SEVENTH REPORT ON IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RTI ... - CIC Haryanacicharyana.gov.in/uploads/pdf/7th_english1.pdf · HARYANA . SCO 70-71 & 114-115 ... Government of a State, his salary

1

SEVENTH REPORT

ON

IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RTI ACT, 2005 (1.1.2012 TO 31.12.2012)

STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, HARYANA

SCO 70-71 & 114-115, Website: WWW.cicharyana.gov.in SECTOR 8 C, MADHYA MARG E-mail: [email protected] CHANDIGARH-160009

http://www.cicharyana.gov.in/

2

CONTENTS

Chapter No. Subject Page no. I. Chapter-I: Introduction 3-5

II. Chapter-II: Constitution of the State Information Commission Haryana

6-11

III. Chapter-III : Salary and allowances 12-13

IV. Chapter-IV: Administration of the Right to Information Act 14-17

V. Chapter-V : Monitoring and Reporting 18-21

VI. Chapter-VI : Status of Complaints and appeals 22-26

VII. Chapter-VII: Creation of awareness about the Act. 27-28

VIII Chapter-VIII: Recommendations for the reformation 29-31

Annexure-A Haryana Right to Information Rules.2009 32-38

Annexure-B Information received from Public Authorities 39-49

Annexure-C Major Public Authorities from whom information has not been received

50-54

Annexure-D Details of penalty imposed upon the State Public Information Officers

55-67

Annexure-E List of cases in which Disciplinary Proceedings were recommended

68-69

Annexure-F Details of Compensation Awarded to the Appellants/Complainants

70-90

3

CHAPTER- 1

INTRODUCTION

“ An Act to provide for setting out the practical regime of right to

information for citizens to secure access to information under the control of

public authorities, in order to promote transparency and accountability in the

working of every public authority.”

(Preamble to the RTI Act, 2005)

1.1 The RTI Act is an expression of the people’s aspiration for an open

Government. Democracy requires an informed citizenry and

transparency of functioning. It is imperative to contain corruption and

to hold Government and their instrumentalities accountable to the

citizens. With such objectives the Right to Information Act was enacted

on 15th June, 2005.

1.2 Information does not belong to the Government---it belongs to

everybody and any information gathered by the Government is for the

benefit of the public. The Act has come to establish “transparency as

the norm and secrecy as an exception.”

1.3 The Right to Information thus placed the obligation on the Government

to store and organize information in such a way that makes it easily

accessible to the public, to provide information proactively by

responding promptly to all such requests for information.

4

1.4 The system that was put in place has provided access to information

and is a positive step taken by the Government to achieve economic

and social goals, poverty alleviation and reduction of corruption.

1.5 The public authorities having realised the effect of the Act and are

responding positively in catering to the needs of the people by

providing the required information.

1.6 Further, the Commission is mandated to submit its Annual Report to

the Government under section 25(1) of the Act. In pursuance to this ,

the Commission is presenting an overview of the status of

implementation of the Act during 2012 (01.01.2012 to 31.12.2012)

1.7 This report contains analysis of the data received from the state

government departments in accordance with the responsibility cast on

them under section 25(2) and 25(3) of the Act.

1.8 The report includes :-

(i) Number of requests for information received and disposed by

the Departments.

(ii) Number of requests rejected u/s 8 & 9 of the Act.

(iii) Number of appeals /complaints received & disposed by the

commission.

(iv) Amount collected as application fee and further fee collected

by the State Public Information Officers.

5

(v) Amount of penalty imposed on SPIO’s and compensation

awarded.

(vi) Analysis of information furnished by departments.

1.9 The Annual Report also presents a detailed account of activities and

events associated with the State Information Commission as well as its

Budget during 2011-2012 and 2012-2013.

6

CHAPTER-II

Constitution of the State Information Commission,

Haryana

2.1 The State Information Commission Haryana is a constitutional Authority

vested with quasi-judicial powers established on 31st October ,2005

under central RTI Act, 2005.

The duties and functions of the Commission are to conduct

efficient and fair examination into complaints/appeals of access to

information requests. The commission strives to maximize compliance

with the Act for disclosure of public sector information in order to

promote transparency and accountability in the working of every Public

Authority.

In exercise of the powers vested under sub-section 3 of section

15, the State Government appointed the following State Chief

Information commissioners and State Information Commissioners

alongwith the details of assuming the charge of the office:-

Name Inducted as Date of assuming the charge

Sh. G. Madhwan, IAS (Retd.)

State Chief Information Commissioner

1.11.2005

Mrs. Meenaxi Anand Chaudhry, IAS (Retd.)

State Information Commissioner 9.05.2006

Mrs. Asha Sharma, IAS (Retd.)


7

2.2 During the period under report the following State Chief Information

Commissioner and State Information Commissioner retired after

completing their tenure.

S.No. Name Designation Date of Retirement

1. Smt Asha Sharma

IAS, (Retd)

State Information

Commissioner

17.02.2012

Lt. Gen. J.B.S.Yadava


Sh. Ashok Mehta


Sh. M.R. Ranga


Sh. Prem Veer Singh


Mrs. Meenaxi Anand Chaudhry, IAS (Retd.)

State Information Commissioner taken over as State Chief Information Commissioner.

29.10.2010

Sh. Naresh Gulati, IAS (Retd)

State Chief Information Commissioner

20.05.2011

Smt Urvashi Gulati, IAS (Retd)


Maj. Gen.(Retd) Jagbir Singh Kundu


Sh. Sajjan Singh, IAS (Retd)


Sh. Prahlad Rai Meena, IPS(Retd)


8

2.3 The Head quarter of the State Information Commission is situated in

Sector-8c, Madhya Marg Chandigarh SCO No 70-71 & 114-115.

Allocation of budget to the State Information Commission, Haryana

2.4 The State Government since the inception of State Information

Commission Haryana in 2005 to 2012-2013 has made the following

allocations under the head of account “2070-Other Administrative

Services-Non Plan:-

2.5 The breakup of the funds for the year 2011-2012 & 2012-2013 under

the various sub heads was as under:-

Year Funds provided (Rs. in Lacs) Original Final

2005-2006, 30.00 26.79

2006-2007 140.04 126.00

2007-2008 167.94 135.05

2008-2009 244.27 212.02

2009-2010 265.62 233.04

2010-2011 269.34 223.74

2011-2012 257.97 237.38

2012-2013 266.75 282.45

9

(Rs. in Lacs) Sr. No.

Object 2011-2012 (Final)

2012-2013 (Final)

1. Salary 81.51 95.89

2. Dearness Allowance 45.08 69.05

3. Travel Expenses 1.74 3.48

4. Office Expenses 30.84 32.00

5. Motor Vehicle 13.01 2.26

6. POL 5.91 10.99

7. Medical Charges 1.31 1.01

8. Professional & Special

Services

13.70 16.99

9. Contractual services 29.75 39.88

10. LTC 7.45 1.86

11. Information Technology 7.08 9.04

Total 237.38 282.45

2.6 The State Government sanctioned the following staff for the

Commission in the pre-revised and revised pay scales as follows:-

Sr. No.

Number and nomenclature of the post

Sanctioned pay scale Pre-revised Revised

1. One Chief Information Commissioner

Rs. 30000/- fixed Rs. 90000/- fixed

2. Seven State Information Commissioners

Rs. 26000/- fixed Rs. 80000/- fixed

3. One Secretary (From the Joint Secretary level)

Rs.15100-400-18300

Rs.37400-67000+8000GP

10

4. One Senior Secretary to CIC

Rs.12000-375-16500+400SP

Rs.15600-39100+7600 GP

5. One Under Secretary 10000-325-13900+400 SP

Rs.15600-39100+6000 GP

6. Seven Private Secretaries to SIC

8000-275-10200-EB-275-13500

Rs.9300-34800+5400 GP

7. Accounts Officer 6500-200-8500-EB-200-10500

Rs.9300-34800+5400 GP

8. Legal Consultant Consolidated as fixed by the Commission.

Consolidated as fixed by the Commission.

9. One Research Officer-cum-Consultant

7450-225-9025-EB-225-11500

Rs.9300-34800+4600 GP

10. One Superintendent 6500-200-8500-EB-200-10500-200 SP

Rs.9300-34800 +4200 GP+200 SP

11. Nine Personal Assistants

6500-200-8500-EB-200-10500

Rs.9300-34800+4200 GP

12. Two Assistants 5500-175-8300-EB-175-9000

Rs.9300-34800+3600 GP

13. One Accounts Assistant 5500-175-8300-EB-175-9000

Rs.9300-34800+3600 GP

14. Eight Readers 5500-175-8300-EB-175-9000

Rs.9300-34800+3600 GP

15. One Junior Scale Stenographer

4000-100-4800-EB-100-6000+40 SP

Rs.5200-20200+2400 GP

16. Eight Steno Typists 3050-75-3950-EB-80-4590+100 SP

Rs.5200-20200+1900 GP + 100 SP

17. Twelve Clerks -cum-Computer Operators

3050-75-3950-EB-80-4590+40 SP

Rs.5200-20200+ GP+40 SP

18. Eleven Drivers 4000-100-4800-EB-100-6000+300 SP

Rs.5200-20200+2400 GP + 300 SP

19. Twenty three Peons 2550-55-2660-EB-60-3200+30 SP

Rs.4440-7440+1300 GP+30 SP

11

2.7 As on 31st December 2012, all the posts except Legal Consultant,

remained filled up in the Commission. Sh. Bhupinder Singh, HCS joined

as Secretary of the Commission w.e.f from 18.09.2012. As a matter of

policy, the staff was taken on transfer from the Haryana Civil

Secretariat and other Departments of the State Government. When

officials of Haryana Civil Secretariat or Government Departments were

not made available, appointments were made on contract basis or

through identified outsourced agency.

12

CHAPTER - III

Salary and allowances

3.1 The salary and allowances payable and other terms and conditions of

service as provided under Sub Section 5 of Section 16 of the RTI Act

of:-

(i) The State Chief Information Commissioner shall be the same as that of an Election Commissioner;

(ii) The State Information Commissioner shall be the same as that of the Chief Secretary to the State Government;

Provided that if the State Chief Information Commissioner or a State

Information Commissioner, at the time of his appointment is, in receipt

of a pension, other than a disability or wound pension, in respect of

any previous service under the Government of India or under the

Government of a State, his salary in respect of the service as the State

Chief Information Commissioner or a State Information Commissioner

shall be reduced by the amount of that pension including any portion

of pension which was commuted and pension equivalent of other forms

of retirement benefits excluding pension equivalent to retirement

gratuity;

3.2 The salary and allowances payable to other officers and employees of

the State Information Commission, Haryana shall be at par with other

13

State Government employees. Personnel appointed on contract basis

or out sourced are entitled for payments at the contract rates which

shall not be less than the minimum wages.

14

CHAPTER-IV

Administration of the Right to Information Act

4.1 Effective Suo-moto disclosure of information:

Right to Information Act under Section 4 mandates every public

authority for pro-active disclosure of information. The information

which is required to be disclosed under this section includes

particulars of the organization including functions and duties, rules,

regulations, instructions, manuals, and records followed for the

discharge of functions, directory of officers and officials alongwith

monthly remuneration being paid to them, details of annual budget

including expenditure incurred, details of schemes/programmes

being handled, its beneficiaries and concession or subsidy being

provided etc. The particulars of State Assistant Public Officers/State

Public Information Officers/First Appellate Authority are also

required to be disclosed. It is a statutory requirement which every

public authority is bound to meet. Further, it is not sufficient to

publish the above information once but every public authority is

obliged to update such information periodically. As far as possible

the information should be updated immediately as and when any

development takes place. The information may be posted on the

website facilitating the citizens to access to the information without

15

approaching the public authority. This exercise as per requirement

of RTI Act, 2005 was to be completed within one hundred and

twenty days from its commencement but a number of public

authorities are yet to take effective steps as contemplated under

Section 4 of the Act.

4.2 Maintenance and retrieval of records.

Section 4 (1) (a) of the Right to Information Act 2005 lays

importance on maintenance of records by the public authorities duly

catalogued and indexed in a manner and form which facilitates

access within a reasonable time. In many cases the disposal of

requests asking for copies of documents, it was experienced that

the State Public Information Officers failed to retrieve the

documents requested because of absence of a proper record

keeping system. Record keeping is an area neglected in most of the

offices of Government and Public Sector Undertakings. Government

may launch a special drive in this direction so that the record

available in the offices of the public authorities are properly

catalogued, indexed and stored in a manner that facilitate easy

retrieval of information. The Act also emphasizes upon

computerization of the records and access through net-work.

16

4.3 Provisions of adequate staff and budget for furnishing the information.

The Right to Information Act, 2005 can successfully create a

practical regime for information sharing with the citizen if there is

an effective delivery mechanism in public authorities especially at

the district and block levels. Some of the public authorities at the

district or at the block level do not have any basic infrastructure like

photocopiers, computers etc. to provide information to the public.

Since funds under contingency are also limited the option to get

photocopies from the market is also not possible. In the absence of

infrastructure hand written illegible information is sometimes

furnished to the information seekers. These difficulties had been

constantly voiced in the interaction which the Commission had with

the members of the public, State Public Information Officers and

other stake holders apart from being raised in the public hearings

before the Commission. Therefore, the State Government may

earmark a certain percentage of budgets for implementation of the

RTI related issues. Adequate provisions be made for purchase of

stationery, office equipments like photocopiers, computer etc. in the

office of designated officers.

4.4 Cost and Fee rules under the RTI Act.

Section 27 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 read with Sections

6 (1), 7 (1) and 7 (5) of the Act provide for prescribing fee for

17

submission of application and the cost for providing the information.

Accordingly, the Haryana Government had notified the Haryana

Right to Information Rules, 2005 on 28th October 2005 wherein the

application fee was prescribed @ Rs. 50/- and additional fee @ Rs.

10/- per page. The State Government after reconsidering the

matter and by repealing the Haryana Right to Information Rules,

2005 notified Haryana Right to Information Rules, 2009 on 21st

December 2009 wherein the additional fee to be charged under sub

Section 5 of Section 7 of the Act was reduced from Rs. 10/- to Rs.

2/- per page. Copy of the rules notified on 21st December 2009 is

appended at Annexure ‘A’.

4.5. Appeal Procedure

In exercise of powers conferred under Section 27 read with sub-

Section 10 of the Section 19 of the Right to Information Act, 2005,

the State Government laid down the procedure for filing appeals,

procedure for deciding appeal, mode of serving notices, appearance

of appellant/complainant before the Commission etc. by notifying

Haryana Right to Information Rules, 2009 on 21st December 2009

by repealing the earlier rules notified on 28th October 2005.

18

CHAPTER-V

Monitoring and Reporting 5.1 Section 25 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 provides that State

Information Commission at the end of each year shall prepare a report

on the implementation of the provisions of this Act for the year and

forward a copy to the appropriate Government. The report is required

to be laid before the State Legislature thereafter. Section 25 (2) of the

Act further mandates that each Ministry or Department or Public

Under takings shall in relation to the public authorities within their

jurisdiction collect and provide such information to the State

Information Commission as is required to prepare the Annual Report

by the Commission. When no report was received from the public

authorities, the Commission vide letter dated 28.10.2013 directed the

Administrative Secretaries, Heads of Departments, Divisional

Commissioners, Deputy Commissioners of the Districts in the State,

Managing Directors of Boards, Corporations and public sectors

undertakings, Registrar, Punjab & Haryana High Court, Secretary

Haryana Vidhan Sabha to collect the required details from the

designated State Public Information Officers and furnish it to the

Commission for the preparation of the Annual report from 01.01.2012

to 31.12.2012. Statistical analysis of the administration of the Act, on

19

the basis of the data received by the Commission from the various

public authorities, arranged in alphabetical order in respect of

Administrative Secretaries, Heads of Departments, Boards,

Corporations, Public Undertakings, Commissioners of Divisions and

Deputy Commissioners separately is annexed as Annexure ‘B’. A list of

major Departments and public authorities who did not respond to the

Communications from the Commission dated 28.10.2013 is placed at

Annexure ‘C'.

5.2 As per available information during the period from 01.01.2012 to

31.12.2012, a total of 34996 applications were received by the

reporting public authorities. The access to information was withheld on

account of exemption provisions in 169 and 92 cases under Section 8

and 9 respectively of the RTI Act, 2005. Thus access to information

was denied in about 0.745 percentages of total cases. A total sum of

Rs. 1487878 was deposited as prescribed application fee and

additional fee by the applicants during the period under report.

These figure shows that the public authorities have by and large

provided the information in majority of cases to the RTI applicants.

5.3 Suggestions received from the Public Authorities towards

improved implementation of the Act.

For bringing improvement in the implementation of the RTI Act, 2005,

certain suggestions have been received from various public authorities

20

while submitting reports sought under Section 25(2) of the Act. These

are as under:-

(i) The designated State Public Information Officer should be a

senior level officer who could take action against the erring

officer/official for committing delay in supplying the information.

(ii) Additional fee should be enhanced to discourage the information

seeker for frivolous information.

(iii) Numerous, frivolous and voluminous complaints are received

from RTI applicants which not only diverts the attention of the

staff but also resources in collecting such information which do

not serve any public interest.

(iv) To reduce frivolous applications and to ensure that only genuine

information seekers invoke the provision of the RTI Act it is

suggested that only one information be allowed in one RTI

application.

(v) The BPL applicants are seeking information which does not relate

to them. Generally the BPL applicants are seeking the entire

information on the functioning of the public authority which is

apparently a misuse of the Act. In such cases there should be

some mechanism in the Act so that the BPL persons are actually

benefited for their cause. The time limit of 30 days should be

21

increased in respect of the information pertaining to more than 5

years old.

(vi) The State Public Information Officers/First Public Authorities

should be refreshed from time to time by imparting trainings.

(vii) The penalty should be imposed upon the public authority with

the stipulation to recover it from the erring official responsible

for the delay in supplying the information.

(viii) Third party information should not be disclosed.

22

CHAPTER-VI

Status of Complaints and Appeals

6.1 The State Information Commission has the original jurisdiction to

receive and enquire into the complaints under Section 18 (2) and

second appellate jurisdiction under Section 19 (3) to receive

appeals against the decisions of the public authorities. During

the period from 01.01.2012 to 31.12.2012 the institution of

complaints and appeals, decision taken and the matters which

were remained pending as on 31.12.2012, is given below:-

(i) Details of complaint cases:

(II) Details of appeal cases:

Pending cases as on 31.12.2011

Complaints instituted during the period under report

Decided during the period

Pending as on 31.12.2012

01.01.2012 to 31.12.2012

Total

193 263 456 335 121

Pending cases as on 31.12.2011

Appeals instituted during the period under report

Decided during the period

Pending as on 31.12.2012

01.01.2012 to

Total

31.12.2012

1879 4301 6180 3781 2399

23

6.2 During this period from 01.01.2012 to 31.12.2012 the Commission

decided 1140 miscellaneous applications by advising the applicants

suitably to take further necessary action to complete the formalities as

mandated under the RTI Act, 2005 and rules before entertaining the

request as complaint or appeal.

6.3 The State Information Commission, Haryana has been deciding all the

complaints and appeals after summoning both the parties and by

following the practice of affording an opportunity of personal hearing

to both complainants/appellants and the State Public Information

Officers/First Appellate Authorities and third parties as well. Decisions

are announced after examining the written and oral submissions made

by the parties. The original and the relevant record is also perused, if

deemed necessary by the Commission during the hearing.

6.4 Action taken Under Section 20 of the Act.

The Commission during 01.01.2012 to 31.12.2012 issued 882 show

cause notices for imposing penalty to the State Public Information

Officers and the Deemed State Public Information Officers under

Section 20 (1) of the RTI Act, 2005. Penalty was imposed on 79 State

Public Information Officers/Deemed State Public Information Officers

respectively who had failed to furnish complete information within the

24

specified time limit and the delay was not found to be due to

reasonable cause. Details of these cases for the period of report from

01.01.2012 to 31.12.2012 are placed at Annexure ‘D’ alongwith the

details of amount imposed on account of penalty. Disciplinary action

had also been recommended under Section 20 (2) of the Act against

the delinquent officers/officials including the deemed State Public

Information Officer who had failed to provide timely and complete

information to the State Public Information Officer. During 01.01.2012

to 31.12.2012 in 14 cases it was recommended to initiate disciplinary

action against the erring officials/officers, details of such cases are

placed at Annexure ‘E’.

6.5 Compensation under Section 19 (8) (b):

Section 19 (8) (b) of the Act empowered the Commission to require

the public authorities to compensate the complainants or the

appellants for any loss or detriment suffered by them. Details of these

cases in which compensation had been awarded during the report

period of 01.01.2012 to 31.12.2012 are at Annexure ‘F'. During this

period in 264 number of cases, compensation has been awarded to the

appellate/complainants. It is pertinent to mention here that some of

the public authorities decided to recover the same from the concerned

State Public Information Officer or the person found responsible for the

delay.

25

6.6 Court Cases

In some cases the aggrieved parties have preferred writs against the

orders of the Commission in Hon’ble Punjab & Haryana High Court at

Chandigarh. The Commission in its statutory capacity under the

provisions of the Right to Information Act, 2005 has decided not to

defend such writs. In such situations a letter to the Registrar (Writ)

and Registrar (Judicial) including the Advocate General, Haryana as

well is being sent.

6.7 Website and email address of the Commission:

The website of the Commission www.cicharyana.gov.in is operational.

The cause list and orders passed by the Commission on Complaints

and appeals cases are being posted on the website. The email address

of the Commission is [email protected].

6.8 Central Assistance for IT enablement

During the calender Year 2012 the Government of India, Ministry of

Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of Personnel &

Training, New Delhi released an amount of Rs 9,68,540/- towards

second installment of IT enablement under the erstwhile scheme “

Strengthening and Capacity Building And Awareness Generation for

Effective Implementation of the Right To Information Act ” under the

Centrally Sponsored plan Scheme. The Scheme aims at strengthening

the infrastructure of the Commission in terms of computers, up-

gradation of the existing website, file tracking system, application

status through SMS, digitization of record, video conferencing facility.

http://www.cicharyana.gov.in/

mailto:[email protected]

26

6.9 Improving Transparency and Accountability in Government

through Effective Implementation of RTI Act, 2005.

Ministry of Personnel Public Grievances and Pension ,Department of

Personnel & Training, Government of India released an amount of Rs

2,87,449/- towards Workshops/seminars and competitions under

awareness Generation for RTI during the calendar Year 2012. Further

this amount was released for 4 workshops for citizens /SPIOs/FAAs

and Essay competitions in 50 Colleges .State Govt has designated the

H.I.P.A.(Haryana Institute of Public administration) Gurgaon as Nodal

agency to organize workshops and Director Higher Education has been

authorized to conduct Essay competitions.

27

CHAPTER-VII

Creation of awareness about the Act.

7.1 Section 26 of the Right to Information Act directs the State

Government to create awareness among the public by developing and

organizing educational programmes to advance the understating of the

public, in particular of disadvantaged communities as to how to

exercise the rights contemplated under this Act. The Sub Section 1 (d)

of Section 26 of the Act casts obligation on the Government to train

State Public Information Officer of public authorities and produce

relevant training material for use by the public authorities themselves.

The Commission in its earlier reports has suggested launching of a

programme for training and awareness of the public for ensuring

effective implementation of the Act. The response of the Government

is as under:-

(i) Training Programme for SAPIOs/SPIOs/FAAs.

The State Government has designated the Haryana institute of

public administration (HIPA), Gurgaon as nodal agency in this

regard. Training for the designated officers which includes

SAPIOs/SPIOs and FAAs is being imparted in regular intervals by

HIPA as well as other training institutes like HVPNL Technical

Training institutes for power utility department and Haryana

28

Institute of Rural Development, Nilokheri. Training to other

employees working in various public authorities on RTI Act is

also being imparted to sensitize them and to make them aware

for dealing with the matters related to RTI.

(ii) Publication of directory and a user guide.

The Commission in its first and second report recommended that

a guide in the official language should be compiled to assist the

citizens in exercise of their right to access information under the

Act. It was also recommended to prepare a directory of the

designated SAPIOs/SPIOs and the FAAs. Now in the year of 2008

on the recommendations of the State Government the HIPA,

Gurgaon has published a directory of the designated officer’s

alongwith a user guide on RTI and a ready reckoner on the Act in

English and Hindi for the use of citizens of the State.

29

CHAPTER-VIII

Recommendations for the reformation

The Right to Information Act casts responsibility upon both, the

State Information Commission as well as public authorities, to suggest

measures for effective implementation of the Act. Recommendations

for reforms of the Commission to the State Government and the public

authorities are as under:-

(i) Disposal of first appeals:-

Sub Section 1 of Section 19 of the Act provides for taking up a

matter of first appeal before the Appellate Authority in the pubic

authority, when the applicant is not satisfied with the

information furnished by the State Public Information of the

public authority. The First Appellate Authority is to dispose of the

appeal within 30 days or within such extended period not

exceeding a total of 45 days from the date of filing the appeal.

In many cases, Commission has experienced that the First

Appellate Authority either deal with the appeal late or do not

dispose it of at all. This inevitably results in delayed receipt of

information or compels the applicant to take up the matter with

the Commission in second appeal. This causes delay, additional

expenditure and avoidable agony. The Commission, therefore,

30

recommends providing training to concerned officials to improve

their perception of and performance under the Act.

(ii) State Public Information Officers also need training to sensitize

them to the needs of citizens. A massive round of training of

SPIOs must therefore, be undertaken to enable them to

discharge the responsibilities cast on them under the Act.

(iii) Even though pro-active disclosure was mandatory under section

4(1), it was noticed that pro-active disclosure was not done in a

satisfactory manner by many public authorities. The public

authorities should realize the importance of pro-active disclosure

as, in the long run , such disclosure would reduce the number of

requests for information. Hence it is recommended that

Government may suitably instruct the public authorities to

disclose as much information as possible under section 4(1) of

the Right to information Act, such as functions, duties,

procedures, accountability and norms set by the public

authorities for discharge of their functions has all the

characteristics of the citizen’s charter.

(iv) Citizen’s charter should therefore form an integral part of the

disclosure under Section 4 (1) (b) so that the public is aware of

the commitments of a public authority towards the citizens. All

public authorities must, whenever necessary, revisit their

31

procedures. Irksome procedures should be debated in public and

made more citizens friendly. Citizens should be able to enforce

the norms disclosed under the RTI Act whenever necessary.

(v) Disclosures under Section 4 (1) (b) must contain all the details

as required under the Act and these details should be

periodically updated. Commissions should have the authority to

penalize pubic authorities for inadequate disclosure or non-

disclosure of details required under this Section.

(vi) It should be obligatory for public authorities to publish these

disclosures in their Annual Reports.

(vii) It is suggested that specific columns be included in the annual

confidential reports of officers regarding their attitude towards

implementation of the Act. The self assessment report of the

SPIO and the First Appellate Authority must include information

regarding number of applications/appeals received by them and

their disposal.

32

Annexure ‘A’

HARYANA GOVERNMENT

ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT

Notification

The 21st

December, 2009

No.S.O.99/C.A.22/2005/S.27/2009.—In exercise of the powers conferred sub-section (1) read with sub-section (2) of section 27 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (Act 22 of 2005), the Governor of Haryana hereby makes the following rules providing for information under the said Act, namely :—

Short title and

commencement.

1. (1) These rules may be called the Haryana Right to Information Rules , 2009.

(2) They shall come into force from 1st

January, 2010.

2. (1) In these rules, unless the context otherwise requires,

a) “Act” means the Right to Information Act, 2005 (Act 22 of 2005);

b) “Commission” means the Haryana Information Commission , constituted under section 15 of the Act;

c) “Model Form” means a model form appended to these rules;

d) “section” means the section of the Act.

(2) The words and expressions used in these rules, but nor defined, shall have the same meanings as respectively assigned to them in the Act.

Application for 3. (1) a person who desires to obtain any information Obtaining admissible under the Act, shall make an application, preferably in Information Model Form ‘A’ to the State Public Information Officer and in his Sections 2(m), 6 absence to State Assistant Public Information Officer along-with fee and 27 as specified in sub-rule (1) of rule 5 of these rules.

(2) On the receipt of an application, made under sub-rule (1), the State Public Information Officer or State Assistant Public Information Officer as the case may be, shall give a receipt in token, thereof to the applicant.

33

Deposit of fee 4. (1) The fee shall be deposited with the State Public Section 6 Information Officer either in Cash against proper receipt, by Bank

Draft, by Indian Postal Order or by treasury Challan in the following Heads of Account :— Major Head 0070—Other Administrative Services Sub Major Head 60—Other Services Minor Head 800-Other Receipts Sub Head 86—Fee under the Right to Information Act, 2005. Detailed head “0070-Other Administrative Services-60-Other Services-

800-Other Receipts-86 Fee under the Right to Information Act, 2005”.

(2) The amount of fee shall be credited to the account as referred in sub-rule (1): Provided that the Boards, Corporations and other autonomous bodies of the State may get the amount of requisite fee deposited in their own accounts maintained by the. (3) On receipt of an application, submitted under sub-rule (1) of rule 3, the State Public Information Officer shall scrutinize the application and shall assess how much fee is required to be paid by the applicant for obtaining the information. (4) The fee assessed under sub-rule (3), shall be intimated to the applicant by the State Public Information Officer, expeditiously, in Model Form ‘B’ to ensure the delivery of information within time specified under sub-section (1) of section 7 of the Act. (5) In case the applicant fails to deposit the requisite fee within a fifteen days after the issuance of the intimation given to him under sub- rule (4), it shall be construed that the applicant is no longer interested in obtaining the information sought for and his application shall be deemed to have been filed.

Quantum of fee. 5. (1) An application for obtaining any information under sub Section 6 and 7 section (1) of the section 6 shall be accompanied with a fee of Rs. 50/-

. (2) For providing information under sub-section (1) of section 7, the fee shall be charged from the applicant at the following rates, namely: — (a) Rs. 2/- for each page in A-4 or A-3 size paper, created or copied; and (b) if information is to be provided on a large size of paper than that specified in clause (a), the actual cost shall be charged.

34

(3) For providing information under sub-section (5) of section 7, the fee shall be charged from the applicant at the following rates, namely:-

(a) Rs. 50/- for providing information in a floppy;

(b) Rs. 100/- for providing information in diskette; and

(c) if information sought is of such a nature, which is contained in a printed document, of which a price has been fixed, then that information shall be provided after charging the price, fixed for that printed document. However, if only an extract or page of such a printed document is asked for, then a fee of Rs. 2/- per page shall be charged.

(4) No fee for inspection of record shall be charged, if such an inspection is made for one hour only. However, if inspection is made for a period of more than one hour, then a fee of rupees ten shall be charged for every fifteen minutes in excess of first hour. Every fraction of the period above fifteen minutes shall be construed as complete period of fifteen minutes and it shall be charged as full period of fifteen minutes.

Procedure for 6. (1) The memorandum of appeal shall contain the following filing appeals. information, namely :— Sections 19(1) and (3) (a) name and address of the appellant, including the details of

contact telephone/mobile Numbers/e-mail address, if any;

b) official designation and address of State Public Information Officer or State Assistant Public Information Officer, as the case may be ;

(c) official designation and address of the Officer against the decision of whom the appeal is preferred;

(d) particulars of the order including number, if any , against which the appeal is preferred;

(e) brief facts leading to the appeal;

(f) prayer or relief sought;

(g) grounds for the prayer or relief;

(h) verification by the appellant; and

(i) any other information which the Commission may deem

necessary for deciding the appeal.

35

(2) the appellant shall submit three copies of the memorandum of appeal for official purpose.

(3) Every appeal made to the Commission shall be accompanied by the following documents, namely :—

(a) self attested copies of the Orders or documents against which the appeal is being preferred;

(b) copies of documents relied upon by the appellant and

referred to in the appeal; and

(c) an index of the documents referred to in the appeal. Provided that in case complete documents are not furnished, the appeal shall not be rejected but the appellant shall be asked to complete the above formalities.

Procedure for 7. Before deciding an appeal, the Commission shall , — Deciding appeal Section 19(10) (a) serve notice to the concerned persons;

(b) entertain any evidence in support of appeal, which may be oral or in writing from the concerned persons; (c) examine on oath or an affidavit from the persons concerned; (d) examine the documents or any records or copies thereof; (e) inquire through the authorized office the facts of the appeal or may require facts in detail, if he so deems appropriate, hear the State Public Information Officer or any other senior officer who had decided the first appeal, as the case may be; and (f) receive evidence on affidavits from the State Public Information Officer or any senior officer who had decided the appeal or from any other person from whom the evidence may be deemed necessary.

Mode of 8. The Commission may serve notice to the persons concerned serving notice in any of the following modes, namely :— section 19(10)

(a) By hand delivery (dasti) through process server;

(b) By Registered Post, Speed Post, Under Postal Certificate, Courier or such other means ;

(c) By electronic mail, if e-mail address is provided ; or

36

(d) By publication in the newspaper.

Appearance or 9. The appellant or the complainant, as the case may be, shall in Appellant / Complainant every case be informed of the date of hearing at least 15

clearthat date. If the complainant/ appellant fails to appear on the date of hearing, the Commission will decide the matter on merits: Provided that where the Commission is satisfied that the circumstances exist due to which the complainant or appellant is being prevented from attending the hearing, then, he may afford the complainant or appellant another opportunity of being heard before taking a final decision days before .

Order by 10. (1) the Commission shall make order in writing and Commission pronounce the same in the presence of the concerned parties. section 19(10)

(2) The party concerned may obtain the copy of the order from the Commission.

Repeal and 11. The Haryana Right to Information Rules, 2005 are hereby Saving repealed: Provided that any order made or action taken under the rules so repealed shall be deemed to have been made or taken under the corresponding provisions of these rules.

37

MODEL FORM ‘A’ [See rule 3(1)]

To State Public Information Officer/ State Assistant Public Information Officer, __________(Name of the office with address)

(1) Full Name of the applicant:

(2) Address:

(3) Particulars of Information required—

(i) Subject matter of information*

(ii) The period to which the information relates**

(iii) Description of the information required***

(iv) Whether information is required by post or in person (actual postal charges shall be include in additional fee) (v) In case by post (Ordinary, Registered or Speed post)

Place: Date:

Signature of the applicant.

* Broad category of the subject to be included (such as grant / Government land/ Service matters/ Licenses etc.) ** Relevant period for which information is required to be indicated. *** Specific details of the information are required to be indicated.

___________________________________________________________ ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

Received your application dated …………………………. Vide diary

No…………………… dated………………..

Signature of State Public Information Officer/ Sate Assistant Public Information Officer (Name of the Department/Office)………………………………………..

38

MODEL FORM ‘B’ [See rule 4(4)]

From

Designation of the State Public Information Officer. To

Name of the applicant Address of the applicant.

Sir, Please refer to your application dated ………………. addressed to the undersigned requesting for information under Right to Information Act, 2005. 1. The additional fee for supplying this information is `…………………………

2. You are requested to pay the fee through any of the mode of payment i.e. either in cash against proper receipt, by Bank Draft, by Indian Postal Order or by Treasury Challan as mentioned in rule 4(1) of the Haryana Right to Information Rules, 2009 and send a copy of proof thereof to this office so that the requisite information can be supplied to you.

3. In case you are dissatisfied with the above estimate, you are requested to submit an appeal before the Appellate Authority………………………

(Name of the department).

State Public Information Officer

____________________________________________________________ URVASHI GULATI,

Chief Secretary to Government, Haryana

39

w.e.f. 1-1-2012 to 31-12-2012

Sr. No.

Name of the Public Authority Number ofrequests received

No. ofrequests rejected (reasons inbrief) as perprovisions ofthe Act.

Particulars ofany disciplinary action taken against any official onaccount ofviolation ofRTI Act.

Factual report of theefforts made by thePublic Authorities toadminister andimplement the spiritand intention of thisAct.

Recommendations, ifany, received for thedevelopment/ improvement/ modernization/ reform oramendment to thisAct or otherlegislation orcommon law or anyother matter relevantto RTI Act andaction taken thereon.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7(a) (b) (a) (b) (a) (b)u/s 8 u/s 9 On the

recommen-dations of the Commiss-ion

Otherwise

Applica- tion

Charges u/s 6(1)

Documentation charges u/s 7(3)

1 Agriculture (Director) 374 6 3 16610 15190 All steps have been taken to implement

the Act

ANNEXURE-BREGISTER OF REQUESTS FOR INFORMATION & DISPOSAL OF REQUESTS UNDER RTI ACT, 2005

e amount of charges collec

Heads of Department

40

2 Archives (Director) 20 350 44 The departmentmade ful efforts toimplement the spirit& intentions of theAct

-

3 C.I.D. (ADGP.CID(H) 122 47 4450 341 0 -4 Consolidation (Director) 46 - - - - 1450 55 Strongly

implemented0

5 Cooperation (Registrar) 358 10 41 14 60 17380 4843 06 Development & Panchayats (Director) 1694 2 2 66820 16224 0 0

7 School Education (Director General) 2342 - - - - 48335 4470 - -

8 Elementary Education (Director) 1949 26229 5709 To give information and motivation to

the applicants under RTI Act, 2005

-

9 Elections (Chief Electoral) 502 3 - - - 9875 62617 Information provided well in

time as per RTI rule

10 Employment (Director) 220 2 1 - - 7610 4161 -11 Environment (Director) 36 - - - - 1250 1365 -12 Exise & Taxation (E.T.C) 1235 2 28675 6688

Best possible steps are taken to provide

the requisite information vide the RTI application as

immediately as possible from time to time the staff was educated in

respect of provisions of RTI

Act/Rules. 13 Food & Supplies (Director) 2632 - - - 2 71926 4167214 Forests (P.C.C.F) 661 2 13250 16914

41

15 Health Services (Director) 2033 5 0 0 0 51490 28508 All necessary Information has

been displayed on the notice board,

rules, under the Act have been down loaded from the

website and kept this copy for the

convenience of the public.The register

open and maintained by this office in connection with the RTI Act,

2005 as per directions of SIC

16 Home Guards & Civil Defence (Comdt. Genl.)

102 - - - - 3550 6984 - -

17 Horticulture (Director) 143 - 6 - 1 5410 10080 -18 Hospitality (Director) 14 - - - - 330 70 Reports provided to

the applicant on real facts under Administor and

implement the spirit and intention of this

Act

19 Industries & Commerce (Director) 720 19 - - - 27930 20961 _ -

42

20 Industrial Training & Vocational Education (Director)

963 20850 15817 Website of the Department has

already been launched.SPIO of

the Department has been given training regarding RTI Act by HIPA.Sincere

efforts were made to implement the ACT in letter &

Spirit

21 Institutional Finance & Credit Control (Director)

6 - - - - 200 - _

22 Irrigation Research & Management Institute (HIRMI) (Principal Director)

149 1250 _

23 Labour Commissisoner Haryana, Chandigarh

740 - - 2 - 25318 10222 _

24 Land Records (Director) 46 1450 55 _25 Law & Legislative (L.R & Secy.) 57 - - - - 1200 1334 Information

provided-

26 Lotteries (Director) 16 - - - - 400 206 _27 Mines & Geology (Director) 174 - - - - 5750 2172 _28 Police (D.G) 367 10540 13148 _29 Printing & Stationery (Controller) 87 0 0 0 0 3450 631 _30 Public Relations & Cultural Affairs

(DPR)2 _

31 PWD (B&R) (E.I.C.) 1578 38720 21874 Reply Submitted to the applicant within

prescribed time

32 Rural Development (Director) 730 4 - - - 16570 2712 -33 Social Justice & Empowerment

(Director)521 18850 24154 _

34 Small Savings (Director) 5 - - - - - - - -35 Sports & Youth Affairs (Director) 157 - - - - 4340 1774 -36 Supplies & Disposals (Director) 21 - - - - 1050 12670 - -37 Town & Country Planning (Director) 50 2500 6745

43

38 Transport Commissioner 1474 - - - - 35590 6212 - -39 Welfare of Scheduled Castes &

Backward Classes (Director)566 - - - - 8900 3085 Every efforts were

made to implementthis Act

-

40 Women & Child Development (Director)

1139 35 2 - 5 29795 17661 - -

41 Engineer in chief, Public Health Engineering Department, Panchkula

1791 35630 3643 RTI Act 2005 is being followed in the Department

42 Food & Drug Administration Haryana 301 1 8770 1524 Application disposed of with in

time as per the spirit & intention of

the Act.Total 26143 136 50 18 73 674043 392535

1 Agriculture Marketing Board (Chairman)

44 650 _

2 Fed of Coop. Sugar Mills Ltd. (Chairman)

48 - - - - 2570 3130 - -

3 Coop. Supply & Marketing Fed Ltd. (HAFED) (Chairman)

258 - - - - 9740 21923 Information given tothe applicants asper RTI Act.

4 Dairy Dev. Coop. Fed. Ltd. (Chairperson )

129 13 - - - 2850 994 - -

5 Electronics Dev. Corpn. Ltd. (HARTRON) (Chairman)

68 - - - - 2550 3380 Efforts are being made for

implementation of the Act.

6 Khadi & Village Industries Board (Chairman)

27

7 Land Reclamation & Dev. Corpn. Ltd. (HLRDC) (Chairman)

13 - - - - 650 339 -

Board & Corporation

44

8 Seed Certification Agency (Chairman)

13 - - - - 560 500 -

9 Seeds Dev. Corpn. Ltd. (Chairman) 66 - - - - 3300 2399 - -10 Haryana Electricity Regulatory

Commission (HERC)39 - 1 - - 1060 82 The information

regarding all therelvant documentincluding orderpassed by theHERC on the ARRsare alreadyavailable on thewebsite harc.gov.in.However, theinformations soughtby the citizens havebeen suppliedwithin the stipulatedperiod specified inthe Act.

11 Cooperative socities, Haryana 355 10 41 14 60 17280 4837 RTI seminarsattended bydepartmental officials inPanchkula, Hisar,Gurgaon.

45

12 CCS Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar

636 1 - - - 32382 7656 The incharges of allthe branches/unitsof the office havebeen instructed toattend to the RTIcases promptly andsincere efforts havebeen made by themfor quick and timelydisposal of suchcases.

13

State Information Commission,Haryan

113

- - - -

4900 1145

-14 Haryana Forest Deptt 10 350 132

15 Bhagat Phool Singh Vishwavidyalaya 158

4

7630 10589 The PIO whose ppoint are

maximum wil provide the

information after gathering the rest of the information from the various PIO's as

per order of the Hon'b;le vice Chancellor

conveyed vide Ends. No. 1282 to

1317 dated 28.08.2012.

Total 1977 28 42 14 60 86472 57106

1 Commissioner, Gurgaon Division, Gurgaon

206 - - - - 4000 1429

2 Commissioner, Rohtak Division, Rohtak. 107 - - - - 2110 410 -

Total 313 6110 1839

Divisional Commissioners

46

1 Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar 297 8090 3902 Deputy Commissioner, Rewari 840 - - - - 21670 27757 - -3 Deputy Commissioner, Sonepat 224 - - - - 3550 600 199 -4 Deputy Commissioner, Yamuna Nagar 235 - - - - 7846 - - -

Total 1596 41156 28747 199

1 Chief Secretary to Government Haryana, Chandigarh 1047 - - 31610 1345

-

2 Revenue & Disaster Management & Consolidation Departments

713 3 - - - 28665 17127 - -

3 Home, Jails, Criminal Investigation & Administration of Justice Department

17 - - - - 780 - - -

4 Public Health Engineering Department

- - - - RTI Act, 2005 is being followed in the department

5 Excise & Taxation Department 1221 2 - - - 28515 6688 Best possible steps are taken to provide

the requisite information vide the RTI Application as

immediately as possible

8 Industries & Commerce, Mines & Geology & Electronics & Information Technology Departments

19 - - - - 470 80 Efforts are being made for

implementation of the Act

Administrative Secretaries

Deputy Commissioners

47

9 Archives Department - - - - The department made full efforts to implement the spirit and intention of this

Act.

-

10 Health Department 166 - - - - 4450 5110 Efforts have been made to implement the spirit & intention

of this Act

11 PW(B&R) & Architecture Departments

1502 - - - - 38020 21874 All necessary information has

been displayed on the notice board.

The rules under the Act have been

down loaded from the website and

kept this copy for the convenience of

the public. The register open and maintained by this office in connection with RTI Act, 2005 as per direction of

SIC.

48

12 Printing & Stationery Department 87 - - - - 3450 631 -

13 Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat 98 - - - - 3170 3731 Sincere efforts are made to implement the provision of the

Act in letter and spirit

Specific trainingprogramme fromState InformationOfficers and FAAshould beorganized fromtime to time.Provision shouldbe made to createseparate post forthe additional workunder the RTI act.There should beprovision toprovide honorariumto the State PublicInformation OffIcerand FAA toperform additionalduties under theRTI Act.

49

14 Information Technology 21 450 620 Efforts are being made for

implementation of the Act.

15 Industries & Commerce Departments 19 470 80

16 Legal Remembrancer and Administrative Secretary Haryana

57 1200 1334 Information Provided

17 Total 4967 5 0 0 0 141250 58620Grand Total 34996 169 92 32 133 949031 538847 199

50

ANNEXURE- C

Major Public Authorities from whom information has not been received

Heads of Department

1 Advocate General (A.G)

2 Animal Husbandry & Dairying (Director General)

3 Archaeology & Museums (Director)

4 Architecture(ChiefArchitect)

5 Ayush (Director)

6 Charitable Endowments (Admtr. Genl & Official Trustee)

7 Census Operation(Director) 8 Civil Aviation (Advisor)

9 Economic & Statistical Analysis (ESA)

10 Higher Education (Commissioner) 11 Electronics & Information Technology (Director)

12 Chief Electrical Inspector (Chief Electrical) 13 State Employment Exchange (Dy. Director) 14 Fisheries (Director)

15 Grievances(Director) 16 Reproductive & Child Health (Project)

17 Haryana Aids Control Society (Chairperson) 18 State TB. Cont. Socy & Leprosy Socy.(Chairman) 19 State TB. Association Haryana (President) 20 ESI (Director)

21 Haryana Institute of Public Administration(HIPA)(Director) 22 Irrigation (Advisor)

23 Haryana State Legal Services Authority (Exe Chairman) 24 Local Audit(Director)

25 NIC-Computer Centre (Sr. Tech.) 26 Panchayati Raj Public Works ((C.E.) 27 Prisons (D.G)

28 Prosecution (Director) 29 Rehabilitation (Joint Secy.) 30 Renewable Energy (Director) 31 Revenue Training Institute (Principal)

32 Science & Technology (Director) 33 Technical Educatio(Director)

34 Tourism (Director) 35 State Transport Controller (State Transport)

36 Treasuries & Accounts (Director) 37 Urban Local Bodies(Director)

38 Urban Estates (Director) 39 Vigilance (Inquiry Officer) 40 State Vigilance Bureau (Director)

41 Vigilance Department, Haryana

51

Board & Coorporations

1 Agro-Industries Corpn. Ltd. (Chairman) 2 Backward Classes & Economically Weaker Sections Kalyan Nigam (Chairperson)

3 Board of Ayurvedic & Unani Systems of Medicine (Chairman) 4 Council of Homoeopathic System of Medicine (Chairman)

5 Command Area Development Authority (Administrator) 6 Coop. Apex Bank Ltd. (Chairman)

7 Coop. Dev. Fed. Ltd. (M.D) 8 Coop. Housing Fed Ltd. (Chairman)

9 Coop. Labour & Construction Fed. Ltd. (Chairman) 10 Coop. Agri. & Rural Dev. Bank Ltd. (M.D)

11 Fed of Consumers Coop. Wholesale Stores Ltd. (CONFED) (Chairman) 12 State Counseling Board (Chairman)

13 Vidyut Prasaran Nigam (HVPN) (Chairman) 14 Power Generation Corpn. (HPGC) (Chairman) 15 Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam (Chairman) 16 Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam (Chairman) 17 Vidyut Prasaran Nigam (HVPN) (Chairman) 18 Power Generation Corpn. (HPGC) (Chairman) 19 Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam (Chairman) 20 Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam (Chairman) 21 Financial Corpn. (HFC) (Chairman)

22 Handloom & Handicrafts Corpn. Ltd. (Chairman) 23 Scheduled Castes Finance & Dev. Corpn. Ltd.(Chairman)

24 Housing Board (Chairperson) 25 Small Inds. & Export Corpn. Ltd. (Chairman)

26 Indl. Coop. Fed Ltd. (Liquidator) 27 Industrial & Infrastructure Dev. Corpn. Ltd. (HSIIDC) (Chairman)

29 Kala Parishad (Vice-Chairman) 30 Land Use Board (Director-cum-Member Secy.)

31 Livestock Dev. Board (Chairman) 32 Shri Mata Mansa Devi Shrine Board (Chairman)

33 Medical Council (President) 34 State Dental Council (President)

35 Nurses Registration Council(President) 36 Mewat Development Agency(Chairman) 37 Minor Irrigation & Tubewells Corpn. Ltd. (MITC) (M.D)

38 Overseas Placement Assistance Society (HOPAS) ( Chairman) 39 Pharmacy Council(Registrar)

40 Police Housing Corpn. Ltd. (Chairman) 41 Pollution Control Board (Chairman) 42 Haryana Prathmik Shiksha Pariyojna Parishad (President)

43 Haryana Panjabi Sahitya Akademi (Chairman)) 44 Rajya Sainik Board (Secy.)

45 Renewable Energy Development Agency (HAREDA) (Chairman) 46 Roads & Bridge Dev. Corpn. Ltd. (Chairman)

47 Rural Dev. Fund Admn. Board (HRDF) (Chairperson) 48 SAMVAD (Chairman)

49 Haryana Sahitya Akedemi (Chairman)

52

50 Sanskrit Akademi(Chairman) 51 Sanskritic Akademi (Member Secy.)

52 Council for Science & Technology(Chairman/EC) 53 Shivalik Development Board (C.M)

54 Slum Clearance Board (Chief Admtr.) 55 Social welfare Board (Chairperson) 56 Swatantrata Sainik Samman Samiti (Chairman)

57 Tourism Dev. Corpn. Ltd.(Chairperson) 58 Urban Development Authority (HUDA) (C.A)

59 Panchkula Circle (Admn. (P)) 60 Haryana Urdu Akademi (Chairman)

61 Warehousing Corpn. (Chairman) 62 Haryana Women Dev. Corpn. (Chairperson)

63 Swarana Jayanti Shahari Rozgar Yojana & Urban Dev. Society (Proj. Dir) 64 Council for Child Welfare (President)

65 Wakf Board (Chairman) 66 Welfare Society for Hearing & Speech Handicapped (President)

67 Blindness Control Society (Chairperson) 68 Indian Red Cross Society (President)

69 Bhartiya Grameen Mahila Sangh (President) 70 Hind Kusht Nivaran Sangh, Hr. (President) 71 Saket Council (President)

72 State Election Commission, Haryana 73 Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC)

74 Lokayukta Haryana 75 Haryana State Commission for women (Pkl.)

76 Shri Mata Sheetla Devi Shrine Board Gurgaon 77 State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (Secretary)

78 Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Rohtak (Director)

Commissioner

1 Commissioner, Ambala Division, Ambala 2 Commissioner, Hisar Division, Hisar.

Deputy Commissioners

1 Deputy Commissioner, Ambala

2 Deputy Commissioner, Bhiwami 3 Deputy Commissioner, Faridabad 4 Deputy Commissioner, Fatehabad 5 Deputy Commissioner, Gurgaon 6 Deputy Commissioner, Hisar

7 Deputy Commissioner, Jind 8 Deputy Commissioner,Karnal 9 Deputy Commissioner, Kaithal

10 Deputy Commissioner, Kurukshetra 11 Deputy Commissioner, Mahendergarh (Narnaul)

12 Deputy Commissioner, Mewat (Nuh) 13 Deputy Commissioner, Palwal

53

14 Deputy Commissioner, Panipat 15 Deputy Commissioner, Panchkula 16 Deputy Commissioner, Rohtak 17 Deputy Commissioner, Sirsa

District & Sessions Judge

1 District & Sessions Judge, Ambala 2 District & Sessions Judge, Bhiwani 3 District & Sessions Judge, Faridabad 4 District & Sessions Judge, Fatehabad 5 District & Sessions Judge, Gurgaon 6 District & Sessions Judge, Hisar 7 District & Sessions Judge, Jind 8 District & Sessions Judge, Jhajjar 9 District & Sessions Judge, Kaithal 10 District & Sessions Judge, Karnal 11 District & Sessions Judge, Kurukshetra 12 District & Sessions Judge, Mahendergarh at Narnaul

13 District & Sessions Judge, Mewat at Nuh 14 District & Sessions Judge, Panchkula

15 District & Sessions Judge, Panipat 16 District & Sessions Judge, Palwal 17 District & Sessions Judge, Rewari 18 District & Sessions Judge, Rohtak 19 District & Sessions Judge, Sirsa 20 District & Sessions Judge, Sonepat 21 District & Sessions Judge, Yamuna Nagar

Administrative Secretaries

1 Political Department

2 Environment Department 3 Food & supplied Department & Secretary office of LokayuktHaryana

4 Urban Local Bodies Department 5 Cooperation Department

6 Women & Child Development Department 7 Finance & IFCC & Planning Departments 8 Transport & Civil Aviation Department

9 Power Department 10 Technical Education & Industrial Training Department

11 Town & Country Planning & Urban Estates Department 12 Irrigation Department

13 Tourism & Housing Departments 14 Higher Education & Languages Department

15 Animal Husbandry & Dairying Department & Member Secretary, Third State Finance Commission, Haryana 16 Science & Technology & Renewable Energy Sources Department

17 Archaeology & Museums Department 18 Welfare of SCs & BCs Department 19 School Education, Labour & Employment Departments & Chairperson, Haryana Minerals Ltd. New Delhi

54

20 Development & Panchayats Department & Secretary BAC & Commissioner Gurdwara Elections Haryana 21 Information & Public Relations, Cultural Affairs & Grievances Departments

22 Social Justice & Empowerment Department 23 C&S, Fisheries Department

24 Chief Electoral Officer, Haryana, Elections Department & Director Renewable Energy Sources, Haryana 25 Secretary to Governor, Haryana

55

Annexure-‘D’ DETAILS OF PENALTY IMPOSED UPON THE STATE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER

UNDER SECTION 20(1) OF THE RTI Act, 2005 by the Commission. During 1.1.2012 to 31.12.2012

Case No. Date of Decision

Amount of Penalty Imposed

detail of defaulter SPIO Name / Address of the Public Authority

755/2011 in 152/2011

30.11.2011 25000/- Dr. Rajpal LambaVs Director, National Rural Health Mission, Haryana, Panchkula

Sh. N.K. Gupta, SPIO-cum-Deputy Director O/o Director, National Rural Health Mission, Haryana, Panchkula.

436/2011 in 1179/2011

27.1.2012 10000/- Sh. Rajeev SachdevaVs HUDA, Panchkula Estate Officer, HUDA, Sector 6, Panchkula.

760/2011 in 425/2011 in 1487/2011

1.2.2012 25000/- Sh. Maya Chand Vs Sh. Ram Avtar Gupta the then District Revenue Officer-cum-SPIO, Rohtak (now Land Acquisition Officer, HUDA, Gurgaon)

District Revenue Officer, Rohtak

516/2011 in 1408/2011

8.2.2012 5000/- Sh. Om ParkashVs Block Development Panchayat Officer, AteliNangal

Sh. HarBhagwan, SPIO-cum-Block Development Panchayat Officer, AteliNangal, Mahendergarh.

916/2011 in 3111/2011

8.2.2012 5000/- Sh. Ram DevVs Block Development Panchayat Officer, AteliNangal

Sh. HarBhagwan, SPIO-cum-Block Development PanchayatOfficer, AteliNangal, Mahendergarh.

789/2011 in 2916/2010

28.2.2012 5000/- Sh. Rajesh Kumar Vs HUDA, Sonepat SPIO-cum-Estate Officer, HUDA, Sonepat.

56

728/2010 IN 3040/2010

13.3.2012 10000/- Sh. Om ParkashVs District Development Education Offcier, Mewat at Nuh

SPIO-cum-District Development Education Officer, Mewat at Nuh

920/2011 in 768/2011 in 2415/2011

19.3.2012 5000/- Sh. HarinderDhingraVs HUDA, Gurgaon. The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula.

83/2012 in 4522/2011

19.3.2012 15000/- Sh. Ramesh ChhabraVs HUDA, Faridabad The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula.

72/2012 in 868/2011 in 1924/2011

19.3.2012 15000/- Sh. Om ParkashMiglaniVs Sh. ArvindMalhan, the then SPIO-cum-Estate Officer, HUDA, Faridabad now posted as Additional Deputy Commissioner, Jind (Rs.10000/-) & Sh. Jai Bhagwan, present SPIO-cum-Suptd. O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Faridabad (Rs.5000/-).

The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula.

74/2012 in 854/2011 in 2630/11

19.3.2012 10000/- Sh. Bhim Singh Vs Sh. ArvindMalhan, the then SPIO-cum-Estate Officer, HUDA & Land Acquisition Officer, Faridabad now posted as Additional Deputy Commissioner, Jind.

The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Developmet Authority, Sec-6, Panchkula

80/2012 in 534/2011 in 322/2011 in 2556/2009

19.3.2012 10000/- Sh. Mohinder Pal Vs HUDA, Faridabad. The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula.

81 & 82/2012 in 874/2011 in

19.3.2012 15000/- Sh. Vikas Kumar Gupta Vs Sh. B.S. Kali Raman, the then SPIO-cum-Estate Officer,

The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6,

57

4039/2011 HUDA, Faridabad (Rs.10000/-) and present SPIO-cum-Sub Divisional Engineer (Survey) O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Faridabad (Rs.5000/-)

Panchkula.

85/2012 in 950/2011 in 3945/2011

20.3.2012 5000/- Sh. Balbir Singh Vs HUDA, Gurgaon The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula.

878/2011 in 739 & 740/2011 in 2638/2011

20.3.2012 10000/- Sh. Surinder Singh Vs HUDA, Rewari. The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula.

947/2011 in 4358/2011

20.3.2012 10000/- Sh. Om ParkashVs HUDA, Gurgaon Deemed SPIO-cum-Sub Divisional Engineer (Survey) O/o Estate Officer-II, HUDA, Gurgaon.

65/2012 & 875/2011 in 2386/11

20.3.2012 10000/-

Dr. YashYadavVs HUDA, Rewari Rs.6000/- on the then SPIO-cum-Estate Officer, HUDA, Rewari.

Rs.4000/- on Present SPIO-cum-Deputy Suptd. O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Rewari.

22/2012 in 20.3.2012 3500/- Sh. BhanuParkashVs Sh. Desh Raj, SPIO- The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban

58

3542/2011 cum-Deputy Suptd., O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Rewari.

Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula.

5/2012 in 460/2011 20.3.2012 5000/- Sh. Aakash Aggarwal Vs Deemed SPIO-cum-SDE, HUDA, Survey Sub Division No. 1, Gurgaon.


948/2011 in 2795/2011

20.3.2012 10000/- Sh. Manoj Kumar Vishvakarma Vs SPIO-cum-XEN, Div-III, HUDA, Gurgaon (Rs. 5000/-) and Sh. S.K. Rana, the deemed SPIO-cum-SDE (Survey) O/o Estate Officer-I, HUDA, Gurgaon (Rs.5000/-).


55/2012 in 3866/2011

26.3.2012 10000/- Sh. Shakti Chand Vs Land Acquisition Officer, PKL

SPIO-cum-Land Acquisition Officer, Urban Estate, Haryana, Panchkula.

SCN 111/2012 in 2792/2011

3.4. 2012 5000/- Deputy Supdtt Office of E.O ,HUDA ,Rewari

Shri Braham Dev Yadav vs EO,HUDA,Rewari.

SCN 51/2012 in 3717/2011

12.4. 2012 5000/- XEN,HUDA,Div.II ,Hisar. Shri.H.L.Mittal vs XEN, HUDA, Div-II, Hisar.

SCN 17/2012 in 3276/2011

1.5.2012 2000/- Shri Maha Singh VS SPIO –cum-District Elementary Education Officer, Panipat

Director School Education.

SCN 15/2012 in case 3275/2011

1.5.2012 2000/- Shri Maha Singh Vs SPIO –cum-District Elementary Education Officer, Panipat.

Director School Education

SCN 121/2012 in 4648-A

14.5.2012 2000/- Shri Tayab Vs SPIO-Cum-Principal, YasinMeo Degree College, Nuh, District Mewat

Higher Education Commissioner.

59

SCN 210/2012 in 3289/2011

22.05.2012 1000/- Shri.Bijender Kumar VS Superintendent (Teacher Estt-II), O/o Director, Elementary Education Department, Haryana, Panchkula.


SCN 578/2011 in case no 1329/2011

28.5.2012 10,000 Sh.Aseem Takyar VS SPIO-cum-Executive Engineer, HUDA, Division No. II, Gurgaon

Chief Administrator, HUDA, Panchkula.

729/2010 in case no 2063/10

11.5.2012 2000/- Sh. Bhagwat Prasad Vs SPIO O/o Director , School Education, Haryana, Shiksha Sadan, Sector-5, Panchkula.


223/2012 in case no 4210/2011

7.06.2012 2000/- Sh. Jitender Pal S/o Sh. Karamnarayan Vs SPIO-cum- Superintendent (Estt.T) office of Director Elementary Education Department, Haryana Shiksha Sadan Secotr-5 , Panchkula.


2158/2012 18.6.2012 1000/- Sh. Kanti Parshad Vs Deputy Commissioner of Police (HQ), Faridabad.

Director General of Police, Haryana, Panchkula.

224/2012 in case no 3605/2011

18.6.2012 1000/- Shri. Anupam Goyal Vs SPIO-cum-Block Education Officer, Bhiwani.

The Commissioner & Director General, School Education, Haryana, 30 Bays Building, Sector 17, Chandigarh.

762/2011 ,763/2011 in case no .1628/2011

21.06.12 15000/- Sh. P.K. Gupta PHP Div-3, Bhiwani=5000, and D.K Gambhir Executive Engineer Div-I=10000

The Engineer-in-Chief, Public Works (Water Supply and Sanitation), Bay 13-18, Sector 4, Panchkula

60

4597/2011 22.6.2012 1000/- Shri S.K. BindalVs SPIO-cum- Associate Professor, Sanatan Dharam Mahila Mahavidhyalaya Society, Hansi (Hisar)

Higher Education Commissioner, Haryana, ShikshaSadan, Sector 5, Panchkula.

1643/2012 22.6.2012 5000/- Shri S.K. Bindal VS SPIO-cum- Associate Professor , Sanatan Dharma Mahia Mahavidyalaya Society, Hansi (Hisar)

Higher Education Commissioner, Haryana, ShikshaSadan, Sector-5, Panchkula.

719/2011 in case 1740/2010

22.06.12 15000/- Sh. Ram Mehar Sharma S/o Sh. Rai Singh Sharma VS SPIO-cum-Director (Training) O/o Director General, Health Services, Haryana.

Director General Health Service , Haryana, Sector-6 , Panchkula

188/2012 in case no 2147/2011

25.6.12 5000/- Sh. Aseem Takyar Vs SPIO O/o Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd., Plot No.C-13& 14, Sector-6, Panchkula.

Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd.

172/2012 in case no 4001/2011

26.6.12 25000/- Sh. Dharamvir Singh Vs SPIO-cum- Registrar, Birth and Death, Kurukshetra.

Registrar, Birth and Death, Kurukshetra.

147/2012 in case no 1092/12

3.7.2012 5000/- Sh. Surender SinghDhillonVs Superintendent, Estate officer, HUDA, Rewari.

The Chief Administrator HUDA, Sector-6, Panchkula.

SCN 63/2012 in 3.7.2012 5000/- MrsDhanpatiChaudhary VS HUDA, Rewari. The Chief Administrator HUDA,

61

appeal case no. 4363/2011

Sector-6, Panchkula

150/2012 In case no 1147/2011

4.7.2012 10000/- Lt. Col J.K. Kaushal (Retd) Vs SPIO-cum-Deputy Superintendent (2). SPIO-cum-Shri A,k.Maggu, the then Executive Engineer HUDA Division-II, Gurgaon. (3) SPIO-cum- Superintending Engineer , HUDA Circle, Karnal, Sub- Divisional Engineer (Survey), Sub Division No.I, Gurgaon. (4) SPIO-cum- Assistant in–charge of Sector 22, Gurgaon. All SPIOs to Pay 2500 each.


736/2011 In case no 2379/2011

4.7.2012 5000/- Sh. Hemant Saini Vs District Child Welfare Officer, Rewari.


83/2012 in case no 4522/2011

16.7.2012 10000/- Sh. Ramesh Chhabra Vs SPIO-cum- Superintendent O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Faridabad.


81/2012 and 82/2012 in SCN 874/2011 in Appeal Case No.4039/2011

16.7.2012 10000/-

Sh. Vikas Kumar Gupta Vs SPIO-cum Superintendent O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Faridabad.


312/2012 in case no 2260/1202

23.7.2012 5000/- Sh. Devi Ram Sharma Vs Irrigation Department.

Engineer-in-Chief, Irrigation Department, Haryana, Sinchai, Bhawan Sector-5 Panchkula.

904 and 134/2011 in case

26.7.2012 2000/- Sh. M.C. Sharma Vs District Elementary Education Department, Haryana.


62

no 3400/2010

266/2011 in case no 1460/2011

23.08.2012 2000/- Sh. S.K. Bindal , Advocate vs Sanatan Dharam Mahila Mahavidyalaya Hansi.


264/2011 in case no :1377/2011

23.08.2012 2000/- Sh. S.K.Bindal , Advocate Sanatan Dharam Mahila Mahavidyalaya, Hansi, Hisar.


263/2011 in appeal case no.1378/2011

23.08.2012 2000/- Sh.S.K. Bindal, Advocate Vs Sanatan Dharam Mahila Mahavidyalaya, Hansi.


256/2011 in case no:1468/2011

30.8.2012 2000/- Sh. Devender Singh VS District Elementary Education Officer, Rewari.


285/2012 in case no. 1507/2012

26.10.2012 5000/- Smt. Sushila Devi Vs EO, HUDA, Sector-01, Rewari.


481/2012 in SCN. 708/2011 in Appeal case no. 3021/2011

26.10.2012 10000/- Sh. A.P. Nagrath Vs HUDA, Sector-56, Gurgaon.


404/2012 in case no. 1757/2012

26.10.2012 5000/- Sh. Kuldeep Singh Vs HUDA, Sector-14, Gurgaon.


222/2012 in case no. 2693/2011

26.10.2012 5000/- Smt. Qaisar Jahan Vs EO-I, HUDA, Sector-14, Gurgaon.


63

286/2012 in case no. 1510/2012

26.10.2012 15000/- Sh. Hari Om Vs HUDA, Rewari. The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula.

487/2012 in case no 2367/2012

22.10.2012 5000/- Smt. RajanaYadav VS Superintendent of Police, Hisar.


501/2012 in case no. 4446/2011

30.10.2012 1000/- Sh. Harinder Dhingra Vs Executive Engineer, OP. Division City, Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited, Gurgaon

The Managing Director, Dakshin Haryana BijliVitran Nigam.

616/2012 in case no. 2294/2011

31.10.2012 25000/- Sh. Hitesh Sharma, SPIO as District Town Planner, Panchkula=20000/- and Sh. Jitender Sihag , SPIO as Senior Town Planner (E&V), Town & Country Planning Department, Haryana=5000/-

Director General Town Country & Planning.

510/2012 in case no. 2171/2012

5.11.2012 10000/- Sh. Fateh Singh Gill Vs Superintending Engineer, Yamuna Water Services Circle, Irrigation Department, Yamunanagar.

Engineer-in-Chief, Irrigation Department, Haryana, SinchaiBhawan, Sector 5, Panchkula.

845/2011 , 928/2011 and 064/2012 in case no. 1277/2011

5.11.2012 25000/- Sh. P.C. Sanghi Vs HUDA, Gurgaon. (5000 each by Sh. Vatsal Vashishta , Sub-Divisional Officer, (Civil), Pataudi, and Sh. Mukesh Solanki , Joint Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Faridabad, and Smt. Krishna Goyal, Deputy Superintendent Office of Adminstrator, HUDA, and SPIO-cum-Executive Engineer , Electrical Division and Rs 3000 by Sh. A.K. Maggu Superintending Engineer

The Chief Administrator, Haryana Urban Development Authority, Sector 6, Panchkula

64

,HUDA, Circle, Karnal, and Rs 2000/- by SPIO-cum- Executive Engineer , HUDA, Rewari.

340 & 646/2012 in complaint case no. 134/2012

6.11.2012 15000/- Sh. Ranjeet S. ChawlaVs Sh. SatishBhardwaj , the then SPIO , as District Revenue Officer, Ambala imposed penalty on 10000/- and Sh. M. S . Sangwan SPIO as Land Acquisition Officer, Panchkula imposed penalty on 5000/-


105/2012 in case no. 4732/2011

6.11.2012 25000/- Smt. Shanti Devi Vs Estate Officer, HUDA, Rohtak.


613/2012 in case no. 3688/2011

6.11.2012 25000/- Sh.Kewal Krishan Khanna Vs State Vigilance Bureau, Haryana. (3000/- by SPIO-cum- State Vigilane Bureau, Panchkula and Rs 22000/- by SPIO-cum- Deputy District Elementary Education Officer, Faridabad).


776/2011 in case no. 2342/2010

15.11.2012 5000/- Sh. Ram Narayan Vs. Secretary , Municipal Committee, Cheeka , Tehsil GulhaCheeka , Distt. Kaithal, Haryana.

The Director Urban & Local Bodies, Haryana, SCO No. 6-7, Sector 17-B, Chandigarh.

494/2012 in case no. 1225

20.11.2012 10000/- Sh. Balwinder Singh Vs. Labour Commissioner, Haryana, Chandigarh.

Labour Commissioner, Haryana, 30 Bays Building, SCO No. 82-83, Sector 17, Chandigarh.

345/2012 in case no. 4562/2012

27.11.2012 5000/- Smt. Parveen Sharma Vs Superintendent O/o Labour Commissioner, Haryana.

Labour Commissioner, Haryana, 30 Bays Building, SCO No. 82-83, Sector 17, Chandigarh.

65

389/2012 in case no. 1834/2012

29.11.2012 5000/- Sh. Rajesh KokchaVs Estate Officer, HUDA, Rewari.


630 and 148/2012 in complaint case

no. 337/2011

30.11.2012 10,000/- Sh. Sant Singh Vs Land Acquisition Officer, Panchkula. (5,000 by SPIO Sh. SatishBhardwaj now posted as District Revenue Officer , Ambala and 5000/- by SPIO-cum- Land Acquisition Officer, Panchkula)


641/2012 in case no. 3184/2012

3.12. 2012 5000/- Sh. Bhudpriye, Advocate Vs Haryana State Coopertaive Supply Marketing Federation Limited, Kurukshetra. (5000/- by Sh. VikasDeswal, State Public Information Officer-cum- District Manager, Haryana State Coopertaive Supply Marketing Federation Limited, Kurukshetra.

Agriculture Marketing Board, MandiBhawan, C-6, Sector 6, Panchkula

68/2012 in case no. 2929/2011

4.12. 2012 6000/- Sh. CharanjiLalVs Sub Divisional Officer, Kaithal. (6000/- given by Sh. Hawa Singh, SPIO-cum-Sub-Divisional Officer, Kaithal.)

Sub Divisional Officer (Civil), Pataudi

629/2012 in case no. 240420/12

5.12. 2012 5000/- Sh. VirenderSingh , Advocate VsDakshin Haryana BijliVitran Nigam Limited, Narnaul. (5000/- by Sh. Ranbir Singh, SPIO-cum- Executive Engineer, OP. Divn. Dakshin Haryana BijliVitran Nigam Limited, Narnaul.

The Managing Director, Dakshin Haryana BijliVitran Nigam.

893/2011 in case no 2249/2011

6.12. 2012 4000/- Sh. Bhupinder Pal Singh VsNaibTehsildar, Bhuna (4000/- given by Sh. Mohinder Kumar).

Sub Divisional Officer (Civil), Pataudi

66

473/2012 in case no. 3129/2011

12.12. 2012 10000/- Sh. ShishpalVs Block Development and Panchayats Officer, Thanesar. (10000/- is given by Sh. Partap Singh, SPIO-cum-BDPO).

The Director Development and Panchayats, Haryana, PanchyatBhawan, Plot No. 3, Sector 28-A, Chandigarh.

942/2011 in case no. 2942/2011

12.12. 2012 10000/- Sh. Didar Singh Vs Block Development and Panchayat Officer, Thanesar, District Kurukshetra. (10000/- is given by sh. PartapSingh , SPIO-cum-Block Development &Panchyats Officer, Thanesar)


19 & 20/2012 in case no. 0341/2011

12.12. 2012 5000/- Sh. Ram KishanVs District Development and Panchayats Officer, Yamunanagar.(5000/- given by Sh. Jag Ram Mann, SPIO-cum-District Development Panchayats Officer, Yamunanagar)


156/2012 in case no. 3317/2010

17.12. 2012 5000/- Sh. Hemant Singh Vs Deputy Superintendent officer of Estate Officer, Rewari.


469/2012 in complaint no. 25/2012 in case no. 3023/2011

17.12. 2012 7500/- Sh. B.K. SahniVs Executive Engineer, HUDA, Division-II, Gurgaon. (7500/- each is imposed on Sh. A.K. Makhen, the SPIO-cum-Executive Engineer, HUDA, Division No-II, Gurgaon, and Sh. AmitRathee, Sub Divisional Engineer, HUDA, Sub Division No. 7, Gurgaon)


157/2012 in case no. 3834/2011

20.12. 2012 25000/- Sh. Kuldeep Singh Vs Deputy Director , Fisheries Department, Haryana, Gurgaon. ( 25000/- is given by Sh. C. D. Yadav, SPIO-cum- Deputy Director , Fisheries Department,

Fisheries Department.

67

Haryana, Gurgaon.)

736/2012 in case no. 2996/2012

21.12. 2012 2000/- Smt. Neelam Mohan VsDistirct Red Cross Society.(2000/- by Sh. Balwan Singh Vs SPIO-cum- Secretary, District Red Cross` Society, Ambala).

District Red Cross Society, Narnaul.

68

Annexure-‘E’

List of cases in which recommendations were made to initiate Disciplinary Proceedings

by the Commission. During 1.1.2012 to 31.12.2012

Case No Particular of case Date of Decision

No. defaulter employees

Name of Public Authority

876/2011 in 4099/2011

Sh. Jai Parkash Mavi Vs HUDA, Faridabad 9/2/2012 1 Chief Administrator, HUDA, Panchkula

4514/2011 Sh. HarinderDhingraVs HUDA, Gurgaon 10/2/2012 1 Chief Administrator, HUDA, Panchkula

899/2011 in 391/2011

Sh. AshishNarangVs HUDA, Gurgaon 10/2/2012 Responsibility to be fixed

Chief Administrator, HUDA, Panchkula

921/2011 in 4349/2011

Mrs. ChanchalKapoorVs HUDA, Gurgaon 10/2/2012 Responsibility to be fixed

Chief Administrator, HUDA, Panchkula.

84/2012 in 534/2011 in 4364/2011

Sh. InderjitGoyalVs HUDA, Faridabad 19/3/2012 1 Sh. B.S. Kali Raman, the then SPIO-cum-Estate Officer, HUDA, Faridabad.

85/2012 in 950/2011 in 3945/2011

Sh. Balbir Singh Vs HUDA, Gurgaon 20/3/2012 2 Sh. Ramesh Saini of Survey Branch and Sh. Vishav Kumar, Clerk.

937/2011 & 738/2011 in 2791/2011

Sh. Devender Kumar Vs HUDA, Gurgaon 20/3/2012 1 Sh. Ramesh Saini of Survey Branch,

954/2011 in 2787/2011

Sh. Ashok Kumar DhingraVs HUDA, Gurgaon 20/3/2012 2 SPIO-cum-Estate Officer-II, HUDA, Gurgaon.

69

1348/2012 Sh. Rajesh Sharma , Advocate VS Land Acquistion Officer, Gurgaon.

16/4/2012 2 Additional Director (Urban Estate ) Haryana, Panchkula.

SCN 53/2012 in case no 2797/2011

Mrs. QaisarJahan VS Estate Officer-I, HUDA, Gurgaon

16/05/2012 1 Chief Administrator, HUDA

33/2012 Sh.Gaurav Kumar Vs Superintendent, Administrative reforms Department.

19/6/2012 1 Chief Secretary to Government, Haryana.

221/2012 in case no. 4812/2011

Sh. Khem Chand Vs Superintendent of Police, Bhiwani.

3/10/2012 1 Director General of Police, Haryana, Panchkula.

550/2012 in case no. 2209/2012

Sh. Ramesh Verma Vs Estate Officer-II, HUDA, Gurgaon.

19/11/2012 1 Chief Administrator, HUDA, Panchkula.

635/2012 in case no. 3437/2012

Sh. Manoj Tiwari Vs Deputy Superintendent O/o Estate Officer-II, HUDA, Sector-56, Gurgaon

11/12/2012 1 Chief Administrator, HUDA, Panchkula.

70

Annexure-‘F’

DETAILS OF COMPENSATION AWARDED TO THE APPEALLANTS/COMPLAINANTS UNDER SECTION 19 (8) (B) OF THE RTI ACT, 2005 DURING 1.1.2012 to 31.12.2012

Case No. Date of Decision

Amount of compensation

Detail of Parties

2225/11 23.11.2011 5000/- Sh. Ranjit Singh Vs Deputy Commissioner, Rewari.

2752/11 29.11.2011 5000/- Sh. Attar Singh Dalal Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3275/11 7.12.2011 2000/- Sh. Maha Singh Vs District Elementary Education Officer, Panipat.

3276/11 7.12.2011 2000/- Sh. Maha Singh Vs District Elementary Education Officer, Panipat.

3568/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Ram Niwas Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3570/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Smt. Leela Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3571/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Raghbir Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3561/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Satbir Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3562/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Jagdish Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3567/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Naresh Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar

3564/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Surte Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3566/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Naresh Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3569/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Baljeet Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3572/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Bhane Ram Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

71

3573/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Hardeva Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3563/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Krishan Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3565/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Manphool Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

3574/2011 3.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Mahender Vs Deputy Commissioner, Jhajjar.

2835/2011 4.1.2012 1000/- Sh. Ahmed Jan Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula

3366/2011 10.1.2012 1000/- Smt. Murti Devi Vs Uttar Haryana Bijali Vitran Nigam Limited, Rohtak.

3204/2011 10.1.2012 500/- Sh. Ramesh Chander Saihgal Vs Food & Supplies Department

606/2011in 2796/2011

12.1.2012 1000/- Sh. Sukhdev Singh Vs Urban Estates, Haryana, Panchkula

3376/2011 13.1.2012 500/- Sh. Rajinder Singh Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

3358/2011 18.1.2012 700/- Sh. Gopi Chand Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

213 & 214/2011 in 323/2010

30.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Jatinder Singh Vs HUDA, Karnal

642/2011 in 1837/2011

31.1.2012 2000/- Sh. Kewal K Khanna Vs Deputy Director, School Education, Haryana.

823/2011 in 3340/2011

2.2.2012 2000/- Sh. Ravinder Nath Vs Land Acquisition Officer, Urban Estate, Haryana, PKL.

72

4496/2011 6.2.2012 3000/- Sh. Om Parkash Madaan Vs HUDA, Hisar.

4498/2011 6.2.2012 1000/- Sh. Jeet Ram Vs Deputy Superintendent O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Hisar.

4726/2011 10.2.2012 2000/- Sh. Rama Kant Rohilla Vs Estate Officer-I, HUDA, Gurgaon.

4514/2011 10.2.2012 2000/- Sh. Harinder Dhingra Vs Estate Officer-II, HUDA, Gurgaon.

4363/2011 10.2.2012 3000/- Smt. Dhanpati Chaudhary Vs Estate Officer, HUDA, Rewari.

2331/2011 10.2.2012 1000/- Sh. Dhalu Ram Vs Director, School Education, Haryana.

4507/2011 14.2.2012 1000/- Sh. Anand Kumar Vs LAO, HUDA Complex, Sector 12, Faridabad.

3166/2011 21.2.2012 1000/- Sh. Rajesh Kumar Vs District Education Officer, Jhajjar.

1821/2011 22.2.2012 500/- Sh. Ram Mehar Vs Director, School Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

1835/2011 22.2.2012 500/- Sh. Rajinder Singh Vs Director, School Education, Haryana.

3646/2011 23.2.2012 2000/- Sh. Raj Singh Vs Director, School Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

4732/2011 27.2.2012 1000/- Smt. Shanti Devi Vs HUDA, Rohtak.

SCN 330/2012 in case no 4729/2011

27.2.2012 2000/- Major Neki Ram Sharma Vs HUDA, Hisar.

3028/10 20.10.10 500/- Sh. Krishan Sihag Vs DSE, Haryana, Chandigarh.

17/2011, 18/2011 in case no

1.3.2012 500/- Sh. Jagdish Prasad Kaushik Vs. Director, School Education, Haryana, Hry., Chd.

73

3013/10

1782/2011 2.3.2012 1000/- Sh. Hari Om Vs FC&PS to Govt. Haryana, Education Department.

4889/2011 7.3.2012 1000/- Sh. Mahavir Singh Vs Transport Commissioner, Haryana, Chd.

4879/2011 15.3.2012 5000/- Sh. Om Parkash Kadian Vs HUDA, Panchkula.

3940/2011 20.3.2012 2000/- Sh. Kishori Lal Vs Deputy Excise and Taxation, Narnaul Distt. Mahendergarh.

1092/2012 20.3.2012 2000/- Sh. Surinder Singh Dhillon Vs HUDA, Rewari.

4877/2011 20.3.2012 2000/- Smt. Rakhi Devi Vs HUDA, Rewari.

24/2012 in 2173/2011

20.3.2012 3000/- Sh. Rajender Rathee Vs Estate Officer-I & II, HUDA, Gurgaon & CA, HUDA, Panchkula.

2035/2011 21.3.2012 2000/- Sh. Rajinder Kumar Vs Director School Education, Haryana, Sector 5, Panchkula.

1523/2010 21.3. 2012 3000/- Sh. Zile Singh Mehra Administrative Officer Vs Director School Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

3853/2011 22.3.2012 1000/- Sh. Tej Bhan Vs Director General Health Services, Haryana , Sector-6, Panchkula.

3168/2011 28.3.2012 1000/- Sh. Rajesh Kumar Vs Director School Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

3772-A 29.3. 2012 500/- Sh. Satish Kumar vs HSSC,Pkl.

3772- B 29.3. 2012 1000/- Sh. Satish Kumar vs HSSC,Pkl.

4379/11 14.7.11 2000/- Sh.Hemant Saini vs DSWO,Rewari.

2806/10 16.8.11 2000/- Sh.R.L.Arora Vs HUDA,Pkl.

2093/11 20.9.11 5000/- Sh.Vivek Sharma vs Deputy Registrar ,KuKUniversity

74

2792/11 4.10.11 2000/- Sh.Braham Dev Yadav vs E.O,HUDA,Rewari.

SCN 933/2011 in 1796/2011

2.4. 2012 3000/- Sh.Ashwani Kumar vs E.O,HUDA,Panipat.

SCN 721/2011n 133/11

3.4. 2012 5000/- Sh. Tara Singh vs Director ,Consolidation ,Haryana ,Chandigarh.

1607/2011 3.4. 2012 5000/- Sh.Rajiv Kumar vs Principal Kurukshetra College of Education.Dhurala.

1212/2012 10.4. 2012 1000/- Shri Inder Singh vs DG State,Transport,Haryana,Chandigarh.

429/2011 10.4. 2012 1000/- Shri.Suresh Goel vs BPS,Mahila Vishaw Vidyalaya,Khanpur Kalan,Sonipat.

428/2011 10.4.2012 1000/- Sh. Suresh Goel Vs Mahila Vishwavidyalaya, Khanpur Kalan, Sonipat.



1284/2012 11.4. 2012 500/- Sh.Ram Kanwar vs I.G.P, Panchkula.

1198/2012 16.4. 2012 2000/- Sh.Prem Kumar vs E.O-II, HUDA, Gurgaon.

SCN 27/2012 in 2298/2011

16.4. 2012 3000/- Sh.J.B.Hooda vs E.O.I ,HUDA, Gurgaon.

SCN 76/2012 in 3867/2011

16.4. 2012

3000/- Sh.Rajveer Singh vs E.O-II,HUDA, Gurgaon

SCN 16.4. 2012 2000/- Sh.Kanwar Singh vs XEN,HUDA Division- IV , Gurgaon.

75

5420/2012 in 2082/2011

2812/2011 17.4. 2012 500/- Sh.Phool Singh vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission,Pkl.

SCN 718/2011 in 1491/11

24.4. 2012 600/- Smt.Shanti Devi Gupta vs City Magisterate ,NNL

2536/2011 24.4. 2012 600/- Sh.Bhoop Singh Baghel vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission,Pkl.

1351/2012 25.4. 2012 1000/- Smt.Asha Devi vs E.O ,HUDA,Pkl.

3986/2011 30.4. 2012 2000/- Shri.Dinesh Kumar vs Public Health Engineering Department,Pkl.

3808/2011 2.05.2012 1000/- Sh.Panna Lal Vs Divisional Forest Officer, Mohindergarh.

SCN 900/2011 in case no. 3742/2011

3.05.2012 1000/- Sh.R.K. Aggarwal Vs Estate Officer, HUDA, Panchkula.

2867/2011 4.05.2012 2000/- Sh.Mohinder Kumar VS Director, School Education, Haryana.

2369/2011 4.05.2012 2000/- Sh.Dull Chand Legha VS Director, School Education Haryana, Panchkula.

SCN 882/2011 in case no 2918/2011

15.05.2012 5000/- Sh.Dalbir Singh VS District Social Welfare Officer, Bhiwani.

Complaint Case no.399/20

17.05.2012 500/- Sh.Ravinder Kumar Vs Director, School Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

76

11

3843/2011 17.5. 2012 500/- Shrimati Shaymo Vs Tehsildar, Bahadurgarh, Distt. Jhajjar.

4346/2011 17.05.2012 2000/- Sh.O.P.Meel Vs Executive Engineer, Research.

1516/2012 17.05.2012 2000/- Sh. Vinod Kumar VS Chief Administration, HUDA, Panchkula.

3891/2011 17.05.2012 500/- Sh.Suraj Bhan Vs Tehsildar, Bahadurgarh, Distt. Jhajjar.

Show Cause Notice 223/2012 in 4210/2011

18.05.2012 500/- Shri Jitender Pal S/o Sh.Karam Narayan Vs Director Elementary Education Department, Haryana, Shiksha Sadan Sector-5 Panchkula.

1255/2012 18.5.2012 500/- Sh.Vijay Winner S/o Sh. Ved Parkash Vs Director Elementry Education Department, Haryana.

Complaint Case no 6920/12

21.05.2012 1000/- Sh.Prem Singh S/o Sh. Hoshiar Singh Vs Regional Transport Authority, Jind.

SCN 832/2011 in case 1725/2011

22.05.2012 5000/- Sh. Manish Kumar Vs City Magistrate, Mahendergarh.

SCN 858/2011 in case 1730/2011

22.05.2012 5000/- Sh. Ram Chander Vs City Magistrate, Mahendergarh.

118820/12 23.05.2012 1000/- Sh.Harish Chander VS Regional Transport Authority, Rohtak.

77

Complaint case no 89/2012 in case no 4162/2011

25.05.2012 5000/- Sh.Sandeep Panwar Vs Land Acquistion Officer, Panchkula.

4181/2011 25.05.2012 5000/- Sh.R.K.Mittal Vs Public Work Department (B&R) Complex, Chandigarh.

Show Cause Notice 343/2010 in case 1590/2010

28.5.2012 2000/- Shri Pradeep Kumar Sharma Vs Inspector General of Police (personnel ) Haryana.

1617/2012 28.5. 2012 2000/- Sh.Mahesh Kumar Vs Estate Officer, HUDA, Rewari.

1607/2012 28.5. 2012 2000/- Sh.Premlata Soni VS Estate Officer, HUDA, Rewari.

SCN 30/2012 in case no 3141/2011

28.5.2012 2000/- Sh. Harmeet Singh VS Regional Transport Authority, Faridabad.

91/97 of 2012 in case no 3928/2011

29.5.2012 1000/- Sh. Satinder Kumar Vs Block Development & Panchayat Officer, Ladwa.

74/2012 in case no 3217/2011

30.5.2012 5000/- Sh. Kanwal Pal Singh VS Haryana State Industrial & Infrastructure Development Corporation, Panchkula,

3883/2011 31.5.2012 1000/- Sh. Mahavir Singh Vs Director School Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

78

3823/2011 31.5.2012 1000/- Sh. Mahavir Singh Vs Municipal Council , Kurukshetra.

2170/2012 1.6.2012 1000/- Sh. Sunil S/o Sh. Rajmal Vs District Food & Supplies Officer, Hisar.

3897/2011 1.6.2012 1000/- Dr. Ramphal Shastri Vs Secretary, Haryana Public Service Commission.

3922/2011 6.6.2012 2000/- Sh. S.P.Jain Vs Director, School Education, Haryana, Shiksha Sadan, Sector -5, Panchkula.

223/2012 in case no 4210/2011

7.06.2012 500/- Sh. Jitender Pal S/o Sh. Karamnarayan Vs Director Elementary Education Department , Haryana Shiksha Sadan sector-5 , Panchkula.

81/2012 11.06.2012 2000/- Sh. Vikas Gupta Vs Chief Administrator HUDA, Sector-6, Panchkula.

3978/2011 12.6.2012 1000/- Sh. Harish Khanna Vs Assistant Registrar , Cooperative Societies, Faridabad.

1703/2012 14.06. 2012 1000/- Ms. Rama Devi W/o Sh. Hukam Chand Vs Divisional Forest Officer, Mohindergarh

4176/2011 14.06.2012 1000/- Sh. Satish Sharma Vs Finance Department, Chandigarh

1768/2012 18.6. 2012 1000/- Sh. Ram Kumar Vs Civil Surgeon, Sirsa.

1767/2012 18.6. 2012 1000/- Smt. Murti W/O Late Sh. Hukan Chand Vs District Social Welfare Officer, Karnal.

506/2011 in case no .2214/2011

21.6. 2012 2000/- Sh. Satya Narain Vs District Social welfare, Sonepat

1750/2012 26.6. 2012 500/- Sh. Ram Singh Vs Accounts Officer, Haryana Roadways , GTB Nagar, Delhi

2484/2011 15.6.2012 500/- Ms. Neetu VS Secretary, Haryana Public Service Commission, Haryana, Pachkula.

2486/2011 15.6.2012 500/- Ms Neetu VS Secretary, Haryana Public Service Commission.

79

3882/2011 20.6.2012 2000/- Sh. Om Parkash Vs Vocational Education Officer, O/o Director, School Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

4/2012 in case no 2904/2011

22.6.2012 1000/- Sh.Virender Singh Vs Superintendent(Confidential Branch), Haryana Staff Selection Commission

2251/2012 25.6.2012 1000/- Shri. Sachin Chhokar Vs Acting Principal, Gandhi Adarsh College, Samalkha (Panipat)

4050/2011 27.6.2012 1,200/- Col.(Retd) R.K.Sharma Vs O/o Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Haryana, Panchkula.

145/2012 in case no 469/2011

2.7.2012 2000/- Shri Chet Ram Vs Block Development & Panchayat Officer, Hodal.

4156/2011 3.7.2012 1000/- Shri Khazan Singh Hadda Vs Uttar Haryana Bijali Vitran Nigam Limited, Jhajjar.

1537/2012 3.7.2012 1000/- Smt. Santra Vs Forest Department.

1536/2012 3.7.2012 1000/- Smt . Luxmi VS Forest Department.

4154/2011 3.7.2012 1000/- Sh.Mahender Singh Dahiya Vs Haryana Public Service Commission, Panchkula.

1846/2012 3.7.2012 2000/- Sh. Surender Sing Dhillon, Advocate Vs HUDA, Rewari.

23/2012, 79/2012,152/2012, SCN=714/2011 in Appeal Case NO.1181/

3.7.2012 2500/- Major Mahabir Prasad Vs District Town Planner and Land Acquisition Officer, Gurgaon.

80

2011

1820/2012 3.7.2012 2000/- Sh. Dhirender Singh VS HUDA, Rewari.

155/2012 3.7.2012 2000/- Sh. Dinesh Kumar Vs HUDA, Rewari.

1941/2012 3.7.2012 1000/- Smt. Premlata Soni Vs Superintendent, O/o Estate officer, HUDA, Rewari.

1817/2012 3.7.2012 2000/- Sh. Brahm Dutt Vs HUDA, Faridabad.

1911/2012 4.7.2012 2000/- Sh. Ram Partap Vs Public Health Engineering Department Division No.1 Rewari.

1919/2012 4.7.2012 2000/- Sh. Umrao Singh Vs Public Health Engineering Department, Rewari.

439/2011 4.7.2012 1000/- Shri Manesh Kumar Vs Block Development & Panchayat Officer, Palwal.

3736/2011 in SCN 8/2012

5.7.2012 2000/- Shri Dinesh Singhal Vs Deputy Director, Industrial Training Haryana, Chandigarh.

4240/2011 5.7.2012 500/- Sh.Virender Kumar Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

1832/2012 6.7.2012 500/- Sh. Rajesh Sharma VS Land Acquistion Officer, Panchkula.

1907/2012 17.7.2012 1000/- Sh. Malkiat Singh Vs Land Acquisition Officer, Panchkula.

1068/2012 19.7.2012 500/- Sh. Krishan Kant S/o Sh. Des Raj Vs Public Health Engineering Department.

148/2012 in Complaint Case No.337/2011

19.7.2012 10000/- Sh. Sant Singh Advocate Vs Land Acquisition Officer, Panchkula.

2053/2012 16.7.2012 1000/- Shri Abdul Gani Vs Block Development & Panchayats Officer, Mewat.

81

4418/2011 19.7.2012 1000/- Shri Sawarn Singh Vs Block Development & Panchayats Officer, Ateli Nangal , District Mahendergarh.

1069/2012 19.7.2012 1000/- Sh. Sanjay Kumar Vs District Revenue Officer, Bhiwani.

446/2011 in case no 1088/2011

20.7.2012 500/- Ms. Meenakshi Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission.

1258/2012 24.7.2012 600/- Sh. Jasbir Singh VS Sub Divisional Officer, Tohana (Fatehabad)

143/2012 in case no 4132/2011

31.7.2012 1000/- Shri Deepa Ram Vs Block Development & Panchayat Officer, Palwal.

1222/2012 31.7.2012 1000/- Sh. Ravinder S/o Sh. Ram Pariwar Vs Tehsildar, Sahalwas (Jhajjar)

4539/2011 1.8.2012 1000/- Sh. Bajarang Parjapat Vs Director School Education, Shiksha Sadan Sector5, Panchkula.

157/2012 in case no.3834/2011

1.8.2012 1000/- Sh. Kuldeep Singh Vs Deputy Director Fisheries Department, Haryana , Guragaon.

2903/2011 2.8.2012 5000/- Sh. Prem Singh Vs Forest Departmetn. Sector-6, Panchkula.

3101/2011 3.8.2012 1,500/- Sh. Rajesh Kumar Vs FC& PS to Govt. Haryana Secondary Education, Chandigarh.

1073/2012 8.8.2012 1000/- Sh. Diwan Chand Vs Tehsildar Pundri (Kaithal).

4545/2011 9.8.2012 1000/- Sh. Sanjay Yadav Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Sector-2 Panchkula.

1066/2012 9.8.2012 1000/- Sh. Bhot Ram Vs Deputy Commissioner, Mahendergarh.

82

10/2012 in case no :2061/2011

9.8.2012 1500/- Sh. Mahesh Chand Devadi Vs Joint Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Faridabad.

327/2012 in case no.1138/2012

9.8.2012 2000/- Sh. Santosh Kumar Gupta Vs District Education Officer, Jind.

211/2012 in case no:1650/2012

13.8.2012 1000/- Sh. Narender Singh Vs Deputy Civil Surgeon, Kaithal.

SCN:180/2012 in appeal case no.1255/2011

16.08.2012 2000/- Sh. Bharat Goyal Vs District Town Planner O/o Director General Town & Country Planning, Haryana, Chandigarh.

2690/2012 16.08.2012 3000/- Sh. Om Parkash Sharma Vs Director School Education, Haryana, Panchkula.

SCN:167/2012 in Complaint Case No.456/2011 in case no. 2274/2010

21.8.2012 2000/- Sh. Qaisar Jahan Vs Deputy Superintendent, HUDA, Sector-14 Gurgaon.

1712/2012 21.08.2012 1000/- Sh. Bishamber Dayal Vs Deputy Commissioner. Rewari.

83

863/2011 in case no.2399/2010

22.08.2012 15000/- Sh. Bijender Kumar Jain Vs Executive Officer, Municipal Council, Jagadhri.

2540/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Smt. Kamla Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

2497/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Sh. Singh Raj Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh

2538/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Sh. Parveen Kumar Vs Forests Department, Mahendergarh.

2496/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Sh. Ramesh Kumar Vs Consrvator of Forests, Mahendergarh.

3328/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Sh. Balwant Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

1523/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Sh. Randhir Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

3245/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Sh. Dalip Kumar Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

1532/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Smt. Kela Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

1526/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Smt. Angoori Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

3249/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Smt. Lali Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

2511/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Sh. Uday Ram VS Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

1538/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Smt. Rambal Vs Forest Department. Mahendergarh.

2509/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Smt. Bimla Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

1528/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Smt. Kalawat Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

2539/2012 22.08.2012 500/- Sh. Amar Singh Vs Forest Department, Mahendergarh.

2118/2012 23.8.2012 2000/- Sh. Manoj Kumar Vs Deputy Superintendent O/o Estate Offcer-II, HUDA.

84

2208/2012 24.8.2012 1000/- Sh. O.P. Madaan Vs Deputy Superintendent, Estate Officer, HUDA, Sector-13, Hisar.

SCN:11320/12 in Appeal Case no.4037/2011

27.8.2012 5000/- Sh. Surinder Kumar Vs Estate Officer, HUDA, Kaithal.

683/2011 in case no:233/2011

28.8.2012 10000/- Sh. Sat Pal Vs Block Development & Panchayat Officer, Ateli Nagar, District Mahendergarh.

Complaint No.91/2012

30.8.2012 1000/- Sh. Thakur Lal Vs E.S.I. Hospital, NH-3, NIT, Faridabad

2307/2012 30.8.2012 1000/- Sh. Ram Phal Rathi Vs Block Development & Panchayats Officer, Rai, District, Sonipat.

2419/2012 4.09.2012 2000/- Sh. P.P. Kapoor Vs Superintendent o/o Director, Urban Local Bodies, Haryana, Chandigarh.

4640/2011 4.09.2012 1000/- Sh. Satya Narain Gupta Vs Tehsildar, Ambala.

2396/2012 5.09.2012 1000/- Sh. Parmod Kumar Vs Director, Industrial Tranining Department, Haryana, 30 Bays Building, Sector-17, Chandigarh.

1236/2012 6.09.2012 1000/- Sh. Prem Pal Vs Block Development & Panchayat Officer, Bahadurgarh, District, Jhajjar.

1237/2012 6.09.2012 1000/- Sh. Prem Pal Vs Block Development & Panchayat Officer, Bahadurgarh, District,

85

Jhajjar.

1238/2012 6.09.2012 1000/- Sh. Prem Pal Vs Block Development& Panchayats Officer, Bahadurgarh, District, Jhajjar.

1239/2012 6.09.2012 1000/- Sh. Prem Pal Vs Block Development & Panchayat Officer, Bahadurgarh, District, Jhajjar.

1840/2012 6.09.2012 1000/- Sh. Nirmal Khullar Vs Deputy Superintendent o/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Sector-13, Kurukshetra.

2108/2012 6.09.2012 2000/- Sh. Sudhir Kumar Sain Vs Superintendent o/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Sirsa.

3658/2011 10.09.2012 1000/- Sh. Dalbir Chand Vs Secretary o/o Director, Urban Local Bodies Department, SCO 6-7, Sector 17-B, Chandigarh.

4802/2011 12.09.2012 500/- Sh. Devender Singh Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission. Pkl.

1309/2012 13.09.2012 2000/- Sh. Hukam Chand Bhardwaj Vs Deputy District Education Officer, Palwal.

170/2012 in case no. 1153/2012

29.3.2012 2000/- Sh. Ashok Kumar Loomba Vs Land Acquistion Officer, Sector-8, Panchkula.

3554/2012 4.10.2012 1000/- Smt. Shanti Devi Vs HUDA, Hisar.

515/2012 in case no. 4036/2011

4.10.2012 1000/- Sh. Satya Narain Vs Director Town Planner, Jind.

2361/2012 4.10.2012 1000/- Sh. O.P. Madan VS HUDA, Hisar.

3416/2012 8.10.2012 500/- Sh. Shree Krishan Vs Director Elementry Education Department, Haryana, Shiksha Sadan, Sector-5, Panchkula.

86

1882/2012 9.10.2012 1000/- Sh. Ramesh Chhabra Vs Joint Commissioner (T) O/o Municipal Corporation, Faridabad.

4601/2011 9.10.2012 290/- Sh. Jai Bhagwan Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

4301/2011 10.10.2012 1500/- Sh. Baljeet Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

3625/2011 10.10.2012 2000/- Sh. Bhupinder Sharma Vs Haryana State Industrial & Infrastructure Development Corporation, Panchkula,, Panchkula.

1875/2012 10.10.2012 1000/- Sh. Surinder Kumar Vs Urban Local Bodies Department, Haryana, Chandigarh.

4301/2011 10.10.2012 1500/- Sh. Balijeet Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

2526/2012 18.10.2012 300/- Sh. Man Singh Vs Personal Assistant to Cooperation Minister, Haryana.

4287/2011 18.10.2012 1000/- Sh.Balbir Singh Vs Haryana Public Service Commission, Panchkula.

2603/2011 19.10.2012 500/- Sh. Naresh Kumar Vs Secretary, Municipal Council, Bhiwani.

4254/2011 19.10.2012 1000/- Sh. Jagdish Parsad Vs Urban Local Bodies Department, Haryana, Chandigarh.

405/2012 in case no. 1857/2012

26.10.2012 2000/- Sh. Parmod Kumar Vs Superintendent O/o HUDA, Sector-14, Rewari.

1101/2012 30.10.2012 1000/- Sh. Udami Ram Vs Forest Department, Panchkula.

110220/12 30.10.2012 1000/- Sh. Udami Ram Vs Forest Department, Panchkula.

2516/2012 30.10.2012 1000/- Sh. Anil Asija vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

1100/2012 30.10.2012 2000/- Sh. Sanjiv Kumar Vs Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Haryana, Panchkula.

2362/2012

5.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Madan Lal Makkar Vs Assistant Estate Officer O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Sector-6, Panchkula.

87

SCN No. 577/2012 in case no. 88/2012

6.11.2012 3000/- Sh. Ishwar Singh Chhattar Vs Pubic Health Engineering Department, Jind.

1027/2012 6.11.2012 700/- Sh. Virender Kumar Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

2879/2012 6.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Narinder Kumar Vs Municipal Corporation,Ambala.

2524/2012 7.11.2012 500/- Sh. Man Singh Vs Registrar, Cooperative Siceties, Haryana, Pnachkula.

3610/2012 8.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Pardeep Kumar Vs District Elementry Education Officer, Mewat.

464/2012 in case no. 2110/2012

8.11.2012 2000/ Smt. Pista Devi Vs Depurty Superintendent , O/o Estate Officer-I, HUDA, Sector 14, Gurgaon.

470/2012 in case no. 1931/2012

8.11.2012 3000/- Sh. Yashpal , Vs Estate Officer, HUDA, Rohtak.

4141/2011 15.11.2012 1500/- Sh. Om. Parkash Vs Secretary, Municipal Council, Rewari.

3701/2012 19.11.2012 5000/- Mrs. Rani Aruna Vs Deputy Civil Surgeon, Kaithal.

2996/2012 19.11.2012 4000/- Smt. Neelam Mohan vs District Red Cross Society, Ambala.

SCN 240/2012 in case no. 3148/2011

20.11.2012 3000/- Sh. Dilbag Singh Ropria Vs Regional Tranport Authority, Hisar.

2571/2012 20.11.2012 4000/- Sh. Krishan Kumar Vs Tehsildar, Bahadurgarh, District, Jhajjar.

3873/2012 20.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Deen Dayal Soni Vs Director Social Justice & Empowerment.

88

1163/2012 21.11.2012 500/- Sh. Kapil Dev Vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula.

3973/2012 21.11.2012 1000/- Sh. S. P. Sharma Vs Tranport Commissioner, Haryana, Chandigarh.

2531/2012 21.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Ashok Kumar Vs Forest Department,Panchkula.

3090/2012 21.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Manohar Lal Vs Arya Post Graduate College, Panipat.

3092/2012 21.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Manohar Lal vs Arya Post Graduate Colelge, Panipat.

48/2012 23.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Ashok Kumar Vs Forest Department, Pinjore.

4830/2011 26.11.2012 2000/- Sh. Jagjit Singh Vs Forest Department, Panchkula.

2944/2012 26.11.2012 1000/- M/s Ram Singh Om Parkash Vs Mines & Geology Department. Haryana Sector -17, Chandigarh.

2519/2012 26.11.2012 500/- Sh. Surender Kumar Vs Forest Department, Panchkula.

3899/2012 26.11.2012 2000/- Smt. Kreshni Vs Director, Social Justice, and Empowerment.

2879/2012 29.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Sudhi Ranjan Garg Vs Estate Officer, HUDA, Rewari.

2694/2012 30.11.2012 500/- Sh. Man Singh Vs Registrar Cooperative Societies, Haryana, Panchkula.

2720/2012 6.11.2012 1000/- Sh. Narinder Kumar vs Municipal Corporation. Ambala.

3779/2012 3.12.2012 3000/- Sh. Mahender Singh Vs District Education Officer, Panchkula.

628/2012 in case no. 4423/2011

4.12.2012 2000/- Sh. Deepa Ram Vs District Development and Panchayat Officer.

Complaint case no.168/20

5.12.2012 2000/- Smt. Santosh Devi Vs District Elementary Education Department, Panipat.

89

12

2578/2012 5.12.2012 1000/- Sh. Panna Lal Vs Municipal Corporation. Mahendergarh.

2580/2012 5.12.2012 2000/- Sh. Khem Chand Vs Municipal Corporation. Mahendergarh.

2085/2012 5.12.2012 1000/- Sh. Khazan Singh Vs Municipal Corporation., Bahadurgarh.

2733/2012 5.12.2012 1000/- Sh. Sharwan Kumar VS Block Development & Panchayats Officer, Mandi Dabwali, District Sirsa.

2731/2012 6.12.2012 1000/- Sh. Sharwan Kumar Vs Block Development & Panchayats Officer, Mandi Dabwali, District Sirsa.

2536/2012 11.12.2012 500/- Sh. Nawal Kishore Vs Haryana Public Service Commission, Panchkula.

19 & 20/2012 in case no. 0341/2011

12.12.2012 2000/- Sh. Ram Kishan Vs District Development and Panchayats Officer, Yamunanagar.

429/2012 in case no. 1817/2012

12.12.2012 2000/- Sh. Brahm Dutt Vs Deputy Superintendent O/o Estate Officer, HUDA, Sector-12, Faridabad.

2069/2012 12.12.2012 1000/- Sh. Dharam Pal Vs Deputy District Education Officer, Assandh (Karnal)

3153/2012 13.12.2012 1000/- Sh. Bhagwan Dass Arora Vs Women and Child Development, Haryana, Panchkula.

3154/2012 13.12.2012 500/- Sh. Surender Singh Vs Public Health Engineering Department, Haryana, Panchkula.

1584/2012 13.12.2012 1500/- Smt. Gurinder Kaur Ghungas Vs Municipal Council, Thanesar, District Kurukshetra.

3998/2012 14.12.2012 1500/- Sh. Fhamida Vs Director Social Justice & Empowerment Department.

90

3023/2012 14.12.2012 1000/- Sh. Satish Sharma Vs Elementry Education Officer, Ambala.

2778/2012 18.12.2012 1000/- Sh. Sanjay Arora Vs Municipal Corporation Bhiwani.

1867/2012 20.12.2012 500/- Sh. Mahavir Singh Dhankar VS Executive Engineer, M.C. Rohtak.

1576/2012 20.12.2012 1000/- Sh.Mahabir Singh Vs Municipal Corporation. Rohtak.

3129/2012 20.12.2012 1000/- Smt. Janak Devi Vs Land Acquistion Officer, Sector-14, Panchkula.

Documents

SEVENTH REPORT ON IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RTI ... - CIC Haryanacicharyana.gov.in/uploads/pdf/7th_english1.pdf · HARYANA . SCO 70-71 & 114-115 ... Government of a State, his salary