2
Middle Kingdom Art in Egypt by Cyril Aldred Review by: Nora Scott Artibus Asiae, Vol. 14, No. 1/2 (1951), p. 196 Published by: Artibus Asiae Publishers Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3248696 . Accessed: 10/11/2012 15:07 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. . Artibus Asiae Publishers is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Artibus Asiae. http://www.jstor.org

Rew. Middle Kingdom Art in Egypt by Cyril Aldred

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Middle Kingdom Art in Egypt by Cyril Aldred

Citation preview

  • Middle Kingdom Art in Egypt by Cyril AldredReview by: Nora ScottArtibus Asiae, Vol. 14, No. 1/2 (1951), p. 196Published by: Artibus Asiae PublishersStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3248696 .Accessed: 10/11/2012 15:07

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

    .JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

    .

    Artibus Asiae Publishers is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Artibus Asiae.

    http://www.jstor.org

    http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=artibushttp://www.jstor.org/stable/3248696?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • The book is produced in the sumptuous style that

    one has come to expect from the Boston Museum

    of Fine Arts. Nevertheless, with a stricter measure

    of economy the text might have been more suc-

    cinct and easier to find one's way about in. Really

    stimulating observations are hidden away so that

    one despairs of finding them for a second reading. But by and large, this is a book of facts, on which

    the student must draw to support or refute his

    own fancies.

    Metropolitan Museum of Art Nora Scott

    Cyril Aldred, Middle Kingdom Art in Egypt. 5o pp.,

    83pl. Alec Tiranti, London, Ig50o. 61-. This is the second of the three volumes in which

    Mr. Aldred has set out to discuss Egyptian art up to the Amarneh age. It is to be hoped that he will

    continue his study to cover the entire dynastic

    period, for nowhere else is there a comparable treatment of the subject. Clear and concise, well

    printed, with many carefully selected illustrations,

    and - an important point - remarkably inex-

    pensive, the two volumes which have now appeared

    help to fill a surprising gap in the literature of

    Egyptology. Mr. Aldred pratically limits his discussion to sculp-

    ture, "the most forceful and characteristic expres-

    sion of the artistic genius of the Egyptian, which

    alone can provide a common standard for measuring

    the development of his aesthetic ideas throughout

    the ages. Like its predecessor, Middle Kingdom Art consists of an introductory essay and a brief

    historical summary, followed by detailed notes on

    the plates. The introduction compares the art of

    the Old and Middle Kingdoms, discusses the

    religious, political, and social backgrounds of the

    Middle Kingdom, and sums up the points made in

    the notes, emphasizing the development of style

    The book is produced in the sumptuous style that

    one has come to expect from the Boston Museum

    of Fine Arts. Nevertheless, with a stricter measure

    of economy the text might have been more suc-

    cinct and easier to find one's way about in. Really

    stimulating observations are hidden away so that

    one despairs of finding them for a second reading. But by and large, this is a book of facts, on which

    the student must draw to support or refute his

    own fancies.

    Metropolitan Museum of Art Nora Scott

    Cyril Aldred, Middle Kingdom Art in Egypt. 5o pp.,

    83pl. Alec Tiranti, London, Ig50o. 61-. This is the second of the three volumes in which

    Mr. Aldred has set out to discuss Egyptian art up to the Amarneh age. It is to be hoped that he will

    continue his study to cover the entire dynastic

    period, for nowhere else is there a comparable treatment of the subject. Clear and concise, well

    printed, with many carefully selected illustrations,

    and - an important point - remarkably inex-

    pensive, the two volumes which have now appeared

    help to fill a surprising gap in the literature of

    Egyptology. Mr. Aldred pratically limits his discussion to sculp-

    ture, "the most forceful and characteristic expres-

    sion of the artistic genius of the Egyptian, which

    alone can provide a common standard for measuring

    the development of his aesthetic ideas throughout

    the ages. Like its predecessor, Middle Kingdom Art consists of an introductory essay and a brief

    historical summary, followed by detailed notes on

    the plates. The introduction compares the art of

    the Old and Middle Kingdoms, discusses the

    religious, political, and social backgrounds of the

    Middle Kingdom, and sums up the points made in

    the notes, emphasizing the development of style

    The book is produced in the sumptuous style that

    one has come to expect from the Boston Museum

    of Fine Arts. Nevertheless, with a stricter measure

    of economy the text might have been more suc-

    cinct and easier to find one's way about in. Really

    stimulating observations are hidden away so that

    one despairs of finding them for a second reading. But by and large, this is a book of facts, on which

    the student must draw to support or refute his

    own fancies.

    Metropolitan Museum of Art Nora Scott

    Cyril Aldred, Middle Kingdom Art in Egypt. 5o pp.,

    83pl. Alec Tiranti, London, Ig50o. 61-. This is the second of the three volumes in which

    Mr. Aldred has set out to discuss Egyptian art up to the Amarneh age. It is to be hoped that he will

    continue his study to cover the entire dynastic

    period, for nowhere else is there a comparable treatment of the subject. Clear and concise, well

    printed, with many carefully selected illustrations,

    and - an important point - remarkably inex-

    pensive, the two volumes which have now appeared

    help to fill a surprising gap in the literature of

    Egyptology. Mr. Aldred pratically limits his discussion to sculp-

    ture, "the most forceful and characteristic expres-

    sion of the artistic genius of the Egyptian, which

    alone can provide a common standard for measuring

    the development of his aesthetic ideas throughout

    the ages. Like its predecessor, Middle Kingdom Art consists of an introductory essay and a brief

    historical summary, followed by detailed notes on

    the plates. The introduction compares the art of

    the Old and Middle Kingdoms, discusses the

    religious, political, and social backgrounds of the

    Middle Kingdom, and sums up the points made in

    the notes, emphasizing the development of style

    from the beginning of the XI to the XIII Dynasty. The author distinguishes two schools of art, a

    northern and a southern, the products of two

    different cultures, the former (connected with

    Memphis) stimulated by sun worship and continu-

    ing the naturalistic tradition of the Old Kingdom. The triumph of the cult of Osiris in the early Middle Kingdom, he believes, encouraged the more

    sombre and massive architecture and the formalized

    style of sculpture which became associated with

    Thebes.

    The plates include a number of illustrations not

    generally available. Of particular interest is no. 81,

    a statue from the Hapsburg collection, which

    would almost certainly be classed as Saite were it

    not for the inscription, which has the name and

    title of a well-known XIII Dynasty official.

    Metropolitan Museum of Art Nora Scott

    Schuyler Camman, " The Land of the Camel."

    New York, The Ronald Press Co. 197 pp., with

    map and 39 photographic illustrations.

    As an officer of the U. S. Navy, Dr. Schuyler

    Camman, now associated with the Chinese de-

    partment of the Museum of the University of

    Pennsylvania, was ordered in August, 1945 to

    deliver a valuable truckload of supplies to an

    American weather outpost near Shanpa in the

    Suiyuan Province of Inner Mongolia. This book

    describes with a wealth of detail the country, the

    people and their food, shelter, costumes and

    customs, and especially the lama temples of the

    area he was able to observe during a stay of

    approximately three months, made necessary by the breakdown of his six-wheel truck.

    Dr. Camman had visited Suiyuan Province briefly in 1936 as a student of Far Eastern peoples and

    their cultures. This background, plus his command

    from the beginning of the XI to the XIII Dynasty. The author distinguishes two schools of art, a

    northern and a southern, the products of two

    different cultures, the former (connected with

    Memphis) stimulated by sun worship and continu-

    ing the naturalistic tradition of the Old Kingdom. The triumph of the cult of Osiris in the early Middle Kingdom, he believes, encouraged the more

    sombre and massive architecture and the formalized

    style of sculpture which became associated with

    Thebes.

    The plates include a number of illustrations not

    generally available. Of particular interest is no. 81,

    a statue from the Hapsburg collection, which

    would almost certainly be classed as Saite were it

    not for the inscription, which has the name and

    title of a well-known XIII Dynasty official.

    Metropolitan Museum of Art Nora Scott

    Schuyler Camman, " The Land of the Camel."

    New York, The Ronald Press Co. 197 pp., with

    map and 39 photographic illustrations.

    As an officer of the U. S. Navy, Dr. Schuyler

    Camman, now associated with the Chinese de-

    partment of the Museum of the University of

    Pennsylvania, was ordered in August, 1945 to

    deliver a valuable truckload of supplies to an

    American weather outpost near Shanpa in the

    Suiyuan Province of Inner Mongolia. This book

    describes with a wealth of detail the country, the

    people and their food, shelter, costumes and

    customs, and especially the lama temples of the

    area he was able to observe during a stay of

    approximately three months, made necessary by the breakdown of his six-wheel truck.

    Dr. Camman had visited Suiyuan Province briefly in 1936 as a student of Far Eastern peoples and

    their cultures. This background, plus his command

    from the beginning of the XI to the XIII Dynasty. The author distinguishes two schools of art, a

    northern and a southern, the products of two

    different cultures, the former (connected with

    Memphis) stimulated by sun worship and continu-

    ing the naturalistic tradition of the Old Kingdom. The triumph of the cult of Osiris in the early Middle Kingdom, he believes, encouraged the more

    sombre and massive architecture and the formalized

    style of sculpture which became associated with

    Thebes.

    The plates include a number of illustrations not

    generally available. Of particular interest is no. 81,

    a statue from the Hapsburg collection, which

    would almost certainly be classed as Saite were it

    not for the inscription, which has the name and

    title of a well-known XIII Dynasty official.

    Metropolitan Museum of Art Nora Scott

    Schuyler Camman, " The Land of the Camel."

    New York, The Ronald Press Co. 197 pp., with

    map and 39 photographic illustrations.

    As an officer of the U. S. Navy, Dr. Schuyler

    Camman, now associated with the Chinese de-

    partment of the Museum of the University of

    Pennsylvania, was ordered in August, 1945 to

    deliver a valuable truckload of supplies to an

    American weather outpost near Shanpa in the

    Suiyuan Province of Inner Mongolia. This book

    describes with a wealth of detail the country, the

    people and their food, shelter, costumes and

    customs, and especially the lama temples of the

    area he was able to observe during a stay of

    approximately three months, made necessary by the breakdown of his six-wheel truck.

    Dr. Camman had visited Suiyuan Province briefly in 1936 as a student of Far Eastern peoples and

    their cultures. This background, plus his command

    I96 I96 I96

    Article Contentsp.196Issue Table of ContentsArtibus Asiae, Vol. 14, No. 1/2 (1951), pp. i-xiii+1-204Volume Information [pp.i-xiii]Front Matter [pp.1-3]Find of Tempera Painting in Stbhiji, District Keojhr, Orissa [pp.5-25]The Yeh-Chou Yao Celadon Excavated in Japan [pp.26-42]Japanese Monochrome Painting at Seattle [pp.43-61]Date and Provenance of Death Masks of the Far East [pp.62-71]Some Refined Tool-Shapes of the Mongolian Stone Age [pp.72-76]Ordos Daggers and Knives: New Material, Classification and Chronology. Second Part: Knives [pp.77-162]Hiroshi Yoshida, 1876-1950 [pp.163-168]Histoire Ancienne de la Sibrie du Sud. Matriaux et recherches archologiques en U.R.S.S. [pp.169-189]In Memoriam: Roswell Sessoms Britton (Died February 2, 1951) [pp.190-191]Bibliographiauntitled [pp.192-195]untitled [pp.195-196]untitled [p.196]untitled [pp.196-197]untitled [pp.197-198]untitled [p.198]untitled [pp.198-202]untitled [p.202]untitled [pp.202-203]untitled [p.203]untitled [pp.203-204]untitled [p.204]