8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

1/13

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

2/13Page 2

4. S,ssions Cs, No.1009 o" 200 ris,s o! o" FIR

No.159;200% r,gis!,r, ! P.S. M),r

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

3/13Page 3

++r,,nsion o! !, "irn,ss o" !, ++ro= 7i= !,

!ri# Cor! 86 o+! in i,7 o" !, "inings r,=or, in !,

or,r o" is=rg, ,r#i,r +ss, 6 ,r. T, =o8+#inn!

(++,##n! ,r,in$ ,@+r,ss, !,s, ",rs "irs! in T.P. (Cr#.$

No.41 o" 2014 "i#, ,"or, !, S,ssions Jg,3 Roini 7i=

7s is8iss, 6 !, si =or! 6 or,r !, 22 nM63

2014 o#ing !! sin=, no o!,r o""i=,r in Nor! ,s!

Dis!ri=! in D,#i s ,,n no!i"i, "or !ri# o" =s,s n,r !,

S=,#, Cs!, n S=,#, Tri, (Pr,,n!ion o"

A!ro=i!i,s A=!$3 1% !, +r6,r "or !rns",r in ,ss,n=, 7s

!n!8on! !o s)ing "or !rns",r !o no!,r is!ri=! 7i=

=o# , ##o7, on#6 6 !, Hig Cor!. I! 7s in !, o,

=)ro+ !! !, =o8+#inn! "i#, T.P. (Cr#.$ No.41 o" 2014

,"or, !, Hig Cor! s,,)ing !rns",r o" !, =s, !o n6

o!,r Cor! =o8+,!,n! !o !r6 !, s8, o!si, Roini

Dis!ri=!. T! ++#i=!ion3 s no!i=, o,3 s ,,n

is8iss, 6 !, Hig Cor! in !,r8s o" !, or,r i8+gn,

in !, +r,s,n! ++,# +ri8ri#6 on !, gron !! !, or,r

+ss, 6 !, Hig Cor! s 8, i! s""i=i,n!#6 =#,r !!

!, os,r!ions 8, in !, or,r +ss, 6 !, !ri# Cor!

s## no! in"#,n=, n6 "r,s or,r 7i= !, si Cor! 86

3

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

4/13Page 4

+ss +rsn! !o !, r,8n 8, 6 !, Hig Cor!. T,

Hig Cor! s #so os,r, !! !, =o8+#inn!

(++,##n! ,r,in$ 7i#, "i#ing Cr#. R.P. No.2&2 o" 2010

gins! !, is=rg, or,r ,@+r,ss, no ++r,,nsion nor

sog! !rns",r o" !, =s, "ro8 !, Cor! 7,r, i! is

+,ning !o n6 o!,r Cor!.

5. , , ,r #,rn, =ons,# "or !, +r!i,s ! so8,

#,ng!. I! is !r, !! !, !ri# Cor! 7i#, is=rging

!, ==s, +,rsons n,r !, S+,=i# A=! 8,n!ion, o,3

8, =,r!in os,r!ions o! !, ##,g, 8iss, o" !,

+roisions o" !, si A=! 6 ns=r+#os ,#,8,n!s n #so

=,r!in sgg,s!ions "or r,8,6ing !! si!!ion. I! is #so

!r, !! !, !ri# Cor! =o8, !o !, =on=#sion !!

!,r, is no r,# sis "or i! !o "r8, n6 =rg, gins! !,

==s, +,rsons n,r !, si A=!. B! i! is ,?##6 !r,

!! 7i#, s,!!ing si, !! or,r n ir,=!ing "r,s

or,r on !, ?,s!ion o" =rg,3 !, Hig Cor! s =#,r#6

8,n!ion, !! !, !ri# Cor! s## r,8in nin"#,n=, 6

!, os,r!ion 8, in i!s ,r#i,r or,r. T! os,r!ion

is3 in !, o+inion o" !, Hig Cor!3 s""i=i,n! s",gr

4

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

5/13Page 5

gins! n6 +ossi#, +r,

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

6/13Page 6

s!rong#6 7or, !! i! =o# in ## #i),#ioo gi, ris, !o

r,son#, ++r,,nsion in !, 8in o" !, =o8+#inn!

7i= =nno! , #ig!#6 rs, si,. , 8s! s!,n !o

!! 7, r, no! in !, #,s! sgg,s!ing !! !,

Pr,siing O""i=,r o" !, !ri# Cor! is !o!##6 in=+#, o"

o+!ing "ir ++ro= 7i#, +ssing "r,s or,r !

!,n !, ?,s!ion is no! 7,!,r !, Jg, is is, or

in=+#, o" rising o, !, ,r#i,r os,r!ions 8, 6

,r. T, ?,s!ion is 7,!,r !, ++r,,nsion o" !,

=o8+#inn! is r,son#, "or s !o ir,=! !rns",r. Js!i=,

8s! no! on#6 , on, ! 8s! s,,8 !o , ,,n on,. A

#r)ing ss+i=ion in !, 8in o" !, =o8+#inn! 7i## #,,

i8 7i! rooing s,ns, o" ing s"",r, in

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

7/13Page 7

9. , r, 8in"# o" !, "=! !! !, !rns",r or,r, 6

s 86 =s, in=on,ni,n=, n rss8,n! !o !, ==s,

+,rsons ! !! =n3 in or o+inion3 , !),n =r, o" 6

ir,=!ing !! in =s, n ++#i=!ion "or ,@,8+!ion "ro8

+,rson# ++,rn=,s is "i#,3 !, Cor! =on=,rn, s##

=onsi,r !, s8, n +ss ++ro+ri!, or,rs in

==orn=, 7i! #7.

. In !, r,s#!3 7, ##o7 !is ++,#3 s,! si, !, or,r

+ss, 6 !, Hig Cor! n ir,=! !! S,ssions Cs,

No.1009 o" 200 +,ning in !, Cor! o" Ai!ion# Dis!ri=!

n S,ssions Jg,3 Roini s## s!n !rns",rr, "ro8 !!

Cor! !o !, Cor! o" S,ssions Jg,3 Tis H:ri3 7o s##

!r6 !, s8, i8s,#" or 8), i! o,r !o n6 o!,r Cor! #6

no!i"i, n =o8+,!,n! !o o so. R,=or o" !, =s, s## ,

!rns8i!!, !o !, !rns",r,, Cor! ,@+,i!ios#6.

*************.*..*J. (T.S. THAKUR)

*************.*..*J.

N,7 D,#i3 (ADARSH KUMAR GOEL)F,rr6 &3 2015

7

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

8/13Page 8

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIACRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 222 OF 2015(Arisi! "#$ "% S.L.P. (Cr&.' N". 1)2014'

*ANA*LATA ..A++,&&-$

,rs#s

STATE (NCT' OF DELHI / ORS. .. R,s+",$s

J U D M E N T

R. BANUMATHI, J.

I -, - $, ,,%i$ "% !"i! $r"#! $, #!,$

+r"+"s, is L"rsi+ J#s$i8, T.S. T-9#r. F"r $, r,-s"s

:i8 I -, ii8-$, ,&":; I - #-&, $" -!r,, :i$ $,

+r"+"s, %i-& ,8isi" - i i,:; $, +r,s,$ -++,-& is

&i-&, $" , isiss,.

2. T, -++,&&-$ s,,9s $r-s%,r "% S,ssi"s C-s,

N".1006)200< -risi! "#$ "% FIR N".156)200 r,!is$,r, -$

P"&i8, S$-$i" M#9,r,, N-!-r; D,&i. As +,r $, -&&,!-$i"s

-, $, 8"+&-i-$)-++,&&-$ i $, FIR -$, 4.5.200;

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

9/13Page 9

$, -, ,, $, $,-$s #,r $, -88#s, +,rs"s - "

3.5.200; -88#s,)r,s+",$ N"s. 2 $" 10 "s$r#8$, -

-#s, $, #$$,ri! ",8$i"-&, 8-s$, -s, r,-r9s

-!-is$ $,. O $, -sis "% $, 8"+&-i$ &"!, $,

8"+&-i-$; FIR :-s r,!is$,r, #,r S,8$i"s 323)341)354

- 34 IPC - S,8$i" 3(i' (='; (=i' - (=' "% S8,#&,

C-s$,s - S8,#&, Tri,s (Pr,,$i" "% A$r"8i$i,s'

A8$;1

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

10/13Page 10

s+,8i-& &,-,; s,,9i! $r-s%,r "% $, S,ssi"s C-s,

N".1006)200< ,=+r,ssi! -++r,,si" $-$ i s+i$, "% $,

ir,8$i" "% $, Hi! C"#r$; $, $ri-& 8"#r$ i!$ +r"8,, " -

+r,?8"8,i, "$i".

3. @, -, ,-r $, &,-r, 8"#s,& %"r $, -++,&&-$

- Ms. Pi9 A-; &,-r, Ai$i"-& S"&i8i$"r ,,r-& "%

Ii- %"r r,s+",$ N".1 - Ms. S#si$- L-&; &,-r, 8"#s,&

%"r r,s+",$ N"s. 2 $" 10.

4. A -++&i8-$i" %"r $r-s%,r "% - 8-s, +,i! -!-is$

$, -88#s, 8-"$ , +,ri$$, ,r,& ,8-#s, $, &,-r,

S,ssi"s J#!, - -, 8,r$-i "s,r-$i"s - r,8"r,

%ii! i $, ,-r&i,r "r,r -$, 22.3.2010 :i&, -&&":i! $,

is8-r!, +,$i$i". T, s-i "r,r -$, 22.3.2010 :-s s,$

-si, $, Hi! C"#r$ - $, -$$,r :-s r,-, $" $,

S,ssi"s C"#r$ $" 8"si,r $, -$$,r -%r,s ,i!

#i%,8, - "s,r-$i" -, i $, ,-r&i,r "r,r.

@, $, ,-r&i,r "r,r -s ,, s,$ -si, $, Hi! C"#r$

- $, -$$,r :-s r,i$$, -89 $" $, S,ssi"s C"#r$ %"r

8"si,r-$i" "% $, -$$,r -%r,s; -++r,,si" "% $,

-++,&&-$ $-$ $, &,-r, $ri-& #!, - "$ -"+$ - %-ir

-++r"-8 is #$,-&,.

10

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

11/13Page 11

5. As ri!$& +"i$, "#$ $, Hi! C"#r$; ,-r&i,r :,

$, r,isi" +,$i$i" :-s -&&":, $, Hi! C"#r$ - $,

-$$,r :-s r,i$$, -89 $" $, $ri-& 8"#r$; " -++r,,si" "%

i-s :-s ,=+r,ss, "r - r,#,s$ :-s -, %"r - $r-s%,r "%

$, 8-s, %r" $, S+,8i-& C"#r$ $" s", "$,r 8"#r$. O ,-&%

"% $, -++,&&-$; i$ is ": 8"$,, $-$ i $, s-i r,isi"

+,$i$i"; $, -++,&&-$ 8"#& "$ -, -s9, %"r $r-s%,r "% $,

8rii-& 8-s,. I 8"si,r, i,:; s#8 8"$,$i" 8-"$

, 8"#$,-8,. U,r S,8$i" 42 Cr.P.C.; i "r,r $" s,8#r,

,s "% #s$i8,; $, Hi! C"#r$ -s i,r,$ +":,r $" +-ss

-++r"+ri-$, "r,r. H-i! -88,+$, $, "r,r "% r,- $" $,

$ri-& 8"#r$ %"r 8"si,r-$i" "% $, -$$,r -%r,s; $, -++,&&-$

is "$ #s$i%i, i s,,9i! $r-s%,r. T, -++,&&-$ -s ,i$,r

8-&&,!, $, s-i "r,r "% r,- "r r-is, $,

-++r,,si" $-$ $, $ri-& 8"#r$ - "$ -"+$ - %-ir -++r"-8.

6. I$ is +,r$i,$ $" "$, $-$ $, 8-s, -s ,,

r,!is$,r, $, 8"+&-i-$ :" :,r, $, $,-$s -!-is$

$, r,s+",$s?&-&"rs #,ri! -s - -s i, +,rs"s

- $, -$$,r is +,i! $ri-& si8, 200 %i&i! $r-s%,r

+,$i$i" i 2013; $, -++,&&-$ s,,s $" -++,-r $" , i$,r,s$,

"& i ,&-i! $, -$$,r.

11

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

12/13Page 12

7. I 8"si,ri! $, $r-s%,r -++&i8-$i"; i$ is $" , 9,+$

i i $-$ :,$,r - &i$i!-$ 8"#& r,-s"-& -++r,, -

i-s -$$ri#$-&, $" - +r,sii! J#!,. Tr-s%,r "% - 8-s, %r"

", 8"#r$ $" -"$,r -s s,ri"#s ,%%,8$s " $, J#!, %r"

:" $, 8-s, is s"#!$ $" , $r-s%,rr,. M,r, +r,s#+$i"s

"r +"ssi&, -ss#+$i"s -r, "$ s#%%i8i,$ %"r $r-s%,r "% - 8-s,.

O& " !"" - s#%%i8i,$ !r"#s - $r-s%,r 8- , "r,r,.

I 8"si,r, i,:; $, -++,&&-$ -s "$ -, "#$ -

!"" - s#%%i8i,$ !r"# %"r $r-s%,r.

. I$ is -&s" +,r$i,$ $" "$, $-$ - 8-s#-&

"s,r-$i"s -, - +r,sii! "%%i8,r "% $ri-& 8"#r$ :"#& "$

, - s#%%i8i,$ !r"# %"r $r-s%,r %"r $, r,-s" $-$ $, $ri-&

8"#r$s :"r9 i - 8-r!, -$"s+,r, - $, " "$ -, $,

,,%i$ "% - ,$-8, -$"s+,r, "% $, i!,r 8"#r$s s" -s $"

$i9 8""& - ,8i, +-$i,$&. I $is r,!-r; :, -

#s,%#&& r,%,r $" $, ,8isi" "% $is C"#r$ i K.P. Tiwari v. State

of M.P.; 1

8/9/2019 Sc St Act Judgment

13/13

is8-r!, is #$i,s $" $, ,s$ "% is 8-+-8i$. @i&,"i! s"; s",$i,s; , is &i9,& $" ,rr. I$ is :,&& s-i$-$ - #!, :" -s "$ 8"i$$, - ,rr"r is ,$ $" ,"r. A $-$ -++&i,s $" #!,s -$ -&& &,,&s %r" $,&":,s$ $" $, i!,s$. S",$i,s; $, i%%,r,8, i

i,:s "% $, i!,r - $, &":,r 8"#r$s is +#r,& -r,s#&$ "% - i%%,r,8, i -++r"-8 - +,r8,+$i". Os#8 "88-si"s; $, &":,r 8"#r$s -r, "$ ,8,ss-ri&:r"! - $, i!,r 8"#r$s -&:-s ri!$. I$ -s -&s" $", r,,,r, $-$ $, &":,r #i8i-& "%%i8,rs "s$&:"r9 #,r - 8-r!, -$"s+,r, - -r, 8"s$-$,r - +s8"&"!i8-& +r,ss#r, :i$ -&& $, 8"$,s$-$s- $,ir &-:,rs -&"s$ r,-$i! ": $,ir ,89s "r, 8"rr,8$& #+ $" $,ir "s$ri&s. T, " "$ -, $,,,%i$ "% - ,$-8, -$"s+,r, "% $, i!,r 8"#r$s $"$i9 8""&& - ,8i, +-$i,$&. E,r ,rr"r; ":,,r!r"ss i$ - &""9; s"#& "$; $,r,%"r,; , -$$ri#$, $"i+r"+,r "$i,.