Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 1/15
ZIJY\AXQ AZZYIZ AK JDAKAJ@D AKCN\G@XAJZ
@|ykoyg`| \ihhq G`|iu`ddq Jb|az Ag`cahnk
i`zqu`xaikx|ijn|hzEfg`ad+jng jb|az0<Eyid+`j+yo Zjbnnd nc Jnguyxakf$ Akcn|g`xank Zjbnnd nc Jnguyxakf$ Akcn|g`xank
Xijbkndnfq kh Ikfakii|akf Xijbkndnfq kh Ikfakii|akfYkasi|zaxq nc I`zx Dnkhnk$ Ykasi|zaxq nc I`zx Dnkhnk$
Hnjod`khz J`guyz$ Ykasi|zaxq V`q$ Hnjod`khz J`guyz$ Ykasi|zaxq V`q$
Dnkhnk I03 <\H Dnkhnk I03 <\H
Cn|gi|dq$ Bi`h nc G`k`figikx nc Xijbkndnfq Ykax$ Pyiik G`|q$ Ykasi|zaxq nc
Dnkhnk+Fyizx Zigak`| Dijxy|i| `x Ykasi|zaxq nc J`gl|ahfi+
Fyizx Dijxy|i| `x Ykasi|zaxq nc Nrcn|h+
@JOKNVDIHFIGIKXZU|ncizzn| H|+ O`n|a Z`z`oa$ Agui|a`d Jnddifi$ —Uyldaj Ykhi|zx`khakf nc Jnguyxi| H`x`l`ziz
ak Bi`dxb J`|i‗+
Ykasi|zaxq nc J`gl|ahfi cn| xbi Zijy|axq Zigak`| Zi|aiz bidh `x J`gl|ahfi+
Viddjngi X|yzx cn| biducyd akcn|g`xank nk akcn|g`xajz+
OIQVN\HZ=Akcn|g`xajz$ Jdakaj d Akcn|g`xajz$
Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|hz$ Xijbkndnfq$
Zijy|axq Azzyiz$ U|as`jq$ @yxbikxaj`xank$
Akcn|g`xank Ldnjoakf Gijb`kazgz+
@LZX\@JXXbi |ndi nc Akcn|g`xajz ak Jdakaj`d
Akzxaxyxankz$ Bi dxb N|f`kaz xankz `kh
Bnzuax dz b`si liik xnv`|hz agu|izzasi
f|nvxb ak `hnuxakf Xijbkndnfaiz vbajb
bidu ak g`oakf jdakaj`d hijazankz$ agu|nsi
j`|i$ agudigikxakf bi dxb akcn|g`xank
zqzxigz `kh jdakaj`d g`k`figikx+
Akxi|kix$ Xijbkndnfaiz$ Zncxv |i
agudigikx xankz `|i civ xi|gakndnfaiz
vbajb hizj|ali xbi bi`dxb n|f`kaz`xankz ak
xbi u|izikx jnkhaxankz+ X|`kzcn|gakf xbi
u`ui| l`zih gihaj`d |ijn|hz xn idijx|nkaj
v`z `k i`|dai| x`zo `kh knv x|`kzcn|gakf
xbi Idijx|nkaj U xaikx \ijn|hz akxn
hasazankz daoi zygg`|q `kh hix adih
|ijn|hz `|i kiv ak Bi`dxb n|f`kaz`xankz ak
KBZ+
@z Akxi|kix az xbi g`mn| zny|ji nc
jnggykaj`xank `kh akxi|`jxank lixviik
ubqzaja kz$ u xaikxz `kh bi`dxbj |i
u|nsahi|z xbi h`x` n| xbi akcn|g`xank
zxn|ih az knx u|as`xi+ Gn|i hidali|`xankzbnydh li xnv`|hz Zijy|axq |ipya|igikxz
zyjb `z Hqk`gaj @yxbn|a}`xank ‚ xbaz zxiu
g`oiz hijazankz l zih nk |ykxagi
u`|`gixi|z `kh knx nk myzx |ndi nc xbi yzi|$
Gydxa C`jxn| @yxbikxaj`xank ‚ gn|i xb`k
xvn xquiz nc `yxbikxaj xank u|njihy|iz
zbnydh li g`hi g`kh`xn|q xn xbi zx`cc$
bi dxbj`|i u|nsahi|z `kh jngu`kaiz xn
`jxy`ddq saiv ` u`xaikx‑z bi`dxbakcn|g`xank `kh @jjizz Jnkx|nd
gijb`kazgz ‚ vbajb ik`ldiz
`hgakazx| xn|z xn `jxy`ddq cadxi| xbi
`yxbn|a}`xank ui|gazzankz nc xbi yzi|+
Xbaz u`ui| |iun|xz nk xbi Zijy|axq
Azzyiz |id`xih xn u|as`jq nc xbi h`x` `kh
agudigikxakf u|as`jq g`akx`akakf zixxakfz
daoi `yxbikxaj`xank `kh ldnjoakf nc xbi
akcn|g`xank `jjn|hakf xn xbi u xaikx‑z
unakx nc saiv `|i akx|nhyjih+ Xbizi
U|as`jq Ldnjoakf `kh @yxbikxaj`xank
zixxakfz `|i akx|nhyjih akI`zqu`xaikx|ijn|hz vbajb az irjdyzasidq
hizafkih xn bidu ykhi|zx`kh xbi kiih cn|
u|as`jq jnkx|nd `kh vadd li si|q biducyd
cn| Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|hz+ Xbi |i`znk
KBZ `kh K`xank d U|nf|`ggi cn| AX
"KUcAX! zbnydh jnkzahi| `kh agudigikx
xbizi ak Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|hz az lij`yzi
xbi ZJ\ az `jjizzaldi lq jdakaj d zx`cc$
igi|fikjq zx`cc `kh `dzn lq xbi u`xaikx+
Xbi u|izikx ZJ\ az gazzakf xbi u|as`jq
dnjoz `kh `yxbikxaj xank "u`zzvn|h
|ijnfkaxank u`fi! vbajb `|i akx|nhyjih
xb|nyfb xbaz u`ui|+
0
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 2/15
0+ AKX\NHYJXANKXbi j|i`xank `kh yz`fi nc Idijx|nkaj
U`xaikx \ijn|h Zqzxig ak `kq bi`dxbn|f`kaz`xankz vadd l|akf kiv likicaxz `kh
biduz ak akj|i`zakf xbi iccajaikjq nc xbi
py`daxq nc j |i xn xbi u xaikxz+ Xbi
agu|nsigikx ak jnzx iccijxasikizz$ i||n|
|ihyjxank `kh v`zx`fi nc h`x` hiuikhz nk
bnv fnnh xbi Zncxv |i az akzx`ddih `kh
bnv iccijxasidq xbi uinudi yzakf xbizi
zqzxigz b`si oknvdihfi `lnyx xbi
Akcn|g`xank Xijbkndnfq$ lij`yzi `
fikyaki Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|h zqzxig
j`k hidasi| lixxi| u|nzuijxz xn xbi u`xaikx+
Xbi u|izikx Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx\ijn|h zi|saji ak KBZ az j`ddih xbi KBZ
J`|i \ijn|h Zi|saji vbajb az xbi ud`k nc
K xank`d U|nf|`ggi cn| AX ak Ikfd`kh+
Xbizi Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|hz `|i ak
irazxikji zakji dnkf xagi `kh kiv
agudigikx`xankz daoi KJ\Z az xbi
iru`kzank nc idijx|nkaj u xaikx h x $
akcn|g xank `lnyx FU$ bi`dxb xauz `kh
`hhakf kiv zncxv`|i `kh |iud`jakf kiv
b`|hv`|i+ Xbi g`mn| j|i`xank nc Hix`adih
J`|i \ijn|hz j`gi akxn irazxikji `kh
d`xi| hasahih `z Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|hz
cn| igi|fikjq uy|unziz+
Zijy|axq `kh U|as`jq `|i xbi g mn|
h|`vl`jo vbik hi`dakf vaxb akcn|g`xank
nk vil+ Hix`adih irud`k`xankz nc Zijy|axq
Azzyiz$ @yxbikxaj`xank ak Bi`dxbj`|i `kh
@jjizzakf jnkx|nd `|i xbi g`mn| unakxz xb`x
`|i hazjyzzih bi|i ak xbi u`ui|+
Xbaz u`ui| irudn|iz `lnyx
Xijbkndnfaiz `hnuxih lq KBZ zyjb `z
Vilzaxiz$ Zi`|jb ikfakiz$ Xidigihajaki
`kh G`ad Zi|sajiz? `u`|x c|ng xbixijbkndnfaiz xbi u`ui| `dzn akjdyhiz
akcn|g xank `lnyx Zijy|axq$ U|as`jq$
@jjizz Jnkx|nd$ Jnkcahikxa daxq `kh
agudigikx xank nc @yxbikxaj xank
Gijb`kazgz zyjb `z U|as`jq ldnjoakf
Zixxakfz xb`x `|i zagad | xn Znja d
Kixvn|oakf U|as`jq Zixxakfz+
<+ AKCN\G@XAJZJnguyxi|z b`si lijngi Ykasi|z`d ak
isi|q unzzaldi nccajiz$ vbajb akjdyhiz xbi
bi`dxbj`|i n|f`kaz`xankz `kh Bnzuax`dz+ Akxbi u`zx n| g`q li isik civ qi`|z `fn ax
v`z |`|i xn cakh ` jnguyxi| nk `
ubqzaja`kz hizo+ Lyx knv vaxb xbi
akj|i`zi nc akcn|g`xank `lnyx u xaikx
idijx|nkaj`ddq xbi yzi nc jnguyxi| az
liqnkh myzx zxn|akf n| |ix|aisakf
akcn|g`xank+ Jnguyxi|z `|i yzih liqnkh
`k dqzakf `kh |iun|xakf nc h`x lyx xbi
zqzxigz j`k j|i`xi `yxng`xih zy|siadd`kji
cn| bi`dxb akcijxankz+ _Haioig`$ <505W
Akcn|g`xajz hi`dz vaxb u|nldig zndsakf ak
g`kq g mn| `|i`z `kh `dzn `jxz `z `
gihayg lixviik AX `kh g`kq nxbi|
gnhiz nc zxyhaiz daoi Landnfq$ `|xz$
xidijnggykaj`xankz+ I`jb gnhi xbik
x|`kzcn|gz `kh di`hz xn lan akcn|g`xajz$
`|xz di`hakf xn hisidnugikx nc gydxagiha`
`kag`xankz `kh vil hizafkakf `kh zn nk+Zndsakf ` u|nldig az g`hi i`zq ak `kq
caidh vbik jnguyxakf az aksndsih lij`yzi
jnguyxakf fasiz xbi cnykh xank cn|
zjaikji$ lyzakizz akhyzx|aiz `kh lixxi|
u|nzuijxz xn xbi znjaixq+ _G`jOai'G`znk
<505W
Akcn|g`xajz yxadaziz akcn|g`xank
xijbkndnfq u|`jxaj`ddq xn `kq caidh$ vbadi
jnkzahi|akf axz jnkzipyikjiz nk
akhasahy`dz$ n|f`ka}`xankz `kh znjaixq+
Akcn|g`xajz yziz jnguyx`xank`d xijbkapyiz`z ` xnnd xn zndsi u|nldigz ak nxbi| caidhz$
xn jnggykaj`xi `kh xn iru|izz kiv
akkns`xasi ahi`z+ _Hikkaz F|nxb <505W
Xbi Cafy|i 0 lidnv fasiz ` l`zaj ahi`
`lnyx bnv ` u|nldig az zndsih lq
`k dqzakf xbi zqzxigz `kh bnv byg`kz
akxi|`jx vaxb xbig+ Xbi zisik zxiuz
aksndsih bi|i knx nkdq aksizxaf`xi lyx `dzn
agu|nsiz xbi h`x`+ _Byfbiz <556W
Caf0= 6 Zxiuz ak Zncx Zqzxigz
Gixbnhndnfq+ _Byfbiz$ <556W
<
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 3/15
<+0 JDAKAJ@D AKCN\G@XAJZJdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz b`z liik hizj|alih `z
` caidh xb`x giixz xvn gyxy`ddq |id`xih lyx
vbajb b`z hazxakjx kiihz _Bi|zb$ <55<W$U`xaikx'jikx|aj `kh Oknvdihfi'jikx|aj
_Z`|o`|$ <505W+ Xbi akkns`xankz ak Jdakaj`d
Akcn|g`xajz `|i kiihih xn agu|nsi
u`xaikx‑z bi`dxbj`|i xb|nyfb l`zaj jnkjiuxz
daoi `s`ad`ladaxq `kh akxif| xank nc
akcn|g xank `x xbi xagi nc j`|i _Jnzx $
Cax}fi|`dh$ ix `d <551W
Bi`dxb Akcn|g`xajz az hicakih `z xbi
oknvdihfi$ zoaddz `kh xnndz vbajb
c`jadax xi akcn|g`xank xn li jnddijxih$
g`k`fih$ yzih `kh zb`|ih xn zyuun|x ak
hidasi|akf xbi bi`dxbj`|i `kh u|ngnxakfbi`dxb+ _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb$ <505W
Jdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz b`si xbi
unxikxa`d xn x|`kzcn|g xbi bi`dxb j`|i lq
agudigikxakf$ hizafkakf `kh is`dy xakf
xbi akcn|g`xank `kh jnggykaj`xakf
zqzxigz xb x agu|nsiz u`xaikx j`|i `kh
biduz ak zx|ikfxbik xbi Ubqzaja`k'U`xaikx
|id xankzbau+ Jdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz hi dz
vaxb jdakaj`d akcn|g`xank `kh
ykhi|zx`khakf nc akcn|g`xajz jnkjiuxz$
u|njihy|iz `kh xnndz xn `zzizz akcn|g`xank$
is dy xi `kh |icaki jdakaj`d u|njizziz$hisidnu$ agudigikx jdakaj d zqzxigz$
u`|xajau`xi ak g`k`figikx `kh jnkxakynyz
agu|nsigikx nc jdakaj d akcn|g`xank
zqzxigz+ _F`|hki| <551W
<+< CYXY\I NC JDAKAJ@D
AKCN\G@XAJZ AK KBZ '
PY@DAXQ$ AKKNS@XANK$
U\NHYJXASAXQ @KH
U\ISIKXANK "PAUU!@jjn|hakf xn xbi Jdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz
ud`kz ak ki`| cyxy|i <505'<500 KBZ b`z
zngi u|an|axaiz nc Py daxq$ Akkns xank$
U|nhyjxasaxq `kh U|isikxank "PAUU! `kh
`|i |id`xih
Xn zyuun|x xbi ui|gazzankz nc
u`xaikxz `kh ubqzaja`kz$ xn
gnxas`xi hisidnugikxz ak bi`dxb
zi|sajiz `kh xn akj|i zi xbi
u|nhyjxasaxq$ xbi g`ak cnjyz az nk
g`oakf yzi nc xbi xijbkndnfaiz
vbajb vadd bidu xbi u xaikx xn
jnggykaj`xi vaxb xbi bi`dxb
zi|sajiz `kh xn jnkkijx uinudi+
Xn yzi xbi kiv akkns`xankz `kh
igi|fakf xijbkndnfaiz `kh xbi
hizafk nc xbi zqzxigz zbnydh li
gn|i ykhi|zx`kh`ldi `khx|`kzcn|g xbi irazxakf
xijbkndnfaiz+
Akj|i`zakf jnksikaikji xn yzi xbi
xijbkndnfaiz+
Jdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz ud kz xn
akxif|`xi ud`kkakf `kh
ui|cn|g`kji+ _0W _Hiu`|xgikx nc
Bi`dxbW
:+ XIJBKNDNFQXijbkndnfq ak bi`dxbj`|i akhyzx|q b`z `
g`mn| agu`jx nk ubqzaja`kz$ u|`jxaxanki|z`z xbiq hi`d vaxb AX zqzxigz knx nkdq cn|
`hgakazx|`xasi yzi `kh jdakaj`d uy|unziz
lyx `dzn g`mn| zy|fi|aiz vbajb aksndsiz
bafbizx disid nc jnguyxi|az`xank zoaddz+
Nki nc xbi zagudi yziz nc xijbkndnfq az xn
jnksi|x xbi u`ui| l`zih |ijn|h nc ` u`xaikx
akxn idijx|nkaj h x` `kh `dzn zj`kkakf
ndhi| knxiz$ u|izj|auxankz akxn idijx|nkaj
akcn|g`xank+ _L`xiz$ <55<W
:+0 XIJBKNDNFQ AKBI@DXBJ@\IXijbkndnfq az nki zny|ji xb|nyfb vbajb
xbi bi`dxbj`|i n|f`kaz`xankz j`k agu|nsi
iccajaikjq$ agu|nsi u`xaikx‑z z`cixq `kh
nxbi| likicaxz$ lyx `dzn j`k j|i`xi b`}`|h ac
xbi jdakaj`d zx`cc `|i knx x|`akih+ _Vadhx$
Si|}amhik$ ix `d$ <556W _Gy|ubq$ Lm`|xidd$
ix `d$ <551W
:+0+0 KUcAX= K@XANK@D
U\NF\@GGI CN\
AKCN\G@XANK XIJBKNDNFQHiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb uyldazbih ` |iun|x
j`ddih Hidasi|akf <0zx jikxy|q AX zyuun|x
cn| KBZ= K`xank`d zx|`xifaj u|nf| ggi$
vbajb ak xy|k az ` u|nxnxqui cn| K`xank`d
U|nf| ggi cn| Akcn|g`xank Xijbkndnfq
"KUcAX!+ _Hiu |xgikx nc Bi`dxb$ <55<W
_<W
Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi dxb akaxa`xih K`xank`d
u|nf|`ggi cn| AX xn u|nsahi zijy|i
idijx|nkaj u`xaikx |ijn|hz ak u|ag`|q `kh
zijnkh`|q j`|i+ Ax `dzn akxif|`xiz hacci|ikxoakhz nc zqzxigz daoi u|izj|auxank zi|saji
:
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 4/15
zncxv`|i$ `uunakxgikx zncxv`|i `kh g`kq
gn|i xn bi`dxb zijxn|z+ Ax az izxag`xih
`uu|nrag`xidq `|nykh ª0<+8 laddank cn| 05
qi`|z xadd <508+ _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi dxb$
<55<W _:W _F|iikb dfb$ Zx| gi|$ ix `d$
<505W
:+0+< BI@DXB ZU@JI @KH
ZYGG@\Q J@\I \IJN\H
ZI\SAJI KBZ b`z `hnuxih xbi xijbkndnfaiz zyjb `z
Bi`dxb zu`ji `kh Zyggi|q J`|i \ijn|hz
xn ikzy|i xb`x u`xaikx fixz yuh`xih vaxb
d`xizx xijbkndnfaiz$ zncxv`|i xb|nyfbnyx
xbi gihaj`xank+ _8W_F|iikb`dfb$ <505W
Bi`dxb Zu`ji az `k nkdaki vilzaxi
u|nsahakf zi|sajiz daoi lnnoakf `k`uunakxgikx$ oknvdihfi `lnyx bi`dxb `kh
dacizxqdi$ j dikh`| `kh `hh|izz lnno
xb|nyfb vbajb xbi u`xaikxz j`k zxn|i xbia|
`uunakxgikxz `kh x|`jo xbig+ Zyggi|q
j`|i |ijn|hz zi|saji az dakoih xn Bi dxb
zu`ji akaxa`ddq xn oknv `lnyx zi|sajiz xbi
ZJ\ az ud kkih xn u|nsahi+ @dd xbizi
zi|sajiz `|i `s`ad`ldi nkdq vbik xbi
u`xaikx |ifazxi|z akxn xbi zaxi+
Caf= Gq Bi`dxbZu`ji `jjnykx nsi|saiv+
Zny|ji= Bi dxbZu`ji "<505! _akxi|kixW
`s`ad`ldi c|ng_
bxxuz=..vvv+bi`dxbzu`ji +kbz+yo.W
"`jjizzih nk 9 Ziux$ <505!
:+0+: ZYGG@\Q J@\I \IJN\HZ
Xbi Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|hz az ` zi|saji
akx|nhyjih xn ikzy|i xb`x `dd xbi KBZ
u xaikxz bi dxb akcn|g`xank az |ijn|hih
idijx|nkaj`ddq `kh nkdq xbi zyggi|q nc `
u |xajyd | u`xaikx az liik h|`vk c|ng `
u`xaikx‑z FU bidh |ijn|h+ Xbizi ZJ\ `|i
gi`kx xn li `jjizzih lq nkdq `yxbn|azih
jdakaj`d zx cc+ _F|iikb`dfb$ Zx|`gi|$
L|`x k$ Lq|ki$ \yzzidd$ Bakhi|$ Unxxz$
<505W
@jjn|hakf xn xbi zy|siq |iun|x zylgaxxih
lq YJD$ xbi|i `|i `uu|nrag xidq 095O
ZJ\‑z vbajb vi|i j|i`xih lq gah <552
`kh xbi|i |ici||ih xn l`zaj$ disid'0 n|
|idi`zi'0 ZJ\ `z xbizi |ijn|hz b`h l`zaj
akcn|g`xank nc ` u`xaikx+ Disid'< b`z zngi
gn|i yuh`xiz xn xbi zi|sajiz+
Xqui nc ZJ\ Akcn|g`xank ak ZJ\
Disid 0 n| \idi zi'0 Gihaj`xank$ @ddi|faiz
`kh @hsi|zi \i`jxankz+
Disid < n| \idi`zi'< @#I |iun|xz$ hazjb`|fi
zygg |aiz$ nyxu`xaikx
dixxi|z$ d`l |iun|xz+
Caf= Saivakf ZJ\
:+< XIDIGIHAJAKIXbi `hnuxank nc Xidigihajaki az f|`hy`ddq
akj|i zakf ak bi dxbj |i akhyzx|q+
Xidigihajaki j`k li ncci|akf hacci|ikx
zi|sajiz hiuikhakf nk xbi bi`dxb
hiu`|xgikx+ Xbi zi|sajiz g`q s`|q daoi
u`xaikx xn ubqzaja`k akxi|`jxank$ ubqzaja`kxn ubqzaja`k akxi|`jxank cn| agu|nsakf xbi
py`daxq nc bi`dxbj`|i `kh cak`ddq ax j`k li
ncci|akf zi|sajiz daoi xidiubnki bidudaki
cn| u`xaikx ak igi|fikjq n| vbn ziio `k
`hsaji+ _\nbg$ \nbg M|$ <556W _Vnnxxnk$
0113W
:+<+0 KBZ HA\IJX ‚ K@XANK@DDQ
HA\IJXIH ZI\SAJI KBZ Ha|ijx az ` k xank`d bi`dxb j`|i
zi|saji xb|nyfb xidiubnki `kh vilzaxi+
Xbi g`ak |ndi nc KBZ ha|ijx az xn u|nsahi
bafb py daxq bi dxb j`|i xb|nyfb bi dxb
8
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 5/15
`hsaji$ akcn|g`xank `kh |i`zzy|`kji+
Akaxa`ddq KBZ Ha|ijx v`z ` zi|saji xb|nyfb
xidiubnki `hsaji `kh j`k gi `jjizzih lq
j`ddakf 52898386 `kh ax az knv ncci|akf
zi|sajiz xb|nyfb Vilzaxi `kh Hafax`d XS
"zidc zi|saji! `kh zxadd j`k jnkx`jx ` bi`dxb
u|ncizzank`d xb|nyfb xbi zi|saji+ _9W
_Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb$ <553W
:+<+< KNK IGI\FIKJQ ZI\SAJI
' 000Xbi kiv :'hafax kygli| 000 az ` knk
igi|fikjq xidiubnki bidudaki vbajb
akxikhz xn `hsaji bafb py`daxq bi`dxbj`|i xn
u`xaikxz vbajb az ` <8 bny|z zi|saji+ Xbaz
zi|saji az xn u|nsahi aggiha`xi gihaj`d
`zzazx`kji `kh ac xbi|i az `k igi|fikjq
zaxy`xank$ `k `glyd`kji vaxbnyx `kqcy|xbi| `zzizzgikx+ _3W _Hiu`|xgikx nc
Bi`dxb$ <505W
Xbi|i b`z liik ` vahi hazjyzzank
`lnyx |iud`jakf KBZ Ha|ijx lq 000 vbajb
az akhiih az |iud`jakf xbi KBZ Ha|ijx
52898386 kygli| xn gign|`ldi kygli|
000+ _6W
:+: ZI@\JB IKFAKIZ
:+:+0 KBZ ISAHIKJI@gnkf xbi d`xizx xijbkndnfaiz zi`|jb
ikfakiz az `dzn nki nc xbi akxi|kix zny|ji
vbajb u|nsahi akcn|g`xank `kh KBZ
Isahikji az nki `gnkf xbi Zi`|jb ikfakiz
vbajb fasiz c|ii `jjizz xn `dd jdakaj`d `kh
knk'jdakaj`d akcn|g`xank+ Akcn|g`xank
akjdyhiz isahikji$ fyah`kji `kh fnsx
undajq+ Xbi uy|unzi nc KBZ Isahikji az
cn| `kqnki ak bi`dxb `kh znja`d j`|i vbn
x`oiz hijazankz |if`|hakf x|i`xgikxz `kh
yzi nc |izny|jiz akjdyhakf FU‑z$ Ky|ziz$
Jnkzydx kxz$ Bi`dxb u|ncizzank`dz$|izi`|jbi|z `kh zxyhikxz+_2W
8+ IDIJX\NKAJ U@XAIKX
\IJN\HZ
8+0 AKX\NHYJXANKXbi hisidnugikx nc `kq bi dxbj`|i
hiu`|xgikx hiuikhz nk bnv xbi bi`dxb
zqzxigz `|i dakoih$ j|i`xih xn Idijx|nkaj
U`xaikx \ijn|h "IU\! zqzxigz+ @z xbi|i
`|i kygi|nyz likicaxz vbik IU\
xijbkndnfaiz `|i `hnuxih lij`yzi xbi
zakfdi IU\ zncxv`|i j`k zxn|i$ x|`kzci|
`kh |ix|aisi u`xaikx jdakaj`d akcn|g`xank
idijx|nkaj`ddq vbajb ak xy|k b`z xbi `ladaxq
xn |ihyji jdakaj`d i||n|z `kh agu|nsi xbi
py daxq nc bi dxbj`|i+ Xbi IU\ zqzxigz
`|i `hnuxih `kh yzih xn akj|i`zi
iccajaikjq$ |ihyji i||n| |`xiz `kh j`k li
`jjizzaldi cn| xbi u`xaikxz$ `ddnvakf xbig
xn b`si gn|i jnkx|nd nk xbia| nvk
bi`dxbj`|i+ _1W _05W _00W _0<W
8+<+0 YZIZ NC IU\ Xbi g`ak yzi nc Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|h
az xn agu|nsi xbi u xaikx j |i `kh ak
jnkxirx xn ` u`xaikx xbiq vadd iruijx xb`x
xbi |ijn|hz g`akx`akih idijx|nkaj`ddq `|i
`jjy| xi `kh yzih jnkcahikxa`ddq+ Ac xbi
|ijn|hz `|i zb`|ih lixviik xbi bi`dxbj`|ixi`g `kh bnzuax`dz xbi u|ag`|q `ag zbnydh
li xn agu|nsi xbi u`xaikx‑z bi`dxbj`|i+ Xbi
u xaikx‑z jnkji|k vbik xbi |ijn|hz `|i
dakoih xn irui|x zqzxigz xb`x xbi|i az
gakagyg jb`kji nc x|i`xgikx i||n|z `kh
g`ragyg jb`kji nc lizx x|i`xgikx+
_V`dun|x$ <505W
8+<+< @HS@KX@FIZ @KH
LIKICAXZ NC ZJ\ AK KBZZJ\ "Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|hz! az fnnh
`uu|n`jb ak gihaj d bazxn|q `z gn|iakcn|g`xank az `s`ad`ldi cn| gihaj`d j`|i+
B`sakf ` u`xaikx |ijn|h idijx|nkaj`ddq az
biducyd g akdq ak j zi nc igi|fikjq
zaxy`xankz vbajb vadd bidu xbi bi`dxbj`|i
u|nsahi|z xn z`si xagi `kh gihaj`xi xbi
u`xaikx aggiha`xidq+ @k idijx|nkaj u`xaikx
|ijn|h j`k li biducyd ak fasakf xbi u`xaikx
jn||ijx gihaj xank `jjn|hakf xn xbi
akcn|g`xank u|nsahih ak xbi IU\+ Yzicyd
cn| idhi|dq uinudi vbn gafbx cn|fix vb`x
xbi u|izikx `kh u|isanyz gihaj`xank v`z
`kh `dzn xn xbi uinudi vbn `|i hi`c+
_F|iikb`dfb$ Vnnh$ ix `d <552W
Xbi likicaxz nc Idijx|nkaj bi`dxb
|ijn|h b`si zngi l`zaj unakxz daoi xagi
z`sakf$ `s`ad`ladaxq$ i||n| |ihyjxankz$
akcn|g`xank zb`|akf `kh jdakaj`d hijazank
g`oakf+ _Fykxi|$ Xi||q$ <559W
Xbi zyggi|q j |i |ijn|h biduz xbi
bi dxbj`|i u|nsahi|z xn x|i`x xbi u`xaikx
pyajoi| `x xbi xagi nc igi|fikjq `z ZJ\
b`si l`zaj igi|fikjq akcn|g`xank xb`x ac
`k `jjahikx |iun|xih ak La|gakfb`g$ xbidnj`d `jjahikx `kh igi|fikjq hiu`|xgikx
9
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 6/15
j`k b`si xbi `jjizz xn xbi u`xaikx‑z |ijn|hz
ak Dnkhnk xn jbijo cn| xbi `ddi|faiz$ ldnnh
xqui `kh u|izikx gihaj xank+ _V dun|x$
<505W
8+: DIF@D$ IXBAJ@D AZZYIZDif d `kh Ixbaj`d azzyiz hiuikh nk
hacci|ikx `zuijxz nc hi dakf akcn|g`xank
zyjb `z Kifdafikji? az |id`xih xn ixbaj`d
azzyi vbajb njjy|z vbik xbi|i az Gazyzi
nc h`x`$ v|nkf u|izj|auxank$ v|nkf yzi nc
xbi zqzxigz$ x|i`xgikx `jjn|hakf xn |`ji$
|idafank `kh ykhi| kifdafikji xbi|i `|i
dif`d azzyi daoi c|`yh$ `lyzi `kh x|yzx+
_Mnbkznk$ Vbi`||q$ <505W
9+ ZIJY\AXQ AZZYIZ AK JDAKAJ@D
AKCN\G@XAJZ
9+0 ZIJY\AXQ
Zijy|axq jnkji|kz ak idijx|nkaj bi`dxbj`|i
b`z liik ` g mn| azzyi lij`yzi s`zx
`gnykx nc akcn|g`xank az `s`ad`ldi nkdaki
`kh ` xquaj d i'bi`dxbj |i zqzxig b`zg`kq jngunkikxz zyjb `z idijx|nkaj
bi dxb |ijn|h$ jdakaj d akcn|g`xank$ d`l
akcn|g`xank$ uajxy|iz$ sahinz$ u|izj|auxank
zi|sajiz `kh zg`|x j`|h hix`adz `kh xbizi
zqzxigz `|i sydki|`ldi xn zijy|axq azzyiz+
_Xz`a$ <505W
Xbi hisidnugikx nc Akxi|kix `kh `hnuxank
nc akcn|g`xank xijbkndnfaiz b`z liik `
g mn| u|an|axq ak di`hakf akhyzx|aiz
akjdyhakf bi`dxbj`|i+ @z xbi akcn|g`xank az
`s`ad`ldi ak g`kq znja`d kixvn|oakf zaxiz
_Xz`a$ B`k$ ix `d$ <551W$ ldnfz _Jbik$ Xz`a$
ix `d$ <556W `kh gihaj`d |ijn|hz xbi|i b`z
liik ` f|i`x hig`kh cn| akcn|g`xank xn
zxn|i `kh |ix|aisi+
Idijx|nkaj bi dxb |ijn|h zqzxigz yzakf
yuh`xih xijbkndnfaiz b`si `hhih
jnksikaikji xn u xaikx‑z h adq dasiz+
I`|dai| u xaikx `kh bnzuax`dz yzih xn
g`akx`ak u`ui| l`zih |ijn|hz `kh knv xbi
hnjxn|z j`k `jjizz xbia| u`xaikx
akcn|g xank vaxb myzx ` jdajo+ Knv xbi
jb`ddikfi nc agudigikxakf xbizi zncxv`|izqzxigz az xn u|nxijx xbi u`xaikx
akcn|g xank+ G`mn| |ndi nc xbi bnzuax dz
`kh bi`dxbj`|i zx`cc vadd li ak u|nxijxakf
u`xaikx‑z u|as`jq `kh xbi jnkcahikxa daxq
_Cdn|iz$ Vak$ ix `d$ <551W nc xbi idijx|nkaj
|ijn|hz lij`yzi xbi jnkzipyikjiz `|i
f|i`x ac xbi gihaj`d |ijn|h az di`oih xn
nyxzahi|z$ xbi akcn|g`xank j`k li yzih
`f`akzx u`xaikx `x xbi xagi nc igudnqgikx$
vbik zixxakf yu `k akzy|`kji undajq n| xn
uyldaj+ _Xz`a$ <505W
Caf= Zijy|axq \ipya|igikxz ak Idijx|nkaj
Bi`dxbj`|i Zqzxig+
_H|axz`z$ Fqgknunydnz$ ix `d+ <553W
Xbi `lnsi cafy|i fasiz xbi hizj|auxank
`lnyx ahikxacqakf xbi zijy|axq |ipya|igikxz
`z u xaikx |ijn|hz vbajb `|i `jjizzih
xb|nyfb kixvn|oz `|i uyldaj ak k`xy|i `kh
xbi jnggykaj`xank lixviik xbi kixvn|ozaz knx u|as`xi+ Akaxa`ddq xbi `uudaj xank
zbnydh ahikxacq xbi yzi| hiuikhakf nk xbi
`yxbikxaj xank gijb`kazg `kh xbik xbi
x|`joakf xbi yzi|z vbn `|i `yxbikxaj`xih
`|i u|nxijxih+ Xbi zncxv`|i hisidnui|z
vbn `|i vn|oakf nk xbi agudigikx`xank nc
zncxv`|i ak bi`dxbj`|i n|f`kaz`xank zbnydh
jnkjikx|`xi nk zijy|ih `yxbikxaj`xank `kh
g`k`figikx gijb`kazgz lij`yzi xbizi
`zuijxz `|i `ccijxakf xbi bi`dxbj |i
akhyzx|q `z xbi akcn|g`xank "u`xaikx‑z h`x`!
az si|q zikzaxasi+ _H|axz`z$ Fqgknunydnz$ix `d+ <553W
9+< @YXBIKXAJ@XANKFdnl`d `jjizz xn idijx|nkaj u`xaikx |ijn|hz
az kijizz`|q xn xbi cyxy|i nc bi`dxbj`|i lyx
zx|ajxdq cnddnvakf dif`d$ ixbaj`d `kh znja`d
|ydiz `kh |izunkzaladaxaiz xn u|nxijx xbi
u`xaikx‑z h`x` u|as`jq+ Nki nc xbi gixbnhz
xn u|ngazi ` u`xaikx‑z jnkcahikxa`daxq `kh
akxif|axq az lq agudigikxakf
`yxbikxaj xank gijb`kazgz `kh `jjizzjnkx|nd u|njihy|iz xn u|isikx yk`yxbn|a}ih
3
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 7/15
ikx|q xn xbi zikzaxasi akcn|g`xank+
_L`||nvz$ Jd`qxnk$ 0113W
Irxikhakf ` lyzakizz nui|`xank
nsi| xbi vil az ` gnhi|k h`q nui|`xank
`kh bi`dxbj |i az nki `gnkf xbig+
Bi`dxbj`|i uinudi akjdyhi bnzuax dz$
ubqzaja`kz$ akzy|`kji jngu`kaiz$ h|yf
g`kyc jxy|akf jngu`kaiz `kh bi`dxbj`|i
x|yzxz `|i agudigikxakf xijbkndnfaiz `kh
yuh`xakf zncxv`|i xn akxi| jx vaxb xbi
u`xaikxz vbajb az `k `hhih `hs`kx`fi xn
xbi u`xaikx+ _By$ Vi`si|$ <558W
S`|anyz `yxbikxaj`xank xijbkapyiz ak
bi`dxbj`|i akjdyhi cn|g l`zaj yzi| ah `kh
u`zzvn|h xn `dd kiv lan gix|aj xijbkapyiz+
Ca|zxdq xbi lan gix|aj gixbnhz
"zngixbakf xbi u`xaikx az! akjdyhi cakfi|
u|akxz$ zafk`xy|i$ snaji'|ijnfkaxank `kh a|azzj`k+ _0:W _By$ Vi`si|$ <558W
@knxbi| vahidq yzih `yxbikxaj`xank
xijbkapyi az xbi zg |x j`|hz "zngixbakf
xbi u xaikx unzziz! vbajb `|i zxadd ak
u|njizz ak KBZ+ Xbi g`ak cykjxank`daxq nc
xbi zg`|x j`|h az zagad`| xn xb`x nc ` l`ko
j`|h vaxb jbau `kh uak+ _KBZ'Jnkkijxakf
cn| Bi`dxbW
Uyldaj Oiq Akc|`zx|yjxy|i "UOA! az
` j|quxnf|`ubaj gijb`kazg vbajb j`k li
yzih cn| ikj|quxakf `kh hij|quxakf h`x` xn
ikzy|i akcn|g`xank zijy|axq+ _Hvasiha$L`da$ ix `d$ <55:W
Xbi u|njizz nc Hafax`d zafk`xy|iz
aksndsiz ` UOA zafkakf nc `k akhasahy`d az
u|as`xi `kh j`k li yzih xn b`zb `kh xbi
gizz`fi b`z xn li si|acaih lq xbi zikhi|‑z
uyldaj oiq vbajb ikzy|iz `yxbikxaj`xank nc
xbi h`x` `z vidd `z oiiuakf xbi akcn|g`xank
u|as`xi+ _Oiddq$ GjOik}ai$ <55<W
9+: JNKCAHIKXA@DAXQ KBZ b`z hicakih xbi jnkcahikxa`daxq
zi|sajiz xn u`xaikx ak cny| g`ak v`qz xbiq
`|i u|nxijxakf u xaikx akcn|g xank$
akcn|gakf xbi u`xaikx `lnyx akcn|g`xank
yz`fi$ fasakf xbi u`xaikxz ` jbnaji vbixbi|
xbia| akcn|g`xank b`z xn li hazjdnzih `kh
xn zyuun|x xbizi xb|ii zi|sajiz xbi|i zbnydh
li ` cny|xb zi|saji xn agu|nsi xbi u`xaikxz
jdakaj`d h`x`+ _0:W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxbW
L|axazb Gihaj d @zznja`xank b`z hicakih
xbi u`xaikx‑z jnkcahikxa`daxq `z xbi
u|akjaudi nc oiiuakf xbi akcn|g`xank
zijy|i `kh zij|ix vbik xbi akcn|g`xank az
irjb`kfih ak `kq oakh nc gihayg+ _Oiddq$
GjOik}ai$ <55<W
9+8 U\AS@JQ @KH @JJIZZXbi ahindnfq libakh `jjizz `kh jnkx|nd nc
Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|hz az i`jb jdakaj`d|ijn|h b`z xn li g |oih vaxb `jjizz
jnkx|nd dazx vbajb b`z f|nyu nc uinudi vbn
b`h nuikih `kh ihaxih xbi |ijn|h+
Jnkx|nddakf nc xbi |ijn|hz az hnki vbik
xbi |izunkzaldi ui|znk az g`|oih ak xbi
`jjizz jnkx|nd dazx+ _Ra`n$ By$ ix `d$ <551W
U|as`jq xn xbi idijx|nkaj u`xaikx
|ijn|hz az gnzx jnkji|kih xn g`kq
bi`dxbj`|i akzxaxyxankz `kh xbi azzyiz `lnyx
u|as`jq `|aziz vbik gnzx nc xbi bi`dxbj`|i
akzxaxyxankz hn knx u|nsahi `jjizz cn| xbi
u`xaikx‑z xn xbia| nvk h`x` `kh `dxbnyfbxbi|i az xijbkaj d yzicydkizz _S`k
Vakfi|hi$ Zjbakhdi|$ ix `d$ 0113W xbi
bi`dxbj`|i u|nsahi|z zbnv akxi|izx xnv`|hz
zb`|akf h x` vaxb xbi jnguixaxn|z+
_Onb`ki$ S`k Vakfi|hi$ ix `d$ 0113W Vaxb
xbi z`gi lib`sany| nc gnzx nc xbi
bi`dxbj`|i u|ncizzank`dz xbi u`xaikxz `|i
lijngakf gn|i `kranyz `lnyx xbi u|as`jq
nc xbia| gihaj`d |ijn|hz+ _Vizxak$ 0113W
U|as`jq az ` g`mn| jnkji|k `z AX zqzxigz
`|i agudigikxih ak bi`dxbj`|i akzxaxyxankz
`kh xbik Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|hz `|ivil'l zih `kh vaxb xbaz xbi ci | nc
zijy|axq xn xbi akcn|g`xank ak xbi |ijn|hz
`|aziz+ @z xbi akcn|g`xank nc ` u`xaikx az
zb`|ih yzakf va|idizz akxi|kix xn x|`kzgax
xn gydxaudi dnj`xankz+ _\`zb$ <559W
9+9 U\NXIJXANK YZAKF GYDXA
C@JXN\ @YXBIKXAJ@XANK@jjn|hakf xn YO Jnykjad cn| Bi`dxb
Akcn|g`xajz U|ncizzankz "YOJBAU! xbi
azzyi nc h`x u|as`jq$ v zx fi `kh
u|nxijxank nc xbizi azzyiz az xbi
|izunkzaladaxq ac Akcn|g`xajz u|nsahi|z `kh
xbiq zbnydh dnno akxn `zuijxz daoi Zijy|axq
`kh l`joyu nc xbi h`x`+ Knx nkdq
agudigikxakf xbi zncxv`|i lyx `dzn
jbijoakf xbi h`x` py`daxq vbik akuyxxakf
xbi |ijn|h `kh xbnzi yzakf xbi zqzxigz
zbnydh b`khdi xbig z`cidq+ _08W
_YOJBAUW
Yzakf zg`|x j`|hz `kh xbi jbau
`kh uak zi|sajiz `|i xbi <C@ "Xvn C`jxn|
@yxbikxaj`xank! j`k li agudigikxih xng`oi xbi jnggykaj`xank isik gn|i
6
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 8/15
zijy|ih+ Nki nc xbi `yxbikxaj xank
gijb`kazgz az xbi Uyldaj Oiq
Akc| zx|yjxy|i "UOA! `kh xbi jnkjiux
|if`|hakf UOA vi|i hisidnuih ` dnkf xagi
ak i`|dq 65‑z `kh xbi yz`fi nc UOA ak
bi`dxbj`|i v`z |ijikxdq `hnuxih ak i`|dq
<555+ Xbaz UOA xijbkndnfq v`z ca|zx
`hnuxih lq cak`kja`d akhyzx|q `kh d`xi| lq
xbi bi`dxb n|f`kaz`xankz+ _Biggakfz$
<555W
@ UOA az `k `yxbikxaj`xank
gijb`kazg vbajb j`k li ikj|quxih `kh
hij|quxih yzakf xvn oiqz$ nki cn|
ikj|quxank `kh `knxbi| cn| hij|quxank+ Xbi
yzi nc UOA ak `kq oakh nc jngu`kaiz az xn
`jbaisi bafb disid nc zijy|axq xn xbi `jjizz
nc akcn|g`xank+ Xbi j|i`xank `kh yz`fi nc
xbizi oiqz `kh hafax`d ji|xacaj`xiz `|ig`akx`akih `kh u|nsahih lq |ifazxi|akf
`yxbn|axaiz vbajb `|i |izunkzaldi xn azzyi
uyldaj `kh u|as`xi oiqz xn i`jb ji|xacaj`xi
bndhi|+ _Ixbi|ahfi$ <550W
Agudigikx`xank nc UOA `yxbikxaj`xank
vaxb xbi zg`|xj`|hz az xbi |ijikx u|nf|izz
ak zijy|akf xbi u`xaikx akcn|g xank+ Xbi
jikx| d |ifazx|q vbajb azzyiz xbi oiqz `kh
g`akx akz xbi `yxbikxaj`xank gijb`kazgz
az xbi Bi`dxb @jjizz Zqzxig vbajb `dzn
`jxz `z ` Gahhdiv`|i lixviik xbi yzi|z
`kh xbi `uudaj`xankz+ Ak xbaz zqzxig vbikxbi yzi| dnfz ak |ignxidq xbiq b`si xn
u|nsahi Xvn C`jxn| @yxbikxaj xank
Gijb`kazgz zyjb `z ikxi|akf xbia| zg`|x
j`|h `kh ikxi|akf xbi oiq$ lq hnakf xbaz
u|njizz xbik xbi yzi| b`z `k `jjizz xn xbi
`uudaj`xank+ Xbi jikx|`d |ifazx|q vbajb az
xbi B@Z vadd zxn|i xbi Zg`|x J`|h kygli|
vbik xbi yzi| dnf ak cn| xbi ca|zx xagi `kh
xbik fasiz xbig `k `joknvdihfgikx lq
u|nsahakf ` Oiq+ @cxi| xbaz u|njizz xbik
xbi yzi| ykhi|fniz xbi Xvn C`jxn|
@yxbikxaj`xank lq fasakf lnxb Zg`|x J`|h`kh UOA hix`adz+ Xbaz ikzy|iz bafb zijy|axq
cn| xbi yk`yxbn|a}ih `jjizz `kh
g`akx`akakf xbi jnkcahikxa`daxq nc xbi
u`xaikx akcn|g`xank+ _09W
AGUDIGIKX@XANK NC
@YXBIKXAJ@XANK @KH
U\AS@JQ GIJB@KAZGZ
3+ AGUDIGIKX@XANK NC
ZIJY\AXQ V@DDZ XNIDIJX\NKAJ U@XAIKX
\IJN\HZ'VN\OAKF
U\NJIHY\IZXbi hizafk nc zijy|axq v`ddz az hasahih
akxn xvn g`ak j`xifn|aiz ca|zx az xbi vil
u`fi vbajb az xbi g`mn| zijy|axq v`dd `cxi|
xbi yzi| ikxi|z baz.bi| yzi| ah `kh u`zzvn|h `kh vadd knx li |iha|ijxih xn xbi
yzi| `jjnykx lyx c`jiz ` zijy|axq u`zzvn|h
|ijnfkaxank u`fi `kh Zijnkhdq `cxi|
dnffakf akxn xbi `jjnykx xbi yzi| j`k
g`k`fi xbi `jjnykx lq zidijxakf xbi
ldnjoakf gijb`kazg vbajb az vahidq
cnddnvih ak g mn| znja d kixvn|oakf
vilzaxiz+
3+0 VN\OAKF U\NJIHY\IZ NC
@YXBIKXAJ@XANK U@FI
Xbi vil u`fi hisidnuih bi|i az `lnyx`yxbikxaj xank xijbkapyiz ` yzi| yziz `x
bngi c|ng xbia| ui|znk`d jnguyxi|z+ Ak
fiki|`d `jjizzakf nkdaki vilzaxi aksndsiz
`yxbikxaj`xank xijbkapyiz u`zzvn|hz$
ykapyi kygli| `kh xirx zi`dz+
Xbaz zijxank fasiz ` hix adih
hizj|auxank nc l`zaj u`zzvn|h xijbkapyi
`kh g`oakf ax b`|h cn| xbi b`joi|z xn
`jjizz `kh l|i`o xbi u`zzvn|h+
Akaxa`ddq xbi u|njizz zx`|xz c|ng
zidijxakf ` u`zzvn|h vbajb az b`|h cn| `kq
nxbi| ui|znk xn |igigli| irjiux xbi
nvki|+ Zijnkhdq zixxakf yu civ zijy|axq
pyizxankz ak j`zi xbi yzi| cn|fixz xbi ah
`kh u`zzvn|h xbi zijy|axq pyizxankz j`k
cixjb ` kiv u`zzvn|h xn xbi ui|znk`d
ig ad vbajb az zixyu vbadi |ifazxi|akf+
Xbaz u|njizz az ` |nyxaki u|njihy|i cn| `kq
nkdaki vilzaxi ncci|akf xn zxn|i qny|
ui|znk`d akcn|g`xank+
Knv xbi kirx `yxbikxaj`xank xb`x az liik
u|nunzih bi|i az U`zzvn|h \ijnfkaxank+ Ak
xbaz u|njizz nc u`zzvn|h |ijnfkaxank xbiyzi| b`z xn |igigli| xbia| nvk u`zzvn|h
lij`yzi xbi kirx zx`fi `cxi| ikxi|akf yzi|
ah `kh u`zzvn|h az xbaz |ijnfkaxank zxiu+
Bi|i xbi yzi| vadd li `zoih xn zidijx
|`khng jb`|`jxi| kygli| c|ng xbi
u`zzvn|h+ Xbaz az nki nc xbi `yxbikxaj`xank
gijb`kazgz ak nkdaki l`koakf+ Isi|q xagi
xbi yzi| ikxi|z baz yzi| ah `kh u`zzvn|h
xbi zijnkh zxiu nc u`zzvn|h |ijnfkaxank
hazud qz |`khng jb`|`jxi| zidijxank `kh
xbizi jb`|`jxi| kygli|z `|i hacci|ikx
isi|q xagi xbi yzi| dnfakz+
2
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 9/15
U`zzvn|h Gar xbi
u`zzvn|h
vaxb dixxi|z$
kygli|z `kh
zqglndz+
Salfqn|556
Zafk ak Yzi| ah ‚
rq}`lj
Uvh 7
salfqn|556
U`zzvn|h
|ijnfkaxank
Jb`| :7>
Jb`| 27>
X`ldi= U`zzvn|h \ijnfkaxank U|njizz+
Caf= U`zzvn|h \ijnfkaxank+
3+0 VN\OAKF U\NJIHY\IZ NC@YXBIKXAJ@XANK U@FIXbi vil u`fi hizafkih bi|i az `lnyx
U|as`jq Ldnjoakf zixxakf vbajb vi
jnggnkdq zii `kh yzi ak znja`d
kixvn|oakf zaxiz daoi C`jilnno `kh
Xvaxxi|+ Xbi ahi` libakh xbaz vil u`fi az
xn fasi xbi u`xaikx "gafbx b`si ` znja`d
kixvn|oakf `jjnykx! `k Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx
\ijn|h vbajb b`z zagad`| u|as`jq ldnjoakf
zixxakfz `z ak znja`d kixvn|oakf zaxiz+
Bi|i ak xbaz u`fi ` u`xaikx j`k
g`k`fi xbia| nvk akcn|g`xank `kh ldnjo
`jjn|hakf xn xbi zikzaxasaxq nc xbi
akcn|g`xank+
Bi`dxb Akcn|g`xank'@ddi|faiz'Kn Ldnjoakf
Ui|znk`d Akcn|g`xank'Ig ad'Ldnjo D`l
Xijbkaja`k+
Ui|znk`d Akcn|g`xank'KA Kygli|'Ldnjo
D`l Xijbkaja`k$ Hnjxn|+
Xqui
nc
Akcn|
g`xan
k
Vbn
>
Akcn|
g`xan
k
Ldnjo Ldnjoa
kf
zixxakf
z
@ddi|f
aiz
Hnjx
n|z
Ky|z
i
D`l
xijbk
aja`k
Isi|
qnki
Nxbi|
@ddi|f
aj xn
Uikaja
ddak
Xbaz
akcn|
g`xan
k az
agun|x`kx `x
xbi
xagi
nc
igi|f
ikjq+
Xbaz
akcn|g
`xank
j`k li
ldnjoih
`jjn|h
akf xn
xbi
IU\
zqzxi
gz
yz`fi+
@hh|i
zz `kh unzxjn
hi
QU0<
IU3
Knx zn
agun|x`kx xn
` d`l
xijbka
ja`k+
Ldnjo
d`lxijbka
ja`k
X`ldi= Ldnjoakf zixxakfz xn ` U`xaikxz
Akcn|g`xank+
Xbi vil u`fi lidnv hizj|aliz xbi
agun|x`kji nc akcn|g`xank xn li ldnjoih
`kh xbi u|as`jq zixxakfz j`k li `uudaih xn
i`jb `kh isi|q u`|x nc xbi akcn|g`xank daoi@ddi|faiz$ \i`jxankz$ Ldnnh xqui$ u|isanyz
hnjxn|$ U|izikx hnjxn|$ U|izikx addkizz$
Xizxz$ Ud`kkakf$ Sazaxz$ U|izj|auxankz `kh
gn|i bi`dxb akcn|g`xank+ Knx nkdq xbi
bi`dxb akcn|g`xank az ldnjoih lyx `dzn
ui|znk`d h`x` b`z xn li ldnjoih zyjb `z
@hh|izz$ Jnkx`jx kygli|z$ Gnladi
kygli|z$ KA kygli|$ KBZ Kygli|$ Unzx
jnhi `kh Ig`ad+
1
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 10/15
Caf= U|as`jq Ldnjoakf xn xbi U xaikx
Akcn|g`xank+
Vbik xbi `lnsi Ldnjoakf u`fi az
jngu`|ih xn KBZ Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|hz
u`fi lidnv$ U|as`jq Ldnjoakf Zixxakfz n|
U|as`jq Dnjoz `|i gazzakf+
Caf= KBZ Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|h U`xaikx
Akcn|g`xank
Ak xbi `lnsi cafy|i vi j`k zii xbi KBZ
Zygg`|q j`|i \ijn|h u`fi vbi|i xbi
u`xaikx n| xbi jdakaj`d zx ccz cadd xbi
ui|znk`d `kh bi dxb akcn|g`xank nc xbi
u`xaikx `kh `dzn akcn|g xank `lnyx
|ifazxi|ih FU+ Bi|i `z vi j`k zii xbi
hacci|ikji lixviik Cafy|i ZJ\ `kh xbi
Cafy|i U|as`jq Ldnjoakf u`fi az xb`x xbi
ZJ\ b`z kn U|as`jq Dnjoz n| `kq nxbi| Zi`dih Iksidnuiz vbi|i `z xbi u|as`jq
ldnjoakf u`fi xb`x az akx|nhyjih b`z xbi
Ldnjoakf Dnjoz+
6+ J\AXAJ@D IS@DY@XANK @KH
DIZZNKZ DI@\KX
6+0 CAKHAKFZAgudigikx`xank nc xijbkndnfaiz `kh
hidasi|akf akcn|g`xank xb|nyfb vil az `
g`mn| zny|ji nc jnggykaj`xank ak `dgnzx
isi|q hacci|ikx oakh nc akzxaxyxankz+
Xbi akaxa d cakhakfz nk jdakaj`d
akcn|g`xajz biduih xn ykhi|zx`kh xb`x
Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|hz az nki nc xbi
jdakaj d akcn|g`xajz `zuijx vbajb az `kh
azzyi zakji ` si|q dnkf xagi+ Xbi g`ak
`zuijxz xb`x di`h xn azzyiz `|i xbi u|as`jq
`kh jnkcahikxa daxq nc xbi h`x `khagudigikx`xank nc xbi zncxv`|i
xijbkndnfaiz ak jy||ikx bi`dxb
n|f`kaz`xankz+
Zncxv`|i akzx`dd`xankz b`si liik `
g`mn| h|`vl`jo ak KBZ xadd xbi gahzx nc
<505+ Xbi zncxv`|i j`ddih Dn|ik}n az `
u`xaikx `hgakazx|`xank zqzxig vbajb
aksndsiz hyxaiz daoi u xaikx lnnoakf$
g`k`fakf u`xaikx |ijn|hz `kh |ici|| dz+
Xbaz zncxv`|i az hisidnuih lq nki nc xbi
YZ di`hakf nyxzny|jakf jngu`kq
Jnguyxi| Zjaikji Jn|un|`xank "JZJ! `kh
@yzx| da`k zncxv`|i zyuudai| azncx vbajb
akhiih c`adih xn akzx`dd xbi zncxv`|i nk
xagi `kh vaxb `dd xbizi AX c ady|iz xbi
Jdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz f|nyu vbajb az xbi
KUcAX zbnydh jnkjikx| xi nk idigikxz
zyjb `z —Bnv xbi Zncxv`|i az akzx`ddih‗$
—bnv `jjizzaldi az ax xn xbi jdakaj`d zx`cc‗$
—Az xbi Zncxv`|i akzx`ddih vaxb `dd xbi
zijy|axq |ipya|igikxz‗+
Yzi nc U`zzvn|hz `kh Zijy|axq
gi`zy|iz xn jdakaj`d h x` b z liik `j|axaj`d azzyi vaxb xbi KBZ ak xbi qi`|
<551+ Xbi|i vi|i `uu|nrag xidq 085
Zijy|axq l|i`jbiz xn xbi h`x` vbajb vi|i
|id xih xn ' jnkcahikxa`daxq `zuijxz daoi
di`sakf xbi h`x` yk`xxikhih `kh zngi h`x`
v`z dicx ak ikj|quxih hazjz$ Zijy|axq
`zuijxz zyjb `z hnvkdn`hakf xbi u`xaikx
h`x`l`zi nk xn `k Ykzijy|ih d`uxnu"v`z
d`xi| zxndik! vbajb akjdyhih xbnyz`khz nc
gihaj`d |ijn|hz+ @knxbi| g`mn| zijy|axq
l|i`jb v`z ` gign|q zxajo vbajb b`h
xbnyz`khz nc u`xaikx gihaj`d |ijn|hz v`zdnzx isik xbnyfb xbi h`x` az ikj|quxih xbi
05
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 11/15
u`zzvn|h v`z `xx`jbih `z ` knxi ak xbi
hisaji+
@jjn|hakf xn Gajo Fn|add_@zzazx`kx
Akcn|g`xank Jnggazzanki| ak jb |fi nc
ikcn|jigikx$ <551W akzy| kji jngu`kaiz
ba|i u|as`xi hixijxasiz xn cakh nyx xbi
gihaj`d bazxn|aiz+
Zn xbaz jdi |dq zbnvz xb`x xbi
akcn|g xank ak gihaj`d |ijn|hz az knx
u|as`xi$ xbiq j`k li `s`ad`ldi fdnl`ddq cn|
fnnh `kh l`h j`yzi+ Xbi |izunkzaladaxq nc
jdakaj`d akcn|g`xajz zx`cc vbn `|i
|izunkzaldi vaxb hi dakf akcn|g`xank n|
h`x` `lnyx isi|q u xaikx zbnydh oknv
zngi nc xbi |ydiz daoi H`x` U|nxijxank
D`vz$ Zijy|axq Zixxakf nc xbi Zncxv`|i
yzakf$ `yxbikxaj`xank z`cixq xijbkapyiz
daoi zafkakf nyx `cxi| yzakf u xaikx‑z u|ncadi$ knx xn di`si jnguyxi|z yk`xxikhih
`cxi| zafkakf ak$ vbn xn jnkx`jx ac xbi
zncxv`|i hniz knx vn|o n| b`kfz yu+ Ac
xbizi zagudi zxiuz `|i cnddnvih xbi|i az `
fnnh jb`kji nc agu|nsakf u xaikx‑z
akcn|g`xank zijy|axq+
6+< IS@DY@XANK
A b`si akx|nhyjih xvn zijy|axq gi`zy|iz ak
gq |iun|x vbajb gafbx li ` zikzaldi
`uu|n`jb vbik agudigikxih ak Idijx|nkajU`xaikx \ijn|hz zqzxigz+ Nki nc ax az xbi
—U|as`jq Ldnjoakf Zixxakfz‗ vbajb az
zagad`| xn C`jilnno U|as`jq Zixxakfz+ Xbi
g`ak |i`znk xn `hnux xbizi zixxakfz az
jdi`|dq lij`yzi nc xbi kygli| nc yzi|z
yzakf xbig az si|q bafb+ Zn xbizi U|as`jq
Zixxakfz `|i knx kiv lyx fasakf xbi u`xaikx
xbi z`gi nuxankz xn baz.bi| Idijx|nkaj
U`xaikx \ijn|h az kiv `kh ac xbi yzi| b`z `
C`jilnno `jjnykx xbik bi.zbi j`k ahikxacq
xbi U|as`jq Zixxakfz `kh j`k g`k`fi
`jjn|hakf xbi jngcn|x+
Zijnkh az xbi —Zijy|axq V`dd ‚
@yxbikxaj xank Xijbkapyi‗$ xbi gnzx
jnggnk `yxbikxaj`xank vbik yzakf `
vilzaxi az AH `kh U`zzvn|h n| Ykapyi AH
Kygli|z+ Vb`x az xbi jnggnk xbakf xb`x
b`uuikz `cxi| zafkakf ak> @cxi| ikxi|akf
qny| AH `kh UVH xbi vilzaxi vadd
`yxng`xaj ddq `uu|nsi qny| hix adz `kh
zbnvz xbi u|ncadi$ xbaz az vb`x b`uuikz xn
gnzx nc xbi vilzaxiz+
Lyx xbi zijnkh gixbnh u|nunzihbi|i az xbi u`fi `cxi| xbi yzi| ikxi|z AH
`kh UVH$ xbi yzi| vadd knx li |iha|ijxih
xn xbia| u|ncadi ykdizz xbi yzi| j|nzziz xbi
—Zijy|axq V`dd‗ vbajb vadd `zo xbi yzi|
xbia| u`zzvn|h lyx knx `z ax az+ Xbi|i vadd
li ` |`khng jb`|`jxi| jbijo cn| ir`gudi
—Ikxi| qny| Jb`|`jxi| 9$ 2$ 1 n| <$8$0 nc
qny| u`zzvn|h‗ xbaz gafbx zxnu xbi yzi|
ac xbi yzi| az `k Yk`yxbn|azih ui|znk+
Akx|nhyjakf xbizi xijbkapyiz biduih gi xn
ykhi|zx`kh `kh di`|k gn|i `lnyx=
@yxbikxaj`xank xijbkapyiz
`kh zijy|axq jnkzx|`akxz+
Yziz nc Akcn|g`xank
Xijbkndnfq ak Bi`dxbj`|i+
Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|hz
`kh xbi zqzxigz yzih xn
zxn|i |ix|aisi `kh g`k`fi
xbizi |ijn|hz+
Vb`x `jxy ddq b`uuikakfak KBZ `kh Jdakaj`d
Akcn|g`xajz `kh AX
U|nf|`ggiz cn|
agu|nsakf bi`dxbj`|i+
Zyggi|q J |i \ijn|hz
vbajb `|i gnzx
jnkx|nsi|za`d `zuijx
lij`yzi nc u|as`jq azzyiz
lyx ac jnkzahi|ih xbi
likicaxz nc ZJ\ ax az si|q
yzicyd `x xagiz nc
igi|fikjq+
ZPD Akmijxank `kh xquiz
nc Pyi|aiz `kh x|aih zngi
pyi|aiz vbajb `|i
irjdyzasidq cn|
ihyj`xank`d uy|unzi+
Agudigikx`xank nc zijy|axq ci`xy|iz daoi
UOA `kh Zg`|x j |h @yxbikxaj xank
Gijb`kazg `kh jnglak`xank nc lnxb xbi
xijbkapyiz gyzx li `hnuxih cn| isik gn|i
xafbx zijy|axq+
6+: CYXY\I VN\O
Gydxac`jxn| @yxbikxaj xank
xijbkapyiz xn xafbxik xbi zijy|axq+
Aksndsigikx nc u`xaikx‑z |ndi ak
xbia| nvk Ui|znk`d U`xaikx \ijn|h
`kh u|nsahakf akcn|g`xank nk
zijy|axq xb|nyfb zigak`|z `kh
u| jxaj`d irud`k`xank nc U|as`jq
`kh bnv xn g`k`fi xbi bi`dxb
|ijn|hz+
@uu|nsih jdakaj`d zx`cc xn nui|`xi
Jnguyxi|z `kh Zncxv`|i+
00
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 12/15
Jnguyxi|azih ubqzaja`kz vbajb
gi`kz vbik xbi|i az ` zaxy`xank
vbik xbi hnjxn| b`z xn u|izj|ali `
u`xaikx xb|nyfb Idijx|nkaj
U|izj|auxank Zi|saji$ xbi
ubqzaja`kz zbnydh oknv l`zajxquakf$ yzi nc u|akxakf$ yzi nc xbi
u`|xajyd`| zncxv`|i nk vbajb xbiq
`|i hiuikhakf+
Oknvdihfi `kh |izunkzaladaxq
xnv`|hz H x` U|nxijxank `kh
U`xaikx Akcn|g`xank
Jnkcahikxa`daxq+
Nkdq agudigikxakf jnzxdq
zncxv`|i az knx |i`ddq xbi
jnkjdyzank `lnyx fasakf py`daxq nc
j`|i xn u`xaikx+
@ag zbnydh li xnv`|hz nk bnv xnyzi xbi zncxv`|i+
Zijy|axq jnkji|kz zbnydh li
xnv`|hz Zijy|i Zxn|`fi$ Zijy|i
Jnggykaj`xank$ g`k`figikx `kh
agudigikx xank `kh Kixvn|o
U|nxijxank+
@z hazjyzzih ak xbi |iun|x `lnyx Zijy|axq
|ipya|igikxz `kh Gydxa C`jxn|
@yxbikxaj`xank$ xbi agudigikx`xank nc `kq
zncxv`|i cn| jdakaj d uy|unzi gyzx li
zijy|idq jnkcafy|ih+ Nki |ijikx ir`gudi
az KBZ n|f`kaz`xank ak Kn|xb Dnkhnk b`si
agudigikxih Gydxa C`jxn| @yxbikxaj`xank
lq akxif|`xakf xvn xquiz nc zijy|axq jbijoz
zyjb `z UOA `kh Zg`|x J`|h vbajb az xn
ikzy|i xb`x u`xaikx‑z idijx|nkaj h`x` az knx
v`zxih n| h`g`fih kn| unakxih xn `kq
zijy|axq l|i`jbiz+
6+8 CAKHAKFZ@cxi| agudigikxakf xbi vbndi vn|o xbi|i
`|i civ xbakfz A knv oknv `lnyx Jdakaj`d
Akcn|g`xajz= Knx nkdq Idijx|nkaj U xaikx
\ijn|hz `|i u`|x nc Jdakaj`d
Akcn|g`xajz xbi|i `|i g`kq nxbi|
`zuijxz nc Jdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz
zyjb `z Idijx|nkaj U|izj|auxank
Zi|saji$ ziu`| xi D`l \iun|x
Zi|sajiz `kh jnglak`xank nc
Akcn|g`xank$ Xijbkndnfq$
Ubqzaja`k `kh U xaikx az `dzn
Jdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz+
@lnyx v|nkf yz`fi nc h`x` zyjb
`z u|nsahakf `jjizz xn xbiakcn|g`xank xn Akzy|`kji
jngu`kaiz `kh H|yf
g`kyc`jxy|akf jngu`kaiz isik
xbnyfb xbi|i `|i zafkacaj`kx
likicaxz ac xbi h`x` nc ` u`xaikx az
fasik xn `k akzy|`kji jngu`kq+
D`jo nc jnguyxi| `kh zncxv`|i`uudaj`xank oknvdihfi ak jdakaj`d
zx`cc+
D`jo nc oknvdihfi `lnyx
agun|x`kji nc zijy|axq `zuijxz+
Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|hz vadd li
`yxng`xaj`ddq yudn`hih nk xn xbi
vil ac xbi|i az kn |izunkzi c|ng
xbi u`xaikx+
@lnyx ZPD Akmijxankz u|`jxaj`ddq+
Agudigikx`xank oknvdihfi `lnyx
Hng`ak K`gi Zi|si|z `kh
\ifazxi|akf Hng`akz+ @lnyx Vil Bnzxakf+
@jxasaxaiz `lnyx Hiu`|xgikx nc
Bi`dxb$ KBZ ud`kz$ U|ag`|q J`|i
x|yzxz$ K`xank`d U|nf|`ggi cn|
Akcn|g`xank Xijbkndnfq `kh
g`kq bi`dxbj`|i u|nsahi|z `kh xbi
|ndi nc xbig ak Jdakaj`d
Akcn|g`xajz+
6+9 JNKJDYZANK
@j|nzz xbi vbndi hnjygikx xbi|i `|izisi| d jb`uxi|z vbajb hizj|ali xbi
`zuijxz nc Jdakaj`d Akcn|g`xajz `kh nki axz
`uudaj`xank az xbi Idijx|nkaj U xaikx
\ijn|hz$ xbi g`ak `ag nc xbi zqzxig az xn
u|nsahi agu|nsih py`daxq nc j`|i xn
u`xaikxz+
@jjizzakf xbi Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx
\ijn|hz n| zb`|akf xbi akcn|g`xank ak xbi
|ijn|hz az xb|nyfb ` uyldaj kixvn|o daoi
Akxi|kix vadd kisi| li u|as`xi+ Zn xbi
l`jof|nykh bi|i az xbi zijy|axq vbajb ak
xy|k gi`kz xn u|nxijx xbi JA@ x|a`h nc xbih`x`$ knxbakf lyx Jnkcahikxa`daxq$ Akxif|axq
`kh @s`ad`ladaxq nc xbi h`x`? u|as`jq vbajb
gi`kz cnddnvakf i`jb `kh isi|q xi|gz n|
|ydiz `kh |ifyd`xankz zix lq xbi bi`dxb
hiu`|xgikx nk H`x U|nxijxank+ Xbaz az
`lnyx xbi akcn|g`xank ak Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx
\ijn|hz$ xbi zijy|axq `kh u|as`jq nc xbi
h x` j`k li |ihyjih ac nkdq Jnguyxi|
Daxi|`xi Igudnqiiz `|i vn|oakf vaxb xbi
zqzxigz n| lq x|`akakf ` jdakaj`d zx`cc+
Zygg`|q J`|i \ijn|hz `|i u`|x nc
Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|hz vbajb b`z nkdqxbi zygg`|q nc u`xaikx‑z bi`dxb
0<
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 13/15
akcn|g`xank vbajb az `jjizzaldi lq
Jdakaj`d zx`cc$ Ubqzaja`kz `kh `dzn lq xbi
U`xaikx c|ng baz.bi| ui|znk`d jnguyxi|
xb|nyfb dnffakf akxn Bi`dxbzu`ji vbajb
u|nsahi `jjizz xn xbi u`xaikx xn saiv `kh
`gikh jb`kfiz xn ZJ\+
L`zih nk xbi ZJ\ u|nf|`ggi$
oiiuakf ak gakh xbi U`xaikx j`k b`si
`jjizz xn xbia| nvk |ijn|hz xbi hazzi|x`xank
u|`jxaj`d az hizafkih zuija ddq cn| xbi
u`xaikx‑z vbn `|i knx vidd c`gada`| vaxb
Jnguyxi|z$ caddakf idijx|nkaj cn|gz `kh
xbizi —Yzi| C|aikhdq @yxbikxaj`xank `kh
Ldnjoakf Zixxakfz‗ j`k `x di`zx |ihyji xbi
u`xaikx jnkcyzank xnv`|hz vbajb h`x` xn li
irunzih `kh vbajb nc xbi akcn|g`xank xn
li ldnjoih+
Kirx laf xbakf az xbi |ndi nc Fnsi|kgikx ak bi dxb hiu`|xgikx$
Bi`dxbj |i n|f`kaz xank KBZ `kh
U|nf|`ggi cn| AX hiu |xgikx$ bnv g`kq
laddankz `|i zuikx nk Zncxv`|i
Agudigikx`xankz `kh c ady|iz$ `dd xbi
f|nyuz bi|i `|i jnkji|kih `lnyx u`xaikx‑z
h`x` u|as`jq+ Lyx gn|i jnkji|k zbnydh li
xnv`|hz bnv zijy|idq xbi zncxv`|i az
akzx`ddih `kh vbn az yzakf xbi Zncxv`|i$
`|i xbiq x| akih `kh U`xaikx Nvki|zbau
xnv`|hz xbia| nvk h`x`$ xbizi `zuijxz vadd
l|akf kiv jnkcahikji ak u`xaikxz vbn vazbxn b`si `k ZJ\+ @z hazjyzzih `lnyx Gydxa
c`jxn| @yxbikxaj`xank ak xbi u`ui| `kh
`jjn|hakf xn xbi |ijikx yuh`xiz nk
bi`dxbj`|i `kh KBZ$ zngi nc xbi KBZ
n|f`kaz`xankz agudigikxih <C@ "< C`jxn|
@yxbikxaj xank! vbajb akjdyhi yzakf nc
UOA "Uyldaj Akc|`zx|yjxy|i Oiq! `kh Zg`|x
j`|hz cn| xbi yzi| vbn v`kx xn `jjizz xbi
akcn|g`xank |ignxidq+ Vbadi
agudigikxakf xbizi bafb py`daxq zijy|axq
zqzxigz xbi U`xaikxz zbnydh li fasik
akcn|g`xank$ Knxaji$ Hign `lnyx xbi kivxijbkndnfaiz xb`x KBZ az jy||ikxdq yzakf$
lq hnakf xbaz xbi u`xaikxz vbn `|i knx
akxi|izxih ak Idijx|nkaj \ijn|hz vadd f`ak
x|yzx `kh KBZ gafbx fix fnnh kygli| nc
ZJ\‑z `z ud`kkih+
2+ \ICI\IKJIZ
Haioig`$ H+ "<505!+ ,U|`jxaj`d Bi`dxbj`|i
Iuahigandnfq+, M`g` :58":!= :98+
Q`zkncc$ V+$ U+ N J`||ndd$ ix `d+ "<555!+
,Uyldaj bi`dxb akcn|g`xajz= agu|nsakf `kh
x|`kzcn|gakf uyldaj bi`dxb ak xbi
akcn|g`xank `fi+, Mny|k`d nc Uyldaj Bi`dxb
G`k`figikx `kh U|`jxaji 3"3!= 36'69+
G`jOai'G`znk$ M+ `kh H+ F|nxb "<505!+
,Vbq `k akcn|g`xajz hif|ii>,+
KLY$ H+ "<55<!+ ,Gajb`id Cny|g`k+,
F|nxb$ H+ `kh M+ G`jOai'G`znk "<505!+
,Vbq `k akcn|g`xajz hif|ii>,
Jnggykaj`xankz nc xbi @JG 9:"<!= <3'
<2+
Byfbiz$ U+ "<556!+ ,Bnv bi dxb'
akcn|g`xajz u|`jxaxanki|z ak Ikfd`kh‑z
KBZ saiv xbia| ui|znk`d `kh u|ncizzank`dhisidnugikx+, L| M Bi dxbj`|i Jnguyx
Akcn G`k`fi <8"8!= <5'<<+
Bi|zb$ V+ "<55<!+ ,Gihaj`d akcn|g`xajz=
agu|nsakf bi`dxb j`|i xb|nyfb
akcn|g`xank+, M`g` <22"03!= 0199+
Z`|o`|$ A+ "<505!+ ,Langihaj`d akcn|g`xajz
`kh x|`kzd xank`d gihajaki+, Mny|k`d nc
X|`kzd`xank`d Gihajaki 2"0!= <<+
Jnzx`$ L+$ O+ Cax}fi|`dh$ ix `d+ "<551!+
,Iccijxasikizz nc AX'l`zih ha lixiz
g`k`figikx akxi|sikxankz= ` |isaiv nc xbi
daxi|`xy|i+, LGJ c`gadq u|`jxaji 05"0!= 6<+
_0W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb+ "<505!$ KBZ=
Akcn|g`xajz Ud`kkakf <505.00+W$
_Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb+ "<551!$
Agudigikxakf xbi Kirx Zx`fi \isaiv
Sazankz= Xbi Py`daxq `kh U|nhyjxasaxq
Jb`ddikfi+W
F`|hki|$ \+$ M+ Nsi|b`fi$ ix `d+ "<551!+
,Jn|i jnkxikx cn| xbi zylzuija dxq nc
jdakaj`d akcn|g xajz+, Mny|k`d nc xbi
@gi|aj`k Gihaj`d Akcn|g`xajz
@zznja`xank 03"<!= 09:+
_L`xiz$ H+ "<55<!+ ,Xbi py`daxq j`zi cn|
akcn|g`xank xijbkndnfq ak bi dxbj`|i+,
LGJ gihaj d akcn|g`xajz `kh hijazank
g`oakf <"0!= 6+W
0:
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 14/15
_hi Vadhx$ Z+$ \+ Si|}amhik$ ix `d+ "<556!+
,Dizznk nc xbi Viio= Akcn|g`xank
xijbkndnfq j`kknx fy`|`kxii u xaikx
z`cixq+, LGM= L|axazb Gihaj`d Mny|k`d
::8"6912!= 290+W
_Gy|ubq$ H+$ @+ Lm`|xidd$ ix `d+ "<551!+
,Hnvkzahiz nc |nlnx'`zzazxih d`u`|nzjnuaj
|`haj d u|nzx`xijxngq= dagax`xankz `kh
jngudaj`xankz+, Iy|nui`k Y|ndnfq+W
_<W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb+ "<55<!$
Hidasi|akf <0zx Jikxy|q AX zyuun|x cn| xbi
KBZ= k`xank`d zx|`xifaj u|nf|`ggi$ Myki
<55<$ u+0W _@jjizzih Mydq <505W
_:W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb+ "<55<!$
Hidasi|akf <0zx Jikxy|q AX zyuun|x cn| xbi KBZ= k`xank`d zx|`xifaj u|nf|`ggi$ Myki
<55<$ u+0W @jjizzih Mydq <505W
_8W _F|iikb dfb$ X+$ O+ Zx|`gi|$ ix `d+
,XBI HISAD‑Z AK XBI HIX@AD+,$
<505W
_F|iikb dfb X$ Zx|`gi| O$ L|`x`k X$
Lq|ki I$ \yzzidd M$ Bakhi| Z$ Unxxz B+ Xbi
Hisad‑z ak xbi Hix`ad= Cak`d |iun|x nc xbi
akhiuikhikx is dy xank nc xbi Zygg`|q
J`|i \ijn|h `kh Bi`dxbZu`ji
u|nf|`ggiz+ Dnkhnk= Ykasi|zaxq Jnddifi
Dnkhnk? <505+W
_\nbg$ L+ `kh J+ \nbg M| ,Jdakaj`d
Akcn|g`xajz= @ Kiv U`|`hafg cn|
@hs`kjiz ak LanGihaj d Akcn|g`xajz+,$
<556W
_Vnnxxnk$ \+ "0113!+ ,Xidigihajaki= `
j`yxanyz vidjngi+, L|axazb Gihaj dMny|k`d :0:"6531!= 0:69+W
_9W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi dxb+ "<553!$ KBZ
Ha|ijx Jnggazzank C|`givn|o @u|ad
<553'g`|jb <556= Fyah`kji cn| U|ag`|q
j`|i X|yzxz nk Jnggazzankakf KBZ
Ha|ijx Zi|sajiz c|ng @u|ad <553W
_3W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi dxb+ "<505!$ 000'
Xbi Kiv Kygli| cn| xbi Cyxy|i nc Knk'
Igi|fikjq Bi`dxb Zi|sajiW
_6W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb+ "<505! —KBZ
Ha|ijx Zi|sajiz `kh kiv KBZ 000
kygli|W
_2W _K`xank`d Akzxaxyxi cn| Bi`dxb `kh
Jdakaj`d Irjiddikji$vvv+isahikji+kbz+yo $ d`zx `jjizzih nk 9xb
Ziuxigli| <505W
_1W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb+ "<505!$ —C`jxz
`lnyx IU\ idijx|nkaj u xaikx |ijn|hz
izzikxa`d |i`hakf cn| `dd jdakaja`kz$ KBZ
Irijyxasi$ IU\ U|nf|`ggi‗W
_05W _F|i`x L|ax`ak+ U`|da`gikx+ Bnyzi nc
Jnggnkz+ Bi`dxb Jnggaxxii+ Xbi
Idijx|nkaj U`xaikx \ijn|h= u|nf|izz zakji
<556= Zarxb \iun|x nc Zizzank <553'56W
_00W _AZLK= 5<095:30<:$ F|i`x L|ax`ak+
U`|da`gikx+ Bnyzi nc Jnggnkz+ Bi dxb
Jnggaxxii+ L`||nk$ Oisak$ Xbi idijx|nkaj
u xaikx |ijn|h = zarxb |iun|x nc zizzank
<553'56+ Snd+ 0 = \iun|x$ xnfixbi| vaxb
cn|g`d gakyxiz+W
_0<W _Bnyzi nc Jnggnkz u`ui|z+ Zizzank
<553'56? BJ 8<<'A
bxxu=..vvv+uyldaj`xankz+u`|da`gikx+yo.u`.
jg<55356.jgzidijx.jgbi`dxb.8<<.8<<+uhc
W
_V`dun|x$ G+ "<505!+ ,Hn zygg`|q j`|i
|ijn|hz b`si xbi unxikxa`d xn hn gn|i b`|g
xb`k fnnh> Kn+, L|axazb Gihaj d Mny|k`d
:85"myk03 8!= j:5<<+W
_F|iikb`dfb$ X+$ F+ Vnnh$ ix `d+ "<552!+
,U xaikxz& `xxaxyhiz xn xbi zygg`|q j`|i
|ijn|h `kh Bi`dxbZu`ji= py`dax`xasizxyhq+, L|axazb Gihaj`d Mny|k`d ::3"6393!=
0<15W
_Fykxi|$ X+ `kh K+ Xi||q "<559!+ ,Xbi
igi|fikji nc k`xank`d idijx|nkaj bi dxb
|ijn|h `|jbaxijxy|iz ak xbi Ykaxih Zx`xiz
`kh @yzx|`da = gnhidz$ jnzxz$ `kh
pyizxankz+, Mny|k d nc Gihaj d Akxi|kix
\izi`|jb 6"0!+W
_Mnbkznk$ U+ `kh Z+ Vbi`||q "<505!+ ,Xbi
Ahikxacaj`xank `kh \izndyxank nc Ixbaj d
Azzyiz ak Bi dxb J`|i= Xbin|ixaj d `kh
08
8/8/2019 SECURITY ISSUES IN CLINICAL INFORMATICS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/security-issues-in-clinical-informatics 15/15
U|`jxaj`d Saivunakxz+, Nkdaki Mny|k`d nc
Bi`dxb Ixbajz 3"0!+W
_Xz`a$ C+ "<505!+ ,Zijy|axq Azzyiz ak I'
Bi`dxbj`|i+, Mny|k`d nc Gihaj`d `kh
Landnfaj`d Ikfakii|akf :5"8!+W
_Xz`a$ C+$ V+ B`k$ ix `d+ "<551!+ ,Hizafk
`kh hisidnugikx nc ` gnladi uii|'xn'uii|
znja`d kixvn|oakf `uudaj xank+, Irui|x
Zqzxigz vaxb @uudaj`xankz :3"2!= 00566'
00526+W$
_Jbik$ Q+$ C+ Xz`a$ ix `d+ "<556!+ Ldnf
zi`|jb `kh gakakf ak xbi lyzakizz hng`ak$
@JG+W
_H|axz`z$ Z+$ D+ Fqgknunydnz$ ix `d+"<553!+ ,@ oknvdihfi'l`zih `uu|n`jb xn
zijy|axq |ipya|igikxz cn| i'bi dxb
`uudaj`xankz+, Idijx|nkaj Mny|k d cn| I'
Jnggi|ji Xnndz `kh @uudaj`xankz+W
_L`||nvz$ \+ `kh U+ Jd qxnk "0113!+
,U|as`jq$ jnkcahikxa`daxq$ `kh idijx|nkaj
gihaj`d |ijn|hz+, Mny|k`d nc xbi @gi|aj`k
Gihaj`d Akcn|g`xajz @zznja xank :"<!=
0:1+W
_Hvasiha$ @+$ \+ L da$ ix `d+ "<55:!+
Xnv`|hz ` u|`jxaj`d bi`dxbj`|i akcn|g`xank
zijy|axq gnhid cn| bi`dxbj`|i akzxaxyxankz+W
_By$ M+ `kh @+ Vi`si| "<558!+ @ hqk`gaj$
jnkxirx'`v`|i zijy|axq akc| zx|yjxy|i cn|
hazx|alyxih bi`dxbj`|i `uudaj`xankz+W
_0:W _Hiu`|xgikx nc Bi`dxb+ "<55:!$
Jnkcahikxa`daxq= KBZ Jnhi nc Ixbajz+W
_Oiddq$ F+ `kh L+ GjOik}ai "<55<!+,Zijy|axq$ u|as`jq$ `kh jnkcahikxa`daxq
azzyiz nk xbi Akxi|kix+, Mny|k`d nc Gihaj`d
Akxi|kix \izi`|jb 8"<!+W
_Ra`n$ D+$ L+ By$ ix `d+ "<551!+ Xnv`|hz
Oknvdihfi Zb`|akf `kh U`xaikx U|as`jq ak
` Jdakaj`d Hijazank Zyuun|x Zqzxig+W
_S`k Vakfi|hi$ C+$ M+ Zjbakhdi|$ ix `d+
"0113!+ Yzakf BD6 `kh xbi Vn|dh Vahi
Vil cn| ykacqakf u`xaikx h`x` c|ng |ignxi
h`x`l`ziz$ @gi|aj`k Gihaj`d Akcn|g`xajz
@zznja`xank+W
_Onb`ki$ A+$ C+ S`k Vakfi|hi$ ix `d+
"0113!+ Zb`|akf idijx|nkaj gihaj`d |ijn|hz
`j|nzz gydxaudi bixi|nfikinyz `kh
jnguixakf akzxaxyxankz$ @gi|aj`k Gihaj`d
Akcn|g`xajz @zznja`xank+W
_Vizxak$ @+ "0113!+ ,B`||az'Ipyac`r
jnkzygi| u|as`jq zy|siq 0110+, @xd`kx $
F@= Ipyac`r Akj+W
_08W _YOJBAU$ <551+ —Akhiuikhikx
\isaiv nc KBZ `kh Znja`d J`|i AX‗+
c|ng bxxu=..giha`+cx+jng.jgz.lchc1j0i'
29l:'00hi'12hi'55088ci`lhj5+uhc W
_@jjizzih 9 @yf <505W
_Biggakfz$ X+ "<555!+ ,UOA= yu jdnzi `kh
ui|znk`d+, Bi`dxb g`k`figikx xijbkndnfq<0"1!= <5+W
_Ixbi|ahfi$ Q+ "<550!+ ,UOA "uyldaj oiq
akc| zx|yjxy|i!''bnv `kh vbq ax vn|oz+,
Bi dxb g`k`figikx xijbkndnfq <<"0!=
<5+W
_09W _Zi`|jb Zijy|axq "<505$ Ziux! —KBZ
zg`|x j`|h hisajiz ik`ldi zijy|i `jjizz xn
bi`dxb j`|i `uuz+‗ C|ng
bxxu=..zi`|jbzijy|axq+xijbx`|fix+jn+yo.kivz
.`|xajdi.5$<2108<$zah025^fja0901909$55+bx
gd `jjizzih Ziux 05$ <505W
1+ L\AIC LANF\@UBQ
@|ykoyg`| \ihhq G`|iu`ddq$ G+Zj+ az
` f|`hy xi zxyhikx nc Jnguyxakf$
Akcn|g`xank Xijbkndnfq `kh
Ikfakii|akf$ Ykasi|zaxq nc I zx
Dnkhnk$ Hnjod`khz J`guyz$ Ykasi|zaxq
V`q$ Dnkhnk I03 <\H+
H|+ Jb|az Ag`cahnk az ` Zikan| Dijxy|i| `x
Jnguyxakf$ Akcn|g`xank Xijbkndnfq
`kh Ikfakii|akf$ Ykasi|zaxq nc I`zx
Dnkhnk$ Hnjod`khz J`guyz$ Ykasi|zaxq
V`q$ Dnkhnk I03 <\H+
Cn|gi|dq$ Bi`h nc G`k`figikx nc Xijbkndnfq Ykax$ Pyiik G`|q$ Ykasi|zaxqnc Dnkhnk+Fyizx Zigak`| Dijxy|i| `x Ykasi|zaxq nc J`gl|ahfi+
Fyizx Dijxy|i| `x Ykasi|zaxq nc Nrcn|h+
09
