14
"#$%& ’( (%&)%*)$)+, %-. /&). 0-+12&%+)#- !"# %&’())# ’#* +*’, -./0,’1"& 2"#"3’45" 6)&7/3"87 9&):".7 ;.7)4"& <=> <?=?

Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&!'(!(%&)%*)$)+,!%-.!/&).!0-+12&%+)#-!

!"#$%&'())#$'#*$+*',$-./0,'1"&$

2"#"3'45"$6)&7/3"87$9&):".7$

$

;.7)4"&$<=>$<?=?$

Page 2: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! "!

#$%&'!()!)&'*&+*%*,-!&./!0'*/!1.,23'&,*$.!!!

!" #$%&'()*%+,'--./0+

45!6$5,5!7$'!5$%&'!89$,$:$%,&*6!;()<!32.2'&,*$.!6$.,*.=2!,$!7&%%!&./!>$'2!=,*%*,-?56&%2!32.2'&,*.3!7&6*%*,*25!&'2!+2*.3!/2:2%$82/@!=,*%*,*25!&'2!+23*..*.3!,$!6$.5*/2'!,92!27726,5!$7!5$%&'!2.2'3-!:&'*&+*%*,-!&./!=.62',&*.,-!$.!,92!8$A2'!3'*/B!!C9*5!'28$',!5=>>&'*D25!&:&*%&+%2!/&,&!5$='625!&./!8&82'5!/256'*+*.3!277$',5!,$!E=&.,*7-!5$%&'!:&'*&+*%*,-!&./!=.62',&*.,-!*.!$'/2'!,$!92%8!/*'26,!8$A2'!5-5,2>!&.&%-5,5!*.,2'25,2/!*.!6$./=6,*.3!5$%&'!*.,23'&,*$.!&.&%-525B!

C92!>2,9$/!7$'!6&%6=%&,*.3!6%2&'!5F-!5$%&'!'&/*&,*$.!*5!A2%%!=./2'5,$$/!&./!,92!$=,8=,!$7!5$%&'!2.2'3-!32.2'&,$'5!$.!6%2&'!/&-5!*5!,92'27$'2!9*39%-!8'2/*6,&+%2B!!G%$=/5!6'2&,2!&.!&//*,*$.&%!%&-2'!$7!6$>8%2H*,-@!.26255*,&,*.3!6$%%26,*$.!$7!7*2%/!/&,&!,$!69&'&6,2'*D2!,92!:&'*&+*%*,-!&,!8&',*6=%&'!%$6&,*$.5B!#2:2'&%!5$='625!$7!'23*$.&%%-!6$%%26,2/!5$%&'!/&,&!&'2!&:&*%&+%2!3$*.3!+&6F!&5!7&'!&5!"IJKB!L9*%2!,92!8$*.,?5$='62!/&,&!59$A5!6$.5*/2'&+%2!:&'*&+*%*,-@!()!5*,25!58'2&/!$:2'!56&%25!$7!MK!F>!59$A!%*,,%2!,$!.$!6$''2%&,*$.!$.!5=+?9$='%-!,*>256&%25@!*./*6&,*.3!5=+5,&.,*&%!5>$$,9*.3!*.!&33'23&,2!8$A2'!$=,8=,!$.!'23*$.&%!56&%25B!

N$!7=%%?56&%2!5$%&'!*.,23'&,*$.!5,=/*25!9&:2!+22.!=./2',&F2.!*.!,92!N$',9A25,!,$!/&,2B!#=69!5,=/*25!&'2!9$A2:2'!8$55*+%2!A*,9!&:&*%&+%2!/&,&!&./!*,!*5!'2&5$.&+%2!,$!=./2',&F2!5=69!5,=/*25B!0*:2.!'2&5$.&+%2!/*582'5*$.!$7!5$%&'!32.2'&,*$.!5*,25@!,92!%&6F!$7!32.2'&,*$.!&,!.*39,@!&./!,92!'2%&,*:2!62',&*.,-!$7!5$%&'!32.2'&,*$.!%2:2%5!/='*.3!6%2&'!&./!6$>8%2,2%-!6%$=/-!/&-5@!,92!27726,5!$7!5$%&'!:&'*&+*%*,-!>&-!+2!5*3.*7*6&.,%-!%255!,9&.!,9&,!7$'!A*./B!

!!" 1*%/*)%2+34+,35./+6%7%/.()37+89./.&(%/):()&:+

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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"!V27*.*,*$.5!,&F2.!7'$>!V=77*2!&./!Y26F>&.!;"II"<!&./!Z&6$+52.!;MKK[<B!!!

Page 3: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! M!

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

!C)D'/%+EB!!)&'*$=5!,-825!$7!5$%&'!'&/*&,*$.!$.!&!,*%,2/!5='7&62B!!#$='62W!!V=77*2!&./!Y26F>&.@!"II"B!!!!#$%&'!32$>2,'-!&%%$A5!7$'!:2'-!8'26*52!6&%6=%&,*$.5!$7!,92!'2%&,*:2!8$5*,*$.5!$7!,92!2&',9!&./!5=.@!&%%$A*.3!,92!5$%&'!'25$='62!,$!+2!8'2/*6,2/!.2&'%-?82'726,%-!7$'!6%2&'!5F-!6$./*,*$.5B!!1.!$,92'!A$'/5@!,92!:&'*&+*%*,-!$7!5$%&'!2.2'3-!7'$>!8$A2'!8%&.,5!*5!&%>$5,!6$>8%2,2%-!8'2/*6,&+%2!*.!,92!6$='52!$7!6%2&'?5F-!/&-5B!!`$A2:2'@!,92!8'252.62!&./!+29&:*$'!$7!6%$=/5!*.,'$/=625!5*3.*7*6&.,!:&'*&+*%*,-!,9&,!6&.!'25=%,!*.!52:2'2!&./!'&8*/!7%=6,=&,*$.5!*.!5$%&'!*''&/*&.62!&./!,92'27$'2!5$%&'!()!$=,8=,B!!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<!'272'!,$!/2:*&,*$.5!7'$>!6%2&'!5F-!7$'26&5,!&5!,92!S5,$69&5,*6!6$>8$.2.,T!$7!,92!5$%&'!'25$='62!&./!69&'&6,2'*D2!*,!=5*.3!&!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H@!A9*69!*5!,92!'&,*$!$7!&6,=&%!>2&5='2/!3%$+&%!'&/*&,*$.!,$!,92!'&/*&,*$.!2H826,2/!*7!,92!5F-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!M!V258*,2!9&:*.3!6%2&'!5F-!6$./*,*$.5@!,92!8'252.62!$7!&2'$5$%5@!$D$.2@!&./!A&,2'!:&8$'!*.!,92!&,>$5892'2!&7726,!,92!&>$=.,!$7!5$%&'!'&/*&,*$.!'2&69*.3!,92!5='7&62B!!455=>8,*$.5!>=5,!+2!>&/2!,$!&66$=.,!7$'!,9252!27726,5B!!!P!C92!8'$62/='2!*5!/256'*+2/!*.!/2,&*%!+-!V=77*2!&./!Y26F>&.!*.!#$%&'!\.3*.22'*.3!$7!C92'>&%!('$625525@!&5!A2%%!&5!$,92'!5$='625B!!!^!C92!Y*'/!G%2&'!#F-!a$/2%!6&.!+2!/$A.%$&/2/!*.!\H62%!7$'>&,!7'$>!NX\]W!9,,8WRR''2/6B.'2%B3$:R5$%&'R>$/2%5R6%2&'5F-B!

Page 4: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! P!

A2'2!6%2&'B!!C92!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!&%%$A5!7$'!,92!5,$69&5,*6!6$>8$.2.,!$7!,92!'25$='62!,$!+2!528&'&,2/!7'$>!,92!8'2/*6,&+%2!6$>8$.2.,!$7!,92!'25$='62!;U*3='2!M<B!!!Y26&=52!5$%&'!()!8$A2'!$=,8=,!*5!8'$8$',*$.&%!,$!*.5$%&,*$.@!,92!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!6&.!+2!=52/!,$!E=&.,*7-!5$%&'!()!:&'*&+*%*,-!;a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

!C)D'/%+F"!!G'2&,*.3!&!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!7'$>!$+52':2/!&./!2H826,2/!*.5$%&,*$.!$.!&!9*39%-!:&'*&+%2!/&-B!!#$='62W!!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<B!!Y26&=52!5$%&'!()!$=,8=,!:&'*&+*%*,-!*5!&!7=.6,*$.!$7!6%$=/!6$:2'@!/*772'2.625!*.!6%*>&,2!59$=%/!+2!6$.5*/2'2/!A92.!&.&%-D*.3!,92!8$,2.,*&%!*>8&6,5!$7!()!:&'*&+*%*,-!$.!&!+&%&.6*.3!&'2&B!!1.!,92!N$',9A25,@!,92!G&56&/2!a$=.,&*.!X&.32!52':25!&5!&!/*:*/*.3!%*.2!+2,A22.!5*3.*7*6&.,%-!/*772'2.,!6%*>&,2!D$.25B!!4!5&>8%2!$7!6*,*25!*.!b'23$.!&./!L&59*.3,$.!%*5,2/!*.!C&+%2!"!5=3325,5!,9&,!,92!2&5,!5*/2!6*,*25!9&:2!$.!&:2'&32![Jc!>$'2!6%2&'!/&-5!,9&.!6*,*25!$.!,92!A25,!5*/2dB!!C92!7&6,!,9&,!5$%&'!()!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!d!C92!/&,&!*.!,9*5!,&+%2!A&5!$+,&*.2/!7'$>!,92!L25,2'.!X23*$.&%!G%*>&,2!G2.,2'!;LXGG<@!9,,8WRRAAABA'66B/'*B2/=B!!G%2&'!/&-5!&'2!/27*.2/!&5!KBK!e!KBP!&:2'&32!5F-!6$:2'@!8&',%-!6%$=/-!/&-5!&5!KB^?KBQ!&:2'&32!5F-!6$:2'@!&./!6%$=/-!/&-5!&5!KB[?"BK!&:2'&32!5F-!6$:2'B!!

Page 5: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! ^!

$=,8=,!6&.!+2!82'726,%-!8'2/*6,2/!7$'!6%2&'!/&-5!>*39,!5=3325,!,9&,!5$%&'!()!*.,23'&,*$.!$7!2&5,!5*/2!5*,25!A$=%/!9&:2!%255!*>8&6,!&./!'2E=*'2!72A2'!+&%&.6*.3!'252':25!,9&.!5*,25!$.!,92!A25,!5*/2B!!`$A2:2'@!8&',%-!6%$=/-!/&-5!9&:2!,92!3'2&,25,!*>8&6,!$.!5$%&'!:&'*&+*%*,-!&./!,92!6$>8&'*5$.!59$A5!,9&,!2&5,!&./!A25,!5*/2!5*,25!9&:2!5*>*%&'!.=>+2'5!$7!8&',%-!6%$=/-!/&-5!82'!-2&'B!!C9*5!5=3325,5!,9&,!*.,23'&,*$.!'&,25!>*39,!&6,=&%%-!+2!5*>*%&'!7$'!2&5,!&./!A25,!'23*$.5B!!4!/2,&*%2/!&.&%-5*5!$7!5$%&'!:&'*&+*%*,-!2&5,!&./!A25,!$7!,92!6&56&/25!A$=%/!92%8!/2,2'>*.2!A92,92'!/*772'2.,!6%*>&,*6!D$.25!*.!,92!N$',9A25,!A$=%/!'2E=*'2!/*772'2.,!&>$=.,5!$7!+&%&.6*.3!'252':25JB!+

A.?5%+E"++G*%/.D%+85%./H+853'=0H+.7=+I./(50+853'=0+>.0:+J%/+K%./++)7+8)()%:+L%:(+.7=+#.:(+34+(9%+8.:&.=%:"+

West Side Cities Clear Cloudy

Partly Cloudy East Side Cities Clear Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

Astoria, OR 38 239 88 Burns, OR 120 151 94 Eugene, OR 75 209 81 Meacham, OR 94 204 67 Portland, OR 68 222 75 Pendleton, OR 101 173 91 Olympia, WA 52 228 85 Walla Walla, WA 116 162 87 Seattle, WA 58 226 81 Yakima, WA 109 164 92 Average 58 225 82 Average 108 171 86 ! #$='62W!!L25,2'.!X23*$.&%!G%*>&,2!G2.,2'!;LXGG<@!9,,8WRRAAABA'66B/'*B2/=B!!

!!!" >.(.+G*.)5.?)5)(0+.7=+,93/(4.55:+

L*./!*.,23'&,*$.!5,=/*25!&'2!9*39%-!/282./2.,!$.!/2:2%$8*.3!/&,&!7$'!8'$_26,2/!A*./!5*,25@!&./!&.&%$3$=5!5$%&'!32.2'&,*$.!/&,&!*5!.22/2/!,$!6$./=6,!5$%&'!*.,23'&,*$.!5,=/*25B!C9*5!526,*$.!'2:*2A5!&:&*%&+%2!/&,&!5$='625!7$'!=52!*.!5$%&'!*.,23'&,*$.!5,=/*25B!!C92!>$5,!2H,2.5*:2!'23*$.&%!/&,&!5$='62!*5!,92!f.*:2'5*,-!$7!b'23$.O5!#$%&'!X&/*&,*$.!a$.*,$'*.3!]&+$'&,$'-!;#Xa]<@Q!'26$'/*.3!5$%&'!'25$='62!/&,&!&6'$55!,92!N$',9A25,!*.!$'/2'!,$!S8'$:*/2!9*39!E=&%*,-!56*2.,*7*6!/&,&!7$'!5$%&'!2.2'3-!'25$='62!2:&%=&,*$.!&./!%$.3?,2'>!6%*>&,2!5,=/*25T!;fb!#Xa]@!MKKK<B!C92!Y$..2:*%%2!($A2'!4/>*.*5,'&,*$.!;Y(4<!9&5!+22.!&!>&_$'!58$.5$'!$7!,9*5!277$',!5*.62!"IQ[[@IB!!C92!#Xa]!+23&.!,'&6F*.3!5$%&'!'25$='62!/&,&!*.!\=32.2!*.!"IQd!&./!25,&+%*592/!*,5!7*'5,!'23*$.&%!.2,A$'F!*.!"IQQB!!C92!#Xa]!,'&6F2/!5$%&'!'25$='62!/&,&!&,!:&'*$=5!5*,25!&6'$55!,92!N$',9A25,!*.,2'>*,,2.,%-!7'$>!"IQQ?"II^B!!1.!"II^@!&!6$.5$',*=>!*.6%=/*.3!,92!Y(4@!\=32.2!L&,2'!&./!\%26,'*6!Y$&'/!;\L\Y<@!1/&9$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J!C9*5!&.&%-5*5!6$=%/!+2!6$>8%2,2/!=5*.3!5$%&'!/&,&!&:&*%&+%2!7'$>!,92!f.*:2'5*,-!$7!b'23$.!#$%&'!X&/*&,*$.!a$.*,$'*.3!]&+$'&,$'-!;#Xa]<B!Q!f.*:2'5*,-!$7!b'23$.!#$%&'!X&/*&,*$.!a$.*,$'*.3!]&+$'&,$'-W!9,,8WRR5$%&'/&,B=$'23$.B2/=![!C92!Y(4!8'$:*/2/!7=./*.3!7$'!,92!fb!#Xa]!7'$>!"I[K?"I[d!&./!7'$>!"II^?8'252.,B!;9,,8WRR5$%&'/&,B=$'23$.B2/=R#8$.5$'5B9,>%<!I!C92!Y(4!7*'5,!8'$:*/2/!8'$3'&>!*.*,*&,*$.!7=./*.3!,$!,92!fb!#Xa]!*.!"IQ[B!!;9,,8WRR5$%&'/&,B=$'23$.B2/=R#'>%`*5,$'-B9,>%<!

Page 6: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! d!

($A2'@!(&6*7*G$'8@!&./!($',%&./!02.2'&%!\%26,'*6!;(0\<!6$.,'&6,2/!,92!fb!#Xa]!,$!6'2&,2!&!%$.32'?,2'>!&./!>$'2!6$>8'292.5*:2!5$%&'!'&/*&,*$.!/&,&+&52!;fb!#Xa]@!MKKK<B!!G=''2.,%-@!,92!#Xa]!9&5!>$.*,$'*.3!5,&,*$.5!$82'&,*.3!*.!b'23$.@!L&59*.3,$.@!1/&9$@!a$.,&.&@!L-$>*.3@!&./!f,&9!;U*3='2!P<B!!4%%!/&,&!6$%%26,2/!+-!,92!fb!#Xa]!*5!&:&*%&+%2!7$'!/$A.%$&/!$.%*.2!&./!6&.!+2!E=2'*2/!=5*.3!:&'*$=5!52&'69!$8,*$.5B!

!

!C)D'/%+M"!!]$6&,*$.5!$7!8&5,!&./!8'252.,!fb!#Xa]!5$%&'!>$.*,$'*.3!5,&,*$.5B!!!#$='62W!!fb!#Xa]B!!#,&,*$.5!*.!0'22.!X*:2'@!Lg@!&./!a$&+@!fC@!&'2!.$,!'28'252.,2/!92'2B!

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fb!#Xa]!9&5!,*>2!5-.69'$.*D2/!3%$+&%!9$'*D$.,&%!/&,&!7$'!>&.-!$7!*,5!5*,25!&,!&!,*>2!'25$%=,*$.!$7!7*7,22.!>*.=,25!$'!%255B!1.!&//*,*$.@!,92!#Xa]!9&5!7*:2!-2&'5!$7!9$='%-!*.5$%&,*$.!/&,&!/2'*:2/!7'$>!5&,2%%*,2!

Page 7: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! J!

*>&32'-!&,!&!"K!H!"K!F>!'25$%=,*$.!7$'!b'23$.@!L&59*.3,$.@!&./!1/&9$!,9&,!*5!&:&*%&+%2!7$'!8='69&52B!!`*5,$'*6&%!5$%&'!/&,&!6&.!&%5$!+2!*.72''2/!7'$>!>2,2$'$%$3*6&%?5,&,*5,*6&%!>$/2%5!&./!5&,2%%*,2!*>&32'-B!!!NX\]!9&5!8'$/=62/!,A$!9*5,$'*6&%!5$%&'!'&/*&,*$.!/&,&+&525@!A9*69!'&.32!6$%%26,*:2%-!7'$>!"IJK!e!MKKd@!,9&,!25,*>&,2!&:2'&32!9$='%-!5$%&'!*.5$%&,*$.!7$'!>=%,*8%2!5*,25!*.!2&69!5,&,2"KB!!NX\]!9&5!&%5$!8'$/=62/!25,*>&,25!$7!9$='%-!*.5$%&,*$.!:&%=25!7$'!,92!2.,*'2!f.*,2/!#,&,25!&,!&!"K!H!"K!F>!'25$%=,*$.B!!C9252!:&%=25!A2'2!*.72''2/!+-!NX\]!7'$>!5&,2%%*,2!*>&32'-!8'$:*/2/!+-!,92!02$5,&,*$.&'-!b82'&,*$.&%!\.:*'$.>2.,&%!#&,2%%*,2!;0b\#<!""!5-5,2>B!!0b\#!9&5!6$>8*%2/!"P!-2&'5!$7!5&,2%%*,2!*>&32'-!,9&,!6&.!+2!=52/!,$!/2,2'>*.2!9$='%-!*.5$%&,*$.!&,!&!P!H!P!F>!'25$%=,*$.!7$'!,92!2.,*'2!L25,2'.!`2>*5892'2B!!C92!N$',9A25,O5!$A.!PC1\X!0'$=8!=525!&!5*>*%&'!>2,9$/!,$!*.72'!*.5$%&,*$.!7'$>!0b\#!/&,&!7$'!*,5!5$%&'!7$'26&5,*.3!52':*62@!A9*69!*.6%=/25!/&-?&92&/!5$%&'!*''&/*&.62@!8$A2'@!&./!A2&,92'!/&,&B!!4//*,*$.&%%-@!/&*%-!&:2'&32/!9$'*D$.,&%!*.5$%&,*$.!/&,&!7$'!,92!2.,*'2!3%$+2!$.!&!"?/23'22!3'*/!*5!&:&*%&+%2!7'$>!,92!N&,*$.&%!42'$.&=,*65!&./!#8&62!4/>*.*5,'&,*$.!;N4#4<"M!;N4#4@!MKKI<B!!!!1.!&//*,*$.!,$!,9*5!/&,&@!9*39!,2>8$'&%!&./!9*39!58&,*&%!'25$%=,*$.!5$%&'!'25$='62!/&,&!*5!&:&*%&+%2!*.!62',&*.!'23*$.5!$7!,92!f#!&./!&+'$&/B!!a=%,*8%2!5,=/*25!9&:2!=52/!,9*5!/&,&!,$!&.&%-D2!5$%&'!()!:&'*&+*%*,-!&./!,$!/2,2'>*.2!,92!8$,2.,*&%!*>8&6,!$7!%&'32?56&%2!5$%&'!()!/2:2%$8>2.,!$.!3'*/!$82'&,*$.5B!!U$'!2H&>8%2@!5,=/*25!$7!7*:2?>*.=,2!*.5$%&,*$.!/&,&!9&:2!+22.!6$./=6,2/!7$'!5*,25!&6'$55!02'>&.-!;L*2>F2.@!MKK"<!&./!5,=/*25!$7!$.2?>*.=,2!*.5$%&,*$.!/&,&!9&:2!+22.!6$./=6,2/!7$'!,92!#$=,92'.!0'2&,!(%&*.5!$7!,92!f#!;a*%%5!&./!L*52'@!MK"K<!&./!7$'!5*,25!&6'$55!Z&8&.!;a='&,&@!2,!&%B@!MKKI<B!!f,*%*,*25!6&.!%$$F!,$!,9252!5,=/*25!7$'!3=*/&.62!A92.!6'2&,*.3!5$%&'!()!*.,23'&,*$.!8$%*6-B!!4!5=>>&'-!$7!,92!%*,2'&,='2!&:&*%&+%2!$.!,92!,$8*6!*5!8'252.,2/!*.!,92!.2H,!526,*$.B!!!4%,9$=39!5$%&'!()!5-5,2>5!&'2!*.5,&%%2/!$.!2*,92'!&!82'>&.2.,!,*%,!$'!$.!&!,'&6F*.3!5-5,2>@!A9*69!&/_=5,5!>$/=%2!,*%,!,$!+2,,2'!6&8,='2!+2&>!*''&/*&.62@!9$'*D$.,&%!3%$+&%!*''&/*&.62!*5!&!5=*,&+%2!>2&5='2!7$'!&.&%-D*.3!5$%&'!'25$='62!&./!()!$=,8=,!:&'*&+*%*,-!;a*%%5!&./!L*52'@!MK"K<B!!C92!$+52':2/!3%$+&%!9$'*D$.,&%!/&,&!&:&*%&+%2!7'$>!,92!fb!#Xa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a\C#C4C<!>$/2%B!!C92!=8/&,2/!N#XVY!6$.,&*.5!25,*>&,2/!9$='%-!'&/*&,*$.!&:2'&325!7$'!,92!-2&'5!$7!"II"?MKKd!/2'*:2/!7'$>!&!6$>+*.&,*$.!$7!,92!a\C#C4C!>$/2%!&./!5&,2%%*,2!$+52':&,*$.5!;NX\]@!MKKQ<B!!V&,&!6&.!+2!/$A.%$&/2/!7'$>W!9,,8WRR''2/6B.'2%B3$:R5$%&'R$%/h/&,&R.5'/+RB!""!C92!0b\#!5-5,2>!*5!$82'&,2/!+-!,92!f.*,2/!#,&,25!N&,*$.&%!\.:*'$.>2.,&%!#&,2%%*,2@!V&,&@!&./!1.7$'>&,*$.!#2':*62!;N\#V1#<W!!9,,8WRRAAAB3$25B.$&&B3$:R!"M!N4#4!25,*>&,25!&'2!+&52/!$.!3%$+&%!5&,2%%*,2!$+52':&,*$.5!7'$>!Z=%-!"I[P!e!Z=.2!MKKdB!!C92!/&,&!6&.!+2!&662552/!7'$>W!9,,8WRR2$5A2+B%&'6B.&5&B3$:R63*?+*.R552R552B63*B!

Page 8: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! Q!

*./2H!:&'*&+*%*,-!$+52':&,*$.5!6&.!+2!=52/!,$!/2,2'>*.2!,92!6$''2%&,*$.!$7!:&'*&+*%*,-!$.!/*772'2.,!%2:2%5!$7!32$3'&89*6!/*:2'5*,-!&6'$55!,92!N$',9A25,B!!C9*5!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!6&.!&%5$!+2!=52/!,$!/2,2'>*.2!,92!/23'22!$7!8$A2'!$=,8=,!5>$$,9*.3!,9&,!A$=%/!'25=%,!7'$>!()!5-5,2>5!+2*.3!8%&62/!*.!3*:2.!&'2&5!&6'$55!,92!N$',9A25,B!!!!

!C)D'/%+NB!!U$'26&5,2/!&./!$+52':2/!&:2'&32!9$='%-!*''&/*&.62!7$'!G9'*5,>&5!)&%%2-@!bX"P@"^B!!C92!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!62.,2'5!&'$=./!$.2"d@!*./*6&,*.3!.2&'!82'726,!8'2/*6,&+*%*,-!$7!*.5$%&,*$.!$.!&!6%2&'!/&-B!!!!!

!O" ,35./+<%:3'/&%+.7=+IO+O./).?)5)(0+G7.50:):+

X252&'69!,$!/2,2'>*.2!,92!27726,5!$7!:&'*&+%2!5$%&'!*.5$%&,*$.!$.!5$%&'!()!$=,8=,!&./!*,5!8$,2.,*&%!*>8&6,5!$.!3'*/!$82'&,*$.5!+23&.!*.!,92!"I[K5!;45&.$!2,!&%B@!"IIJi!Y$=D3=2./&!&./!X&9>&.@!"IIPi!G9&%>2'5!2,!&%B@!"I[di!G9$A/9='-!&./!X&9>&.@!"I[[i!Z2A2%%!&./!f.'=9@!"IIKi!]22!&./!g&>&-22@!"I["i!(*AF$!2,!&%B@!MKKQi!(*AF$!2,!&%B@!MK"K<B!a$5,!$7!,9252!5,=/*25!&'2!+&52/!$.!56&%*.3!()!/&,&!7'$>!&!5*.3%2!5*,2!$'!5*>8%2!6%$=/!>$/2%5i!*.!32.2'&%@!,9252!5,=/*25!7&*%!,$!&66$=.,!7$'!,92!5>$$,9*.3!27726,!2H826,2/!7'$>!&33'23&,*.3!>=%,*8%2!5*,25!$'!*.,'&?5-5,2>!5>$$,9*.3!$66=''*.3!*.!=,*%*,-?56&%2!5$%&'!32.2'&,*$.!5,&,*$.5!;a*%%5!&./!L*52'@!MK"K<B!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"P!b+52':2/!*''&/*&.62!/&,&!7$'!G9'*5,>&5!)&%%2-@!bX@!A&5!$+,&*.2/!7'$>!,92!f.*:2'5*,-!$7!b'23$.!#$%&'!X25$='62!a$.*,$'*.3!]&+$'&,$'-!;#Xa]<B!!V&,&!8'252.,2/!92'2!*5!7'$>!#28,2>+2'!MQ@!MKKJ!;V&-!$7!g2&'!MQK<B!!('2/*6,2/!*''&/*&.62!A&5!/2'*:2/!7'$>!,92!NX\]!Y*'/!G%2&'!#F-!a$/2%!7$'!,92!6$$'/*.&,25!^PBM^N!""IB^LB!"^!U$%%$A*.3!,92!>2,9$/$%$3-!=52/!+-!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<@!,92!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!*5!$.%-!6&%6=%&,2/!7$'!82'*$/5!A92.!,92!6$5*.2!$7!,92!5$%&'!D2.*,9!&.3%2!2H622/5!KB"dB!b.!,9*5!/&-@!,92!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!A&5!6&%6=%&,2/!7$'!,92!9$='5!$7![&>!e!d8>B!!"d!C92!/2:*&,*$.!7'$>!$.2!&,!,92!,&*%5!$7!,92!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!&'2!%*F2%-!,92!'25=%,!$7!&.!&55=>8,*$.!+-!,92!Y*'/!G%2&'!#F-!a$/2%!'23&'/*.3!&,>$5892'*6!6$./*,*$.5!A9*69!%2/!,$!&!6$.52':&,*:2!25,*>&,2!$7!*''&/*&.62!*.!,92!2&'%-!&./!%&,2!9$='5!$7!,92!/&-B!!!

KBd!KBJ!KBQ!KB[!KBI!"!"B"!"BM!"BP!"B^!"Bd!

K!"KK!MKK!PKK!^KK!dKK!JKK!QKK![KK!IKK!"KKK!

JKK!

QKK!

[KK!

IKK!

"KKK!

""KK!

"MKK!

"PKK!

"^KK!

"dKK!

"JKK!

"QKK!

"[KK!

85%./+,P0+!7=%$+@1?:%/*%=+Q+#$J%&(%=B+

!//.=).7&%+LQ-

F+

R3'/+

I/%=)&(.?)5)(0+34+S3/(92%:(+,35./+<%:3'/&%+37+85%./+>.0:+

b+52':2/!1''&/*&.62!

1''&/*&.62!U$'26&5,!

G%2&'!#F-!1./2H!

Page 9: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! [!

a=%,*8%2!5,=/*25!/2>$.5,'&,2!&!5*3.*7*6&.,!/26'2&52!*.!&33'23&,2!5$%&'!()!$=,8=,!:&'*&+*%*,-!7'$>!5-5,2>5!&,!:&'-*.3!%2:2%5!$7!58&6*.3!;Z2A2%%!&./!X&>&F=>&'@!"I[Qi!j&A&5&F*!2,!&%B@!MKKJi!j2'.!&./!X=552%@!"I[[i!a*%%5!&./!L*52'@!MK"Ki!a='&,&!2,!&%B@!MKKIi!b,&.*!2,!&%B@!"IIQi!L*2>F2.!2,!&%B@!MKK"<B!!a*%%5!5,&,25@!Sb:2'&%%@!,92!6%2&'!6$.6%=5*$.!7'$>!,9*5!+$/-!$7!8'2:*$=5!'252&'69!*5!,9&,!A*,9!k2.$=39O!32$3'&89*6!/*:2'5*,-!,92!5=+?9$='%-!:&'*&+*%*,-!/=2!,$!8&55*.3!6%$=/5!6&.!+2!'2/=62/!,$!,92!8$*.,!,9&,!*,!*5!.23%*3*+%2!'2%&,*:2!,$!,92!>$'2!/2,2'>*.*5,*6!:&'*&+*%*,-!/=2!,$!,92!69&.3*.3!8$5*,*$.!$7!,92!5=.!*.!,92!5F-T!;a*%%5!&./!L*52'@!MK"K@!8B!""<B!!!U$'!2H&>8%2@!*.!&!5,=/-!$7!"KK!()!5-5,2>5!/*582'52/!,9'$=39$=,!02'>&.-!;&88'$H*>&,2%-!JKK!l!QdK!F>M<@!L*2>F2.!2,!&%B!;MKK"<!7$=./!,9&,!,92!&33'23&,2!$=,8=,"J!$7!"KK!5-5,2>5!7%=6,=&,2/!+-!.$!>$'2!,9&.!dc!$.!&!7*:2?>*.=,2!,*>256&%2!A9*%2!&.!*./*:*/=&%!5-5,2>!6$=%/!7%=6,=&,2!+-!>$'2!,9&.!dKc!;U*3='2!d<B!

!

!C)D'/%+dB!!L*2>F2.!2,!&%B!;MKK"<!/2>$.5,'&,2!&!5*3.*7*6&.,!/26'2&52!*.!()!$=,8=,!:&'*&+*%*,-!;(R(!*.5,&%%2/<!7'$>!"KK!32$3'&89*6&%%-!/*582'52/!5*,25!6$>8&'2/!,$!&!5*.3%2!()!5-5,2>B!!C92!8'$+&+*%*,-!$7!8$A2'!7%=6,=&,*$.5!59$A5!,9&,!,92!&33'23&,2!$=,8=,!$7!"KK!5-5,2>5!/$25!.$,!7%=6,=&,2!>$'2!,9&.!dc@!A9*%2!$.2!5-5,2>!>&-!7%=6,=&,2!$:2'!dKc!$.!&!7*:2?>*.=,2!,*>2!56&%2B!!02$3'&89*6!/*:2'5*,-!*5!6'=6*&%!,$!=./2'5,&./*.3!,92!*>8%*6&,*$.5!$7!()!:&'*&+*%*,-!7$'!'23*$.&%!3'*/!$82'&,*$.5B!!!C92!>$5,!'262.,!&./!'$+=5,!5,=/*25!$.!,92!,$8*6@!`$77!&./!(2'2D!;MK"K<@!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<@!&./!a='&,&!2,!&%B!;MKKI<@!>&/2!6$.5*/2'&+%2!8'$3'255!*.!69&'&6,2'*D*.3!,92!5>$$,9*.3!27726,B!!a='&,&!2,!&%B!25,&+%*592/!&!'2%&,*$.59*8!+2,A22.!,92!6$''2%&,*$.!$7!:&'*&+*%*,-!+2,A22.!32$3'&89*6&%%-!/*:2'52!()!8%&.,5!&./!,92!'25=%,*.3!&33'23&,2!:&'*&+*%*,-!$7!,9$52!8%&.,5B!!Y$,9!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!&./!`$77!&./!(2'2D!+=*%/!$.!,9*5!'2%&,*$.59*8!&./!8'252.,!>2,9$/5!7$'!25,*>&,*.3!&33'23&,2!5-5,2>!:&'*&+*%*,-!7'$>!,92!:&'*&+*%*,-!$7!&!5*.3%2!5-5,2>B!!Y$,9!8&82'5!5,&,2!,9&,@!7$'!&!7%22,!$7!*./282./2.,!;*B2B!=.6$''2%&,2/<!()!5-5,2>5!A*,9!5*>*%&'!5*D2!&./!:&'*&+*%*,-!69&'&6,2'*5,*65@!,92!&33'23&,2!:&'*&+*%*,-!$7!5-5,2>5!A*%%!&88'$H*>&,2!

!

1/ N $7!,92!:&'*&+*%*,-!$7!&!5*.3%2!5*,2@!A92'2!N!2E=&%5!,92!.=>+2'!$7!5*,25"QB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"J!L*2>F2.!2,!&%B!;MKK"<!=52!,92!,2'>!S.$'>&%*D2/!8$A2'T!A92.!'272''*.3!,$!8$A2'!$=,8=,B!!N$'>&%*D2/!8$A2'!*5!,92!$+52':2/!()!8$A2'!/*:*/2/!+-!,$,&%!()!6&8&6*,-B!"Q!`$77!&./!(2'2D!;MK"K<!8$*.,!$=,!,9&,!,9*5!'2%&,*$.59*8!*5!,'&/*,*$.&%%-!F.$A.!&5!,92!Y*2.&->2!7$'>=%&B!!!!

Page 10: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! I!

!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!&%5$!=52/!2>8*'*6&%!/&,&@!*.!,92!7$'>!$7!&!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H@!,$!7*./!,92!6$''2%&,*$.!$7!:&'*&+*%*,-!+2,A22.!MP!5*,25!*.!,92!#$=,92'.!0'2&,!(%&*.5!+&52/!$.!32$3'&89*6!/*:2'5*,-!&./!,*>2!56&%2"[!&./!*,5!'2%&,*$.!,$!&33'23&,2!$=,8=,!:&'*&+*%*,-!;U*3='2!J<B!!C92-!7$=./!,9&,!$.2?>*.=,2!&./!7*:2?>*.=,2!/2%,&5"I!9&:2!S.2&'!D2'$!6$''2%&,*$.T!7$'!5*,25!&,!%2&5,!MK!F>!&8&',i!,92'27$'2@!&33'23&,2!8$A2'!:&'*&+*%*,-!$.!,9252!,*>2!56&%25!7$'!5*,25!&,!%2&5,!MK!F>!&8&',!A*%%!5>$$,9!5*.3%2!5*,2!:&'*&+*%*,-!+-!&!7&6,$'!$7!

!

1/ N @!A92'2!N!2E=&%5!,92!.=>+2'!$7!5*,25B!!a='&,&!2,!&%B!;MKKI<!7$=./!,9&,!5*,25!58&62/!$.%-!I!F>!&8&',!9&/!.$!6$''2%&,*$.!$.!&!7*:2?>*.=,2!,*>256&%2B!!!!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!&%5$!7$=./!,9&,!A92.!&%%!MP!5*,25!&'2!&33'23&,2/@!,92!&:2'&32!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!$:2'!&!$.2?>*.=,2!82'*$/!A*%%!$.%-!9&:2!&!8'$+&+*%*,-!$7!KBPc!$7!+2*.3!KB"!%&'32'!$'!5>&%%2'!,9&.!,92!&:2'&32!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!*.!,92!.2H,!$.2!>*.=,2!82'*$/!;U*3='2!Q<B!!!C92!&:2'&32!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!$:2'!&!5*H,-?>*.=,2!82'*$/!9&/!&!KBPc!8'$+&+*%*,-!$7!+2*.3!KBM!%&'32'!$7!5>&%%2'!,9&.!,92!&:2'&32!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!*.!,92!.2H,!5*H,-?>*.=,2!82'*$/B!`2'2!&3&*.!,92!/2%,&5!&'2!+&52/!$.!8$*.,!>2&5='2>2.,5!$7!5$%&'!*''&/*&.62!&./!,92!&>$=.,!$7!:&'*&+*%*,-!&,!2&69!5*,2!*5!3'2&,2'!,9&.!A$=%/!$66='!7'$>!%&'32?56&%2!()!*.5,&%%&,*$.5MKB!!!43&*.@!()!*.5,&%%&,*$.5!&'2!&+%2!,$!&,,&*.!*.,'&?5-5,2>!5>$$,9*.3!+&52/!$.!,92!5*D2!$7!,92!5-5,2>@!A*,9!%&'32'!5-5,2>5!&69*2:*.3!5>$$,9*.3!$.!%$.32'!,*>2!56&%25!;a*%%5!2,!&%B@!MKKI<B!!!!C92'27$'2@!+&5*.3!()!:&'*&+*%*,-!$.!8$*.,!*.5$%&,*$.!$+52':&,*$.5!59$=%/!+2!6$.5*/2'2/!&.!$:2'%-!6$.52':&,*:2!&88'$&69!,$!25,*>&,*.3!()!*.,23'&,*$.!*>8&6,5B!!G$>+*.*.3!32$3'&89*6!/*:2'5*,-!A*,9!82'5*5,2.62!7$'26&5,*.3!$7!,92!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!>*,*3&,25!,92!&88&'2.,!5$%&'!()!:&'*&+*%*,-!,&F2.!7'$>!8$*.,!>2&5='2>2.,5B!!C92!6=>=%&,*:2!8'$+&+*%*,-!/*5,'*+=,*$.5!;U*3='2!Q<!9*39%*39,2/!+-!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<!5=3325,!82'5*5,2.62!7$'26&5,*.3!$7!,92!6%2&'!5F-!*./2H!7$'!5$%&'!()!8'$/=6,*$.!8'$:*/25!>2&.*.37=%!8'2/*6,*:2!&66='&6-B!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"[!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<!=52!/&,&!7'$>!MP!,*>2?5-.69'$.*D2/!*''&/*&.62!52.5$'5!58&62/!+2,A22.!MK?^^KF>!&8&',!,$!>2&5='2!:&'*&+*%*,-!$.!,*>2!56&%25!$7!"@d@"K@!"d@!PK@!JK!&./!"[K!>*.=,25B!!"I!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<!=52!,92!,2'>!/2%,&!,$!'272'!,$!,92!69&.32!*.!8$A2'!$=,8=,!$:2'!&!3*:2.!,*>2!&:2'&3*.3!*.,2':&%!,$!,92!.2H,!&:2'&3*.3!*.,2':&%B!MK!a*%%5!2,!&%B!;MKKI<!'28$',2/!,9&,!*.!&!"PBM!aL!()!8%&.,@!S"?>*.!69&.325!*.!$=,8=,!$7!*.:2',2'5!A*,9*.!,9*5!8%&.,!A2'2!.2&'%-!82'726,%-!6$''2%&,2/!7$'!6%$52!*.:2',2'5@!+=,!*.:2',2'5!7&'!&8&',!A*,9*.!,92!5&>2!8%&.,!59$A!6$''2%&,*$.!6$277*6*2.,5!+2,A22.!5*>=%,&.2$=5!"?>*.!69&.325!*.!$=,8=,!,9&,!/'$8!&5!%$A!&5!KB"T!;8B!J<B!!4%5$@!,92-!5,&,2!,9&,@!Sm7$'!8%&.,5!*.!,92!,2.5!$7!aL!56&%2@!,92!$=,8=,!$7!&.!*.5$%&,*$.!>2,2'!A*%%!59$A!/*5,*.6,%-!>$'2!52:2'2!'&>85!*.!,*>2!56&%25!=8!,$!&+$=,!,2.!>*.=,25!,9&.!A*%%!+2!$+52':2/!*.!,92!$=,8=,!$7!,92!()!8%&.,T!;a*%%5!2,!&%B@!MKKI@!8B![<B!!!

Page 11: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! "K!

!C)D'/%+JB!!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<!6$''2%&,*$.!$7!/2%,&5!;*B2B!:&'*&+*%*,-<!7$'!:&'-*.3!/*5,&.625!&./!,*>2!56&%25B!

!C)D'/%+QB!!a*%%5!&./!L*52'!;MK"K<!6=>=%&,*:2!8'$+&+*%*,-!/*5,'*+=,*$.!$7!$.2!>*.=,2@!7*:2!>*.=,2@!&./!5*H,-!>*.=,2!/2%,&5!7$'!*./*:*/=&%!5*,25@!7*:2!6%$52!5*,25!&33'23&,2/@!&./!&%%!MP!5*,25!&33'23&,2/B!!!!

Page 12: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! ""!

#&,2%%*,2!*>&32'-!>&-!&%5$!8'$:2!,$!+2!&!:*&+%2!>2&.5!$7!8'2/*6,*.3!,92!*>8&6,5!$7!&88'$&69*.3!6%$=/5!$.!59$',!,2'>!()!$=,8=,!;a*%%5!2,!&%B@!MKKI<B!!4!>2,9$/!/2:2%$82/!+-!`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

O" 837&5':)37:+

#$%&'!'25$='62!6&.!+2!8'2/*6,2/!&66='&,2%-!A*,9!2H*5,*.3!&%3$'*,9>5!7$'!&.-!%$6&,*$.!&./!,*>2!/='*.3!6%2&'!5F-!6$./*,*$.5@!&%%$A*.3!7$'!.2&'?82'726,!7$'26&5,*.3!$7!5$%&'!()!$=,8=,B!!G%$=/!6$:2'!6&=525!:&'*&+*%*,-!*.!5$%&'!()!5-5,2>5@!&./!8$A2'!$=,8=,!&,!&!5*.3%2!5*,2!6&.!7%=6,=&,2!$.!,92!$'/2'!$7!dK?JKc!$:2'!_=5,!>*.=,25!$'!2:2.!526$./5B!!4:&*%&+%2!%*,2'&,='2!*./*6&,25!,9&,!&33'23&,2!5$%&'!()!:&'*&+*%*,-!*5!5*3.*7*6&.,%-!'2/=62/!A*,9!32$3'&89*6!/*582'5*$.!$7!5$%&'!()!5-5,2>5B!!C92!/23'22!$7!8$A2'!5>$$,9*.3!$7!&33'23&,2/!5*,25!/282./5!$.!,92!6$''2%&,*$.!$7!,92!:&'*&+*%*,-!+2,A22.!5*,25B!!('2:*$=5!&.&%-525!9&:2!/2>$.5,'&,2/!,9&,!$.!7*:2?>*.=,2!,*>256&%25@!5*,25!*.!,92!f#!#$=,92'.!0'2&,!(%&*.5!9&:2!.$!6$''2%&,*$.!$7!:&'*&+*%*,-!&,!/*5,&.625!$7!MK!F>!$'!>$'2@!&./!5*,25!*.!Z&8&.!59$A2/!.$!6$''2%&,*$.!$:2'!/*5,&.625!$7!_=5,!I!F>B!!1.!=.6$''2%&,2/!5*,25@!,92!8$A2'!$=,8=,!$7!,92!&33'23&,2/!5-5,2>!A*%%!+2!5>$$,92/!,$!&!7&6,$'!$7! $7!,92!:&'*&+*%*,-!&,!&!5*.3%2!5*,2@!A92'2!N!2E=&%5!,92!.=>+2'!$7!5*,25B!!4!5=77*6*2.,!'26$'/!$7!5$%&'!/&,&!2H*5,5!,$!6$./=6,!&!>2&.*.37=%!N$',9A25,!5$%&'!*.,23'&,*$.!&.&%-5*5B!!C92!Y(4!7=./2/!f.*:2'5*,-!$7!b'23$.!#$%&'!X25$='62!a$.*,$'*.3!]&+$'&,$'-!;#Xa]<!9&5!+22.!6$%%26,*.3!5=+?9$='%-!5$%&'!'25$='62!/&,&!7$'!,92!N$',9A25,!5*.62!"IQQB!!4!,9$'$=39!&.&%-5*5!$7!,9*5!/&,&!A$=%/!&%%$A!7$'!,92!6$''2%&,*$.!$7!:&'*&+*%*,-!+2,A22.!5$%&'!'25$='625!&,!:&'-*.3!/*5,&.625!,$!+2!*/2.,*7*2/!7$'!,92!N$',9A25,B!!C9*5!*.7$'>&,*$.!6$=%/!+2!=52/!,$!E=&.,*7-!,92!&>$=.,!$7!:&'*&+*%*,-!2H826,2/!7'$>!&.!&33'23&,2/!52,!$7!32$3'&89*6&%%-!/*582'52/!()!5-5,2>5!*.!$'/2'!,$!+2,,2'!=./2'5,&./!,92!&>$=.,!$7!+&%&.6*.3!'252':25!'2E=*'2/!,$!*.,23'&,2!=,*%*,-?56&%2!()B!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!M"!a$'2!/2,&*%!$.!,92!'252&'69!8'$_26,!6&.!+2!7$=./!&,W!9,,85WRR59&'2B5&./*&B3$:R.2A5R'25$='625R.2A5h'2%2&525R8'2/*6,?5$%&'?8:?$=,8=,R!

!

1/ N

Page 13: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! "M!

<%4%/%7&%:+

!45&.$@!`B@!g&_*>&@!jB@!j&-&@!gB@!"IIJB!1.7%=2.62!$7!89$,$:$%,&*6!8$A2'!32.2'&,*$.!$.!

'2E=*'2/!6&8&6*,-!7$'!%$&/!7'2E=2.6-!6$.,'$%B!1\\\!C'&.5&6,*$.!$.!\.2'3-!G$.:2'5*$.!""!;"<@!"[[?"IPB!

!Y$=D3=2./&@!aB@!X&9>&.@!#B@!"IIPB!)&%=2!&.&%-5*5!$7!*.,2'>*,,2.,!32.2'&,*$.!5$='625!

7'$>!,92!5-5,2>!$82'&,*$.5!82'5826,*:2B!1\\\!C'&.5&6,*$.!$.!\.2'3-!G$.:2'5*$.![!;P<@!^[^?^IKB!

!G9&%>2'5@!#B@!`*,,@!aB@!f./2'9*%%@!ZB@!4./2'5$.@!(B@!)$3,@!(B@!1.32'5$%%@!XB@!"I[dB!C92!

27726,!$7!89$,$:$%,&*6!8$A2'!32.2'&,*$.!$.!=,*%*,-!$82'&,*$.B!1\\\!C'&.5&6,*$.5!$.!($A2'!488&'&,=5!&./!#-5,2>5!(4#?"K^!;P<@!dM^?dPKB!

!G9$A/9='-@!YB@!X&9>&.@!#B@!"I[[B!15!62.,'&%!5,&,*$.!89$,$:$%,&*6!8$A2'!

/*58&,69&+%2n!1\\\!C'&.5&6,*$.!$.!\.2'3-!G$.:2'5*$.!P!;^<@!Q^Q?Qd^B!!V=77*2@!Z$9.!&./!Y26F>&.@!L*%%*&>B!!#$%&'!\.3*.22'*.3!$7!C92'>&%!('$625525B!!!L*%2-?

1.,2'56*2.62B!!"II"B!!!!`$77@!CB!\B@!(2'2D@!XB@!b6,B!MK"KB!o=&.,*7-*.3!()!8$A2'!$=,8=,!:&'*&+*%*,-B!#$%&'!

\.2'3-![^!;"K<@!"Q[M?"QIPB!!Z&6$+52.@!4'.2B!!MKK[B!!C92!#$%&'!\.2'3-!X25$='62!&./!&.!1.,'$/=6,*$.!,$!#$%&'!

02$>2,'-B!!`=>+$%/,!#,&,2!f.*:2'5*,-!]26,='2@!U&%%!MKK[B!!Z2A2%%@!LB@!X&>&F=>&'@!XB@!"I[QB!C92!2h26,5!$7!>$:*.3!6%$=/5!$.!2%26,'*6!=,*%*,*25!

A*,9!/*582'52/!89$,$:$%,&*6!32.2'&,*$.B!1\\\!C'&.5&6,*$.5!$.!\.2'3-!G$.:2'5*$.!\G?M!;^<@dQK?dQJB!

!Z2A2%%@!LB@!f.'=9@!CB@!"IIKB!]*>*,5!$.!6%$=/?*./=62/!7%=6,=&,*$.!*.!89$,$:$%,&*6!

32.2'&,*$.B!!1\\\!C'&.5&6,*$.!$.!\.2'3-!G$.:2'5*$.!d!;"<@![?"^B!!j&A&5&F*@!NB@!b$D2F*@!CB@!b,&.*@!jB@!j='$F&A&@!jB@!N$:B!MKKJB!4.!2:&%=&,*$.!>2,9$/!$7!

,92!7%=6,=&,*$.!69&'&6,2'*5,*65!$7!89$,$:$%,&*6!5-5,2>5!+-!=5*.3!7'2E=2.6-!&.&%-5*5B!#$%&'!\.2'3-!a&,2'*&%5!&./!#$%&'!G2%%5!IK!;"[?"I<@!PPdJ?PPJPB!

!j2'.@!\B!ZB@!X=552%%@!aB@!"I[[B!#8&,*&%!&./!,2>8$'&%!*''&/*&.62!:&'*&,*$.5!$:2'!%&'32!

&''&-!7*2%/5B!1.W!(9$,$:$%,&*6!#826*&%*5,5!G$.72'2.62@!"I[[B@!G$.72'2.62!X26$'/!$7!,92!CA2.,*2,9!1\\\B!88B!"K^P?"KdK!:$%BMB!

!]22@!#B@!g&>&-22@!pB@!"I["B!]$&/?U$%%$A*.3!&./!#8*..*.3?X252':2!82.&%,*25!7$'!

*.,2'>*,,2.,!32.2'&,*$.B!1\\\!C'&.5&6,*$.5!$.!($A2'!488&'&,=5!&./!#-5,2>5!(4#?"KK!;P<@!"MKP?"M""B!

Page 14: Solar PV Variability and Grid Integration Ken Dragoon and Adam

! "P!

!a*%%5@!4B@!4%5,'$>@!aB@!Y'$A2'@!aB@!\%%*5@!4B@!02$'32@!XB@!`$h@!CB@!j'$8$5F*@!YB@!

]2.$H@!GB@!a*%%2'@!NB@!#,2*.@!ZB@!L&.@!gB@!V26B!MKKI&B!f./2'5,&./*.3!:&'*&+*%*,-!&./!=.62',&*.,-!$7!89$,$:$%,&*65!7$'!*.,23'&,*$.!A*,9!,92!2%26,'*6!8$A2'!5-5?!

! ,2>B!C269B!X28B!]YN]?M[dd\@!]&A'2.62!Y2'F2%2-!N&,*$.&%!]&+$'&,$'-@!Y2'F2%2-@!G4B!!9,,8WRR22,/B%+%B3$:R\4R2>8R'28$',5R%+.%?M[dd2B8/7B!

!a*%%5@!!4./'2A!&./!L*52'@!X-&.B!!MK"KB!!]&A'2.62!Y2'F2%2-!N&,*$.&%!]&+$'&,$'-!

;]YN]<B!!!"#$%&'(%)*+,)-,.%/01230',40)53'#6%&,7%803+%(9,-)3,:6)3(1;03",<'3%'=%$%(9,)-,:)$'3,>)?03B!!]YN]?P[[^\B!!!#28,2>+2'@!MK"KB!!!

!a='&,&@!4B@!g&>&3=69*@!`B@!b,&.*@!jB@!MKKIB!4!>2,9$/!$7!25,*>&,*.3!,92!$=,8=,!

7%=6,=&,*$.!$7!>&.-!89$,$:$%,&*6!8$A2'!32.2'&,*$.!5-5,2>5!/*582'52/!*.!&!A*/2!&'2&B!\%26,'*6&%!\.3*.22'*.3!*.!Z&8&.!"JJ!;^<@!Iq"IB!

!N&,*$.&%!X2.2A&+%2!\.2'3-!]&+$'&,$'-!;NX\]<B!!MKKQB!!N&,*$.&%!#$%&'!X&/*&,*$.!

V&,&+&52!"II"?MKKd!f8/&,2W!f52'O5!a&.=&%B!!C269.*6&%!X28$',!NX\]RC(?d["?^"PJ^B!!48'*%@!MKKQB!

!N&,*$.&%!42'$.&=,*65!&./!#8&62!4/>*.*5,'&,*$.!;N4#4<@!MKKIB!!#='7&62!>2,2$'$%$3-!

&./!#$%&'!\.2'3-!;##\<!X2%2&52!JBK!a2,9$/$%$3-B!!)2'5*$.!MB^B!Z&.=&'-!PK@!MKKIB!9,,8WRR2$5A2+B%&'6B.&5&B3$:R552R/$6=>2.,5R##\Ja2,9$/$%$3-B8/7B!

!b,&.*@!jB@!a*.$A&@!ZB@!j='$F&A&@!jB@!b6,B!"IIQB!#,=/-!$.!&'2&%!5$%&'!*''&/*&.62!7$'!

&.&%-D*.3!&'2&%%-?,$,&%*D2/!()!5-5,2>5B!#$%&'!\.2'3-!a&,2'*&%5!&./!#$%&'!G2%%5!^Q!;"?^<@!M["?M[[B!

!(*AF$@!XB!ZB@!Y&*@!lB@!G%&'F@!jB@!Z$'/&.@!0B!4B@!a*%%2'@!NB!LB@!Z=%B!MKKQB!1.,2'>*,,2.6-!

4.&%-5*5!('$_26,W!4882./*H!YW!1>8&6,!$7!1.,2'>*,,2.,!02.2'&,*$.!$.!b82'&,*$.!$7!G&%*7$'.*&!($A2'!0'*/B!G&%*7$'.*&!\.2'3-!G$>>*55*$.@!(1\X!X252&'69!V2:2%$8>2.,!r!V2>$.5,'&,*$.!('$3'&>B!!

!(*AF$@!XB@!G%&'F@!jB@!U'22>&.@!]B@!Z$'/&.@!0B@!a*%%2'@!NB@!U2+B!MK"KB!L25,2'.!A*./!&./!

5$%&'!*.,23'&,*$.!5,=/-B!C269B!'28B@!N&,*$.&%!X2.2A&+%2!\.2'3-!]&+$'&,$'-@!0$%/2.@!Gb@!9,,8WRRA*./B.'2%B3$:R8=+%*6RLL1#RB!

!f.*:2'5*,-!$7!b'23$.!#$%&'!X25$='62!a$.*,$'*.3!]&+$'&,$'-!;#Xa]<B!!MKKKB!!S`*5,$'-!

$7!,92!fb!#$%&'!X&/*&,*$.!a$.*,$'*.3!]&+$'&,$'-BT!!V262>+2'@!MKKKB!!X2,'*2:2/!7'$>W!9,,8WRR5$%&'/&,B=$'23$.B2/=R#'>%`*5,$'-B9,>%B!!#28,2>+2'!"^@!MK"KB!

!L*2>F2.@!\B@!Y2-2'@!`B!0B@!`2-/2.'2*69@!LB@!j*272'@!jB@!MKK"B!($A2'!69&'&6,2'*5,*65!$7!

()!2.52>+%25W!2H82'*2.625!7'$>!,92!6$>+*.2/!8$A2'!8'$/=6,*$.!$7!"KK!3'*/!6$..26,2/!()!5-5,2>5!/*5,'*+=,2/!$:2'!,92!&'2&!$7!02'>&.-B!#$%&'!\.2'3-!QK!;J<@!d"P?d"[B!