| | | | About Us Buy Reprints Advertise Contact Us Services

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Search

Adam and His Eves < Home > Deadly, Tiny, and Ready For Its Close-up, Mr. DeMille

August 25, 2004Spite in a Petri Dish

Spiteful bacteria. Two words you probably haven't heard together. Then again, you probably haven't heard of altruistic bacteria either, but both sorts of microbes are out there--and in many cases in you.

Bacteria lead marvelously complicated social lives. As a group of University of Edinburgh biologists today in , a nasty bug called

, which causes lung infections, dedicates a lot of energy to helping itsfellow . The microbes need iron, which is hard for them to find in a usable form in our bodies. To overcome the shortage, can release special molecules called siderophiles that snatch up iron compounds and make them palatable to the microbe. It takes a lot of energy for the bacteria to make siderophiles, and they aren't guaranteed a return for the investment. Once a siderophile harvests some iron, any that happens to be near it can gulp it down.

reported Nature Pseudomonas aeruginosa

P. aeruginosaP. aeruginosa

P. aeruginosa

At first glance, this generosity shouldn't exist. Microbes that put a lot of energy into helping other microbes should become extinct--or, more exactly, the genes that produce generosity in them should become extinct. Biologists have discoveredmutant that cheat--they don't produce siderophiles but still suck up siderophiles made by the do-gooders. It might seem as if the cheaters should wipe the do-gooders off the face of the Earth. The solution to this sort of puzzle--or at least one solution--is helping out family. Closely related microbes share the same genes. If a relative scoops up the iron and can reproduce, that's all the same for your genes.

P. aeruginoa

To test this hypothesis, the Edinburgh team ran an experiment. They filled twelve beakers with bacteria they produced from a single clone. While the bacteria were all closely related, half were cheaters and half were do-gooders. They let the bacteria feed, multiply, and compete with one another. Then they mixed the beakers together, and randomly chose some bacteria to start a new colony in twelve new beakers. More successful bacteria gradually became more common as they started new rounds. In the end, the researhers found--as they predicted--that these close relatives evolved into cooperators. The do-gooders wound up making up nearly 100% of the population.

That didn't happen when the researchers put together two different clones in the same beakers. When the bacteria had less chance of helping relatives, the do-gooders wound up making up less than half of the population.

But the biologists suspected that even families could turn on themselves. Mathematical models suggest that the benefit of helping relatives drops if relatives are crammed together too closely. They never get a free lunch--siderophiles produced by other, unrelated bacteria. Instead, all the benefits of consuming iron are offset by the cost of producing the siderophiles. In the end, the benefit doesn't justify the cost.

The Edinburgh team came up with a clever way to test this prediction out. They ran the same colony experiment as before, but now they didn't take a random sample from the mixed beakers to start a new colony. Instead, they took a fixed number of bacteria from each beaker. This new procedure meant that there was no longer a benefit to being in a beaker where the bacteria were reproducing faster than the bacteria in other beakers. The only way to survive to the next round of the experiment was to outcompete the other bacteria in your own beaker--even if they were your own relatives. The researchers discovered that when closely related bacteria were forced to compete this way, utopia disappeared. Instead, the ratio of cheaters to do-gooders remained about where it started, around 50:50.

The evolutionary logic of altruism also has a dark side, known as spite, which the Edinburgh have explored in a paper in press at the Journal of Evolutionary Biology. (They've posted a on their web site.) It's theoretically possible that you can help out your relatives (and even yourself) by doing harm to unrelated members of your same

pdf

Corante Industry News

Corante Weblogs

ABOUT THIS AUTHOR

is the author of several popular science books and writes frequently for magazines including

and .

VISIT

Carl Zimmer

The New York Times Magazine, National Geographic, Science, Newsweek, Discover, Popular Science, Natural History More about Carl...

CARLZIMMER.COM

SUBSCRIBEEnter your email to be notified of new posts to THE LOOM

Submit

THE LOOM ARCHIVESSelect Month...

ABOUT THIS SITEThe Loom weaves together deep time and modern life. It surveys new research on evolution, paleontology, and comparative biology and links them to biotechnology, medicine, neuroscience, computer science, environmental issues, politics, and ethics. Plus the occasional mind-controlling parasite.

RECENT TRACKBACKSGene Expression: Tell that to Mrs. Coolidge....The Panda's Thumb: What mitochondria and Y chromosomes tell us about marriage...Pharyngula: The Loom is back in businessGene Expression: Sex skewidiolect.org.uk: Links for 15th of JulyMuck and Mystery: Politics As Usual

SYNDICATIONRSS 1.0RSS 2.0

CATEGORIZED POSTSBrainsEvolutionGeneralThe Parasite Files

MORE ABOUT CARLCarl's books include and

. He has been been called "as fine a science essayist as we have" by the

His new book,

Parasite RexEvolution: The Triumph of An

IdeaNew York Times Book

Review. Soul Made

THE LATEST BOOK

SOUL MADE FLESHIn which I follow a motley crew of 17th-century alchemists, religious fugitives, and various scientific visionaries as they transformed the search for the soul into the science of the brain."Illuminating"--"Thrilling"--"Remarkable"--"A page-turner"--"A tour-de-force"--

NY TimesLA Times

NatureWired

Sunday TelegraphBUY A COPYREAD THE INTRODUCTION

RECENT COMMENTSSeth on Deadly, Tiny, and Ready For Its Close-up, Mr. DeMilleSeth on Deadly, Tiny, and Ready For Its Close-up, Mr. DeMilleNightmare on Adam and His EvesGreyshade on Adam and His Evesjoel on Adam and His EvesBrian on Adam and His Eves

GOOD LINKSDienekes' Anthropology BlogAlan Boyle: Cosmic LogArts & Letters DailyAstrobiology MagazineBorneo ChelaBorneo ChelaBrain WavesBrightsurfButterflies and WheelsChris C MooneyComplexity DigestConscious EntitiesConservation NewsCorey PowellCrumb TrailDavid GrinspoonDe Rerum NaturaDefense TechDiscover MagazineEvolution WikiEvolutionblogFuture NowFuturePundithelminthologHuman Nature Daily ReviewInfo PollutionJay ManifoldJohn HorganKen Miller's Evolution PageLiving CodeMainlyMartianMark LynasMartian SoilMassimo Pigliucci: Rationally SpeakingNational Center for Science EducationNature is ProfligateNeuroeconomicsPaleontology NewsPharyngulaPhilip BallPipeline by Derek LowePLoS BiologyPreposterous UniversePubMedQuark SoupSarkar Lab WebLogSciTech Daily Review

27/8/04 9:48 amThe Loom: Spite in a Petri Dish

Page 1 of 2http://www.corante.com/loom/archives/005849.html

species, even if you have to pay a cost to do it. You might even die in the process, but if you could wreak enough havoc with your competitors, this sort of behavior could be favored by evolution. Biologists call this sort of behavior spite.

It turns out that many bacteria are spiteful in precisely this way. They produce antibiotics known as bacteriocins that are poisonous to their own species. These poisons take a lot of energy to make, and the bacteria often die as they release them. But these spiteful bacteria don't kill their own kin. Each strain of bacteria that makes a bacteriocin also makes an antidote to that particular kind of bacteriocin. Obviously, evolution won't favor a lineage of microbes that all blow themselves up. But it may encourage a certain balance of spite--a balance that will depend on the particular conditions in which the bacteria evolve.

Understanding the evolution of spiteful and altruistic bacteria will help scientists come up with new ways to fight diseases. (The altruism of can make life hell for people with cystic fibrosis, because the bacteria cooperate to rob a person of the iron in his or her lungs.) But bacteria can serve as a model for other organisms who can be altruistic or spiteful--like us. While some glib sociobiologists may see a link between a spiteful self-destructive microbe and a suicide bomber, the analogy as both disgusting and stupid. Yet the same evolutionary calculus keeps playing out in the behavior of bacteria and people alike.

P. aeruginosa

Posted by Carl at 9:58 PM

There are no comments posted for this entry.

Post a Comment

Name: Email:

URL:

Comments:

Remember personal info? Yes No Post

Email this entry to a friendEmail this entry to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):

Send

Related Entries

- -

- -

- -

- -

• Deadly, Tiny, and Ready For Its Close-up, Mr. DeMille 08/26/2004• Spite in a Petri Dish 08/25/2004• Adam and His Eves 08/23/2004• Blog Revived 08/22/2004• Mooney on the Science War 07/08/2004• Evolution meets IVF 07/07/2004• Dawn of the Leafy Age 07/05/2004• The Little Ones 07/02/2004

is a chronicle of the dawn of neurology in the 1600s. It will be published in January 2004. Please send newsworthy items or feedback to blog-at-carlzimmer.com.

Flesh,

RECENT MAGAZINE ARTICLES

The New York Times Magazine, September 23, 2003

Discover, September 2003

Newsweek, June 8, 2003

"Whose Life Would You Save?" , April 2004Discover

"Can't Get It Out of My Head: Brain Discorder Causes Mysterious Music Hallucination"

, February 28, 2004The Sunday Telegraph Magazine

"Mind Over Machine" , February 2004

(cover story)Popular Science

"A Distant Mirror For the Brain", January 2, 2004Science

"Zeroing in on climate change,", December

1, 2003Newsweek International

"What If There Is Something Going On In There?"

"Great Mysteries of Human Evolution"

"Head Shots"

FULL-TEXT ARTICLE ARCHIVE

WHY THE LOOM?"...among the joyous, heartless, ever-juvenile eternities, Pip saw the multitudinous, God-omnipresent, coral insects, that out of the firmament of waters, heaved the colossal orbs. He saw God's foot upon the treadle of the loom, and spoke it; and therefore his shipmates called him mad." -- Moby Dick

All text in this web log is licensed under a .Creative Commons License

POWERED BYMOVABLE TYPE 2.64

Signal+NoiseStephen Jay GouldSteven Berlin JohnsonSteven Pinkerstranger fruitTalk ReasonTalk.OriginsThe American Journal of Bioethics :: Bioethics News ArchiveThe Leiter ReportsThe Panda's ThumbThe Personal GenomeThree-Toed SlothUnAustralianUnderstanding EvolutionVirginia PostrelWangBlogWeb of AffinitiesPowered byBlogRolling

MORE BOOKS

Evolution: The Triumph of an Idea (2001)

Parasite Rex (2000)

At the Water's Edge (1998)

27/8/04 9:48 amThe Loom: Spite in a Petri Dish

Page 2 of 2http://www.corante.com/loom/archives/005849.html