Upload
rocunited
View
222
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
1/37
SERVING WHILESICK
By The Restaurant Opportunities Centers United
High Risks & Low Benets for the Nations Restaurant
Workforce, and Their Impact on the Consumer
September 30, 2010
rimary Research Support Provided by:
he National Employment Law Projecthe UCLA Center for the Study of Urban Poverty
unding Provided By:
he Public Welfare Foundationhe Ford Foundationhe Rockefeller Foundation
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
2/37
SERVING WHILE SICK
By The Restaurant Opportunities Centers United
High Risks & Low Benets for the Nations RestaurantWorkforce, and Their Impact on the Consumer
September 30, 2010
Primary Research Support Provided by:
he National Employment Law Projecthe UCLA Center for the Study of Urban Poverty
Funding Provided By:
he Public Welfare Foundation
he Ford Foundationhe Rockefeller Foundation
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
3/37
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
With over 10 million workers, the restaurant industry is one o the largest and astest-growing sectors
o the United States economy, even during the current economic crisis. However, most workers in this
industry work in restaurants that put them at high risk o injury and illness, and provide them with littleor no benets to cope with these challenges. Tese conditions increase the likelihood o workers commit-
ting dangerous practices that place the health o the dining public at risk.
Tis report is drawn rom analysis o 4323 surveys
o restaurant workers nationwide - the largest
national survey sample o restaurant workers ever
conducted as well as 240 employer interviews and
240 worker interviews, on their wages, working
conditions, and access to benets. It is also based
on 500 additional surveys and 20 additional
employer interviews on health insurance needs in
the industry. In all o these surveys and interviews,
restaurant workers across the country reported
very high rates o injury and illness and very low
rates o benets to cope with these symptoms. Tis
report will highlight the increased risk actors
aced by restaurant workers and their low access tobenets. It will also outline restaurant workers
and employers particular needs with regard to health insurance. Our ndings have important
implications not only or workers, but also or employers, taxpayers, policy-makers, and dining
consumers.
Our Findings
High rates o restaurant workers nationwide report working in low road restaurant jobs, with
strenuous work environments and little access to benets. Direct intervention to reduce stressul,
ast-paced working conditions in restaurants would reduce injury and illness in these workplaces.
However, access to benets such as health insurance and paid sick days are both also a necessity.
Te ability to take time o rom jobs and see a physician or prompt care o injury and illness
could shorten illness duration and help prevent uture injury and illness. Since the median wage
o all restaurant workers nationwide is $8.591, most workers who do not have paid sick days
are unlikely to take a day o to recuperate and are unlikely to receive timely medical attention
Our study reveals that there are two roads toprotability in the nations restaurantindustry the high road and the low
road. Restaurant employers who take thehigh road are the source o the best jobs inthe industry those that enable restaurant
workers to support themselves and theiramilies, remain healthy, and advance in theindustry. aking the low road to
protability, on the other hand, creates low-wage jobs with long hours and ew benets. Itultimately harms workers, other restaurantemployers, consumers, taxpayers and the
public health.
Two Roads to Profitability
Serving While Sick | i
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
4/37
unless desperately ill i they do not have paid health insurance.
Restaurantworkersinoursurveysamplereportedfacinghighratesofexposurestodangerous
working conditions; 38.1% reported that they had done something while working that put
their own saety at risk. Almost hal (49.5%) reported being cut on the job, and nearly as many(45.8%) reported being burned on the job.
87.7%reportednotreceivingpaidsickdays.Morethan63%ofallrestaurantworkersreported
cooking and serving ood while sick, thus impacting consumers health.
Almost90%ofallworkerssurveyedreportednotreceivinghealthinsurancethroughtheir
employer. Workers without health insurance were three times as likely to visit the emergency
room without being able to pay as their counterparts with health insurance. Immigrants in our
sample were ar less likely to have health insurance than U.S.-born restaurant workers, with dire
consequences.
Finally,workerswhoexperiencedhighlevelsofemploymentlawviolationsintheirworkplace
were more likely to have worked under conditions that have negative consumer health impacts.
Workers who reported that they had done something as a result o time pressure that might have
harmed the health and saety o the customer were much more likely to experience overtime
violations(59.6%,asopposedto48.6%oftheentiresurveypopulation)andworkingothe
clockwithoutpay(63%,comparedto39.4%ofthetotalsurveypopulation).
In most o the urban areas we studied, the majority o workers in the restaurant industry are immigrants
and people o color. Because they are overrepresented in high-risk, low-wage jobs, immigrants and
workers o color disproportionately experience the combination o poor job conditions, high workplace
risk actors and low access to employment benets.
Serving While Sick | ii
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
5/37
From2003until2010,theRestaurantOpportunitiesCenter(ROC)workedwithlocalrestaurantindustrycoalitionsineightregionsNewYork,Chicago,MetroDetroit,NewOrleans,LosAngeles,Washington,Miami,andMaine-toconductcomprehensiveindustryanalyses,includingmorethan500worker surveys, 30 employer interviews, and 30 worker interviews in each locality. Tis study draws uponthe combined health and saety data rom these studies, and is thus based on analysis o 4,323 workersurveys, 240 employer interviews, and 240 worker interviews nationwide. In addition, rom January toJunein2010,ROCconducted500additionalsurveysofitsrestaurantworkermembersinsevenoftheselocalities on their health insurance needs and access, as well as their consumer preerences or insuranceproducts.ROCalsoconducted20employerinterviewsonthesameissueswithregardtohealthinsurance.isreportrepresentsacombinationofthesetwodatasets,andalsodrawsuponROCspreviousstudyonoccupationalsafetyandhealthamongNewYorkCityrestaurantworkers,Burned:HighRisksandLowBenetsforWorkersintheNewYorkCityRestaurantIndustry.
Methodology
Serving While Sick | iii
Our Recommendations
Restaurants should oer workers saer workplaces and conventional job benets, including health
insurance, paid sick days, and workers compensation insurance. Without these improvements, the
industry will continue to put both workers and consumers at risk. Our specic policy recommendations
areto:
1. Support ederal legislation and other policy eorts that would and require employers to provide
paid sick days and provide greater access to health insurance or all low-wage workers, includingimmigrants.
2. Provide education or employers and restaurant workers to help them identiy workplace risksand ways to reduce these risks, including rights to workers compensation insurance, strategies tore-organize workplaces to be more ergonomic, and the importance o providing benets.
3. Improve workplace saety and health conditions or restaurant workers, by having theOccupational Saety and Health Administration (OSHA) develop a special emphasis programto reduce injuries and illnesses in the industry, and encourage employers to ollow ergonomicguidelines developed or the restaurant industry.
4. Provide all workers with greater access to better jobs with improved benets through promotions
policies and anti-discrimination monitoring.
5. Publicize model occupational saety and health employer practices to provide much-neededguidance to other employers.
6. Supportcollectiveorganizingamongrestaurantworkerstoimproveworkingconditionsforall
workers in the industry, including better wages, access to health insurance, and other benets.
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
6/37
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
Te restaurant industry is one o the largest private-sector employers in the nation, with over 10 million
employeesnationwideworkinginmorethan568,000foodserviceanddrinkingplacesthatmake
signicant contributions to the countrys tourism, hospitality and entertainment sectors and to its
economyasawhole.2NationwideandineachoftheeightregionsstudiedNewYork,Chicago,Metro
Detroit,NewOrleans,LosAngeles,WashingtonDC,Miami,andMaine-therestaurantindustryis
vibrant, resilient, and growing. Despite the current economic recession, the restaurant industry continues
to grow in each o the eight regions and nationwide.
Tis study is based on an analysis o the health conditions and access to benets among restaurant
workers rom survey data emerging rom the largest survey sample o restaurant workers ever conducted.
In more than 4,000 surveys o restaurant workers, 240 employer interviews, and 240 worker interviews
that we conducted in eight locations nationwide, we ound that health and saety challenges were a
primary concern or the restaurant industry in the United States. An additional 500 surveys o restaurant
workers in these eight locations and 20 employer interviews ocused on the health care coverage needs
oftheindustrythatexploredmoredeeplythechallengeofnothavinghealthinsurance.Forexample,
restaurant workers without health insurance reported that they were much more likely to avoid needed
EmergencyRoomtreatmentbecausetheywerenotabletopay(seeTable6).
We suspect that the magnitude o health problems and unsae practices may be higher than ound in this
study. Workers without access to health care coverage may under-report symptoms or illnesses that have
not been conrmed by a health care provider. Also, many workers may be reluctant to admit, even in a
condential survey or ocus groups, that they are compelled to engage in behaviors that harm the public.
What is certain is that low road employment conditions that compel workers to do things that might
harm consumer health and saety, such as having to work while sick or not receiving proper health andsaety training, are pervasive in the restaurant industry nationwide.
Methodology
Tis report includes data rom comprehensive restaurant industry studies in eight locations, each titled
Behind the Kitchen Door, and rom an additional 500 worker surveys and 20 employer interviews
ocused on the health care needs o restaurant workers. Background inormation was also drawn rom the
Serving While Sick | 1
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
7/37
2009 reportBurned: High Risks and Low Benefts or Workers in the New York City Restaurant Industry , a
our-year study unded by the National Institute or Occupational Saety and Health on the occupational
safetyandhealthofNewYorkCityrestaurantworkers.Burned: High Risks and Low Benefts or Workers
in the New York City Restaurant Industry was based on 500 worker surveys, 40 worker interviews and 40
employer interviews specically regarding health and saety issues.
TeBehind the Kitchen DoorstudieswereconceivedofanddesignedbyRestaurantIndustryCoalitions
inNewYork,SoutheastMichigan,Chicago,NewOrleans,Washington,DC,LosAngeles,Miami,and
Maine,from2005untilthepresent.Ineachlocation,theseCoalitionsconsistofacademics,policy
analysts, worker advocates, worker organizers, unions, and others, and included participation rom
restaurant workers and restaurant industry employers. Tis document includes summary data rom the
Behind the Kitchen Doorreport rom those eight locations, with pooled survey data weighted or
position, industry segment, and local workorce size. In each locality,Behind the Kitchen Dooris one o
the most comprehensive research analyses o the restaurant industry conducted in that regions history.
Tis study is thus the most comprehensive national research analysis o the health needs and conditions
o restaurant workers conducted to date.
Each o the eightBehind the Kitchen Doorreports uses data rom more than 500 worker surveys,
approximately 30 one-hour interviews with restaurant workers, and 30 one-hour interviews with
restaurant employers in each region. Tus, this study includes data rom 4323 worker surveys the
largest in-depth survey sample o restaurant workers ever conducted nationwide and more than 240
employer interviews and 240 worker interviews. Te surveys contained questions regarding job hazards,wage and benets, working conditions, injuries, abuse, wage the and other employment law violations.
Great care was taken to match the survey sample with the ethnic and gender demographics o the
localrestaurantindustryasfoundintheUSCensusBureausAmericanCommunitySurvey(ACS).Each
report also included over 30 in-depth worker and employer interviews that were recorded, transcribed,
and coded. In each locality, the results o this primary research are supplemented by analysis o industry
andgovernmentdata,suchastheCensus,aswellasareviewofexistingacademicliterature,toproduce
the ullBehind the Kitchen Doorreport.
Te research orBurned: High Risks and Low Benefts or Workers in the New York City Restaurant
Industry was implemented rom August 2005 until July 2009 with primary unding rom the National
InstituteforOccupationalSafetyandHealth.TogetherwiththeHealthandSafetyTaskForce,the
RestaurantOpportunitiesCenterofNewYork(ROC-NY)conductedastudyoftheoccupational
safetyandhealthofNewYorkCityrestaurantworkers.eHealthandSafetyTaskForceincludedthe
QueensCollegeCenterfortheBiologyofNaturalSystems,theMt.SinaiSchoolofMedicine,theNew
YorkCommitteeforOccupationalSafetyandHealth,theNYUCenterfortheStudyofAsianAmerican
Serving While Sick | 2
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
8/37
Health,andMaketheRoadNewYork.estudyincluded502surveysofrestaurantworkers,10focus
groups with workers o dierent ethnicities, and 35 one-hour employer interviews. Te survey sample
wasstrictlymatchedtoraceproportionsofNewYorkCityrestaurantworkersinthe2000census.
Forthisreport,wesupplementedtheknowledgethatwehavecompiledabouthealthandsafetythrough
theBehind the Kitchen Doorand Burnedstudies with 500 health-care specic surveys and 20 employer
interviews that asked detailed questions about health care issues. and 20 employer interviews that asked
detailed questions about health care issues. Te surveys were completed by restaurant worker members o
theRestaurantOpportunitiesCenter(ROC),anationalrestaurantworkersorganization,ineightstates.
Te survey questions documented health care coverage needs, access and consumer preerences or
insurance. Te employer interviews explored employer perspectives rom seven states on the difculties
and benets o oering health insurance to their employees.
Serving While Sick | 3
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
9/37
CHAPTER 2: INCREASED RISK FACTORS
In2008,theU.S.DepartmentofLaborfoundtherestaurantindustrytobethethirdhighestintermsof
totalnonfataloccupationalinjuriesandillnesses.With227,600cases,FoodServicesandDrinkingPlaces
wasrankedbelowonlyElementaryandSecondarySchools(284,500cases)andGeneralMedicaland
Surgical Hospitals (258,200 cases).3
Our survey data revealed explanation or the industrys high ranking in terms o occupational injury and
illness. A majority o workers we surveyed reported working in ast, demanding and pressure-lledenvironments, and that their workplaces commonly do not employ or enorce regulations designed to
ensure the health and saety o workers, sometimes in violation o the ederal Occupational Saety and
Health Act (OSHA).4
Table1:HealthandSafetyViolationsReportedbyRestaurantWorkers
Serving While Sick | 4
Violations Percent of Workers
Unsaely hot in the kitchen36.1%
Firehazardsintherestaurant 25.2%
Missingmatsontheoortopreventslipping 22.0%
Missingguardsoncuttingmachines 21.1%
Done something that put own saety at risk 38.1%
AsshowninTable1,36.1%percentofworkerssurveyedreportedthatitgetsunsafelyhotinthekitchenin their restaurant workplace. Signicant numbers o workers reported absences o guards on the
cuttingmachines(21.1%),aswellasmatsontheoortopreventslippage(22.0%),andrehazardssuch
as blocked doors or non-unctioning re extinguishers in the restaurant where they worked (25.2%).
Tirty-eight percent (38.1%) reported having done something at work that put their own saety at
risk.Despitetheprevalenceofhealthandsafetyhazardsinrestaurantworkplaces,66.6%ofallworkers
surveyed reported a lack o knowledge o workers compensation laws, and nearly a quarter o the workers
(33.0%) told us they did not receive health and saety training rom their employers
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
10/37
Given the prevalence o work hazards reported above, it is not surprising that large numbers o workers
reportedsueringfrominjuryandillnessonthejob.Forty-nine(49%)percentofworkerssurveyedormore than 2000 workers out o 4188 surveyed - had suered work-related cuts on the job, and 45.8% o
all workers surveyed had been burned on the job. Almost one-quarter (24.5%) had come into contact
withtoxicchemicals.Almostseventeenpercent(16.7%)reportedthattheyhadslippedandinjured
themselves while at work. Additionally, 20.8% reported chronic pain that was caused or worsened by
their job.
In some restaurants people are doing a lot o physical labor, like I work at a three story restaurant where
Ihaultrashcansoficeupthreeightscauseduringbusinessyoucantusetheelevator.Sothereisthisgo, go, go! type o attitude and people wind up doing crazy stu like pulling things or slipping on thestairs. Broken glass, people getting their hands cut, [etc]. You know, youre in a ne dining restaurant
with the crispy bread and the knie slides along the bread into your nger. Ive seen that several times.Grease res and burns in the kitchen, Ive seen a lot o those kinds o health concerns. And I think its
just, people are generally in a high risk health situation. I have seen a lot o just not healthy stu or theworker. Male, NewOrleans, 13 years in the industry, Server.
IrecallonetimeIhadtothrowoutthoselongorescentbulbs,theonesyouseehereandIdontbelieve
that was part o my job description. It seems like something that should have been handled bymanagementcauseIthrewitoutandithitthesideofthedumpsteranditexplodedandglassewinmyace. So I had bits o glass in my ace. Male, Detroit, 1 year in the industry, Dishwasher
Serving While Sick | 5
Injuries Percent of Workers
Burned while on the job 45.8%
Cutwhileonthejob 49.0%
Slipped and injured while on the job 16.7%
Cameintocontactwithtoxicchemicalswhileonthejob 24.5%
Have chronic pain caused or worsened by the job 20.8%
Table2:WorkplaceInjuriesReportedbyRestaurantWorkers
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
11/37
able 3 reveals that understafng, which places inordinate pressure on workers, is a common industry
practice. An overwhelming majority o respondents reported working when their restaurant was
understaed(78.2%),andasimilarnumbersaidtheyhaveperformedseveraljobsatonce(77.5%).
Nearly orty-three percent (42.8%) responded that they have been required to perorm jobs or which
they had not been trained, and 38.1% o workers reported doing something that put their own saety at
risk. Such low road workplace practices not only aect workers, but can also have serious consequences
forconsumers.Forty-twopercent(42.5%)ofworkersreportedhavingdonesomethingasaresultoftimepressure that might have put the health and saety o the customer at risk. In act, as urther discussed in
Chapter4,surveydataindicatedacorrelationbetweenhealthandsafetyviolationsandnegativeimpact
on consumers.
Serving While Sick | 6
Workplace Practices Percent of Workers
Worked when the restaurant was understaed 78.2%
Perormed several jobs at once 77.5%
Experienced verbal abuse rom supervisors 29.1%
Perormed a job not trained or 42.8%
Done something due to time pressure that has put own
health and saety at risk
38.1%
Done something due to time pressure that might have
harmed the health and saety o customers
42.5%
Table3:WorkplacePracticesReportedbyRestaurantWorkers
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
12/37
Serving While Sick | 7
At48yearsold,JuneLindseyisaproudmothero nine and a 30-year veteran o Detroit quick serve
restaurants.Sherstenteredintothislineofworkwhenshewas17years old and looking or a job. One o the ew businesses nearby was aMcDonaldsandtheyhiredme,andIhavebeenintheindustryeversince. Since that time she has not stopped struggling to support herchildren despite terrible working conditions. Her stories illustrate theadverse eects o these working conditions on the health and saetyon the worker as well as the eects on the greater public.
It was an extremely hot day and I was working in the ront counter at Popeyes.erewasnoACintherestaurant.SweatwasrunningdownmyfaceandIhadtoconstantlywipemyace and assist customers with their ood order and cashiering at the same time. I am so thirsty but I cantdrink in the ront because the manager tells me Im not allowed to drink in ront o customers, and thatI have to drink in the back. And when I try to go to the back and get a drink, the manager tells me againthatIcantleavethecounterandgobackforadrink.IsaidIamreallythirsty.Ifeeldizzy.Myvisionisblurry.Myearsarepoppingandsomethingiswrong.Ineedsomethingtodrink.emanagerthreatensme [that] i I go to the back I might as well just go home.
Aer about an hour the pain started to get worse and worse and I asked i I can leave and go to the ER .She reused again and threatened me o losing my job. I told her,[I] am really sick. I need this job; I have
children to eed at home. She reused, so I chose to go to the ER not knowing i I was going to have myjob or not. At the ER I ound out that my blood pressure was low because I was dehydrated. I have nohealth insurance so Ihad to pay a lot o money that I didnt have to spend. Te next I went back to workwiththeERdocumentsandwenttotheGMandexplainedmysituation.Iendedupkeepingmyjobbutwith a hostile attitude rom the manager that didnt want to let me go or have a drink o water.
[Anothertime]Iwasworkingatthesamejob.Ihadareallybadcold.Mynosewasrunning,Iwassneezing, [and] I had a bad cough and a ever. I could not call in sick because no work meant no moneyandIcouldntaorditatthattime.Mykidswereveryyoung,soIwenttoworktoseeifIcanmakeitthrough the day. Hal way through the day, the sneezing, coughing and runny nose got worse. I asked themanager,I am really sick and need to go because I could make others sick and I am dealing with ood.
She laughed and told me try not to cough then. So I had to work that day sick, and who knows howmany customers I got sick because I couldnt go to the back and leave the counter to wash my hands aereverysneezeornosewipe.Lateronallofusgotsickonebyone,andallthiscamefromanotherworkerthat came to work sick like me, but was not allowed to leave work!
I elt angry and just wanted to leave but I couldnt because I needed this job to support myamily. I elt like a slave!! o add insult to injury, it was especially hard to accept it because Iam almost 50 years old and being disrespected by amanager that was hal my age. Tis aectedmy sel esteem and sel worth. Its not my ault I got sick, and its just not air!
June Lindsey: DetroitTen Years in the Industry: Fast Food WorkerW
ORKER
PROFILE
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
13/37
Serving While Sick | 8
EMPLOYER LIABILITY
In interviews, many employers expressed that promoting health and saety practices in the restaurant
setting was a matter o liability orthe restaurant, both nancially and legally. One employer spoke the
need to meet the health and saetystandards set orth by local department o health and insurance car-riers. Oentimes when you have a restaurant this large and you have insurance carriers and insurance
brokers, they usually do a walkthrough [on] saety issues. Te Department o Health has a lot o issues
a lot o things they look at when they come and do an inspection that are also health related but also
saety related,but our insurance brokers the companies, beore they will issue a certicate o insurance,
willcomethroughandtalkaboutourstaircases,workingconditionsIthinkalotofthoseissuesarebasic
common sense.
In act, several employers noted that the costs associated with being noncompliant with government
saety standards were reason enough to promote high health and saety practices in the restaurants. One
employer stated, Beore i they nd [sic] an employee not wearing a hat, they used to let it go. Tey
would just put a correction, like you have to tell your employee. But right now its like a $200 ne per
employee. So things like that, you know so many things, which you dont have to pay or, they just let
you pay or and its getting higher and higher. And now Im paying almost $2000 a year. Which I used to
neverdo.Forlittlethings,thatneverhappenedbefore.Itsnotcriticalthing,itsjustsomethingyoucould
rectiy. Tats it.
Other employers drew a direct connection between promoting high health and saety standards throughtrainingandreducingcostsfortherestaurant.Forexample,oneemployerstated,Everynewhire,
depending on the department in which they are hired, they go through a training program. Tey
basically dont start in their positions on till they have successully completed this training program. Just
to insure that they know what theyre doing so we can prevent uture accidents or anything that might be
job-related just cutting any human costs, any nancial cost that might be associated with healthcare.
In act, employers expressed that while implementing strong health and saety training programs or
workers may require initial investment, it is more cost-eective in the long run than not providing
training..Forexample,oneemployerwhodidoerhealthandsafetytrainingreportedthatifsomeone
slipped and ell in the restaurant and broke something, Once they are out o work, you need to replace
that employee, two youre insurance has to cover it, you know insurance isnt ree, and the more oen you
use it, as ar as workmans comp, I would assume the more you have to pay, the more you crash your car,
themoreyourinsurancegoesup[but]Ithinkitallworksoutintheend;Ithinkitactuallyworksout
bettermoney-wise.Youproduceonevideoandthewholecompanygetsonevideo,andyousave100
people rom alling. I guarantee that didnt cost that much.
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
14/37
Serving While Sick | 9
Were concerned or our employees. We want to make sure that theyre healthy and happy. Maine, 5years at restaurant, Family style
As ar as what we can control is to provide a sae and riendly work environment. So they are not pissedo when they come to work because o something we are doing wrong. I they look at us like I hate thisplace I dont want to go to work but I get to make money, I lose those guys much more quickly. Plus nowwiththeeconomythewayitisbutstillwecankeepthemhappyandmakeitsomewhatfunbuteec -tive work environment then we can keep the turn over pretty low. Chicago, 17 years in business,
Family style
Te concerns expressed by the employers that we interviewed regarding liability issues are reafrmed by
government agencies and in numerous trade articles rom the restaurant industry. Particularly given the
high rate o cuts experienced by restaurant workers as reported by our survey sample, the cost associated
with cuts can be a tremendous liability to employers. OSHA reports that it is estimated that more than
$32,000 worth o direct (health insurance, workers compensation) and indirect costs, such as wages paid
to injured workers not covered by workers compensation, expenses related to time lost/work stoppage,
administrative time spent by supervisors ollowing accidents, employee training, replacement costs, lost
productivity related to new employee learning curves, accommodation o injured employees and
replacement costs o damaged material/property, can be attributed to just one cut or laceration.5
In
addition, all hand injuries, including cuts, which are all too common in restaurants, have been noted to
be one o the highest sources o employer cost among all occupational injuries. In addition to thephysicalpain,handinjuriestakeanancialtoll.eaveragehandinjuryclaimhasnowexceeded$6,000,
witheachlosttimeworkerscompensationclaimreachingnearly$7,500,accordingtotheBureauof
LaborStatisticsandtheNationalSafetyCouncil.eoveralldrainonemployeeproductivitybecomes
apparent, especially when you consider there are about 110,000 estimated lost time hand injuries every
year,accordingtoBLS.6
Restaurant trade journals have also noted the employer liability associated with occupational injuries and
illnesses. As cited in one major trade journal, in an age when litigation is prevalent, restaurant owners
and managers need to give some serious thought to the liability they are exposed to i they allow health
and saety issues to go unchecked.7
In 2005, more than 800 restaurants were ound to have critical health
code violations, resulting in major costs or the employers.8Forexample,food-bornedisease,whichcan
sometimesbeattributedtoworkersillness,cancostanestablishmentasmuchas$75,000inlegalfees,
medical claims, lost employee wages, cleaning and sanitation, discarded ood, and lost income.9
Similarly,
it has been reported that on-the-job injuries experienced by restaurant workers cost the industry $300
million in medical ees and lost labor.10
In act, in 2003, 24,000 restaurant workers lost a day o
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
15/37
Serving While Sick | 10
workduetoacut,burn,orscald,andintotal62,000restaurantworkershurtthemselvesbadly
enough to miss a day o work.11
Te ederal Occupational Saety and Health Act (OSHA) imposes standards or health andsaety in the workplace, requiring employers to provide protection or workers in hazardousenvironments and to keep records o all workplace injuries and accidents. OSHA covers toxicchemical use the statute requires gloves, or example, or dishwashers and kitchen cleaners whouse very heavy toxic chemicals and temperature o work environments, including excessivelyhot kitchens. While there is no mandatory requirement that employees be provided withspecic health and saety training, such training is eectively necessary to ensure compliance
with OSHA and workers compensation law.
Employers in every U.S. state and territory must secure workers compensation insurance orevery employee.
12MoststatesWorkersCompensationlawalsostipulatesthat,providedthe
employer is inormed o any workplace accident within a certain time period, workers relatedmedical expenses will be ully covered. Workers may also be eligible or weekly compensationi they lose work due to a work-related injury, and or xed compensation or any permanentdisability.
13
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
16/37
CHAPTER 3: LITTLE OR NO ACCESS TO BENEFITS
Te vast majority o restaurant workers we surveyed reported not having paid sick days, to take time o
to care or themselves or loved ones, or, even i they had the ability to take time o, health insurance to
cover the cost o medical care. In surveys and interviews, workers regularly repeated their need or both
kinds o benets. Teir lack o benets impacts not only workers and their amilies, but also consumers,
taxpayers, and employers.
A. Paid Sick Days
Almostallrestaurantworkerswesurveyedreportednothavingpaidsickdays.87.7%ofallworkers
surveyedreportednothavingaccesstopaidsickdays,and63.6%reportedworkinginrestaurants
preparing, cooking, and serving ood - while sick.
able 4. Access to Benets
Serving While Sick | 11
Do not get paid sick days 87.7%
Do not get paid vacation days 79.3%
Have worked when sick 63.6%
Sick time? I take my own sick time, i Im very sick I dont go. But many times you cant aord to takethe day o because youre sick, and all the time, especially this season and in the spring, a lot o mycoworkers they were sick, sneezing in the ood. Tey were disgusting. But you know, what can they do?Tey cannot aord to take the day o. Female, Maine, 4 years in the industry, Server
Tere [are] times when I call in and tell them Im sick and they still say you cant come in or a ewhours? Tey dont care! You gonna be sneezing, over peoples ood and stu like that and i you wanna
put a mask on or try to cover yoursel up or whatever then its bad or the business. Tats why you shouldhave allowed me to stay home. I told yall I was sick! Tats how it is right now [though]; they just dontcare. Female, New Orleans, 23 years in the industry, Server
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
17/37
Serving While Sick | 12
econceptdoesnotexist:thereisnosicktime,youcometoworkeitherway.Ifyoudontcomeyoudont get paid and i you stay o too long you get red, thats it, even i youve been there or two years. Male, Michigan, 5 years in the industry, Line Cook
Insomelocalities,weaskedworkersfurtherquestionsaboutwhythiswastrue.Forexample,inMaine,
o the workers surveyed who reported having gone to work sick, nearly hal (49.2%) reported needing to
work while sick because they could not aord to take the day o. One kitchen worker who has been in
the industry or 8 years explained, I remember going to work one week straight with a cold, coughs, sore
throat, everything, ever, and working and my manager didnt say anything and I was expecting he would
have gone go home, eel better because we work out back in the kitchen separating donuts and by the
timethesedonutsgetspreadoutitsalloverthestateofMaine.Imean,itcomesoutofmyhand,andyou
know i Im sick, everybodys sick. And I didnt want to call o because I wasnt going to get paid, or my
managerwasntgonnaletmecausehedidntexcuseme,soIjustbasicallyworked.Maineworkersalso
reported additional consequences or working while sick, with
31.8% o workers surveyed reporting that they endured a prolonged
illness, 21.4% couldnt complete tasks necessary or work, 19.9%
caused other workers to become sick, and 12% reported that they
coughed or sneezed into the ood when they went to work sick.
DuringtheoutbreakoftheH1N1SwineFluepidemicin
early 2009, the president and surgeon general both urged peoplestaying home to be the best way to minimize the spread o the
u.14
However, the act that nearly all ood service workers lack paid
sick days means that such an option would not be easible or most
ood service workers, thus contributing to the risk o the widespread
illness among both restaurant workers and the public they serve.
With restaurant workers in particular, given their regular interace with preparing, cooking and serving
ood or the dining public, the lack o paid sick days and high incidence o workers working while sick is
a public health concern.
OnApril30,2009,NewYorkTimescolumnistJudithWarnerproledaROCmemberworkingin
MiamiasaserverinarestaurantwhilesickwithuduringtheH1N1epidemic.15
Without paid sick
days, the worker knew that she would lose her job i she did not go to work, despite the act that she had
both a ever and cough. Te column reported that nationally, only 14 percent o the people serving and
handling ood in restaurants can stay home rom work when theyre coughing and sneezing , without ear
o losing their jobs.
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
18/37
Serving While Sick | 13
Employers who orce restaurant workers to work while sick are contributing to a public healthchallenge.eU.S.CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention(CDC)inAtlantaestimatesthatnoroviruses, a amily o pathogens associated with outbreaks o oodborne illnesses, are actuallymore common in restaurants. In 2004, the most recent year or which data are available, 251reported outbreaks o oodborne illnesses across the country involving 10,000 victims werethoughttobeviral.AccordingtoCDCstatistics,almostallwereclassiedasnorovirus-related,and 93 were norovirus outbreaks tied to restaurants.
16
I an employee stays home sick, its not only the best thing or that employees health, but also his
co-workers and the productivity o the company.17
CommerceSecretaryGaryLocke
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
19/37
Serving While Sick | 14
Te son o an Arican-American mother and a Puerto Ricanfather,LuisDeLeonwasbornandraisedinChicago.Hestartedworkingback-of-the-houserestaurantjobswhenhewas17.Now,at27,hesaten-yearveteranoftheChicagorestaurantindustry. He started working in restaurants simply because it
was available to him and the application process was short.However, in the last our years he has developed a passionor the work and has no intention o leaving. Despite all
this,hesaysrestaurantworkcanbeverytough.Luissharedhis experience with illness in the workplace, a story that issimilar to many restaurant workers. He explained, In my10 years o working in the industry there have beennumerous times that I havegone to work while sick. I
would try and call o and tell a manager I dont eelgood but they still made me come in to work. I wassneezing in the ood, sweating,coughing, and eeling aint,and Im sure I was spreading germs to all my customers. I was less productive, ittook more time to get the ood out, it was an awul situation to be in.
I would stay sick or several days, and even up to a week, and all I really needed wasa ull day or two torest and recover. I never got, nor do I currently get, that day ortwo, because I am always orced to comein and i I dont, I know I will be red or myhours will be drastically reduced. I cant aord to lose my
job or get my hours cut so I just put up with it. I have to payrent, buy ood, and pay the other bills Imresponsible or- no job means no livelihood.
I want to just emphasize that i it were up to me Id stay at home to recuperate but my employerswont allow it- so in turn I jeopardize my own health and saety, that omy co-workers and that o youthe consumer, and it is not air to any o us.
Luis DeLeon, Chicago10 years in industry, grill cookW
ORKER
PROFILE
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
20/37
B. Health Insurance
Inoursampleof4,323surveys,89.7%ofallworkerssurveyednationwidereportednotreceivinghealth
insurancethroughtheiremployer,and61.5%reportednothavinghealthinsuranceatall.Almostone
quarter(22.7%)reportedthattheyorafamilymemberhadgonetotheemergencyroomwithoutbeingable to pay in the last year.
Given the high rates o injuries and illnesses suered by workers in this sector and the low rates o access
tohealthinsurancereportedbyrestaurantworkers,theRestaurantOpportunitiesCenter(ROC)sought
to understand the specic health care needs, access and consumer preerences o its membership in order
todesignanappropriatesolution.ROCthusconductedamorein-depthsurveyontheseparticularissues
Serving While Sick | 15
Policies that would help the restaurant industry or the workers? Denitely health insurance is the mostimportantonebecauseyouwanttoretainyourstasothatwayyourenotturningoverpeoplebenets
would be key. So implementing some kind o health insurance would be vital or workers and owners andbeyond that, I know they work on sick days and sick days would be important but I think because the
way the restaurant industry is set up there has to be some way to compensate. Male, Maine, 13 years inthe industry, Bartender
Well, or me, its your lie, its how you pay your bills and the way I saw it was, you work with thesepeople. But I know I shouldnt get riendly or personal with these people but, you know, you spend somuch time together, and you make jokes together and you try to work and have un at the same time.
What I noticed was the owners o this restaurant that I used to work at they were more concerned aboutmy production than my well-being, or how I got along with everybody. And one o the owners came overto me and said, Well, now that youve done all your duties and all the work that youre supposed to do,
why dont you go to the back o the house and bring in, you know, this urniture, and I thought, youregiving me something something to do and Im going to break my back and you dont even provide me
with insurance. So we had this big-big argument and he said, Get back and do your job or else yourered.Anditwaslike,youdontgetit.Like,Ibreakmybackinhereandwhosgoingtotakecareofme,
whos going to eed me, whos going to pay my bills, Im only supposed to work in the restaurant. Im notyour maid! Male, Chicago, 9 years in the industry, Busser, Barback, & Server
Job Benefits and Health Reported by Restaurant Workers Percent of Workers
Does not receive health insurance through employer 89.7%
Do not have any health insurance coverage 61.5%
Gone to ER without being able to pay 22.7%
Table5:JobBenetsandHealthReportedbyRestaurantWorkers
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
21/37
Serving While Sick | 16
with 500 restaurant worker members nationwide, and interviews with 20 employers around the country.
Similar to the rates reported rom the more general, non-member survey conducted with more than
4,000workersnationwide,64.5%ofROCssurveyedmembersreportednothavinghealthinsuranceat
all. And, as victims o the low-road jobs previously described, members without health insurancereported lower wages than those with access to health insurance. Whereas those workers with access to
health insurance rom their employer reported earning a median weekly income o $400, workers
without access to health insurance reported a median weekly income o only $330 an annual income
ofonly$17,160.79%ofworkerswithouthealthinsurancestatedthatthemainreasontheydidnothave
it was because they could not aord it. And, as can be seen in able 5 below, although workers with and
without healthcare were both hospitalized at similar rates, workers with health insurance were ar more
likelytohavebeentreatedforamajorcondition(22.3%asopposedto16.8%),takeprescription
medication (45.5% vs. 29.2%) and receive treatment or a chronic illness (18.4% compared to 12.8%).
Not surprisingly, while restaurant workers with and without healthcare both clearly had medical needs,
workers with health insurance were more likely to receive regular treatment.
Table6:Relationshipbetweenhealthcareneedsandhealthinsurance
Have you or a family member been... Percent of workerswith healthcare
Percent of workerswithout healthcare
Hospitalized in the past year 19.3% 17.9%
Been treated or a major condition 22.3% 16.8%
ake prescription meds 45.5% 29.2%
Chronicillnessorpersistingmedicalconditionreceivedtreatmentforwithinthepast6months
18.4% 12.8%
Unortunately, even restaurant workers with health insurance reported paying large amounts out o
pocket or medical costs. Among those with health insurance, only 8.8% reported that their employer
paid or the insurance in ull. In act, workers with health insurance reported paying more than $1000out o pocket in medical care costs in the past year at higher rates than those without health insurance
(28% vs. 19.5%).Not surprisingly, all workers both those with and without health insurance reported
avoidingmedicalcarebecauseoftheirinabilitytopay.However,ascanbeseeninTable6below,workers
without health insurance were three times as likely to avoid emergency care as workers with health
insurance, but also three times as likely to report using the emergency room because they could not
receive health insurance elsewhere, and three times as likely to go to the emergency room without being
able to pay. Tus, restaurant workers lack o access to benets clearly has a public cost.
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
22/37
Serving While Sick | 17
Table7:AordabilityofHealthInsurance
Percent of workerswith health insurance
Percent of work-ers without health
insurance
Avoided doctors visits because couldnt pay 91.9% 94.7%
Avoided prescription drugs because couldnt
pay
58.5% 48.6%
Avoided ER when needed because couldnt pay 13.2% 37.6%
Went to ER because couldnt receive healthinsurance elsewhere
11.1% 33.4%
Went to ER without being able to pay 13.6% 37.2%
Inattemptingtodesignasolution,ROCthensoughttounderstandwhatexactlyitsmemberswould
wantoutofahealthplan.Avastmajority71.5%-reportedthattheysoughtahealthplanasawayto
protect against high medical bills, and in particular, to see the doctor or general checkups a ew times a
year, get cheaper medication, and be able to visit the emergency room i needed, and only 28.4% sought
a health plan to treat recurring medical conditions. Tis statistic indicates that, despite the high rates o
injuriesandillnessestheysuerintherestaurantdescribedinChapter2,ROCssurveyedmembersarea
largely healthy population seeking preventative treatment rather than treatment or chronic conditions.In addition, a majority 55.5% - reported that the major actor in selecting a plan was cost, not
surprising given these workers low income.
Employer Perspectives on Health Insurance
Employers generally agreed that health insurance was a necessity or the restaurant workorce, both or
the welare o their own employees, and or their restaurant to be able to recruit and retain qualied
employees. When asked what might incentivize them to oer insurance besides having access to a low-costplan,onegeneralmanagerfromMaineinacasualfamilystyleestablishmentstated,Idontthink
I would need other incentives. I eel like its something everyone deserves access to. Several employers
cited the importance o providing health insurance in being able to recruit and retain qualied
employees. One amily-style restaurant owner in New York stated that oering health benets would
make working here more competitive better sta because [we give] better benets o working Its a
higherprioritythanithasbeeninthepasttopeopleAnothergeneralmanagerfromaMiamifamily-
style establishment stated that they wanted to provide benets in order to raise [our] restaurants image
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
23/37
Serving While Sick | 18
among possible applicants; i restaurant workers hear that we oer benets then we would be able to
attract more qualied workers, improve worker moral and reduce turnoverA rustrated general manager
fromMainerecounted,Ivehademployeesleavesotheycangogetrealjobssotheycangetinsurance
that covers prescriptions!
Several employers also stated that they would be willing to join a collective o employers and workers to
obtainacheaperrate.Moreover,iftheyfoundsuchanaordableplan,thattheywouldbewillingtopay
a portion o weekly premiums or their employees. When asked what would be the important actors o
such a plan, at least one employer stated that it was important to them to have a plan that would cover
their undocumented immigrant employees.
One o the ew employers we interviewed who were able to provide ull insurance or all her employees
explained the tremendous return that oering these benets has brought to the restaurants bottom line.
Astheownerofafamily-styleestablishmentinMichigan,sheexplainedthat:Employeesfeelmore
invested in and they are thereore more committed to their work and do a higher quality job. I your
employees eel ownership over their business and their work, they require less day-to-day supervision,
which rees business owners to be able to do more work on expanding the business and improving
conditions and opportunities which ultimately benets everyone.
Immigrant Restaurant Workers & Health Care Coverage
enationsfoodserviceindustryreliesheavilyonimmigrants.48.7%ofthe4,323restaurantworkerswesurveyednationwidewereforeign-born,and14.7%reportednothavinglegaldocumentstoworkinthis country, while only 12.8% o the total U.S. population is oreign-born, and recent estimates place theundocumented portion o the total population at only 4%.
18
Unortunately, not only in the restaurant industry but also nationwide, immigrant restaurant workersand, in act, all immigrants, are signicantly underrepresented in the nations healthcare system. In 2008,15%ofnativecitizens,22%ofnaturalizedcitizens,and46%ofnon-citizenslackanyformofinsurance, regardless o whether it was obtained privately, through anemployer, through a amilymember, or through some orm o public program. Examined on their own, 59% o all undocumentedimmigrants nationwide lack coverage.
19Using a cross-national comparative approach, public health
researchers Siddiqi, Zuberi and Nguyen ound that this disparity in health insurance is a critical cause othe dierences in unmet medical needs between immigrants and non-immigrants.
20Inaddition,7%ofall
people under age 18 in the United States are children o undocumented immigrants. While almost ourin ve o them are U.S.-born citizens eligible or public insurance, and many o the immigrant childrenare even eligible or public insurance benets, immigrants are still severely underinsured. 45% oimmigrant children and 25% o U.S. born children o undocumented immigrants are uninsured ascompared to only 8% o children o U.S. born parents.
21
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
24/37
Serving While Sick | 19
Amongrestaurantworkerswesurveyed,26.3%ofnon-citizensand14.3%ofundocumentedworkerslackaccesstohealthinsurance,comparedto61.5%ofallworkerssurveyed.Andwhileonly10%ofallrestaurantworkersreceivehealthinsurancethroughtheiremployers,afarsmallerpercentage-only6.2%- o undocumented workers have access to health insurance through their employer. Teir lack o accessto care is compounded by their lack o access to paid sick days. While only 13.3% o all workers surveyed
reported having access to paid sick days, only 8.2% o undocumented workers had paid sick leave.Additionally,immigrantshavefarlessincometopayformedicalcostsoutofpocket.Medianwagesdecreasewithdocumentationstatus:inourtotalsurveypopulation,themedianwagereportedwas$11.25forcitizens,$10.00forauthorizednon-citizens,and$8.61forundocumentedimmigrants.Notonly do immigrants and particularly undocumented immigrants lack sufcient health insurance, theyalso lack sufcient purchasing power to purchase health insurance out o pocket.
O the 505 surveys we conducted specically on restaurant workers health insurance needs, 30 wereundocumented immigrants, and 90% o these immigrants did not have access to any health insurance,comparedto64.5%ofthetotalsurveypopulation.eseworkersreportednotonlyaninabilitytoaccesshealth insurance due to cost, but also a general lack o knowledge and inormation about the health care
system in the United States. Among undocumented immigrants surveyed that did not have insurance,themostcitedmainreasonfornothavinghealthinsurance,besidesthatitwastooexpensive(69.6%),wasthattheydidnotknowhowtoobtaininsurance(21.7%).Only5.2%ofU.S.citizensinthesurveysample cited not knowing how to obtain insurance as an important actor, less than a quarter o the
percentage o undocumented immigrants who reported the same.
eAordableCareActthatwassignedintolawonMarch23,2010willreducethetotaluninsuredpopulation in the United States through better regulations o health insurance companies and publicsubsidies or individual health insurance. However, immigrants who have been in the country or lessthan ve years and undocumented immigrants have been excluded rom key pieces o the health reorms.AuthorizedimmigrantscontinuetobebarredfromMedicaidfortheirrstveyearsofresidency.
However, they will have access to the state exchanges in which health insurance will be competitively soldand to all o the subsidies available to low-income amilies in that orum. On the other hand,undocumentedimmigrantscontinuetobebarredfromMedicaidandarenotevenallowedaccesstothestate exchanges to buy unsubsidized insurance. Barring undocumented immigrants rom the stateexchanges denies this part o the U.S. population rom their right to health.
Moreover,itincreasestheburdenoncitizensandauthorizedimmigrants.emedianageforundocumented immigrants in all industries (35.5 years) is more than a decade younger than authorizedimmigrants(45.9years)andcitizens(46.3years).
22Including this younger and healthier segment in the
insurancepoolwouldreducecostsfortherestofthepopulation.AccordingtotheKaiserFamilyFoundation,manylawfullyresidingandundocumentedimmigrantswouldstilllikelybedependenton
saety-net providers, such as community health centers, clinics, and public hospitals, and state and localsaety-net programs or care and assistance.
23While undocumented immigrants pay taxes and thus
contribute to the public coers that must pay or these institutes, it would be preerable to everyone orthem to be able to pay into an insurance pool or proper health carecoverage and thus help reduce theburden on publicly-unded saety-net providers.
Providing immigrants access to proper medical care is not only a question o their well-being. As so manyimmigrants work in restaurants preparing, cooking, and serving ood, and so ew get paid sick days,depriving them o proper access to medical care is a threat to consumer saety and public health.
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
25/37
Serving While Sick | 20
Carlosisa33year-oldundocumentedimmigrantthathasbeenlivinginMiamiforveyearsworkingintherestaurantindustry.Athiscurrent
job he brings 10 years o restaurant industry experience, including 5 yearsin his birth country o Guatemala. In his current restaurant he works as abarback but occasionally bartends and has the ability to ll other
positions due to his long experience in the industry. Recently though,Carloswasbadlycutonthejob.Hefacedanintimidatingsituationthatheclaimsisnotuncommonintheindustry.BecauseCarlosdidnot
know his rights, his bosses were able to pressure him to work at risk o aggravatingthe injury and they discouraged rom using workers compensation when he brought it up.
All o this really happens because o how nervous you are not to break anything. I was cleaning coeecups while one o the owners was at the bar. I dropped one o the cups and I tried so hard to catchit but it broke right as I tried to grab it and it cut me really deep. Te manager helped me clean it upbut then I ound a piece o porcelain in it. When I pulled it out [my wrist] really started to gush darkblood and I got really lightheaded and scared. I was worried I cut an artery.
Tey bandaged it up though and gave me a latex glove and told me to nish the last hal hour o myshiuntil4:00.InisheditandwhenIleItoldthemthatmywristreallyhurtandIdidntfeelgood.
Tey told me to go home and take some ylenol, or something or the pain and to come back andnishmydouble[shi]at7:00andmaybehewouldletmegoalittleearly,maybeatmidnight.
IthurtalotsoIcalled[theROCorganizer].BeforethatIdidntevenknowwhatworkerscompwas.Aer I talked to him I called the restaurant and told them I wasnt going in and I was going to thehospital. He was mad but when I mentioned workers comp he said I could take the day o and tocall tomorrow but dont worry about workers comp. At the emergency room they x-rayed my handto make sure there wasnt any more porcelain in there and the doctor gave me a bill or my boss and anote that said I wasnt supposed to work or a ew days. When I brought the note to the owner he wassomadhewouldnteventalktome.IhadtogivethepaperworktothemanagereownercalledmelatertoseeifIhadanyinsurance.ItoldhimthatIdidnthaveinsuranceHewasangry.Itwasnally
the manager that called me back to tell me that I could go back to the hospital when I need to get thestitches out and that I would get paid or the time I spent at home recuperating but that i I go workanywhere else during those days I could get in trouble with the law. I told him I only have one job and I
was going to use those days to get better. Its good in a way what happened because I learned how to goabout making sure my rights are respected no matter i you dont have insurance, no matter i you donthave documentation, it doesnt matter you have rights. And so this experience taught me how to goabout getting those rights respected and it also allowed me to serve as a sort o guide to my co-workersin the uture should anything like this happen to them. Now I know what to do and I can help themout to make sure their rights are respected.
Carlos, Miami
10 years in industry, BarbackWOR
KER
PROFILE
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
26/37
Serving While Sick | 21
Carlosnowfeelsempoweredthathecanbenetfromtheprotectionsthatworkerscompoersbuta more difcult adversity or him to overcome is his lack o health insurance. Despite his generallygoodhealth,heisconcernedabouthislackofinsuranceinthecaseofanemergency.Moreover,hehas
wanted to go to the doctor at certain points in the past but has avoided doing so because o the cost.Frustratedaboutthissituationheassertsthattherighttohealthisarightthateverybodyshouldhaveindierent o your immigration status or where youre coming rom. Tis is a right you are born with.Carlosnowfeelsempoweredthathecanbenetfromtheprotectionsthatworkerscompoersbuta
more difcult adversity or him to overcome is his lack o health insurance. Despite his generallygoodhealth,heisconcernedabouthislackofinsuranceinthecaseofanemergency.Moreover,hehaswanted to go to the doctor at certain points in the past but has avoided doing so because o the cost.Frustratedaboutthissituationheassertsthattherighttohealthisarightthateverybodyshouldhaveindierent o your immigration status or where youre coming rom. Tis is a right you are born with.
Carlos, Miami,
10 years in industry, BarbackWOR
KER
PROFILE
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
27/37
CHAPTER 4: CONSUMER EFFECTS
atswhytheyhavethatshowRamseysKitchen.IcantellyouIvebeenintoalotofkitchenssomeo the kitchens that are out here in Portland are just as bad. But, yeah it does aect like especially peoplelike, you catch colds, and this and that, and then youre wondering why, just take into mind/considerationwhereyouveeateninthelastcoupleofdays.Causeyoucouldhavecaughtthatcoldfromthat restaurant. When Im coughing on a plate and then just putting your ood there, youre saying Othat gravy tastes good, rubbing your nger and licking it. Male, Maine, 25 years in the industry, LineCook
A. Serving While Sick
I have been in the restaurant industry on and o or 4 years. I have spent many days sick, in the back oa kitchen or in ront o customers - too many to remember. I had the choice o either taking the day oonly i I could nd someone to cover my shi, or go to work sick. Nine times out o ten I went into worksick. I did my best to keep a sanitary kitchen, but when youre sick with a viral or bacterial inection it isalmost impossible not to inect others, as well as the ood youre preparing or serving. I recall oneevening;Ihadtogointoworksickwithareallybadcaseoftheu.IcalledintoseeifIcouldstayhome,but the owner told me I had two choices; come in or not come back. I had to choose between living in ahouse or on the streets. I I didnt come in, I wouldnt have been able to aord my rent or even to eat orthat manner. I I did come in, I ran the risk o becoming more sick and inecting those around me.Unortunately, I had to go into work. It was an incredibly busy weekend, at one point, one o my ellow
workers sat me down because I was about to aint. Te smell o grease and long shi had taken their toll. Ispent the next 5 days vomiting, expectorating phlegm, and drinking a lot o orange juice. I had to orcemy co-workers to cover or me and work double shis, they didnt want to see me red, and I didnt wanttolosemyjob.Laterthatweek,twoofmyco-workerscaughtmyvirusaswellasquiteafewcustomers.-Male, Chicago, 4 years in industry CookTable 4. Access to Benefts
I may have been, had a cold and been at work and then served ood that could have spread a [contagiousillness] Im sure because Ive caught colds rom other people at work. Female, Maine, 6 years in the
Serving While Sick | 22
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
28/37
Serving While Sick | 23
Our research ndings strongly suggest that low road workplace practices prevalent in the restaurant
industrycanincreasepublichealthrisks.Forinstance,63.6%ofworkerswespokewithinthecourseof
our study reported working while sick. And workers without paid sick days were ar more likely to work
whilesickthanthosewithpaidsickdays.Amongthosewithpaidsickdays,lessthanhalf(46.7%)report-
edgoingtoworkwhilesick,whileamongthosewithoutpaidsickdays,nearlyseventypercent(68.5%)reported preparing, cooking, and/or serving ood while sick.
Employers acknowledged the connection between worker exposures, the lack o benets, and consumer
healthrisk.OneNewYorkCityemployerjoked,Sickdays.erearentasetamountperyear.Youknow
itsoneofthejokesintherestaurantindustry:therestaurantindustrykeepsNewYorkCitysickbecause
we dont take days o. We single-handedly keep New York sick during the winter months because we
donttakedaysoWerepassingonalltheillnessestothecustomers.atsjustajoke.Youknow,itall
depends. Sta calls in sick all the time. Its kind o known as ar as management goes is that you show up
andthengetsenthome.Nomatterhowsickyouare:showupandthengetsenthome.
A2008studybyBarry-EatonDistrictHealthDepartment(BEDHD)inMichiganpublishedintheJournalofAmericanMedicalAssociationinvestigatedthesourceandagentofinfectiontodeterminethescope o illness among patrons and employees at a national chain restaurant. Te BEDHD environmentalassessment o the restaurant identied deciencies with employee hand-washing practices, cleaning andsanitizing o ood and nonood contact suraces, temperature monitoring and maintenance o potentiallyhazardous ood, and maintenance o hand-sink stations or easy accessibility and proper use. As a resulto a lack o health and saety training in cleaning up the incident (the restaurant had used an ammonium-based sanitizer that was ineective against norovirus), a total o 95 people had gotten sick (an attack rateof33.7%)and64peopleexperiencedanorovirustransmission(anattackrateof13.5%).Unfortunately,transmission continued through the next day. BEDHD intervened and mandated that (1) all ood
prepared during the dates o attack be discarded; (2) all ill employees were excluded rom working or atleast72hoursaertheirsymptomshadsubsided;and(3)thefacilitywascleanedextensivelywithdisinfectaccordingtoMDCHandMichiganDepartmentofAgricultureguidelinesforenvironmentalcleaning and disinection o norovirus.
24
B. Pressure to Cut Corners, with Potential to Harm the Customer
Over orty percent (42.5%) o the 4,323 workers surveyed had done something as a result o time
pressure that might have put the health and saety o a customer at risk. Employers pursuing a low road
business strategy place enormous pressure on workers, and oen cut corners on health and saety
training, leading to workplace practices that endanger employee and ood saety, and consequently public
health.AsdemonstratedbyFigure1,workerswhoreportedemploymentlawviolationsattheirplace
o work were also much more likely to report workplace practices such as ailure to provide health and
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
29/37
Serving While Sick | 24
training, being required to work when the restaurant is understaed or perorm several jobs at once, and
being asked to perorm a job or which they are not trained. Tis combination o workplace conditions
could have harmul eects on the health and saety o customers. Workers who reported that they had
done something as a result o time pressure that might have harmed the health and saety o the customer
weremuchmorelikelytoexperienceovertimeviolations(59.6%,asopposedto48.6%oftheentiresurveypopulation),andworkingotheclockwithoutpay(63%,comparedto39.4%ofthetotal
survey population).
Figure1:LinkagebetweenRiskstoConsumerHealthandWorkplaceViolations
Employers engaging in high road practices provide saer and healthier dining experiences or
consumers. Tese employers understand the public health risks involved with orcing workers to work
while sick and putting so much pressure on workers that they are orced to cut corners that harm the
health and saety o the consumer. Tese challenges in the restaurant industry have public health
implications, which should be concern to employers, legislators, and consumers alike.
Worker did something to puther/his own saety at risk
Among Workers WhoExperiencedNoLaborViolations
Among Workers WhoExperiencedAnyLabor
Violations
13.443.9
21.8 46.7
64.780.5
25.946.7
65.281.1
16.936.7
020406080100
Worker had to cut corners
because o time pressure thatmight have harmed the health
Worker had pressure to perormseveral jobs at once
Worker had to do a job or whichworker was not trained
Worker had to work whenrestaurant was understaed
Worker did not receive healthand saety training rom
employer
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
30/37
Serving While Sick | 25
OwnerGeorgeWeldandGeneralManagerHollyHoward run Egg, a Brooklyn restaurant that utilizesa concept o sustainability that not only integratesnutritional and environmental actors but alsoassures that the labor that prepares and serves theood is able to do so with dignity. Eggs mission isrst, to make it a great place to work, second tomake it a great place to eat, and third to change the way the ood system worksessentially to give ac-
cess to good ood to more people.
Aside rom generous wages, Egg employees receive health insurance on a 50-50 split and ten days paidtime o per year that they can use or sick time, personal days or vacation. When asked why Egg oerssuch benets that are uncommon in the restaurant industry, Weld emphasized the irony o how societytreats restaurant workers as compared to white-collar jobs and wanting to change this relationship. Heexplained, I worked in ofces or a while. Part o it is the rustration o seeing people who barely li anger all day long in an ofce getting rich benets or what they do and having their parents proud othemItsfrustratingtobein[therestaurant]industrythateveryonelooksdownonasdeadendjobsor people who dont have any other skills. I want people to take [restaurant jobs] seriously. I want peopleto look at the restaurant business and say this is work; this is a good alternative or people who are well
educatedandreallywanttomakeadierenceintheworld.Forme,abigpartofitisjusttreatingthejobthe way that it should be treated. It should have a dierent prole. Howard added rom an operationalpoint o view, its a high risk environment that people are in and as an employer you owe it to yourworkers to provide health care i theyre around knives. And you know everyone is on their eet all daylong. I also think that it helps us keep a low turnover rate. When people come to work here, they getreally excited about it. Its a reason that they stay. So our turnover rate is really low, which o course savesmoney on training.
Although they insist that oering health insurance and paid time o benets the restaurants bottomline, when asked about any challenges in oering the benets, the two named cost as the biggestchallenge. However, Weld claimed that cost should not even be as big o an issue i large business lobbies
would not take such a belligerent stance on employment law reorm and instead invest their resourcesintoproductivematters:atsoneofthethingsthatsfrustratingabouttheNationalRestaurantAssociation and groups like that. I dont know why they couldnt use their bargaining power to get betterhealth care rates and to do good instead o always being on the deensive against change and innovation.It just seems that they have a very narrow ocus. And thats the other thing. I dont know anybody that is
part o the NRA. Teyve never approached me. I dont know who they represent. I dont know i theyrepresent big chains or multi-million dollar restaurants or what. I dont think 90% o the restaurants inthis neighborhood have any contact with them at all.
EMPLOYER PROFILE: Egg, Brooklyn, New York
Owner George Weld, 5 years in the industry
General Manager Holly Howard, 10 years inthe industry
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
31/37
Serving While Sick | 26
When asked how this type o business model could spread in the industry Weld and Howard wereoptimistic.Oneingredientwasre-educatingconsumers.Weldasserted,ItsthesamewaytheGoodFoodMovementspreadthroughrestaurants.Oncepeoplestarttorealizethattheywanttosupportrestaurants
that support their workers, then theyll go to those restaurants. Another ingredient to a solution involveshow restaurants are run. Howard added I think its also about a reeducation o business owners. Tere issuch a way o doing things and its been done or so long that people really need to be reeducated. Weldalso expanded on this idea claiming that seeing restaurants that are protable and ethical is inspiring toowners. You dont want to be the last guy paying your workers under the table below minimum wage.Tey want to be as good as the best people in their business. And i you can show that you can do that atour scale, its exciting. You dont have to have 15 million dollars o revenue to do a good job. You can doit at a smaller scale.
Both Weld and Howard had advice or others that are considering the high road restaurant model.Howardcounseledthatownersshouldfocusonthelong-termbenetsovertheshort-termcosts:Ithink
thatpeoplegetoverwhelmedattheideaofit.Forinstance,ourhealthinsurance,onoursideofit,forayear will cost about $15,000. But when you tell a small restaurant like ours that thats $15,000 dollars oyour prot that youre going to lose, people tend to reak out. But you know when you break it down andthinkaboutwhatitmeanstomake$15,000over365days,itsnotthatmuchmoremoneythatyouneedto make. But its a commitment. So many people in the restaurant industry get into it orimmediate rewards or ast cash. But when you are trying to build a sustainable business, which includes
providing employee benets, its important to be able to think long term and realize that you might notsee the rewards immediately. She also added that owners should understand that certain practices willchange:Becauseitbringsaboutsomanychangesinyournancesandyourschedulingandyourpersonnel,Ithinkitssoimportanttobeexibleandopentoproblem-solving.
Weld advised other owners that these practices have positive results on the restaurants bottom line buthe also emphasized the non-monetary actors o the personal relationships between owners and work-ers:epayofordoingthingscorrectlyhasnancialawards,[butitalso]hashugeemotionalawards.Iknow restaurant owners who hide rom their employees when theyre o somewhere taking a break andtheir employees are killing themselves to make the money. Its a horrible way to eel. He argued thatlow-road employer practices necessarily have a toll on owners too. Te emotional rewards or these high-road practices are more than ample enough to justiy making these changes.
EMPLOYER PROFILE: Egg, Brooklyn, New York
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
32/37
Serving While Sick | 27
CHAPTER 5: POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS
Some o the health challenges addressed in this report can be improved by educating workers and
employers about best practices to avoid injury and illness on the job. However, to eectively address the
high rates o injury and illness among workers, it is clear that education is not sufcient; while it will
reduce the risks workers ace in the workplace, workers need to be able to care or their health in any
situation. Tese workers need benets, including health insurance, paid sick days, and paid vacations.
Without both education and intervention, the industry will continue to put both workers and
consumers at risk.
1. Benefts.
Workers who have access to ringe benets are better able to cope with injury or illness on the
job. Since injury and illness is related to demanding work environments, having the ability to take
timeoortoseeadoctorcouldpreventtheappearanceofnewsymptoms.Legislationshould
ensure restaurant consumer saety and level the playing eld by mandating paid sick days or all
workers and creating a public system that provides health care coverage or all, including
immigrants. Until such legislation is achieved, eorts to provide uninsured workers with low-cost
orfreehealthinsurance,suchasthroughROCsNationalRestaurantWorkersHealthInsurance
Plan (see box), should be supported.
2. Education or workers.
Workers should receive health and saety training on paid time, and in their own language. All
workers should be educated on workers compensation insurance, with language-specic written
materials and verbal education.
3. Saety and health conditions in restaurants need to be improved.Trough incentives or penalties, employers should be encouraged to ollow restaurant-specic
ergonomicguidelinesdevelopedbyROC,andgenerallyprovidesafe,well-ventilated,
well-organized environments or their workers to work; all employers should provide health and
saety training to their workers. Occupational Saety and Health Administration (OSHA)
standards or the restaurant industry should be improved and enorced.
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
33/37
Serving While Sick | 28
4. Education or employers and consumers.
Employers and consumers could benet rom learning the inormation gleaned rom this study,
to help employers avoid liability by re-organizing their workplaces and providing benets, and to
help consumers better understand what occurs behind kitchen doors.
5. Greater access to better jobs.
Since it is clear that higher-level positions provide greater access to benets, and that immigrants
and people o color are underrepresented in these jobs, we should work toward more equal
opportunity or these workers to obtain higher positions, including a ormal and transparent
protocol or workers to apply or promotion to higher-paying positions and the monitoring o
discrimination.
6. Model employer practices should be publicized to provide much-needed
guidance to other employers.
With policy makers support, research can be conducted and materials created to help employers
understand the benets o promoting rom within and creating a sae and diverse work
environment, as well as the negative consequences o ailing to provide such opportunities. All
ocus groups reported that i employers were willing to spend even minimal time and money on
saety, accidents and injuries could be avoided.
7. Collective organizing among restaurant workers should be supported.
Rather than simply providing workers with access to living-wage jobs, we must simultaneously worktoimproveworkingconditionsforallworkersintheindustry.Collectiveorganizingeorts
which oster better wages and working conditions enable restaurant workers to access health
insurance and other benets, and acilitate advancement, investment and ownership in the
industry.
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
34/37
Serving While Sick | 29
THE ROC-UNITED NATIONAL RESTAURANTWORKERS HEALTH INSURANCE PLAN
In 2010, based on the 505 worker surveys and 20 employer interviews ocused specically on workers
health insurance access and needs and consumer preerences with regard to health insurance, the
RestaurantOpportunitiesCenters(ROC)Unitedlaunchedanationalrestaurantworkershealth
insurance plan, in an attempt to oer its low-wage restaurant worker members with access to aordable
healthcarecoverage.Bypoolingits6,000membersnationwide,ROCwasabletonegotiateanaordable
rate or a limited benet plan through Aetna.
ROC-Unitedbelievesthathealthcarecoverageshouldbearightforall
peopleincludingundocumentedimmigrants.us,ROC-Unitedhasormed a National Health Insurance Plan to (1) oer aordable health
care coverage to all low-wage restaurant workers, especially those
excluded rom national Health Reorm legislation; (2) demonstrate that
undocumented immigrants are an insurable population, and (3)
encourage legislation to ll the gaps in coverage created by Health
Reform.ROCwillbeoeringtheplantoits6000membersineight
states, and partnering with high road employers looking to provide
aordable health insurance benets to their employees.
ROCsplanisnotcomprehensivecoverage.roughouttheprocessofenrollingitsmembers,itwill
continue to educate restaurant workers on the benets and limitations o a low-cost limited medical plan,
and limit membership enrollment to those restaurant workers whose needs would be best suited by a
low-costplan.Forlow-incomerestaurantworkerswhohavechronicillnessesorgreaterhealthcareneeds,
ROCcontinuestoinformthemaboutotherhealthinsuranceoptions,includingMedicaidifqualied
and discount clinics.
Mostimportantly,ROCisdocumentingitsexperienceinprovidingthisaordablecaretolow-wage restaurant workers to educate legislators about the need or, importance and potential o covering
populations that have been excluded rom national Health Reorm legislation, including undocumented
immigrants. Ultimately, we hope to provide easier access to health care or all.
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
35/37
APPENDIX | Survey Demograpics
As mentioned above, this report was based on two dierent data sets. Te larger data set was a sample o
4,323surveysadministeredbysta,members,andvolunteersfromRestaurantOpportunitiesCenter
aliatesinChicago,Detroit,NewOrleans,Maine,NewYork,Miami,LosAngeles,andWashington,DC,aswellasinpartnershipwithvolunteersfromallyacademicorcommunitybasedorganizationswith
signicant contacts among restaurant workers and access to workplaces in the industry. A total o 4,323
surveys were conducted rom 2003 until 2010. Tey were conducted ace-to-ace with workers in the
vicinity o restaurants during breaks or at the end o shis, and inside restaurants.
Serving While Sick | 30
Percent of Sample Percent of Sample
Race Restaurant Segment
White 36.9 FancyExpensive 33.6
Black 20.0 FamilyStyle 38.4
Hispanic/Latino 18.5 Fast/QuickServe 27.1
MiddleEastern 1.6 Location
Asian 14.4 Maine 12.1
Mixed 2.7 Chicago 13.3
Sex Michigan 11.7
Male 45.1 New Orleans 12.4
Female 54.8 New York 12.3
Age Miami 13.4
Below 25 46.6 Washington,DC 11.8
26-35 34.9 LosAngeles 13.0
36-45 11.7 TOTALSAMPLESIZE 4323
46-55 5.3
Above 55 1.5
Table8:CharacteristicsofLargeNationalRestaurantSurveySample(Unweighted)
Source:RestaurantOpportunitiesCentersUnitedsurveydata
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
36/37
Notes on Large National Restaurant Survey Sample
Because there is no government data source listing individual restaurant workers in each city, it would
have been extremely difcult to conduct a strictly random sample o this industry. Tus, in each location
we conducted a convenience sample survey, but used stratication to ensure that our sample was asrepresentativeaspossibleofthecitysrestaurantindustry.WeusedBureauofLaborStatisticsindustry
datatoidentifythesizeofkeyrestaurantindustrysegments,andCensusdatatoidentifythesizeofkey
demographic groups (race, gender, age, and county o residence), in order to develop sampling goals in
eachcity.Overaperiodof6to12monthsineachindividuallocality,andsevenyearstotalinalllocalities,
interviewers then contacted restaurants workers on the streets and in communities in which restaurant
workers reside, identiying workers as they le restaurants, or in restaurant uniorms, or simply by asking
individualsiftheyworkedinarestaurant.Likeallmethods,oursamplingmethodologyhasstrengthsand
limitations. While ours were not strictly random surveys, the strength o our outreach methodology is
thatitallowedustoincludepopulationsofworkerstypicallyunderrepresentedintheCensus.In
addition, in-person surveys lead to high question-specic response rates. Aerelding the surveys, we
weighted the data as a nal step to ensure representativeness. Specically, using data rom the United
StatesBureauofLaborStatistics,weweightedoursampletomatchthedistributionofbackofthe
house and ront o the house sta in ull-service establishments and limited-services eating places
inthenationsrestaurantindustry.Finally,inpoolingallofthelocaldataintoonenationaldataset,we
weighted each citys sample by the relative size o its restaurant industry, to ensure that restaurant workers
in dierently-sized markets were represented appropriately.
Serving While Sick | 31
8/4/2019 Serving While Sick High Risks & Low Benefits for the Nation's Restaurant Workforce, and Their Impact on the Cons
37/37
eRestaurantOpportunitiesCentersUnited(ROC-United)wouldliketothankthemanystudents,
volunteers, restaurant owners, and restaurant workers who devoted countless hours to conducting, input-
ting, and analyzing surveys and interviews and generally assisting with this project. Photos were taken by
membersandstaoftheRestaurantOpportunitiesCentersUnited(ROC-United),especiallyROC-
NY,ROC-NOLA,andROC-Chicago.
RestaurantOpportunitiesCentersUnited
350 Seventh Ave., Suite 1504
New York, NY 10001
(212)243-6900
fax:(212)243-6800
d