45
1 1 Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Horbatt CoChair of SOA’s IES Working Group

Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

1 1 

Society Of Actuaries 

International Experience Study (IES) 

April 19, 2007 Mexico City 

William Horbatt Co­Chair of SOA’s IES Working Group

Page 2: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

2 2 

AGENDA 

SOA IES Overview 

“ Beware Greeks Bearing Gifts ” 

SOA Experience Study “ Tool”

Page 3: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

3 3 

Origins Of the SOA’s International Experience Study

Page 4: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

4 4 

HISTORY 

2002 –  “Brainstorming” 

2003 –  International Survey (Phase I) 

2004 –  International Survey (Phase II) 

2005  –  Country Initiative and IES “Tool” (Phase III) 

2006 –  Expanding Reach

Page 5: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

5 5 

PUBLISHED RESULTS 

•  Publication of Results (updated as data becomes available) 

– http://soa.org/professional­ interests/international/intl­international­ experience­study.aspx/

Page 6: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

6 6 

LOCAL COUNTRY INITITATIVE 

•  Expand to include local companies 

•  “Empower” local country actuaries 

•  SOA Confidentiality & Technical Support

Page 7: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

7 7 

Local Country Initiative 

•  Local Industry Meetings 

–  Rio de Janiero – September 2004 –  Warsaw – October 2004 –  Guatemala – August 2005 

•  SOA International Section Sponsorship 

–  Caribbean Actuarial Association ­ 2006

Page 8: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

8 8 

Local Country Initiative – Why Participate? 

Actuarial Incentives ­ Improved Product Pricing 

–  Mortality –  Persistency –  Non commission acquisition costs (Agents) –  Financial assumptions

Page 9: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

9 9 

Local Country Initiative – Why Participate? 

Accounting Incentives 

•  International Accounting Standards (IFRS & EEV) –  Loss Recognition Testing –  Embedded Value Assumptions 

•  US GAAP –  SFAS 60 Era Assumptions –  SFAS 97 / 120 Dynamic Assumptions –  Loss Recognition Testing

Page 10: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

10 10 

Local Country Initiative – Why Participate? 

Management Incentives 

•  ROI –  Agent Training Allowances 

•  Competitive  Benchmarking –  Expected values –  Deviations within “normal” range 

•  Strategic Planning –  New market entrance –  M&A pre­due diligence

Page 11: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

11 11 

Local Country Initiative – Why Participate? 

•  Regulatory Incentives 

–  Resource for updating valuation tables 

–  Resource for understanding variability between companies and over time (solvency management)

Page 12: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

12 12 

Local Company Initiative – Experience Study “ Tool”  

An Incentive to Participate 

•  Microsoft Access / Excel Program 

•  Joint SOA / Company Sponsorship –  ING, MetLife, New York Life, Prudential

Page 13: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

13 13 

Experience Study “ Tool”  

•  Technical Advantages –  Consistent exposure formulas –  Uniform Excel output 

•  Practical Advantages –  Efficiency – actuaries focus on data and analysis –  “Built in” Data validation tools

Page 14: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

14 14 

Results International Experience Study

Page 15: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

15 15 

Contributing Companies (parent only) 

•  AEGON •  Aspecta •  AIG / ALICO •  Bradesco •  Brazil Previdenza •  Guardian Life •  Generali •  G&T 

•  ICATU Hartford •  ING •  MetLife •  NY Life •  Occidente •  Pru (US) •  Winterthur •  Zurich

Page 16: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

16 16 

Work in Process – Company Progress 

AR  BR  Ca  CL  GT  IT  MX  PL  KR  TW Country 

Contributing Companies 

Missing Summary Data Unpublished Detail Published Detail

Page 17: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

17 17 

In Depth Country Studies 

ARGENTINA

Page 18: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

18 18 

In Depth Country Studies Argentina 

•  Peso Devaluation 

Study Policy Counts Only Studied 

–  Mortality –  Persistency –  Agent Retention

Page 19: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

19 19 

In Depth Country Studies Argentina Mortality Exposure 

0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 70,000 80,000 90,000 

Policies 

0  20  25  30  35  40  45  50  55  60 

Age 

Policies Exposed 

Male Female

Page 20: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

20 20 

In Depth Country Studies Argentina Mortality 

A/T Mortality (Ultimate2001 VBT) 

0.00% 20.00% 40.00% 60.00% 80.00% 100.00% 120.00% 140.00% 160.00% 

0  20  25  30  35  40  45  50  55  60  65  70 

Attained Age 

A/T  Male 

Female

Page 21: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

21 21 

In Depth Country Studies Argentina Mortality 

A/T Mortality (Select 2001 VBT) 

0.00% 50.00% 100.00% 150.00% 200.00% 250.00% 300.00% 350.00% 400.00% 

0  20  25  30  35  40  45  50  55  60  65  70 

Issue Age 

A/T  Male 

Female

Page 22: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

22 22 

In Depth Country Studies Argentina Persistency 

Policy Persistency 

0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% 

1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10 

Policy Year 

Policy Lapse Rate 

Lapse Rate

Page 23: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

23 23 

In Depth Country Studies Argentina Agent Retention 

0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 

Attri tion Rate 

1  2  3  4  5 

Employment Year 

Agent Attrition 

Attrition Rate

Page 24: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

24 24 

In Depth Country Studies 

POLAND

Page 25: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

25 25 

In Depth Country Studies Poland 

•  Studied – Mortality (policy                    insurance) – Persistency (policy) 

•  Lines of business – Studied – individual risk/savings – Plan to study – 

•  individual risk separate from savings •  Group life

Page 26: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

26 26 

In Depth Country Studies Poland Mortality Exposure 

20,000 

40,000 

60,000 

80,000 

100,000 

Policies 

0  20 25  30 35 40  45 50  55 60  65 70  75 80 

Age 

Mortality Exposure 

Male Female

Page 27: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

27 27 

In Depth Country Studies Poland Mortality

A/T Mortality (Ultimate 2001 VBT) 

0.00% 

20.00% 

40.00% 

60.00% 

80.00% 

100.00% 

120.00% 

0  20  25  30  35  40  45  50  55  60  65  70  75  80 

Attained Age 

A/T  Male 

Female

Page 28: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

28 28 

In Depth Country Studies Poland Mortality with Selection 

A/T Mortality (Select 2001 VBT) 

0.00% 

50.00% 

100.00% 

150.00% 

200.00% 

250.00% 

300.00% 

0  20  25  30  35  40  45  50  55  60  65  70  75  80 

Issue Age 

A/T  Male 

Female

Page 29: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

29 29 

In Depth Country Studies Poland Persistency 

Policy Lapse Rates 

0.0% 

5.0% 

10.0% 

15.0% 

20.0% 

25.0% 

30.0% 

1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10 

Policy Year 

Lapse Rates

Page 30: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

30 30 

IES Microsoft Access / Excel “ Tool”  

DEMONSTRATION

Page 31: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

31 31 

Main Menu

Page 32: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

32 32 

Selecting Data File to Input

Page 33: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

33 33 

Mapping Data Fields

Page 34: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

34 34 

Selecting Data Field Definitions

Page 35: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

35 35 

Error Messages

Page 36: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

36 36 

Mapping Field Codes

Page 37: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

37 37 

Data Validation

Page 38: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

38 38 

Mortality Report Request

Page 39: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

39 39 

Mortality Report (Excel)

Page 40: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

40 40 

Input Data Matrices

Page 41: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

41 41 

Next Steps International Experience Study

Page 42: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

42 42 

Next Steps Geographical Expansion 

Current Argentina Brazil Caribbean Chile  * Guatemala Mexico * Poland So. Korea * Taiwan * 

Future? Bolivia China Hong Kong Hungary India Indonesia Peru Philippines Venezuela

Page 43: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

43 43 

Next Steps Scope Expansion 

Current  Future? 

Mortality  Expenses Persistency Agent Retention Agent Productivity 

Key Financial Assumptions

Page 44: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

44 44 

Next Steps 

•  What it takes in your country? 

1.  At least 3 interested companies 2.  Your management’s support 3.  Microsoft Access skills 4.  Curiosity!

Page 45: Society Of Actuaries...Society Of Actuaries International Experience Study (IES) April 19, 2007 Mexico City William Ho rbatt Co Ch air of SOA’s IES Working Group 2 2 AGENDA SOA IES

45 45 

Next Steps ­ Contacts 

•  Ronora Stryker, Research Actuary, SOA –  [email protected] 

•  Bill Horbatt, Chair IESWG –  [email protected]