Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Self-concept among Primary school Students according to Gender and Academic
Achievement variables in Jordan
Nadia Al-Srour Safa Al-Ali The
University of Jordan The Hashemite University
Abstract
The aim of this study is to explore the level of self-concept among primary
school students according to gender and academic achievement variables in Amman.
A random sample was chosen from fourth, fifth and sixth grades in private schools in
Amman city. The sample of the study consisted of (365) male and female students,
(177) males and (188) females. To investigate the level of self-concept among the
sample's participants an Arabic version of self-concept questionnaire was
administrated after investigating reliability and validity for the self-concept
questionnaire.
The findings of the study showed that had a high level of self-concept in
general. However, the level of self-concept differs according to gender and academic
achievement variables as the means of males was higher than the means of females on
the total score and on each scales of peers' relations. Moreover, there is a significant
statistical differences at the level of (∞ ≥ 0.05) in the level of self-concept among
students due to differences in achievement as the differences were for the favor of
high achievers who score more than 95% in the present study, followed by the
students who achieved 85%-94% then those who achieved 85% and those who
refused to tell their averages.
2
Introduction
self- concept is one of the significant psychological concepts for many of the
developmental, clinical, social, and specifically educational outputs, it is in the
common sense the positive self concept may contribute positively in enhancing the
academic achievement level, as it consisted of two elements, descriptive and
evaluative, the first represents the first represents the individual's personal belief or
what can be called the self image (Marsh,a 1990).
Self –concept shaped by others and the environment and reciprocally influences how
one perceives the self, others, and the environment, the domains of self concept are
often differentiated from global self worth, self esteem and general self concept all of
which refer to the evaluation of ones worth as a person (Scott and Barona,2011).
Shavelson (1976) defined self-concept as the mental image or perception that
one has of oneself and shaped during his interaction with others and the surrounding
environment, this can be affected by the judgments of others as well as the provided
support. Moreover, he differed between the self-concept that is formed according to
the individual's perceptions for his own behavior and actions and the one based on
others reaction (Bracken, 1996).
Shavelson explained in his definition seven fundamental features related to the
theoretical background of self-concept (Hunt, 1997), those are:
1.It is organized structure
2. It is multi-dimensional, with each dimension reflecting an individual or group’.
3. It is hierarchical, with personal behavior in specific situation at the base, broad
inferences about the self in the middle, and global/general self-concept at the apex.
4. General self-concept is stable, but as one descent the hierarchy, self-concept
becomes more situations specific, and thereby less stable.
5. Self-concept becomes increasingly multidimensional as one grows polder.
6. Self-concept has both a descriptive and an evaluation aspect, and individuals may
weight dimensions differently.
7. Self-concept can be differentiated from others construct such as achievement or
fitness.
3
Developmental studies suggest that self-concept emerged as a result of
cognitive and social development, it consists of information related to self cognition
which is a means used by the individual to interpret and understand his experiences
and behaviors. Furthermore, it is a social outcome develops during his relation with
other while affected by their judgments and reactions. For example, the academic self
concept among children is affected by their parent expectations about their academic
abilities (Oyserman, 2001).
Achieving the effective functional performance includes the positive perception
of the individual for himself, and due to the huge amount of experience gained in
school, the academic achievement and school are considered the most important
factors affecting the individual's perceptions and realizations of himself (Hunt, 1997)
Self-concept is a multidimensional concept; it interacts with many areas of the
individual as the imaged perceived by the individual about himself and his abilities
are affected by his behaviors, actions and other people reactions towards those
behaviors in many situations. Despite the differences of images and perceptions
formed by the individual about himself due to the differences in those situations they
are integrated in a sequenced hierarchy since the individual perceptions about him self
extends from sub-domains to form the general self-concept. Therefore, there are two
types of self-concept: 1) academic self-concept which included the perceptions about
personal academic abilities affected particularly in mathematics area and verbal areas
2) non- academic self- concept which includes the perceptions formed by individuals
about his behaviors in the emotional, social and physical fields (Bracken, 1996).
The belief of the strength of self-concept emerged from its interference in
many physiological, social and educational fields due to the interactions with
experiences and behaviors with others reactions. William James stated that the
individual's beliefs about himself will directly affect his decisions and behaviors. In
an analytical study for (21) studies investigated the general self-concept and another
(20) studies aimed to investigate the academic self-concept, the findings reveled that
LD children showed low self-concept especially in the academic domain (Chmpan,
1988), this indicates the correlation strength between the achievement and the self
image formed by the individual (West, et al, 1980).
4
In sociology, Herbert and coolly confirmed the importance of social self
concept, stating that positive self-concept will lead to a desirable social behavior
(Scheirer and Kraut, 1979).
Sandchez & Roda (1995) stated the strong relation between academic
achievement and self- concept among primary school students, they used self
description questionnaire on a sample consisted of (245) primary school students. The
findings showed that the general self-concept and the academic self-concept
considered to be a good predictor for the individuals general performance.
Ishak & Chaw (2010) sought to explore the factors affecting the general self-
concept among adolescents in a study consisted of (1168) male and female students.
Self- concept questionnaire was administrated to explore their perceptions of
themselves. The results concluded three primary factors affecting the self-concept,
those are academic achievement, appearance and physical abilities and social
relations.
Furthermore, Wenglinsky (1996) administrated the 102- Item SDQ-II, to a
sample of 1,130 students participating in outward Bound, USA programs, finding that
the instrument can be reduced to thirty items with little loss of reliability, second it
applies regression analysis to the national educational longitudinal study, which
contain items from the SDQ-II, to measure the relationship between each self concept
domain and achievement in reading and mathematic, find that the effect of self
concept on achievement is domain specific: academic domains of self concept affect
academic achievement, while non academic domains do not.
The relation between academic self concept and academic self efficacy, studied by
(Ferla, Valcke, and Cai, 2009), the results indicates :
1. Students academic self concept strongly influences their academic self
efficacy beliefs.
2. Academic self concept is a better predictor (and mediator) for effective
motivational variables while academic self efficacy is the better predicator for
academic achievement.
5
In another study, Kaur & Kaur (2009) aimed to explore the relationship
between academic achievement and home environment and self-concept among a
sample of student consisted of (300) male and female students. The researchers
administrated Self concept list (Deo, 1988) and home environment Inventory
(Misra, 1989). The findings of the study showed that there was no significant
correlation relationship between self-concept and academic achievement among
adolescents meanwhile, there were a significant relation between self-concept and
the nature of home environment.
The relationship between self-concept and achievement is not comprehensible;
however, intervention programs assumed that positive self-concept is related to
student's performance; as if self-concept is high the student's academic
achievement is enhanced. Meanwhile, researchers noticed that there is a problem
in explaining this relation assuming that the high academic achievement led to a
high self-concept ( Hunt, 1997)
The weakness of relation between general self-concept and achievement may
hide the reality revolving around the strength between some fields of self-concept
and academic achievement. Marsh(1990)found that there is strong positive
relation between mathematics achievement and mathematics self concept as well
as between reading achievement and verbal self concept. Meanwhile, there were
reversal relation between reading achievement and mathematics self concept and
the same for verbal self concept.
Gender differences in academic self – concept have been a topic of research
for several decades, studies of gender differences in general academic self –
concept have yielded inconclusive result. Githua and Mwangi ( 2005) investigated
how student' mathematics self – concept (MSC) is related to their motivation to
learn mathematics (SMOT) and gender differences in the two constructs. Result
show a statistically significant relationship between students' mathematics self –
concept (MSC) and motivation to learn mathematics ( SMOT). Mathematics self –
concept explained 63% of the variance in SMOT. Gender differences favoring
boys, that boys perceive their success in mathematics more positively than girl.
Gender differences continue to exist,Skaalvik and Skaalvik (2004) indicated
that male students had higher self – concept in mathematics than did femal
6
students, but older student had higher verbal than mathematics self – concept
regardless of gender.
Rationale of the Study
The rationales of this study are represented in:
1) The need of developing an instrument for the Jordanian environment with
suitable validity and reliability considering the natural of the educational stage
to contribute in investigating the student's understanding of themselves.
2) The necessity of exploring the variables related to self concept among students
and identifying the differences between them.
3) Enriching the related literature with the level of self concept among primary
school students in Amman area and the influence of academic achievement.
Study Importance
The importance of this study is represented in developing a Jordanian form of
(SDQ-I) questionnaire with suitable validity and reliability values to contribute in
investigating the student's understanding of themselves. Therefore, the importance of
this study appears in:
1) Providing a Jordanian form of (SDQ-I) questionnaire with suitable Jordanian
validity and reliability values.
2) Enriching the related literature with the level of self concept among primary
school students in Amman area.
3) Exploring the level of differences between students' self concept according to
the differences in gender and academic achievement.
4) Providing teachers and school counselors with a Jordanian form that can be
used in exploring the levels of self-concept expressed by self description in the
questionnaire among primary school students.
5) Directing researchers' attention towards self-concept and its affect with
academic achievement and gender.
http://www.google.jo/url?q=http://www.adbi.org/working-paper/2009/03/17/2899.global.determinants.stress.risk.ppp.infrastructure/objectives.and.rationale.of.the.study/&sa=X&ei=9NhfTsmBGciO8gPy-7GtAw&ved=0CDcQ2wQ&usg=AFQjCNGvHXr6uCTD1wAEPwfu5ZwaKPLLxw
7
Study Questions
The aim of this study is to explore the level of self-concept among primary school
students (Fourth, fifth, sixth grades) according to their gender and academic
achievement variables in Amman area. This in order to conclude some information
that may contribute in determining the level of self concept among primary school
students in this area and the effects of gender and achievement to help specialists to
consider it in educational applications. Particularly, the study is seeking to answer the
following research questions:
1) What is the level of self concept among primary school students in Amman?
2) Are there any significant statistical differences at the level of (∞= 0.05) for
performance on the total score on the self description questionnaire among
primary school students due to differences in gender and academic
achievement? .
3) Are there any significant statistical differences at the level of (∞= 0.05) for
performance on the subscales on the self description questionnaire among
primary school students due to differences in gender and academic
achievement? .
Method
Population and Study Sample
The population of the study is all Primary school students studying in the
fourth, fifth and sixth grades in the private school in Amman Area (Jordan University
Metropolitan area). The sample of the study consisted of (365) male female students
chosen randomly. Table (1) shows the distribution of the sample according to gender
and achievement variables
8
Table (1): Study Sample distribution according to gender and achievement (n=365)
Achievement
Gender
Male Female Total
Less than 85% 30 28 58
84%-94% 78 77 155
More than 95% 47 49 96
Refused to tell 22 34 56
Total 177 188 365
Research Instruments
To achieve the aim of this study an arabized form of Self- Description
Questionnaire (SDQ) for the primary school was developed. The original
questionnaire was developed by Marsh (1988) setting out from the theoretical
background of multidimensional self-concept. This questionnaire can be
administrated individually and in groups and there are no certain training needs as it
needs only 15 minutes to be finished on individual level. The SDQ is targeting fourth,
fifth and sixth graders. Items were phrased in sentences followed by an evaluation
questionnaire (True, sometimes true, and wrong) (Marsh, 1990).
The questionnaire is consisted of (76) items asses student's self description in
two domains
- The Academic domain: the items in this domain aim to explore the level of
individual's description of himself in the school academic fields, this include
the following areas: reading, mathematics and General School.
- Non Academic domains: the items in this domain aim to explore the level of
individual's description of himself in non academic domains, it includes the
following areas: physical appearance, physical abilities, Peer relations ,
Parental relations and General Self.
The original questionnaire had high reliability and validity calls for the need to
develop an Arabic version fitting the Jordanian environment to contribute in exploring
the level of student's description for themselves. Following the procedures followed to
develop the Jordanian form of the questionnaire:
9
1) The initial form of the questionnaire was developed through the
translation of the original items into Arabic language taking into
consideration the content of each item with the correct phrasing.
2) The Arabic form of the questionnaire was sent to (10) specialized raters
working in special education and counseling Department in the
University of Jordan to obtain their opinions about the translation
accuracy into Arabic language and to obtain their opinions about
phrasing.
3) The Arabic form of the questionnaire was sent to (10) specialized raters
working special education and counseling Department in the University
of Jordan to obtain their opinions about the reliability of the content .
Their agreement totaled (90%).
4) The questionnaire was administrated on a total sample to reach
statistical Data about the validity of the Jordanian form as reliability
coefficients were calculated using internal consistency, in terms of
statistics paragraph using the equation of Cronbach alpha. Table (2)
shows that.
Table (2): Internal Consistency Coefficients for the Total sample by scale (N=365)
Scales Coefficient Alpha
Physical Ability 76.0
Physical Appearance 7600
Peer relations 7600
Parental relations 7600
Reading 76.7
Mathematics 76.0
General School 76.0
General Self 76.0
Total score 7600
Table (2) shows that the reliability coefficients are high, as it totaled (0.93) for
performance on the total score. Meanwhile, coefficients ranged from (0.65 – 0.89) for
performance on the subdomains of the questionnaire. Therefore, the questionnaire has
good reliability values and it is appropriate to be administrated on the study sample.
Administration
11
The study instrument was administrated on the students studying in the private
schools West Amman District, in the fourth, fifth and sixth classes. The
administration duration was 3 months as the researchers applied the questionnaire
without any help on the sample as a group (chosen randomly). The researchers
explained the administration instructions mentioned on the questionnaire asking
respondents to response accurately on all items. The confidentially of information
were confirmed too. Thus, writing the name of the respondent on the questionnaire
sheet was optional.
The questionnaire was distributed on all respondent whom in turn wrote their
evaluations and since there is a possibility of difficulties in reading or
misunderstanding among fourth grader, each item was read solely and explained for
students then they were asked to write their evaluations.
Scoring
The scores were obtained by convert the student' response to each item into one
of the following scores: True =3, sometimes true =2, false =1. 8 scores were obtained
to represent the subscales of the SDQ-I: Physical Ability, Physical Appearance, Peer
relations , and Parental relations, Reading, Mathematics, General School and General
Self. All scores were added for each respondent to obtain the total score on the
questionnaire to represent the general self concept of them.
Study Design and Statistical analysis
To answer the study questions, the means and standard deviations of students'
scores for each subscales were obtained. Moreover, the means and standard deviations
of the performance in the total score of the questionnaire were calculated according to
gender and academic achievement variables. Two way ANOVA was used to measure
the indication of the differences between the means, then Tukey test was used for post
differences of performance on the total score of the questionnaire.
Two way MANOVA and Two way ANOVA were used to calculate the
indication of means differences on the subscales according to gender and achievement
variables. Additionally, Tukey test was used for post differences to revel the sources
of differences.
11
Results
The purpose of this study is to investigate the level of self-concept among
primary school students and its relation to their gender and academic achievement in
Amman Area. To achieve this purpose a random sample was chosen from primary
school students studying in the private schools Amman. The instrument was
administrated on the sample after checking out reliability and validity. Following, the
results of the study.
First: Results of the first question: What is the level of self concept among
primary school students in Amman?
To answer this question the performance mean of the sample on the total score
of the questionnaire and subscales were extracted, the obtained scores were
distributed on three categories as follows:
- low level of self description represented on the degrees 1- 1.66
- Average level of self description represented on the degrees 1.67- 2.33
- high level of self description represented on the degrees 2.34- 3.00
Table (3) Demonstrates the means and Standard Deviations For subscales and total
score on Self Description Questionnaire in Jordanians sample , (n= 365).
Table 3: Means and Standard Deviations For Subscales and Total
Score on Self Description Questionnaire , (n= 365).
Scale Mean SD
Physical Ability 06.. 76000
Physical
Appearance 0600 76000
Peer relations 060. 760.0
Parental relations 06.7 76000
Reading 0600 76007
Mathematics 0600 76000
General School 0600 76007
General Self 0600 76000
Total score 06.0 76000
12
Table (3) shows that the level of self description among primary school students
was high in general. Moreover, it appears the highest means were for the Parental
relations scale while the lowest was for mathematics scale.
Second: Results of the second question: Are there any significant statistical
differences at the level of (∞= 0.05) for performance on the total score on the self
description questionnaire among primary school students due to differences in
gender and academic achievement?
Means and standard deviations were calculated for performance on the total
score of the questionnaire according to gender and academic achievement (n=365)
Table (4) shows that:
Table 4: Means and Standard Deviations For Total Score on Self Description
Questionnaire According to Gender and Achievement , (n= 365).
Achievement Gender Mean SD
Less than 85%
Male 06.0 76000
Femal 0600 76000
Total 0600 76000
( 84%-95%)
Male 06.0 760.0
Femal 06.0 76077
Total 06.0 76000
More than 95%
Male 0600 76000
Femal 0600 76000
Total 0600 760..
Refused to tell
Male 06.. 76000
Femal 0600 76007
Total 060. 76000
Total
Male 06.0 76000
Femal 06.0 76000
Total 06.0 76000
As shown in Table(4) there are significant statistical differences between the
means of performance on the total score of the questionnaire according to gender and
academic achievement as the means of males' performance were higher from the
means of female's performance in general. Furthermore, Table (2) shows that the
highest means were for the favor of the students with the highest achievement (95%)
while the lowest for the students who achieved less than (85%) or those who refused
to give their averages.
13
To find the indication of the differences in performance means on the total score
of self description questionnaire Two way ANOVA was used according to gender and
academic achievement. Table (5) demonstrates the results of Two way ANOVA
according to gender and achievement.
Table 5:Two way ANOVA for Total Score on SDQ-I According to Gender and Achievement
(N=365)
Source of
Variantion
Sum of
Squares
Degrees of
Freedom
Mean of
Squares F Significance
Avrg 06000 0 76000 060.. 76777
Gender 76000 0 76000 .6000 76770
Avrg * G 76000 0 76700 76..0 7600.
Error 0.6000 000 76700
Total 0.6.00 000
Table(5) shows that (f) value for gender and academic achievement was
significant at the level of (∞ = 0.05) indicating that there are significant statistical
differences due the differences in gender and achievement. Meanwhile, (F) value for
the effect of interaction between f
Tukey test was used to explain the sources of differences shown in the means of
the sample's performance. Table (6) shows that the differences in performance means
for the total score was for the favor of high achievement students in general, the
differences were for the (95%) category students, followed by (85-84%) students then
those with less than 85% and finally students who refused to give their averages.
Table 6: Tukey Pos Hoc Test for the Total Scores on SDQ-I According
to Achievement (N =365).
Achievement Achievement
(84% -94%) More than 95% Refused to tell
Less than
85% -7670 -.00)*( 7670
(84% -94%) -.00)*( 7670
More than
95% .0.)*(
14
Third: Results of the third question: Are there any significant statistical
differences at the level of (∞= 0.05) for performance on the subscales on the self
description questionnaire among primary school students due to differences in
gender and academic achievement? .
Means and standard deviations were calculated for performance on the sub
Scales of the questionnaire according to gender and academic achievement (n=365)
Table (7) shows that:
Table 7: Means and Standard Deviations For Subscales Score on Self Description Questionnaire
According to Gender and Achievement , (n= 365).
Subscales Achievement
Gender
Male Female Total
Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD
Physical Ability
Less than 85% 060. 76000 06.0 76000 0607 760.0
(85% -94%) 0600 76000 0600 7600. 06.0 76000
More than
95% 06.7 76007 0600 760.. 06.0 76007
Refused to tell 0600 76007 060. 76000 0600 7600.
Total 0600 7600. 0600 76000 06.. 76000
Physical
Appearance
Less than 85% 06.0 7600. 06.0 760.7 06.. 76007
(85% -94%) 0600 76000 0600 7600. 0600 76070
More than
95% 0600 76000 0600 76000 0600 76077
Refused to tell 06.7 76000 0600 76007 0600 76000
Total 0600 76000 0600 76000 0600 76070
Peer relations
Less than 85% 060. 76077 0600 76000 0600 7600.
(85% -94%) 0600 76000 06.7 7600. 060. 760.7
More than
95% 06.0 7600. 06.0 76070 06.0 76000
Refused to tell 0600 760.0 0600 76000 0600 76000
Total 0600 76000 0600 76070 060. 760..
Parental relations Less than 85% 0600 76000 0600 76000 060. 76007
(85% -94%) 0600 76000 06.0 76070 0600 76000
More than
95% 06.. 76000 06.0 76000 06.. 76000
Refused to tell 06.0 76000 06.7 7600. 06.0 7600.
Total 0600 76000 06.0 76070 06.7 76000
Reading
Less than 85% 06.0 760.. 06.7 76000 06.0 76000
(85% -94%) 0600 7600. 060. 7600. 0600 76000
More than
95% 06.0 76000 06.0 76070 06.0 76070
Refused to tell 0607 7600. 0600 76000 0600 76070
Total 0600 76000 060. 7607. 060. 76000
Mathematics Less than 85% 0600 76000 0600 76.70 0600 76.7.
(85% -94%) 0600 76000 0600 760.. 0607 76000
15
Table 7: Means and Standard Deviations For Subscales Score on Self Description Questionnaire
According to Gender and Achievement , (n= 365).
Subscales Achievement
Gender
Male Female Total
Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD
More than
95% 0600 760.7 0600 76000 06.0 76070
Refused to tell 06.0 76000 060. 760.. 0600 76000
Total 0600 7600. 0607 76000 0600 76000
General School
Less than 85% 0600 76000 0600 76000 0600 760.7
(85% -94%) 0600 76000 0600 760.0 0600 760.0
More than
95% 06.0 76000 06.0 76077 06.0 76000
Refused to tell 0600 76000 0600 76070 060. 76000
Total 0600 7600. 0600 76000 0600 76070
General Self Less than 85% 0607 7600. 0600 76000 0600 7600.
(85% -94%) 0600 7600. 0600 760.0 0600 76000
More than
95% 06.0 76000 06.0 76007 06.0 76000
Refused to tell 06.. 76000 0607 76007 06.0 76000
Total 0600 7600. 060. 76007 0600 76000
Table (0) shows that shows that the level of self description among primary
school students was high in general. Moreover, it appears the highest means were for
the Parental relations scale while the lowest was for mathematics scale. Moreover, the
means of performance on the sub scales among students was higher for students with
(95%) averages compared with those with less than (85%) averages.
With regard to gender variable table (5) shows that the means of males'
performance were hand higher than the means of females on physical abilities, Peer
relations , General School and mathematics scale. Meanwhile, the means of females'
performances were higher on relation with parents, reading and General Self scale. On
the physical appearance scale there were no differences between males and females.
To find the indication of the differences in performance means on the total score of
self description questionnaire Two way MANOVA was used according to gender and
academic achievement. Table (.) demonstrates the results of Two way MANOVA
according to gender and achievement.
16
Table 8: Two way MANOVA for Subscales Score on SDQ-I According to Gender and
Achievement (N=365)
Source Value F StdError Sig
Wilks' Lambda
Achievement(Avrg) 76.00 06.0. 0.06.70 76777
Gender(G) 76.70 076070 0006777 76777
(Avrg) * (G) 76000 76.70 0.06.70 76000
Table (.) shows that (f) value for both gender and academic achievement was
significant statistically, indicating that there are significant statistical differences due
to gender and achievement, meanwhile, there were no significant statistical
differences due to the interaction between them.
Furthermore, Two way ANOVA was used to calculate the indications of performance
differences on the subscales. Table (0) explains those differences.
Table 9:Two way ANOVA for Subscales Score on SDQ-I According to Gender and
Achievement (N=365)
Scales Dependent
Variable
Sum of
Square
s
Df Mean
Square F Sig
Physical Ability
Avrg 76000 0 76000 06007 76000
Gender 06000 0 06000 006..0 76777
Avrg * G 76000 0 767.0 760.7 7607.
Error 006.00 00. 76070
Total 0060.0 000
Physical
Appearance
Avrg 76000 0 76700 760.0 7600.
Gender 76700 0 76700 76007 76000
Avrg * G 76000 0 7670. 76070 76000
Error 006000 00. 76700
Total 006070 000
Relation with
Peers
Avrg 060.0 0 76000 060.0 76700
Gender 76700 0 76700 76000 760.0
Avrg * G 760.. 0 7670. 76000 76000
Error 006000 00. 76000
Total 006000 000
Relation with
Parents
Avrg 76000 0 760.. 06000 7670.
Gender 76700 0 76700 76000 76.00
Avrg * G 76070 0 76070 06077 76000
Error 006070 00. 76700
Total 0.677. 000
Reading
Avrg 06000 0 76070 06000 76777
Gender 76700 0 76700 760.7 76.00
Avrg * G 7600. 0 7670. 76.70 76007
17
Error 006007 00. 76700
Total 0060.0 000
Mathematics
Avrg 06700 0 06000 06.70 76770
Gender .600. 0 .600. 006000 76777
Avrg * G 06000 0 7607. 06070 760..
Error .06.00 00. 76007
Total 0060.0 000
General School
Avrg 06000 0 06000 .6.70 76777
Gender 760.. 0 760.. 06000 760.0
Avrg * G 76700 0 76700 76000 7600.
Error 006.70 00. 76000
Total 0.6770 000
General Self
Avrg 0600. 0 76000 06000 76770
Gender 76700 0 76700 760.0 76000
Avrg * G 76700 0 76770 767.0 76000
Error 006000 00. 76700
Total 0.6000 000
As shown in Table (0) (f) values according to gender were significant statistically on
physical abilities and mathematics Scales. While, on academic achievement variable
(f) values was significant on Peer relations , reading, mathematics, General School
and General Self scales.
Tukey test was used to explain the sources of differences shown in the means of the
sample's performance. Table (07) explains those sources.
Table 10:Tukey Pos Hoc Test for the Subscales Scores on SDQ-I
According to Achievement (N =365).
Scale Achievement Achievement
(85%-
945)
More
than
95%
Refused to
tell
Physical Ability
Less than 85% 7670 7670 7600
(.0 %-00)% -7670 767.
More than 95% 7600
Physical
Appearance .
Less than 85% -7670 -7670 -767.
(.0 %-00)% -7670 -7670
More than 95% 7670
Peer Relations
Less than 85% -7670 -7670 7600
(.0 %-00)% -7670 .00)*(
More than 95% .00)*(
Parental
Relations
Less than 85% 7670 -767. -7670
(.0 %-00)% -7670 -7670
More than 95% 767.
Reading Less than 85% -7600 -.00)*( -7600
18
(.0 %-00)% -.00)*( 7670
More than 95% 7600
Mathematics
Less than 85% -767. -.00)*( -7670
(.0 %-00)% -.00)*( 7670
More than 95% .00)*(
General School
Less than 85% -7670 -.00)*( -7670
(.0 %-00)% -.07)*( 767.
More than 95% .0.)*(
General Self
Less than 85% -7670 -.00)*( 7670
(.0 %-00)% -.00)*( 7670
More than 95% .0.)*(
Table (10) shows that the means of the highest performance were for the favor of high
achievers who scored (95%) on all subscales which all were significant statistically.
Discussion
The purpose of this study is to explore the levels of self concept among primary
school students according to gender and achievement variables in Amman area. To
achieve this aim a random sample consisted of (365) male and female students from
the ,fourth, fifth and sixth grades were chosen.
The findings of the study showed that primary school students in Amman area
had a high level of self concept represented in the performance mean on the total
degree totaling (2.64) and on all the subscales of the questionnaire. The highest was
for the relation with parents scale while the lowest was for the mathematics scale.
With regard to gender variable the means of males' performance were higher than the
means of females' performance. This may be due to the differences in several factors
such as parenting styles and the culture in Arab states which focuses on increasing
males' confidence in a higher manner than females, as well as the type of enforcement
received by males is different than the one received by females.
Furthermore, findings indicated that there are significant statistical differences
in performance on the total score of the questionnaire according to achievement as the
result showed that high achievers (95%) had higher self concept than those with
achievement lower than 85%. This result is a very important one when talking about
scientific and achievement outcomes and students' motivation as well as its relation to
19
the perspective that formed by the students about himself. Many studies mentioned
that there is a strong interaction relation between self concept among students and
their academic achievement level as one can predict one of them by knowing the
other.
When defining self concept as the image formed by the individual himself
during interactions with others and its interactions with the surrounding environment,
the academic achievement, which reflects the ability of the student in reading and
mathematics skills and other academic areas, from more variables that contribute to
the image formed by the individual himself, as students with high achievement feel
success and confidence than low achievers and that the level of social acceptance by
parents, teachers and other students with achievement of high and the promise of the
boosters and the positive feedback reflects the satisfaction, enhance the confidence of
the student high achievement by itself, and it is expected that develop the concept
with the highest when compared with students with low achievement, which gave
them a sense of shame, frustration and failure, as well as refusal to meet him and
scolding and dissatisfaction of teachers, parents and others in the community around
him.
Those differences seem to be clear in the results of the current study as after
administrating Tukey test for post differences the level of self concept was for the
favor of the students with academic achievement higher than 95% followed by
students with academic achievement varied between 85-94% then the students with
achievement less than 85% finally the students who refused to mention their averages.
This indicates that there is a strong correlation relation between positive self concept
with achievement, another confirmation of this results that those who refused to
mentioned their averages had a low self concept compared by other students. This
makes us expecting that the achievement is low unless there was no other reason since
the students was informed that the data will be for scientific research only and will be
treated confidentially.
With regard to the results of the third question the findings showed that there is
a difference in the means of students' performance on the subscales of the self
description questionnaire, those means differed according to the differences in gender
and academic achievement. The highest mean was for the relation with parents scale.
21
Meanwhile, the lowest was foe mathematics scale. This result indicates the self
concept related to the relation with parents was high in general and can be attributed
to the parenting and culture factor the concentrates from a young age on the respect
and love of parents for both males and females and this can be reflected and
reinforced by satisfaction from parents.
On the other hand, the self concept in mathematics scale was low, this may be
due to the negative idea about mathematics as it is undesired subject by students in
many educational stages.
With regard to gender variable, the results indicated that the averages of the higher
significance was in favor of males on each of the of physical and mathematics scales,
which means that the self-concept among males in their abilities physical and skills in
mathematics were higher than females on these dimensions.
Those two subscales especially the physical scale is affected totally by gender,
parenting and Arabic culture which assumes that physical ability of males is higher
than in females. Additionally, the opportunity of practicing sports by males is higher
than the opportunity of females providing students with a feedback on their physical
skills higher than the one provided for females.
As well as mathematic scale, the nature of encouragement and strength by the
parents is usually directed more to males than in females, as the family seeks to
provide all the ways to facilitate the learning process, especially if the son mentioned
he was ranked first. All of the practices followed by the family, school and
community to enhance the male self-concept have a high score compared with female.
The results of the current study, confirmed the difference in the level of self-concept
on different sub-dimensions of academic achievement, as were all for the achievement
of students with high grades who were above 95% on all sub-dimensions that showed
the results of analysis of variance as a function of the bilateral statistically. This result
is logical in light of the importance of academic achievement on many variables,
psychological and educational, the concept of self, which might as a student for the
same with regard to his skills in reading, math and other academic areas depend
primarily on academic achievement, in addition to that usually has the students with
the collection of high acceptance social high by teachers, parents and colleagues, it is
21
expected to be associated with the concept of self-peer relations with also high.
What has been concluded from the results, confirming the need for attention to the
concept of self among primary school students in particular and all students in
general, on account of its importance in the educational applications and because of
its relationship to positive with many of the educational concepts, For educators and
teachers keen to develop the concept of positive to all students, and taking into
account individual differences among them, and strengthen their self-confidence, and
provide opportunities for all, as factors play a role in the perceptions formed by the
student himself.
Furthermore, the researchers state the need of careful attention when
generalizing the results, as it is limited to students in grades fourth, fifth and sixth in
private schools in the Amman area, and recommends that further research on self-
concept among students and disclosure of its relationship with other educational
concepts such as motivation and effectiveness, and General School.
22
References
- Braken,B.(1996). Handbook of Self Concept: Developmental, Social and
Clinical Considerations. Canada, Oha Wiley & Sous, Inc.
- Champman.,W.(1988). Learning disabled children's Self – Concepts, Review
of Educational Research, 58,347 -371.
- Ferla,J.,Valcke,M., and Cai,Y.(2009). Academic Self Efficacy and Academic
Self Concept: Reconsidering Structural Relationships. Learning and
Individual Differences, 19,499-505.
- Githua,B., and Mwangi,J.(2003). Students' mathematics self – concept and
motivation to learn mathematics; relationship and gender differences among
Kenya Secondary School in Nairobi and Rift Valley Provinces, International
Journal of Educational Development. 23,487-499.
- Hunt, Teresa.(1997). Self Concept , Hope and Achievement: A look at the
Relationship Between Achievement self concept , Level of Hope and
Academic Achievement. Missouri Westren State.
- Ishak,Z., and Chew,F.(2010). Factors Influencing Students' Self –Concept
among Malaysian Students. World Academy of Science, Engineering and
Technology. 66.
- Kaur, J., and Kaur,R.(2009). Home Environment and Academic Achievement
as Correlates of Self Concept Among Adolescents, Stud Home Comm Sci,
3(1), 13-17.
- Marsh, Herbert a.(1990) . The Structural Academic Self Concept, the Marsh
\Shavelson Model. Journal of Educational Psychology ,82,623-636 .
- Marsh, Herbert b.(1990). Self Description Questionnaire – I: Manual,
Publication Unit, Faculty of Educational University of Western Sydney,
Macarthur.
- Oyserman,D.(2001). Self Concept and Identity. In: Tesser.,A and Schwarz
. Handbook of Social Psychology: Intra individual Processes: Blackwell
Publishers Ltd.
23
- Sanchez, F., and Roda,M.( 1995). Relationships between Self –Concept and
Academic Achievement in Primary Students. Journal of Research in
Educational Psychology and Psycho pedagogy, 1 (1), 95 -120.
- Scheirer,M., and Kraut, R.(1979). Increasing Educational Achievement Via
Self Concept Change. Review of Educational Research. Vol 49,No 1, 131-
150.
- Scott ,A., and Barona, M.(2011). The Stability of Self Concept Between
Elementary and Junior High School in Catholic School Children. Catholic
Education: A Journal of Inquiry and Practice, Vol 14, No 3, 292 -318.
- Skaalvik,s., and Skaalvik,E.(2004), Gender Differences in Math and Verbal
Self – Concept, Performance Expectations, and Motivation, Sex Roles,
Vol.50,Nos,3\4, 241-252.
- Wenglinsky, Harld.(1996). Measuring Self Concept and Relating it To
Academic Achievement: Statistical Analysis of Marsh Self Description
Questionnaire. Educational Testing Service Princeton, New Jersey.
- West,C.,Fish,J., and Stevens,R.J(1980). General Self Concept, Self Concept
of Academic Ability and School Achievement :Implications for " Causes " of
Self Concept. The Australian Journal of Education,24, 94 -213.