27
Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR INTRODUCTION THE MANUFACTURE AND USE of Tridacna adzes have long been associated with cul- tures inhabiting atolls and raised coral islands in the Pacific region. A survey of the archaeological and ethnographic literature reveals that Tridacna adze blades have been on numerous islands as establishing broad range island b:;bltats for the of these the study adzes by archaeologists has almost exclu- sively on typological classification and culture-hIstorical relationships (Kennedy 1931; Thompson 1932; Spoehr 1957; Osborne 1966; Rosendahl 1969; Davidson 1971; Garanger 1972; Craib 1977; Ward 1979; Takayama and Intoh 1980; Kirch and Yen 1982; Sinoto 1984), with primary analytic emphasis given to the form and style of blade. The (Tridacna spp. rarely, Hippoplls hippopus) from which have received al attention. to consider their morphological and the relevance of these to tool and efficiency, The Tridacnidae as components of reef ecosystems, together with their microenvi- ronmental requirements for life, suggest a different focus for investigation that may have important implications for archaeological research, article surveys ecology of two (Tridacna) gigas Tridacna maxima often iden- tifIed Tridacna adze Jssemblages-and the recorded distribution of Tri- dacna adze blades throughout the Pacific from an ecological perspective. It offers five propositions that might be of use to archaeologists in the development of an ecologi- cally based model of Tridacna adze distribution. Finally, it underscores the signif- icance of;J multidisciplinary approach to the of material and suggests that as well cultural variables affect the form geographical assemblages. Moir is alIili,llcd the Anthropology Department of the of Hawaii· Malloa

Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications

for Archaeological Research

Received 20 1985

BARBARA G. MOIR

INTRODUCTION

THE MANUFACTURE AND USE of Tridacna adzes have long been associated with cul­tures inhabiting atolls and raised coral islands in the Pacific region. A survey of the archaeological and ethnographic literature reveals that Tridacna adze blades have been on numerous islands as establishing broad range island b:;bltats for the of these

the study adzes by archaeologists has almost exclu-sively on typological classification and culture-hIstorical relationships (Kennedy 1931; Thompson 1932; Spoehr 1957; Osborne 1966; Rosendahl 1969; Davidson 1971; Garanger 1972; Craib 1977; Ward 1979; Takayama and Intoh 1980; Kirch and Yen 1982; Sinoto 1984), with primary analytic emphasis given to the form and style of blade. The mateml~ (Tridacna spp. rarely, Hippoplls hippopus) from which have received al attention. to consider their morphological and the relevance of these to tool and efficiency, The Tridacnidae as components of reef ecosystems, together with their microenvi­ronmental requirements for life, suggest a different focus for investigation that may have important implications for archaeological research,

article surveys ecology of two (Tridacna) gigas Tridacna maxima often iden-

tifIed Tridacna adze Jssemblages-and the recorded distribution of Tri-dacna adze blades throughout the Pacific from an ecological perspective. It offers five propositions that might be of use to archaeologists in the development of an ecologi­cally based model of Tridacna adze distribution. Finally, it underscores the signif-icance of;J multidisciplinary approach to the of material and suggests that as well cultural variables affect the form geographical

assemblages.

Moir is alIili,llcd the Anthropology Department of the of Hawaii· Malloa

Page 2: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

),1

Page 3: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR
Page 4: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

98 Perspectives, 986-1987

tions are believed to maintain themselves through "recruitment" of juveniles that develop from the gametes of local adults (Yamaguchi 1977)-i.e., the majority of

tcnd to settle metamorphose vIcinity of their and short-term scientific data demonstrate considerable variability in the

of T. gigas. specimens annual increases· shell length of 51 mm (Rosewater 1965), from 50-80 mm (Bonham 1965), from 80-120 mm (Beckvar 1981), and means of 55 mm (J. Munro, pers. comm.) and 142 mm (Ham­ner n.d.) during the respective periods of investigation. There is also evidence for marked variation in tridacnid growth rates relative to latitude (Munro and Gwyther 1981; and Pearson Munro n.d.) habitat-e.g.,

gigas ft)und on and in more turbid sites near areas human activity even arnong rncmbers ofthc same apparent cohort under uniform environmental conditions (McKoy 1980; Beckvar 1981; Munro and Heslinga 1983).

McMichael (1974) measured the growth of different size classes of T. maxima under natural conditions; annual mean increment ranged mm (for the

to 38 rn (srnaUest clams). tridacnids, increment appears be a function size of the first measurement; the rate growth seems to be most rapid during the early years of life, slowmg as the clam grows larger (McMichael 1974; Yamaguchi 1977; Beckvar 1981; Romanek et al. 1987; Pearson and Munro n.d.). Specimens of T. maxima have achieved shell lengths of 35 em, while T. gigas hds been known to re:leb more than 1 m in length (Rose­water but in extant populations of such appear to be rare.

Nourishment

The Tridacnidae, like most bivalves, are filter feeders of phytoplankton, and they absorb dissolved inorgamc nutrients from (Fankboner, Coreau et aL

the gre;ltcst metabolic benefit, is obtained throllgh a highly method of nourishment that is 11l1lque among (Rosewater

1965). In addition to extracting nutrients from phytoplankton and utilizing dis­solved inorganic substances found in seawater, tridacnids also harbor and benefit from vast numbers of zooxanthellae-unicellular algae residing in the haemal

the clam's siphon J 936; Muscatine 1967; Trench et ; 1;lsher et aL and to a lesser extent in the stomach, and

tract (Goreau 1973; Trench 1981). Zooxanthellae are also found m the hermatypic corals. The highly developed association of these algae and the Tridacnidae is reflected in the clams' morphology, habits, and the environmental conditions under which they occur (Rosewater 1965; Goreau et al. 1973; Yonge 1974).

uptake of zooxanthellae from environment occurs ll1

stage of clarn development (Fit! Trench 1981). C::olcHlies of these infest the inner folds of mantle. When by the tide,

these folds extend laterally from the gaping valves and are maximally exposed to sunlight, permitting photosynthesis to take place within the znoxanthellae. Tridac­nids may receive some food energy via digestion of the algae, but the primary meta-bolic believed from released photosynthates et al. 1973;

Trench et specifically and alanine 1967).

Page 5: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR
Page 6: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

100 Perspectives, 1986-1987

For marine fauna in general, temperature ranges favorable to reproduction and juvenile development are far more narrow than those tolerated by adult individuals

a1. 1954). providing a condition spawning, how-temperature important determining ;It which the tridacnid anilnal precIpItate carbonate seawater for the

formation of its shell (Sverdrup et a1. 1954; Romanek et a!. 1987).

SEAWATER CLARITY

The clear water habitat of tridacnids facilitates the transmission of light to their zooxanthcllar symbionts. and Hardy found thJt limiting depth (10~20 for the growth reefs was deterrnincd in large part by water's clarity, the insufficiency light for at depths greater than this (see also Brown and Muskanofola 1985). Their study of Tridacna ecology in Belau revealed the following microhabitat distributions for T. gigas and T. maxima: both were very seldom found in the bays, occasionally in the lagoons, and often in the w;lters of the and barrier T'he primary

difference these microhabltats is that of clarity, with providing condition 1940).

On Fanning Atoll, Kay and Switzer (1974) found the lagoon basIn effectively divided into a clear-water area near the deep reef pass (transparency to 10-15 m), and turbid-water sectors elsewhere (transparency less than 2 m). Distribution of T. max­ima (the only tridacnid species present) was confined to the dear lagoon, where massive cOfJls (Porites permitted settlement above carbonate mud sedirncnts. However, Tridacna found in exposed sections fossil reefs. occurrence in presently devoid livmg Tridacna suggests changes in lagoon character associated with the closure of former reef passes that would have affected water clarity, coral growth, and/or sea level.

Renaud-Mornant et al. (1971) demonstrated the confinement of T. maxima dis-tribution an atoll in Tuarnotus to the shallow, transparent depths of that atoll's Their data underscore the of seawater to tridacnid survivaL Moreover, studies the geomorphological effects of storms on coral reefs suggest that increased turbidity of reef waters following erosion may delay recovery of hermatypic corals (and their faunal associations) for as many as 30 years (Stoddart 1971).

SEA WATER SALINITY

are found with salinity of near 35 mInImUm salinity level tolerated by tridaCiuds is not known, but it may be related to that of the hermatypic corals with which they are associated; tropical corals have been reported to withstand a 20 percent reduction in the salinity of their environment (Sverdrup et a1. 1954). Tridacna gigas has been successfully maintained in raceways at a level of 32

1981; 1984) and sites, together T. maxima, at ppt (Munro Gwyther 1981)

opposite end spectrum, at species of known to tolerate higher saline levels than those normally found in the open ocean. Tridacna maxima occurs in enormous numbers in the closed lagoons ofReao, Maturei Vavao, and Takapoto atolls in the Tuamotus, which have salinity levels of 37.5, 37.5, and 43 respectively 1970; Renaud-Mornant et a1. 1971; J. Newhouse, pers,

Page 7: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR
Page 8: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

102 xxvu(1), 1986-1987

Tridacna populations. normal maintenance of through local recruitment adults, it would be reasonable that intensive might well result in decimation extinction of a species (Wells et a1. 1983). Should this happen, it would be unlikely to recover without reintroduction (Yamaguchi 1977; Hirschberger 1980; Hamner n.d.). Studies by Hardy and Hardy (1969) and by Bryan and McConnel (1976) indi­cate a substantial decline in population densities for larger tridacnid species on the reefs of Belau; this decline is viewed as the direct result of overfishing for the export of shell (see also Hester and Jones 1974). In recent years T. gigas has become extinct in the waters offPohnpei, Truk, and Kosrae, presumably as a consequence of human exploitation (Heslinga Tal\vanese fishing vessels, in known to poach the adductor muscle-abandoning maining flesh of the and vulnerable reefs in the (Pearson 1977; Wankowski and Munro 1981; Hamner n.d.a). In the the success of any Tridacna would have been density oflocal human settlernent extent and rate of rates of tridacnid reproduction, and growth do not keep pace with the demand for this resource, human behavior creates a marginal habitat for the Tridacnidae.

The conditions necessary for tridacnid life are also found to combine in ways that permit a high level of species richness, but where competition for resources may limit the number of individuals the habitat can support. These combinations may be termed competitive habitats. Open atolls (with three or more deep reef passes) in par­ticular, and those fringing and barrier reef areas unaffected by freshwater runoff and siltation, are examples of hahitats, where the basic ments for tridacnid which are characterized by richness but lower for some species. The researches and Richard (Salvat 1971 b, 1971c, 1972, 1973; Richard 1971, 1972) have contrast in molluscan tion and individual atollslreefs and closed systems differ of open seawater and lagoon corresponding differences m clrculation, salinity, and turbidity. Open recf systems apparently offer conditions favorable to a variety of tridacnid species, but competi­tion for available resources may restrict the number of individuals of some species to comparatively low levels.

The findings of Richard and Salvat suggest a third combination of environmental variables that affect the ecological success of the Tridacnidae: the exceptional habitat. Here too are found all the basic requirements for tridacnid survival, but they com­bine with low faunal diversity and minimal competition for resources to comprise a habitat wherein the rnay be exceptionally successfllL example of this habitat IS concerned may be the ing deep reef passes), forms (with one or two appear to offer Radtke et a1. (n.d.) found reef of Rose Atoll support a single tridacnid ima, at a density of per m2 . Studies by Richard the benthic fauna Pukarua, Marutea, Pukapub, Maturei Vavao, Fangataufa, and Vahitahi atolls in the Tuamotus-all of them closed-revealed T. maxima (the only tridacnid present) to be dominant among all

Page 9: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR
Page 10: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

104 xxvu(1),1986-1987

found together on atolls, T. maxima will be reef biotopes while only rarely and only on the These impressions propositions that relate variables (habitat) to ecological variables (success ofTridacnidae):

P1: Open and semi closed atolls (with one or more deep reef passes) will be character­ized by a greater diversity of Tridacnidae species than will closed atolls (lacking such passes), within the distributional overlap of any or all species.

P2: Within the distributional range of T. gigas, open and semiclosed atolls will be found to support viable populations of this species in both reef and lagoon biotopes. Populations of T. gigas will rarely occur on closed atolls within the range of this species. represented on a closed atoll within will be as the outer reef and not in the closed

Tridacna Technology A fundamental tndacnid ecology is essential to

made from this comparative analyses of tween island groups and across habitats. Within the distributional overlap of '1'. gigas and T. maxima, prehistoric human populations on open and semi closed atolls, or on islands with associated reefs, may have had ready access to more species of Tridacna for tool material than did communities living on closed atolls. If this were the case, one might anticipate the tool kits of the former to be representative of more Tridacna species than those of the latter. It might be argued that whereas open reef systems offered competitive habitats for both T. gigas and T. maxima, closed atolls constituted only marginal bhitats for T. gigas but competitive or even habitats for T. differences in the availability of might correspond extent to which they were material.

These speculations relate environmental

the form of the following material culture variables

P3: Within the T. gigas and T. maxima, Tridilwa manufactured and used by the prehistoric inhabitants of open and semi closed atolls, or of volcanic and raised coral islands with associated reefs, will in general include blades made from the valves of both species.

P4: Within the distributional overlap of T. gigas and T. maxima, Tridacna adze kits manufactured and used by the prehistoric inhabitants of closed atolls will in general be characterized only by blades made from the valves of T. maxima. The low frequency with which T. gigas populations occur in this environmental context suggests the possibility of external origins for locally recovered tools made from this materiaL

Artifactual and data (Moir n. d. b, 1989; BPBM lections) indicate gigas valve were utilized than was the case tridacnid valves. Valve features from T. gigas adze hinge line, individual radial line plus anterior umbonal region (Fig. 2). By ima blades were fashioned primarily from the valve body between the dorsal margin (lip) and ventral/hinge lines (Fig. 3)-an area frequently misidentified by

Page 11: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

MOIR: TRU)ACNID ECOLOGY AND POSSIBLE IMPLICATIONS

o "0

l\RCHAE010C;ICAL RESEARCH

a: o 0:0 wZ I-W Z «

o a:0 wZ I-W

Q) 0lQ)

- c.:: .c.

o

Page 12: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

106

ANTER 10 R E D

Perspectives, 1986-1987

Exterior and intetior of valves of (Chametrachea) maxima ([(c,ding). Valve section most often identified from T. maxima adze blades is outlined.

as the lip "-as were H. hippopU5 preforms re-Takuu h) and another Bikini (c. llnpublished

data). same region squamosa also have lIsed for blade material (Sinoto 1984), as well as the thicker UInbonal section (Moir n. d. b). In gener­al, owing to their proportionately greater mass, the umbonal and hinge line areas of a mature T. gigas valve would have yielded a more plastic tool material than the corresponding features of the valves of smaller species. Given this greater morpho-logical and the that more the T. gigas were used for tool than of other t.ridacnid valves, be argued inhabitants of open semiclosed atolls Islands with associated reefs 'T"ridacna adze kits characterized by a greater diversity of blade form than those produced on closed atolls.

This suggests a further environmental-material proposition:

the distributional overlap of T. gl.~ill T. maxima, adze kits manufactured and the prehistOriC .inhahitants of semiclosed

or of volcanic raised coral islands associated character-ized by a greater diversity of blade form than will those produced on closed atolls.

These last three propositions may easily be tested, initially through a careful ex­amination of the available literature and collections, and more rigorously through

investigation. The findings interpreted the perspec-

Page 13: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR
Page 14: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

TABI.J~ J'FIlDACNA ADZES ON VOLCANIC ISLANDS

T.gigas

(Belau)l,z*.*'

Fefan3

Guam4

Kosrae5.6 .7

Lelepa8

Okinawa9

Palawan lO

Pohnpei 11.12.13.14.15

Retoka8

Sanga Sanga 10 Santa Cruz l6

Tikopia 17

To1'8,19

Tongoa8 (Truk)20 Yap7,21

Buka24

(Belau)I.2 Efate8,25

Erromanga22

Fila25

Futuna, West25

Guam4,26.27 Kosrae6,28

Lelepa8

Santa Cruz l6

Tikopia 17.36 To)l8.19

Tongoa8

Vanikoro37 Yap38

• Localities in parentheses indicate island was unspecified .

Buka4')

Efate8

Ishigaki41 ,42 New Britain8

New Ireland43,44

Niuatoputapu45 Pohnpei33,46 Rota34,47 Rotuma35,48,49

• * Data sources: 1, Osborne 1900; 2. Gllmerman et a!. 1981; 3, Sinoto 1984; 4, Hiro & Clayshulte 1981; 5, Bath & Shun 1982; 8, Garanger 1972; 9, O.P.B.E 11, Christian 1899; 12. 1980; 14, Athens 1984; 15, Rosendahl McCoy (unpub!. data); T"kayarn:l & Seki 1973; 19, Takayama & 1 1964; 21, D. Rubinstein Spriggs (unpub1. data); 23, Kirch & Wickler (unpubL data); j 966; 26, Hiro et al. 1982; 27, Hunter-Anderson Athens et aJ. 1983; 29, Clay 1974; 31, Thompson 1932; Ayres et a1. n.d.; 34, Gardiner 1898; 36, Kirch & Yen 38, Gifford & Gifford Specht 1969; 41, Kokubu & Kaneko 1969; 43, White 1972; Rogers 1974; 46, Sarfert 1913; 47. 48, Eason 1951; 49, Parke 1964.

TABLE 2. RECORDS OF TRIDACNA ADZES ON RAISED CORAL ISLANDS

1'. gigas

Banaba I' Fais2

Pakea3

Pur4

Sonsorol4

Tobi5

T. maxima

Banaba l

Bellona6

F~js2

UNIDENTIFIED Tridacna SP.

Fulanga l2

Malden t3

Namllb l2

• Data sources: 1, Lan'lwn (pers. comm.); 3, L Groube, 4, Eilers 1935; 5, Eilers 1936; 6, Poulsen J972; 7, Rosendahl 1987; 8, Krause 1906; 9, Ward 1979; 10, Sarfert & Damm 1935; II, Moir (unpub!. data); 12, Thompson 1938; 13. Dixon 1878; 14, M, Spriggs (unpuhl. data); 15, Loeb 1926; 16, Poulsen 1964.

Page 15: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

TRIDACNID ECOLOGY AND POSSIBLE IMPLICATIONS fOR ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH

TABLE 3. RECORDS OF Tridawi2 ADZES ON OPEN, SE,MICLOSED, AND CLOSED ATOLLS

Open atoll tAilinglaplapl tAnd2

tAur 1

tBikilli3 tEIoaua-Emananus4

(Mussau Is,) tE~rJulapS

tFunafuti6

tJaluit7

tK wajalein8 tLamotrek 1.5.9 tLikiepl tMaloelap' tNgulu 'O

tNukununu"· 12 tNukuria 11 ,12

tOntongJava ll . 13 tSikai.lll:l 1:l,15 tTabltcuca 16

Tongareva 17

tUlithiI8.19.20

tWoleai 21

tWotho l

tWotje l

Semic/osed atoll tArno l •22

Atalu23

tEbon 1

tlfaluk1'()

tKa pi n gam arangi24.25 tLae' tMajuro1.26 tNgatik27

tNonomi l6

tNukufetau28

tNukuorolS.29.30

tOnotoa '6 tPuluwat31

ISatawan32 tTakuu"· 13.33

atoll Cbmtmas34 tEtaj32

Fang:1 Ll" fa ls

Manihiki l5.36

tMokil' tNanumea28

Napuka3S

tNiutao28

tPingelap' Pubpuka37

T gigas

x

X

X X

X X X

X

X

X

X

X X

X

T maxima

x X X X X

X

X

X

X X X X X X

X X

X

X X

X X X

UNlDENTIHED

Tridacna SP,

X

X

X

X

X

X X

X

X

X

X X

X

X

X

X

Page 16: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR
Page 17: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

MOIR: TRJDACNID ECOLOGY AND POSSIBLE IMPLICAHONS FOR ARCHAEOLOCICAL RESEARCH 111

early evidence that such a trade link existed between Belau and Yap (Muller 1917)­T. ~i~as blades or valves were reportedly brought from Belau (where the species was

to Yap was not, except ancient valves in coral)-hypothesize similar situation obtained on Lamotrek. a volcanic with associated situated within distributional

extent of T. gigas, this species may be expected to have inhabited those reefs in the past. Subsequent local extinction of T. gigas may have been related to adverse en­vironmental conditions (e.g., sedimentation of reefs following one of the typhoons

the area) or overcxploitation humans. This may been the case as well, that an extant of T. have been

reduced rather completely ina ted. While and Alkire found no ltve T. gigas specimens on Lamotrek during their research in 1976, a "relict" population was reported there by marine biologists a decade later (Munro n.d.), specimens that probably had been overlooked by the archaeologists. This suggests that Lamotrek may well have been a viable habitat for T. }?~iZaS in the past; that population bivalves cou Id supplied the m~lterial for the adzc recovered and in the sequenee (perhaps more than environment~ll cultural were instrumental reducing the T. gigas population to an extremely low level. It is also possible, of course, that the large Tridacna adze blades recovered by Fujimura and Alkire-or the raw materials themselves-were obtained from external sources.

~amotrek's embedded valves could serve P2 for prehistoric Lamotrek, by to deter-mine Tridacna Vi/ere present on atoll in earlier Evidence for prehistoric local population of T. gigas would simplify the archaeologist's search for the source of this tool material. The possibility of external origins for T. gigas tools recovered from Lamotrek would not be discounted, but might be argued less con­vincingly on environmental-ecological grounds in the face of J local supply of raw material. The artifactual from Fujimura Alkire's (1977, excavations support the adze includes blades from marc one species of Tridama, apparently including T. gigas.

A closed atoll in the eastern Carolines would offer an equally interesting oppor­tunity for tests of P1, P2, and P4. Some 150 km distant from the volcanic island of Pohnpei, Mokil Atoll lacks deep reef passes that can be navigated by ship. Bryan (1971) recorded four "canoe passages" the north and reef sectors, one has been to accom small motorized craft. Mokil is located within the distributional range of but reportedly not toda y support a population of this species (A. Sepedi, pers. comm.). Rosendahl (1979) conducted a reconnaissance survey of Mokil, focusing on a traditional chiefly resi­dence site, and recovered a number of artifacts from the surface and from infor-mants, Among these Tridacna adze (illustrated Rosendahl 1987 and in Table appear to manufactured quite mas-sIve hinges, and from valves , gigas. The survey rep on (1979) does not specify whether these two blades were obtained through surface collection or from informants. In the latter case, information regarding the context and history of the artifacts' possession by informants would provide a more solid basis for establishing their cultural provenience.

survey Mokll's reef and biotopes, both speCImens

Page 18: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

) ,

Page 19: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

MOIR: TRIDACNID ECOLOCY

rials indigenous to assume a local source with every type of

L\;lPLlCATIONS FOR ARCHAEOLOGICM.

neither, perhaps, would recovered from cultural deposits

Procedures for tracing the sources of Tridacna materials to individual island groups, similar to those for sourcing volcanic glass and pottery tempers, have not been and may never be developed. Nonetheless, the formulation and testing of environmental-ecological correlates (such as Pl and P2) should contribute to our awareness of the ecology of these species. An improved understanding of the habits and habitats of the Tridacnidae would allow archaeologists to anticipate, within known geographical distributions, the presence or absence and relative abundance of these resources in' the concepts of marginal, and exceptional species to the conditions reef system.

Further, environmental-material corrclates (such as P3, P4, and P5) us to test and to build propositions through the and island ecosysterns excavation. New evidence, including in the biological or should stimulate further and help to modify this prelirninary model in useful ways.

A multidisciplinary approach of this kind suggests that it is not enough to examine the tools of a culture apart from the ecosystemic contexts in which they occur; the materials from which tools are made are as much components of an ecosystem as are the human beings who make them. The complex associations of the Tridacnidae with their natural habitats are directly related to their ecological success, and thus to their availability for human exploitation.

EDGMENTS

This paper has with many individuals, ful for their input. access to unpublished artifact collections. Melody Actouka, Tim Adams, Joyce Bath, Robert Gerald Heslinga, Jay Kay, Patrick Kirch, Munro, Richard Radtke. Donald Rubinstein, Ahm Sepedi, Matthew Spriggs, Charles Streck, and Steven Wickler for providing data, comments, and criticism and for tolerating persistent questions. Any errors of presentation or interpretation are solely my responsibility.

ATHENS, J. S. 1980 Archaeological

Monograph 1984 Jobs Bill

submitted to

submitted to

AYRES, W. S., AND A.

REFERENCES

Lip/ Maps and Surface Artifacts. Pacifil Pacific Studies Institute. Project, Ponape, Eastern Caroline

\'ClI:ion, Trust Territory of the Pacific

AND T. UEKI

a rd1Jeological site descriptions and test Preserv.ltion, Trust Territory of the Pacific

n.d. Ponape settlement archaeology Archaeological Survey Report 79-Office of Historic Preservation, Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands, Saipan (1980). Forth­comIng.

Page 20: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

114

AYRES, W. S., A. E. n.d. Nan Madol

BARRINGTON, E.]. W.

xxvn(1),1986-1987

excavations. Report submitted Pacific Islands, Saipan.

1982 Invertebrate Structure and Function. 2nd Ed. Workingham, England: Van Nostrand Reinhold.

BATH,]' E., AND K. SHUN

1982 Archaeological salvage on Line "C": Lelu, Kosrae. Report submitted to the Historic Preserva­tion Committee, Kosrae District, Office of Historic Preservation, Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands, Saipan.

BEAGLEHOLE, E., AND P. BEAGlEHOLE

1938 Ethnology ofPukapuka. Bernice P. Bishop Museum Bulletin 150.

BECKVAR, N. 1981 Cultivation,

in Palau,

BONHAM, K. 1965 Growth ratc

S 149:300-.302.

BRALEY, R. D. 1984 Reproduction

Barrier ReeC

BROWN, J. H., AND M. R. MUSKANOFOlA

giant clams Tridacna gigas, T. 21-30.

at Bikini Atoll as revealed

gigas and T. derasa in situ on tbe Guinea. Coral Reefs 3: 221-227.

1985 An investigation of stocks of giant clams (family Tridacnidae) in Java and of their utilization and potential. Aquaculture and Fisheries Management 16(1): 25-39.

BRYAN, E. H., JR.

1971 Guide 10 Place Names in the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands. Honolulu: Pacific Scientific In­formation Center, Bernice P. Bishop Museum.

BRYAN, P. G., AND D. B. MCCONNEL

1976 Status of giant clam stocks (Tridacnidae) on Helen Reef, Palau, Western Caroline Islands, April 1975. Maritl" 38: 15-18.

BUCK, P. H. (TE RANG!

1932a Ethnology 1932b Ethnology 1950 Material culture

CHRISTIAN, F. W. 1899 The Caroline

CLAY, R. B.

Museum Bulle/in 92. P. Bishop Museum Bulletin

P. Bishop Museum Bulletin 200.

1974 Archaeological reconnaissance In central New Ireland. APAO 9(1): 1-17.

CORDY, R.

n.d. The LeW Stone Ruins, Kosrae, Micronesia. APAS, No. 10. Honolulu: Social Science Researcb Institute. Forthcoming.

CRAIB, J. L. 1977 A typological investigation of western Micronesian adzes. M. A. thesis, California State Uni­

versity, Long Beach. University Microfilms International. 1980 Archaeological survey of Ulithi Atoll, Western Caroline Islands. Pacific Studies Institute. Re­

port submitted to the Office of Historic Preservation, Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands, Saipan.

CRAWFORD, C. M.,

1986 Spawning 58:281-295.

DAVIDSON,]. M.

1971 Archaeology

DEANE, E. M., AND

1981 Uptake of 128(3) :

rearing of the giant clam, Tyid{!(lW g(~{lS.

of the Auckland Institute and Museum

free-living dinoflagellates. Arrhives

Page 21: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

MOIR: TRIDACNID ECOLOGY

DIXON, W. A. 1878 Notes on the

New South

DYE, T.

lMPLICATIONS FOR ARCHAEOLOGICAL '''',~t,''''LM

hlSlory of a guano island. Journal

1987 Archaeological survey and test excavations on Arno Atoll, Marshall Islands, in Marshall Islands Archaeology: 271-399, ed. T. Dye, Pacific Anthropological Records 38. Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press.

EASON, W. J. E.

1951 A Short History oj Rotuma. Suva, Fiji: Government Printing Office.

EILERS, A. 1935 Westkarolinen 1, Songosor, Pur, MeriT. Ergebnisse der Siidsee-Expedition 1908-1910 II, Bd. 9(1).

Hamburg: Friederichsen, de Gruyter and Company. 1936 Westkarolinm der Siidsee-Expedition 190R 1910 II.

Hamburg: C:ompany.

EMORY, K. P. 1934 Archaeology 1975 Material Cultllts

nice P. Bishop

FANKBONER, P. V.

Islands. Bernice P. Bishop Museum Bulletill. il r[fIlI),c;'llO," Pacific Anthropological Records

1971 Intracellular zooxanthellae by host amoebocytes glJllt

(Bivalvia:Tridacnidae), a note on the nutritional role of the hypenropllled siphonal epidermis. Biological Bulletin 141 :222-234.

FINSCH, 0. 1893 Ethnologische erfahrungen und belegstiicke aus der Siidsee. Annalen des K. K. Naturhistorischen

HoJmuseums 8(2). 1914 Siidseearbeiten. Hamburg: L. Friederichsen and Company.

FIRTH, R. 1959 Ritual adzes in Tikopia, in Anthropology in the South Seas: 149-159, eds. J. D. Freeman and W. R.

Geddes. New Plymouth: Thomas Avery and Sons, Ltd.

FISHER, C. R., W. K. 1985 PhotosyntheSIS

Bulletin 169:

FITT, W. K. 1984 The role of

host behavior 81 (1) :9-17.

FlIT, W. K., C. R. FISHER,

gigas as a function of irradiancc

Symbiodinium microadrialicum, intcrrnedwe coelcnterates and molluscs with zooxanthcllac,

1984 Larval biology oftridacnid clams. AquaculhlYe 39: 181-195.

FITT, W. K., AND R. K. TRENCH

1981 Spawning, development, and acquISItIOn of zooxanthellae by Tridawa squamosa (Mollusca: Bivalvia). Biological Bulletin 161 :213-235.

Fox, R. 1970 The Tabotl Caves. National Museum Monograph, No. 1. Quezon City: National Museum

Press,

FREUDENTHAL, H. D. 1962 Symbiodiniulil

life cycle, and

FUJIMURA, K., AND W, 1977 Recent excavations 1984 Archaeological

Micronesia, Records 35.

GARANGER, J.

microadriaticum sp. nov., a zoox,mthdla: oj' Protozoology 9: 45-52.

Caroline Islands: a note. JPS 86(3) , beau!.:p, Woleai, and Lamotrek in the

65-129, ed. Y. H, Sinoto, PacifIC Press.

1972 Archeologie de Nouvelles Hebrides. Publications de la Societe des Oceanistes, no. 30.

Page 22: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

116 Perspectives, ). 1986-1987

GARDINER, J. S.

1898 The natives of Rotuma. Journal oj the Anthropological Institute 27: 396-435, 457-524.

GIffORD, W., AND D. S.

Archaeological : 149-224.

GOREAU, T. F.

in Yap. Anthropoioxical Records oj oj California

1964 Mass expulsion of zooxanthellac from jamaican reef communities after Hurricane Flora. S 145:383-386.

GOREAU, T. F., N. I. GOREAU, AND C. M. YONGE

1973 On t.he utilization of photosynthetic products from zooxanthellae And of:l dissolved amino in Tridacna eiongata (Mollusca: Journal oJ (London) 169:41

G. J., D. SNYDER. B. MASSE

1981 An Archaeological Reconnaissance il1 the Palau Archipelago, Western Caroline islands, Micronesia. Center for Archaeological Investigations Research Paper No. 23. Carbondale: Southern Illionis University.

GWYTHER,J., AND]. L MUNRO

Spawning induction rearing oflarvae dams (Bivalvu: ·rridacmdae). Aquaculwre 21197-217.

Pot/ope 3, Die Rui/let! POIMpe (Ponape Ergebnisse del Siidscc- Expedition 190R-1910 ][, Bd. 7(3). Hamburg: Friederichsen, de Gruyter and Company.

HAMNER, W. N. n.d. Resource enhancement of giant clams (Tridacna). Proposal submitted to Sea Grant, University

of Hawaii, Honoh,lll.

H,IIlDY. • AND S. A. HARDY

Ecology of TridauUJ Pacific Science

Hrnuy. 1899 The mollusca of Funafuti, Part [I. in The Atoll of FunaJuti, Ellice Group: Its Zoology, Botany,

Ethnology, and General Structure: 489-510. Australian Museum. Sydney, Memoir 1lI.

HESLINGA, G. A., F. E. PERRON, AND O. ORAK

1984 Mass culture of giant clams (F. Tridacnidae) in Palall. Aquaculture 39'197-215.

, AND E. C. JONES

survey of giant 36(7): 17-22.

HIRO, K., AND R. N. CLAYSHULTE

Tridacnidae, on a western Paciflc Marine Fisheric(

1983 Site formation processes and cultural sequence at Tarague, Prehistory Association 4: 114-122.

Guam. Bulletin oj the Indo-Pacific

HIRO , K., E. RAY, J. STEVENS, D. MOORE, AND K. MOORE

Cldtural resources the Merizo Anthropology. Bishop Museum

University of Guam. J prepared for Honolulu.

HIRSCHBERGER, W.

Harbor, Melizo. the MicroneSian Army Engineer

[Departmell! llesearch Center.

1976 Tridacnidae clam project. Micronesian Mariculture Demol1Stratiol1 Center Newsletter, No. S. Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands Department of Resources and Development.

1980 Tridacnid clam stocks on Helen Reef, Palau. Western Caroline Islands. Marine Fisheries Review :8-15.

HUNHn-ANDERSON, R. I drainage archaeological assessment: report. Agana. Pacific Studies

5utute.

jAAP, W. C. 1979 Observations on zooxanthellae expulsion at Middle Sambo Reef, Florida Keys. Bulletil1 oj

Marine Science 29:414-422.

Page 23: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR
Page 24: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR
Page 25: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

MOlll: TRIDACNID ECOLOGY POSSIBLE IMPLICATlONS FOR ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH 11

RADTKE, R., J. LUDWIG, AND J. 1. BELL

n.d. Growth in giant clams, Tridacna maxima, at Rose Atoll. Submitted to Bulletin of Marine Science.

REHG. K. L, AND B. W. BENDER

1988 transfer from to Mokilesc: at the Fifth Imernational Conference

RENAUD-l\'lmlN,\NT, J. c., B. AND C. Bossy

10 intra-Micronesian borrowing. Paper Austronesian Linguistics, Auckland, N.Z.

lY71 Macrobenthos and melobenthos from the closed lagoon of a Polynesian atoll, Maturei Vavao (Tuamotu). Biotropica 3(1) :36-55.

RICHARD, G., AND B. SALVAT

1971 Bilan comparatif qualitatif et quantitatif des mollusques de recifs exterieurs d'atolls ou d'jles

RILEY,

1987

de Polynesie Haliotis 1 : 43-44. Ecolor;ie quantitative mollusques du lagon

Rendus Academic Sciences (Paris) 175:

I

Tlai1ura, i1e de Moored. Polynesie fran<;aise 1550.

Archaeological survey and testing, Majuro Atoll, Marshall Islands, in Marshall Islands Archaeolo­gy: 169-270, ed. T. Dye, Pacific Anthropological Records 38. Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press.

ROGERS, G. i\ rchaeological discoveries Niuatoputapu Tonga. jPS 83(3l.

ROLSTON.

on some MeLmcsian wood-working jPS 54(4)

ROMANEK, C. S., D. S. JONES, D. F. WILLIAMS, D. E. KRANTZ, AND R. RADTKE

1987 Stable isotopic investigation of physiological and environmental changes recorded in shell car­bonate from the giant clam Tridacna maxima. Marine Biology 94 (3) : 385-393.

ROSENDAHL, P. H. M.icwnesian shell a preliminary terminology and c1assiftcation in Depart-

of Anthropology, P. Bishop lonolulu. 1979 Archaeological reconnaissance survey in the and Eastern CarolinE Isillllds: a prelimin-

:ny report on the Kehon-BlShop Museum to Eastern Manuscript in Department of Anthropology, Bernice P. Bishop Museum, Honolulu.

1987 Archaeology in Eastern Micronesia: reconnaissance survey in the Marshall Islands, in Marshall Islands Archaeology: 17-168, ed. T. Dye, Paciftc Anthropological Records 38. Honolulu: Bernice P. Bishop Museum Press.

R05EWAIEH, R. Llmily Tridacnidae Indo-Pacific.

species of H'!'POptiS (Blvalvia:Tridacnidde)

SALVAT,13.

,Vlol/usca 1 : 347 .'\9(,. Nautillis 96(1)

1969 Dominance biologique de quelques mollusques dans les atolls ferme (Tuamotu, Polynesie). Malacologia 9(1): 187-189.

1970 Donnees bionomiques sur les peuplements benthiques it predominance de mollusques, d'un lagon d'atoll fermc polynesien. COllgrcs Societe Fran{aise de Mala(Oloc~ie.

19710 Evaluation quantitative la faune benthique de bordure lagunaire atoll de Polyne-h,m~aise. Compti'l /lcademie des Scifllli'.1 272: 211-21

Mollusques lagunaircs de I'ile de (i\ustrales, Polyncsie), Mal,1{ological Review 5.

1971c Quantitative balance of benthic fauna in Polynesian atolls. Proceedillgs ~r the 12th Pacific Science Congress, Canberra, Vol. 1: 155, Abstracts of Papers.

1972 La [aune benthiquc de I'atall de Reao (Tuamotu, Polynesie). Cahiers dll Pacifiqlle 16:30-111. 1973 Mollusques des lies Tubuai (Amtrales, Polynesie): Comparaisons avec des lies de la Societe et

des Tuamotu. Malacologia 14' 429-430.

SARfEIlT,

19L1 Ausgrabungsfunde I.F37.

SARFERT, E., AND H. DAMM

Matol aufPonape. des Museums I,it 1!.'Nvl".~"p zu Leipzix

1929 Luangiua lind Nukumanu. Ergebnisse der Sudsee-Expedition 1908-1910 II, Bd. 12. Hamburg: Friederichsen, de Gruyter and Company.

1935 Inseln !Im Truk. Ergehnisse clef Sudsee-Expeclition 1908-1910 II, Bd. fl. Hamburg: Friederich­Gruyter and

Page 26: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

120

SCHMELTZ, J. D. 1881 Die l::thI10~'rav·11ISi

L. r-neaf~nc:n

SHUTLER, M. E., AND R. SHUTLLIl, JIl.

xxvn(1),1986-1987

Abtfii'lI1g des Museum Godeffroy in

1966 A preliminary report of archaeological explorations in the Southern New Hebrides. AP 9: 157-166.

SINOTO, Y. H. 1984 Descriptions of portable artifacts (other than pottery) from Fefan Island, in Caroline Islands

Archaeology: 26-38, ed. Y. H. Sinoto, Pacific Anthropological Records 35. Honolulu: Bernice P. Bishop Museum Press.

SKINNER, H. D. 1920 Shell adzes of the Maori.}PS 29(4):200-201.

SPECHT, J. 1969 Prehistoric

thesis, The 1982 Some shell

tion 3: 135-142.

iana, A,,·thrmu)/oo

STEELE, R. D.

of Buka Island, T. P. N. C. Canberra.

Ocean Island. Bulletin of the Indo-PaCIfic

and excavations on Saipan, Tinian

1975 Stages in the life history of a symbiotic zooxanthella in pellets extruded by its host Aplasia tagetes (Duch. and Mich.) (Coelenterata, Anthozoa). Biolo,~ical Bulletin 149:590-600.

1977 The significance of zooxantheIla-containing pellets extruded by sea anemones. Bulletin of Marine Science 17: 591-594.

STEPHENSON, A. 1934 The breeding of reef animals, Part II. Invertebrates other than corals. Scielltific Report of the Great

Barrier Reef Expedition 1928-19293: 247-272.

STODDART, D. R. 1971 Coral reefs

]. A. Steers.

STRECK, C. F., JR.

1987 Archaeological ".nVTlfIUD)Un

lands, Micront'!';,/. Berkeley, CA,

SVERDRUP, H. U., M. 1954 The Ocealls,

TAKAYAMA, j., AND T. EGAMI

storms, in Applied Coastal Geomorpilo!on

the Islands of Bikini Atoll, Republ;( Committee Supplementary

FI.EMING

Ceneral Biology. New York: Prentice-Hall

1971 Archaeology on Rota in the Marianas Islands. Reports of Pacific Archaeological Survey No. 1. Hiratsuka City, Japan: Tokai University.

TAKAYAMA, J., AND M. INTOH

1980 Reconnaissance Archaeological Survey in the Lower Mortlocks, Truk State. Reports of Pacific Archaeological Survey No.6. Nara City, Japan: Tezukayama University.

TAKA Y AMA, J., AND T. SEKI

1973 Preliminary Archaeological Investigations on the Island of Tol in Truk. Reports of Pacific Archaeolo­gical Survey No.2. Japan.

TAYLOR, D. L. 1973 Algal symbionts

TAYLOR,]' D. 1971 Reef associated

Society of Lom/oll 1978 Faunal response

Atoll. PalaeollloioliV

THOMPSON, L. M.

Review of Microbiology 27: 171-187.

the western Indian Ocean. Symposium

reef habitats: Pleistocene molluscan

1932 Archaeology of the Marianas Islands. Bernice P. Bishop Museum Bulletin 100. 1938 Adzes from the Lau Islands, Fiji. jPS 47(3): 97-1 08.

Page 27: Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for ... · Revi of Trl nid Eco ogy and Some Possible Implications for Archaeological Research Received 20 1985 BARBARA G. MOIR

MOIR: TRIDACNID Le.C)LC}b LvlPLlCATIONS FOR ARCHAEOLOGICAL n<:,1:.""'0U

TRENCH, R. K., D. S. 1981 Observations zooxdnthellae among the Tridacnidae

Biological Bullftlll 1

USHER, G. F. 1984 Coral Reef Invertebrates in Indonesia: Their Exploitation and Conservation Needs. IUCN/WWF Re­

port No.2. Bogor, Indonesia.

WADA, S. K. 1954 Spawning in the tridacnid clams. Japanese Journal of Zoology 11 : 273-285.

WANKOWSKI, J. W. J. 1979 Rep~rt on'a preliminary survey of Nuguria. Nukumanu. and Takuu Atolls. Papua New Guinea

Department of Primary Industry, Fisheries Research Section. Manuscript.

WARD. G. K. 1979 Prehistoric ,cltlem""

WELLS, S. M .• R. M. 1983 Marine molluscs.

tiona I Union

WHITE.]. P. 1972 Carbon dates

WHITE, j. P., AND j. E. DOWNIE

.1 tropical small island environment: The Australian National UnivCfsity.

m't:nemUll Red Data Book: 69-90. Gland. Switzerland:

1\(4): 309-310.

1980 Excavations at Lesu, New Ireland. AP 23(2): 193-220.

WILKERSON, F. P., AND R. K. TRENCH

1986 Uptake of dissolved inorganic nitrogen by the symbiotic clam Tridacna gigas and the coral Acro­pora sp. Marine Biology 93(2): 237-246.

YAMAGUCHI, M. 1977 Conservation and cultivation of giant clams ill the tropical Pacific. Biological Conservation 11 : 13-

20.

YONGE. C. M. 1936 Mode of life,

Report ot! the 1974 Coral reefs ami 1980 Functional

cords of the

YONGE. C. M., AND A. 1931 Studies on the

s Y III blOsis with zooxanthellae in the T 1

11)28-19291 :283-321. Royal Society, Edinburgh 69(7) : 1

lhe Tridacnidae (Mollusca: Bival\'lll 777.

effect of starvation in light and Scientific Report on the Great