1
role in suppressing distractive information. We tested these hypotheses and tried to elucidate their essential neuronal mechanisms. We simu- lated a neural network containing a sensory network (SN) and a default mode network (DMN). The SN consisted of cell assemblies. Each cell assembly, comprising principal cells, GABAergic interneurons and glial cells, responded to one specic sensory feature. A single cell assembly, comprising principal cells and GABAergic interneurons, constituted the DMN. Principal cells of the DMN showed intrinsic high level ring activity during the ongoing-spontaneous time period prior to sensory stimulation (without sensory stimulation). We let the SN carry out a simple perceptual task: detection of sensory feature stimuli. During DMN activation, glial cells of the SN were hyperpolarized, by which glial membrane transporters imported GABA molecules from the extracellu- lar space and decreased ambient GABA concentration. Ambient GABA molecules acted on extrasynaptic GABA receptors. Hence, the decrease of ambient GABA concentration reduced inhibitory current in P cells of the SN. This depolarized the P cells below ring threshold and enhanced their responsiveness to sensory feature stimulus. During the stimulus presentation period, the SN inhibited P cells of the DMN and caused DMN deactivation. This depolarized glial cells, by which the glial membrane transporters exported GABA molecules into the extracellular space and increased ambient GABA concentration. The increase of ambient GABA concentration augmented inhibitory current in P cells of the SN in a global manner (i.e., across cell assemblies). Interestingly, the ring activity of stimulus-relevant P cells was maintained provided that a hypothetical interneuron-to-glia signaling worked. This resulted in inhibiting the stimulus-irrelevant P cells while maintaining the stimu- lus-relevant P cell activity. We suggest that the DMN may have roles in improving sensory responsiveness and suppressing distractive informa- tion, reected in the decrease in stimulus-irrelevant P cell activity, in order to achieve the best perceptual performance. The GABAergic glio- transmission mechanism may coordinate the effects of DMN activation and deactivation in sensory information processing. doi:10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2014.08.780 Oral Session 3 Emotion and decision making Chair: Márk Molnár (Hungary) Risky and cautious choice-making Age-dependent changes of feedback related negativity in a gambling task Márk Molnár, Zsóa K. Kardos, Roland Boha, Bálint File, Brigitta Tóth Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience and Psychology, Research Centre for Natural Sciences, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary Choice behavior is inuenced by motivation in which processing of feedback stimuli plays an important role. The neural systems behind reward and punishment that guide these processes are more or less clear but less is known how these are modied by aging. The aim of the present study was to analyze the age-related differences in risk- taking behavior by using electrophysiological methods. 25 young (mean age: 21.76 yrs) and 23 elderly (mean age: 66.87 yrs) partici- pated in the study. The subjects performed a monetary gambling task in which they had to choose between low or high stakes both with possible gain or lose outcomes. The monetary difference between the high and low stake conditions was twofold. The results (gain or loss) were indicated by an outcome stimulus (green or red light). No time pressure was applied. The EEG was recorded by 64 electrodes and the feedback related potentials (FRPs) evoked by the outcome stimuli were analyzed. It was found that in both age groups high losses were followed by opting for higher stakes. Of the FRPs the negative component (feedback related negativity [FRN], latency: approx. 250 ms) was analyzed. The amplitude of the FRN was much larger evoked by the loss signalthan those elicited by the gain signalin the young, irrespective of whether the stake was high or low. The FRN component was also seen in the elderly but with lower amplitude and with no conspicuous difference between conditions. The scalp distribution of the FRN was different in the two age groups. Time- frequency analysis revealed a conspicuous difference between gain and lose conditions depending upon age. In conclusion, whereas overt behavioral differences were not obvious between age groups in the condition investigated, analysis of FRPs revealed that the processes reected by FRN were strikingly different in the young compared to the elderly. Characteristics of the FRN corresponded to error assessment but were obvious only in the young. It appears that the evaluation of feedback stimuli is markedly less efcient in the elderly. Grant support: OTKA 104332. doi:10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2014.08.781 Decision-making in individuals with intellectual disabilities revealed by near infrared spectroscopy Hiroaki Shoji a , Ayano Mizokoshi b , Taichi Hirayama c , Hisaki Ozaki a a College of Education, Ibaraki University, Japan b Graduate School of Education, Ibaraki University, Japan c Graduate School of Science and Engineering, Ibaraki University, Japan Previous studies have shown that individuals with intellectual disabilities have difculty in utilizing information from two different dimensions for decision-making. For instance, individuals with intel- lectual disabilities tended to choose randomly or with only a single dimension (time or money) in the temporal discounting (TD) task, which is required to choose between a small immediate reward and a large delayed reward. However, neural correlates of their behavioral characteristics on decision-making have not been claried. Therefore, we examined cerebral activity during decision-making in individuals with intellectual disabilities using near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS). Five adolescents with intellectual disabilities (mean age 17.6 years) and 15 normal adults (mean age 22.9 years) participated in this experiment. In the TD task, two apple images were presented at the left and right side of the screen. Simultaneously, sale money and harvest day was presented on the bottom of the images. In one side of the screen, the amount of money was relatively expensive but delayed harvest could fail to get the apple (high risk). In the opposite side, harvest was surely possible but sale money was relatively inexpensive (low risk). In each trial, participants were asked to select by touching either side of the screen. 4 sequential trials for each 5 seconds were conducted in the task period. Feedback on a total amount of money was also presented for 2 seconds after the 4th trial. 20-second rest period and 22-second task period were repeated twice for NIRS measurement. NIRS was recorded from 16 channels in frontal area (OEG-16, Spectratech). Mean values of Oxy-Hb at each channel was compared between 5-second before and 22-second during the task period. In normal adults, response pattern based on trade-off between reward value and time delay was observed. Therefore, waveforms of blood ow were averaged over trials indicating such a pattern. As a result, the concentration changes in Oxy-Hb during the task period signicantly increased in left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC). In individuals with intellectual disabilities, there was no response pattern based on the trade-off in every trial. However, increment of Oxy-Hb in left DLPFC was observed during the task period in two individuals with intellectual disabilities. Focusing on their behavioral data, their response was decided by utilizing information from two different dimensions although it was not rational trade-off. International Journal of Psychophysiology 94 (2014) 120261 186

Risky and cautious choice-making — Age-dependent changes of feedback related negativity in a gambling task

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Risky and cautious choice-making — Age-dependent changes of feedback related negativity in a gambling task

role in suppressing distractive information. We tested these hypothesesand tried to elucidate their essential neuronal mechanisms. We simu-lated a neural network containing a sensory network (SN) and a defaultmode network (DMN). The SN consisted of cell assemblies. Each cellassembly, comprising principal cells, GABAergic interneurons and glialcells, responded to one specific sensory feature. A single cell assembly,comprising principal cells and GABAergic interneurons, constituted theDMN. Principal cells of the DMN showed intrinsic high level firingactivity during the ongoing-spontaneous time period prior to sensorystimulation (without sensory stimulation). We let the SN carry outa simple perceptual task: detection of sensory feature stimuli. DuringDMN activation, glial cells of the SN were hyperpolarized, by which glialmembrane transporters imported GABA molecules from the extracellu-lar space and decreased ambient GABA concentration. Ambient GABAmolecules acted on extrasynaptic GABA receptors. Hence, the decrease ofambient GABA concentration reduced inhibitory current in P cells of theSN. This depolarized the P cells below firing threshold and enhancedtheir responsiveness to sensory feature stimulus. During the stimuluspresentation period, the SN inhibited P cells of theDMNand causedDMNdeactivation. This depolarized glial cells, by which the glial membranetransporters exported GABA molecules into the extracellular spaceand increased ambient GABA concentration. The increase of ambientGABA concentration augmented inhibitory current in P cells of the SN ina global manner (i.e., across cell assemblies). Interestingly, the firingactivity of stimulus-relevant P cells was maintained provided that ahypothetical interneuron-to-glia signaling worked. This resulted ininhibiting the stimulus-irrelevant P cells while maintaining the stimu-lus-relevant P cell activity. We suggest that the DMN may have roles inimproving sensory responsiveness and suppressing distractive informa-tion, reflected in the decrease in stimulus-irrelevant P cell activity, inorder to achieve the best perceptual performance. The GABAergic glio-transmission mechanism may coordinate the effects of DMN activationand deactivation in sensory information processing.

doi:10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2014.08.780

Oral Session 3

Emotion and decision making

Chair: Márk Molnár (Hungary)

Risky and cautious choice-making — Age-dependent changes offeedback related negativity in a gambling task

Márk Molnár, Zsófia K. Kardos, Roland Boha, Bálint File, Brigitta TóthInstitute of Cognitive Neuroscience and Psychology, Research Centre forNatural Sciences, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary

Choice behavior is influenced bymotivation in which processing offeedback stimuli plays an important role. The neural systems behindreward and punishment that guide these processes are more or lessclear but less is known how these are modified by aging. The aim ofthe present study was to analyze the age-related differences in risk-taking behavior by using electrophysiological methods. 25 young(mean age: 21.76 yrs) and 23 elderly (mean age: 66.87 yrs) partici-pated in the study. The subjects performed a monetary gambling taskin which they had to choose between low or high stakes both withpossible gain or lose outcomes. The monetary difference between thehigh and low stake conditions was twofold. The results (gain or loss)were indicated by an outcome stimulus (green or red light). No timepressure was applied. The EEG was recorded by 64 electrodes and thefeedback related potentials (FRPs) evoked by the outcome stimuliwere analyzed. It was found that in both age groups high losses

were followed by opting for higher stakes. Of the FRPs the negativecomponent (feedback related negativity [FRN], latency: approx.250 ms) was analyzed. The amplitude of the FRN was much largerevoked by the “loss signal” than those elicited by the “gain signal” inthe young, irrespective of whether the stake was high or low. The FRNcomponent was also seen in the elderly but with lower amplitude andwith no conspicuous difference between conditions. The scalpdistribution of the FRN was different in the two age groups. Time-frequency analysis revealed a conspicuous difference between gainand lose conditions depending upon age. In conclusion, whereas overtbehavioral differences were not obvious between age groups in thecondition investigated, analysis of FRPs revealed that the processesreflected by FRN were strikingly different in the young comparedto the elderly. Characteristics of the FRN corresponded to errorassessment but were obvious only in the young. It appears that theevaluation of feedback stimuli is markedly less efficient in the elderly.

Grant support: OTKA 104332.

doi:10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2014.08.781

Decision-making in individuals with intellectual disabilitiesrevealed by near infrared spectroscopy

Hiroaki Shojia, Ayano Mizokoshib, Taichi Hirayamac, Hisaki OzakiaaCollege of Education, Ibaraki University, JapanbGraduate School of Education, Ibaraki University, JapancGraduate School of Science and Engineering, Ibaraki University, Japan

Previous studies have shown that individuals with intellectualdisabilities have difficulty in utilizing information from two differentdimensions for decision-making. For instance, individuals with intel-lectual disabilities tended to choose randomly or with only a singledimension (time or money) in the temporal discounting (TD) task,which is required to choose between a small immediate reward and alarge delayed reward. However, neural correlates of their behavioralcharacteristics on decision-making have not been clarified. Therefore,we examined cerebral activity during decision-making in individualswith intellectual disabilities using near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS).Five adolescents with intellectual disabilities (mean age 17.6 years) and15 normal adults (mean age 22.9 years) participated in this experiment.In the TD task, two apple images were presented at the left and rightside of the screen. Simultaneously, sale money and harvest day waspresented on the bottom of the images. In one side of the screen, theamount of money was relatively expensive but delayed harvest couldfail to get the apple (high risk). In the opposite side, harvest was surelypossible but sale money was relatively inexpensive (low risk). In eachtrial, participants were asked to select by touching either side of thescreen. 4 sequential trials for each 5 secondswere conducted in the taskperiod. Feedback on a total amount of money was also presented for2 seconds after the 4th trial. 20-second rest period and 22-second taskperiod were repeated twice for NIRS measurement. NIRS was recordedfrom 16 channels in frontal area (OEG-16, Spectratech). Mean values ofOxy-Hb at each channel was compared between 5-second before and22-second during the task period. In normal adults, response patternbased on trade-off between reward value and time delaywas observed.Therefore,waveforms of bloodflowwere averaged over trials indicatingsuch a pattern. As a result, the concentration changes in Oxy-Hb duringthe task period significantly increased in left dorsolateral prefrontalcortex (DLPFC). In individualswith intellectual disabilities, therewas noresponse pattern based on the trade-off in every trial. However,increment of Oxy-Hb in left DLPFCwas observed during the task periodin two individuals with intellectual disabilities. Focusing on theirbehavioral data, their response was decided by utilizing informationfrom two different dimensions although it was not rational trade-off.

International Journal of Psychophysiology 94 (2014) 120–261186