1

BY

ANTONY CUMMINS

EDITED BY ROSS DOWNING

2

Wordclay 1663 Liberty Drive, Suite 200 Bloomington, IN 47403 www.wordclay.com Copyright 2009 Antony Cummins. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted by any means without the written permission of the author. First published by Wordclay on 11/30/2009. ISBN: 978-1-6048-1674-7 (sc) Printed in the United States of America. This book is printed on acid-free paper.

3

4

NOW THAT THE NINJA HAVE PASSED INTO

THE PAGES OF HISTORY, ALL THAT REMAINS ARE THE

ECHOES OF THEIR VOICES

PEERING INTO A WORLD OF SECRETS AND THE HIDDEN, WE CAN HAVE NO CERTAINTIES

AND MAY ONLY INVESTIGATE.

THIS BOOK IS ONE SUCH INVESTIGATION.

5

BOOKS

The Shoninki A 17th century Ninjutsu Manual (2011)

Shinobi Sagas

True Ninja Accounts

T.S Royalist Voyage Manual

Burzum

Black Speech

To Stand on a Stone 50 Fundamental Principles for the Martial Arts

Conversations with an Assassin Reflections on Modern Society

True English

A Dictionary of English Swearing (In Japanese)

DVDS

To Stand on a Stone

50 Fundamental Principles for the Martial Arts

The Medieval Combat Series Natural Body Dynamics

6

AUTHORS NOTES CHAPTER 1 THE REALITY- WHAT IS A NINJA COMMON MISCONCEPTIONS HOW THEY WROTE NINJA IS NINJUTSU A MARTIAL ART? CHINESE NINJAS? WHAT IS A NINJAS JOB? THE KOKA NINJA VERSUS THE IGA NINJA CHAPTER 2 HISTORICAL WEAPONS OF THE NINJA WHAT ARE NINJA WEAPONS? THE NINJA SWORD THE SHURIKEN CHAPTER 3 THE TOOLS OF THE NINJA FIRE & GRENADES CLIMBING & SCALING BREAKING & ENTERING TOOLS POISON CHAPTER 4 THE TRUTH BEHIND THE NINJA SUIT THE NINJA SUIT WHAT COLOUR IS A NINJA SUIT? CHAPTER 5 ESCAPE METHODS ESCAPOLOGY

CHAPTER 6 INFILTRATION METHODS WAR & PEACE IN-NIN YO-NIN ASSASSINATION CHAPTER 7 THE SPELLS AND ESOTERIC BELIEFS OF THE NINJA KUJI KIRI KUJI-IN RITUAL MAGIC CHAPTER 8 NINJUTSU AND ZEN TO DO OR DIE! CHAPTER 9 INTERVIEW WITH LEADING NINJUTSU AUTHORITIES DEFENCE AGAINST A NINJA AN INTERVIEW WITH OTAKE SENSEI NINJA QUESTIONS! AN INTERVIEW WITH NAKASHIMA SENSEI PART I DID THE ARCHETYPE NINJA EXIST AND OTHER STATEMENTS AN INTERVIEW WITH NAKASHIMA SENSEI PART II

7

This book is based on magazine articles published in Combat Magazine and originally wrote with an aim of dismantling the considerable misconceptions that seem to surround our common understanding of these Ninja men and women of history. This book attempts to find a pathway through the mythology and to look beyond the modern creation that is the media version of the Ninja. Through logical investigation I will take you on a journey that will reinforce the element of the elite that the Ninja once stood for. My hope is that I can open your mind to the possibilities that you thought not possible. What It will not do and that which is common to Ninjutsu students is to spout and dribble hundreds of Japanese words and Ninjutsu terminology, in the hope that you will get confused and feel that the author is superior in knowledge. This principle is set with you now to display that the concept of a Ninjutsu expert does not exist. By definition the word expert is someone who is well versed and familiar with all elements of a given subject, and on this subject there are no experts. There are people who have a deep interest, there are people in love with the Ninja and there are those who try to discover what happened in that black and dark past but there are no experts in the true sense of the word. That, in mind I want you to join me in an investigation into the world of the Ninja or Shinobi.

8

9

The first misconception you must put out of your mind is the word assassin in connection with the Ninja. This does not mean that Ninja sometimes did not assassinate people as a secondary activity but it was simply not a primary role. The concept of assassin is a commonly accepted one in most parts of the world, so why did the historical Ninja gain worldwide renown as the ultimate assassin figure? Moreover the question arises, what is a Ninja? When looking at the name Ninja and the surrounding terminology we hit on the word Shinobi or Shinobi no mono. Both reflect a person who uses Ninjutsu or is in fact a Ninja. If you analyse the ideogram for Ninja we find two main sections. The first is Heart and the second is Blade and as with all Japanese we can read this in a phonetic or symbolic way. Therefore, Ninja can be viewed as perseverance or adept of stealth. As you can see the fundamental message lacks any hint or reference to assassination. We can read from the Japanese ideograms that a Shinobi no mono was a person who undertook a stealthy art and or had

10

perseverance under duress. Now, if you wipe clean your slate and remove what you thought you knew about the Ninja and start to form an image of a person who is trained in all elements of stealth and can endure untold levels of hardships we can start to identify with what would be the base of the Shinobi. Continuing along the theme of names for the Ninja, we know that such epithets as: Ninpei (Shinobi Soldiers), Suppa (thief), Rappa (Ruffian), Kusa (grass) were employed to describe their arts. This tends to trap most people investigating Ninja history. We perceive a word and give it an identifying label, a label with connotations often misdirected. Take the term knight. Consider knights at the end of the first millennium, then their counterparts in the Middle Ages, then a Victorian knight and finally the accolades given out each year by the Queen. All are knights, all are under the same banner, yet all differ immensely. As with the Ninja of all over Japan and from chronological diversities we will find that they are also dissimilar in some respects. A Ninja is not a product of machine manufacture but an artist of skill with personal traits that resemble the needs of the world around them. A fundamental misconception is that of the Ninja as a person and an identity as apposed to a skill. There is debate as to whether the Ninja existed at all or if Ninja was simply a set of skills used by those who trained in the art. I argue however, that this is redundant, for even if the art of the Ninja is just a set of skills taught to different people it stands to reason

11

that person is a Ninja by default. But what does come out of this debate is that the concept of the Ninja being a separate class is not wholly correct. We do know through historical records such as the Shoninki (True Ninja account) that there were sections of the Samurai class that did adopt Ninjutsu as a skill and were classed as adepts of the Ninja arts. Here we have a most tantalizing piece of historical evidence for this, from the Samurai Katsuda Nangusai Yoshin of the Kishu Domain, he writes the following text in reference to the Ninja: Lately, Fujinoissuishi Masatake Jofu has recorded this secret document on the art of Ninpei by his own hand. The esoteric way of this writing is extremely scrupulous and subtle. If you attentively trust in and perform these skills, there wouldnt be a single warrior you couldnt deceive, no matter how prudent and discreet he was. Doubtlessly you would be able to take hold of the enemy by your tactics and have a complete control over them, by having them within the palm of your hand. It seems almost magical, this art of night stealth which enables you to make yourself invisible in the black of night.

(1681)

12

The first thing you should know about the Japanese language is that it was a fully developed and spoken language well before it was a written one. It is said that the Kanji characters of the Japanese language came to Japan from China in around the 6th century BC. You must understand that words in Japan existed before the written form, which in the case of much of western speech was historically mainly the other way around. Also consider that the Japanese had to pick the Kanji that they thought represented the word and which also had the phonetic sound. Thus, for example Shinobi no Mono () a person who steals in, consists of the Kanji for steal-in and there is also the Kanji for person . Thus, the word Shinobi was there before the written form. That does not mean that the Shinobi existed in the 6th century (no one can place their origin, of this we simply do not know) but it does mean that when the Shinobi came about, they were given a name and then chosen Kanji were put in place after the naming. This is why we have variations on the Kanji for the word Ninja. It is

13

fundamental in understanding the Ninja to understand how people historically recorded them.

Pronunciation: Shinobi or Nin Meaning: The basic form of Nin which consists of blade above a heart it has the dual meaning of to steal-in or perseverance. Information: This is by far the most common version of the word Shinobi that is written today. Historically it was used to refer to the activity of creeping or stealing-in and also as a reference to a person. This is also the basic element of most words connected with the Ninja; it is the foundational Kanji character that may use almost any verb ending put onto it to describe Ninja-like activities. For example, Shinobi-Iru () to enter in a stealthy way or Shinobi-Iku () to go discreetly.

Pronunciation: Ninja or Shinobi no mono Meaning: This is the basic form of Nin with the ending of person or a person who steals in Information: This is the most popular Kanji character for the Ninja, it is the iconic version and now the only one used to mean Ninja in modern Japanese. Some authorities claim that it is a modern invention but these people are incorrect, since we can see this word as early as the 17th century and used in the Shoninki manual.

14

Pronunciation: Ninjutsu or Shinobi no jutsu Meaning: The art of stealing-in: Nin is the base Kanji and jutsu, as is well know, means the art of. Information: The original reading for this is Shinobi no jutsu but alternatively it can be read as Ninjutsu which is now more popular. This is used to describe the arts of the Ninja or for a person who can use the skills of the Ninja arts. Thus, it does not have to be a Ninja by definition, it can be a samurai who has learnt some methods and is referring to using this skill. Remember, this is the action of and not the description for the person themselves.

Pronunciation: Ninpo Meaning: The way of the Ninja Information: The Kanji for Po usually means the laws or morals you should follow or the way to do something. The latter is more pragmatic and refers to the way to do, to act. However, we have to remember that Ninjutsu is NOT a martial art and using Po here has little or minimal difference to Jutsu Many modern Ninja students believe that Po is the spiritual side of Ninjutsu, this is incorrect and there is no evidence for this. This Kanji may be interpreted as laws of the Ninja or principles of the Ninja or it may simply be an alternative way of expressing Ninjutsu. We do know that this also appears in the Shoninki and therefore it

15

is at least as old as 1681.

Pronunciation: Ninpei Meaning: Shinobi Soldiers Information: This is a rare, old version of Ninja which is used in the written form only. It is rare because it is written by people of high status when referring to people lower then themselves. The second Kanji is used for foot soldiers by the military elite and thus, this means Ninja foot soldiers. We do know from the manual Gunpo that an average army of around 4000 would have around 20 Ninjas in their retinue and were used and integrated with the samurai, that is if the Ninjas themselves were not samurai using Ninjutsu. Therefore, this is a sophisticated way of writing about Ninja agents when penned by the military elite. As a point of interest this was the Kanji chosen for the title of this work Shinobi Soldiers.

( (or in the old form of first character) Pronunciation: Shinobi (also this can be read as Setto- stealing, but it sounds very modern.) Meaning: There are two Kanji here, the first (or ) means sneaking or spying the second means thievery, stealing or thief, thus it could be translated as a person who steals and spies: it is interesting to point out that it is also pronounced as Shinobi, the original word for Ninja.

16

Information: This version of Shinobi is as old as 1615 at least and reinforces the aspect of stealing and thievery that the Ninja were originally linked to, around the beginning of the Ninjas golden age. So-called modern Ninja masters have sought to take Ninjutsu away from this concept, but the historical Kanji always reminds us of the fact that a Ninja was in essence a spy and a cat-burglar.

Is Ninjutsu a martial art?No! Does it have martial arts in it?No! Do Ninjas learn martial arts?...Yes! To understand this simply, there were what we could class as a Ninja (that is, a man being brought up in the mountain regions of Koka and Iga and other such places) learning the Shinobi arts. Also, it is noteworthy that there were sections of the Samurai class learning Ninjutsu, or having been taught Ninjutsu. We know this to be a basic given fact and we can verify this by historical documents and accounts. This leads to the question, if the Samurai also studied Ninjutsu, then what were they learning? Surely a Samurai would be an extremely competent martial artist? Some people automatically say, well, they must have learnt secret weapons, this is a mute reply, as most of the weapons we think of as Ninja

17

weapons were in fact open to other Samurai martial arts schools. Hidden canes, throwing stars, chain weapons etc, all can be verified as being used outside of the realm of the Ninja. Therefore we must ask, what did the Samurai learn when they were taught Ninjutsu? If we look to the birthplace of the Ninja: Iga and Koga in Mie/Shiga prefecture, they were at the time of the Ninja, basically a separate state unto themselves, a self ruling body. Should this not put them on a comparable level to the Samurai, the elite warrior aristocracy? Or did the Iga state have a recognized Samurai family itselfit seems so according to the Iranki document? These questions are difficult to answer, and to some extent both questions are irrelevant. We must wonder that if warrior elites were to go to learn Ninjutsu as an external skill, what were they learning? Since it could not be fighting styles they were to learn. The comparisons between battlefield martial arts developed before the Edo period and modern Ninpo Taijutsu (skill with the body) taught today will lead you to a very clear conclusion, they both look the same. Thus, modern Ninpo Taijustu is a form of Kobudo or old martial arts. This fits in perfectly with the argument that battlefield martial arts are just a small section of a Ninjas needs, whereas now it is the main focus of todays Ninjutsu students. This still leaves the glaring question, what were the other sections that were taught? There are three major texts on Ninjutsu from the medieval period, the

18

Bansenshukai, the Shoninki and the Ninpiden. Out of over 20 volumes in the Bansenshukai, only 5 are about weaponry/tools, there are no references to martial arts in the Shoninki (Lit: True Ninja Account) and the Ninpiden deals with espionage tools. This information or lack of martial information is a startling indication that the arts of Ninjutsu were predominantly that of espionage and infiltration. We can postulate with reasonable faith that, using the original sources, to be a Shinobi, was not the way of learning Ninpo Taijutsu martial arts, but to understand how to infiltrate and disturb the enemy, to creep in and gain secrets and or to dispose of people, stores or buildings (by fire). Furthermore, there are in-depth references to psychology, meteorology, esoteric rituals, endurance testing amongst a range of non-martial pursuits. We have been led to believe that to learn the arts of the Ninja today, is to learn how to fight or kill with weapons. When in fact, life as a warrior, or for that matter a Ninja, during the feudal age, was to be able to fight and kill: a fundamental need. It is comparable to asking a modern day butcher about his trade and he then give you a 10 year lesson on sharpening knives. A fundamental section of his training, but it will not teach you how to be a butcher. Like Ninjutsu training, if all you do is learn how to fight, you have only ventured into the basics. Yet we have Ninjutsu Masters around the world claiming to teach Shinobi no Jutsu (the original way to pronounce Ninjutsu), and their curriculum is comprised only of fighting. I am yet to see the DVD on sale that is a Ninjutsu DVD that teaches meteorology or arson! What good would it do you to creep into a camp, kill

19

the guards and then not be able to set that camp on fire using the same stealth and efficiency used during infiltration? Erm, could someone lend me a match please?! This brings us to the point that, when you hear of Ninjutsu, you should not understand it as a selection of martial artists dressed in black making an investigation into body movement, no matter how skilled they are. I suggest that you see them instead as a selection of people studying Kobudo, old martial arts. Thus, when you think of the Ninja, consider the rigorous training and spectrum of abilities you would need to acquire in order to operate as a spy, an infiltrator, an arsonist, a meteorologist, a con-artist, a survival expert, a doctor, a disguise artist, a fighter, a horseman, an archer, a botanist and more than likely, a brutal and ruthless killer of men. Today we think of the Ninja as a spiritual warrior, but what we forget is that these were men of pure daring and capability, true warriors beyond that of most modern martial artists.

AFTERTHOUGHT I once had the honour of speaking with a SAS veteran of the Second World War. He was around 85, yet still recounted to me with disturbing clarity how he had killed men, many of them by infiltration and the knife. His eyes were that of those few men you occasionally come across in life that are truly dangerous. His eyes really lit up with killer instinct as he told me some of the Germans he killed had begged

20

to be left alive; he said that he had smiled when he told them that they were soldiers and should die with honour. No matter what style of martial artist you care to name, no matter if they are a world champion or a street fighter, I would dare any of them to face that shadow in the dark without fear. Imagine a man who out of nowhere grips you in his bare hands, and whilst forcing a dagger into your heart he tells you to die with honour. For me, that is what the Ninja is: a man of true daring.

Where did Ninjas come from? Some say they were born out of a political need in the region around Iga. Others claim that they were brought from abroad into the land of Japan. These are the two main arguments for the origins of the Ninja but most people side on the idea that the Ninja were imported weapons from China who took up residence in the mountains of Iga. From a historical context it is practically impossible to trace the movements of possible Ninja from China to Japan and therefore completely pointless in trying to verify this using demographic movement patterns. What we do know for 100% certain is that the

21

Chinese did not use the word Ninja or the different variations of the Chinese ideograms that the Japanese used to say Shinobi. Thus, some people claim that as there is no mention of the Ninja in the Chinese documents that we have left, they did not therefore exist there. However, this may not be the case, as we have good evidence in another document to tell us that the Ninjas did in fact start in China. The author of the Bansenshukai and the author of the Shoninki state without hesitation that the origins for the Ninja were in fact China and the adoption of Ninjutsu was taken from the teachings of the Chinese classics. The Bansenshukai goes into much more depth about this subject and says that the origin of Ninjutsu goes back to 2850 BC and is paraphrased in the Chinese classic The Art of War by Sun Tzu. The author of the Bansenshukai feels that Ninjutsu was used throughout the ancient Chinese world and that it was always there, he even goes on to mention why they changed the reference-name of the Ninja time and time again. He states that the names of the Ninja change as the skills in Ninjutsu adapt to the political situation around them, thus they change their name to reflect the time. He also states that the reason that they, the Ninja of Japan use the word Ninja or Shinobi in the format of the classic ideogram of a Heart and a Blade is to denote that a Ninja should have a heart as hard as a blade of iron and thus will be able to achieve anything. On the other hand, we cannot gain any information about the type of Ninjutsu that was performed when referred to as Shinobi.

22

There is always one element that we have to contend with when dealing with historians who are actually a part of history themselves. They could be wrong! Modern academics understand that those in history did not have access to the bigger picture nor to the details that we often acquire through, for instance, archaeology. The Ninja from Koka who wrote the Bansenshukai, referencing some very real books of his time (some now lost), tells a compelling history and appears to be the only enduringly reliable authority we have on the history of the Ninja. So we have two alternatives in discussing the origin of the Ninjas, firstly, it is quite possible that the Ninja were from China or that at least their skills were, it is not only probable but also likely. However, we must also consider the view that the Ninja may have claimed to be from China because China was seen as more cultured from the Japanese point of view, thus they were giving themselves validation by such claims. We can say with some certainty that the art of Ninjutsu (in some form) has been in existence for at least 2000 years and that it may have started in China where the Ninja were called Kan . From there Ninjutsu probably moved to Japan either through the study of military classics or through the movement of people. What is certain is that an art form was perfected in Japan, and the words Shinobi and Ninja became the main names at the start of the Edo period. However this marks the beginning of the end of the Ninja, although the Edo period has been resurrected by modern media as their golden age.

23

THE NAMES FOR NINJA USED IN CHINESE HISTORY This following list states the words used in China that the author of the Bansenshukai believes to be Ninja and why he believes them to be so. Also it is an oversimplified list; it has been made that way so that it is a gate into the world of the Chinese Ninja and thus the origins of the Japanese Ninja. Therefore treat this list as an opening to what could be a very large area. The meanings are very basic understandings and are there so that you can get a feel of what the basic names mean. To do a full investigation into these names would be a much larger project. Kan Meaning: Gap or estrange Kan is the main name used for Chinese Ninja and the basic meaning is a gap or opening that one uses, such as a weakness in the enemy or to abuse the information you have in order to gain an opening. Thus they used to be called Kanjin or people of the opening. On the other hand if you break the ideogram down it means sun coming through a gate and thus it can be interpreted as sunlight entering through even the smallest gap of the enemies defences. Lastly, it can also mean estrange, that is to estrange the enemy lord from his people, -his retainers and his neighbouring warlords and to leave him helpless. If you are looking for the equivalent word for Ninja in the Chinese texts then look no further than Kan.

24

Kancho Meaning: Detect an opening or to spy in general This is quite straight forward and simply means those who detect. Connected with the important word Kan. Cho Meaning: to spy or detect This is quite straight forward and simply means those who detect. Connected with the important word Kan. Kojin Meaning: Person who goes A simple if philosophical name referring to the world of the Ninja. Saisaku Meaning: To make up in detail The basic need in Ninjutsu is the need for excellent recording of details, as we have seen in all the manuscripts a Ninja is the ultimate collector of details! Yushi Meaning: playing warrior This is quite an interesting take on Ninjutsu. Here it appears to mean to play, seem stupid or even mean a base character. In reality it holds a very esoteric message about the plots behind each mission and being able to play the situation in a way you want to.

25

Yutei , Meaning: To play and detect Again, this is not difficult to link with the ways of Ninjutsu.

REFERENCES TO THE WORLD OF THE NINJA USED IN JAPANESE HISTORY Kansai Meaning: Wicked The ideogram used here insinuates it is a man who uses evil or wickedness to gain what they need and thus we have the origin to the dark and evil image of the Ninja. Kyoudan Meaning: Kyo to give a feast, dan means to talk. To feast someone so that he will give away secrets. Mitsumono Meaning: three men Takeda Shingen divided his Ninja into three groups as part of his tactics, thus we get three men. Nokizaru Meaning: A monkey in the eaves This is possibly the most image-conjuring name for the Ninja as this gives us the classic picture of the climbing expert hiding in the roof vaults and listening to those secret conversations. There is another theory

26

that Nokizaru comes from another name for the Yellow Emperor of China, who is said to have used spies. Rappa , Meaning: to confuse and waves or break This may have been merely a phonetic transference and not a Kanji or ideogram representation. In some ancient writings there is a mention of those thieves called Rappa used in the employ of warfare. Also in a famous account of the Hojo clan, it says enigmatically that there were scoundrels called Rappa who were thieves but at the same time not thieves and that these Rappa were employed widely by Daimyos (lords). Suppa , Meaning: transparent or look or go through and waves. Suppa was also used to mean scoundrels such as pickpockets, thieves, frauds. But it is unknown which use is older.

27

If we were to ask the question on the street, what was a Ninjas Job, what answer would be given? A high percentage would surely say assassin. A few people might say spy. But what was the job of a Ninja? Again we must first qualify two things:

1. A Ninja is not a set figure but a person trained in needed skills across a thousand year history

2. The ideogram for Ninja is a blade above a heart and can mean either, perseverance or to creep in/ adept of stealth.

This does not mean that the Ninja did not perform assassinations but it does mean that a Ninja is not an assassin by nature. The job description for a Ninja would be quite long and detailed but the word assassin would only be a minor part. As a Ninja your job would be set into these four areas:

28

THE SHINOBI CV FUNDAMENTAL NEEDS: To be able to survive in the wild using bush craft, be an adept in the martial arts and the use of weaponry to a master level, to be able to swim and stay submerged for extended periods, to understand basic chemistry for the use of explosives, understand medicine and herbal law as well as toxins, to know many geographical areas and their customs, tourist points and dialects, to be able to impersonate priests and their rituals, musicians and street entertainers etc, to be psychologically sound and not to reveal stress under high pressure (hence the name perseverance), to have fire-starting skills and understand the principles of arson, the understanding of written codes and code breaking and to have an understanding of meteorology. INFILTRATION NEEDS: To understand or glean passwords and secret codes so as to gain entry into forbidden places, to be able to adopt a trade and infiltrate yourself into a community, to deal with undercover stress and work in enemy territory, to have an in-depth knowledge of conversation and police style investigation and conversation tactics, be adept at burglary, con-artistry and forgery. STEALTH NEEDS: To understand and be able to use an array of breaking-and-entering tools, to travel across mountains and forests without being identified, to

29

have the ability to free-climb and scale walls with the aide of climbing equipment, to understand the principles of camouflage and moving in shadows, the ability to move with stealth, to be able to work in teams, to understand the sleeping patterns of humans and animals, to be able to identify a false sleeper and be able to understand where to tread on wooden structures to create the least amount of friction to have an understanding of assassination skills and the ability to kill with the minimum noise and effort. PHILOSOPHICAL NEEDS: To have an understanding of Zen and esoteric Buddhism (including the infamous Kuji-in), to be proficient in physiognomy (the ability to read a persons personality via their facial or body types, a skill now being reinvestigated by the scientific world), to have a full understanding of charms, spells for destruction or pacification and ritualistic magic, to have some understanding of fortune telling and palmistry, high level psychology, to be a cold reader and to have a stout heart and the ability to deal with stress under life-threatening situations. This would be the job description for a Shinobi Soldier, and if you are a Ninjutsu student you need to seriously ask yourself am I learning these things? And if not why not? After reading all of the above we can start to get an understanding of the extremities that a Shinobi would be able to go to, we start to understand why they are renowned as they are. We

30

can start to see the truth behind the myth. People on the whole are in mixed awe and submerged envy at any of humanitys great warriors of history: the Spartans, the Samurai, the Vikings and so on, -people who were feared have always been given fame and respect, and it is no different for the Ninja. We all wish we could be like this, some of us know we could be if we were brought up in that world, alas we have not, so we can do the next best thing and that is study and emulate. If as humans we can master even a portion of what the Ninja were, we will be great people in our age, but then people may ask what is the point? But I would reflect, then what is the point of life, if not to excel in all things and enrich the human mind and make your heart stronger.

KOKA & IGA: THE MISCONCEPTION

Throughout most of the Ninja media is the very common understanding that all Ninja come from either Koka or Iga and that the two Ninja factions were in fact at constant war. One can see this warfare is constant in the imaginary image of the Ninja. The Japanese film Shinobi portrays this war as its central theme as does the animation version entitled Basilisk. It seems to be a modern myth that these two Ninja

31

clans were at war and that they had a deep routed blood hatred for each other. We know little of both Koka & Igas formations and their connection with Ninjutsus origins. But what we do know is that these two places were the most famous of all the Ninja clans. People do not realise that Ninja clans existed all over Japan and are recorded. However, Iga is attributed to the start of Ninjutsu which is a fact that we can neither prove nor disprove. What is concrete is that the Iga clan were without doubt classed as the premiere Ninjutsu clan, even to the point that one name for the Ninja is Iga no Mono or Men of Iga. Geographically the two areas border on each other and or the same area in all but name.

KOKA

For years now we have always known Koka by the word Koga, which is the common English spelling. However, the difference between the Japanese Ka and Ga is almost insignificant to the English ear. The reason that I have chosen to change the spelling is the fact that Koka is technically the correct version and the aim of Shinobi Soldiers is to investigate the truth of the Ninja. Koka is in the modern day city of the same name which is found in the Shiga prefecture on the main island of Honshu.

32

SHIGA PREFECTURE

KOKA

33

The most famous Koka Ninja was a man called Fujibayashi Yasutake who wrote the major Ninjutsu manual called the Bansenshukai. When he signs his masterwork on Ninjutsu he signs it in the following manner:

Enpo 4 (1676) Summer

Written by Koshu Kokagun Retired Warrior, Fujibayashi Yasutake

You may be drawn to the word Kokagun, this means of the area of Koka. Interestingly the towns of Iga and Koka argue among themselves as to where Fujibayashi Yasutake was from. Fujibayashi Yasutakes house is technically in Iga but he signs himself as Koka, thus the seeds of argument were sown. However, what the modern people of Koka and Iga do not know is that once there bonds of friendship between the two people.

IGA Iga, like Koka, is a mountainous area and is special in Japanese history. Up until the Iranki wars, that was the defeat of the Iga clans by Oda Nobunaga, Iga was a separate state external to Japanese central rule. They were a self governing body of mountain families who are believed to be Ninja families. Iga is found in modern day Mie prefecture and is home to the official Iga Ninja museum.

34

MIE PREFECTURE

IGA

35

ONE PEOPLE AND ONE NINJA? The problem with the warring Ninja factions theory of the modern media is that it only shows one side of the story. We have been led to believe that on sight Koka and Iga Ninjas would kill each other. This is simply not true. While we assume there was some confrontation between the two, there is another side to the coin. We have historical evidence that there were indeed bonds of friendship between them. One big question is when these two clans were actually at war with each other. Were they at war constantly but held bonds of friendship when the province was threatened? Or were their intermittent periods of peace where they became friends? Whatever the answer, our investigation shows that there was an element of trust and friendship between the two.

THE EVIDENCE THE SCROLL

36

Dr Nakashima owns the scroll Shinobi Ichiryu which in rough translation means The Ninja scroll of Secret Letters which has a very interesting ending. The signatures at the end name two Ninjas as the authors. They are:

Kido Hachirouemon of Iga Daizaburo Kitaemon of Koka

Thus, we see (opposed to the classic image of Ninjas killing each other) instead the two factions writing books together probably over lots of sake! Also, in the Bansenshukai it says that the Ninja Kido of Koka, was one of the top 11 Ninjas whose best skill was creeping in at night.

THE PROMISE There is a sacred oath taken by the people of Iga and Koka, a promise that affirms their friendship beyond doubt. The following extract is taken from the Shoninki manual of 1681. Later, the people from Kga , next to Iga followed this path of Ninjutsu and having made the oath of Ichigun Ichimi , the friendship oath of one district and one band, joining the people together, they went out expansively to various provinces to utilize their skills. Thus, being universally recognized as the premier Shinobi they exchanged a firm written form

37

of oath which says If I come to where you are, you should show me everything of your province, and if you come to where I am, I will show you everything about my province. By doing this, it is said they should show that their family tradition was extraordinarily exquisite and outstanding and also show the marvel of their tradition of Ninjutsu, at its best.

SHARING INFORMATION

Interestingly, the historical manuals tell us of one trick to get the information you need if you wish to infiltrate an enemy stronghold. They say as a Ninja you should visit the Ninja clan of that area and ask for the information, even if that Ninja clan are in the employ of the enemy! It just goes to show the strength of the bond they must have had if they were willing to sell out their own employers. So there you have it, sometimes at war and sometimes not and sometimes one people, one land and a secret spy network that went beyond the imagination!

38

39

If we list the Ninja weapons we commonly see in the media, we get:

1. The Ninja Sword 2. The Throwing Star 3. The Hand and Foot Claws 4. Hidden Weapons 5. Caltrops 6. Chain length 7. Hand Held Bar 8. Finger Rings With Spikes 9. Rice Flails 10. Sickles with Chains 11. Claws that attach to the Backs of hands 12. Knuckle Dusters

Now if we ask how many of the above weapons were actually used by the Ninja, the answer would be difficult since, as we have discussed, the concept of

40

Ninja is not so easy to pin down. Thus, if we restate the question as to who else used the above weapons? then we may get a better picture of who is using what!

THE NINJA SWORD

As for as the modern understanding of the Ninja sword goes, it did not exist, we know the Ninja preferred the O-wakazashi with a longer cord, but so did many other people. So the Ninja sword is a dead start, this is not a Ninja weapon.

41

THE THROWING STAR

The Shuriken is by far the most iconic Ninja weapon there is and by far the most misrepresented. We have been told by some masters that the Ninja star was a secret weapon. This is simply not the case, there were many samurai martial arts schools who taught the art of shuriken-jutsu. Shuriken schools are not even attributed to the Ninja in any way whatsoever, you will find no historical document telling you how the Ninja used a shuriken or that they were used by them alone. However, we can be quite certain that the Shinobi did in fact use them at least, as they were fairly commonplace. Therefore, is the shuriken a Ninja weapon? No. Did they use it?Yes.

42

THE HAND & FOOT CLAWS

These are the most difficult Ninja items to identify, as the origins of these weapons seem quite obscure and thus no firm statement can be made about these, they are discussed more in the climbing section.

HIDDEN WEAPONS

The moment you are told that a knife-fan, cane-sword or any other type of hidden weapon is a secret Ninja weapon politely thank the person who is talking to

43

you and leave. Hidden weapons are a worldwide certainty, most cultures with laws have them, the samurai did use them and there is no evidence to say that the Ninja invented them, any so-called master who has published or spoken of them as Ninja weapons is a fraud.

CALTROPS

These small weapons were definitely used by the Ninja, in fact they crop up more then most. However, they were also used by western knights in the middle ages to bring horses down. So, were they invented by the Ninja?No.

44

CHAIN LENGTH

Chain weapons in any form were well-spread around the east and in Japan, it is as simple as that. They were used by many and were most certainly not invented by the Shinobi.

HANDHELD BAR

This weapon, held in the hand and used to strike nerve points was used by several Jujutsu schools and were definitely not a Ninja invention.

45

FINGER RINGS WITH SPIKES

Known as horned rings these were rings with teeth on the outside to help create pain during a grab. They were used by some Jujutsu schools and have a vague but unproven connection to the Ninja.

RICE FLAILS

46

If any one tells you that this is a Ninja weapon ask them where the English flail weapon comes from? I say this simply because these were farming tools, they have only been attached to the Shinobi by common default.

SICKLES WITH CHAINS

Again, this farming implement was a farmers weapon, unless it was the purpose-built version that came about later in the Samurai age, then it was a warriors weapon. We do know that the Ninja used this type of kama as it is mentioned by Hattori Hanzo.

47

CLAWS THAT ATTACH TO THE BACKS OF HANDS

Again a very good contender for the Ninja weapon but also obscure in origin.

KNUCKLE DUSTERS

48

Bands of iron wrapped around the fist to help you smash skulls, yes this was used by many people in many cultures. A Ninja weapon?No! Now we have established that there are possibly very few or no weapons that can be classed as Ninja weapons, we have to ask the question, what weapons did a Ninja use?The answer must be- all of the above! The debate here is NOT what weapons a Ninja used but what weapons are classed as Ninja weapons? Weapons are simply weapons and a Ninja is a form of spy/007 figure. Weapons were used and not created by the Ninja, we know that the weapons above were around in Japan at the time and that most were used by a lot of different people (especially the allegedly definitive Ninja weapon: the shuriken). Therefore, if someone is telling you that this is a secret Ninja weapon, or this is how a Ninja used it then they are wrong. If they are saying a Ninja may have used this, then that would be more correct. On the whole we do not know how Ninjas trained for combat, we simply know that they utilized the tools around them.

49

The question of who could carry a sword in Japan is always answered with the resounding chorus of The Samurai! This is not only incorrect but completely misleading. The Samurai have a thousand year history and it is a common misconception that only they could wear swords and only people born into a Samurai family could be Samurai. We know that in the early periods almost anyone could become a Samurai, you just had to take that path. It is only later in history do we get the Samurai becoming a hereditary institution. The greatest example of this was Toyotomi Hideyoshi. He was born a peasant but became the ruler of Japan and, ironically, it was he that segregated the Samurai from the peasants by the disarmament of the farmers in 1588. Furthermore, it is only after the 1500s that the ruling class started to control the swords people wore to denote what rank they were. This truly came into effect during the Edo period of peace, which also correlates to the decline of the Ninja. Therefore, we must understand, at the height of the Ninjas golden years (pre-Edo period

50

before AD 1600), each and every person could carry weapons if they so wished, it was only the type of weapon that was restricted towards the end. Fujinoisshuishi Masatake, a Ninja from the 1600s tells us that one of the main tools a Shinobi should use is the O-Wakazashi, or short sword, the O means larger, so the O-Wakazashi is a short sword that is just inches shorter then the Katana or long sword. He says this is the best sword to carry is it is the most common. As we know the Samurai carried two swords we can take this to mean that the average Joe carried a short sword for protection. When we look at martial arts today, we concentrate on grappling or knock-outs and such. Imagine a world where most people carried a 50 cm hatchet or blade! Try to envisage a street-fight where two aggressors are hacking fillets of flesh off each other, or severing main arteries and blood is gushing down the street. Add to this image a Ninja, trained since birth at fighting with blades. Can we truly comprehend what it means to train day in and day out since birth with a blade? The only comparison that we have is a Chinese gymnast, taken to a camp at a young age and trained and trained. Imagine what skill a person would have with that upbringing, not only that but the probable fact that they may not care if you die? What kind of mentality are we dealing with? How do you grapple that? Would you cheer if you had struck a blow? Perhaps you had broken a rib?Or maybe you died in the street pumping blood on the pavement as they cut off your limbs? We do not laugh or jibe at knife-stabbings in the west. We do not laugh when

51

people are attacked by a gang with knives; I know no martial arts school that does not warn about the dangers of knives. So why then do people mock traditional arts, when the aggressor is no longer a yob with a knife, but a trained warrior with a bigger one!? This is a simple fact, that we must understand that in our past, both at home and in Japan, it was not illegal to carry weapons. The illegality of carrying weapons is in fact only a modern concept. That is why we have given birth to the Sports Martial Arts and their false bravado. No man withstands a cut-out throat, no man can argue with a knife in the ribs, no matter how big or strong you are. In this sense we must start to see the Ninja again, not only as highly trained and highly disciplined figure, but a figure who would put real fear in you. People say, I would not like a punch off Mike Tyson but I say I would prefer that to a Ninja with a short sword. One I may survive, the other I would surely die. Violence in our time and during that of the historical Ninja has changed dramatically. This leads to the Ninja sword the classic straight bladed weapon with a square guard. Did the Ninjas have a sword? Yes, they did, as we have seen. What made them different to other swords? Not much. There is reference to swords having air-holes in the scabbard for people to breathe through, but on the whole we know that they carried the O-Wakazashi to blend in. The myth may come from the fact that they would have used lower quality swords to not risk taking any family heirloom on a mission. After a conversation with Dr Steven Turnbull, he assured me that the archetypal Sword of Japan is often thought of

52

as being the most well-made, but what we all too often fail to consider is that even in the feudal times of Japan you could pick up a lower quality sword, in fact they were made in the thousands. It was common for most people to have a lower quality sword. Thus, the issue of a Ninja owning a low quality sword, this would be so it was ready to be thrown away. Not because they made them that way, but because they needed to fit in with society. Imagine being dressed as a traveller with a top notch weapon. Its like a beggar on the street having a tailored suit on. In summary, we know that the Ninja carried a sword, we know he would be deadly with it, he would carry it openly and he used it as a tool to climb and to break and enter and to fight with. Did he have a straight-bladed purpose-made weapon? Probably not. Was he deadly with 50 cm of steel in his hand?A resounding yes!

The Shuriken or Throwing Star as it is better known is fixed within the iconic image of the Ninja. As discussed, the Shuriken is not a Ninja weapon per se. We must be clear on this, there is no evidence for

53

Shuriken as an umbrella term being an invention of the Ninja. This is a vast misconception. However, that does NOT mean that Ninjas did not use the Shuriken. Be clear on this next fact, there is no evidence for the Ninja inventing or being the only users of Shuriken! But what we can be logically sure of is that Ninjas would have used them. So why add them here if this is an investigation into the Ninja? The Shuriken has been inserted here because people not only have the misconception about the relationship between the Shuriken and the Ninja but also have a great misconception about the Shuriken themselves.

ETYMOLOGY

The word Shuriken can be translated as blade hidden inside the palm or hand and can also be read as Te-no-ura. However we can find 5 other examples of Chinese ideograms that can be read as Shuriken. The word Shuriken may have been the most used but there are other examples of words used for Shuriken that could have been used in its place. Further to this you will sometimes hear the words Shuriken-Jutsu. This simply means the art of throwing a hidden blade from the palm or hand.

TYPOLOGY

If you ask an Englishman what shape a Shuriken is they will most likely say star-shaped, if you ask a

54

Japanese martial artist he may say like a dart. So why the difference? Well, the Shuriken can be broken up into a massive amount of variations however there is no room here and thus, we can break it down into two major forms.

BO-SHURIKEN

Bo Shuriken are straight bladed Shuriken that come in different forms and cross-sections. They are generally not flat but three dimensional.

SHA-SHURIKEN

Sha-Shuriken are Wheel Shuriken and are what we as westerners class as the iconic Shuriken when we use the name. These are generally flat spinning plates.

55

OTHER EXAMPLES OF SHA-SHURIKEN

MANJIGATA SHURIKEN

A FORM OF HAPPOGATA

JUJI SHURIKEN

56

WHO USED THEM?

Samurai martial arts schools often place Shuriken as part of their curriculum for use alongside other arts such as Kenjutsu. There is nothing to say that they are not or were not secret weapons and each school kept them under wraps but the point is that samurai schools also had Shuriken Jutsu as one of their skills and thus they are not a Ninja weapon. . .

ACCURACY

Did you know that a Ninja can extinguish a candle flame with a thrown shuriken? Well thats the urban myth anyway! But what is the reality of the ability of the Ninja when using this weapon? There is no way to tell how good the Ninja were with these thrown weapons and that is because there are too many variables. What we can say is that some would have been good, some would have been okay and some would have been outstanding. This is based on general ability across the human species. What we can say is that someone who practices with them relentlessly will become good, a good thrower would become expert and then there are those who would be so natural that they became throwing masters. How do we know this? Easy, look at the skills of the professional knife-throwers of today. You can find vast examples of highly skilled blade-throwers in every country simply add this skill to the historical setting of the Shinobi.

57

EFFECTS AND DAMAGE

Before you think about the damage that a Shuriken could do you must first understand the difference between historical and modern types of Shuriken. Do not fall into the trap of imagining the modern Shuriken as the same as its ancestor. These cheap and lightweight blades are in no way a comparison to the heavy iron blades of the past. You must imagine thickset and heavy duty blades which are larger than the new versions. Now ask yourself if you would like a 6 to 10 inch blade through your neck, in your stomach, through your foot or even through your eye and into your brain? You only have to see a blade-thrower of today launch knives with accuracy into wood to understand what that would be like when hitting the soft parts of your body. Most people have played down the damage of a Shuriken and call them distraction weapons. If a nail in your eye or stomach is only distracting I applaud you!

IN REALITY

So, we know that the Ninja did not invent the weapon and we know that the Shuriken was used by many people but that means that the Ninja probably would have used them, as they would have made good shock weapons. Maybe we can envisage the situation where an expert blade-thrower is part of the Ninja ambush team set up in the woods to stop other Ninjas infiltrating their lords camp. A man runs past but does not have the password, with a flick of the wrist

58

the blade-throwing Shinobi sends a shuriken into the face of the enemy and the other Shinobi cut him down? This would be as close to the reality of the Ninja as we may get.

59

60

Did a Ninja disappear in a cloud of smoke? Could they throw handmade grenades around a corner and shock a group of Samurai? Do these iconic images have any reflection in the shadows of history? Well, not only do these popular images of the Shinobi have reality within these shadows, they are actually more solid than a castle wall! One can divide the Ninjas use of fire into two main areas, flames used for torches, arson and infiltration, and fire used as an explosive. Fire-power as used in projectile weapons will not be discussed in this section.

61

GRENADE!!!

1 Yes the Ninja not only knew about black powder but they had hand grenades, land mines and nail bombs. The Gunpo manual which holds three scrolls based on the Ninja states the following: This [grenade] is used on a night attack by throwing

it where many enemies are gathering in order to create a commotion among them.

(1615) The slick image of some Samurai hanging around on watch, waiting by the fire for the cold to pass, suddenly thrown over by a Shinobi grenade and to be cut down by an attacking force is an image that is put forward by modern media and is one of the only factors of the Ninja that a modern audience has not got wrong. If this is not enough we also have the other image of the Ninja escaping into the night in a

1 Image taken from the 1615 Gunpo manual

62

puff of smoke, and to help us see if this is true we have the following quote from the same source as above: it [the grenade] should be made of clay and as thin as unglazed earthenware. Put strong gunpowder

and iron filings, fine sand and so on and then place the mixture between the two pieces. You use it by

throwing it where the enemies are gathering. Also it is good in the case that you need to flee very quickly

from a Shinobi mission.

(1615) Where there is fire, there is smoke and thus there would be a Ninja escaping within its cloud. Further to this amazing fact we see that the Shinobi had a form of landmine that once tread upon exploded and damaged the area and people around, made from thin bamboo, straw mats and packed with gunpowder, this incredible weapon shows us that the Ninja were extremely expert explosive technicians and that they were possibly at the forefront of the firework industry.

63

FIRE, FIRE, FIRE!!! How would a Ninja use fire? Most people consider the Ninja to stand in front of flames making mystical hand signs and showing an esoteric silhouette. Of course any real enthusiast would have a different idea but what does history tell us about these architects of the flame? A Ninja would use fire for the following reasons:

For arson For warmth For signalling For infiltration

ARSON

It was important, as the scrolls tell us, that a Ninja should know the time so that he and his squad would be able to set fire to a camp or castle at the same instant. It appears that setting fires and arson were a fundamental aspect of the Ninjas way of life.

WARMTH

Although we all think Ninjas have the skin of a rhino and that the simply laugh at the cold, Im afraid to say, they were human and had human needs and warmth is a big need in the life of a man running around in the woods at night waiting to set fires. We do know that the Shinobi would set fire to the ground

64

and cover it over to keep warm at night, have fires and watch fires to look out for the enemy. It is said in the Gunpo that a Ninja should always carry embers of ash in a holder so that a fire is never far away. Alongside this we know that the Ninja also had quick-start ignition power so that they could ignite warmth at will.

SIGNALLING

Most of the fire signalling information in the historical texts comes in the form of smoke signals (which mainly tell of using wolf droppings) and rarely in flames themselves. The only main time that fire is used as a signal is that of the thrown fire arrows, which are launched just before an attack, in unison with a war cry and the Ninja descend on the unsuspecting victims!

INFILTRATION

Infiltration is where we possibly find the most references to the use of fire. You would expect the silent Ninja to be covered in shadow and not using fire to infiltrate their ways into enemy territory. However a lot of the historical information dedicated to the flame is used to give information on various types of torches. We find torches that last 12 miles for those long journeys in the mountains, thus if you knew the distance you knew the amount of torches needed. Add to that we find tree bark torches for

65

those emergency situations, then waterproof torches that will stay lit through rain storms and river crossings. Further to this, and very surprising, is the fact that a Ninja would spark up a small hand held tree bark torch to look into windows and into keyholes! It seems unbelievable to us but it does appear that a Ninja felt safe enough to light up and illuminate the world around them while on what we would consider to be an In-Nin mission, that is to say- infiltration in the dead of night. Thus, we can now understand that a Ninja would use fire to blow up their enemies through land mines, grenades and nail bombs allowing them to disappear in a puff of smoke or kill enemies in a very modern way. Further to that we can see the Ninja running through the mountains with waterproof torches in hand, looking through key holes and windows or launching burring arrows to signal the all-out attack!

The Ninja scaling a wall, windswept and catlike in their ability, -true or false? Firstly, asking a question such as could all Ninjas climb like a cat, is

66

completely flawed. That is like asking can all people in the British intelligence network speak Russian? Otake Sensei of the Katori Ryu and the author of the 1615 Gunpo scrolls tell us that people have differing specializations and that certain sections of the Ninjutsu community did different things. Both of the masters mentioned above talk about climbing and the reality of the Ninjutsu skills. Otake Sensei talks of their climbing in relation to trees and states that they had specialist climbers who could scurry around the treetops like squirrels going about their business. But he also talks about the reality of them needing to use wet lengths of cloth to throw and wrap around branches to get a purchase. The Gunpo goes into much more detail and talks about creating lifting baskets to haul up cliff faces. It states that a group of nimble or agile Ninjas could scale a cliff face and attach the equipment needed to get the lift secure and ready to be used. But keeping our feet on the ground we can see that the Ninjas, like the common window cleaner would simply use a ladder! To put a small amount of Ninja magic back into our understanding and idea of the Shinobi night infiltrator we should simply look to the Shoninki manual. It states that one of the main tools of the Ninja was in fact the Kaginawa or grappling hook! Both the Gunpo and the Shoninki state that a Ninja should infiltrate a place from the most difficult place. In the Gunpo it talks about the warring period, mentioning infiltration into castles and on steep mountain ridges, and of peace time the Shoninki refers to manor houses and such. Thus, we can certify that a Shinobi did send

67

aloft his grappling hook, scale castle walls and samurai estates and do all the things that we expect a Ninja to do! For a realistic understanding of the scope of the Ninja you need look no further than our own world. Look to the experienced free-climbers of today or the native tribes of the developing world and their ability to scale trees in search of foods and fruits. It is here that we can see the reality of the climbing level of the Ninja, a vast mixture of ability, from the fearless to the ground-bound!

SHUKO & ASHUKO

THE NINJA CLAWS

68

The iconic and now world famous Ninja hand-claws, sold in martial arts shops around the world and instantly recognisable as positively Ninja! But are they real? Would you believe that there appears to be only one museum in Japan that has them listed? The main museum in Iga-Ueno which is the officially recognised Ninja authority does not hold any of these so called Ninja claws. Also, to date there have been no examples of these said claws in any of the Ninjutsu manuals anywhere in academic records. Recognised Ninja researchers have so far never seen them in historical contexts, and no one who is a true martial arts researcher has been able to place them within the archaeological record. So you may ask, where is this museum that holds a pair of these Ninja claws? Well, would you be surprised to know that the only historical sets of these are in Ninja Land, and would you believe that the patron of this museum is none other then Dr Masaki Hatsumi! So the only man who claims the only and absolute lineage of Ninjutsu is the patron of the only museum to back up his claims that these claws are real Ninja weapons. Simply put, these weapons came into common discussion with his Ninja school, they are not found in any historical record and only his museum have a pair. So did these claws exist or not? The answer is we dont know, we can probably venture to say no, they are not historical tools. But just because they are not in the archaeological record does not mean they never existed. For now we are only left yet again with the

69

word of Dr Masaki Hatsumi...If that is something that can be trusted (no blasphemy intended). THE BANSENSHUKAI CLAWS Those of you who have read the Bansenshukai in the original Japanese will bring up the image of the foot-claws that are without doubt a version of Ashuko. The problem here is that Ashuko are said to be secret Ninja weapons/tools. In the Bansenshukai it says that these foot spikes are for crossing icy passages and are not referenced as climbing tools or as weapons. Further to this they are not named. We have evidence from all over the world that people used spikes on shoes to cross ice. Thus, were Ashuko, secret Ninja weapons? No, a version does appear in the documentation but in all probability they are well known and not specific to climbing or used as tools. Be careful here, it is probable that the Ninja could have used them as weapons, but again that does not make them secret Ninja weapons.

HISTORICAL NINJA CLIMBING TIPS We do know from the archaeological finds of small tips that the Ninja used, that they would place hair pins and spikes into the gaps within rocks and use them as footholds. They would also use u-shaped metal spike clamps that the Japanese builders of the day used and utilize them as spiked handholds.

70

In the Bansenshukai the author says if you use Ninjutsu with the wrong frame of mind you will simply be a thief. It is this message that tells us how much of the Ninjas job we do not include in our iconic image of the Shinobi and that is the ability for a Ninja to infiltrate a compound and break into a house. Because even though the concept of thievery within Ninjutsu was only meant to be done on a lord command, thievery still had to be done.

71

THE GRAPPLING HOOK

The Shoninki tells us that one of the primary tools of the Ninjas arsenal was the grappling hook. This simple tool was the key tool for a Ninja to break and enter.

THE SAW

There is a tool called a Tsuijiyaburi , this tool is for breaking through clay walls. The overall length is 33 cm and 15 -18cm wide. It has a saw edge around the rim. You can use this to break through a wall by cutting while rotating it until you reach the other side. This was used by the Ninja to tear away at the wattle walls and gain entrance into a compound.

72

Surprisingly the Ninja had a second simpler saw, this was used to open sliding doors or paper screens, you can then cut into the screen and then open it up allowing you to reach inside and open locks.

73

SCORING DEVICES

There is also another small tool that was used to score through wattle walls and create holes that the Ninja could use to aid them when they were breaking and entering. They would place the tool against the wall and spin it until it began to cut.

SELF PROTECTION

Interestingly there always seems to be a Ninja versus Ninja situation when we talk about the Shinobi. This is no different to the world of thievery. The Shoninki tells of how, if you suspect a Ninja to enter your

74

house you should double tie all the locks with thread. Then leave one door open so that it would entice the enemy Shinobi to come in that route and you can kill them as they crawl through the window.

CROW BARS

The Ninja had a small style crow bar that was used to take out wood joints and their fixings and also to break open doors and take them off their rails.

THE COLLAPSIBLE SAW

The Ninja had a folding saw. This is a typical Japanese tool and still used in traditional carpentry in Japan.

THIEVES?

So were the Ninja thieves or not? The answer to this question depends on many variables, such as, who is asking the question, of what time period are you talking etc. The original Japanese for Shinobi meant thief and stealing, which was later changed to mean a heart like an iron blade. The author of the Shoninki definitely says that he is not a thief, as to him a thief was called a Nusubito and that they were basically scum. He does say that they were skilled but that they had zero morals, thus were not Ninja and were simply thieves. Further, to this he states that the people in the early Edo period had changed the old word for Ninja Yato (leader in the Night) into Yato (thief in the Night) thus we can see how the view of the Ninja

75

changed from spy to thief back and forth, depending on the time and the geographical location and by who was saying it. However, there is no doubt that the Ninja was a form of thief. The archetypal Ninja was an infiltrator that would steal on the command of his superiors or when he needed proof of his missions success or when he needed to create cash flow to achieve the mission at hand and would never steal for simple monetary profit. How far that idealistic image went in the reality of historical events will never be known. However we can understand that the difference between Ninja and thief was down to the morals of the field agent themselves. As Nakashima Sensei said to me over tea in the mountains the line between Ninja and thief is a very thin one that is often crossed.

Have you seen the films with Ninjas holding snakes, milking poison and dipping their shuriken into a vile? Or even dipping darts for blowguns into poison. Also we can take the James Bond image from You only Live Twice where the Ninja slides poison down a thread to the 00 agent below. All of these things are

76

common to the Ninja identity, from the poison tipped blade to the fat lord dying from eating a deadly cake. But what is in fact the reality behind the poisons used by the Ninja, if any?

Firstly, let us say that poison is most definitely included in the Shinobi arsenal and is a factor that is taken seriously by the texts. However, it may not quite be in the style that we expect.

DOGS

In the manuals dogs are part of the poison story but only from the receiving end of the poison and not always from a poison you would expect. To defeat the humble guard dog, some Ninja were taught how to make iron-filling style food gifts for these cuddly creatures who would gulp them down with glee. Only to find that the iron fillings would rip open their internals and make the dog bleed to death and thus giving the Ninja an opportunity. Further to this they would feed the dog a plant based oil which would radically dehydrate it and leave the animal weak and in need of water and also without the ability to bark, thus giving the Ninja time to enter.

THE MAD HATTERS TEA PARTY

One of the best examples of poison comes from the Shoninki and involves swapping the poisoned cakes around the dinner table. Remembering that in the day

77

of the Shoninki the Ninja were a form of secret police, we are given a situation where a Ninja spy is sat at diner with the lord he is to visit and supposedly gain information from. Here we get a glimpse of an amazing image where the lord knows he has a Ninja in his midst and the Ninja knows that the lord knows he is a Ninja! The Shoninki warns that when at such a dinner you must eat only communal food and never taste anything that is served only to you. The same goes for drink, which is mainly communal anyway, but what takes the biscuit and I mean that literally, is the next point A Ninja who suspects that he is trying to be poisoned by his host should try, if he can to swap the cakes laced with poison that he has been given and somehow have them passed back to the lord or his retinue in secret, so that they choke to death on their own plans.

STRYCHNINE

The poison that the Ninja used during the above example is said to be a poison called Strychnine. The Strychnine tree (Strychnos nux-vomica L.) also

78

known as nux vomica, is an evergreen tree native to southeast Asia, a member of family Loganiaceae. It is from this tree that we presume the Ninja gathered a portion of their poison.

SNAKES There are tales of the Ninja using snakes tied to ropes, using their poison and generally making use of these deadly creatures. We can find a small amount of evidence from the Koga document Ohara Katsui Monjo about snakes but not enough. However if you look at the fauna of Honshu, the main island in Japan where the men of Iga or the Ninja lived there is one major suspect! The Mamushi is a kind of pit viper (Agkistrodon blomhoffi) that can kill a human with its

79

venom. Now we know from the historical documents that a Ninja would fit into a specialisation and one of those is said to be that of the animal handler. Thus it is possible that the Ninja snake stories have a base of truth set about them. Furthermore there is one more snake on Honshu that is also a suspect and that is the yamakagashi (Rhabdophis tigrinus). It has a small mouth and thus cannot attack large prey, however that does not mean a Ninja could not have obtained that poison. So, are the stories of poison and threads true? I think the reality was somewhere in between the myth and scepticism. Yes poisons were used, maybe even milked from snakes, and they were definitely fed to people. So we can rest in the knowledge that the Ninja were probably herbalists and snake handlers who had a good knowledge of poison and how to kill a person with it!

80

81

A major concept that is misunderstood by the average person in each household across the western world is the idea of an off the shelf Ninja suit, a karate style black suit with gauntlets and a two piece hood. To a non-martial artist this has become the image of the Ninja and has caused massive arguments within the Ninjutsu world, arguments that have become distorted and based on incorrect information. One side argues that the Ninja suit did exist and that the Ninja had a get up for their covert activities, while the other side of the argument is that the Ninja suit is a modern concept that was invented for the media during the Ninja boom of the 20th century and that suit was derived from Japanese theatre assistants. As

82

a historian, I cannot say with certainty what the reality was, but I can say that both arguments are illogical and are based on a misguided view of the concept of a suit or need for required equipment. It is clear to see that in essence and quite paradoxically that both are correct and both are wrong. To establish the correct ground to argue this on, we need to see the historical version of the Ninja suit and not the commercial one. To a martial artist or Ninja enthusiast a Ninja is a man clad in black, loose-fitting trousers stretched tight around the calf, straw sandals and split-toe slippers, a kimono jacket, hand gauntlets and face mask. This is the common, more correctly establish version of the Ninja in his covert activity suit. This being said we should now understand what is fundamentally incorrect about the argument itself. The main problem comes with the difference in common understanding, between a 21st century martial artist and that of a member of the feudal Japanese community. As a modern western person, we see the Ninja suit as exotic and unfamiliar, that is, it would be uncharacteristic to see one walking down the road. However, if you were in feudal Japan what parts of the Ninja suit would be out of place in the world you live in? If we can remove the common elements from our understanding of the Ninja costume, we can see what was unique about it.

83

SANDALS

Straw sandals are or were a common feature in medieval Japan, you can still buy these on market stalls today as a historical curiosity. Thus, would a Ninja wear them? Yes of course, these are a basic form of footwear.

84

TABI OR SPLIT-TOED SOCKS

As above, Tabi are still used in Japan and were universal footwear used in the past.

85

IGA-BAKAMA LOOSE-FITTING TROUSERS WHICH ARE STRETCHED TIGHT

AROUND THE CALF

There are many forms of dress in medieval Japan, but one of them was the Iga-Bakama. As described, they are basically, Hakama, or formal trousers with the exception that they are closed tight on the lower half of the leg. These trousers where used by farmers, travellers, workers etc. They were light and had a freedom of movement, making it easy to get around as appose to full Hakama.

86

JACKET

We are all familiar with the Uwagi jacket of Japanese tradition. Even though there are many versions and it is a science within itself, the principle is that a jacket wraps around the body leaving the iconic V shape, well-used and well understood on the streets of Japan.

GAUNTLETS OR TEKKO

These items are an unbelievable icon of the Ninja suit, that is, to a non-Japanese audience. These gauntlets were and are used across Japan, they are a basic piece of equipment for people working in the fields or travelling. These Tekko are still on sale all over Japan. This only leaves the Ninja mask, or Sanjaku Tenugui, even this is not unfamiliar in Japanese society. However, Natori Masazumi, a 17th century Ninja,

87

tells us that a Ninja, when doing covert operations should wear this mask or face cloth to hide who he is. He also states that you may need to use ink to darken your face. He also states that the colour of your clothes should be black, brown, navy blue, or a mix of red and black called suhozome. He states that the reason for this is not to do with stealth at night, as most people think, but as they are the most common colours and you will not be suspect by wearing them. It can now be seen that, the Ninja did not have a special suit to wear on operations but what they did have was set of clothes that allowed them to be discreet and with the addition of this face mask could quickly become disguised and ready for a stealth mission. Thus, the argument is that the Ninja did not have a suit to wear but did the Ninja look like the ideal that we have? Yes they did, to us theirs was a Ninja suit, a Ninja did look like we thought he did, climbing castle walls at night dressed in that now so iconic image. To a medieval Japanese person, there was a person wearing non-descript clothes and a face mask climbing up a wall and running through trees. Both are the same image but mean different things to each set of people. In the end all we need to truly get from the argument is that the image did not come from Japanese theatre and the Ninja did wear this iconic get-up, but on the other hand this get-up is not as specialised as we thought, as it was a common outfit. For the more romantic of us, it is nice to know that, once in a far away land, a long time ago, there was a

88

moon, a castle and a Ninja, just how we wished they were. Feel at ease knowing your childhood dreams are not shattered, and that a Ninja, might just be out there.

Going around the Ninja enthusiast community, there are a few theories of what colour the Ninja Suit is, they are as follows.

1. A Ninja Suit is black 2. A Ninja Suit is dark red 3. A Ninja Suit is white in the snow 4. A Ninja Suit is double sided 5. There is no such thing as a Ninja suit

Remembering that the reality of a Ninja suit was discussed earlier and keeping that lesson in mind we will exchange the term Ninja Suit for stealing-in attire to represent the clothes that they would wear during a bout of In-Nin, that is infiltration methods.

89

INFORMATION FROM THE SHONINKI BY MASAZUMI NATORI

Because the stealing-in attire of a Shinobi was basically the common clothes of the day with the addition of the mask, the Shoninki states that it should be one of four colours.

1. Black 2. Brown 3. Dark blue 4. A mix of dark red & brown

He then goes on to say that these colours are common in Japan and that wearing them will simply make you blend in with the crowd. He means that you will not be found out of place if someone stumbles up on while you are spying, there is no mention of them being better at night. The problem we have to highlight is that the Shoninki was written in 1681 and this was 80 years after the Tokugawa takeover and well into the era of peace. The needs of the Shinobi and their role changed during this social and political changeover. The Ninja of the Shoninki period was more akin to the secret police and their Ninjutsu was mainly Yo-Nin, which is the art of staying in plain sight while spying.

90

INFORMATION FROM THE GUNPO

The Gunpo has two major points that deal with the colour of the Shinobis stealing-in attire. The first is in the point that a Shinobi should wear fur garments as they spend a large portion of their time in the mountains, woods and sleeping under the stars. Through this we can see that the modern Japanese image of the Ninja, with his fur waistcoat is possibly more correct then the black clad Ninja at night. The second statement in the Gunpo is that during the full-moon a Ninja should wear all white and during no moon the Ninja operative should wear black. This came with no explanation, however, upon talking to Nakashima Sensei it is evident from his research that in an environment where artificial light is non-existent and when the moon is full, there is a white glow that surrounds the landscape. Thus, a Ninja wearing white who is in hiding would not show up as easily because wearing white would allow them to blend in with the moons highlights. To wear black in this situation would simple create a hole in the white blanket of light. Vice versa, when there is no moon in a purely light-free place then you have total or partial blackness and to wear black would render you as almost invisible. The Gunpo was first written in 1615 and was a form of collective information from the experiences of the warring time. Remembering that the use and role of a Shinobi was completely different during the warring

91

period we know that they did more of the In-nin activities. That is the classic infiltration sequences we see in films. This is where we see the iconic Ninja step up, here we have the Ninja creeping into castles, stealing from houses and generally being a Ninja in the modern understanding.

THE QUESTION REMAINS! What colour was a Ninja suit? Well we can now say, through this research that the colour of the Ninja suit changed depending on the period, activity and phase of the moon! The rules of colour for the attire a Shinobi should wear when stealing-in are as follows:

1. During the full-moon white 2. On a moonless night Black 3. At other times when you have to blend

in with the crowd brown, black, blue or dark red.

4. when crossing the mountains or hiding in the wilderness Fur

Remember, a Ninja suit is simply Japanese common streetwear until you put a face mask on (or over your head) and wearing the get-up does not make someone a Ninja, training in Ninjutsu is the fundamental element, not the costume.

92

93

There is one myth that Ninjas could dislocate all their joints and escape from any restraint by popping their joints in and out. From the start we must establish that it has been difficult to find any evidence for the ability to dislocate and relocate the joints of the human body. From the Shinobi to Harry Houdini there are only hints of this fabled ability but no proof as such. So from the start it is inconclusive if the Ninja could actually perform this feat. With escapologists keeping their secrets close and no apparent historical evidence from the manuscripts, this iconic image of the Ninja is a difficult one to break. Thus, we have to look at what we do know about actual historical information on the topic of how Ninjas used to get out of sticky situations.

ESCAPE TECHNIQUES THAT WE CAN SUBSTANTIATE

The following list can substantiate, confirmed by dates and from historical evidence, the main forms of escape that a Ninja had the ability to enact.

94

THE CLOUD OF SMOKE

The iconic image is that of a Ninja escaping in a cloud of smoke. As discussed before, the hand grenade and explosion is historical fact so we know that the boom of a bomb and the escaping Ninja was a definite in their repertoire.

THROWING STONES

The Shoninki tells us the trick of throwing a pebble down the opposite side of a roof when a Ninja has been spotted! That way the guards will follow the sound, thinking it as falling masonry disturbed during your escape. In reality you are on the other side and are away!

STEALING A TORCH

Interestingly, the Shinobi manuals of the Gunpo tell how you should keep your handheld torch away from the grasp of a prisoner as often they grab the torch and burn the guard to make good their escape!

COPYING THE INSECTS VOICE

The Ninjutsu oral traditions tell of how, when you have a Ninja for a prisoner you should listen out for animal noises. They say that Ninja communicate by mimicking the sound of insects and birds to hatch a plan of escape. Thus, if you have a Ninja in custody

95

and you hear these sounds you know that a Ninja is talking to an ally and planning his escape!

PUTTING OUT THE LIGHT

It appears that one version of escape was to extinguish the guards light and use the darkness to escape. This evidence comes up with a special torch invented by the Ninja so that it will not go out in wind or when a prisoner tries to put out the flame.

ESCAPING BONDS

There is one compelling piece of evidence that points to the possibility of the art of escapology in Ninjutsu. The Gunpo says the following:

If you capture prisoners, be sure not to let your guard down. It is often the case that they would

remove the neck brace or slip their bonds In Asia a type of wooden neck brace was used and a series of complex knots. The manual also says how you should not leave a prisoner alone, so that they will not have a chance to make their escape. This is the closest evidence that we have to the iconic body-popping Ninja!

TAKE THE OPPONENTS WEAPON

When approaching a prisoner you must not take a weapon with you but guard in numbers, as stealing

96

the guards weapon seems to be a trick used. Something you must know is that to tie a Samurai with bonds and rope was impolite, thus you could have unbound warriors in a room as a prisoner, so do not take a weapon in there!

SAMURAI SUICIDE

Remembering that a samurai could be a Ninja or use Ninjutsu we also have to consider that suicide was an option. The manuals tell us that a samurai should be kept in a cage or palanquin small enough to stop them from committing suicide.

THE ESCAPE ROUTE

One thing that comes up time and time again in the historical manuals is the concept of escape route. The best way to escape is to not be captured!!! That was the real Ninja ethos. A Ninja was taught to plan and plan again, and again his way out. If you know the way in, you had better know your way out, that is what the real escape trick of the Ninja was.

97

HOJOJUTSU THE JAPANESE ART OF TYING UP A PRISONER (ACCORDING TO RANK)

In the manuals it shows how a Ninja was taught (hojojutsu) knots and rope techniques to tie up an enemy with certainty. Just the simple existence of these sophisticated knots shows how conscious a custodian would have been of some prisoners ability

98

to escape. Thus, heavy measures would be taken to restrain a prisoner. Even to the point of using a captive to lead you on a night attack with the promise of life and gold!

The above image is a mouth gag from the Gunpo which was used to stop a prisoner shouting out and warning his friends about the attack. Alongside this he would be bound with knots and be retrained with sticks tied to his sides to stop him bending down whilst also having his feet bound, allowing for small movements. In conclusion, we can take it that the Ninja did have differing degrees of escape tricks but apart from the historically attested ones, we cannot be sure what their levels of skill were. However, logically we can say that each Ninja had a differing level of ability and that some may have been the Harry Houdinis of the

99

time and others who were done for if the enemy even got a whiff of them!

100

101

What is the difference between a 16th and 17th century Ninja? No this is not the start of a really bad martial arts joke, it is a question that requires a lengthy answer. First we have to do understand what the difference in the Japanese way of life between the 16th and 17th centuries actually was. If you were a Ninja in the 1500s you would be in the middle of the warring period. That was when Japan was separated into warring factions and at the head of each faction was the leading warlord. Grouped in to basic conglomerates the warlords would fight back and forth for power, sending army against army, turning on each other and generally keeping the country in a state of constant war. Now, if you were a Ninja after 1603 and especially if you were alive later in the century you would enjoy the harmony of living in the Tokugawa era or as we now know it, the Edo-period. That is when that mighty old warlord, Lord Tokugawa went back on his word of protecting the next boy ruler and basically took all of Japan for himself. Now after things settled down, the country was held in totalitarianism and under the iron fist of

102

the Tokugawa it was brought into an era of peace. So, what is the difference between a 16th & 17th century Ninja?

THE 16TH CENTURY NINJA

When looking at the job of a Ninja we now understand th