Upload
cecilia-gibbs
View
224
Download
4
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Rule 609:Use of Convictions to Attack Credibility
Problem 8
Problem 8: Your Flow
Charts
One Possible Flow Chart
Flow Chart 1Conviction offered to impeach witness
Is Witness
the Accused
Accused Rules
Regular Rules
NoYes
Flow Chart 2Conviction of Non-Accused
Yes Crime of Dishonesty?
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
Felony?
Pass 403?
Admit subject to Exceptions (b) - (d) Exclude
Flow Chart 3Conviction of Accused
Yes Crime of Dishonesty?
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
Felony?
Special Balance
Admit subject to Exceptions (b) - (d) Exclude
1
2
3
4
5
Admit
Admit
Admit
Admit
Exclude
403 Balancing
1
2
3
4
5
Admit
Admit
Exclude
Exclude
Exclude
Special 609(a)(1) Balancing
1
2
3
4
5
Admit
Admit
Admit
Admit
Exclude
Regular 403 Balancing
Exclude
Exclude
Special 609(a)(1) Balancing
Rule 403 reflects a
strong preference
for admission
Rule 609(a)(1) reflects a
weak preference
for exclusion
Flow Chart 4Old Conviction
Admit subject to Exceptions (b) - (d) Exclude
>10 yrssince
conviction?
>10 yrssince
release?
PassesSpecial609(b)
Balance?
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
1
2
3
4
5
Admit
Admit
Admit
Admit
Exclude
403 Balancing
1
2
3
4
5
Admit
Exclude
Exclude
Exclude
Exclude
Special 609(b) Balancing
1
2
3
4
5
Admit
Admit
Admit
Admit
Exclude
Regular 403 Balancing
Exclude
Exclude
Special 609(b)
Balancing
Exclude
Rule 403 reflects a
strong preference
for admission
Rule 609(b) reflects a
strong preference
for exclusion
Flow Chart 5Pardon
NoPardon?
RestoreRights
Yes Type ofPardon
Admit Subject to Exception (d) Exclude
Innocence
Rehabilitation
Stayed
Clean
YesNo
Flow Chart 6Juvenile Convictions
AdmitExclude
Yes
No YesYes
No
NoWas it ajuvenile
conviction?
Currentcase
criminal?
Iswitness the
accused?
Admit
Yes
No
AdmissionNecessary
for FairTrial
NoYes
OKto attack
credibilityof adult
?