33
Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs (sdM, esdM, usdM) from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Sébastien Lépine American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY, USA

Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs (sdM, esdM, usdM) from the

Sloan Digital Sky Survey

Sébastien Lépine

American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY, USA

Page 2: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Cool subdwarfs in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: new spectroscopy

Page 3: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Kinematic separation of the M dwarfs and M

Disk starsHalo stars

(high velocity)

sdM / esdM / usdM subclass definition :TiOCaH

Spectral indices used for the classification.

Require S/N > 30with medium to high-resspectra

Page 4: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Kinematic separation of the M dwarfs and M

Disk starsHalo stars

(high velocity)

sdM / esdM / usdM subclass definition :TiOCaH

Spectral indices used for the classification.

Require S/N > 30with medium to high-resspectra

Page 5: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Kinematic separation of the M dwarfs and M

Disk starsHalo stars

(high velocity)

sdM / esdM / usdM subclass definition :TiOCaH

Spectral indices used for the classification.

Require S/N > 30with medium to high-resspectra

Page 6: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Kinematic separation of the M dwarfs and M

Disk starsHalo stars

(high velocity)

sdM / esdM / usdM subclass definition :TiOCaH

Spectral indices used for the classification.

Require S/N > 30with medium to high-resspectra

Page 7: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Kinematic separation of the M dwarfs and M

Disk starsHalo stars

(high velocity)

sdM / esdM / usdM subclass definition :TiOCaH

Spectral indices used for the classification.

Require S/N > 30with medium to high-resspectra

Page 8: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based on the TiO5, CaH2, CaH3 indices. Instead, new classification templates are introduced, composites of SDSS stars with S/N >10.

Spectral classification is performed from best fit of the 5500 A - 8500 A region.The TiO/CaH band ratio still largely determines the subclass (M / sdM / esdM / usdM).

Page 9: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based on the TiO5, CaH2, CaH3 indices. Instead, new classification templates are introduced, composites of SDSS stars with S/N >10.

Spectral classification is performed from best fit of the 5500 A - 8500 A region.The TiO/CaH band ratio still largely determines the subclass (M / sdM / esdM / usdM).

Page 10: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based on the TiO5, CaH2, CaH3 indices. Instead, new classification templates are introduced, composites of SDSS stars with S/N >10.

Spectral classification is performed from best fit of the 5500 A - 8500 A region.The TiO/CaH band ratio still largely determines the subclass (M / sdM / esdM / usdM).

Page 11: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based on the TiO5, CaH2, CaH3 indices. Instead, new classification templates are introduced, composites of SDSS stars with S/N >10.

Spectral classification is performed from best fit of the 5500 A - 8500 A region.The TiO/CaH band ratio still largely determines the subclass (M / sdM / esdM / usdM).

Page 12: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based on the TiO5, CaH2, CaH3 indices. Instead, new classification templates are introduced, composites of SDSS stars with S/N >10.

Spectral classification is performed from best fit of the 5500 A - 8500 A region.The TiO/CaH band ratio still largely determines the subclass (M / sdM / esdM / usdM).

Page 13: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based on the TiO5, CaH2, CaH3 indices. Instead, new classification templates are introduced, composites of SDSS stars with S/N >10.

Spectral classification is performed from best fit of the 5500 A - 8500 A region.The TiO/CaH band ratio still largely determines the subclass (M / sdM / esdM / usdM).

Page 14: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based on the TiO5, CaH2, CaH3 indices. Instead, new classification templates are introduced, composites of SDSS stars with S/N >10.

Spectral classification is performed from best fit of the 5500 A - 8500 A region.The TiO/CaH band ratio still largely determines the subclass (M / sdM / esdM / usdM).

Page 15: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

color variation with subclass and subtype

As shown in the next 4 plots, subdwarfs populate the g-r/r-i color-color diagram according to their spectral subclass and subtype.

This suggests that faint subdwarfs could be classified based on their g-r. r-i color alone. In particular, the 4 subclasses (M/sdM/esdM/usdM) populate very distinct loci.

The loci “fan out” at later subtypes, which makes the ultra-cool subdwarfs even easier to identify and classify.

The reduced proper motion diagram indicates that esdM and usdM subclasses are dominated by high velocity stars from the halo (high transverse velocity => higher reduced proper motion Hz => shifted down on the reduced proper motion plot), while the M and sdM are consistent with the low velocity disk population.

Page 16: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

color-color (g-r / r-i)

color variation with subclass and subtype M0 / sdM0 / esdM0 / usdM0

reduced proper motion

Page 17: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

color-color (g-r / r-i) reduced proper motion

color variation with subclass and subtype M2 / sdM2 / esdM2 / usdM2

Page 18: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

color-color (g-r / r-i) reduced proper motion

color variation with subclass and subtype M6 / sdM6 / esdM6 / usdM6

Page 19: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

color-color (g-r / r-i) reduced proper motion

color variation with subclass and subtype M8 / sdM8 / esdM8 / usdM8

Page 20: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

KINaI

New classification features - mid subdwarfs:

Traditional classification featuresNew classification features

Page 21: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

KINaI

New classification features - mid subdwarfs:

Traditional classification featuresNew classification features

Page 22: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

KINaI

New classification features - mid subdwarfs:

Traditional classification featuresNew classification features

Page 23: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

New classification features - late subdwarfs:

Traditional classification featuresNew classification features

Page 24: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

New classification features - late subdwarfs:

Traditional classification featuresNew classification features

Page 25: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

New classification features - late subdwarfs:

Traditional classification featuresNew classification features

Page 26: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Rb I

New classification features - late subdwarfs:

Traditional classification featuresNew classification features

Page 27: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Getting the subclass (M/sdM/esdM/usdM) is critical for: 1 - Calibrating the color magnitude relationship to determine photometric distances. 2 - Simple estimating of the metallicity / population membership study.

Gizis (1997)

Do we need the 4 “flavours” of low-mass stars?

Page 28: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Getting the subclass (M/sdM/esdM/usdM) is critical for: 1 - Calibrating the color magnitude relationship to determine photometric distances. 2 - Simple estimating of the metallicity / population membership study.

Gizis (1997)

Do we need the 4 “flavours” of low-mass stars?

Page 29: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Getting the subclass (M/sdM/esdM/usdM) is critical for: 1 - Calibrating the color magnitude relationship to determine photometric distances. 2 - Simple estimating of the metallicity / population membership study.

Gizis (1997)

Do we need the 4 “flavours” of low-mass stars?

Page 30: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Getting the subclass (M/sdM/esdM/usdM) is critical for: 1 - Calibrating the color magnitude relationship to determine photometric distances. 2 - Simple estimating of the metallicity / population membership study.

Gizis (1997)

Do we need the 4 “flavours” of low-mass stars?

Page 31: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

Getting the subclass (M/sdM/esdM/usdM) is critical for: 1 - Calibrating the color magnitude relationship to determine photometric distances. 2 - Simple estimating of the metallicity / population membership study.

Gizis (1997)

Do we need the 4 “flavours” of low-mass stars?

Page 32: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

But are we sure these are metallicity effects? Best evidence: the common proper motion pairs.

But there’s not enough pairs which have been classified. More are needed: this is the key to this problem!

Page 33: Spectroscopic sequences of cool and ultra-cool subdwarfs ...web.mit.edu/~ajb/www/browndwarfs/cs15/presentations/lepine.pdf · Classification of the SDSS subdwarfs is no longer based

14

• SIM / NStars grant AST-0087313

• Galactic Astronomy grant AST-0607757

• Research Experience for Undergraduates (REU) program

• Kalbfleich Research Fellowship

• Mr. Hilary Lipsitz

U.S. National Science Foundation