Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
it changes everything!
multicollectivity
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
our old cultural paradigm: people belonging primarily to one culture
situation problem objective approach results plea
person A
culture A culture B
person B
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
our old cultural paradigm: people belonging primarily to one culture
situation problem objective approach results plea
one individual belonging primarily
to one culture
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
our old cultural paradigm: people belonging primarily to one culture
situation problem objective approach results plea
clear cultural borders
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
our old cultural paradigm: people belonging primarily to one culture
situation problem objective approach results plea
homogeneous cultures
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
our old cultural paradigm: people belonging primarily to one culture
situation problem objective approach results plea
similarities between people from the same
culture
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
the traditional concept of interculturality: an objective situation outside the normal
situation problem objective approach results plea
interculturality = collision of two worlds
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
the traditional concept of interculturality: an objective situation outside the normal
situation problem objective approach results plea
interculturality = collision of two worlds
unusual, not normal
situation
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
the traditional concept of interculturality: an objective situation outside the normal
situation problem objective approach results plea
interculturality = collision of two worlds
situation can be identified
objectively
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
the traditional concept of interculturality: an objective situation outside the normal
situation problem objective approach results plea
interculturality = collision of two worlds
arising con!lict highly likely
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
traditional intercultural trainings: explain cultural differences between those “primary“ cultures
situation problem objective approach results plea
ignorance of other culture
ignorance of other culture
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
traditional intercultural trainings: explain cultural differences between those “primary“ cultures
situation problem objective approach results plea
ignorance of other culture
ignorance of other culture
intercultural training:
• spread knowledge about cultural di"ferences
• prevent con!lict
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
traditional intercultural trainings lead to four major problems that question their effectiveness
situation problem objective approach results plea
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
traditional intercultural trainings lead to four major problems that question their effectiveness
situation problem objective approach results plea
1
generalization • pretend to be able to
tell how others are
• reduce individuals to a group membership
• disseminate falsities
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
traditional intercultural trainings lead to four major problems that question their effectiveness
situation problem objective approach results plea
perpetuation • claim „eternal“ di"ferences
• keep people in permanent state of emergency
2
1
generalization • pretend to be able to
tell how others are
• reduce individuals to a group membership
• disseminate falsities
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
traditional intercultural trainings lead to four major problems that question their effectiveness
situation problem objective approach results plea
perpetuation • claim „eternal“ di"ferences
• keep people in permanent state of emergency
2
rivalry • construct adverse
groups
• foster out-group dynamics
3
1
generalization • pretend to be able to
tell how others are
• reduce individuals to a group membership
• disseminate falsities
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
situation problem objective approach results plea
generalization • pretend to be able to
tell how others are
• reduce individuals to a group membership
• disseminate falsities 1
perpetuation • claim „eternal“ di"ferences
• keep people in permanent state of emergency
2
rivalry • construct adverse
groups
• foster out-group dynamics
3 red herring
• pretend that con!licts can be avoided through some kind of knowledge
• try to solve the wrong problem
4
traditional intercultural trainings lead to four major problems that question their effectiveness
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
if we want to solve these problems we need new trainings
based on a different cultural paradigm
situation problem objective approach results plea
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
situation problem objective approach results plea
What‘s wrong with this picture?
let‘s start from scratch
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
we are all michelin men
situation problem objective approach results plea
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
the concept of multicollectivity can help reshape our cultural paradigm
situation problem objective approach results plea
german woman
professor pearl jam fan
berliner
scientist
heterosexual
sister
civil servant
schleswig-holsteiner
choir member
daughter
couch potatoe
european
owner of a convertible
godmother
forty-something
mba
ukulele player
schöneberger
church member
anti-smoking
entj personality type
apple aficionada
star trek fan
early bird
...
multi-collectivity
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
multicollectivity: people navigate between memberships depending on context
situation problem objective approach results plea
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
multicollectivity: people navigate between memberships depending on context
situation problem objective approach results plea
country soccer league
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
multicollectivity: people navigate between memberships depending on context
situation problem objective approach results plea
world championship
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
multicollectivity: people navigate between memberships depending on context
situation problem objective approach results plea
christopher street day
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
multicollectivity: people navigate between memberships depending on context
situation problem objective approach results plea
metal festival
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
multicollectivity: we are not icebergs nor are we in constant flux
situation problem objective approach results plea
iceberg identity concept
flux identity concept
• static
• claims homogeneity and coherence of identity
• implies cultural determinism
• no connection to modern reality
• !luent / undefined / arbitrary
• implies randomness of identity
• fails to explain relative stability of identity
• fails to explain strong human identifications
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
the concept of multicollectivity can help reshape our understanding of human identity
situation problem objective approach results plea
iceberg identity concept
flux identity concept
multicollectivity concept
• relative stabilitycollective memberships marked by clear boundaries
• flexibilityindividuals add and end group memberships
• relevance of context navigation through memberships depending on context (virulence)
• radical individuality unique combination of memberhips and cultural in!luences
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
multicollectivity: whenever individuals interact a multitude of cultures are involved
situation problem objective approach results plea
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
multicollectivity: interculturality depends on the perception of the involved
situation problem objective approach results plea
missing link
interculturality • when people have something to do with each other
and perceive the other as not belonging to them
• when those memberships become virulent that we don‘t share with the involved
he doesn‘t belong
to us
she doesn‘t belong
to us
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
intercultural training based on a new cultural paradigm: help people deal with dynamics of collective dissociation
situation problem objective approach results plea
downward spiral of collective
dissociation
unfamiliarity attribution to di"ferent memberships
feeling estranged / excluded
feeling threatened exclusion /
discrimination rivalry
stigmatization attempt to destruct
he doesn‘t belong
to us
she doesn‘t belong
to us
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
intercultural training based on a new cultural paradigm: help people initiate cohesive dynamics
situation problem objective approach results plea
upward spiral of cohesion
establish normality
establish familiarity
discover common memberhips establish new
memberships
participation
appreciation
culture production
he doesn‘t belong
to us
she doesn‘t belong
to us
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
intercultural training based on a new cultural paradigm: help people initiate cohesive dynamics
situation problem objective approach results plea
he belongs to me
she belongs to me
upward spiral of cohesion
establish normality
establish familiarity
discover common memberhips establish new
memberships
participation
appreciation
culture production
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
work on developingthese new forms of intercultural training
and help save the world!
situation problem objective approach results plea
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
let‘s stop telling people they‘re like this
situation problem objective approach results plea
© prof. dr. stefanie rathje
more is more!
let‘s show them that they‘re like this
situation problem objective approach results plea