36
SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING INFRASTRUCTURE FOR EXTENDED LIFE SPAN Facilities Engineering Seminar April 24-26, 2019 Jacksonville, FL April 24, 2019 Mohsen Shahawy, PhD, PE (Principal) Hatem Seliem, PhD, PE, PMP (Senior Structural Engineer) Panel I: Tech Forum: Using Tech to Extend Infrastructure

SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.

ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING INFRASTRUCTURE FOR EXTENDED LIFE SPAN

Facilities Engineering SeminarApril 24-26, 2019Jacksonville, FL

April 24, 2019

Mohsen Shahawy, PhD, PE (Principal)

Hatem Seliem, PhD, PE, PMP (Senior Structural Engineer)

Panel I: Tech Forum: Using Tech to Extend Infrastructure

Page 2: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

OUTLINE

Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

Material Properties

Common Types / Application Techniques

Advantages of FRP

Advanced Computing Techniques

Advanced Structural Analysis

Soil-Structure Interaction

Damage Assessment

Testing and Instrumentation

Selected Projects

Page 3: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

OUTLINE

Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

Material Properties

Common Types / Application Techniques

Advantages of FRP

Advanced Computing Techniques

Advanced Structural Analysis

Soil-Structure Interaction

Damage Assessment

Testing and Instrumentation

Selected Projects

Page 4: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Fibers: Glass

Carbon

Aramid

Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymers (GFRP)

Carbon Fiber Reinforced Polymers (CFRP)

Aramid Fiber Reinforced Polymers (AFRP)

Constituent Materials

Resins: Epoxy

Polyester

Vinyl esters

+

Page 5: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Constituents vs. Composite

Page 6: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Mechanical Properties

0

100

200

300

0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5%

Strain

Str

ess (

ksi)

GFRP(180 ksi)

AFRP(240 ksi)

HM CFRP (220 ksi)

CFRP (310 ksi)

Steel (60 ksi)

Page 7: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

High strength-to-weight ratio

Excellent durability

Non-magnetic, Non corrosive

Low profile when installed

Fast and easy application

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Advantages of FRP

ACI 440.2R

Page 8: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

Pre-cured LaminatesWet lay-up systems

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Common Types of CFRP

Page 9: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Pre-cured

Pre-cured Composite shapes manufactured

off-site

Wet lay-up

Dry fiber sheets or fabrics impregnated

with resin on-site

Pre-preg

Pre-impregnated uncured fiber

sheets or fabrics

Common Types of FRP

Page 10: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Application Techniques

Externally Bonding (EB)

Page 11: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Application Techniques

Near-Surface-Mounted (NSM)

NSM Bars NSM Strips

Page 12: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Application Techniques

Wrapping

Page 13: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Reasons to Retrofit with FRP

Increase load-carrying capacity

Flexure strengthening, shear strengthening, axial load strengthening

Impact damaged structures

Ductility enhancement

Blast mitigation

Structural upgrade and seismic retrofit

Cutouts and penetrations

Page 14: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Durability

Environmental considerations

Alkalinity/acidity

Thermal expansion

Electrical conductivity

Loading considerations

Impact tolerance

Creep rupture and fatigue

Page 15: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

FIBER-REINFORCED POLYMERS (FRP)

Durability

Environmental reduction factor (conservative estimates)

Fiber type & exposure conditions

Protective coatings

Projects that are more than 30 years old

ACI 440.2R

Page 16: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

OUTLINE

Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

Material Properties

Common Types / Application Techniques

Advantages of FRP

Advanced Computing Techniques

Advanced Structural Analysis

Soil-Structure Interaction

Damage Assessment

Testing and Instrumentation

Selected Projects

Page 17: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

ADVANCED COMPUTING TECHNIQUES

Advanced Structural Analysis

Finite Element Analysis (FEA)

Non-linear analysis

Geometrical non-linearities

Shell elements, solid elements

Page 18: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

ADVANCED COMPUTING TECHNIQUES

Soil-Structure Interaction

Piles: beam elements

Soil springs (P-y curves)

Lateral springs

Vertical springs

Page 19: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

ADVANCED COMPUTING TECHNIQUES

Soil-Structure Interaction

Gravity Loads Lateral Loads

Page 20: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

ADVANCED COMPUTING TECHNIQUES

Damage Assessment

SMART BRIDGE SUITE

Section loss

Corrosion of steel

Loss of bond

Deterioration

Page 21: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

OUTLINE

Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

Material Properties

Common Types / Application Techniques

Advantages of FRP

Advanced Computing Techniques

Advanced Structural Analysis

Soil-Structure Interaction

Damage Assessment Tools

Testing and Instrumentation

Selected Projects

Page 22: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

TESTING AND MONITORING

Load Testing

Actual behavior of structure (load distribution)

Strength enhancing factors not included in calculations

Composite actions

Continuity/fixation

Secondary members

Static tests (proof test and diagnostic test)

Dynamic tests

Page 23: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

TESTING AND MONITORING

Load Testing

Counter weights Trucks with known weights

Page 24: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

TESTING AND MONITORING

Load Testing

390 KIPS TRUCKS

Page 25: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

TESTING AND MONITORING

Non-Destructive Testing

Chloride Ion Penetration Cover removal and reinforcement inspection

Page 26: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

TESTING AND MONITORING

Instrumentation

Page 27: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

Instrumentation

TESTING AND MONITORING

Instrumentation plans are developed based on analysis of structure.

Page 28: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

OUTLINE

Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

Material Properties

Common Types / Application Techniques

Advantages of FRP

Advanced Computing Techniques

Advanced Structural Analysis

Soil-Structure Interaction

Damage Assessment Tools

Testing and Instrumentation

Selected Projects

Page 29: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

SELECTED PROJECTS

Allen Creek BridgeClearwater, FL 2005

Wrapping of piles

Underwater application

Splash zone

Page 30: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

SELECTED PROJECTS

US 1 BridgeMelbourne, FL 1994

Corrosion of main reinforcement

Girders repair

Concrete section restoration

Page 31: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

SELECTED PROJECTS

Rockaway Line ViaductNew York, NY 2009

Corrosion of reinforcement

Girders repair

Concrete section restoration

Page 32: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

I-10 Bridge Over L&A RailroadLA 2016

Strengthening of deck slab

Instrumentation & proof testing

SELECTED PROJECTS

Page 33: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

SELECTED PROJECTS

Bayou Pierre BridgeDesoto & Red River Parishes, LA 2018

46-AXLES SPMT

5-Span with total length of 500 ft.

10 PPC girders

10,000 kips (4,500 tons) DRAGLINE390 KIPS TRUCKS

Page 34: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

SELECTED PROJECTS

Bayou Pierre BridgeDesoto & Red River Parishes, LA 2018

Page 35: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

SELECTED PROJECTS

Bayou Pierre BridgeDesoto & Red River Parishes, LA 2018

Page 36: SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc.aapa.files.cms-plus.com/2019Seminars/FacilitiesEng/Seliem final... · SDR Engineering Consultants, Inc. ENHANCING LIVE LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITY OF EXISTING

www.sdrengineering.com

ThankYou !