Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
p IN TN E GupA€mE Covgr aF
scetraaoMIC HR€L €NARLES DefuE UPA€M€CouRT CAS€ At
ÔCA C ASE Mo.: JD/A 334
LT cAsg yq|e70/il CA 4/$Q
VS,
Kewner+i Tuck€g , seenctn*Y ¤W
TNG FCdRMA O€PARTM€NTef CoRRECitdy3
Ñ€¶PONDENT
QuRESDecinewAL BRi€F of P€TirtoWEA'S
z 7
poI
a ziÊ O
tcyngl C WAAl€s DeSct E
oEE
CdyHauW CodRECTioWH løvsTitteftevj†54A$dctTH€nST IW$itistridk DRSVW
ÅlaueVTsTouaN9 AoAFDJP 32Y2Y
Cc-nrrftenr€ of .747€A€5r J0cgfear
/hrs . Ji>nndes #n£ke4
Genernt Counset Dept. ©ÞT reC fr onS
Sauff, Callnecrvr 5+ree f
Thl/nhøssee, ft 32399-37ao
this. Pnm+tte (To bondi
i4Herney Genern! Deg. cf
I-- et J+ffør'rs
Ike Cnpty i )ÛL -O f
Tc4 l in k nss <<1 E' 3239†- 165o
ASr Dútcr^ct <*ot«f af Affer/
20C0 bpMyful De etr-e
77+ rnhnrsee, (=t 31379 - 09fd
I i
PAGE Nc C.5), · T~nBL E of CarvTEIVT3
- t 2 -
€€R TIf1c A TE cF Erv T€p€s i Gensoiv.sil i
t#96L€ OF €ðNT€N75 ....
T!76LEqof CITATICWS
ÞR€Linume£ y €TnTEtviENT
STerEmeNT of Tec cnSc nuo Facrs
6Vmmr9Ay ARGuaynENT
ARGürv>cevr3
ISSuE ONE : 44 HETHEA THE FtRsi DESTAICT Cac!AT D€CESE¢N
ott AUGuit IGi 241% CcNSTRUE FLaREDA CoNSittuTtoN
of AArtc l¢ y SEC . Ly [4y g <j [63 x3 n [ny€tvTrorv8L
ViolArtorv 8tf CçpugT of p€TtTadNéA'S RicHTé To Du€
MCCESS GMDER AAftCLé E JEC.9 l'cA.QaNET
$5U€Tico W HETy£& TN€ FiRST DasTAtcT CoerAT QECistolV
oN Ac.tGuST 16, 2cts R€bESIGNt37/MG DE3uErs tinnaDamus •¡
DeSrvusS6L APPEAL As p Maric€ To ZNyakE C'€AftoAr1AíAEviEt4 DietECTLlf 19tvD £×PGES3Ltf CONFi!CT CutTH Ai!THoRrry
of ArvoTHER besTRICT AND GF E73 ocuìy DISTRtCT P
toivct..usion
(EntrYKATE of SERVi¢E9
cEerificnTE oF °
7"AB£ of CITATranv3 PAGE McCs)
cases 3Gonu lez V . 3461e, Goy So. ad 77Y C Ftn. t©t DC A i993)
Pow·ell lr~ Ste†c, 70 So. 3d S'8·7 ( Vin. Zott)
t½Arshnli v. &rrico Ev1cz YYG Ct·5· 137 , too S.Cf LGlo,14t3 (cy L£4. pd S T
(79. (19%o)
fï'9nzen V. ORN09e Coun(Cf ., Trit so.;ht 8~5')-75't (Fin.sYt-i DcA 20 7
¿ßurg€ss v.c^rcsby ,17o So.2d at7-72T CFin. iSt DCA 2004) g- 7
lioicawn b v. beyot . of car l'. , bo? Ja, 2d 73-7 , 732 Crt,9. 157 DCt9 1992 ) 5
.Jn Ñ€ (nr y f on , 37 8 bo· Ad I & 22, / 2 EG ( fin. 1979) (p
vvlorri son V • È Ê* L'AC , 592 E' #"f
oi ( v. Mc Lìonnell, 9tg it.S. 537 ( 1994)
Y k V . Ü"33eA a So d loT, toy ( fin. 15+ OCR 1992)
Tones y . ¿va pve,'; 3
Al - 169 karva v. ivic Dono
AUS b'n V - /Vk Donou S
Greert v . tviaore > 77 7 So. 3 d 4 2 3 ( ft t st nen zoo
frogro A to/V$ttruitoaV PRoVisioNS
/}ettet< V, sec·3(S)(3)
A£†ic(+ V sec. 4 (a) S
Rahtt« K See. 3 (a) S
f]£fict-e.. Y SeC . 4Cb)(A)
Aetect< ) 3ec. t
r4a we i e i sec.. 95
ortyca squrgan:Tz€.s3
fin. R.Tud. Admin.
Fin. AppettAie t''rAch'cq f GT.S• certi'or
Chp. 33.3o7.002(ta) f·n.c..
-¡V
pecunmune y s'rnrcrsEmi
bishnet chn<t-s DeSœ z<>ss Hnc pebNoner appellnnt en five First
histne f food et 19ppen t fccwa ike Cerecer7 Cow+ de sme'ssæty hå tviandenes
Êt'l e d Êro i~i Depnrtwvi† of C'o cr ec b'orq3 A dme ¼'s frafäre no flos1 3 (û e . de'sci'p/<n
repe>rt wh<ch im 16a5 jun>4¼(<'on brtef the mit be re1Greed A by
if Or E
Th< øefetàner ev,rt des, te referenees to 1+e keerd on nppent
efzør fi^< Desfent c¼urf of Appent A'ted toy the Secort4Judt0¼t curw'f
f of Ce°n Coh ort ®ty 27, 2ota usta ne symbat "R'> foj7
i †* ^PP®f '^" P^r nous ber e o par en ttu si9 .
srnTOUCAt7 0F CûTE émb M7
7tne 4)epàrtmnt c/' C<.,trecNons 19&ntsfrnhbn œrofe De
ntn/era/('eëµ9{ 9/se di'S / diff
(ae wc4S lifÈÿMf(n} ncyntáf fûe th$fffchor? of &Mwet lorrectt,n 5
a j hwy he'.« uninwb14y d€f . (A.63 - 3¢°
rhe second pdærni Crymå surf iswed a sks cm<se order
tapen The Deparfærut of 6erectr'arts fa /despond it, fim seocen atteojn/Jor13
(A. 3U VO ),
The Circuit Caurf on mny 21, poig evitered a der
the pebboner(s mandanws ¿ahæf he t's entified to an appnl
finen A cerfiarnri reve'eQ (L 9e- 93). Aeh*"' *) dente 4 ora ne n, 2ct?
cesrmssnt òrd€r Arc41¿)ena appented fi~e vnmndnmus
De5'<a lo S /on rtup-st t, zeta f ísue4 n order regaterny
appmi shoard not be frented as n Cerhòrnri, he AFP
(tyst t, 2o1A ord*r bY °"'I]
Cet cu, y Csart is l'egyr'red fs b 7ff 4 ø urb rnri re i 'ee4 d5
n titrnppropråt e noethod of Revi'e
†he 6fø{e Êtled M reSpoAS* fin Couff deCtŸe3rurt fu ·frenf †t e Apfe>1/ MS M 7,y jp $/n/·e c»dt neeo
n 39 ¿q ex tent c avi of f¾¢, Éc ÊrYf 39 M11w3C * €'S
August 3, 2ot7 fried Enthni Beref on fke appi ineerfs.
rtne bestent Court ort f¼pst (4, 2042 utered n deed'ion of redes nn 4
/kc appent æt ike mnndsc«uS kswitssdi as /n¥o/cm Eerkornra r
reguèq †M phh'oner to Ate a cerhòrari o< giW Mohd f° /t
cost to frenf his À1tWM / ef 143 ø Cerfrocarì\ 5ee Append
( August 14 20t2 beet'sion b
Tim's dect5cÈv) doeS M*f C ej of 4 4 es en ere
lh/s deo'srbcpohcg. ÊnvGÑrn TCP
Dene an 1%cpst 2o, 2072 Y
fletrreze3 by /ke fiorridd frec«e
im H2 (k D estrî et Cour'f , tJfA A °'n e i br*f kna beeri A1e d
oJithin to d*yS of Cr'Liny ike ñofite †r ¡nvoke de'scretiooney F'en e
fronn +ke date on thù brief cover page. of Doc offe'crës teking control
of this brief under Gomzntez r.Sin†e, Goy 6.2d VN (fog. tstocA £192)
P€tiNoner on AugusF 2 o, Joja pursumat h fin. R.17pp. P 7. 3/o Ce)
Gle d a moli'an in siny proceeding s t'v> the Des/rect ewei- pen o¼>3
discrehònnry review determtîmttàn by }his courf
3.
Survrwinr<ç Atacurnenr
E. T(ar De½racf (ourt has construe d previsicQs sf' this synte c'ens
in vicintion of due precežs to ''énfentr'onntly te'n1-t pettfi aer!S
r-î9hts to n direct reviee» nppent from bepartment af c¼rrn
AŠMtäiSfrg|t'on f¶cft'onj wir>ere fkg ( 7 yµ p r
Üudye Chnries Fknnc.ts oisenq5ed Peitlicner's í¾ndna tus not addressin
Hae evteri·ls c>f the Cin,'ens , whùb ike oct) r'edesejated line 7ppent as
i nv o kinJ c ert:ben r i ge7teea by ¡¡, 'þ,y7en ; p,co,,'>
PeMiana, u>hem thl.s decîsion is nef a decîston bernusë ey was né
en fered toy fine re caired ihree (Q pnnet of Castnkt rfud9e3 rep<by
T¼ Supreivre cocut tu ace,PI durisdicti°n of the cese cander the ct'r-
^umstances ,
The Destrict cauet 17uyest tG>,20tg decistan redestynnfi'ny pebbòner1s
direef ('evieri. appeni AS invokuby cerhorari reviet» from th·e GrcuEt
°«f of Cean cos.mty "Ártendnma.1 DesmesSnt okdeR "expressly r1nd deh-city
ist fs uit f ¼ Sufbare f/es o f atn other Desbricf our f , a nd im fk È s ocent
bestrict,u>hic'h the Des/rec/ (%cf ust|r3 !)S Poliçî ,t Awer "enfered if3
ouso deCISÈon indepevident l'rowe the States response redestynr+Mn pehfròner$
PPe91 AS n cerWornrì concents +ke e ndnmr.es isentssAt o£deg ,y,4
(ftoinfeS due proce33
C e t' fterriri è5 n in'u s ht e ref ur'r n the Suprem e Court t o ,pccept y'uc,3.4,è yan
of this ense. in fue raterest of tjustice.
4.
SM oNC (AM€rHER THE FIRST DISTAfty co,_gy-D€CEStoN on Auc,usi È&t 2ail Cot\rSinu€ Vcoî9CDigØCNstiturten of ,qp7
3 A faviErvrtour1c vialnTtody Qy couRr ofPEftrgqngggi pp
02rict.è r séc. 9 fås eatvsil
rhe fearide dupreme Couri enn ærcin ifs dekrefio<·7 and r
99 deciSibn beg th,c OtHrtòf Court f(nnt cortsfrue n syny œ çq..4,,µ¿ c,
prove x io a under ARNct e V 6ec . 3 (h)(3) Fen. Const.
Under sinte provisions th the b.Sfr<ct Court's requires a decîst n
i n three (3) pnnel of Jüdyes to constr¼te ns n te9nt dectsào under
Arfict e. V. ócc . 9 (a) Fin. Const. See Fin A.qud. p4mí g .oyo ç,3.
The first Dàtrict Court's 19upust IG, 2oi2 decis‡on redesynnkry
pefifian<•r's affeni as t'nvascin3 Certiorari Review by the Court construes
the Provision,s of 19ateste ir. Eec. '1(a) Fin.Const. En e dimiine Circumsfance3
the suprenne court peoruen entered n * decister7" in Po<.»ett v.Sinte,
70 So 34 37f7 (fin. 2oll), h,lding PeMion for r»rif of Certiornri fited
fa SufrewC Court , and frented n3 e nanndnwjuS , is nem frented ris
A noficC io inVoke discreHenory ,jurisdiefion five Cs) Jusfice,s ertfered
f¼is decision . See Ar+. v se< 3 (a) fin cansf.
u f Aupst 14, zeta decision is not a te9nt decisào under
Cortsfifulianni provisforjS of fyrs gypµe, ¿qcqug.e n three (3) panc) of Didrief
ܯod) '6 did not enter tN whicto this décèsran Vicinfrs' DeShe'S }}uaranfeed
rights of due process of inæ, hecnust fac wns mi provided Couk n (nii
a nd imfer f in t tribunn y i,, i hr Distml court , wk,c h fue de cision ains entered
a order to deprìVC pettfioner of his riqhts to e direct review appent
of a dmines ft'n fión ge µfoqS MS r}uire d under Arfrtt e V. Sec . 9 (6 )(.z) Firt .
Apfendt¥ A € 8 infrn) tVinrShnt/ v.ferrico Enc,, Y G c.t.5. 237 too
a IGl3 j G9 L.Ed.24 tv (199o) ; p,wy¿7 yy 3
furthermor€ the Disfrict Court Knows n mandamuS Psmissel l'eguireS
4 QPfeni naf n certiareri Revien is fke censon evhy the Dufraf JAye.s
does inot put their name on fhe decision entered ø9uyosp tc, zot2 . See
Meza v. O£nng e County , 7tt 5°~ Ad îS7 ~ î5-7 ( fin. s¼ oct9 2oos.); 0"'3®SS
v. Crosby, 77o s.. ad an. 317 ( fin. t :>t ocn 2004); 14alcomb v. Dept. o f
Corr., Go9 & ad ys, , pga çg,µ. ,sy pe,9 1992
sn
T h e Di s-lin f court u s e d iV s 6°oliticnt Poweß fo conc ert / time tv2nndervauS
Dismissal ôRder to sfrne; end irmptyir pet,·timp op h,
direct reviw appent , when the Distrcst court in hinsness for µf
redesF3nnie4 †he appeni to Coe invekïh3 ceri vrari Aerim to infediennity
limit the nevèeu of knving dîscreHon net to address the enerit.s on accept
gevieta does vtotofc the prevàlans of 19rfícte E ,see.1 Fin conSf. Sc -
Fin oppetute Prectree 27.3- ceratiorerì¡ cp. 97_q3y app r, 19 .g if,orn.
farther-are the !9ugu% 10, 2012 dechion doa ,-,y a 7 pg,¥îbn«
fo Ê<1e n È¢JñÍ "Ÿ P¢¢USot of Õ×4ye3 beer)ct3e †(tjer'r nenzte nrC
concented, theaefore no recusal ->ation enn net be served upe·n thervi
as reyuir ed ûn , .in Ae CnA lien , 37T 6e ,14 saia , taig (r'in. ¿9,9);Marshall
too s.Ct. icio, ¿coe3.
The Suprenne caugt shauid exercise. its discrehannry jurisdàtion
by acceptir3 ft/lis ense b>r te evie-w , wh ere †he on s fra f cour† kn s con s fraed
joddioner's conddakonni ri'3 his ,
to-
IS3u€ TuJo.'. UJcKrNER 77té Fir?ST Drsrtect Couef·
O€CtStoi1r Onr 67CtGt.tsr ico, 2cis R€OESFC/V87¯!a\rc,
DESu€/S Mi9rVDoMuS htStuissnc. AppEoC 195 19Nort C E To Irvvaxc C€RrtaRARf £€veEuJ O tR€c7ty
O ÜPRES5CV CGNf4tetS t.øtry t9uTHoRtTY ofarti€A btSTRect #9WD of Eis occi\r OtsTRtcf P
The Frari de Supreme coucµ ung,p 79 ,enat,
(nns <t'<'Scr4fion io RevieuJ t9 decision µµqq <eexpressly nød derec ft y
conflict «><Yh n decision of another D:sfrit† c>curp^
IM Pe tt fron+r''S 7%idamus uJns Dr 3.+r isSed by LIV 4Je ¢hnr/es
Fennels of f~eon €•unty Caycui'† ¿~oacf on SViny 82, 2ai u.théch a de'reet
c'evé eta 19ppeA l krns (c'ted . (A. 91- 93) C Appendik B. infrø ( M&f 31, .2ar2
innndemus Drswsset o£deg)
Au3uW ti 20i2 after fue appe,71 i fee,., C,led ud assipd
f he District court on tYs curva ordered 3
fhe "appent* shourd not be treated as ûrvakeh3 Cerhornri Revi'eW of
fM Distrût cour(..
Þe fitioner on RupSt 3, aola % e respoon W1d iniltài 17ppent
Brïef on the nnerets demronstrr+Frn) where ti,e rmerels of his ciniu3
in htä ¼ndemuS knd not been addressed by flac Circuit couc†
concerning peMioner betà3 written n Cntse uscijotínney reporf by DCC
ns retàtt'nlion Ar hee lify feh3 y,èsf ooe of haw,¼3 h,ð anincoluity
ned, and achilener}?ity rernaved hi,è from 3eneral Popuention
a l'mcfed library resenrch to obin>> tm Lberty , euh,e k the Grea,ç
oud dismis5ed hi'S manndemus.( A. o3. 3r,; 9t-93 ) cyp. 33-ZoW~oo2(ta)
noorrisen 7. Leferrx<, werA / Syp. los i to7t ~73 (S.o.Ar.y 19ty).
onnett , yet <¿.L s-39 Ct97Y); Vt9n Poyck v .Doy9er, swatot to1 C rin. ist Dcn t?91) >
Inv9s been <»ett es/nbtûsed th& n nonndnmus Disnaiss4/ oRdeR by 49
cc ue / court ce g ur'r e ,7 appent t~nther +hen ¢erhäreri _ See ihnrez v, orn<nye
C y , 7tit So- 24 Tcs¯7- TrG1r (fo9. sn Den zaa2), wh,c h trae F<rst bcr9 v.5fn bt,'shed
i Burgess v . Cros by , Tr7a Sw 2d at7 - prW (fen. t st kr+ 2coy)3 Tones v. me -
Fren I , % So- 34 it 5% ( fin. c sr oc A 2010) ; +9t- ttnbiva y . n4e• Dmy in , y y
So. 24 1ra2CFca. est ocp9 2004),
Dn '90s H'<n v. Mc Danou9hj 99 fr Je.2d 97a C fin. tsroce9 zoa7) ''h
Dcn held ,wl->ere (nr Ç<·t·ed in peti:He,n for C<Jrr I of Cer/r'arari m court converted
t- to en 4 appeni
7tve Desired eaart's /%yust it.r zot2 decrrr~on c:xygessly and denec H y"
con(trèf wej¼ fö·e abcvc cded rtutheresie.5 of hve hcr? rrdeseynntem'
pdé jr sunr 's appa /, to b< rhvak, c ertrèrver rzeve~ero , <:~shem $69
courf /<'rows f¾• &ppe4/ wns he prya_r ReArte naefhad frem
f tue 6 re ut f c'wet "de s eu tbing DeSu e s nundemus ora mn-y a e, 2hr
culvde HA< bcA daràsty eencents is dewf DeSc'e due frocess' in
j¼ tvtan dwtus prec e e a ,i toe, c on d u e.fe d betoco. 5cc a7pfendix's
A L 6 inkø j GL qq _ q3) 3,, c,,, y , yn,,re, 97 7 s._ 2 4 etòs^ (
l 57 bct4 ~2cco) ; Yv ncs hn t I to L cf. Et»t o , ico t5,
The Es-prei-e Wf nwst ê×eret s·e. e ¥s dìscre&èñary <J Àn s&c M•1
by necepfin3 t¼r's enre la eµcnntee Be5«e due frecess 7%sis 6
Èvt % ft artu ft y c¥¶< s ed Ioy f¼ bcA lae t eeG .
f-r
o^!C/A/Stoty
The poef'¯honer prays for The flarryn C Court fe ,gee,pµ
discrett'onnry jure dîct;oo of this cm,
/2espec+fuity s u6m, te4
MK HM€t... CManc€$ h-
cear.rfrcárc o f SEAv'c E
I N€R€89 Do cyp7,µy yggµ ./M foreyoray v~urisdietronn ) dré'ef w<th Appe
4. ô has been pinced In fke hnnds of A Department of carrec1!-¿>n off,c,
hnnds 4r mn-Noy to, mrs. G~ennifer Per ken, General Coun:set A~e Doc, rot sourb
(nihaun JYree f , T¯e Ifn høgssec , Fi 3.7399- 25'00, ANorney Generrt / Mrs. Pame inq o on
The Cnpit at PL~ of , 77elin hAss ee , fj 39 3 99. /os-o, Cler k 17?r. CTan S. <dhe
20so benyton DRivK Tnlinhasseep F/ 3?399-095'á, AMCI to Cterk e,C The
Supreme surf , tur. Thamn s b. Unti , Soo 3èvfH Dunj J+ree f , TAtin hessee
23ŸŸ·1997 °n #3 dy & Ý , 2m
MKNME4 CHAp sHi, fi<t L.
CAc Hocin Cogn Â! To
f9M 3aut4e&tounfstoe.ory
Ccerrfzcarc of no p , ,ye,
7his û'urisdkflann j Brief has been hendwe,'ilen ,