SHAREBOX on-line trainingsharebox-project.eu/sharebox01/files/2019/08/P3.-SHAREBOX_Evalu… · SHAREBOX on-line training Evaluating Industrial Symbiosis Opportunities (EVALIS Service)

SHAREBOX on-line training

Evaluating Industrial Symbiosis Opportunities (EVALIS Service)and Cost Allocation in Industrial Symbiosis Relations (COSTIS Service)

www.sharebox-project.eu Copyright © SHAREBOX Consortium 2

Introduction: Industrial Symbiosis (IS) Phases

Identification

Evaluation

Implementation

Administration

SHAREBOX decision support tools developed by the University of Twente provide two services that support firms in:

• the Evaluation phase (EVALIS Service)

• and the cost-allocation process in the Implementation Phase (COSTIS Service).


IS Evaluation

• An IS opportunity can be implemented in various forms:

• Using different modes of transportation

• Using different recycling technologies

• Picture on the left: https://www.tibco.com/blog/2015/08/25/en-route-keys-to-value-driven-iot-deployments-in-transportation-and-logistics/

• Picture on the right: https://salesscripter.com/a-great-question-to-ask-your-manager-or-direct-reports/

• Which implementation is promising?

https://www.tibco.com/blog/2015/08/25/en-route-keys-to-value-driven-iot-deployments-in-transportation-and-logistics/

https://salesscripter.com/a-great-question-to-ask-your-manager-or-direct-reports/


What is EVALIS?

Single vs. Shared Mode

How to Use EVALIS

The EVALIS ServiceEvaluation Tool for Industrial Symbiosis


An Industrial Symbiosis (IS) opportunity between two firms can be implemented in

various forms, for instance, as a result of using different modes of transportation or

recycling technologies.

EVALIS (Evaluation Tool for Industrial Symbiosis) is a decision support tool for

evaluating potential industrial symbiosis opportunities.

It supports firms whether, and based on what priority, to consider an opportunity by

ranking potential implementations with respect to obtainable cost reductions.

Firm managers can either use it individually, in the single mode, or together with

their IS partner, in the shared mode.

What is EVALIS?


In the single mode — where one firm enters all the required information — you will

have a ranking based on exact values from your side and estimated values about the

other company.

The shared mode — in which firms provide the required information together — the

ranking is based on the entered values from both sides.

Single Mode vs. Shared Mode


How to use EVALIS

EVALIS can be used for any potential IS opportunity.

After choosing the appropriate mode (single or shared), user will see a data entry form.

User fills the fields and clicks on the Save button to create an implementation profile.

For a full description on how to fill the forms and use these two services, see the “Help File” in the SHAREBOX platform.


Cost-Sharing in IS

• Picture on the right: https://shorttermhealthinsurance.com/cost-sharing-with-short-term-health-insurance/

Having an implemented

relation, what would be a

reasonable and stable

cost allocation for

involved firms?

https://shorttermhealthinsurance.com/cost-sharing-with-short-term-health-insurance/


What is COSTIS?

Single vs. Shared Mode

How to Use COSTIS

The COSTIS ServiceCost-sharing Tool for Industrial Symbiosis


What is COSTIS?

Having an implemented Industrial Symbiosis (IS) relation, what would be a reasonable way to share

the operational costs among the firms?

COSTIS (Cost-sharing Tool for Industrial Symbiosis) is a method for sharing the total operational cost

with respect to firms' traditional costs.

Firm managers can either use it individually, in the single mode, or together with their IS partner, in

the shared mode.


Single Mode vs. Shared Mode

When firms already realized a relation and are aware of the collective costs, they can use the shared

mode of COSTIS to learn about their individual shares.

In this mode, where firms provide the required information together, the individual cost-shares will be

calculated based on the entered values from both sides.

This mode is useful for firms that already realized the relation, built a level of common understanding,

and are interested in sharing the collective operational costs.

In the single mode, in which one firm enters all the required information, individual cost-shares will be

calculated based on exact values from one side and estimated values about the other side of the IS

relation.

This mode can be used as a pre-negotiation decision support tool when firms have an estimation of the

costs and aim to learn about the estimation of their individual shares (prior to negotiating and

implementing the relation).


How to Use COSTIS

COSTIS can be used for potential or

implemented IS relation.

After choosing the appropriate mode, user will

see a data entry form.

In the single mode, the user fills all the fields and

clicks on the Save button.

The result is the amount that the firm is ought to

pay out of the total operational cost.

Results will be also shown with graphics to

compare the cost-share in case the symbiotic

relation is implemented with the case of not

implementing the relation.


Scientific References

Yazdanpanah V., Yazan D.M. (2017) Industrial symbiotic relations as cooperative games, 7th Industrial Engineering and Systems

Management Conference, Saarbrucken, Germany, October, 11-13. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1802.01167

Yazdanpanah, Vahid, Devrim Murat Yazan, and W. Henk M. Zijm. "FISOF: A formal industrial symbiosis opportunity filtering method."

Engineering applications of artificial intelligence 81 (2019): 247-259. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engappai.2019.01.005

See the following articles for the scientific account of COSTIS and EVALIS:


The project: SHAREBOX

▪ Joint project funded by EU (Horizon 2020)

▪ 16 project partners from 8 countries

▪ EC funding (A): 5.416.544,75 €

▪ Private investment (B): 1.500.000 €

▪ Funding period: 2015-2019

www.spire2030.eu

Secure Management Platform for Sharing Process Resources

www.sharebox-project.eu


Authors of this presentation

www.spire2030.eu

www.sharebox-project.eu

Vahid Yazdanpanah

Devrim M. Yazan

Documents

SHAREBOX on-line trainingsharebox-project.eu/sharebox01/files/2019/08/P3.-SHAREBOX_Evalu… · SHAREBOX on-line training Evaluating Industrial Symbiosis Opportunities (EVALIS Service)