49
7/27/2016 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference Rachel Kittenbrink, Ph.D., B.C.B.A Why Social Skills? Autism Spectrum Disorder as in DMS-V (American Psychological Association, 2013) Persistent deficits in social communication and social interaction as evidenced by… – Deficits in social/emotional reciprocity (eye contact, back & forth conversation, emotions, failure to initiate or respond to social situations) Deficits in developing, maintaining, and understanding relationships

Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

1

Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network

Social Skills

Research Validated Interventions

8/3/16

National Autism Conference

Rachel Kittenbrink, Ph.D., B.C.B.A

Why Social Skills?

• Autism Spectrum Disorder as in DMS-V

(American Psychological Association, 2013)

• Persistent deficits in social communication and

social interaction as evidenced by…

– Deficits in social/emotional reciprocity (eye

contact, back & forth conversation, emotions,

failure to initiate or respond to social situations)

– Deficits in developing, maintaining, and

understanding relationships

Page 2: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

2

Problems with Teaching Social Skills

• Frequent assumption that children have pre-

requisite skills to participate in instruction that

are missing.

• Frequently social skills programs do not take

motivation or stimulus control into

consideration.

• Over use of script training without attention

to the relevant controlling variables of social

interactions may produce immediate results,

but issues with generalization are highly likely.

Issues Teaching Social Skills

• Generalization is often not achieved.

• Often treatment packages/programs have

many variables and simplification of

procedures (component analysis) can show

controlling variables.

Page 3: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

3

Language and Social Interaction

• Language is social interaction. Communication

is social behavior.

• When teaching learners with limited language

skills expanding the verbal repertoire will be a

priority.

• Learners need to develop the basic

communication in order to be able to develop

more advanced social skills.

ASSESSMENT

Page 4: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

4

Assessment and Skill Sequences

• Early Start Denver Model Curriculum Checklist for

Young Children with Autism (Rogers & Dawson, 2007)

• Social Skills Solutions: A Hands on Manual for

Teaching Social Skills to Children with Autism (McKinnon & Krempa, 2002)

• Skillstreaming (McGinnis, 2011)

• Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and

Placement Program (Sundberg, 2008)

• Within program curriculum-based assessments

Page 5: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

5

Early Start Denver Model Curriculum Assessment

• Criterion-Referenced Assessment

• Four levels with basic developmental

categories

– Level 1(98 skills assessed): receptive language,

expressive communication, SOCIAL SKILLS,

imitation, cognition, play, fine motor, gross motor,

behavior, personal independence

(eating/dressing/grooming/ chores)

• Level 2 (122 skills assessed): adds joint attention as category

for assessment, splits social behaviors into those observed

with adults & peers, and splits play into representational and

independent.

• Level 3 (101 skills assessed) & 4 (125 skills assessed) covers

the same general assessment areas, but has more advanced

skills based on developmental sequences.

• Scored as pass (consistently observed), pass/fail

(inconsistently), fail (not observed)

• Allows for parent report, teacher report, or direct

observation, & provides an opportunity to record prompt

levels if needed.

Early Start Denver Model Curriculum Assessment

Page 6: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

6

Sample Social Skills Covered

• Level 1

Level 2 Sample Skills

Page 7: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

7

Level 3 Sample Skills

Level 4 Sample Skills

Page 8: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

8

Social Skills Assessment: ESDM

• Provides detailed social skill sequence for

some of the earliest learners.

• Provides clear break down of skills assessed.

• Provides general sequence with levels of

assessment.

• Provides opportunity for family as well as

professional input.

• Has corresponding curriculum to guide

teaching.

Page 9: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

9

Social Skills Solutions

Social Skills Solutions

• Categories assessed: joint attention, greetings,

social play, self-awareness, conversation,

perspective taking, critical thinking, advanced

language, friendships, & community skills.

• Provides broad strategies for how to

potentially teach skills. • Instructors would need to have strong general training

in behavioral principles to apply procedures that are

likely to result in success.

Page 10: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

10

Social Skills Solutions

• Provides an opportunity to score as present

or absent skills in 1:1, in group, or in the

natural environment.

Breaking down of Social Skills Solutions

• User/family friendly, jargon-free

• Skill sequence covers a broad range of skills

including those that need to be developed by

the earliest learners.

• Provides general sequence with levels of

assessment.

• Caution: some skills significantly differ within

range of a particular level.

Page 11: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

11

Skillstreaming

• Assessment and behavioral skills training

program.

• Provides teacher, student (self), and parent

assessments.

• Assessments include 60 questions each and

raters score based on likert scale. • 1= almost never good at using this skill, 2 = seldom “ “,

3 = sometime “ “, 4= often “ “, always “ “

– Items focus on intermediate and more advanced

social behaviors.

Page 12: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

12

Skillstreaming

• Examples of skills covered include:

– Relaxing, dealing with group pressure, making

decisions, asking for help, saying thank you, etc.

• Assessments and programs available for early

childhood, elementary, and secondary

learners.

• Learners in this program benefit significantly

from having rule-governed behavior.

– Assessment not well suited for students with

significant language impairments/early learners.

Page 13: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

13

Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment &

Placement Program (VB-MAPP)

• Behaviorally-based criterion referenced assessment

that assesses developmental milestones acquired by

typical learners from birth to 48 mths (3 levels).

– 0-18 mths: – Social behaviors assessed include: eye contact to adults & peers,

observing approach behaviors, etc.

– 18-30 mths: – Social behaviors assessed include: peer manding, responding

to mands from peers, sustained social play w/ peers.

– 30-48 mths: – Social behaviors assessed include: intraverbal responses to

peers, mands for information, intraverbal responses w/ peer

on-topic for multiple exchanges.

Page 14: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

14

VB-MAPP

• Provides general milestones and task analysis

for more specific skills.

• Some instructors may consider breaking down

skills into smaller components if need is

indicated.

– See within program based assessments.

Sample individual program assessment

Page 15: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

15

Page 16: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

16

Page 17: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

17

Other intermediate social skills to consider

Assessment Tools

• A variety of assessment tools on the market.

• Selecting the most valuable combination of

assessment tools requires consideration for

the learner, the skills he/she has, and the skills

that he/she is likely to develop next based on

developmental/ instructional progressions.

Page 18: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

18

TEACHING SOCIAL SKILLS

Before you begin teaching…

• Does the student have the pre-requisite skills

for this type of instruction?

• Does the student have the language skills to

participate in this type of instruction?

• Is this the most simplistic, research supported,

and systematic way of teaching these skills?

• Are these skills being introduced under the

ideal conditions to promote proper stimulus

control & skill generalization?

Page 19: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

19

Instructional Level

• Research validated instructional skills must be

based on the instructional level of the learner.

– Conditioning attention as reinforcer

– Joint Attention

– Manding

– Peer manding

– Intermediated and advanced peer manding

– Behavioral skills training for rule-governed

behavior

• Additional interventions supported include

peer-support strategies.

ESTABLISHING BASIC

SOCIAL BEHAVIORS

Early Learners:

Page 20: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

20

Early Social Skills

• Conditioning attention as a reinforcer/

developing approach behaviors

• Joint Attention

• Manding

Conditioning Attention as a Reinforcer/

Approach Behaviors

• Teaching more formal social skills prior to

developing attention as a conditioned

reinforcer is not likely to result in generalized

appropriate social skill development.

• Teaching social skills through pairing known

reinforcers with neutral stimuli (people) can

result in attention as conditioned a reinforcer

(Taylor Santa, Sidener, Carr, & Reed, 2014;

Dozier, Iwata, Thomason-Sassi, Worsdell,

Wilson, 2012).

Page 21: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

21

How to develop attention as Sr+

• 1st must have known reinforcing

items/activities/edibles for learner

– Conduct formal and informal preference

assessments and take changes in MO into

consideration.

– Ongoing re-evaluation of these items is needed.

• Two types of pairing procedures

– Stimulus-stimulus pairing

– Response-stimulus pairing

Joint Attention

• One of the earliest forms of social

communication

– Coordinated attention between social partner and

object/ event in the environment (Taylor & Hock,

2008).

– Two Elements (Taylor & Hock, 2008)

• Responding to another’s bid for joint attention

• Initiations for joint attention from others

Page 22: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

22

Video of Joint Attention

• Non verbal video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZQcIG

mJdR2A

Manding to Adults

• Early communication from most young children starts with

requests.

• Mands are social behaviors that directly result in improving

conditions.

• Mands are key pre-requisite skills for other more advanced

social skills.

• People responding to the learner’s mands increases their

value.

– Necessary for developing more advanced social skills (conditioning

attention/people as reinforcers).

• Students need to be proficient manders with adults before

working on manding with other kids.

Page 23: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

23

Adult Manding- Key Reminders

• Identify reinforcers from various categories keeping in mind

that items included in sessions may change due to changes in

motivation.

• Instructors must control access to reinforcers during manding

sessions.

• Teach mands when motivation is strong.

• Teach mands across multiple exemplars, environments, and

instructors.

• Target multiple mands at one time.

• Practice mands in discrimination.

• Initial teaching often requires many presentations.

Video of Manding Session

• Mike Miklos

http://www.pattan.net/Videos/Browse/Single/?c

ode_name=mand_training_example_mand_tr

aining3

Page 24: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

24

Mands & Other Language Skills

• After a basic mand repertoire is established

with adults, attention will need to be given to

establish intermediate and advanced manding

with adults.

– Ex: mands for actions, mands for attention, mands

for information, multiple component mands, etc.

• To prepare students for intermediate and advanced

social skills you will need to build other verbal

repertoires (tacting actions, tacting adjectives, tacting

prepositions, multiple component tacts, etc.)

TEACHING SOCIAL

BEHAVIORS

The Intermediate Learner

Page 25: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

25

The Journey

• Baseline

• Generalization Dyad 1

Peer Manding & Reinforcer Delivery

• Receiving preferred items from others

increases the likelihood that learners will

approach and interact with others.

• A pre-requisite for other social skills is peers

serving as conditioned reinforcers.

• It is hypothesized through teaching peer

manding and peer reinforcer delivery that

peers will become conditioned reinforcers.

Page 26: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

26

Literature on Peer Manding

– Taylor, Hoch, Potter, Rodriguez, Spinnato, and Kalaigan (2005)

• EO Manipulation

– Pellecchia and Hineline (2007)

• Instructors, parents, siblings, peers

– Paden, Kodak, Fisher, Gawley- Bullington, and Bouxsein (2012)

– PECs blocked adult mands and prompt peer

– Kodak, Paden, and Dickes (2012)

• PECs + extension blocked adult mands and prompt peer + distance

approach with novel peer

– Lorah, Gilroy, and Hineline (2014)

• Listeners and speakers, PECs users mands for puzzle through interrupted

chain, generalization to novel peer

Research Questions

• Will the introduction of a peer-to-peer manding treatment package consisting of the use of differential reinforcement and time delay procedures effect the rate of unprompted peer mands in individuals with autism/ IDD?

• Will the use of time delay procedures and differential reinforcement effect the rate of the deliveries of preferred items to peers in individuals with autism/ IDD?

Page 27: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

27

Primary Participants

Student Age Gender Primary

Class-

VB-

MAPP

Score at

Study

Onset

Bella 9 Female Autism 124.5

Calvin 9 Male Autism 117.5

Mark 7 Male Autism 86

Caleb 6 Male Autism 88.5

Isaiah 7 Male Autism 129.5

Carter 10 Male IDD 96.5 * All had minimum of 20 mands for items/actions, all had skills betw een 18-30mths on VB-

MAPP (Sundberg, 2007), all vocal responders, all could receptively identify 50 different

pictures of items w ith 3 different exemplars when presented in an array of 8 (VB-MAPP, LR-7).

Studen

t

Grade

Level

Gender Class-

Zoe 3rd Female None

Sam 5th Male None

Adam 4th Male None

Other Participants

• Each peer support was

partnered in play sessions

with two primary participants

for 5-6 play sessions.

Instructor

Participants

Role Years

Receiving

ABA

Consultatio

n

Denise Para

Educator

.5 years

Karly Teacher 4.5 years

Olivia Teacher 4.5 years

Kelly Para

Educator

4.5 years

Zia Para

Educator

.5 years

Page 28: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

28

Experimental Design

• Multiple probe across dyads design (Horner & Baer, 1978; Kennedy,

2005)

• Phases: Baseline, intervention, follow up, generalization phases, and maintenance probes.

• Modifications:

• IV-1: Differential reinforcement for prompted deliveries (Caleb)

• IV-2: Block on free deliveries of reinforcers/ prompting peer manding (Caleb & Mark)

• IV-P: Praise delivered with tangible as differential reinforcement for unprompted mands (Isaiah)

6.5 hours of training

prior to baseline (1.5

video)

All instructors had to get

95% or greater IOA

scoring sample 4 min video

sessions

Page 29: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

29

Measures

• DV: frequency of unprompted mands

• DV: frequency of unprompted Sr+ deliveries

• Other measures collected (via video):

– Frequency of PB

– Prompted mands and prompted Sr+ deliveries

Independent Variable

• Intervention (12 min play sessions, 4 min

materials reset)

– Time Delay (TD) + differential reinforcement

(DR) for unprompted mands and unprompted Sr+

deliveries

– Error Correction

Incorrect Mand Incorrect Delivery of

Sr+

Problem Behavior

5 sec pause echoic

prompt

Not placing within reach

Not delivering

Incorrect item delivered

prompt peer mand 0

sec grad guidance physical

prompt

Prompt mand

Page 30: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

30

Conditions

Condition Description

Baseline 12 min sessions, materials reset every 4 min

12 items & 6 edibles , Sd: indicating play time

Intervention DR for unprompted responses + 3 sec time

delay on mand and SR+ delivery behaviors

Follow up No prompts and differential reinforcement

Generalization Same as follow up with general education

peer partner

Maintenance

Probes

Original partners 1 x/ week for at least 2

weeks

Reintroduce

Intervention

Only as indicated

Modifications

IV P: Adding praise w/ tangible for unprompted mands (Isaiah)

IV 1 : Delivery of DR for prompted deliveries (Caleb)

IV2: Block on free deliveries (Mark & Caleb)

IV3: IV1 + IV2 (Mark & Caleb)

RESULTS

Page 31: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

31

Conditions

Baseline

(12 min sessions)

12 items 6 edibles, materials reset 4 min

Sd: “you can play”

Intervention DR for unprompted responses + 3s TD

on mand and Sr+ delivery behaviors

Follow Up No prompts or DR for mands/ Sr+

deliveries

Generalization Same as follow up. Introduced general

education peer

Maintenance Original play partners, sessions 1 x/week

for min. of 2 weeks

Reintroduce IV As indicated based on responding MSWO preference

assessments conducted

prior to baseline

Free operant MO

checks before

sessions in all

conditions

Modifications

IV-P: social praise +tangible Sr+

delivery for unprompted mands

(Isaiah)

IV-1: Differential reinforcement

for prompted reinforcer

deliveries (Caleb)

IV-2: Block of free deliveries of

reinforcers and prompt mand for

partner (Caleb & Mark)

IV-3: IV-1 + IV-2

Page 32: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

32

Results

Functional

Relation

Bella Calvin Mark Caleb Isaiah Carter

Basic IV on

Unprompted

Mands

+ + + + - +

Basic IV on

SR+

deliveries

+ + + - + +

Follow Up + + + + + + Maintenance + + + - + + Isaiah & Caleb both

demonstrated increased

responding with minor

modifications to the IV tx

procedures

Bella demonstrated lower rates of

unprompted mands & Sr+

deliveries but rates were above

baseline levels and PB levels

indicated a change in program may

be needed.

Bella’s Sr+

response rates

increased in the

follow up phase.

Reintroduction of IV for Caleb

• All participants demonstrated some

maintenance of skills in the maintenance phase

with the exception of Caleb who only

delivered 1 reinforcer to his peer during

maintenance sessions.

Page 33: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

33

Problem Behavior- Bella

Intro of IV increased unprompted mands, unprompted Sr+ deliveries and

PB Follow up: she demonstrated reduced PB

Maintenance: Bella’s PB increased from Gen phase and deliveries were low.

Maintenance session discontinued.

Participants % Agreement

Unprompted

Mands

% Agreement

Unprompted

Sr+ Deliveries

Bella 78 92

Calvin 94 95

Mark 98 97

Caleb 98 92

Isaiah 99 96

Carter 93 99

• Collected on 97.9% of sessions – Calculated using total Agreement

Formula (smaller total number divided larger total number multiplied 100 ).

– If agreement was below 90%, training occurred.

• Total interobserver agreement across participants and measures was 99.5%.

• Early sessions for Bella had lowest agreement levels.

Interobserver Agreement (IOA)

**IOA conducted through video recordings by the PI.

Page 34: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

34

Procedural Integrity & Social Validity

• Procedural Integrity was conducted on 55% of sessions throughout

all phases of the investigation and across all dyads.

• The average procedural integrity for all sessions was 99.9%.

• Retraining occurred if procedural integrity dropped below 90%

• This only occurred on one instance early in the

investigation

• Limitation: Did not develop procedural fidelity checklists for modifications to the IV

• Social Validity 5/10 pt likert scales for adult & peer participants

Discussion

• Functional Relation Mands & Sr+ Deliveries

– The almost immediate increases in unprompted mand & Sr+ delivery

levels when introduced to the intervention indicate a functional

relation between the intervention and peer manding & Sr+ delivery

behaviors.

• Maintenance & Generalization

– The maintenance of these skills across follow up, generalization, and

maintenance probes indicate that the intervention was successful in

developing a sustained skill likely to maintain for the participants

across time and with other peers.

Page 35: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

35

Differences from previous research

• All vocal participants

• Controls for MO

• Use of DR

• General Education Peer Partners

• Ecological validity

• Discriminative listener behavior

Limitations

• Modifications to Procedures • IV-1, IV-2, IV-3, IV-P

• Participant Selection • Further testing needed, large range of participants

• Rate of unprompted mands observed in instructional day, participant reinforcer diversity, overall VB –MAPP scores (Sundberg, 2007), giving up reinforcers and responses to graduated guidance physical prompts

• Articulation Assesment

• Instructor Scoring

• Motivation- Controls for responding to maintain MO, combat competing MO

• Co-variation of Measures/Participants

• No generalization probe in baseline condition

• Immediate Fade vs. Withdrawal of Intervention

• Design Limitation: Intervention on two measures at the same time

Page 36: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

36

Implications for Practitioners

• Promising outcomes for all participants

• Provides practical procedures for replication (staff training required)

• Provides potential modifications for limited responders

• Maintenance of skills and reduced levels of responding may indicate that sessions should be continued for a longer period of time, or elements of the intervention should have been systematically faded (Rusch & Kazdin, 1981).

• Could modify the procedures to focus on teaching one of the two skills first

• Potential to assess many other vital communication and social skills in the play sessions.

• Mands for attention, mands for information, generalized motor imitation during play activities, social commenting, peer eye orienting responses, and eye contact.

TEACHING SOCIAL

BEHAVIORS

Intermediate to Advanced Learners

Page 37: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

37

Intermediate Peer Mands

• After intermediate mands are mastered with

adults peer manding sessions should focus on

cultivating motivation for intermediate as well

as basic mands with peers.

• Instructors may target these skills through

interrupted chains or action-based activities.

• When teaching intermediate peer mands,

deliver prompts and differential reinforcement

only for targeted intermediate peer mand.

ADVANCED SOCIAL SKILLS

Teaching

Page 38: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

38

Rule-Governed Behavior

• Rule-governed behavior: “behavior is

controlled by verbal antecedents rather than

more directly by its particular consequences”

(Catania, Shimoff, & Matthews, 1989, p.119).

• When instructions accurately represent the

contingencies in place it can increase the rate

of behavior acquisition (Hackenberg & Joker,

1994).

Rule Governed vs. Schedule Control

• If learners contact higher rates of

reinforcement through behaviors that are not

socially acceptable more efficiently than they

may contact reinforcement for socially

appropriate rule-following behavior, reviewing

rules for behavior is not likely to result in

improvement in socially appropriate

behaviors.

Page 39: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

39

Language Skills Needed

• For learners to benefit from social skills

instruction that is guided by rules for

responding in particular situations they must...

– Have proficient language skills to respond and

participate in rule-governed instruction.

• If students do not have proficient language skills based

on behavior-based language assessment, participation in

a formal rule-based social skills curriculum is not likely

to be beneficial.

Teaching Rule-Governed Behavior

• If students have language skills, but rule-governed

behavior is not established as a generalized

repertoire, additional procedures may need to be

put in place to establish generalized rule-governed

behavior.

• Strategies: target basic rules, providing explicit prompting

and differential reinforcement for rule-following and

systemically fade differential reinforcement & prompts,

allowing the direct natural contingencies to support

maintenance of the behavior.

• This may be needed before teaching more complex social

multi-step rule sequences.

Page 40: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

40

Chaining as an Alternative

• If students do not have rule-governed

behavior or limited social behavior, but a

learner needs to develop a socially-

appropriate sequence for a given situation

skills can be taught through chaining

procedures.

Behavioral Skills Training

• Research validated treatment package used to

effectively teach a variety of skills to a variety

of populations.

– Ex: Gun safety, abduction prevention techniques,

safety skills, training school professionals to work

with students, training parents to improve feeding

techniques with children, behavior profesionals to

conduct FAs, etc.

– Core elements: instruction, modeling, rehearsal,

feedback

(Buck, 2014)

Page 41: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

41

Skillstreaming

• Assessment, instructional guide, curriculum,

and resources grounded in behavioral skills

training to teach a variety of basic social skills.

• Materials: behavior skill cards, student manual,

instructor manual, video models, lesson plans

& activities.

• Reinforcement: initially instructors will likely

need to apply explicit reinforcement which

will later need to be faded systematically.

Skillstreaming

• Each skill is broken into small steps. Steps are

are formally taught through behavioral skills

training.

• Homework is assigned after

• Recommendation: Structure Natural

Environment Teaching (NET) opportunities to

practice skills

Page 42: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

42

Skillstreaming- Behavioral Skills Training

• Step 1: Define skill

• Step 2: Model skill

• Step 3: Establish student need for skill

• Step 4: Select the 1st role player

• Step 5: Set up the role play

• Step 6: Conduct role play

• Step 7: Provide performance feedback

• Step 8: Select the next role-player

• Step 9: Assign skill homework

PEER SUPPORT PROGRAMS

Page 43: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

43

Peer Support Programs

• Peer support programs are structured

systematic opportunities for peers to

participate in social interactions and

educational experiences with students that

may have different educational needs.

• A number of studies support the effectiveness

of peer support programs in the development

of social and other academic skills.

Teaching Activities of Daily Living

Page 44: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

44

Research Support for Peer Social Interventions (Hughes & Carter, 2008)

• Peers have assisted with teaching how to – Identify peers by name (Hunt, Alwell, & Goetz, 1991),

– Express anger appropriately (Presley & Hughes, 2000),

– Increase social interactions with others in the school (Hughes, Killian,

& Fischer, 1996),

– Respond to common social greetings presented by peers (Ninetimp &

Cole, 1992),

– Demonstrate improved social behavior in lunch and recess (Morrison,

Kamps, Garcia, & Parker, 2001),

– Interact appropriately between classes and in structured social

activities (Haring & Breen, 1992),

– Maintain conversations with their schoolmates (Hughes et

al., 2000).

Community Based Instruction

Page 45: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

45

Program Development

• Develop course description or system to organize

potential peer participants.

• Determine what opportunities within the school day

will be available and when peer supports will be able

to participate.

• Determine how these opportunities will be

presented to potential peer partners/buddies.

• If developing course sequence develop assignments,

grading structure, observation data sheets, etc.

• Develop assessment for matching students with

interests, experience levels, and comfort with PB.

Before you start!

• Organize training for school staff involved.

– Para educator & support teacher training

• How to support peer buddies in developing age-

appropriate social relationships

• How to score observations of peer supports in

different environments.

• Organize peer support/ buddy training

– Key elements: safety, roles/responsibilities,

responding to problem behavior of peers,

disability awareness, logistics, course management,

and team building.

Page 46: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

46

Training Typical Peers

• Training Video

Contact Information www.pattan.net

Rachel Kittenbrink

[email protected]

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

Tom Wolf, Gov ernor

Page 47: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

47

References

• American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual

of mental disorders (5th ed.). Washington, DC:

• Buck, H. (2014). The efficacy of behavior skills training: A literature

review. Southern Illinois University Carbondale, 1-40.

• Carbone, V. (2016). Select Topics in Behavior Analysis and Teaching

Children with Autism, Presentation, PaTTAN, Harrisburg, April 2016.

• Catania, C. Shimoff, E. & Matthews, B. (1989). An Experimental Analysis of

Rule-Governed Behavior. In Rule-Governed Behavior Cognition,

Contingencies, and Instructional Control. Plenum Press, New York,

p.119.

• Dozier, C. L., Iwata, B.A., Thomason-Sassi, J., Worsdell, A.S., & Wilson,

D.M., (2012). A comparison of two pairing procedures to establish praise

as a reinforcer, Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 45, (4), 721-735.

References

• Hackenberg, T. & Joker, V. (1994). Instructional control versus schedule

control of humans’ choices in situations of diminishing returns,

Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 62 (3), 367-383.

• Horner, R., & Baer, D. (1978). Multiple-probe technique: A variation of

the multiple baseline. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 11, 189-196.

• Hughes, C. & Carter, E. (2008). Peer Buddy Programs for Successful

Secondary School Inclusion. Brookes Publishing Co. Baltimore, MD. 1-199.

• Kennedy, C. H. (2005). Single-case designs for educational research. Boston,

MA: Allyn and Bacon.

• Kodak, T., Paden, A., Dickes, N. (2012). Training and generalization of

peer-directed mands with non-vocal children with autism. The Analysis of

Verbal Behavior, 28, 119-124.

• Leaf, J.B., Kassardjian, A., Oppendheim-Leaf, M.L., Cihon, J.H., Taubman,

M., Leaf, E., McEachin, J. (2016) Social Thinking: Science, Pseudoscience, or

Antiscience? Behavior Analysis in Practice, 9: 152-157.

Page 48: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

48

References

• Lorah, E. R., Gilroy, S. P., & Hineline, P.N. (2014). Acquisition of peer manding

and listener responding in young children with autism, Research in Autism

Spectrum Disorders, 8, 61-67.

• McGinnis, E. (2011). Skillstreaming the Elementary School Child: A Guide for

Teaching Prosocial Skills. 3rd Ed. Champaign, IL: Research Press.

• McKinnon, K., & Krempa, J. (2002). Social Skills Solutions: A Hands-On

Manual for Teaching Social Skills to Children with Autism. New York, NY:

DRL Books, Inc.

• Melott, K.(2013). Social skills for higher functioning children. National Autism

Conference, State College, PA. August.

• Paden, A., Kodak, T., Fisher, W., Gawley-Bullington, E., & Bouxsein, K.,

(2012). Teaching children with autism to engage in peer-directed mands using

a picture exchange communication system, Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis,

45, 425-429.

• Pellecchia, M., & Hineline, P. N. (2007). Generalization of mands in children

with autism from adults to peers. The Behavior Analyst Today. 8, 483-491.

References

• Rogers, S.J., & Dawson, G. (2009). Early Start Denver Model Curriculum

Checklist for Young Children with Autism, The Guilford Press.

• Sundberg, M. L. (2007) The Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and

Placement Program Protocol. Advancements in Verbal Behavior Press.

Concord, CA, 1-72.

• Taylor, B. & Hock, H. (2008). Teaching Children with autism to respond

and initiate bids for joint attention. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 41,

3, 377-391.

• Taylor, B.A., Hoch, H., Potter, B., Rodriguez, A., Spinnato, D., & Kalaigian,

M. (2005). Manipulating establishing operations to promote initiations

towards peers in children with autism. Research in Developmental

Disabilities, 26, 385-392.

• Taylor-Santa, C., Sidener, T., Carr, J. & Reeve, K., (2014). A discrimination

training procedure to establish conditioned reinforcers in children with

autism. Behavioral Interventions, 29,2, 157-176.

Page 49: Social Skills Research Validated Interventions · 1 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network Social Skills Research Validated Interventions 8/3/16 National Autism Conference

7/27/2016

49

References

• Test, D.W., Richter, S., Knight, V., Spooner, F. (2011). A comprehensive review

and meta-analysis of the social stories literature. Focus on Autism and Other

Developmental Disorders, 26,1, 49-62.