Utah

StatewideJudge

Overview

Appellate

David Mortensen Utah Court of Appeals

Ryan Harris Utah Court of Appeals

Jill Pohlman Utah Court of Appeals

Gregory Orme Utah Court of Appeals

Diana Hagen Utah Court of Appeals

Michele Chris ansen Forster Utah Court of Appeals

John Pearce Utah Supreme Court

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Appellate Judges •

LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.5

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.9

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.5

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

81%

0% 100%

93%

0% 100%

96%

0% 100%

90%

0% 100%

88%

0% 100%

100% 0% 100%

91%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

First District - Box Elder

Kirk Morgan District Court

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 98%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov • JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • First District Judges •

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

First District - Cache

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • First District Judges •

Ma hew Funk Jus ce Court - Basic

Providence Jus ce court judges who receive a basic evalua on are required to meet four minimum performance stand-ards.*

Kirk Morgan Juvenile Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 98%

d-

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

First District - Rich

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • First District Judges •

Kirk Morgan Juvenile Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 98%

Trevor Cook Jus ce Court - Basic Rich County Jus ce court judges who receive a basic evalua on are required to meet four minimum performance standards.*

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Second District - Davis

David Hamilton District Court

Robert Dale District Court

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Second District Judges •

LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

Noel Hyde District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

Jennifer Valencia District Court LA: 4.1 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100% 87%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

95%

96%

98%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Second District - Davis

Robert Neill Juvenile Court

Michelle Heward Juvenile Court

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Second District Judges •

LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

Jeffrey Noland Juvenile Court LA: 4.9 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

John Ynchaus Jus ce Court - Davis Cty LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

99%

92%

96%

91%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Second District - Morgan

David Hamilton District Court

Robert Dale District Court

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Second District Judges •

LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

Noel Hyde District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

Jennifer Valencia District Court LA: 4.1 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100% 87%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

95%

96%

98%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Second District - Morgan

Jeffrey Noland Juvenile Court

Michelle Heward Juvenile Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

Robert Neill Juvenile Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

LA: 4.9 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 99%

0% 100% 92%

0% 100% 96%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Second District Judges •For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Second District - Weber

David Hamilton District Court LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Robert Dale District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Noel Hyde District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Jennifer Valencia District Court LA: 4.1 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

98%

96%

95%

87%

Michelle Heward Juvenile Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 99%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Second District Judges •For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Second District - Weber

Robet Neill Juvenile Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Jeffrey Noland Juvenile Court LA: 4.9 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

Michael Junk Jus ce Court - Ogden LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Clay Stucki Jus ce Court - Ogden LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.4

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Bryan Memmo Jus ce Court - Basic

Plain City Jus ce court judges who receive a basic evalua on are required to meet four minimum performance standards.*

92%

97%

85%

Trent Nelson Jus ce Court - Midlevel Roy PF: Pass Jus ce court judges who receive a mid-level evalua on are required to meet five minimum performance standards. In interviews with court-users, Judge Nelson receives posi ve reviews from nearly all respondents.*

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Second District Judges •*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Third District - Salt Lake County

Ma hew Bates District Court

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Third District Judges •

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

93% 0% 100%

Kent Holmberg District Court LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

Elizabeth Hruby- Mills District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100% 88%

Keith Kelly District Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100% 90%

Todd Shaughnessy District Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

Andrew Stone District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

93% 0% 100%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Third District - Summit

Kent Holmberg District Court

Ma hew Bates District Court

LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

Keith Kelly District Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100%

0% 100% 0% 100%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

96%

Elizabeth Hruby- Mills District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100% 88%

93%

90%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Third District Judges •

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Third District - Summit

Andrew Stone District Court

Todd Shaughnessy District Court

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

Steven Beck Juvenile Court LA: 4.7 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.9 PF: Pass

Susan Eisenman Juvenile Court LA: 4.8 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

88%

98%

93%

96%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Third District Judges •

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Third District - Tooele County

Kent Holmberg Juvenile Court LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Ma hew Bates District Court LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Keith Kelly District Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Elizabeth Hruby- Mills District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100% 88%

Todd Shaughnessy District Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

90%

96%

96%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Third District Judges • For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Third District - Tooele County

Steven Beck Juvenile Court

Andrew Stone District Court

LA: 4.7 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.9 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

Susan Eisenman Juvenile Court LA: 4.8 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov • JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Third District Judges •

93%

98%

88%

John Dow Jus ce Court - Tooele Midlevel PF: Pass Jus ce court judges who receive a mid-level evalua on are re-quired to meet five minimum performance standards. In inter-views with court-users, Judge Dow receives posi ve reviews from nearly all respondents, though some express cri cism.*

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fourth District - Juab

Robert Lunnen District Court

Thomas Low District Court

Doug Nielsen Juvenile Court

Kraig Powell District Court

Anthony Howell District Court

James Brady District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

93%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov • JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fourth District Judges •

Jared Eldridge District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100% 90%

92%

85%

93%

90%

98%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fourth District - Millard

Robert Lunnen District Court

Thomas Low District Court

Doug Nielsen Juvenile Court

Kraig Powell District Court

Anthony Howell District Court

James Brady District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

93%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov • JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fourth District Judges •

Jared Eldridge District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100% 90%

92%

85%

93%

90%

98%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fourth District - Utah County

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fourth District Judges •

Jared Eldridge District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

James Brady District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Anthony Howell District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Thomas Low District Court LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Robert Lunnen District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100% 93%

85%

93%

90%

92%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fourth District - Utah County

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fourth District Judges •

Douglas Nielsen Juvenile Court LA: 4.8 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 98%

Kraig Powell District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Morgan Cummings Jus ce Court - Lehi LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.4

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100% 91%

Reed Parkin Jus ce Court - Orem LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100% 92%

Kelly Schaeffer- Bullock Jus ce Court - Midlevel Highland PF: Pass Jus ce court judges who receive a mid-level evalua on are re-quired to meet five minimum per-formance standards. In interviews with court-users, Judge Schaeffer-Bullock receives posi ve reviews from all respondents.*

s -f

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

90%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fourth District - Wasatch

James Brady District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

Anthony Howell District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 0% 100%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov • JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fourth District Judges •

Thomas Low District Court LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100% 85%

Jared Eldridge District Court LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100% 90%

93% 92%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fourth District - Wasatch

Kraig Powell District Court

Robert Lunnen District Court

LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

Douglas Nielsen Juvenile Court LA: 4.8 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100%

0% 100%

0% 100%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov • JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fourth District Judges •

Randy Birch Jus ce Court - Midlevel Heber PF: Pass Jus ce court judges who receive a mid-level evalua on are re-quired to meet five minimum performance standards. In inter-views with court-users, Judge Birch receives posi ve reviews from nearly all respondents.*

98%

90%

93%

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fifth District - Beaver

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fi h District Judges •

Ma hew Bell District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.9

AS: 4.9 PF: Pass

0% 100%

John Walton District Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100% 90%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

98%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fifth District - Iron

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fi h District Judges •

Ma hew Bell District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.9

AS: 4.9 PF: Pass

0% 100%

John Walton District Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100% 90%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

98%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Fifth District - Washington

Thad Seegmiller Jus ce Court - Midlevel Washington PF: Pass Jus ce court judges who receive a mid-level evalua on are re-quired to meet five minimum performance standards. In inter-views with court-users, Judge Seegmiller receives posi ve reviews from nearly all respondents.*

Ma hew Bell District Court

ws

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Fi h District Judges •

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.9

AS: 4.9 PF: Pass

0% 100% 98%

John Walton District Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100% 90%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Sixth District - Garfield

Gary Owens Jus ce Court - Basic

Garfield County Jus ce court judges who receive a basic evalua on are required to meet four minimum performance stand-ards.*

d-

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Sixth District Judges •

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

Wallace Lee District Court

0% 100% 95%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Sixth District - Kane

Gary Owens Jus ce Court - Basic

Garfield County Jus ce court judges who receive a basic evalua on are required to meet four minimum performance stand-ards.*

d-

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Sixth District Judges •

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

Wallace Lee District Court

0% 100% 95%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Sixth District - Piute

Wallace Lee District CourtLA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 95%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Sixth District Judges •

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Sixth District - Sanpete

Wallace Lee District Court LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Sixth District Judges •

John Cox Jus ce Court - Basic

Sanpete County Jus ce court judges who receive a basic evalua on are required to meet four minimum performance stand-ards.*

d-

Mark McIff Jus ce Court - Midlevel Ephraim, Fairview, Fountain Green, Moroni, Spring City PF: Pass Jus ce court judges who receive a mid-level evalua on are required to meet five minimum performance standards. In interviews with court-users, Judge McIff receives posi ve reviews from nearly all respond-ents.*

95%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Sixth District - Sevier

Wallace Lee District CourtLA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 95%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Sixth District Judges •

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Sixth District - Wayne

Wallace Lee District CourtLA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 95%

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Sixth District Judges •

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Seventh District - Carbon

Jon Carpenter Jus ce Court - Midlevel East Carbon PF: PassJus ce court judges who receive a mid-level evalua on are re-quired to meet five minimum performance standards. In inter-views with court-users, Judge Car-penter receives posi ve reviews from nearly all respondents.*

Craig Bunnell Juvenile Court

-rom

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Seventh District Judges •

LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

Mary Manley Juvenile Court LA: 4.7 IJT: 4.4

AS: 4.4 PF: Pass

0% 100% 94%

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Seventh District - Emery

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Seventh District Judges •

Mary Manley Juvenile Court LA: 4.7 IJT: 4.4

AS: 4.4 PF: Pass

0% 100% 94%

Craig Bunnell Juvenile Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Seventh District - Grand

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Seventh District Judges •

Mary Manley Juvenile Court LA: 4.7 IJT: 4.4

AS: 4.4 PF: Pass

0% 100% 94%

Craig Bunnell Juvenile Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Seventh District - San Juan

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Seventh District Judges •

Mary Manley Juvenile Court LA: 4.7 IJT: 4.4

AS: 4.4 PF: Pass

0% 100% 94%

Craig Bunnell Juvenile Court LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Eighth District - Daggett

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Eighth District Judges •

Clark McClellan District CourtLA: 4.3 IJT: 4.5

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100% 91%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Eighth District - Duchesne

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Eighth District Judges •

Clark McClellan District CourtLA: 4.3 IJT: 4.5

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100% 91%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1

Eighth District - Uintah

• JPEC 2020 Evalua on Results • Eighth District Judges •

Clark McClellan District CourtLA: 4.3 IJT: 4.5

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100% 91%

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Unanimous JPEC recommenda on to retain

1-5 Scale LA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administra ve SkillsPass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending reten on

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

1