View
219
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 1
Neutrino and Antineutrino Cross Sections at MiniBooNE
Sam ZellerColumbia University
(for the MiniBooNE collaboration)
NO-VE WorkshopFebruary 7, 2006
- our 1st cross section
results (CC +/QE)
- future directions in MiniBooNE
program
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 2
MiniBooNE is a Oscillation Experiment
• main goal: confirm or rule out e LSND results
• search for → e oscillations
• not going to be showing oscillation results
• working hard on performing a very careful e appearance analysis …
• you’ll have to stay tuned
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 3
* well-suited for low E cross section physics
- useful to the community - important for oscillation analysis
- will tell you about
* plus some new opportunities (mention at end)
- antineutrino data! (big change for us)
MiniBooNE On the Way
MiniBooNEis a dynamicexperiment
• while designed for e oscillation search …
updating is
important
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 4
Previous Measurements• most of present low energy knowledge comes from bubble chamber exps
• early experiments at ANL, BNL, FNAL, CERN, Serpukhov, etc.
• 20-100% errors due to: - low statistics (100’s of events)
- uncertainties in flux
• in addition to large errors, results often conflicting (some care in interpreting)
• data useful to constrain our MCs
• idea of caliber of past data …
GGM
BNL
FNAL
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 5
Low Energy Cross Sections
MINOS, NuMIK2K, NOvA
MiniBooNE, T2K
Super-K atmospheric
predictions from NUANCE
- MC which MBooNE uses
- open source code
- supported & maintained by D. Casper (UC Irvine)
- standard inputs (common ingredients - osc exps)
- Smith-Moniz Fermi Gas - Rein-Sehgal 1 - Bodek-Yang DIS
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 6
Low Energy Cross Sections
MINOS, NuMIK2K, NOvA
MiniBooNE, T2K
Super-K atmospheric
• imperative to precisely predict signal & bkgd rates for future oscillation exps
- will be more sensitive to sources of syst error
- nuclear targets! (most past data on H2, D2)
• further motivates need for new measurements
• new data adding new info; revealing interesting features K2K, NOMAD, MiniBooNE
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 7
magnetic horn: meson focusing
decay region: K→
movable absorber: stops muons, undecayed
mesons
“LMC” measure K flux in-situ
450 m earth berm:
magnetic focusing horn
FNAL 8 GeV Booster
MiniBooNE detector
(CH2)
MiniBooNE Beamline• >700,000 contained events
• providing a valuable sample to study low E cross sections
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 8
Flux at MiniBooNE Detector
MC predicted energy spectrum
mainly from
production constrained by global data & E910 … - eventually HARP
- really advance knowledge of low E hadroproduction (see Gibin’s talk)
• incident on detector: high purity beam (>99% flavor)
PRELIMINARY
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 9
Flux at MiniBooNE Detector
MC predicted energy spectrum
- <E>MBooNE ~ 0.7 GeV
- well-suited for low energy cross section studies
- small tail; enjoy smaller backgrounds from higher multiplicity interactions
- complementary to other experiments <E
K2K> ~ 1.3 GeV <E
NuMI > ~ 10 GeV <E
NOMAD > ~ 24 GeV
PRELIMINARY
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 10
Event Fractions at MiniBooNE
- 48% CC QE- 31% CC
- 8% NC 0
- 5% CC 0
- 3% NC +/-
- 4% multi-- 1% NC elastic
MiniBooNE flux-averaged event compositions
(NTANK>200, NVETO<6)
demonstrateunderstanding
of 79% of events before
analyzinge
(<1% of total)
this flux spectrum dictates whattype of interactions we see …
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 11
Quasi-Elastic Scattering
Why important?
n → - p• QE necessary to accurately predict signal rates in oscillation experiments (including our own)
* e QE are main signal for e appearance searches; have similar kinematics &
• channel used as “golden mode” to normalize other cross section samples - lots of events, well known
(common practice that we will also adopt for now)
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 12
Quasi-Elastic Scattering
• highest statistics ~2500 events
• low E data on D2
n → - p
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 13
Quasi-Elastic Scattering n → - p
• new information already coming in (NOMAD, 12C)
(R. Petti, NuInt05)
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 14
Quasi-Elastic Scattering n → - p
• MiniBooNE:
- 12C (valuable for osc exps)
- this analysis: 60k events (3.2x1020 POT) (already more data than all previous exps combined)
- can select 86% pure QE sample
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 15
MiniBooNE QE Data
measure visible E and from mostly Čerenkov () + some scintillation light (p)
n → - p
• most copious events at MiniBooNE• also simplest: two body kinematics
(J. Monroe)
forward muons corresponds to
low Q2 …
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 16
• to improve data, MC agreement performing shape fits for: (J. Monroe)
- axial form factor (MA) & - nuclear model pars (EB,pF)
• incorporating new nuclear models (R. Tayloe)
(that are constrained by modern electron scattering data)
MiniBooNE QE Data• similar effect seen by K2K
• working on understanding these features in our data …
Q2 = m2 - 2E(E-pcos)
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 17
MiniBooNE QE Data
2MpE – m2
EQE =
2(Mp-E+pcos)
(J. Monroe)
• energy distribution that will be used for CC +/QE cross section measurement
• next, numerator (CC +) …
• making use of E, …
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 18
• forward emitted • low Q2
CC 1+ Productioncoherent + productionresonant + production (dominant)
A A+
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 19
CC 1+ Productioncoherent + productionresonant + production (dominant)
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 20
(K2K, hep-ex/0506008)
• K2K: 1st search for coh + prod at low E• somewhat surprising results …• see no evidence for coh + production!
CC 1+ Productioncoherent + productionresonant + production (dominant)
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 21
• forward emitted • low Q2
CC 1+ Production
• MiniBooNE:- inclusive measurement, CH2
- this analysis: 40k events (3.2x1020 POT) (5x more than previous bubble chamber data combined)
coherent + productionresonant + production (dominant)
A A+
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 22
CC + Production
Why important?
• poses largest background to QE samples (large & + can be absorbed in nucleus)
• useful for understanding production in CH2 ( → N a background to → e search)
• possibility for CC + oscillation search
• useful in understanding our event reconstruction
N → N +
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 23
MiniBooNE CC + Selection• very simple selection:
- events with 2 decay electrons - unique, results in 84% purity
-
e-
e+
+ +
e
(M. Wascko)
=2070 ±16 ns = 2242 ± 17 ns
+e+
• expect to have shorter lifetime from capture (8% in12C)
- will also make use of this later
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 24
MiniBooNE CC + Reconstructionmeasure Čerenkov light frommuon (to avoid light from +)
(M. Wascko)
seelarger
deficit inforward (low Q2)than in
QE data
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 25
MiniBooNE CC + Data
(M. Wascko)
2MpE – m2 + (m
2-Mp2)
“EQE” =
2(Mp-E+pcos)
• use 2 body (QE) kinematics
• assume in final state (instead of p in QE case)
• energy distribution that will be used for CC +/QE cross section measurement
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 26
MiniBooNE CC +/QE Ratio• efficiency corrected CC +/QE ratio meas on CH2
• eff corrections from MC
• ample statistics can perform a binned measurement
(J. Monroe, M. Wascko)
first measurement of thiscross section ratio on a
nuclear target at low energy!
• current systematics estimate:
- light propagation in oil: ~20% - cross sections: ~15% - energy scale: ~10% - statistics: ~5%
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 27
MiniBooNE CC + Cross Section• multiplying measured CC +/QE ratio by QE prediction (QE with MA=1.03 GeV, BBA non-dipole vector form factors)
(J. Monroe, M. Wascko)
• ~25% lower than prediction, but within errors
• MC error band from external data constraints
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 28
Plausible Interpretation• since MiniBooNE 1st meas on nuclear target at these E’s
• at 1st glance, one might think this is pointing to a potential problem with nuclear corrs
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 29
Plausible Interpretation• since MiniBooNE 1st meas on nuclear target at these E’s
• at 1st glance, one might think this is pointing to a potential problem with nuclear corrs
• MiniBooNE results more consistent with ANL than BNL - new data helping to decide between 2 disparate meas - once final, type of info that can feed back into open source MC
• but free nucleon ’s disagree!
BNL
ANL• MC prediction splits difference
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 30
New Directions at MiniBooNE
• new antineutrino data!
• observing events from NuMI
• coming soon: new fine-grained new detector to this beamline (comparisons to MiniBooNEwill be interesting)
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 31
MiniBooNE Antineutrino Running
1st MiniBooNE antineutrino event
• goals are two-fold:
- check LSND → e signal (longer program)
- measure cross sections - systematic check of analyses - low Q2 investigations - coherent production
• just started antineutrino running (January 19th)
- ~1,000 events/week - will have world’s largest low E data set in a few weeks!
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 32
Need for Measurements
• data even less abundant
• provide valuable input for future CP violation searches
P(→ e) ≠ P( → e)
• prefer not to rely on extrapolation of models into regions where no data
• MiniBooNE will make world’s 1st meas of in this E range
- expect ~10k QE in 1 year (after cuts)
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 33
Added Difficulty with Beams• contending with “wrong sign” backgrounds ( in beam) - MiniBooNE beam is no exception …
• in neutrino mode, antineutrinos are ~2% of total events
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 34
Added Difficulty with Beams• contending with “wrong sign” backgrounds ( in beam) - MiniBooNE beam is no exception …
• need a way to constrain backgrounds in data
• Čerenkov detectors cannot distinguish , + event-by-event (no magnetic field)
• in antineutrino mode, neutrinos are ~30% of total events
“ -enhanced beam”
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 35
Constraining Backgrounds in Data
• needed to be more clever
• developed several novel techniques to measure from data
• 1st and most powerful …
• makes use of fact that QE & have different angular distributions
• large angle QE’s as means of measuring content in data
(“poor man’s sign-selection”)
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 36
1. QE angular distributions provide best “wrong-sign” constraint, but also … 7% constraint
2. add’l constraint from CC + events in mode data (come entirely from interactions as ’s produce a _ in final state)
- higher E constraint 15% constraint
3. also muon lifetimes ( vs. + to distinguish vs. )- and + have different lifetimes due to capture probability in oil
- not as precise a constraint, but indep of kinematics & recon
30% constraint
→ allows precise antineutrino measurements (once have a handle on backgrounds)
redu
ndan
t ch
ecks
Three Independent Constraints
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 37
Antineutrino Measurements• can add new info by mere fact that scattering is different
ddQ2
QE QE
different shape & axialcontribution
difference isolates interference term - directly to axial FF
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 38
Antineutrino Measurements• can add new info by mere fact that scattering is different
NC 0 NC 0
• 20% is coherent production • 40% is coherent production• “enhanced” coherent sample
latest K2K results say this peak will be
missing:very apparent in data
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 39
Can Detect ’s from NuMI !
NuMI events in MiniBooNE detector
(A. Aquilar-Arevalo)
• ~10,000 events so far
• 100’s of e events (calibration)
• also opened up possibility to use this sample for meas (slightly diff beam spectrum)- MINOS also sees MiniBooNE neutrinos in their detector
• neighbor’s beam
• first off-axis neutrino beam!
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 40
SciBooNE (E954)
• new Int’l collaboration
- couple well-understood, fine-grained detector with high rate beam
- unique, low risk opportunity
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 41
SciBooNE (E954)
• new Int’l collaboration
- excellent final state resolution - improve on MiniBooNE studies
- couple well-understood, fine-grained detector with high rate beam
- unique, low risk opportunity
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 42
SciBooNE (E954)
• new Int’l collaboration
- measurements for T2K
• just received Stage 1 approval (Dec ‘05) rapid schedule: begin data taking this Fall
• www-sciboone.fnal.gov
- excellent final state resolution - improve on MiniBooNE studies
- couple well-understood, fine-grained detector with high rate beam
- unique, low risk opportunity
Sam Zeller, NO-VE Workshop, 02/07/06 43
Conclusions
• coming soon …
- CC QE cross section results - NC 0 cross sections
flux
crosssections
• collected > 700k neutrino (> 1k antineutrino) events (7 x 1020 POT)
- amassed the world’s largest sample in 1 GeV range
- already an order of magnitude more data than previous bubble chamber based measurements
- part of effort to help improve our current understanding of low E
- 1st results on MiniBooNE CC +/QE cross section
• stay tuned for e oscillation results
- HARP results (8 GeV, Be, thick target)