Upload
hong
View
26
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Rule 22c-2 and the impact on TPAs, Trust Companies and RIAs October 26, 2006 Gail Weiss & Associates, Inc. 828 South Charles Street Baltimore, MD 21230 (410) 230-2693 http://www.gailweiss.com. Agenda. Market Timing Overview History of the SEC Rule 22c-2 Industry Response - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
Rule 22c-2 and the impact
on TPAs, Trust Companies and RIAs
October 26, 2006
Gail Weiss & Associates, Inc.828 South Charles Street
Baltimore, MD 21230(410) 230-2693
http://www.gailweiss.com
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
2
Agenda
Market Timing Overview
History of the SEC Rule 22c-2
Industry Response
Practical Concerns
Questions and Answers
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
3
Market Timing Defined
Refers to the practice of buying and selling mutual fund shares over the short term to exploit potential pricing inefficiencies
Usually market timing is contrary tothe stated policies of a mutual fund set forth in the prospectus
Not illegal
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
4
Market Timing Impact
Market timing is detrimental because:
Incurs additional trading costs
Loss of investment opportunity
Shareholder dilution
Tax consequences
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
5
Market Timing Concerns
Market timing can be done with orwithout the consent of the mutual fund
Industry standard trading practices have made market timing difficult and in some cases impossible to detect
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
6
Market Timing Reform
SEC Rule 22c-2 History
Proposed Rule March 5, 2004
Final Rule March 11, 2005
Proposed Amendments
March 3, 2006
Effective Date October 16, 2006
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
7
Market Timing Reform
Consistent themes: Protecting the long-term investor from
market timers
Trading transparency
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
8
Proposed Rule 22c-2
Mandatory 2% Short-Term Redemption Fee for shares purchased within the previous five business days
Fee to be retained by the fund
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
9
Proposed Rule 22c-2
Exceptions: Money Market Funds
Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)
Funds that adopt a policy to permit short-term trading and disclose this policy in the prospectus with comments about the potential additional costs to the fund
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
10
Proposed Rule 22c-2
Operational Considerations: Funds are not precluded from
instituting a longer holding period
Fee determined using the “First in, first out” or FIFO method
De minimis provision permits funds the discretion to forego the assessment of redemption fees if the redemption proceeds are $2,500 or less
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
11
Proposed Rule 22c-2
Operational Considerations continued:
Mandatory fee waivers for unanticipated financial emergencies on redemptions of $10,000 or less upon written request
Funds have the discretion to waive the fee on financial emergency transactions in excess of $10,000
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
12
Proposed Rule 22c-2
Investor Transparency Alternatives: Intermediary account number must be
included with each transaction; or
Intermediary agrees in writing to identify redemptions that are subject to redemption fees and transmit sufficient information to the fund to allow the fund to assess the redemption fee; or
Intermediary agrees in writing to impose redemption fee and remit the proceeds to the fund.
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
13
Proposed Rule 22c-2
Investor Transparency Required Reporting:
Tax Identification Numbers
Amounts and dates of all purchases, redemptions and exchanges within an omnibus account
Weekly or more frequent basis
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
14
Final Rule 22c-2
Voluntary redemption fee not to exceed 2% for shares purchased within the previous seven calendar days
Redemption fees must be determined by each fund board of directors including a majority of independent directors
Fee to be retained by the fund
Written agreements are required with all “financial intermediaries” regarding information sharing and responsibility to restrict or prohibit trading under certain circumstances
Money market and ETFs are excluded
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
15
Final Rule 22c-2
Written agreement requirement: With each financial intermediary regardless of
whether a redemption fee is imposed
Includes requirement that the financial intermediary must provide upon request information about the identity of shareholders and their transactions in fund shares
Contains provision requiring the financial intermediary to restrict or prohibit further purchases or exchanges of a specified shareholder as identified by the fund
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
16
Final Rule 22c-2
Financial Intermediaries Defined: Broker, dealer or any other entity that holds
securities in nominee name; and
Insurance companies that sponsors a registered separate account organized as a unit investment trust, master-feeder funds and certain fund of fund arrangements not specifically excepted from the rule; and
In the case of an employee benefit plan, the plan administrator or plan record keeper
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
17
Final Rule 22c-2
Concerns with the final Rule 22c-2: Redemption fees will vary greatly
Amount assessed
Time period
Accounting method
Obtaining agreements with each “financial intermediary” will be a significant burden for both the funds and firms
Data reporting requests will vary greatly
Restricting or prohibiting future purchases will be a technological challenge for some
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
18
Final Rule 22c-2
Consequences for noncompliance: Funds are prohibited from redeeming shares
within seven days
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
19
Proposed Amendments
Limit the types of intermediaries with which funds must negotiate written agreements
Address situations when there are chains of intermediaries
Clarify the effect of a fund’s failure to obtain agreements with any of its intermediaries
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
20
Proposed Amendments
Proposed Small Intermediaries Exclusion: Excludes any intermediary that the fund treats
as an individual investor for purposes of the fund’s policies intended to eliminate or reduce the dilution of the value of fund shares
Concern that many small retirement plans covering only a few employees would be deemed a “financial intermediary”
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
21
Proposed Amendments
Proposed Intermediary Chain Exclusion: Limits the requirement of the funds to obtain
written agreements with only the first-tier intermediary that trades directly with the fund, its principal underwriter or transfer agent or a registered clearing agency
Concern that many intermediaries are actually holding shares on behalf of other another intermediaries and the underlying transaction data and investor identification was not readily available
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
22
Proposed Amendments
Proposed “Shareholder Information Agreements” must include an obligation to: Provide, promptly upon the fund’s request,
identification and transaction information for any shareholder accounts held directly with the first-tier intermediary
Use its best efforts to obtain and forward or have forwarded the information from underlying intermediaries
Prohibit future purchases due to failure to remit the requested data
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
23
Proposed Amendments
Proposed change to the effect of lacking an agreement: Initially the lack of an agreement meant an
intermediary would be precluded from redeeming the shares within seven days of purchase
Proposed change to revise the rule so that if a fund does not have an agreement with a particular intermediary, the fund must prohibit future purchases
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
24
Industry Response
Variety of working groups have formed including representatives of: American Bankers Association (ABA)
American Society of Pension Professionals and Actuaries (ASPPA)
Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC)
Investment Company Institute (ICI)
Securities Industry Association (SIA)
Society of Professional Administrators and Record keepers (SPARK)
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
25
Industry Response
ICI’s Standardized Data Reporting Working Group: Guidelines Taskforce
Technical Design Taskforce
Communications Taskforce
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
26
Guidelines Taskforce
Definitions
Best Practices
Examples
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
27
Guidelines Taskforce
Significant Definitions: First-tier and underlying intermediary
Participant/Shareholder
Omnibus Accounts
Transaction Categories
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
28
Guidelines Taskforce
Intermediaries defined: First Tier – an intermediary that has an
existing contractual relationship with the fund to act as a conduit for executing transactions
Underlying – a related entity that transacts with the funds through services provided by a first-tier intermediary
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
29
Guidelines Taskforce
Participant/Shareholder defined: Individual investors including participants in
retirement plans or shareholders in an omnibus account.
Participants/Shareholders are usually identified by SSN or TIN to the extent they are available.
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
30
Guidelines Taskforce
Omnibus Account Defined: Represents assets for multiple investors and
usually registered in the name of the intermediary Plan Account – one account for single retirement
plan with multiple participants
Investor Omnibus Account – one account for multiple retail accounts, IRAs, etc.
Super Omnibus Account – includes assets of more than one omnibus account
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
31
Guidelines Taskforce
Transaction categories: Category 1– actively directed by investor or
their agent with sufficient control to perform market timing activities
Purchases and redemptions
Fund Transfers, exchanges, rebalancing
Non-participant directed transactions if the participant receives the benefit
Category 2 – transactions that are considered systematic or non-directed
Periodically scheduled purchases or redemptions
Payroll deductions, loan repayments, earnings
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
32
Guidelines Taskforce
Best Practices: Typical Request:
Date range not to exceed 90 days
Limited to previous year
Acknowledgement within one business day
Data provided within three business days from first tier intermediary and five days with underlying intermediaries
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
33
Technical Design Taskforce
Processing Flow
Critical Data Elements
Data Definitions
Common Terms
Record Layouts
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
34
Technical Design Taskforce
Processing Flow: Day One – Fund initiates request
Day Two – Intermediary confirms receipt
Day Three – Intermediary responds
Day Four – Fund analyzes the data
Day Five – Fund requests additional information with respect to super omnibus accounts and the process starts all over again
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
35
Technical Design Taskforce
SDR Summary and Detail Data Requests
Summary Request Review Detailed Request
NS
CC
1st T
ier I
nter
med
iary
2nd T
ier I
nter
med
iary
Fund
Request Summary data on Omnibus
accounts
Process F40 request from
fund
Process ppt level data
request from funds
Process F40 Request
Process B43 responses
Respond via B43
w/in 1-3 business
days
Provide participant level data
clearing 1st tier
intermediary
Ppt level data maintained
Respond via B42 w/in 1-3
business days
Request data on Omnibus accoutns
Process F40 Request
Process F40 request from
fund
Process B42 responses
Sum
mar
y S
DR
Req
uest
Fund to analyze summary data to determine if additional
information is required from intermediary
No:
Inte
rmed
iary
requ
est
dat
a fro
m u
nder
lyin
g in
term
edia
ry
Yes
1
2
1: Agreements to be established between funds and 1st tier financial intermediaries for omnibus relationships.
2: 2nd tier financial intermediaries will enter into agreements with 1st tier intermediaries or directly with funds. Structure and agreements to be negotiated by and between 1st tier intermediaries and funds.
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
36
Technical Design Taskforce
Critical Data Elements: CUSIP
Fund Account Number
Plan Identifier/Omnibus Account Number
SSN/TIN or other identifier
From/to Dates
Transaction amounts with Type and Category
Threshold Amount
Rep ID, branch and firm
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
37
Technical Design Taskforce
Additional information regarding: Data Definitions
Common Terms
Record layouts
Can be found in the handouts
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
38
Communications Taskforce
Model Language Agreement to provide information
Period covered by the request
Form and timing of response
Agreement to restrict trading
Sample Communication Package
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
39
Practical Concerns
How will Rule 22c-2 impact my business?
What do I need to do from a legal agreements perspective?
What do I need to do from an operational perspective?
Do I need to change any of my policies and procedures?
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
40
Practical Concerns
Evaluate Exposure Identify each mutual fund that is in a client
account
Understand the market timing rules for each mutual fund
Determine how each mutual fund is traded
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
41
Practical Concerns
Evaluate need for Shareholder Information Agreements If you trade directly with funds, you
need to get an agreement
If you trade through an intermediary, you need to confirm that the chain of intermediaries in which you participate has executed all necessary documents
If you trade through an intermediary, you need to sign a agreement with each intermediary
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
42
Practical Concerns
Evaluate required technology enhancements A placeholder for SSN/TINs
Trade tracking to access applicable redemption fees
Indicator to restrict future trades at the investor level
Responding to data requests in a secure manner
Processing turnaround times
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
43
Practical Concerns
Evaluate the compatibility of your legal agreements’ obligations with your technological capabilities
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
44
Practical Concerns
Privacy concerns vs. contractual obligations Applicable federal and state privacy laws
permit the disclosure of confidential customer information if the disclosure is necessary to comply with applicable legal requirements.
Privacy policies as stated may have to be amended.
Contracts between intermediaries, participant record keepers and plan sponsors may have to be amended.
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
45
Practical Concerns
Evaluate impact on policies and procedures Adding a new fund
Executing rebalance/reallocation routines
Fulfilling client request for cash
Processing turnaround times
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
46
Practical Concerns
Gotchas Executing redemptions to pay fees
Managing client expectations with respect to requests for cash
Corrections processing
Trading restriction applied to investor due to trading activity at another institution and now you must also restrict that investor
Staff unwittingly responds to data request in an unsecured manner (i.e. email)
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
47
Conclusion
Reforms have been deemed necessary
All parties involved in mutual fund trading will be impacted
The next steps are unfolding quickly
Be proactive
828 South Charles Street | Baltimore | MD | 21230 | (410) 230 – 2693 | www.gailweiss.com
48
Conclusion
Questions