29
Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage Containment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies Introduction to geological storage of CO 2 Dr Mark Naylor

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Introduction to geological storage of CO2

Dr Mark Naylor

Page 2: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Carbon capture and storage chain

Page 3: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Geological information is inherently uncertain!

• Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated

• Geologists and oil industry have to accept order of magnitude uncertainty and manage it appropriately…

Page 4: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Where do we find geological information?

Lines Planes Volumes

Page 5: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Experimental

Drainage in Fontainbleau Sandstone

Imibition in Fontainbleau Sandstone

Page 6: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Where do we find geological information?Expert knowledge

Page 7: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

• Can the subsurface store co2?– Natural analogues

• How similar is the oil industry?– Reservoir, seal, flow in porous media, multiphase

flow, well design, injection, production, imaging, transport, sub-sea infrastructure…

• Properties of CO2– Phase behaviour

– Multiphase flow

• How much can the earth safely store?– What does safely mean?

• What do we need to monitor? – Extent of CO2 plume?

– Pressure response?

Page 8: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

The Earth naturally stores CO2

Page 9: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Page 10: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Natural CO2 leakage

Sub-marineSub-aerial

Bubbles of liquid carbon dioxide rise from

the seafloor at the Champagne vent on

Eifuku volcano in the W Pacific.

The CO2 is liquid due to the high pressure.

Page 11: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept
Page 12: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Well locations There’s gas in them there hills

Page 13: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Building confidence

• Studying natural analogues allows us to:

– Understand factors that increase security

– Understand why and how it leaks

– Understand impact of leakage

– Test monitoring strategies

Page 14: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

• Can the subsurface store co2?– Natural analogues

• How similar is the oil industry?– Reservoir, seal, flow in porous media, multiphase

flow, well design, injection, production, imaging, transport, sub-sea infrastructure…

• Properties of CO2– Phase behaviour

– Multiphase flow

• How much can the earth safely store?– What does safely mean?

• What do we need to monitor? – Extent of CO2 plume?

– Pressure response?

Page 15: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Porosity controls capacity of reservoir

Open, v. porous medium, coarse to v.

coarse sandstone

Compacted to moderately compacted

medium to fine sandstones

Page 16: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Hydrocarbon reservoir

• Adequate pore volume

• 3D trap

• Seal

• Adequate permeability

Page 17: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

(USGS, 2009)

Page 18: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

• Can the subsurface store co2?– Natural analogues

• How similar is the oil industry?– Reservoir, seal, flow in porous media, multiphase

flow, well design, injection, production, imaging, transport, sub-sea infrastructure…

• How much can the earth safely store?– What does safely mean?

• Properties of CO2– Phase behaviour– Multiphase flow

• What do we need to monitor? – Extent of CO2 plume?

– Pressure response?

Page 19: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

(USGS, 2009)

Page 20: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

(After Bradshaw and Dance, 2005 and USGS 2001)

Page 21: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scotland Storage ������������� �����

��������������� �� �������������������

� �������� �����������������

����������������������������

������� ������!��"������

#���� �#� �� � �!���������

���� �����������#�#�

������������ ��� "��������

�#������#�!��"����� �����������

�$�%&�'$��

� �������� ���������������

� ��������� �������������

����������� ����� �������� �

(�����"�����)������*��������

'�� �#+���#������ � �� �������

WORLD: Deep saline aquifers 400 - 10,000 Gt (16 - 400yr) (IEA GHG 2004)

Oil and gas reservoirs 930 Gt (37 yr) Coal deep seams 30 Gt (1 yr)

Page 22: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

• Can the subsurface store co2?– Natural analogues

• How similar is the oil industry?– Reservoir, seal, flow in porous media, multiphase

flow, well design, injection, production, imaging, transport, sub-sea infrastructure…

• How much can the earth safely store?– What does safely mean?

• Properties of CO2– Phase behaviour– Multiphase flow

• What do we need to monitor? – Extent of CO2 plume?

– Pressure response?

Page 23: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Variability in CO2 density with dT/dz

Cool

Hot

Critical pressure

Sea bed

dT/tz

Page 24: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

• Can the subsurface store co2?– Natural analogues

• How similar is the oil industry?– Reservoir, seal, flow in porous media, multiphase

flow, well design, injection, production, imaging, transport, sub-sea infrastructure…

• How much can the earth safely store?– What does safely mean?

• Properties of CO2– Phase behaviour– Multiphase flow

• What do we need to monitor? – Extent of CO2 plume?

– Pressure response?

Page 25: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Plume extent vs pressure response

Page 26: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

• Can the subsurface store co2?– Natural analogues

• How similar is the oil industry?– Reservoir, seal, flow in porous media, multiphase

flow, well design, injection, production, imaging, transport, sub-sea infrastructure…

• Properties of CO2– Phase behaviour

– Multiphase flow

• How much can the earth safely store?– What does safely mean?

• What do we need to monitor? – Extent of CO2 plume?

– Pressure response?

Page 27: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Where do we find geological information?Line measurements in a 3D volume

Page 28: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Where do we find geological information?Planes in a 3D volume

Page 29: Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage · • Engineers frequently design understandable equipment that can be iteratively interrogated • Geologists and oil industry have to accept

Scottish Centre for Carbon Storage

Scottish Centre for Carbon StorageContainment solutions to compliment emissions reduction strategies

Where do we find geological information?Remote sensing of 3D volumes