Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Preface v
About the authors vii
Acknowledgments viii
List of figures and tables xxi
Introduction 1The parameters of legal research 2
The structure and form of legal information 2
Principles of jurisprudence : 4
The legal interplay between the Parliament and the courts 4
Structure and use of this Guide 5
PART I - THE AUSTRALIA-N LEGAL SYSTEM
1 The Research Problem 9LEARNING OBJECTiVES 9Legal problem solving 9EXAMPLE RESEARCH SCENARIO (ADAM V EVE) 10The MIRAT process : 11
1. The identification of the relevant (material) facts 11THE FACTS OF OUR RESEARCH SCENARIO PRESENTED
IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER 132. Identify the legal issues 13
THE ISSUES RAISED BY OUR RESEARCH SCENARIO 153. Identification and interpretation of the rules that govern
the legal issues 164. Application of the rules to the facts 185. Conclusion 19
Clarifying the legal issues 20
xiii
Initial list of search terms 20Legal dictionaries 20Legal encyclopaedias 23
Expanded Iist of keywords 31Search techniques 31CiTATION 32
2 The Law Online 33LEARNING OBJECTiVES 33Australian online legal research platforms 36
Legal Online 36LexisNexis AU 37CCH IntelliConnect 38
Online searching: some tips 39Boolean search 40
Proximity search 40
Phrase search 41
Truncation 41Field or segment search 42
Browsing 42
Research using the internet 44BarNet Jade ······ 45
Fee Fie Foe Firm Search ······ 46
WebLaw 46
Keeping current 46Findlaw Australia 47CCH 47
Washington & Lee Law School - Current Law Journal Content ···· 47Evaluating websites 47CiTATION 48
3 Leg'lslat'lve Mater"lal 49..............................................................LEARNING OBJECTiVES 49Definitions 51Types of legislative research ··············· 53Legislative databases 54
Government legislation websites ················· 551. How can I find legislation that deals with a particular topic? 56
Indexes 58
2. Where can I find an up-to-date, reliable copy of an Act? 60
F ' d' A t C t I 'I t' 60In Ing an c: urren egls a Ion ·· ·· .. ·
xiv A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
1THE RESEARCH PROBLEM
learning objectives1. Adopt a structured approach to legal problem solving.
2. Analyse a research problem for its key facts and issues.
3. Identify key search terms.
4. Effectively use legal reference tools to gain an overview of a topic.
5. Prepare citations for legal encyclopaedias.
A research problem presents the law student or lawyer with a set of issues, whether
they are factual or legal, which require further analysis and information gathering, in
order to resolve the problem in the context of the law. The methodology of approach
to the research problem is more commonly known as legal problem solving, and is
what law students practice as they learn and apply the law to factual scenarios set
in an assignment or exam. This is academic engagement in replicating the type of
legal problems which confront legal practitioners in their work environment. That
is, the analysis of a set of facts wh ich trigger one or more legal issues, and the
resolution of the issues, through the analysis and application of the relevant law to
the particular facts presented.
legal problem solving
In its simplest form, legal problem solving essentially involves five basic steps.
1. Identification of the relevant facts
2. Identification of the legal issues
3. Identification and interpretation of the rules that govern the legal issues
4. Application of the rules to the facts
5. Conclusion.
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 9
A number of models have been developed to assist with the process of legal problem
solving, including the MIRAT,1 ILAC, IRAC and HIRAC models. They all reflect the
five step approach listed above, with varying emphasis on the fact finding stage as
discreet in itself, or as a component of the legal issue identification process. The
"Application" stage is alternately referred to as "application and argument" and is
perhaps the most intellectually rigorous and important stage of the entire process.
It represents the synthesis of your research on the law and the application of the law
to the facts, presented in argument in support of a particular position. It requires
a mastering of the art of legal discourse, something which is beyond the scope
of this Guide, although we do provide initial guidance on the approach to legal
argument. Importantly, the MIRAT approach to legal problem solvi ng is a process
that is applied to each issue raised in a legal problem, not the composite legal
problem itself. Each issue has its own facts, rules, interpretation and application
to be considered.
Table 1.1: Legal problem solving models
MIRAT IRAC ILAC HIRAC
Material Facts Heading
Issues of law and policy Issue Issues Issue
Rule Rule Law Rule
Arguments/Application I Appl ication I Argument Appl icationI
Tentative conclusion Conclusion Conclusion Conclusion
In this chapter, we introduce a research scenario to illustrate the legal problem
solving process. The particular focus of this Guide is upon the third step - the
identification of the rules that govern the legal issues. To this end, we instruct
you in the information resources and search strategies employed to find the law,
predominately in the online legal information environment, but also with reference
to relevant print resources. A number of alternative sources and databases are
introduced, covering Australian and foreign jurisdictions. This focus upon the
location of the rules that govern the legal issues is supplemented by a demonstration
of legal argument in the preliminary application of the law to the facts of the
research scenario.
EXAMPLE RESEARCH SCENARIO (ADAM V EVE)
You have commenced a Summer Clerkship with a mid-sized family law firm,
where you have been asked by the senior partner to research the law with
L Wade, "Meet MIRAT: Legal Reasoning Fragmented into Learnable Chunks" (1990-91) 2 LegalEducation Review 283. Revised version reprinted as Appendix C in J H Farrar, Legal Reasoning
(Lawbook Co., 2010).
10 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
respect to the right of a parent to unilaterally relocate a child to anothercountry from their normal country of residence.
Client file:Adam is a consultant engineer who works in the oil and gas industry. Heand Eve have been married 10 years and have two children aged 6 and
8. Both children were born in Australia. For the past two years the family
has lived in the United Kingdom (UK) where Adam bases his international
consultancy. He earns an excellent income and his work frequently requires
travel to Europe.
Since living in the UK Eve has missed her home and family, however Adam
was born in the UK and has a wide family network there. The move to the UKwas originally to be for a two year period only, however demand for Adam's
services and the attractive income he brings in has meant that they decided
to stay on for at least a further two years. Six months ago they purchased
a beautiful home in Datchet, Berkshire, where they had been renting, and
where the children have been attending a local school.
Eve has been unhappy in the UK, and decided to take the children back
to Australia for a one month visit at the end of the English school year.
However Eve and the children did not return on the date set for return,
1 September 2009, and it appears they have moved in with Eve's parents
into their comfortable home in the Eastern Suburbs of Adelaide. Adamhas just learned that Eve has obtained a position as a HR consultant for a
defence company based in South Australia and does not intend to return to
the UK. The children have been enrolled into a private school near the home
they share with Eve's parents.
Adam has flown back to Australia for an extended Christmas break with his
family and seeks your advice on the return of the children to the UK.
The MIRAT process1. Identification of the relevant (material) facts
The identification of the relevant facts, that is, facts material to the working
of the law, is an important skill. Legal problems presented to the law studentor practitioner may contain many superfluous facts which are of no relevance.
However it is not always a simple task to recognise a relevant fact. As you become
more familiar with the substantive law you will become more adept at recognising
the relevant facts in conjunction with the constituent elements of the legal rules
which comprise the applicable law. For example, the constituent elements of the
law of (or rule about) negligence, comprise a duty of care, breach of that duty, anddamage as the result of the breach. An understanding of each element of a legal
rule helps to inform you as to the relevancy of particular facts. Further research
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 11
into the law alerts you to exceptions to a rule and nuances of degree in relation
to each required element, thus leading you to identify further facts which you
might previously have not thought material to the problem. Legal problem solving
is therefore not a strictly linear process. 2
The differentiation of material facts from the legal issues which surround the facts
may not be a straightforward process. Facts and legal issues are often intertwined,
in that there are direct or indirect legal implications implicitly attached to a fact.
For example, John was driving a car and was found to have a blood alcohol
reading below that of the prescribed concentration of alcohol.
This is a simple statement of fact, or is it? Is it really complete in that we have all
the facts relevant to the question of John's legal right to drive a car? What form, if
any, of driver's licence is held by John? If John holds a provisional driver's licence,
this may require that while driving, he has no concentration of alcohol in his blood.
There are legal implications aligned to many so-called simple facts, therefore the
factual analysis required at this stage is very much preliminary to the identification
of the legal issues.
As the example above illustrates, the facts might not be clear or facts might be
missing. Missing facts should be acknowledged, and as far as they change the legal
consequences, you must address the facts and consequences for each alternate
scenario when you reach the stage of applying the law to the facts.
For example, It is not known if John holds a provisional drivers licence,
however if he does then he has committed an offence under the Road Traffic
Act.3 But if John holds a full driver's licence and his blood alcohol reading
is below the prescribed concentration of alcohol, he is not in breach of the
law.
Facts might be implied from the circumstances, but take care not to assume facts.
The facts might even be difficult facts in that they resonate with moral or ethical
issues. Although there may be no specific legal consequences attendant on what
makes the fact difficult, it poses a dilemma of a sort for the legal adviser.
Genera I poi nts to note in respect of the facts are su mmarised as follows:
• Iist the facts
• facts shou Id be ordered into a logical or chronological order
• each fact should sit discretely on its own
• the facts should be complete
2 For further guidance on legal analysis and problem solving, see: J H Farrar, Legal Reasoning (LawbookCo., Pyrmont, 2010), Pt 11; B Wolski, Skills, Ethics and Values for Legal Practice (2nd ed, LawbookCo., Pyrmont, 2009), Ch 4; M C Brogan and D Spencer, Surviving Law School (Oxford University
Press, South Melbourne, 2004), Ch 5.3 Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA), or other similar State Act.
12 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
• missing facts should be acknowledged insofar as they change the legal
consequences.
A useful way to determine the facts is through asking questions starting with "What,
Who, When, Where, Why, and How".4 There are variations to these questions
depending on the research problem, and not all questions will be applicable to all
problems, however, examples are:
• What happened, and what is the desired outcome?
• Who was responsible for the event, and to whom did it happen?
• When did the event happen?
• Where did the event happen?
• Why did the event happen?
• How did the event happen?
THE FACTS OF OUR RESEARCH SCENARIO PRESENTED INCHRONOLOGICAL ORDER
• Adam and Eve have been married 10 years and have 2 children
• The family has been residing in the UK for the past 2 years where Adam's
consultancy is based
• The children are Australian born and have been attending school in the
UK
• Eve returned to Australia with the children for a short holiday and has
decided not to return to the UK
• Eve has obtained a job in Australia and the children have been enrolled
into school
• Adam would like the family to return to the UK
2. Identify the legal issues
The extraction of possible legal issues from a given set of facts is an art to be
mastered. It requires a combination of legal knowledge and analytical and lateral
thinking skills, and lies at the heart of legal research.
Legal research requires a combination of factual knowledge and higher-level
intelligence. Factual knowledge involves recognition of objects, activities,
and locations. A higher level of intelligence enables the researcher to
create, manipulate, and apply abstract concepts to the given facts. High
level perception involves recognition of relationships and abstract ideas and
concepts. It draws meaning out of objects, activities, and locations. This type
of insight allows the researcher to think in the abstract, recognizing patterns
4 See T Simpson, Win More Cases: the Lawyer's Too/kit (Serenson, 2008) and companion website athttp://www.win-more-cases.com/for an excellent step-by-step guide to this process.
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 13
in the facts, issues, and primary sources and regrouping them to recognize
new patterns. The researcher may recognize similarities, distinctions, and
relationships. Out of these patterns, insight may allow the researcher to
notice analogies and build abstract conceptual legal frameworks. 5
In some areas of law this might involve, in part, early recognition of the harm done
or the remedy sought. For example, in torts, if you establish that the harm done
amounts to the total restraint of a person's liberty, you are directed to the tort of
false imprisonment and the rules which make out this tort. Similarly, you might
recognise a contract to be void if a party enters into a contract with another to sell
an interest in a company, under the threat of murder if they refuse to sell. 6
At this stage, issue identification need not be overly specific. As you research
further into the legal rules that govern the issues, you will have the opportunity to
refine the questions initially raised. Early recognition of possible issues raised by
the facts also requires a contextual analysis of the issues. For example, a cause
of action such as false imprisonment might arise in both the civil law of tort and
as a criminal law action. You need to decide early on in your research the relevant
context of the action, often determined by the remedy that you seek. You will
also need to begin to address the question of whether the issue concerns State or
federal law, or both.
A legal problem will frequently comprise more than one issue. As outlined earlier,
each issue has its own facts, rules, interpretation and application to be considered.
However, as you research further into the law the resolution of some of the issues
initially raised might be a simple matter not requiring detailed research. This occurs
when the issue relative to the facts and the law is reasonably certain; therefore
little analysis and argument is required. The major issues of your research problem
become the difficult or grey areas of the law, relative to the facts. This may be
because of problems attendant on the facts as provided, or because the law is
uncertain or arguable, or a combination of these factors. The more difficult issues
become the issues upon which you need to focus most of your research effort.
The legal issues should be stated in the form of a question, so focusing your
attention on providing an answer.? This simple method directs you to answering the
issues which arise in the problem to arrive at a conclusion. As the law is frequently
concerned with the rights and liabilities of parties, it is often useful to approach
the framing of the issues in terms of possible rights and liabilities.
5 C M Sast, R C Pyle, "Legal Research in the Computer Age: A Paradigm Shift?" (2001) 93 LawLibrary Journal 285, 296.
6 Void for duress: Barton v Armstrong [1973] 2 NSWLR 598.7 Simpson, above n 4.
14 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
For example, Is John liable for any offence under the Road Traffic Act8 if he
holds a provisional driver's licence and his blood alcohol reading is below
the prescribed concentration?
THE ISSUES RAISED BY OUR RESEARCH SCENARIO
• Does Eve have a legal right to unilaterally relocate the children?
• Do Eve's actions constitute abduction of the children?
• Have Adam's parental rights been infringed by Eve's actions?
• What are the rights of the children?• In what country does the law recognise that the children regularly
resided?
• Does the law of the United Kingdom or Australia apply?
Fact and issue identification are skills to be learnt and refined through continual
practice. From this process the key concepts and associated terms relevant to
the problem can be distilled. These terms can then be used in your initial search
queries of key secondary sources, such as legal dictionaries, encyclopaedias,
commentary services9 and texts. Early identification of relevant key terms is
particularly important given the prominence of online sources of legal information,
which frequently require a keyword search approach to retrieving information.
The relevant facts might be briefly distilled to the following terms:
Country of residence; Parent and child; Removal of children;
International relocation
From your knowledge of the law, you may be able to identify the broad legal topics
which relate to the issues on a general level in the terms set out below. If you
cannot identify any broad legal topics at this stage, return to your research problem
and revise the facts and issues once more, or conduct a preliminary search of a
legal reference information source lO using some of the facts or issues you have
identified as your search terms.
Family law; Child abduction; Relocation; Custody of children;
Parental control; Rights of the child
8 Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA), or other similar State Act.9 "Commentary services" includes what were previously known as loose-leaf services. See Chapter 5.10 A discussion on clarifying legal issues using legal reference sources is set out later in this chapter
under the heading "Clarifying the legal issues".
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 15
3. Identification and interpretation of the rules that govern the legalissues
The rules make up the law on the matter and may comprise precedent, (including
statute or case law), legal principle or policy. For legal rules manifest in a number
of guises, and are to be found not only in statute or case law, but might require
the extraction of principles found within the common law. ll Recourse to policy is
a further level of abstraction of legal authority, where "legal precept, precedent,
authority and past principles offer an insufficient guide to solve a new problem in a
just way", and requires the evaluation of choices. 12 Yet it may also be argued that
the application of case or statute precedent also requires the evaluation of choice
in applying a theory, principle or value. 13
These rules both scope the law and provide authority for the law. The authoritative
law is then recognised as arising from precedent, principle or policy, and the scope
of the law determines the particular elements which make up a legal rule. Enright
classifies these rules into elements and consequences. 14 For example, the elements
of the law on what constitutes a legal marriage are:
• The union of a man and a woman
• To the exclusion of all others
• Voluntarily entered into• For Iife. 15
If all the elements are made out then a legal marriage exists. If not all the elements
are made out, then the marriage is not legally recognised in Australian law. The
consequences attendant on this lack of recognition are wide reaching. This is a
simple example of an aspect of the law which is relatively straightforward, although
questions still arise - for example, what of the issue of transgender in respect of
recognition of sex? Is a man who has undergone sexual realignment as a woman,
recognised under the law of marriage as being a woman?16
Therefore, just as facts resonate with issues which develop as we ask more questions
of the facts, so too, the legal rules become less straightforward as we seek to define
the parameters of each rule.
11 'See, for example, M D Kirby, Judicial Activism - Authority, Principle and Policy in the Legal Method(Hamlyn Lectures, 2003) (Sweet & Maxwell, 2004); M H McHugh, "The Judicial Method" (1999)
73 Australian Law Journal 37.12 See n 11. A clear illustration of the distinction between the application of authority, principle and
policy is provided in the reasoning of the High Court in Cattanach v Melchior(2003) 215 CLR l.13 M H McHugh, "The Judicial Method" (1999) 73 Australian Law Journal 37.14 See especially, C Enright, Legal Skills (Branxton Press, Sydney, 2006).15 Marriage Act 1961 (Cth) s 5(1). The common law definition of marriage was enacted into statute by
the Marriage Amendment Act 2004 (Cth).16 Re Kevin: Validity of Marriage of Transsexual (2001) 165 FLR 404.
16 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
Both identifying the rules and obtaining guidance on the meaning of the rules, are
important aims of legal research and form the main focus of this Guide. That is,
the identification of the law and the attendant interpretation of that law, using the
legal research resources with which you need to become familiar. We provide an
introduction to the nature of legal information and the process of legal research
with the aim to instruct you in the skills and techniques required for you to
efficiently locate the relevant law. The following chapters use the research scenario
introduced earlier to illustrate this process.
Proficiency at identifying the relevant legal rules requires the efficient use of legal
research tools and the critical analysis of the information you retrieve. The skills
involved can be identified as follows:
• a focus upon the issues and context of the research problem
• the early identification of relevant search terms
• an understanding of search syntax (how to employ your search terms)17
• an understanding of the nature of primary and secondary sources of legalinformation 18
• the ability to evaluate legal information for relevance and authority
• the identification of the best authority for a legal rule
• the ability to synthesise the results of your research.
The ability to evaluate legal information for relevance and authority is a skill which
develops as you build both your understanding of the substantive law and your
legal analytical skills. This evaluation also requires a sound understanding of our
legal system, the judicial hierarchy and the doctrine of predecent which all bear
on the question of the authority for the legal rules you use. Such discussions are
beyond the scope of th is book however there are many excellent texts on these
foundation aspects of our legal system. 19
Some additional handy hints when searching for the relevant law:
1. How do you research the law effectively?
• Work quickly but not at the expense of being thorough
• Generally progress from broad concepts to the specific
• Read the relevant primary material (case and statute law), and do not rely
solely upon digests and commentary
• Record your research methodology and take notes as you go
• Think laterally
17 See Chapter 2, The Law Online, for discussion of search syntax.18 See Introduction for discussion on the classification of primary and secondary sources of law.19 For example, C Cook et ai, Laying Down the Law (7th ed, LexisNexis Butterworths, Chatswood,
2009); E Ellis, Principles and Practice of Australian Law (2nd ed, Lawbook Co., Sydney, 2009);R A Hughes, G W G Leane, A Clarke, Australian Legal Institutions: Principles, Structures andOrganisation (2nd ed, Thomson, Sydney, 2003); R Hinchy, The Australian Legal System: History,Institutions and Method (Pearson Education, Frenchs Forest, NSW, 2008).
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 17
• Always check competing sources against each other
• Near enough is NEVER good enough!
2. What if you cannot find any specific law on the issue?
• Rethink your approach to the problem by reviewing the facts
• Change your search terms
• Broaden your search parameters
• Even consider the possibility that there may be very little by way of primary
law or analysis on the matter in Australia
• Try finding similar law in a comparative jurisdiction such as the UK.
3. When to stop?
• Time constraints
• When you are learning nothing new
• When you keep returning to the same case and statute law authorities
• When you are directed to the same commentaries.
4. Application of the rules to the facts
This stage principally concerns the development of your skills in legal reasoning
and argumenPO These skills come into play when you seek to apply the law to
the facts of the matter, examine the issues, canvass the arguments and counter
arguments and provide a conclusion. It is an extremely important step in mastering
the legal research process and is one upon which you should concentrate early in
your student life.
The law is not always simple or clear. 21 Where it is so, for example the straightforward
application of a reasonably unambiguous statutory provision, or a similar fact
and issue case law precedent, the application of this authority to the facts in
determination of the legal outcome is relatively straightforward and predictable.
Where the statute or precedent does not offer direct authority, or is ambiguous,
recourse must be made, respectively, to statutory construction and the logic of
legal reasoning. Reasoning by analogy is the most common form of legal reasoning,
where we treat like cases alike, in that we look to facts, issues, precedent, principles
and policy adopted in a case to see if we can predict the outcome of the issue
confronting us, relative to earlier precedent. Thus, using reasoning by analogy we
might compare differences and distinguish22 a case. Other forms of reasoning
commonly adopted include inductive and deductive reasoning. Inductive reasoning
involves arguing from the specific principle or precedent to a general conclusion;
20 See, for example, B Wolski, Skills, Ethics and Values far Legal Practice (2nd ed, Lawbook Co.,Pyrmont, 2009), Ch 6; J Farrar, Legal Reasaning(Lawbook Co., 2010}; T Hutchinson, Research andWriting in Law(3rd ed, Lawbook Co., Pyrmont, 201O}; C Enright, Legal Technique (Federation Press,Annandale, 2002); R Krever, Mastering Law Studies and Law Exam Techniques (6th ed, LexisNexisButterworths, Chatswood, 2006).
21 If it were so, then the legal system we know might be replaced, in part, with expert systems in law.22 See Chapter 4, Case Law.
18 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
deductive reasoning involves arguing from the general principle or precedent to a
specific concl usion. 23
To ensure your legal reasoning is both logical and transparent, so that your reader
can follow the arguments presented, it is important to first be clear about the
nature of the legal rule applied. The identification of not only the applicable legal
rule, but the form and authority for that rule, is crucial. For example, with reference
to our John and blood alcohol reading scenario, the form of the rule is statute law,
more specifically, the Road Traffic Act.
The application of the law to the facts therefore comprises a number of processes,
including:
• the specific identification of authority (statute or case precedent), principle or
policy as embodying a legal rule
• the identification of the best authority for a legal rule
• the construction or interpretation of a legal rule
• the identification of ambiguity in the construction of a legal rule
• the identification of conflicting rules, or conflict in the past reasoning and
appl ication of a legal ru le
• the logical and systematic application of fact to the legal rule
• the analysis of remedies.
This, in essence, becomes the structure of your argument. The reader is made
aware of the facts, the issues, the applicable law and the reasoning adopted to
argue the facts relative to the law. The legal world is full of examples of the direct
application of the law to the facts. Judges do it when they write their reasons for
decision; lawyers do it when they provide a legal opinion or advice; law students do
it when they address a legal problem in an assignment or exam.
Using the research scenario through this and the following chapters, we provide
illustrations of the application of the law to the facts and identify the authorities
which comprise the legal rules on the matter.
5. Conclusion
Effective legal writing requires you to argue the law and come to a conclusion no
matter how difficult the problem is to resolve. This is done by focussing on the
strengths and weaknesses of the facts relevant to all the elements of the law. It
also requires clear acknowledgment of the difficulties that the law may present, for
example, through uncertain rules, so that your conclusion is coherent and can be
followed. The conclusion is where you also address the remedy once again so that
the applicable outcome sought is clearly defined.
23 See, for example, Lord Atkin's discussion of the neighbour principle in Donoghue v Stevenson [1932]
AC 562, 580-581.
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 19
Clarifying the legal issues
Indiallist of search terms
From your identification of the legal issues in Step 2, an initial list of search terms
was compiled. These, along with any identified synonyms, will be a useful start for
your early research. There are a number of techniques for brainstorming search
terms, one of which is the "Cartwheel of terms".24 This involves placing your topic
in the centre of the diagram (wheel) and placing alternative terms around it under
headings such as broader terms, narrower terms, synonyms, antonyms, closely
related terms, agencies and courts, and procedural terms.
Some of the key terms for our example research scenario that we have identified
so far are:
• Family law
• International relocation
• Rights of the child; Children's rights
• Parental rights; Parental control; Custody
• Child abduction; Removal of children
• Country of residence.
Gaining a proper understanding of the legal terms encountered in the initial stages
of research is vital. So too is understanding the contexts within which these legal
concepts operate and acknowledgment of any related legal issues that arise. For
this reason, as well as to identify leading cases and applicable legislation, it is
useful to begin your research with secondary sources of information,25 such as:
• Legal dictionaries
• Legal encyclopaedias.
Legal dictionaries
A legal dictionary helps to clarify a term, place it in its legal context, and provides
related concepts and keywords. There may also be references to key cases or
legislation. A keyword search of a library catalogue using the terms law dictionarieswill lead you to the dictionaries held at your library. These might include:
• Butterworths Concise Australian Legal Dictionary26
• Oxford Companion to Law?
• Osborn's Concise Law Dictionary28
• Mozleyand Whiteley's Law Dictionary.29
24 Hutchinson, above n 20, p 88.
25 Although this is very much dependent upon the legal knowledge you already hold.26 Butterworths Concise Australian Legal Dictionary (3rd ed, LexisNexis Butlerworths, Chatswood,
2004).
27 D M Walker, The Oxford Companion to Law (Oxford University Press, New York, 1980).28 Osborn's Concise Law Dictionary (llth ed, Thomson Sweet & Maxwell, London, 2009).
29 Mozeleyand Whiteley's Law Dictionary (12th ed, Butlerworths, London, 2001).
20 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
One useful online dictionary is the Encyclopaedic Australian Legal Dictionary(EALD) available on the Australian LexisNexis (LNAU) platform.3D This is a
searchable database of legal definitions supported by Australian legislative
and judicial authority which includes jurisprudential and criminological terms,
explanations of well-known rules and principles of law, international law terms,
treaties and conventions, translations of legal Latin language, descriptions of
landmark decisions of the High Court of Australia, and biographical entries.31
o At LexisNexis AU, the dictionary can be found by clicking Dictionaries
on the top tool bar.
o At the search form, under Sources, select the Encyclopaedic Australian
Legal Dictionary.
o Start with one of the identified issues (above); "child abduction".
o Type child abduction into the Defined Terms box.
o The results include a definition of the phrase as input, as well as for
"international child abduction", and the Child Abduction Convention
(international treaty).
o Click on the definition of "child abduction" and you will find the
definition is associated with two aspects of the law, the first concerning
family law matters, the second, alluding to abduction as an offence
where the victim is a child. Note that the broad area of law is identified
as Family law.
Child abduction
Definition = "In family law matters, the taking or retention of a child in breach of the
custody rights of another person": Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss 64 and IIIB.
Points to note:
• The issues arise in the context of family law, so this definition is immediatelyon point.
• The terminology used is important, note "taking or retention of a child" and
"breach of custody rights". These phrases are important in two respects. They
lead us to the specific elements of the offence of child abduction and introduce
two further key legal terms.
• Authority (primary source authority) for the definition is provided in thereferences to ss 64 and IIIB of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).
In addition to the definition of child abduction, the EALD cites further authority in
the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction 1980
30 See Chapter 2 for an introduction to LexisNexis AU.31 Taken from the LexisNexis source information.
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 21
(the Convention) which is described as an international agreement "relating to the
return of children wrongly removed or retained across international borders". The
issue therefore concerns authority from both domestic and international law.32
Figure 1.1: Defi nition from the Encyclopaedic Australian Legal Dictionary
Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction 1980
See also Abduction; Access; Child; Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989; Custody;Intematlonal chIld abductloniKidnap; Municipal law; Pnvatc Intematlonal hw.
The EALD then proceeds to describe the elements of the legal concept or offence
of child abduction under the Convention.
A person who has a right of custody of a child, who has been removed from
one convention country to another or is wrongfully retained, can apply for an
order for the return of the child.
person with a right of custody of the child
child is removed from one convention country to another, or
is wrongfully retained in a convention country
application for an order for return of the child
Element 1
Element 2
Consequence
An International agreement relating to the return of children wrongly removed or retaIned across International borders,sIgned In the Hague on 25 October 1980, and sponsored by the Hague Conference on Private lnternatlonal Law. TheConvention entered Into force for Australia on 1 January 1987 and IS Implemented by the (CTH) Family Law (ChildAbductIon Convention .. RegulatIons 1966: tCTH) Family Law Act 1975 s 1118 Its purpose 15 to dIscourage the unilateralremoval or retention of children Internationally, and to secure the prompt return of children wrongfully remov€d from orletalned III any slale Director-General of FamIly jJnd Communit.y Services (NSW) v Dav/5 (1990) 14 Fam LR JS1 ; FLC~92-182 . A person who has a right to custody of a Child, who has been removed from one Convention country toanother or IS wrongfully retained, can apply for an order for the return of the child. the court must order the retum ofthe child forthwith unless It IS sabsfied that: th person complainIng has consented to the removal or retention; there IS
a grav~ nsk that the chIld's return would expose the child to physical or psychologIcal harm; the child being of suffiCientmaturity, objects to bEing retumed; or return would be contrary to Australian prinCiples of human rights: (CTH) FamilyLaw (Child Abduction Convention) Regulations 1986 reg 16(3:. ApproXImately 60 countnes are signatories: reg 10. Sch 2Also kno'fin as Hague Convention on the Ovd Aspects of IntematJonal Child Abducoon 1980.
You also need to address any legal exceptions or defences to the offence of child
abduction. These exceptions and defences are also set out in the EALD.
The court must order the return of the child forthwith unless it is satisfied
that: the person complaining has consented to the removal or retention; there
is a grave risk that the child's return would expose the child to physical or
psychological harm; the child being of sufficient maturity, objects to being
returned; or return would be contrary to Australian principles of human rights.
Defence 1 Person applying for return of the child originally consented to
the removal or retention
Defence 2 grave risk of physical or psychological harm to the child if
returned
Defence 3 child objects to being returned and is of sufficient maturity for
objection
Defence 4 return of child contrary to Australian principles of human rights
32 See Chapters 10 and 11 for researching private (known as "Conflict of laws") and public internationallaw.
22 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
Each element and defence making up the rules of child abduction raises further
questions:
• What does a right of custody amount to?
• What is a convention country?
• What is wrongful retention or wrongful removal?
• To what authority is an application for return of the child made and what are the
specific requirements of the application?
• What constitutes consent to removal or retention of the child?
• What amounts to grave risk of physical or psychological harm?
• When is a child's objection to return taken into consideration?
• What are or where would we find the Australian principles of human rights?
Many of these questions should be answered with reference to primary sources
of authority and the EALD cites some of this authority, namely the Family LawAct 1975 (Cth), the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child
Abduction 1980 and the Family Law (Child Abduction Convention) Regulations1986 (Cth). Reference should also be made to any case law which interprets and
appl ies provisions and articles of the legislation and Convention.
The dictionary reference source is, however, only a preliminary step in understanding
the legal rules relating to child abduction. It is a synopsis and guide only and
cannot replace the primary source authority in setting out all the specifics of the
offence, exceptions and defences, particularly as it does so outside the context of
other requirements of the legislation and Convention.33
Legal encyclopaedias
Legal encyclopaedias provide commentary on the current state of the law. They
are arranged systematically by topic, and contain case and statute law authorities
in support of the propositions of law. For the law student they are particularly
useful as they succinctly summarise leading issues. However, remember that they
are secondary sources and that the law cited may not be completely up-to-date,
making it essential to verify and update the primary sources cited. There are two
Australian legal encyclopaedias, both of which are available in print and online:
1. Halsbury's Laws of Australia (LexisNexis)
2. The Laws of Australia (Thomson Reuters).
Halsbury's Laws of Australia
Halsbury's Laws of Australia provides statements of principle on the law of Australia
through 89 subject titles. It is available in print and online via LexisNexis AU. Most
LexisNexis AU publications provide both browse and search options.
33 For example, a specific procedural requirement of the application for return of a child wrongfullyremoved, requires that the application be made within one year of the child's removal: Family Law(Child Abduction Convention) Regulations 1986 (Cth) reg 16(1 Hb).
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 23
D Log on to the LexisNexis AU homepage
o Click the button for Commentary, and then select Halsbury's Laws ofAustralia from the Sources drop-down menu.
o For a search, click the Search option and in the Search terms box, type
in child abduction.
SEARCH OPTION
Figure 1.2: Search results from Halsbury's Laws of Australia on LexisNexis AU with
Table of Contents (left menu) showing Title location
,-------,1'.
J 701/
Sourcl!! & locatlOf'l
...",kbt;ryo; I "nO; (If A.t.rttr~·a 7 Otl,..nshr ~ ""Jr.;Jt'::icn: ]PAS~PORT5 ~B. !SSuf l P,aiSPQi'ts
Halsburys l.a.-.s of Auslral,OI. 8S - Conflict of uws: 1 GENERAl \,2OOMlCILE, RESiDENCE ANO NATIOl'OALm B Ra~"c.
_;l __'!!f1 a c .!'"..IY tI'd~ unC~f tI1~ :CT'"l l::dI'!ll'" la.... C""1d AbdI.Ktk)!"I CO'h!?l'1t.('I t'I!Oul<!ltIO'lS 198'S. '5 A
con~~"'tcr OUr'ltr., P"''''''·l!'! ttle chtr. o'
S;_ rhoP.se c(")u..-t,,4''I an" i1s~"d 11 the {OH Fam"r law (Cnlkl ANiucbQn Cc"',,'!'ntl(lfl' RP!J'Jlanons 1986 S<l't 2 Tht'!po ~I '5 (;Q'Ll$t~r,t ".,VI
r TItle
r 1 1 ",Y::P?I'-;...f .l>I~ of Co"lenb
H,. ".'_'S!~',,'~
fie~t-fJlltftaloof5~
- ... l_klP"f 1t_·(cmI~se/llcM:~~do
When searching or browsing legal encyclopaedias it is especially important that you
are aware of the relevant context of law being researched. For example, in Halsbury's
Laws ofAustralia, a search for the phrase "child abduction" provides a range of results
pulled from the subject areas (Titles) of Family Law, Contempt, Foreign Relations,
Citizenship and Migration and Conflict of Laws. Search results specify the source
and location of the paragraph within the topic arrangement of the encyclopaedia
therefore providing important contextual information. We can see below that an area
of law relevant to our research problem is Title 85 "Conflict of Laws".
of rh.. t1"9'j.@ ( l)('h''''ltlon on th. CI",~ Allp..ct.!i of lnt""matlonal child AbductIOn 1980,J I1 h,ltS ~en held t:tw;t ,It
hk1 may. \oil 3 HdiJU<i! C<lflVlOl1tlon on tne c ... li Aspec.ts of l'1t..rndtK>nal Chl/d Abduc,t,op 1980 ($';)Il..d at Tt.... H.l9'-'@ 04'l 25
0-, tob.,r 1080 Impl4~ted
r.,. [P(;)C"'~,1'rl<J" In F<E'I'ltiN' ~() rh;> \'<"Ifarf> of Halsbuys lafi$ 01 A~lStr",ha SS - COf'llk:r of l'W~ 11 CHOICE OFC.f"uiCr.,.n LAW: {I> FA.MllY LAW ,E PrOC9'!d!ngs In R.elauon to the welfare
(;f :,..,,!,jr,~n
Lt\" U", HdoJue Cor'VO!pll()ll c,f\ t:,,~ C ... " A.,.p~, t:> ~,f !'ll",lllallondl (t,'l'j Abd;.J,t'!;1 TrIO! HaJ'" 2S OdLw,..r 1980,Al'st "T<~ l~&-; N
The results of a search on "child abduction" in Halsbury's reflects the results of
the encyclopaedic dictionary search; that the topic concerns both domestic (Family
Law Act 1975 (Cth)) and international law (Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects
of International Child Abduction 1980), with commentary focussing primari Iy upon
the Hague Convention.
24 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
BROWSE OPTION
Another option is to view the table of contents in the Browse tab, although this
requires an understanding of where relevant information is filed in the Topic
arrangement. Halsbury's Laws of Australia has a "Quick Find" option on the Browse
screen which searches the entire database, not just the Topic titles. The Search
option used in the example above, does however allow you to limit your database
search to a specific Title/s, for example, Conflict of Laws. .
o For the browse view, click the Browse link and follow this path, opening
the + signs as you go to find more specific subtitles, chapters etc.
85 Conflict of Laws> 11 Choice of Law> (1) Family Law> (E) Proceedings
in Relation to the Welfare of Children
Within each Title, the text is organised by numbered paragraphs [indicated by square
brackets] for ease of cross-referencing and updating. Each paragraph number has
two components; the first number represents the Title (Subject category) within
which the paragraph is located (for example, 85 is the number allocated to the
Conflict of Laws Title), the second number indicates the numerical position of that
paragraph within the Title.
o Click on [85-1040] Abduction of children: Hague Convention, to go to
the text of the paragraph.
o Scroll down to view the Notes referred to. These notes identify cases
and legislation. Links are provided where the materials are subscribed
to within LexisNexis AU. Coloured signals next to the cases indicate the
status of the case. 34
o Note the date at the top of the paragraph which indicates when the
paragraph is current to in terms of the law.35 It is extremely important to
update the primary sources.36
34 Case Signals are explained in more detail in Chapter 4, Case Law.35 The paragraph is current to 17 July 2006 when viewed on 29 April 2010.36 See Chapters 3, Legislative Material and 4, Case Law.
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 25
Figure 1.3: Commentary text and Notes section from Halsbury's Laws of Australia
[85-1040) Abduction of children: Hague Convention Under the terms of the Hague Convention on the Civil Asp~cts ofInternational Child Abduction 1980 ,the 'Convention' ,: "'her02 Cl person, Institution or body claims to hav"? custody, underthe lavv In force In Australia, of a child removed from Australia to Cl Convention country2 or retained In Cl Convention
country, \'intten application may be made by the person, lnstltutlon or body ... hose nghts of custody have been Infnnged3
to a rEsponsible central authonty '" to have the claim transmitted to the central authontv of the Con'-Jentlon country In.',hlCh the child had been taken or reta;ned.~ The central authontv of Australta. on recoa~pt of an applicatlon reiatlng to Clchild removed or retained to b.ustraha must, If satisfied N1th the application, end-:a'Jour to take actJc,n undi?r theConventlon to secure the return of thE child .;.
In Australia, the central authOrity, or a person, an lnstlt:uuon or another bOOI that has nghts of C\Jstoov In rela Ion to thechild or the purposes of the Convention, may apply to a court ha"ng Junsd,ct,on under ,h~ CTH Family La" Act 1975 forord~rs for the return of the child, for the Issue of Cl ~"t'arrant to find and fo?cover the child 'IncludIng authonsa on In senous
and urgent cases to enter and search premIses and to stop, enter and search a vehicle, vessel or 3Ifcraft)/ restraIningth~ removal of the child from a specified place, plaCing him or h~r With an appropriate person or Institution pendingd~temllOatlon, and applicant any other order th~ c~ntral authOrity considers appropriate to gl~~ effect to theConventlon.E If the court IS satisfied that the removal or ret'2ntlon IS wrongful. It must order the return of the child... Ithoul consideration of what the beSl Interests Of the child require,'; unless I IS satisfiEd that the case does not faU... Ithln the scope of the ConventJon;c or It has a discretion to decline the return of the child under one or more of thespeClftc grounds set out In the Ccnvennon. ~. If an applicatIOn for (he rEturn of the child IS filed after the explr)i of oneyear from the datE of removal or retemlon, and the person oppOSing tho? appl cation cannot establish that the child ISsettled In hiS or her ne ,'V Em,Ironment, :he court must make an order for the return of the child:: The pnnClple that the
b'?st Interests of the child IS the paramcunt cC',ns1deratlon does not applv to proco?o?dlngs undEr the Conventlon,:3 There ISno constitutional objection to returning a child who IS an Australian clbzen to the foreign country of the child's habitualresidence, 1..;
Notes
: "'h~ C::n."er:cl"l C~ :he C .... 11 A$ceet~::· Jf'te-r~tlc"'a, Cre .:::.bC:",ctlcr Th~ I-<~Qlle :S C=:::be" :;30: ':'ust T3 ~QE- No:: Cml"d S28~ .\55m;;l~me!"'ted b! the (CTH -:amd~ la.\ :hld .:.tdU~i~r. Cc'" er: Cf" ,eJu!at ::rs :<;56 m5::1e pU~5uaN:: \CT~ Fa!""" "La", .let :-=0"5 s 11 ..8"'/"e Cc"'~el"'t<:r er:e-ed lr~o fc"ce fer :".J5tra a Cl"! : Jaf'U!!I ..... : se-
.: In ;'uitraha the fu~etlcn5 ef the cent'.,:,l aut"'o~t-, a~e e)o:!:"C1sed by tt'e CcmmcnAealth Cent"a ':'utrc~lt'f "Ith-m tre Ccmmon...ealth Arrome"Gtne"~s depa'1:mefl: ~nd State -ard Te"ntory centr~1 ~uthcntles, {CTH Fl'mli .. La .... (C"IL:~ ~bdlJC:lcn Co!',,"'er:ICf'1 ~e9ulat:o"s :S86 "eos 5, eAI" appllc:atlcr, for tre retu? of a <:hlld mal a;s::: be T1ade directl." to ar ':'ustrahan c~urt; ibld reg 6_ See hr"!' M3rr3Je 0: Bdrr!C1ougr: (198 7 1
:.: Fam LR i73G; J"('I rne ~/arri5;e cfPtraya:.;es t:996,I:t Fan-: LR ':'~60
Search tip
If you know the area of law that you wish to search, but not the specific
legal principle, use the Browse screen to select the relevant title, eg Conflict
of Laws, then type more specific words into the Quick Find box. This will
eliminate some of the more irrelevant results.
The Laws of Australia
The Laws of Australia is available in print and online via Legal Online.37 Within this
encyclopaedia, subjects are arranged into 36 legal topics, therefore the headings
under which to look for legal principles are different to those in Halsbury's, For
example, unlike Halsbury's, the topic "Conflict of Laws" is not a Topic Title within
37 See Chapter 2 for an overview of Legal Online,
26 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
The Laws of Australia. The topic of "international child abduction" is located
within the "Family Law" title. If in doubt about which Topic headings to browse,
enter your phrase in the Find box at the top left of the screen.
SEARCH OPTION
The free text search option in The Laws of Australia allows you to search keywords
throughout the complete encyclopaedia. Other options include field searches
by Case or Legislation, Title (one of the Laws of Australia 36 Titles), Words and
Phrases (which might be a useful way to research the phrase "wrongful removal"
for example), or "Legal Principle" (which limits your search to the major statements
on the law appearing in bold text). As a general keyword search is your simplest
option it is often the most effective way to search, provided your search terms are
not too general.
The legal dictionary search has given us specific legal terms which accurately
describe some of the legal issues in the research problem scenario. A good way to
proceed with the legal encyclopaedia is to use some of these identified terms in
your search.
D Search for "wrongful retention" in the Free Text Search box, remembering
to use "double quotation marks" around your terms so the search is read
as a phrase.
D The search results are listed as legal principles (in bold) within which
your search terms may appear highlighted. If they are not highlighted the
search terms will appear in the commentary text which sits behind the
statement of legal principle. Selecting any of these principles will then
display the full text summary on the statement together with authorities.
Also appearing in the results list is the classification string under which
the principle is categorised. This classification provides useful context to
the legal principle by noting which Topic and sub-category your results
are appearing within.
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 27
Figure 1.4: Search on "wrongful retention" in The Laws of Australia online
1·",rr3~
r TLA Title
There must be a wron9ful removal of a child from a Contraron9 State, or a rongful retention of a child In ar Contracting State, before the Ccn.efltu: on tne C,/ ASPEcts eF !n::e·'7lc:O~1 C ·d AOdlJC:Gf" (lnterroat,ona Ch"ld
AbdiJc~cn Con,'e.'l:c") (1980) 13~3 UNTS 89; 191U,( 1501, [1987J ATS 2 can be lnvoJ.':ed
• Family L~,,, :> I,~e~("atlcral Chld -toUc:tICI' :> IrH~"n.!ltlcral er-lid "baudlCI" COf',<el"'tIC!'" >- :17 S,3&O)
____'_,'_,C_'_'''-:--9"C'U_"_,Sd_OC_''_cr_'_G_e_''e_"_.' --------"C"C-------------- lr ~~~:~~:~:~ r~s~~:n~:r:;~sc:~na~~td:~~ltle one parent to resile unilaterally from an agreement to return to the country I I
• Faml".. La •.,." If':e'"!"'i!lttcral C'-'ild ~bduct!cr::. Irte-natlcral Chld ;.td",ctlcn C.::rll... ertlc .... ,.1I"' .... c<lng JU"'Sdt;::tCi ::> ;e.mCy·~1 al"ld =<.e·ertICi""
r A party cannot be said to have aCQUiesced unless he or she 15 a.\'are, at least In general terms, of hiS or her custodynghts against the other party
To perform a more specific search, click New Search at the top of the screen.
Din the Legal Pri nciple search box, type "chi Id abduction".
o Select Family Law from the TLA Title drop down box.
o Click Search.
• Fam " la :> l:':e~r'a,!cl""al Chld ':"bdu:t Cl" :;. lr:e: ratlcr'ai Chld _bd...::IICf' CCI"l'wef'tlcr- ::>.... IS--~ll= Ne: ,c O·rl~'" ;e.lu~'" ::> G~cuf'ds er; :.,..::J- Ccu~ Ha. te.fuse:= 8'"de ;'e,u'''::> :crser:C "':'rqu,escer. e
St-C,'Vlro dc::umerts '''CM 1 to 3 of total J ha
Figure 1.5: Search screen from The Laws of Australia online
~ Search The LaViS of A.ustralia for detailed legal principles
:: ~ e 5-:]
I
eg :8: 2
Leoal P'"lrclple I'·chlld abduC:IC~'
:.0"0::;' ard chra!.=e::.1
C••e N.,..,e Ir----------------------
Leg..l.t,on ITL-'- T";e Ir:F,.-.-m"""'-·."CL-.-,,------------------3..,
-L":' ca"a~"'apt-- rJumb~ -I
BROWSE OPTION
You can browse the topic titles of The Laws of Australia in a similar manner to
Halsbury's Laws of Australia. To return to our research scenario, we could check
under the Family Law title to see if any relevant material is there, or locate more
specific information in the browse option, by searching for any mention of "child
abduction" as a topic.
28 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
The subject titles can be browsed in the left frame by opening the folders and then
clicking on a heading to display a list of legal principles or propositions of law (in
bold) in the right frame.
o Browse the following title in The Laws of Australia
Family Law> International Child Abduction
Figure 1.6: Browsing Titles in The Laws of Australia, with legal principles displayed in
right panel
..
. >. ~ ;,- _l.,~t ,," ~ l;'
) '",,- -'';;'' """ r." ".y
• "",,,, I" '"'' '.. ""t~·"It,."~,, .., ~;"l,~ At.,~"(~,~,,,., "'l>:,.:~,o ~"'" l:l''!' ",,<\'"""~~,~'-',AI -·.'h(';~P""i! '
• 1"'.,.,1,, loll'''''' :"U:l'r-~~'''''lIi C~"!(,i Atdv,-w.l( ".1.,(1\"",,,,(, d Cl' Ij,,,,, "'''./l'" ':".p.~".~p~" ,:": ,se)'+~'~.-'~I\I '.'~,,!'I:,I'''''''''~
r• f"'.,,h uP. ~ :'-(l!".rtl ";'Il! C'-,ld ,:,tdv~v;" J"t"-,· ..,,,,~~, Ch' I~cl"ct>':f' C,,·,,~,..~,~·~ 1'1... ".... ~.,. ~ :.q
~f :~",·tl~"t<1 > ·.;~"e-~j
Each Legal Principle within the selected topic is listed sequentially by paragraph
number and is accompanied by the assigned classification/s. For example,
paragraph [17.8.10] has the classification:
Family Law> International Child Abduction> Introduction> Definition
When each level of the classification is selected, the relevant legal principles are
displayed in the right frame.
Din the right frame cl ick on the legal principle [17.8.10] to read a fu Iler
discussion of the principle, with links to related discussions, supported
by Australian case law, legislative and international law authorities.
o The commentary screen links to the full-text case law where subscribed
to via Legal Online with any legislative references linking to AustLlI.38
This information is also displayed below the commentary text in the
"Cases Cited" and "Legislation Cited" boxes.
38 The automatic linking to legislation on AustLlI is a preference setting. See Chapter 3 for findingonline legislation.
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 29
Search tip
Take note of the "Current as at" date at the top of the commentary screen
which advises on the currency of the information. This may alert you to
update the case law information provided with a further search in a more
current case law database such as FirstPoinP9 Legislative changes should
be updated in a relevant legislation database.4o
Figure 1.7: Paragraph from The Laws of Australia online
Cu....ent Searc~ »Tt,.:. Tde Fa!TlIl{ L~.\ > Inte'Teucnal Child ;lbdudicn > Irt'-oductlon > DefH"lbon
"International child abduction" occurs when a child is taken across the border of one COUlltry to another without the
consent of a person,: usually a parent, in contravention of a right which that person has in relation to custody of, oraccess to, that child. Tre means of enfo'-CIl'l9 a '-etur'r of the chld to the country ef ItS ongln HIli depend :)1"1 Nl'~tbe" the CCJn;:"les
"International child abduction" occurs when a child is taken across the border of onecountry to another without the consent of a person, usually a parent, in contraventionof a right which that person has in relation to custody of, or access to, that child.Farmly La .... > :nterfl3tlcnal et'lld ;;'bducttcn > IntrcdlJctlCf' > DefinitIon
In\d.. ec a"e contra~lrg t::artles :c the C~""'/e"~ =~ or ~he C ';1' As!:ec:s of I.,tern=t;a~a, Cr Id t.C.;""t,o,,: ';"':err:t :"0 C~ ,'; ~tj... ::t:"
CC-:''''~I''1~ C'1"1. l~~S:; ~3':; \.<·...-s 5?, ;.; ;~v ~5l'~ :~9.5;~· ~-s :' see :1.7,8 ::7)) - ::;' S 660] If bcth count,. es are cI"lt"aetll"lg ~a~les a
child (ude" the age of :6 years} ...ho has been removed or "etamed In contra,-entlon of custody "lghts mav be the subjEct of an
ode" that!'-e e" she be "e:U'l"'eO to the cour:"'Y of :lngu" fO'i:h.".lth Ir :"'ust"alld, the lnte"~et :l"Ji! C;",'.j At';... :t::1 :,;~.e'~:"l5
implemented by the ~~"!'" .. 1,.3~'" 'er :i :'td... :~,c'" Ccr:o'e>":t c", ~e-g",,·=t ,~s ~9SO (Cth)..3
TL~ ::, 3.::JC~ C.'.er JessEP ~:99~ - "C'~cfesscr Antt-ol"1{ 9lC(ef QC (:9S5
'::'Iexand~a Har!al"d
:.:: September 2C03
C:at~n·
TItle Edltcds):
Current Updatng ~~:hO"(Sl;
Current as at:
1- Comment.'Y I Tep
If the crdd IS raKe:n re Co' f~cm a ccunt')' .\hi:r IS rot a ccmractirg party to the I"tefTl<'~ 0"3 Cr 'd ACJu'::'c;" C:.rv~r: or t~e :d"'-:"
_s.'\' t.:: ~';-5 ~Ctr'l arc; the c:om'l1C" :a,\ "eiatl"';J to I'-;:e"ratlcr"i!! :h,'d abductors appl".L
1- Footnotes I Tep
8' n some .:ases ar" IrstlUtICr..::: :d" l ~~N 'Cr .'J 4ciu:tc"1 '::"" d"":,C"'l; R.eJi.I.!~C"lS 1;56 (Oh) "eg 2(1); Ccnventon C,,", the C -;;, 4s;e:ts cf :'1te;ne!t.c~~ C;",';
4t.:..J::'c" (j te ...r.3: ;'1-3 Cr.'I: 4ci",ct,c"'l ':c'we'"'t,c'1; ";9S0~ ~3';j 1..;,~,T5 S;, 19 £_M :5Dl,' ::;57~·A7"5:. A'1':' ....rcr IS ,ndudedm 1:3"";{)-' _3 ,'er ,,j t.b.:,",:~c"" (;::n;,en:o", ~=q,"';J: ''''S ~935, Set'! 1
3 Tre C~(l ..e"'~c",:;" t"e C / l.s~e:ts -;::F :":::f''''~tor3' C~~:: 4oi-.:::t on ':":::~""dt on3: (il,':! t.r:.:t ell C;;"l~e,,:~cr. (:;S~ ~j43 lo",-55; ;;.-_',' :.5:; :1 ;S~,: l..-S :. IS- lr:lude:a Ir :e-- ~ _c.\ 'C~,; ':'t~",=t,c" Cor.~"': C"~ ~e;v,:tcn5 ';;-55:CtI"). S~r- 1
Th; Jurlsdl~lcr ef tre Fam' v Ccu't d ':'ust"a a e:xterds :0 d chld urder tre age of :8 ye~"s; see :.:!'r' Ir ::J'Y l.et : 975 (Ctr)/ ss 51C\1" 65H{11 - (:)
1- e9"I.l:on Crted I Tep
Commonwealth- ::::"', ~dJ{,!.:t :975 s S1C.: ~s 65H'::' - (:- :;;~rr '/ d.v (':h ;j.:.t ;",.:~.;r ....-c "I/~"'~ cr:, Pe:J_~: c~s ; ,8:. ~e9 2(:)1 Scf'l 1
Treaties and Conventions• :'c('.e"~ c., C'1 ~"'e:.' .!.S;e=~S:;: :":e"~3~ ;;'"''= 2/0:· 'j t.t;...:' Jr" ';"ter-.3:ct"af':1'1 j .cb.;1>oJ::O'" Conler:: :;r. '~Y3:~ ~3':j v,.,r5 5; ~~
: ... ~5C, ;';~3;J' ~-:5:' ":''1-
39 See Chapter 4 for information on this case law database.40 See Chapter 3, Legislative Material.
30 A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO LEGAL RESEARCH
Expanded list of keywords
After checking the legal dictionaries and encyclopaedias, an expanded list of
keywords and concepts on this topic can be developed to assist with the next
stages of your research. You may have come up with some of the following terms
and phrases:
Family law, Private international law, Conflict of laws (broad areas of law)
Child abduction, International child abduction, Wrongful removal or
retention, Breach of custody
Right of custody, Consent
Grave risk of harm, Objection of child, Australian principles of human rights,
Best interests of the child, Paramount consideration
Convention country, Return order, Central authority, Country of habitual
residence
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss 64 and 111 B
Family Law (Child Abduction Convention) Regulations 1986 (Cth)
Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction
1980
Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989
You may also have come up with some cases to follow up, such as MW v Director
General, Department of Community Services.41
Search techniques
You should now start to think about how to group some of these terms together
using search techniques common to most databases. Search techniques vary
with the database being used, so it is a good idea to check the Help links for
each database. Some common connectors (also called Boolean connectors) and
search techniques are discussed in Chapter 2 (including a table which summarises
connectors used for a number of important legal databases).42
There are numerous variations you might begin with when entering your search.
A certain amount of trial and error is expected as you become familiar with the
requirements of particular databases. If a search fails or retrieves no results, go
back and check for spelling, incorrect symbols or the use of "reserved" characters
such as parentheses O. Some searches for our topic could include:
41 (2008) 244 ALR 205.42 Table2.1,seep43.
PART I: THE AUSTRALIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 31
"child abduction" AND "return order"
"wrongful removal" OR "wrongful retention"
Child! w/s custody AND "Hague Convention"
Keep in mind that you will usually need to go back and refine your search strategy
depending on the results you get. Too few results may mean that you need to
broaden your search or use alternative terms. Too many results may mean that you
need to add more specific terms to your search or limit your results in some way,
perhaps by date or jurisdiction.
('"+ lio
This section contains citations for some of the references found from searches
described in this chapter. Citations are constructed according to the Australian
Guide to Legal Citation, 3rd ed (AGLC3).43 Remember that there are various
ways to cite legal information, particularly for secondary sources and traditional
print sources now available online. Consistency is of prime importance, as is the
inclusion of sufficient information to enable the reader to locate the item.
Legal encyclopaedias
Where a legal encyclopaedia indicates the date of the last update, this date should
be included. Otherwise, the date of retrieval should be included.
LexisNexis Butterworths, Halsbury's Laws of Australia, (at 10 December
2009) 85 Conflict of Laws, 85 Conflict of Laws, '11 Choice of Law, (1) Family
Law, (E) Proceedings in Relation to the Welfare of Children' [85-1040].
Thomson Reuters, The Laws of Australia, (at 10 December 2009) 17 Family
Law, '17.8 International Child Abduction' [17.8.10).
43 Australian Guide to Legal Citation (3rd ed, Melbourne University Law Review, Melbourne, 2010).
~? 11. DDI\('TI('f\1 ('lllne TA I C'-" 1\ I nrC"'rAnl"11