SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    1/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    2/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    3/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    4/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    5/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    6/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    7/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    8/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    9/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    10/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    11/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    12/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    13/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    14/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    15/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    16/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    17/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    18/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    19/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    20/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    21/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    22/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    23/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    24/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    25/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    26/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    27/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    28/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    29/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    30/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    31/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    32/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    33/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    34/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    35/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    36/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    37/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    38/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    39/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    40/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    41/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    42/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    43/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    44/55

    Zentrum frinterdisziplinre Forschung

    [Version 1 February 2008]

    IMAGINING OUTER SPACE,1900-2000

    An International Conference

    February 6-9, 2008

    Organization: Alexander C.T. Geppert

    Program

    Wednesday, February 6, 2008

    15.00 Welcome Reception and Opening Remarks

    Ipke Wachsmuth and Alexander C.T. Geppert

    16.00 Introduction

    Alexander C.T. GeppertEuropean Astrofuturism, Cosmic Provincialism. Historical Problems and Historiographi-

    cal Perspectives

    16.30 Keynote Lecture

    Steven J. DickSpace, Time and Aliens. The Role of Imagination in Outer Space

    17.30 Coffee

    18.00 Feature Presentation I

    Philip PocockSpacePlace. Art in the Age of Orbitization

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    45/55

    2Thursday, February 7, 2008

    09.00 Panel I: Theorizing Outer Space

    Chair: De Witt Douglas Kilgore

    Debbora Battaglia

    Galaxies of E.T. Discourse. An Anthropologist's First Contact with the Science ofWeirdLife

    Thomas BrandstetterImagining Inorganic Life. Crystalline Aliens in Science and Fiction

    Benjamin LazierThe Globalization of the World-Picture. Towards a History of Earth and Artifact inTwentieth-Century Thought

    11.00 Coffee

    11.15 Panel II: Personalizing Outer SpaceChair: Bernd Weisbrod

    Christina WesselyCosmic Spectacular. Rocketry, Weltanschauung and the Quest for Cosmic Ice inWeimar Germany

    Thore BjrnvigTranscendence of Gravity. Arthur C. Clarke and the Apocalyptic of Weightlessness

    13.00 Lunch

    14.00 Panel III: Localizing Outer SpaceChair: Andreas W. Daum

    Kerrie Anne DoughertySpaceport Woomera

    Sven MesinovicInner Space and Outer Space. Similarities, Differences and Connections

    16.00 Coffee

    16.15 Panel IV: Screening Outer Space

    Chair: Peter Becker

    Burghard CieslaOuter Space, Inner Fear. Cold War SF-Films in East and West

    Henry KeazorA Stumble in the Dark. Gerry AndersonsSpace 1999

    Werner SuppanzNazis in Space. Distant Worlds as Projection Screen of Cultural Memory

    18.00 Feature Presentation II

    Screening of Historical Films

    18 30 Di t ZiF

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    46/55

    3Friday, February 8, 2008

    09.00 Panel V: Fictionalizing Outer Space

    Chair: Angela Schwarz

    Claudia Schmlders

    Unwriting Heaven. Tunguska Region, June 30, 1908

    Steffen KrmerAncient Heroes and Early Christian Ascetics. Archetypes of Modern Science Fiction

    Rainer EisfeldProjecting Landscapes of the Human Mind on Another World. Changing Features of anImaginary Mars

    11.00 Coffee

    11.15 Panel VI: Visioning Outer Space

    Chair: Alexander C.T. Geppert

    Pierre LagrangeA 'Symmetrical' Explanation for Flying Saucers

    James I. MillerEncountering Aliens in the French Countryside. UFOs and the Fabrication of a NewWorld in Quarouble, France, 1954

    13.00 Lunch

    14.00 Panel VII: Politicizing Outer Space

    Chair: Kai-Uwe Schrogl

    Monica RthersOuter Space, Childrens Material Culture and Soviet Imagery after Sputnik

    Michael J. NeufeldSmash the Myth of the Fascist Rocket Baron. East German Attacks on Wernher vonBraun in the 1960s

    16.00 Coffee

    16.15 Panel VIII: Communicating Outer Space

    Chair: Ralf Blow

    Guillaume de SyonBetween the Bubble and the Moon. Visions of Space Travel in Francophone ComicStrips

    Bernd MtterPer Media Ad Astra? Outer Space in West Germanys Media 1957-1987

    20.00 Dinner Downtown

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    47/55

    4Saturday, February 9, 2008

    09.00 Panel IX: Automatizing Outer Space

    Chair: Paul Ceruzzi

    James Schwoch

    Short, Nasty, and Brutish. The Curious Life of Telstar, 10 July 1962 - 21 February 1963

    Gonzalo MunevarSelf-Reproducing Automata and the Impossibility of SETI

    11.00 Coffee

    11.15 Panel X: Designing Outer Space

    Chair: Peter Davidson

    William R. MacauleyInscribing Scientific Knowledge. Interstellar Communication, Universal Laws and Con-tact with Cultures of the Imagination

    Tristan WeddigenAlien Spotting. Damien Hirsts Beagle 2 Mars LanderCalibration Target and the Ex-ploitation of Outer Space

    13.00 Snack

    14.00 Conclusion

    Chair: Steven J. Dick

    Helmuth TrischlerGeneral Commentary

    16.00 End

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    48/55

    Project Proposal and Briefing - 05 April 2006

    SpacePlace: Art in the Age of OrbitizationPrepared by Prof. Philip Pocock, in consultation with Prof. Dr. Peter Weibel, CEO ZKM.

    Conceptual Launch Pad: Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief Systems of the World (Galileo1632)ItwasnotGalileo'sastrophysicsandmaththatleddirectlytohisimprisonmentduringtheInquisition.Ironically,itwasaplay,Galileo'sSocraticdialoguefrom1632titledADialogueConcerningtheTwoChiefSystemsoftheWorldthatinfuriatedthePopeenoughtoplacehimunderhousearrest.

    Afterall,'Mathematics was rated at the time as a thing for technicians,'MITProf.GiorgiodeSantillanapositsinhisbookTheCrimeofGalileoin1955.Galileo'sdramaturgicalchoiceofaSocraticdialogue,encouragingreaderstoreflectandthinkindependentlyandcritically,wasfarmorepotentpubliclythananyvirtuosodisplayofabstractmathematicalreasoningcouldbeatthetime.

    Galileo'sDialogueconvincinglyandplayfullyrevealedbeforealltheworldtheneedlessabsurdityofadogmaupholdingageocentricworldview,whileaffectivelymakinghisEppur si muove(Andyetitdoemove!)argumentinfavorofCopernicus'heliocentricworldview,withnolossofmythologyanddelightandthecommonsensegainssuchacceptancewouldmetescience,technologyandculture.Ironicallyaswell,itwasthesameinventionthatGalileowentpartiallyblindpeeringthroughtoempiricallysubstantiateCopernicus'viewfromhis1543treatiseRevolutionsoftheCelestialOrbs-namely,thetelescopeorspyglass-thatsoonafteritsinventionturneditsopticalgazebackonustocentertheworldviewagainonhumankind(aswetendorliketoplaceorseeourselves?)

    WiththespeedofacoupleofcenturiestelemediahaveplacedEarthonceagainatthecenterofanothevirtualgeocentricorgeo-centroidworldscheme.AtelematicuniversestarringplanetEarth,orbitedbysurveillingspyglasssatellites,shiningstand-insforplanets,FoxandCNNcompetingwithVenusandMarsformediaattention,SkyTVactingasanersatz-Jupiter,dayandnight.NamJunePaik,aTVartpioneersaiditbesttitlingaTVinstallationfrom1965:Moon is the Oldest TV.

    Impetus to Launch Space Art Now: Open Discourse Concerning the Weaponization of, or the

    Cultural Utilization of Outer Space?

    Spacevehiclesandinter-planetarytravelfirstappearinthegreatepicofIndia,theMahabharata,at220000lines,theworld'slongestpoem,composedbysageVedVyasperhaps2500yearsago:

    'Arjuna, blazing like the sun itself, ascended the celestial car (Vimana). And after he had becomeinvisible to the mortals of the Earth, he beheld thousands of cars of extraordinary beauty. And in thatregion there was no sun or moon or fire to give light, but it blazed in light of its own, generated byvirtue and ascetic merit.'VolumeIII,VanaParva,SectionXLIITranslatedbyKisariMohanGanguli,1886-1890.

    Arjuna,bothwarrior-princeandhumanmonad(symbolicindividual,)apparentlyembarkedaVimuna

    (spacevehicle)soaringupinablazethroughcloudcoverintodeepdarkouterspace.Hewastakingtwdiscreetjourneysinparallel:One,aculturalmythologicaljourney,beholding,forinstance,thecelestiacityofIndra,whileatthesametimesettingoutonanaerialmilitaryforaytoslaytribalopponentsin theancientMahabharataWar,lettinghisironarrows(Baan)flyandfindtheirtargetsfromonhigh.Althoughspaceculture,scienceandtechnologyhaveundeniablymadequantumleapsinmanyregardssincetheMahabharata,theirsharedpolicyissueastowhichpathtotakeconcerningEarth'sutilizationofNearEarthandOuterSpaceremainsthequandaryitwasforArjuna2000yearsago-theweaponizationof,ortheculturalutilizationofspace?

    Accelerating Weaponization of Near Earth Space: 1960 to the Present.

    VicePresidentLyndonB.Johnsonquippedin1961:'Control of space means control of the world.'

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    49/55

    TheUnitedNations1967TreatyonPrinciplesGoverningtheActivitiesofStatesintheExplorationandUseofOuterSpace,includingtheMoonandOtherCelestialBodiesadoptedunanimouslybytheGeneraAssemblyin1963,sinceratifiedby98statesandadditionallysignedby27states,clearlysetslimitstothemilitarizationofspaceinArticleIV:'Parties to the Treaty undertake not to place in orbit around theEarth any objects carrying nuclear weapons or any other kinds of weapons of mass destruction, installsuch weapons on celestial bodies, or station such weapons in outer space in any other manner.'

    TheOuterSpaceTreatyalsocondemnsany'propaganda designed or likely to provoke or encourage anthreat to the peace, breach of the peace or act of aggression, and considering that the aforementionedresolution is applicable to outer space.'

    In1996,USSpaceCommander-in-Chief,Gen.JosephW.Ashy,fannedhisspacedefensepolicycardsflatoutonthetableinAviationWeekandSpaceTechnology:' It's politically sensitive, but it's going tohappen. Some people don't want to hear this, and it sure isn't in vogue, but absolutely we're going tofight in space. We're going to fight from space and we're going to fight into space. That's why the UShas development programs in directed energy and hit-to-kill mechanisms. We will engage terrestrialtargets someday - ships, airplanes, land targets - from space. '

    In2001,shortlyafter9/11,theBushadministrationwithdrewtheUnitedStatesfromtheAnti-BallisticMissileTreatyandvastlyincreasedthemissiledefensebudgetin2002,thesameyearhisadministration'sQuadrennialDefenseReviewdefined:'A key objective is not only to ensure US abilityto exploit space for military purposes, but also, as required, to deny an adversary's ability to do so. 'Followingupatthe2003USAirForceAssociationLosAngelessymposium,PeteB.Teets,USAirForceUndersecretary,declared:'Space is the ultimate high ground. Our military advantage there mustremain ahead of our adversaries' capabilities, and our own doctrine and capabilities must keep pace tomeet that challenge. We haven't reached the point of strafing and bombing from space. Nonethelesswe are thinking about those possibilities.'Hewentontoemphaticallyacclaim:'The United Stateswields airpower more effectively than any other fighting force in history precisely because it hasembraced these three principles: We jealously gain and maintain control of the air even though othersmay try to deny us that control. We aggressively apply airpower in every conceivable manner toachieve our war-fighting objectives, from global vigilance to global reach to global strike. We proudlyand actively support and nurture a culture of airpower professionals. We do all this better than anyoneelse.

    We must do the same in space! If we do not pursue control of space, then someone else will. If we donot exploit space to the fullest advantage across every conceivable mode of war fighting, then someonelse will. If we do not develop a new culture of space professionals- a new form of war fighter- thensomeone else may do so first, with dire consequences awaiting our first engagement with such anadversary. Our success at wielding airpower has come with a realization that we need to do it before-and better than- anybody else. Let us do the same for space.'

    In2006,theUnitedStatesAirForceSpaceCommandHeadquarterswebsitebreviloquentlyadvertisesitsmissiontotheworldonlineinboldbluetype:'To defend the United States of America through thecontrol and exploitation of space.'AndthecurrentUSSpaceCommander-in-ChiefGen.LanceLordhasvoicedhisvisionforUSNearEarthSpacepolicy:'Space superiority is not our birthright, but it is ourdestiny. Space superiority is our day-to-day mission. Space supremacy is our vision for the future.'

    Decelerating Institutional and Private Support for Awareness and Cultural Utilization of

    Space

    Itmaywellbethatitisapan-cultural,almostinnate,humanurgetomaintainamythologyforouter space.Itisequallyarguablethatthemythologicalauraofthe'redplanet'hasraisedinterestandinvestmentforcurrentspaceexplorationgoalsandinnovationinthearrivingtwoorthreedecades.Likthenaturalsciences,culturalproductionisaphysicalresponsetoanenvironment(RenDubos),yet,likemythology,culturalproductionisasharedpsychicresponsetothehumanenvironmentaswell.Anthatincludes,certainlysincetheinventionofthetelescopeandGalileo,outerspace.Subculturefeedsmainstreamculture.Theculturalutilizationofspaceisnodifferent.Whileunfoldingaextendedurbanorhyper-urbanmythologyforspacetravelanddiscovery,itinspiresandexpands

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    50/55

    mainstreamcultureaswellwhenvisionary,meanwhilenourishinghardscienceandtechnologywithdataanddesign.Farmorethanmostothersubculturalactivities,inventingandconstructingspace culturehasimmenselymoreatstake,andindisputablyaswell,intheoffingforhumankind.Whenaestheticallywiseandpertinent,therebyaffectivelyinfluencingpublicawarenessandopinion,opendevelopmentofspaceculturecutsapathandruddersmuchofthecoursebacktotheMoonandontoMars,spaceexplorationandexploitationingeneralafectlifetimestocome.Don'tforgetitwasaculturaldiscoursethatGalileoinitiatedwhichsetoffaculturalchainreaction-JulesVerneandKonstantinTsiolkovskytonameonlytwo-catalyzingthemoderneraofspacescienceandtechnologyculture,Apollo11andtheMarsExpress.

    Spaceartistandactivist,ArthurWoods,considersinhis1993addresstothe44thInternationalAstronauticalCongress,TheExplorationofSpacebyArtistsandWriters,that:"Visualartistsandwriterhavecreatedfictionalimagesandscenariosonthedevelopmentofspace.Suchvisionsaretheprimarywaythatthegeneralpublicisintroducedtoideasaboutspaceexploration.Artistsandwriters,infact,laythefoundationwhichmakesfuturespaceactivitiesunderstandablebythegeneralpublicandthus securesthenecessarypoliticalsupport."Artthatisnotcosmeticmustprecedeitsapplication,appliedartordesign.Assuch,artinscribesdesign'sveryfoundation.Inspiteoftheapparentmaskingthattheseeminglyendlessandexorbitanttechnicalcomplexitybehindaspaceprogrammemayprovide,itilludes.Itisamirage,andartor,moregenerally,culturalproduction,remainsinthekeypublicsupportingroleforfurtheringthespaceexplorationandtravelindustry.Withoutart,Galileowouldhavebeenleftwithabstractmathematicalprinciplestoconvinceanalreadyindoctrinatedpublicthatthey

    werenolongeratthecenteroftheuniverse.PerhapsGalileo'sgreatestpublicsuccesswashisknowledgethatthereisanarttoscience.

    ThelegendaryvideoartistandSatelliteArtpioneer,NamJunePaik,in1988notedininterviewwithmediaartistandanthologistEduardoKactheneedforapeace-instillingroleforartintheglobalpublicperceptionof,andpositionontheactualandpotentialusesoftheEarth'sorbitandsatellitespace:'Since today we have satellites, we want to use them, discover what we, artists, can do with them. Wewant to try something new, in the tradition of Monet and Picasso. These same instruments (satellites)are used in the applied arts, which are essential to humankind because they are useful in everyday lifeBut there is also the military use of satellites. We want to use satellites for pacifist purposes.'Itisnotoutlandishtoimagineorevenforecastthatthegreatestcontributionspaceexplorationanddiscoverymaymakehumankindallinallisinthearts,andnotinscience.

    USAirForceUndersecretaryPeteB.TeetsalreadymadeitclearthatspacecultureisacornerstonefortheUSSpaceCommandandabudgetpriority.TheHon.PeteTeetsunderstandingofspacecultureisthat'If we do not develop a new culture of space professionals - a new form of war fighter - thensomeone else may do so first.'Woulditnotseemplausiblethatwithoutthedemocraticcheck-and-balancethatanappropriateculturalcounterweightfromtheartswouldserveinraisingpublicawarenessforothercoursesforspaceculturetotake,littlewouldstandinthewayoftheelectionbytheUSDefenseDept.tocontinueaspaceculturepolicybentonthepridethattotalmilitarydominatioofspacewouldinstill.Andisitnotequallyplausiblethatsuchapolicymaysparktheinsurgencyofa spacearmsrace?

    FacedwithTeets'gamble,itseemsprudentheretorespondpreemptively,ifthatisstillpossible,andbfirst,notbydevelopingacountercultureofprofessionalspacebelligerents,butinsteadfirstfightingto

    findfundingtosearchforanddevelopameaningfulculturalpanoplyforspaceprofessionals.Itseemstobedemocraticallyprudent,evenprophylactic,fororbitalandEarthlypeaceandstabilitythatart affectivelycontradicttheTeetsiandoctrineforallourouterspaceanditsacculturation.Notbyreactinginprotestandfeedinghismessagetothepressasafirstlineofdefense.Notbyactingcircumstantiallydidacticallyormimeticallybyrestagingspaceprogrammes,suchasmirroringthepanopticsurveillanceofEarthasaprimaryfocus,enablingareadingofculturalproductioninspaceasameremilitary-industrialspin-off.Thefactisthatmanyworksofspacearttodatefallclosetothiscategoryduetoinsufficientandnarrowbandfundingfortheproductionofideasandworkswhichasaresultalltooofteremainaloof,rarelyconnectingtotheaesthetic,conceptualandphilosophicalconcernswhichorbitandareundertheinfluenceofothermajorgenresofactivityinthecontemporaryarts.

    NASA and ESA's Space Culture and Education Expenditures

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    51/55

    NASA'sbudgetreleasedfor2007apparentlydemonstratesanewmoremyopicviewoftheinterdisciplinarynatureandsynergyofartandtechnology.AtNASAthedeclineinculturalfunding continuesexponentially,allthemoreso,whenmeasuredagainstanincreaseingeneralspending.EducationalfundingfellatNASAbetween2005and2007from179to28millionUSdollars.Biologyanphysicalscienceexpendituretookanosediveduringthesameperiodfrom925to145millionUSdollars,whiletotalnewobligationspendingincreasedatNASAto10,364millionUSdollars.In2007from8,371millionUSdollarsin2005.Numberssometimesspeaklouderthanwords.

    FromtheEuropeanSpaceAgencywebsite:'ESA'sbudgetfor2006isanestimated2904million.Europeanpercapitainvestmentinspaceisverylittle.Onaverage,everycitizenofanESAMemberStatepays,intaxesforexpenditureonspace,aboutthesameasthepriceofacinematicket.IntheUnitedStates,investmentincivilianspaceactivitiesisalmostfourtimesasmuch.'InESA'sbudget breakdownbyprogrammethereisnolistingofadiscreeteducationorculturalbudgetallotmentorprogramme.TherearehoweverseveralESA-andpartner-fundededucationalandculturalprogrammessuchastheInternationalSpaceUniversityestablishedin1987inStrasburgFrance,ArtCatalystUKresearchprojectDevelopingaCulturalPolicyfortheInternationalSpaceStationin2006,aswellasESA'sErasmusUserCentre'sArtist-in-ResidenceprogrammeinNoordwijk,theNetherlands,alsoencouragingthedevelopmentofculturalusesfortheInternationalSpaceStation(ISS),withJapanesespaceartistAyakoOnohavingjustfinishedaresidencyinFebruary2006.

    Cultureisamirrorofproduction,themirrorthatthepublicsees.Artisticvisiondrawsperspective,andperspectivenotonlydrawsfactories,itdrawsopinion.Culturalfundingisallthemoreimportantto

    innovationanddiscoveryinadomainofactivityasinvisibleasNearEarthandOuterSpace.Successfuandsafeinterplanetarytravel,NearEarthSpacetourismandotherneo-culturalproductsandpracticesarehard-to-imaginewithoutart'sgenericabilitytocognitivelyextendthehumansensesofsightandsound,eventouch.TheCanadianmediapundit,MarshallMcLuhan,quippedthatartistsaresociety's antennae,makingtheinvisiblevisibleandtheinaudibleaudible.Culturalfundinggoeshand-in-handwithtransducingandtransmittingthepracticesandpurposeswellknowntoinsidersinthespacescienceandtechcommunitybutonlytothepublicatlargethroughculturalrepresentation,thatlikemetaphorandmythologymotivatesunderstanding,rewardingpublicandprivateagencyinvestmentinspaceprogrammesandservices.

    SpacePlace: Art in the Age of Orbitization and The OrbitantsTwo-Stage Plan

    Therearetwostagestothisproject.Thefirstpopulatesacontextforthesecond.StageOnecomprisesamobileinteractiverepositoryencompassingspace-relatedartproducedsinceGalileoGalilei'sDialoguConcerningtheTwoChiefSystemsoftheWorldfirstappeared.Likehischaracters,SpaceisthePlacewillalsobe'orbitants.'Thedatabaseentriesweighinfavorofcontemporaryartandmedia.Nonetheless,architecture,film,literature,music,painting,soundareinabundance.StageOneistitledSpacePlace:ArtintheAgeofOrbitization.

    WithStageOne'saggregateofcontextualspaceartcontentlaunched,instableorbitandaggregatingmorespaceartcontent,fromthewings,StageTwoliftsoff.StageTwoisthelaunchofanartsatellite(orpico-payloadtotheISS)thatinteractsfromorbitwithaseriesofartinstallationsorgroundstationatvariousfar-flungculturalvenuesandmuseumsonEarth.StagetwoistitledTheOrbitants.Itistimeforartaboutorbittoenterorbit.

    Apoeticdiversionordetournottodefineordenoteorbit,buttoigniteinsightenoughtoformanunderstandingoforbitiskeytorecognizingthecurrenttransformationofourenvironmentalparadigmunderwayfromoneofinfluentialglobalizationtoperhapstotalorbitization.

    AfterGalileo'slongnight,thedawningoftheageoforbitizationnotonlycontinuestostimulatedebatebetweenpeacefulandenrichingversusbelligerentanddominatingvisionsinthegreaterspacecommunity,itindicatestheneedforaestheticandphilosophicalresearchwhichspaceartinitsbroadessensecanonlyprovide.Notionsandconnotationsoforbitandorbitizationunderpinthisentiretwo-stageprojectproposal:SpacePlace:ArtintheAgeofOrbitization(StageOne)andTheOrbitants(StagTwo).

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    52/55

    TheenvironmentalparadigmshiftfromglobalizationtoorbitizationisillustratedonarecentcoverofthGermanSpiegelmagazine.Hoveringabitabovepagecenter,itshowsashippingcontainercubeonwhichtheimageoftheEarth'ssurfaceistexture-mapped.Notonlytheglobebutalsoglobalizationhasbecomeamarketablecommoditytobeboughtandsoldoftenthroughcrypticorbitalchannelsinaninvisiblemarketplace,closedtomanyandoverseenbysupra-orbitantbodies,usuallythemilitary.Thistransportablecubicglobeonthecoverhangssuspendedbychainsandacranehook,balancedagainstablackskyaboveahorizonbelowwhichappearsastarkmoonscape,thatuncannilycallstomindplanetEarth,perhapsafutureZombieEarth.TheillustrationisemblazonedwithtypographythatreadsSpiegelSpecial-InternationalEdition-Globalization:ANewWorld.Whatthisillustratesisthat globalizationisnolongerourmostfar-reachingcontext.Itiseffectivelynolongertheborderguardcontainingourworld.Theglobalvillagehasbecomeexactlythat,nowsurroundedbyaterritorythatisorbitalinnature.Itsnucleusnolongerresidingatthesystem'sgeometricalcenterbutratheracollectiveofcitycenters,financialhubs,parliamentforums,evenartcenterstowhichorbitalculturebothgravitatesandattemptsescape.

    Globalization,oncethemostinfluentialenvironmentalprocess,actedinvisiblytoallbutthemosttunedinart,scienceandtechnologyantennae.Environmentsandtheprocessescausingtheirformationarealmostinvariablyinvisiblebynecessity.Unlessunsharporout-of-focustomost,anenvironment,abackgroundbydefinition,cannotworkasabackground.Ironically,themostinfluentialorbitalenvironment,calledNearEarthSpace,isnotnearatall,unlesseyesandearsareupdatedwithaudio-visualtransceivers.Orbitalinfluencesonhumanactivityandtheprocessoforbitizationitselfremainfothepublic-at-largeoutofsight(andoutofmind?)Thisparticularblindnessisexacerbatedbytherecen

    apparitionofglobalizationasanentityresemblingitsdepictionontheSpiegelcover,yetstillassumedtobethatwhichitonceformed,theenvironment,wheninactualityitonlycontainsthishistoryasamemory,asouvenir.Andthisisexactlywhytheorbitalisstealthilyemergingasourall-purpose,all-inclusiveenvironment,andorbitizationtheformativeprocesstowhichweadaptasorbitants,aggregatingandsyndicating.

    Globalizationlikeprecedingparadigmsmarkingthecourseofsomecivilizationshasbeendrawnoutoftheenvironmentitoncecomprised,distilledbyanewgenerationofcontrollingcommercial,cultural,industrial,militaryandsocialtechnologies'thatextendtothosewithreachaccesstoagreatercontextpromisingagreatersphereofinfluence.Thisnewlyformedcontextorenvironmentisofcoursethespaceoforbit,anditsupersedestheglobe.Fromitscommandingandwell-camouflagedposition,orbitizationoverseestheprocessesofurbanization,cyber-urbanizationandglobalizationunderthe

    watchfuleyeofsupra-orbitantcommandingorgans.OrbitizationhasallbutgroundedglobalizationlikeorganizedclustersofLilliputianslandedGulliver.Globalizationundertheinfluenceoforbitizationbecomesagiantfigureinahumungouslandscapethatismostlysky.

    TheorbitizationprocessdubiouslybeganasGalileoempiricallydisprovedgeocentricitywithaspyglassThespyglassanditsprogenyareimmobilizingplanetEarthatthecenterofanewgeocentricmodel-thecenterofaswarmingmilitantmediacosmosoforbitingcontrol,undersupra-orbitantcontrol.Thatsurmountsandsurpasses,relegatesandregulatesevenglobalactivity,allmachineandhumancommunicationandexchangenotonlyonbutalsoaroundtheplanet.Tobesecured,ifdeemedadvantageousornecessary,tochangethepoliticaloreconomiccourseoftheglobe,oralesserregimeasupra-orbitantpower-that-be,mayheed,applyorperfectorbitalthespacesupremacywartacticsthatUSAirForceSpaceCommander-in-ChiefGen.LanceLorddescribedtotheAmericanCongressin2004as:'Simplyput,it'sanAmericanwayoffightingfreedomtoattackaswellasfreedomfrom

    attack."SinceutteringthisnewspacewarstratagemtotheAmericanpeoplewithnexttonocriticalresponseinthemainstreamAmericanpress,bothChinaandRussiahaveuseddiplomaticchannelstocallforinternationalsolidarityagainstthemilitarydominationofEarth'sorbitalspace,withlittle success,andnoresolutionfromtheUN.

    USSpaceCommand'srepeated,provocativespacesupremacypolicyannouncementsopenthemselvesuptotemptation,topartialinterpretationbysomecompetitivenationsandobserversasadoctrineabettingorbitalhitandruntacticswithsupremeimpunityandwithoutatrace,andeverywheretohideIfso,itisimaginablethataspaceracemightbecomemoreaggressivelyAresianthancompetitivelyOlympian.J

    JeanBaudrillardwritesoforbitinhisessayThePataphysicist:'Outside of this gravitational pull which

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    53/55

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    54/55

    TheOrbitantsartsatelliterequiresconsiderablefundingtoacquirethenecessaryservicesincludingtheinvolvementofanaerospacesatellitesystemteamwithexperienceorinterestinlaunchingapico-satellite,preferablybasedinatechnicaluniversitylabwithpriorsuccesswithpico-sats(UniversityofTokyo?)orsponsoredbyaprofessionalsatellitelaunchserviceprovider.

    Apico-satisnotrecoverableandslightlyaddstothecurrentconcernofpotentiallydangerousorbitingdebris.Thisconsiderationalongwiththeapparentlowsuccessrateofstudent-launchedpico-sats(mostlyaround30%),itmaybeadvantageoustoprepareTheOrbitantspico-sattobelaunchedasa

    payloadthatisdeliveredtotheInternationalSpaceStation.OnboardtheISS,therewillbeverylimitetimeavailableforitfromtheISScrew,shouldtheonboardpico-satrequireanyattention.Stillthis scenarioismorepromisingthanadisabledpico-sathurtlingaloneinorbit,andallowsforthepico-satreturntoEarth.

    TheOrbitantspico-satorsimilarpayloadwillbelittlemorethanarelayandaswitchwithcontrolleranpowersupply.Asanorbitingswitch,TheOrbitantsartsatellitebasicallystartsandstops,whilewithinrange,participatorysoundandlightshowstakingplaceingroundstations,mobilesculptural installationsconstructedfortheprojectinvariousmuseumsonEarth.EitherinitsownorbitoraboardtheISS,TheOrbitantsbecomesa90-minuteday,triggeringasunriseasitenterstherangeofoneofitsgroundstationinstallationshousedinoneofseveralmuseumsworldwide.Groundstationinstallatioilluminationbecomesbrightest,audiopeaking,whenTheOrbitantssatelliteisleastdistantfromthetargetgroundstation,finallytriggeringasunsetinthegroundstationinstallationasitmovesoutofrange.Thissunrise-sunsetpatterncontinueswhenTheOrbitantspassesinandoutoftherangeoffurthergroundstationsinmuseumsworldwide.Atotaloffourgroundstationinstallationsareforeseeneachuniqueandsculptural,reflectinginarchitectonicformandimagerytheirimmediatelocaleandsituation.Onegroundstationfunctionsasanomadandisnonameinitsappearance,blendinginasitrovesfromvenuetovenue,intendedtobetheproject'sfestivalparticipatinggroundstation.AllgroundstationsareprimarilyconstructedfromrecycledPChousingsthatactasasortofmodularbrick.SomefacesofsomePChousingbricksarepaintedwithportraits.OtherPChousingshavetextslaser-cutoutontheirsides.Stillothersareadornedwithsiliconcaulkdrawings.AndtheoddPCwillbefastenedtoandsupportaworkingflatscreentodisplaymessagesreceivedfromTheOrbitantsasitpassesoverhead.Thisgroundstationisforeseenfortravelingshowsandtemporaryevents.

    Anothergroundstationresemblesaconceptualbarbequeparty,withkebabskewersculpturesrepresentingorbitalthemesrevolvingslowlyoveragrillthatisheatedsymbolicallybythesoundoftheEarthturningplayingstreamingfromanamateuronlinespaceradiostationovercharcoalgreyspeakebuiltintothebaseofthebarbequegrill,itselfabricollageconstructionofmini-satellitedishesanddiscardedPChousings.ThisgroundstationsituationisforeseenforGermany.

    Athirdgroundstationisnestedunderaflimsynethandmadefromhouseholdsiliconcaulk.IntendedfoChina,theroof-likeinstallationismulti-peakedandporous,allinallasortofvirtualAsianpavilion.Therooftiersarenothingmorethanstretchednetmadeofgreyhouseholdsilicon.Embeddedinthesiliconatsomejunctures,inrandompatches,arequaintandindividualmodeltreespurchasedfromhobbymakersoneBay.Withinsomesiliconlengthscomputerandpowercablesarewiredandhookuptopalm-sizedflatscreensusedformessagereceptionfromTheOrbitantsartsatellitewhenitdepositsnewmessagesitonlyrecentlyitselfwhentheywerebeameduptoitbyguestsinthegroundSpacePlace:stationitlastorbitedover.Afourthgroundstationissunken,partiallybelowground,inspiredbythesubterraneanastronomicalobservatorydesignedandbuiltbyTychoBraheinthelate16thCentury.AllfourofTheOrbitants'sgroundstationshavesomeoftheirPCplatinum-coloredmetalsurfacestransformedintocanvasesadornedwithpaintedandreproducedimagesandiconsassociatedwithStageOne-SpacePlace:ArtintheAgeofOrbitization,inordertoclosetheloopandcompletetheproject.ParticipantsvisitingeachgroundstationaregreetedbyflatscreensscrollingmessagesrelayedbyTheOrbitantsfromparticipantsatthegroundstationitlastpassedover.Inresponsetomessagesreceivedfromapreviousgroundstation,participantsattheactualgroundstationtypemessagesintoa

  • 8/14/2019 SPACEPLACE_Art-in-the-Age-of-Orbitization_ZKM-ZKMax-Imagining Outer Space 2005 - 2008 Germany

    55/55

    repositorythataresubsequentlytransmittedtoTheOrbitantsonceoverhead.Inconcertwiththesunrise-sunsetsoundandlightshowtriggeredbyTheOrbitantsrelativeproximity,theeffectisstunning.AsTheOrbitantsmovesoutofrangeandthesunsetprogramiscomplete,participantsareleinsubduedlighttopondernewmessagesscrollingongroundstationscreens,freshlydepositedbyTheOrbitantsasitorbitstheEarth.

    Credits:Prof.PhilipPocock,TheOrbitantsprojectconcept;withProf.PeterWeibel,CEOandDirector,ZKMCenterforArtandMediaTechnologyKarlsruheGermany2006.