Upload
trimed-media-group
View
1.811
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Citation preview
The SOURCE Family of Registries1 Year Results from Cohort 1 of the SOURCE Registry
The European Registry of Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation using the
Edwards SAPIEN Valve
Martyn Thomas, MD , Gerhard Schymik, MD, Thomas Walther, MD, Dominique Himbert, MD, Thierry Lefèvre, MD, Hendrik Treede, MD, Holger Eggebrecht, MD, Paolo Rubino, MD, Iassen Michev, MD, Rüdiger Lange, MD and Olaf Wendler, MD on behalf of the SOURCE investigators
Speaker’s name: Dr Martyn Thomas
I have the following potential conflicts of interest to report:
Research contractsConsulting for Edwards LifesciencesEmployment in industryStockholder of a healthcare companyOwner of a healthcare companyOther(s)
I do not have any potential conflict of interest
Potential Conflicts of Interest
2
• Trans-catheter Aortic Valve Implantation (TAVI) is an alternative to open surgery in patients considered to be at high risk for the standard procedure.
• Cohort 1 of The SOURCE Registry describes the outcomes in a consecutive group of patients treated in 32 European centres during the first year of commercialisation of the Edwards SAPIEN Valve from Nov 07 to Jan 31st 09.
3
Background
4
SOURCE COHORT 1
SOURCE COHORT 2
PREVAIL
SOURCE XT EU
SOURCE XT Global
2009 2010 2011
Nov 07
The SOURCE Family of RegistriesTimeline
34 Centres Initially Participating in Commercial Launch1123 patients
Included:32 centres
1038 patients
The SOURCE Registry has 100% procedure data
98% 30 day dataAll consecutively enrolled
Excluded:2 Centres / 85 patients
• Unable to obtain Ethic Cte approval• Unable to secure administrative support• One missing patient due to admin. error
5
99.9% 30 Day DataEuroPCR
2010
Methods: EuroPCR 09
We now present 1 year data that represents systematic
follow-up on 98% of implanted patients.
Site Name Pts Site Name Pts
Karlsruhe/Städisches Klinikum + Herzklinik –
G Schymik, H Schroefel
89 Rouen/CHU – H Eltchaninoff, JP Bessou 31
Leipzig/Herzzentrum - T Walther, G Schuler 87 Madrid/S Carlos – C Macaya, E Rodriguez 31
London/St Thomas’ + King’s -M Thomas, O Wendler 75 Bern/Inselspital- P Wenaweser, T Carrel 31
Paris/Bichat – D Himbert, P Nataf 56 Münster – H Baumgartner, H Reinecke 30
Massy/Jacques Cartier - T Lefèvre, M Romano 51 Jena/Uniklinik – K Hekmat, M Ferrari 26
Hamburg/Uniklink- H Treede, O Franzen 48 Lund/Universitetssjukhuset – G Olivecrona, P Johnsson 23
Essen/Uniklinik – H Eggebrecht, M Thielmann 47 Bruxelles/St Luc – P Astarci, J Kefer 21
Mercogliano/Clinica Montevergine-P Rubino, G Sorrogpago 47 San Sebastian/Gipuzkoa – J Goiti, M Larman 20
Milan/S Raff – I Michev, F Maisano 41 Leuven/Gasthuisberg – C Dubois, P Herijgers 17
Munich/DHZ – R Lange 41 Frankfurt/Uniklinik –V Schächinger, M Doss 15
Athens/Onassis – K Spargias, G Stavridis 36 London/Brompton – M Mullen, N Moat 12
Milan/Monzino – P Bigliogli, M Fusari 35 Innsbruck/Uniklinik – L Mueller, T Bartel 10
Paris/HEGP – D Blanchard, JN Fabiani 34 Lübeck/Uniklinik – ED Kraatz, H Sier 8
Aarhus/Skejby- HR Andersen, KE Klaaborg 34 Cambridge/Papworth – C Densem, P Calvert 8
Zurich/KlinikimPark+Hirslanden- W Amann, F Bernet 34
TOTAL 10386
The SOURCE Registry Enrollment
TF(n=463)
TA (n=575) P-Value
Age (yrs) 81.7 80.7 0.022
Female 55.1% 55.8% NSPulmonary Disease 24.6% 29.9% NS
Renal Dysfunction 25.5% 32.5% 0.016
Logistic EuroSCORE 25.8 29.0 0.007
Peripheral Vascular Disease 10.6% 28.0% <0.001
Carotid Artery Stenosis (>50%) 7.1% 17.2% <0.001
Incidence of CAD 47.5% 55.1% 0.020
Porcelain Aorta 4.5% 11.3% 0.001
Prior CABG 17.5% 27.0% 0.003
Mitral valve disease 15.8% 32.0% <0.001
5/03/2010Data Snapshot7
Baseline Demographicsand Risk Factors
TF (n=463) TA (n=575) Total (n=1038)Death 6.3% 10.8% 8.8%
Stroke 2.6% 2.4% 2.5%
Renal Failure Requiring Dialysis
1.3% 7.0% 4.4%
Permanent Pacemaker
6.0% 7.7% 6.9%
5/03/10Data Snapshot8
Major Complications (≤ 30 Days)
To give Context of Early v Late Events
SOURCE: COHORT 11 Year Survival (All Approaches)
10
All Data as KM CurvesCohort 1: 1 YR (Events: Late)
Freedom From: Stroke, PM, MI
11
SOURCE vs Normal Elderly PopulationCause of Late Stroke (30 Days to 1 Year)
Type of Stroke (Total =19 patients) n/%
SOURCE HEMORRHAGIC (n=4/19) 4/21.1%
Mean (days to adverse event ) 176
Median (days to adverse event ) 167
NORMAL ELDERLY POPULATION* 13%
SOURCE NON-HEMORRHAGIC (n=13/19) 13/68.4%
Mean (days to adverse event ) 163
Median (days to adverse event )117
NORMAL ELDERLY POPULATION* 87%
SOURCE UNKNOWN (n=2) 2/10.5%
Mean (days to adverse event) 158
Median (days to adverse event ) 158
*Lloyd-Jones D, et al. Executive summary: heart disease and stroke statistics--2010 update: a report from the American Heart Association. Circulation. 2010 Feb 23;121(7):948-54. Erratum in: Circulation. 2010 Mar 30;121(12):e259.
12
All Data as KM CurvesCohort 1: 1 YR (Events: Late)
Freedom From: Vascular Complication, Endocarditis, and Re-Operation
13
14
Early Vascular Access Complications Relationship to 1 Year Mortality (NB 22/24F Device)
Approach% Survival in Pts who did not have vascular access
complications
% Survival in Pts who didhave vascular access
complicationsP-Value
TF 83.9% 72.2% 0.0121TA 73.2% 47.4% 0.0188
15
Causes of Death30 Days to 1 Year
ALL
ALL179
Cardiac45 (25.1%)
Heart Failure28 (62.2%)
Myocardial Infarction6 (13.3%)
Endocarditis3 (6.7%)
Other*8 (17.8%)
Non Cardiac88 (49.2%)
Pulmonary***21 (23.9%)
Renal Failure11 (12.5%)
Cancer10 (11.4%)
Stroke9 (10.2%)
Gastrointestinal5 (5.6%)
Other**32 (36.4%)
Unknown46 (25.7%)
Sudden Death18 (39.1%)
Unknown18 (39.1%)
Other10 (21.7%)
Other * = Arrhythmia, cardiac arrestOther** = Sepsis, vascular access related, major bleeding, infection, suicide, and multiple organ failurePulmonary***= Respiratory Failure, Pulmonary Embolism and Pneumonia
16
Influence of EuroSCORE - Cohort 1 –EuroSCORE as predictor of 30 Day Mortality
Variable P-ValueHazard Ratio
95% Lower Confidence
Limit
95% Upper Confidence
LimitNumber of
Observations Used Deaths
Scaled Logistic EuroSCORE (%/10) <.0001 1.2122 1.1145 1.3186 574 167
Renal insufficiency / Failure 0.0005 1.7205 1.2671 2.3362 575 168
EuroSCORE >= 30 0.0008 1.6851 1.2433 2.2840 574 167
Liver disease 0.0046 2.5271 1.3315 4.7963 575 168
Other 0.0051 1.6872 1.1703 2.4323 575 168
None 0.0126 0.5365 0.3289 0.8749 575 168
Carotid artery stenosis (over 50%) 0.0158 0.5549 0.3439 0.8952 575 168
Coronary Artery Disease 0.0212 1.4456 1.0566 1.9779 575 168
EuroSCORE >= 20 0.0227 1.5292 1.0612 2.2036 574 167
Cardiomyopathy 0.0329 2.4306 1.0746 5.4974 575 168
PTCA / stent 0.0467 1.3871 1.0048 1.9148 575 168
17
Univariate Analysis – 1YR Mortality (TA)
Variable P-ValueHazard Ratio
95% Lower Confidence
Limit
95% Upper Confidence
LimitNumber of
Observations Used Deaths
NYHA Class IV 0.0002 2.4224 1.5272 3.8422 453 93
Renal insufficiency / Failure 0.0005 2.0948 1.3842 3.1702 459 94
None 0.0012 0.4004 0.2304 0.6957 459 94
Hyperlipidemia / Hypercholesterolemia 0.0019 0.5065 0.3294 0.7788 459 94
Systemic Hypertension 0.0079 0.5774 0.3850 0.8658 459 94
Mitral valvuloplasty 0.0079 6.6950 1.6454 27.2410 459 94
Smoking 0.0098 1.8595 1.1616 2.9769 459 94
Scaled Logistic EuroSCORE (%/10) 0.0149 1.1764 1.0322 1.3407 458 94
Liver disease 0.0194 2.6851 1.1730 6.1464 459 94
Carotid artery stenosis (over 50%) 0.0390 0.1255 0.0175 0.9008 459 94
18
Univariate Analysis – 1YR Mortality (TF)
Multivariate Analysis – 1YR Mortality (TA)
19
*Logistic EuroSCORE is most significant predictor for 1 year mortality in transapical patients*
Analysis of Maximum Likelihood Estimates
Parameter P-ValueHazardRatio 95% Hazard Ratio Confidence Limits
Scaled Logistic EuroSCORE (%/10) <.0001 1.200 1.098 1.311
Renal insufficiency / Failure 0.0047 1.592 1.154 2.197
Carotid artery stenosis (over 50%) 0.0014 0.454 0.280 0.737
Liver disease 0.0005 3.154 1.646 6.043
Other 0.0345 1.489 1.029 2.153
Multivariate Analysis – 1YR Mortality (TF)
20
*Logisitic EuroSCORE is not a predictor for 1 year mortality in patients treated with the transfemoral approach
Analysis of Maximum Likelihood Estimates
Parameter P-ValueHazardRatio 95% Hazard Ratio Confidence Limits
NYHA Class IV 0.0067 1.948 1.203 3.153
Renal insufficiency / Failure <.0001 2.382 1.553 3.656
Hyperlipidemia / Hypercholesterolemia 0.0293 0.602 0.382 0.950
Systemic Hypertension 0.0317 0.622 0.403 0.959
Smoking 0.0009 2.268 1.399 3.677
Mitral valvuloplasty 0.0040 8.237 1.956 34.690
Coagulopathy 0.0073 5.178 1.558 17.208
So what is the context for these results?
21
22
30 Day Survival 1 Year Survival
SOURCE TA ES>20(Mean 36.1%)
87.4% 69.3%
SOURCE TF ES>20(Mean 33.5%)
93.1% 81%
The data/outcomes of all historical monitored EW THV clinical studies were pooled to provide a comparator to The SOURCE Registry
“Monitored EW THV clinical trials” means 100% source data monitored, Core lab read and CEC adjudicated studies.
23
Historical Comparison –TAVI Studies Included
Study No. of Sites
TA n=
TF n=
Dates of Study Principal Investigators
REVIVE 9 _ 106 Jan 2006 - Dec 2007 H Eltchaninoff
REVIVAL 4 55 40 Dec 2005 - Feb 2008 W O’Neill, M Leon, C Smith
TRAVERCE 3 172 _ Feb 2007 – Apr 2008 T Walther, F Mohr, G Wimmer-Greinecker, E Wollner
PARTNER EU 9 69 61 Apr 2007- Jan 2008 T Lefèvre, G Wimmer-Greinecker
24
25
Is there a relationship between the logistic
EuroSCORE and 1 year outcomes?
26
27
Relationship between EuroSCORE and Survival
28
Relationship between EuroSCORE and Survival
29
TF and TAOutcomes in “lower risk” patients
SOURCE-TA SOURCE-TFI Yr Survival 78.4% 80.9%
Are we learning in terms of the who should and who should
not have TAVI?
A glimpse into COHORT 2 of the SOURCE Registry
30
31
SOURCE COHORT 1
SOURCE COHORT 2
PREVAIL
SOURCE XT EU
SOURCE XT Global
2009 2010 2011
Nov 07
The SOURCE RegistryTimeline
Feb 09 Dec 09
N = 1301 (482 TF/819TA) from 38 centers
ALLCOHORT 1(n=1038)
ALLCOHORT 2(n=1301) P-Value
Age (yrs) 81.2 81.0 NS
Female 576/55.5% 767/59.0% 0.05Pulmonary Disease 286/27.6% 309/23.8% 0.03
Renal Dysfunction 305/29.4% 365/28.1% NS
Logistic EuroSCORE 1035/27.6 1297/25.4 0.006
Peripheral Vascular Disease 210/20.2% 255/19.6% NS
Carotid Artery Stenosis (>50%) 132/12.7% 150/11.5% NS
Incidence of CAD 537/51.7% 694/53.3% NS
Porcelain Aorta 86/8.3% 101/7.8% NS
Prior CABG 236/22.7% 262/20.1% NS
Mitral valve disease 257/24.8% 450/34.6% <0.0001
5/03/2010Data Snapshot32
Baseline Demographics and Risk Factors:All Cohort 1 vs. All Cohort 2
• Outcomes at 1 year for COHORT 1 of The SOURCE Registry show an improvement compared to historical controls.
• Survival for the TF approach is now >80%.
• There has been a marked improvement in the TA outcomes with survival now similar to historical TF results.
• Lower risk TA (<20% euroscore) patients have the same 1 year outcome as TF.
• Univariant and multivariant analysis of the COHORT 1 dataset should allow work to start on the development of a TAVI risk score.
33
Conclusions
• COHORT 1 outcomes provide a benchmark against which future TAVI cohorts may be measured.
• The lower risk profile of COHORT 2 patients may lead to further improvement in 1 year outcomes.
• If the lower profile SAPIEN XT delivery systems result in lower vascular complications this should result in further improvement in 1 year survival. This will be tested in The SOURCE XT Registry.
Conclusions
34