Southwest Power Pool CREDIT PRACTICES minutes  · March 16, 2017 Teleconference Minutes . Agenda Item

  • View
    212

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Text of Southwest Power Pool CREDIT PRACTICES minutes  · March 16, 2017 Teleconference Minutes . Agenda...

  • Southwest Power Pool CREDIT PRACTICES WORKING GROUP

    March 16, 2017 Teleconference

    Minutes

    Agenda Item 1 Call to Order Terri Wendlandt called the meeting to order at 1:32p.m. The following members were in attendance: Terri Wendlandt (Westar); Ronnie Hall (KCPL); Cassandra Strange (OGE); and Malcolm Booker (OMPA). Also in attendance were: Nick Becvar (ACES); Jeff Bieker (Sunflower); Justin Riddell (TEA); Christi Nicolay (Macquarie); Matthew Simon (Basin); Bryan Willnerd (LES); Caleb Head (NTEC); Jamie Johnson (MEAN); Matt Robson (Sesco); Melody Wright (Empire), Robert Schleissinger (Xcel); and Phil McCraw; Jared Barker; and Erin Brown; (SPP).

    Agenda Item 2 Approval of Minutes from February Meeting Terri Wendlandt asked if there were changes to the January meeting minutes (CPWG Minutes 20170216). Malcolm Booker made a motion to accept the minutes and Ronnie Hall seconded. The minutes were unanimously accepted without amendment.

    Agenda Item 3 Unsecured Credit Allowance Update Phil McCraw updated the group concerning the progress through the working groups. It has been approved by MWG, RTWG, and the Finance Committee. Next steps are for it to be put on the consent agenda for the MOPC and Board. We should anticipate a filing sometime in May.

    Agenda Item 4 Credit Policy Review Article 5 Market Exposure (ME) Jared barker presented concerning the calculation of Total Potential Exposure including the components of the market exposure. There was discussion after his presentation. Agenda Item 5 Next Meeting April 20

    Agenda Item 6 Adjournment There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 2:00 p.m.

    Respectfully submitted,

    Phil McCraw, Secretary

  • Relationship-Based Member-Driven Independence Through Diversity

    Evolutionary vs. Revolutionary Reliability & Economics Inseparable

    Southwest Power Pool, Inc. CREDIT PRACTICES WORKING GROUP MEETING

    March 16, 2017 Teleconference

    A G E N D A

    1:30 3:30pm

    1. Call to Order ........................................................................................................................... Mark Holler

    2. Approval of Minutes from February Meeting .......................................................................... Mark Holler

    3. Unsecured Credit Allowance Update.................................................................................... Phil McCraw

    4. Credit Policy Review - Article 5 Market Exposure (ME) ................................................. Jared Barker

    5. Next Meeting April 20 ............................................................................................................. Mark Holler

    6. Adjournment ........................................................................................................................... Mark Holler

  • Southwest Power Pool CREDIT PRACTICES WORKING GROUP

    February 16, 2017 Teleconference

    Minutes

    Agenda Item 1 Call to Order Mark Holler called the meeting to order at 1:32p.m. The following members were in attendance: Mark Holler (Tenaska); Terri Wendlandt (Westar); Ronnie Hall (KCPL); Cassandra Strange (OGE); and Malcolm Booker (OMPA). Also in attendance were: Nick Becvar (ACES); Jeff Bieker (Sunflower); Jill Jones (MEAN); Justin Riddell (TEA); Brian Lawson (GDS Associates); Christi Nicolay (Macquarie); Matthew Simon and Jason Mazgian (Basin); and Bryce Schoenfielder (KCPL) and Scott Smith , Phil McCraw; Jared Barker; Erin Brown; and Patti Kelly (SPP).

    Agenda Item 2 Approval of Minutes from January Meeting Mark Holler asked if there were changes to the January meeting minutes (CPWG Minutes 20160117). Malcolm Booker made a motion to accept the minutes and Cassandra Strange seconded. The minutes were unanimously accepted without amendment.

    Agenda Item 3 Revisit TCR Auction Netting Jared Barker presented examples of current and proposed TCR netting calculations. Mark Holler advised the Group that they need to decide how to proceed with re-filing. After discussion the Group decided by consensus that this issue would be tabled for now but will probably be revisited at another time.

    Agenda Item 4 Unsecured Credit Allowance Limit Scott Smith reviewed the revision request with the Group. A motion was made by Ronnie Hall and seconded by Malcolm Booker to accept the changes as presented in the revision request. The motion passed unanimously with all present voting for the motion. Agenda Item 5 TCR Items For Further Discussion The Group discussed several items that had been previously mentioned. The group will look at reference prices next and will continue to look at related items going forward.

    Agenda Item 6 Next Meeting March 16 Mark Holler advised the group that the next meeting will be March 16, 2017.

    Scott Smith advised that there were a couple of individuals asking about becoming voting members. He also advised the Group that we would be taking self-nominations for voting members if anyone was interested.

    We will also be sending an email to the Group to determine availability and willingness of the Group to have a face to face meeting, perhaps in September.

    Agenda Item 7 Adjournment There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 2:30 p.m.

    Respectfully submitted,

    Phil McCraw, Secretary

  • SPP Credit Policy -Article 5

    Jared Barker

    1

  • Article 5: Calculation of Total Potential Exposure

    Each day, SPP performs the following:

    Determine the Total Potential Exposure (TPE) of each Credit Customer.

    Compare the TPE of each Credit Customer to that Customers TCL.

    Results:

    2

    Transmission Service Potential Exposure (TSPE)

    Market Exposure (ME)

    Total Potential Exposure (TPE)

    Unsecured Credit Allowance

    Financial Security (Secured Credit)

    Total Credit Limit (TCL)

    If Total Potential Exposure (TPE)

    The Total Credit Limit (TCL)> If Secured Exposure The Secured Credit Limit

    the Customer must provide financial security to SPP in the amount of the difference.

    >OR

    Total TCR Credit

    Requirement

  • Article 5 Market Exposure (ME)

    3

    Market Exposure

    (ME)

    IMSC:Invoiced Market

    Settlement Charges

    Market Exposure (ME)

    Potential exposure to non-payment associated with market transactions in the Integrated Marketplace.

    Calculating Credit Exposure: TPE ME TSPE

    CMSC:Calculated

    Market Settlement

    Charges

    MEMERT + MEMEDA:Maximum Estimated

    Market Exposure

    EVE:Estimated

    Virtual Exposure

  • Calculating Credit Exposure ME (contd.)ME Example(contd.):

    4

    STEP 1: Take the greater of:

    (a) The average of last 365 days of daily settlement activity (or if settlement activity occurred for a lesser period, the average settlement activity during such lesser period), OR

    (b) The average of the last 7 days of daily settlement activity (if for a lesser period, if the average settlement activity during such lesser period).

    MEME = Maximum Estimated MarketExposure (based on historical usage)

    ME IMSC CMSC MEMERT MEMEDAEVE

  • Calculating Credit Exposure ME (contd.) ME Example(contd.):

    5

    ME IMSC CMSC MEMERT MEMEDAEVE

    The components used to estimate the average of the last seven (7) days of daily settlement activity can differ by market. Real-Time (RT) = Operating Day + 7 Day-Ahead (DA) = Operating Day + 7;

    when available Operating Day + 4

    Maximum Estimated

    Market Exposure (MEME)

  • Calculating Credit Exposure ME (contd.)ME Example(contd.):

    6

    STEP 2: Greater value from Step 1 multiplied by the number of days remaining in the Potential

    Exposure Window

    ME IMSC CMSC MEMERT MEMEDAEVE

    DA Exposure Days (Number of Days)

    Today Max Date Settled

    Cure Period1

    RT Exposure Days (Number of Days)

    Today Max Date Settled

    Cure Period

  • Calculating Credit Exposure ME (contd.)ME Example(contd.):

    7

    STEP 2: Greater value from Step 1 multiplied by the number of days remaining in the Potential

    Exposure Window

    ME IMSC CMSC MEMERT MEMEDAEVE

    DA Exposure Days = 13 03/16/2017 03/08/2017 41

    Cure Period: Number of calendar days in the next two business days. If this goes over a weekend, then include two days for the weekend.

  • Calculating Credit Exposure ME (contd.)ME Example(contd.):

    8

    ME IMSC CMSC MEMERT MEMEDAEVE

    Calculated for all credit approved Bid / Offers or Virtual Awards for which the Operating Day has not yet been settled.

    Estimated Virtual

    Exposure (EVE)

  • Calculating Credit Exposure ME (contd.) ME Example(contd.):

    The EVE for a bid would be calculated as follows:

    The EVE for a offer would be calculated as follows:

    Hourly EVEs for each bid/offer are calculated separately and then summed to determine the EVE for the bids/offers in a single submission.

    9

    BID Estimated Virtual Exposure

    (EVE)

    Max MW(from Bid)

    Bid Reference Price at Location for Quarter

    OFFER Estimated Virtual Exposure

    (EVE)

    Max MW (from Offer)

    Offer Reference Price at Location for Quarter

    ME IMSC CMSC MEMERT MEMEDAEVE

  • Calculating Credit Exposure ME (contd.)ME Example(contd.):

    Once the DA Market is solved, EVEs are updated by replacing the maximum MWs with the actual MWs awarded.

    The Bid and Offer Reference Prices are unchanged.

    Exposure calculations are re-run as follows:

    10

    DEMAND (EVE) Awarded MW(from Bid)Bid Reference Price a