19
Spent Fuel Monitoring Olli Heinonen Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs John F. Kennedy School of Government 1 February 2012

Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Spent Fuel Monitoring

Olli HeinonenBelfer Center for Science and International AffairsJohn F. Kennedy School of Government1 February 2012

Page 2: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Recommendations of the Commission

Develop geological disposal facilitiesConsolidated interim storage facilitiesUS leadership in international efforts to

address safety, waste management, non-proliferation and security concerns

DOE to review its R&D “road map”

Page 3: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Consequences

Spent fuel will be moved from current locations to centralized storages

Page 4: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Challenges

Monitoring of spent fuel can last over 100 years

Calls for- less resource consuming approaches- simple robust remotely interrogated

verification systems- minimum need for re-verification of spent

fuel

Page 5: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Opportunities Safeguards-By-

Design taking into account safety, security and safeguards requirements from the beginning

Paves way for “from cradle to grave” approach which reduces proliferation risks

STR-360 Facility Design and Plant Operation Features that facilitate the Implementation of IAEA Safeguards, 2009

Page 6: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

IAEA Verification Experience

Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors

Page 7: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

IAEA Verification Experience

Spent fuel in wet and dry storages e.g. Japan, Kazakhstan, Sweden, Canada and Germany

Page 8: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

IAEA Verification Experience

Shipment and storing of vitrified high level waste

Page 9: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Verification Requirements – Wet Storages

Verification by a Cherenkov viewing device

Kept under optical surveillance

Traditionally re-verification once a year; under integrated safeguards once in three years

.

Page 10: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Dual C/S

Spent fuel -“difficult to assess item”

Verification prior to fuel transferred into casks

Cask sealing and optical surveillance.

Page 11: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Unattended Monitoring

Witnessing cask loading and unloading resource intensive

Under water surveillance and monitors

Page 12: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Remote Monitoring/Inspection

Take advantage of unattended monitoring systems by transmitting images and other data to Vienna

Combine with unannounced inspections to certifiythe integrity of the system

Page 13: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Further developments

RFIDRemotely

monitored sealing array (RMSA)

Page 14: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Further developments

Canister integrity using laser surface mapping of welds

Page 15: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

Further developments

Gamma scanning of containers

In-situ measurements of neitron signatures

Page 16: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

R&D – Key to Success

The IAEA publishes its next R&D needs document in February 2012

Page 17: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

To-morrow’s Tools

You cannot win to-morrow’s wars with yesterday’s tools

Develop approaches requiring less inspection resources

Page 18: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification

In Summary

Safeguards, security and safety by design

Tap to new technologies with remote inspections combined with announced access scheme

Page 19: Spent Fuel Monitoring - US Department of Energy · IAEA Safeguards, 2009. IAEA Verification Experience Experience in monitoring spent fuel at power and research reactors. IAEA Verification