4
TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM © 2016 SILVERTON CONSULTING, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED SPC performance report Silverton Consulting, Inc. StorInt™ Dispatch This Storage Intelligence (StorInt™) dispatch covers Storage Performance Council (SPC) results 1 . SPC has recently released a new version of their SPC-1 benchmark, V3. There have been no new SPC-1 V1 submissions since our last report but there has been 1 new V3 submission, the IBM DS8888 (AFA). For now, we will include all V3 and V1 SPC-1 submissions together in our analysis. The major IO difference between the two is that V3 uses a larger fixed block size than V1, (8KB vs. 4KB) 2 and while this might take an extra microsecond or two to transfer at 16Gbps, it seems unlikely to impact IOPS and LRT results that much. There have been no new SPC-2 submissions SPC-1 results We begin our discussion with top ten SPC-1 LRT™ (Least Response Time) results shown in Figure 1. Figure 1 Top 10 SPC-1 LRT results 1 All SPC results available from http://www.storageperformance.org/home/ as of 24Nov2016 2 SPC-1 V3 specification can be found at http://www.storageperformance.org/specs/SPC1_v320_final.pdf

SPC performance reportsilvertonconsulting.com/nwsa/SCISPC161128-010.pdf · been no new SPC-1 V1 submissions since our last report but there has been 1 new V3 submission, the IBM DS8888

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: SPC performance reportsilvertonconsulting.com/nwsa/SCISPC161128-010.pdf · been no new SPC-1 V1 submissions since our last report but there has been 1 new V3 submission, the IBM DS8888

TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM©2016SILVERTONCONSULTING,INC.ALLRIGHTSRESERVED

SPC performance report SilvertonConsulting,Inc.StorInt™DispatchThisStorageIntelligence(StorInt™)dispatchcoversStoragePerformanceCouncil(SPC)results1.SPChasrecentlyreleasedanewversionoftheirSPC-1benchmark,V3.TherehavebeennonewSPC-1V1submissionssinceourlastreportbuttherehasbeen1newV3submission,theIBMDS8888(AFA).Fornow,wewillincludeallV3andV1SPC-1submissionstogetherinouranalysis.ThemajorIOdifferencebetweenthetwoisthatV3usesalargerfixedblocksizethanV1,(8KBvs.4KB)2andwhilethismighttakeanextramicrosecondortwototransferat16Gbps,itseemsunlikelytoimpactIOPSandLRTresultsthatmuch.TherehavebeennonewSPC-2submissions

SPC-1resultsWebeginourdiscussionwithtoptenSPC-1LRT™(LeastResponseTime)resultsshowninFigure1.

Figure1Top10SPC-1LRTresults

1AllSPCresultsavailablefromhttp://www.storageperformance.org/home/asof24Nov20162SPC-1V3specificationcanbefoundathttp://www.storageperformance.org/specs/SPC1_v320_final.pdf

Page 2: SPC performance reportsilvertonconsulting.com/nwsa/SCISPC161128-010.pdf · been no new SPC-1 V1 submissions since our last report but there has been 1 new V3 submission, the IBM DS8888

28Nov2016 SCISPCPERFORMANCEREPORT PAGE2OF4

TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM©2015SILVERTONCONSULTING,INC.ALLRIGHTSRESERVED

SPC-1V3nolongerreportsonLRTbutthereisasimilarmetric(RAMPD_10AverageResponseIOtime)inthedetailedmetricsprovidedinthesubmission.FromnowonwewilljustrefertothisasLRTbutnoteLRTisnotformerlyreportedanymore.TherearenochangesinFigure1fromlastquarter’sreviewbuttheIBMDS8888justmissedthetoptenwithanLRT*3of0.254msec.Next,weturntoSPC-1toptenIOPS™inFigure2.

Figure2SPC-1Top10IOPS™

HeretheIBMDS8888camein5thplacewith1.5MIOPS.TheDS8888had240400GBFlashmoduleswith2048GBofDRAMmemoryandused16GbpsFCasthefrontendinterface.AsthiswasSPC-1V3theDS8888wasalsodoinglargerfixedblockIOsthanthe(V1)competitionbutagainthedifferenceshouldbenegligible.Thereisonlyonehybrid(disk-SSD)systemthatremainsonourSPC-1IOPSTopTenandthatistheHuaweiOceanStor18800(#8).WeturnnowtoIOPS/Drivefordisk-onlysystemsinFigure3.

3TheRAMPD_10Avg.ResponseIOtimemetriccanbefoundinSPC1_Metrics_0_Quick_Look.xlsxfileinSupportingFilesforSPC-1V3benchmarksubmissions

Page 3: SPC performance reportsilvertonconsulting.com/nwsa/SCISPC161128-010.pdf · been no new SPC-1 V1 submissions since our last report but there has been 1 new V3 submission, the IBM DS8888

28Nov2016 SCISPCPERFORMANCEREPORT PAGE3OF4

TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM©2015SILVERTONCONSULTING,INC.ALLRIGHTSRESERVED

Figure3Top10SPC-1IOPS/(disk-)drive

InFigure3,theIBMStorwizeV5030systemcameinat#9with354IOPS/diskdrive.Ithad240300GB15KRPMdiskdriveswith64GBofDRAMmemoryandthediskswereSASattachedtothetwocontrollers.Asyoumayrecall,wementionedtheIBMStorwizeV5030asthefirstV3submissioninourlastreportbutatthetimehadnotincorporateditintoour(V1)performanceanalysis,wedosonow.Again,theSPC-1V3benchmarkdoeslargerfixedblockIOs(8KBvs4KB)whichmightbeaslightdisadvantagebutprobablyisn’tmeasurableatthisscale.It’sunusualtoseeanewdisk-onlySPC-1submission,especiallyfromamajorvendor(IBM).It’salmostasiftheynolongerwanttoeventalkofdisk-onlystorageanymore.Andyetwebelieve,there’sstillroomforperformanceimprovementevenindisk-onlystorage,letalonehybridsystems.

Page 4: SPC performance reportsilvertonconsulting.com/nwsa/SCISPC161128-010.pdf · been no new SPC-1 V1 submissions since our last report but there has been 1 new V3 submission, the IBM DS8888

28Nov2016 SCISPCPERFORMANCEREPORT PAGE4OF4

TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM©2015SILVERTONCONSULTING,INC.ALLRIGHTSRESERVED

SignificanceForthemoment,afterreviewingboththeV3andV1specificationforSPC-1wehaveconcludedtojustincorporatethembothintothesameSPC-1analysis.It’sunclearwhetherSPChasstoppedacceptingnewsubmissionswithSPC-1V1.WereservetherighttosplitV3submissionsoutifwedeterminethattheV3andV1workloadsaredifferentenoughtowarranttheirseparation.AFAsystemscontinuetheirmarchtodominatingLRTandnowIOPStoptenpositions.ThereremainsonlyonehybridstoragesystemleftintheIOPStoptenbutit’sbeingslowlypushedoffbyallthenewAFAstoragesystemperformance.Asalways,suggestionsonhowtoimproveanyofourperformanceanalysesarewelcomed.Additionally,ifyouareinterestedinmoreblockstorageperformanceinformation,checkoutourrecentlyupdated(November2016),SANStorageBuyingGuideavailableforpurchasefromourwebsite4.IntheSANStorageBuyingGuidewenowprovidetop30resultsforsomeofourSPCperformancechartsandnew,SCIderived,OLTP,ThroughputandEmailChampionsCharts™forenterprise,all-flash,mid-rangeandSMBclassSANstoragesystems.

Silverton Consulting, Inc., is a U.S.-based Storage, Strategy & Systems consulting firm offering products and services to the data storage community

SANStorageBuyingGuideURLinQRcodeNewslettersignupURLinQRcode)

4Availableathttp://silvertonconsulting.com/cms1/product/san-storage-buying-guide/