24
Revised Destination in Parking Management Kyle Karwowski Ryan Cook Valerie Smith Gwen Webster Alex Flood Shakeel Balroop George Doo April 21 2008

Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Kyle Karwowski

Ryan Cook

Valerie Smith

Gwen Webster

Alex Flood

Shakeel Balroop

George Doo

April 21 2008

Page 2: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Project Introduction

Purpose

Examine parking in downtown East Lansing

Analyze free parking

– Effect to Business

– How and When

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 3: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Project Clients

City of East Lansing, Michigan– Daniel O’Connor, Parking Department

– Timothy H. Dempsey, Department of Planning &

Community Development

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 4: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Presentation Overview

Current Situation

and System

Practices in Parking

Management

Recommendation

on Free

Implementation

Phases

Problems

Findings

Solutions

Improvement

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 5: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Current Situation and System

Page 6: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Who parks downtown

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 7: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

How users think of downtown parking

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 8: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Source: City of East Lansing

West area Core area East area

N

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 9: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Utilization throughout day

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 10: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Fees and enforcement

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 11: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Signage and Way-finding

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 12: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Practices in Parking Management

Page 13: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Provides attractive system for shopping

Free period varies by cities

Free parking findings

Incentivize parking in certain locations

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 14: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Innovations– Cash key

– Pay by cell

– Vehicle detection technology

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 15: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Innovations– Signage and Way-finding

– Marketing and branding

– Customer service

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 16: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Recommendation on Free

Page 17: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

“Free” parking, free?

Free parking needs proper implementation

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 18: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

“Free” parking is viable for East Lansing

Considerations of free parking

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 19: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Implementation Phases

Page 20: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Phase one: Groundwork

Improve user awareness

Increase parking turn over

New parking payment options

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 21: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

21

Phase two: Implement free parkingMinimize direct user expense

Free parking in ramps after 4 p.m.

Cost for free parking $288,000 Annually

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 22: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

22

Two funding mechanisms

Special Assessment, Indirect

Requires $0.25 per square

footRaise user fees, Semi-Direct

Requires $0.05 per half hour

increase

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 23: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

23

Summary

Current system has opportunity

Practices can be enhanced

Free parking–feasible and wise

Must occur after system changes

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 24: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in

Parking Ramps and Garages

N

Lo

t 9

Free parking locations

Revised Destination in Parking Management