALLANA is hereby DENIED

January 16, 2013

111. La Paz, Abra

I

13-111(DC-F)

Joseph Sto. Nino B. Bernos

vs.

Florencia B. Bernos


Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to AFFIRM the First Divisions ruling

January 28, 2013

March 22, 2013

\I ) )




\

112. 1SI District,\ Quezon ^Province

II

13-112(DC-F)

\\

Teresita O. Dator Represented by Atty. Jorge B. Vargas

as her Attorney-in-fact

vs.

Isidro D. Dator

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit

January 16, 2013 \

\\

113. QuezonProvince

I

13-113(\)C-F)

Petition for the declaration of candidate Rolando Merano for position of

Governor of Quezon Province as a nuisance candidate

David C. Suarez

vs.

Rolando Merano

Order (FD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED for failure to file within the reglementary period

November 20, 2012

\

\

114. Gainza,Camarines

Sur

I

13-114(DC-F)

In the matter of the petition to disqualify Romeo A. Gontang and/or to deny due

course to or cancel his COC for the position of Mayor of Gainza, Camarines

Sur, pursuant to title 2, chapter 1, Section 40 (A) of RA 7160 in relation

with Rule 25 of En Banc Comelec Resolution No. 9523

Serafin A. Encinas

vs.

Romeo A. Gontang

Resolution (FD) - xxx the Verified Petition is hereby DISMISSED

January 22, 2013

Page 32 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

1

) ) \

MUN. / CITY/ PROVINCE



\115. Zamboanga

City

II

13-115(DC)

Roel B. Natividad, Arturo N. Onrubia & Ahmad Narzad K. Sampang

vs.

Romeo G. Jalosjos

Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESOLVES, to CANCEL and DENY due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NILE

January 15, 2013 V

\... A_ . ...- - ...........

j16.

\\

Jaen, Nueva Ecija

II

13-116(DC)

SP01 Wilson P. Hipolito

vs.

Rolando I. Manalo


January 21, 2013

\\1

117. First District of Samar

I

13-117(DC-F)

w/ SPA 13-168

(DC)

Elmer M. Candido

vs.

Arnold Vasquez Tan

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant consolidated Petitions are hereby DENIED


January 29, 2013

February 14, 2013

118. Hernani,EasternSamar

II

13-118(DC-F)

Wilmar Mema" Siguan Candido

vs.

Wilmar Memo Daga Candido

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition to declare Wilmar Memo Daga Candido as a nuisance candidate is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, respondent's Certificate of Candidacy is CANCELLED

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (SD) dated 28 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED

January 28, 2013

April 08, 2013

rPage 33 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)



\


119. Province of Camiguin

I

13-119(DC-F)

James A. Ederango

vs.

Luisito P. Ucab

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the^ Petition dated 06 October 2012 for LACK of MERIT

February 01, i 2013

\120. Lagayan,

Abra

I

13-120(DC)

Antonio Maduli Bilong

vs.

Bernadine Sibayan-Joson

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition dated 19 October 2012

Rebruary 01, V 2013

\t

121. 7m District of Cavite

II

13-121(DC)

Laureano S. Mendoza, in his capacity as registered voter of Precinct 0 1 14A, Saiz De Junio Village, Sungay East,

Tagaytay City, Cavite

vs.

Gilbert Cesar C. Remulla

Resolution (SD) - xxx thepetition is hereby DISM ISSED for lack of merit


February 20, 2013

March 05, 2013

122. Lagayan,Abra

I

13-122(DC-F)

Bernadine Sibayan Joson

vs.

Cornelio David Malangen

For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS this case for LACK OF MERIT

January 15, 2013

123. Lagayan,Abra

II

13-123(DC-F)


vs.

Joel Baduli Bilong, Sr.

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DENY the instant Petition for UTTER LACK OF MERIT

t

January 28, 2013

Page 34 o f 77 (SPA 2013 DC)

) ' )



\


For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate \

124. Lagayan,Abra

I

13-124(DC-F)


vs.

Ronnie Blaza Paingan

For: Declaration o f a candidate as nuisance candidate

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition filed against respondent Ronnie Blaza Paingan for LACK OF MERIT ^

\\

\a\

January 29, 2013

125. Lagayan,Abra

I

13-125(DC-F)


vs.

Antonio Maduli Bilong



January 22, 2013

126. Lagayan,Abra

II

13-126(DC-F)


vs.

Alberto Ci-o Pasiguen


Resolution (SD) - RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent Ci-o Pasiguens Certificate of Candidacy

January 16, 2013

Page 35 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)



\


127. Lagayan,Abra

J

13-127(DC-F)


vs.

Rubio Jimenez Sindon


Resolutidp (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit

\

V\

April 10, 2013

128. Banguigui,Sulu

Province

I

13-128(DC)

Whajid Indanan Sahidulla

vs.

Addullajid S. Alih

Verified Petition to deny due course or cancel the COC under Sec. 78 in

relation to Sec. 74 of BP 881

Resolution (Ffy) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the petition to den/,due course or cancel the certificate of candidacy of ADDULLAJID S. ALIH


January 29, 2013

February 14, 2013

-

129. Sallapadan,ABra

I

13-129(DC)

Nenita M. Cardenas

vs.

Wilbert Enostacion For: Petition to deny due course to or

cancellation of COC


130. Sallapadan,Abra

I

13-130(DC)

Nenita M. Cardenas

vs.

Wilbert Enostacion

t For: Petition for Disqualificaiton


MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE



131. CalbayogCity

I

13-131(DC-F)

Renato A. De Los ReVes

vs.

Angelie Tee Tan\

Petition to deny due course andfor to Cancel COC \


132. Province of Isabela

II

13-132(DC)

Re: In the matter of petition to




Petition to declare a candidate as ' nuisance candidate

135. 4m District of Nueva Ecija

II

13-135(DC)

Raul L. Villareal

\ vs \O rlando A. Nagano \

For\ Cancellation of COC \


January 16, 2013


I

13-136(DC)

Esteban Foz Romero

vs.

Joefrey P. Saguid

For: Petition to deny due course to or Cancellation of COC

Resolution (FD) - xxx the Petition to Deny due course and/or to Cancel the COC of Respondent JOEFREY P. SAGUID is hereby DISMISSED

April 29, 2013


I

13-137(DC)

Roderick R. Trinidad

vs.

Nathaniel Ruben D. Taylan II

For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of COC

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISM ISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT

January 11, 2013


I

13-138(DC)

Joel B. Toribio

vs.

Elsie P. Garces

Resolution (FD) - xx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition for LACK OF MERIT

January 23, 2013

i


) )




\\\

For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of COC \

139. Dingras, I llocos Norte

II

13-139^ ( D C ,

\

Roderick R. Trinidad

vs.

Rowena Celerina P. Verzosa


January 16, 2013

\I

\\\


I

13-140(DC)

Joel Baraoidan Toribio

vs.

Rosalinda Ruiz Castro

For: Petition to Deny Due Course and/or to Cancel C O C

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC for LACK OF MERIT

February 01, 2013

141. Dingras, Hocos Norte

II

13-141(DC)

Alemar D. Rosqueta

vs.

Enriqueto J. Canete, Jr.


Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of-merit

January 21, 2013


I

13-142(DC)

Bobby Perfecto R. Simeon

vs.

Osias A. Ballesteros

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT

i

January 11, 2013


) )




\


\\

t

143.

I\

Dingras, llocos Norte

I

13-143(DC)

Esteban F. Romero

vs.

Jose Mari Genaro B. Albano


Submitted for resolution " ' \

\

\\

144. DonVictoriano,

MisamisOccidental

II

13-144(DC)

Carlito M. Bongcac

vs.

Elsie M. Llanes

Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC of Respondent


Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. The assailed Resolution of the Second Division is hereby AFFIRMED

January 21, 2013

April 24, 2013

145. DonVictoriano,

MisamisOccidental

II

13-145(DC)

Ricardo L. Solatorio

vs.

Danny V. Pata

Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC of Respondent


February 01, 2013

146. DonVictoriano,

Misamis

13-146(DC)

Emilio C. Medel

vs.

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is herebyDISMISSED for LACK OF M ERIT

i

February 01, 2013

r Page 4 0 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) )



\


\150. Tuburan,

Cebu

II

13-150(DC)

Antonio M. Primacion and Lourdes D. Esmero

Vs.

Daphne A. Lagon

For: Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of Daphne Arias Lagon as

Vice-Mayor of Tuburan, Cebu

Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is DENIED for lack of merit \

Order (EB) - The Commission (Ej|3) hereby GRANTS the Comment and/or Opposition tq Petitioners Motion for Reconsideration filed by respondent through counsel on March 19, 2013 xxxi The Motion for Reconsideration filed on March 4,' 2013 is hereby DISM ISSED for failure of petitioners to pay motion fees in the amount of One Thousand Pesos (Php1,000.00)

January 28, 2013

April 02, 2013

151. Catanduanes

I

13-151(DC)

Larry S. Que

Vs.

Joseph C. Cua

Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is DENIED for lack of merit

Order (FD) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel on April 19, 2013, xxx elevated to the Commission en banc for proper disposition

April 10, 2013

April 23, 2013

152. Bangar, La Union

II

13-152(DC)

Joy Pinzon Merin

Vs.

Saturnino Dingle

Petition to Cancel COC and to Disqualify Respodent due to ineligibility

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED


January 24, 2013

February 07, 2013

i


>\

MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE


\


153. 2 District, Marcos,

llocos Norte

I

13-153(DC)

Salvador S. Pillos

Vs.

Ignacio A. Agustin

For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellationof CO C

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the instant Petition for UTTER LACK OF MERIT

\

\

March 06, 2013

154. Province of Camarines

Sur

I

13-154(DC)

Luis R. Villafuerte

Vs.

Miguel R. Villafuerte

Verified Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of respondent Miguel Reyes Villafuerte as candidate for

Governor of the Province of Camarines Sur

Resolution iFD ) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition for LACK OF MERIT

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration dated 08 February 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (FD) promulgated on 15 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED

January 15, 2013

April 01, 2013

155. 2nc District of Antipolo

City

1

13-155(DC)

In Re: Petition to disqualify candidate to elective position

'Avelino P. De Quiroz

Vs.

Nixon R. Aranas


i

Page 43 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

)M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE



156. Aringay, La Union

II

13-156(DC)

Frank Ong Sibuma andVDino Ong Sibuma ^

Vs.

Napoleon Chan Ong



January 21, 2013

February 05, 2013

157. 4m District of the Province

ofCamarines

Sur

II

13-157(DC)

Crispin M. Imperial and Francisco Perico Dizon, in their capacity as

registered voters of Brgy. San\Juan, San Jose, Camarines Sur\

Vs.

Ariel Aquino Muhlach

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration dated 12 March 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 05 March 2013 is hereby AFFIRM ED

March 05, 2013

May 02, 2013

158. Datu Hoffer Ampatuan,

Maguindanao

I

13-158(DC)

Bongbong M. Ampatuan

Vs.

Mhurphy P. Ampatuan

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition for LACK OF M ERIT


January 30, 2013

April 05, 2013

159. Datu Joffer Ampatuan,

Maguindana 0

II

13-159(DC)

Bongbong M. Ampatuan

Vs.

Yamashita B. Mangacop

Petition to disqualify for lack of qualificationsor possessing some

grounds for disqualification


May 06, 2013

Page 44 o f 77 (SPA 2013 DC)



\


160. 2na District of Bataan Province

II

13-160(DC)

\ Oscar R. Delos Reyes

'

Juan Miguel R. Bondoc, a.k.a. Onemig Bondoc

\

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for Denial / Cancellation of Certificate of Candidacy

March 19, 2013

161. Estancia,Iloilo

I

13-161(DC)

V Mario B. Golingan

^ N/s.*

' Rene S. Cordero

Resolution (FD) - xxx this Commission RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the instant Petition for utter lack of merit

April 29, 2013

162. Jipapad,EasternSamar

II

13-162(DC)

In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of Leoncio P. Mato,

candidate for Mayor of Jipapad, Eastern Samar

Ruben P. Go

Vs.

Leoncio P. Mato


January 21, 2013

163. Malinao,Albay

I

13-163(DC)

Ofelia Zanosa Bigata and Evelyn Borja Cellona

Vs.

Salvador K. Moll

Petition To deny due course to or cancel COC)

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the instant petition. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Salvador K. Moll is hereby DENIED DUE CO URSE TO AND/OR CANCELLED

Order (EB) - xxx hereby GRANTS the Manifestation with Most Most Urgent Motion (To Deny Respondents Motion for Reconsideration for Lack of Jurisdiction) filed by pets through counsel on March 26, 2013, xxx/ The Motion for Reconsideration filed on March 4, 2013 is hereby DISMISSED for failure of petitioners to pay

February 01, 2013

w/ Separate Opinion of

Comm. Lim

April 02, 2013

i

Page 45 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) )MUN. / C IT Y /

PROVINCE \



\\ motion fees in the amount of One Thousand Pesos (Php1, 000.00) \\164. Zamboanga

City

\\

13-164(DC)

Jose L. Lobregat & Adelante Zamboanga Party

Vs.

Romeo G. Jalosjos


January 15, 2013

\\\\

165. 5tn District op, Quezon City 1

1

13-165(DC)

Manuel V. Macabuhay, Jr.

vs.

Arnold Francisco aka Ogie Susano

For: Petition for denial or Cancellation of COC


January 22, 2013

\9\

166. 3Legislative District of

Camarines Sur

II

13-166(DC)

Nelson B. Julia

Vs.

Angel G. Naval

Verified Petition to deny due course to or cancel the coc

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Angel G. Naval for the position of Member of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of the Third District of Camarines Sur is hereby CANCELLED


March 05, 2013

March 27, 2013

167. 3ro District of the Province

of Albay

II

13-167(DC)

Elmer Felix M. Pornel

Vs.

Fernando Vallejo Gonzalez

Joint Resolution (SD) - xxx the two (2) Petitions are hereby DISMISSED

Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for reconsidedration dated 18 February 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 31 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED *

January 31, 2013

April 05, 2013

w/SPA 13-178


\\ ) ) I

I\\



DATED/PROMULGATED

\

REMARKS

168. 1slLegislative District of

Samar

13-168(DC)

w/SPA 13- 117

(DC)(F)

Tito M. Aniban

Vs.

Arnold Vasquez Tan

Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant consolidated Petitions are hereby DENIED

Pis. see SPA 13-117

January 29, 2013 \

\169. Tineg, Abra

II

13-169(DC)

Cromwell S. Luna

Vs.

Corinthia D. Crisologo

Petition to deny due course/Cancel coc


Order (SD) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel on April 01, 2013 xxx elevated to en banc

March 12, 2013

April 17, 2013 \

) )



\


172. San Jose, Camarines

Sur

II

13-172(DC)

Antonio Bermejo Chavez in his capacity as a registered voted of Brgy. Pugay,

San Jose, Camarines Sur

Vs.

Eduardo Patriarca Pilapil

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DENY the instant Petition for UTTER LACK OF MERIT \

\

\

February 01, 2013

173. Tarlac City

I

13-173(DC)

In Re: Petition for disqualification of Jerome H. La Pena as candidate for

City Mayor, Tarlac City

Esteban B. Aguas, Jr.

Vs.

Jerome H. Lapena

Submitted for resolution \

*

\

174. Lupon,Davao

Oriental

II

13-174(DC-F)

In the matter of the petition for the disqualification of candidate Eva

Afahalces Larrobis Quinones- Mandalupe

Lanie R. Gamurot

Vs.

Eva Afahalces Larrobis Quinones- Mandalupe

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant Petition

February 01, 2013

175. SanRicardo,Southern

Leyte

13-175(DC-F)

In the matter of the petition to invalidate and strike out respondents Certificate of Candidacy for VMayor of San Ricardo,

Southern Leyte in the May 13, 2013 Elections due to ineligibility

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT thePetition dated 19 October 2012. Respondent JOVIC S.MEJIA is hereby excluded from the Certified List ofCandidatesi

March 21, 2013

Page 48 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) >

\



\


I Generoso M. Herrera

Vs.

Jovic S. Mejia

With Motion to Declare Firfel and Executory Comelec Resolution Promulgated Inarch 21, 2013 filed by counsel for pet thru LBC reed on April 19, 2013

\\176. Second

Legislative District of Sarangani Province

I

13-176(DC-F)

In a matter of the petition to disqualify Provincial Board candidate Eugene L. Alzate of Sarangani Province, Region

XII

Mary Ann Gamino Gadian

Vs.

Eugene L. Alzate

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT \

Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion V r Reconsideration is DENIED. The Resolution of the FiVst Division is hereby AFFIRMED

February 01, 2013

April 08, 2013

177. Inabanga,Bohol

I

13-177(DC)

Francisco L. Alesna, Jr.

Vs.

Atty. Epifanio B. Muneses

Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the instant Petition for utter lack of merit

April 25, 2013

178. 3ra District of Albay

II

13-178(DC)

Renato M. Cervantes

Vs.

Fernando V. Gonzalez

Petition to deny due course and to cancfel coc

Joint Resolution (SD) - xxx the two (2) Petitions are hereby DISMISSED

January 31, 2013

w /S P A 13- 167

Page 49 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)



Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petiffon to Deny Due Course to Respondent Jose R. Ramirez, Jr.s Certificate of Candidacy

DATED/PROMULGATED

179. Ligao City 13-179(DC)

Benjamin O. Matias

Vs.

Jose R. Ramirez, Jr.

Petition to deny due course and to cancel coc

January 16, 2013

iA-180. ZamboangaCity

13-180(DC)

Jose L. Lobregat

Vs.

Romeo G. Jalosjos

Petition to deny due course to and/or to cancel COC

Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESOLVES, to CANCEL and D E N \ due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE

January 15, 2013

181. District 1, PasayCity

I

13-181(DC)

Florencio C. Mateo

Vs.

Richard M. Advincula and Lexter N. Ibay


182. Taal,Batangas

13-182(DC-F)

In the matter of the Petition to Cancel COC of Lino Vicente Montenegro y

Masangkay as candidate for Mayor of Taal, Batangas

Michael Rey Villano y Aseron

Vs.

Lino Vicente Montenegro y Masangkay


January 15, 2013

REMARKS

Page 50 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

>MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE



183. Marawi City

I

13-183(DC)

Arip M. Basfyian

Vs.

Shahanie Yasmin C. Salic\

\

Resolution (FD) - In view of the Affidavit dated 11 December 2012, executed by respondent attesting to the fact that she had already withdrawn her certificate of candidacy for vice-mayor of Marawi City, the instant petition is hereby DISM ISSED for being moot and academic. Besides, petitioner informed the Commission that he will no longer pursue his case against respondent

April 02, 2013

184. ZamboangaCity

II

13-184(DC)

Elbert C. Atilano \

Vs. '

Romeo G. Jalosjos

Petition to Deny Due Course to and/or to Cancel COC


January 15, 2013

185. Agno,Pangasinan

II

13-185(DC)

In the matter of the petition to deny due course to or cancel the coc of Gualberto

Ramirez Sison as a candidate for the position of Mayor of Agno, Pangasinan

Jose Pajeta, Jr.

Vs.

Gualberto Ramirez Sison

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Gualberto Ramirez Sison for the position of Mayor of the Municipality of Agno, Pangasinan is hereby CANCELLED

Order (SD) - xxx M R elevated to en banc

February 01, 2013

February 19, 2013

186. 3ra District of Quezon Province

1

13-186(DC)

Rodolfo Reyes Rosales

Vs.

Ma. Lourdes C. De Luna-Pasatiempo

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant Petition for LACK OF MERIT

January 29, 2013

i


) >



\


1\ For: Disqualification and/or Cancellation of COC under Sec 43(b) of the Local Govt. Code pursuant to Sec. 1

of the 1987 Constitution

187. Ligao City

II

13-187(DC)

^ Bertito Latigay

\ Vs.

\ Manuel Laoang Garcia

Petition to deny due course and to cancel COC

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Course to Respondent Manuel Laoang Garcias Certificate of Candidacy

January 21, 2013

188. Ligao City

II

13-188(DC)

Bertito Latigay

Vs.

Patricia Gonzales-Alsua

Petition to deny due course and to cancel COC

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED

February 01, 2013


1

13-189(DC)

Petition to disqualify Marynette Romero Gamboa as mayoralty candidate for the Municipality of Dingras, llocos Norte in

the May 13, 2013 Synchronized National Elections under Rule 25 of the

Comelec Rules of Procedure as amended by Comelec Resolution No.

9523 & Sec. 40, Local Govt Code

Nathaniel Ruben P. Taylan

Resolution (FD) - xxx RRESOLVES to DISMISS the Verified Petition for Disqualification filed by Nathaniel Ruben P. Taylan for being MOOT and ACADEMIC

March 21, 2013

it Page 52 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

) )

MUN. / C I T Y / PRO VINCE



\

. \ " Vs.

Marynette Romero Gamboa

\\

190. Bulakan,Bulackn

i, \ a\

13-190(DC)

Rosendo C. Meneses III

Vs.

Emmanuel N. Meneses

Petition to deny due course to/Cancel the COC of Emmanuel N. Meneses


January 24, 2013 \

\\

\\

191. 5m District of Manila

II

13-191(DC)

Faith C. Maganto

Vs.

Mario Flores Cayabyab

Petition (To Deny Due Course to or to Cancel COC)

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition to deny due course/ or cancel for lack of merit

April 17, 2013

192. Lucena City

I

13-192(DC-F)

Re: Petition to deny due course and/or cancellation of COC of Marijoe

Francisco Asensi

Juanito Y. Diaz

Vs.

Marijoe Francisco Asensi

Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: II. To declare the following as INELIGIBLE candidates for the positions aspired for due to their failure to meet the age requirement / not a registered voter, as reflected and admitted in their COC under oath during the preliminary hearings: xxx d. Asensi, Marjorie Francisco - Member, S. Panlungsod - Lucena City, Quezon xxx Further, to DENY due course to their COCs and to cause the immediate cancellation/deletion of their names from the Candidates Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections; xxx i

January 11, 2013

Page 53 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE


DATED/PROMULGATED

\

REMARKS

193. Cadiz City

II

13-193(DC-F)

Engr. Leonilo B. Hulleza

Vs.

Hon. Patrick G. Escalante

For: Petition to deny due course to or cancel a COC

Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for Denial/ Cancellation of Certificate of Candidacy

April 01, 2013^

\\I

\194. Cortes,

Surigao del Sur

I

13-194(DC)

Senonina P. Cuanan

Vs.

Atty. William M. Angos

Petition for Disqualification / Cancellation of COC

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT

Resolution (EB) - xxx this instant MR is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit

January 30, 2013

April 24, 2013

\a\

195. Cabugao, llocos Sur

II

13-195(DC)

Edgardo Cobangbang, Jr.

vs.

Amelia Amparo Sunio Abarquez

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby G RANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Amelia Amparo Sunio-Abarquez for the position of Mayor of the Municipality of Cabugao, llocos Sur is hereby CANCELLED


February 01, 2013

February 14, 2013

196. Uyugan,Batanes

I

13-196(DC-F)

In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancellation of C O C

Jonathan Enrique V. Nanud, JR.

Vs.

Rogelio Batin Caballero

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to GRANT the instant Petition. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Caballero is hereby CANCELLED

i

May 03, 2013

Page 54 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)



\


197. Munai, Lanao del

Norte

II

13-197(DC)

Re: Petition to disqualify Abdulazis A.M. Batingolo as candidate for

Municipal Mayor

Jamal Dansal Batalo and Fatima Itawa Macalinto

Vs.

Abdulazis M. Batingolo

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is Viereby DISMISSED \

Order (SD) - xxx MR filed by pets through counsel on April 01, 2013 xxx elevated to en banc

\\

\

March 07, 2013

April 17, 2013

198. Tago, Surigao del

Sur

II

13-198(DC)

In the matter of the Petition to disqualify HERMINIGILDO PAREJA PIMENTEL,

JR. as candidate for Mayor of the Municipality of Tago, Surigao del Sur in

13 May 2013 Elections

Rogelio M. Pimentel

vs.

Herminigildo Pareja Pimentel, Jr.

Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition for' disqualification against respondent HERMINIGILDO PAREJA PIMENTEL, JR. is hereby DISMISSED


March 27, 2013

April 25, 2013

199. Lone District of the

Province of Nueva

Vizcaya

1

13-199(DC)

Francisco Aggasid y Acedo

vs.

Rodrigo Perez y Pajarillo

Petition with Motion Ad Cautelam For Disqualification under Section 68 -

OEC

Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the instant Petition for LACK O F MERIT

April 02, 2013

Page 55 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)

i

) > )



\


200. Labason, Zamboanga

del Norte

II

13-200(DC)

In the matter of the Petition to Disqualify Atty. Ramon P. Velasco as a candidate for Vice Mayor, Municipality of Labason,

Zamboanga del Norte in the May 13, 2013 Elections

Dr. Roberto R. Galon and Glenn E. Sanchez

Su

Documents

SPP 2013 DC Case Status.pdf