Results MARPOL Annex VI Monitoring Report Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016 Ward Van Roy - MUMM

Compliance monitoring pilot for MARPOL Annex VI

1

Title of publication

Results MARPOL Annex VI Monitoring Report

Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016

Author(s)

Ward Van Roy

Kobe Scheldeman

Commissioned by, date

23/12/2016

Keywords

MARPOL Annex VI Monitoring, Remote Monitoring, Aerial Monitoring, Sniffer

Contact person

Ward Van Roy (wvanroy@naturalsciences.be) Language of the report

English

Abstract

From August to November 2016, MUMM organised the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016, during

this period, MUMM has successfully implemented airborne MARPOL Annex VI monitoring for the

first time on a broad temporal and spatial scale in an operational coast guard context in the

North Sea.

In the 45 monitoring days, 135 flight hours were performed and Fuel Sulphur Content (FSC)

measurements have been carried out on more than 1300 ships, this means that an average of

10 ships could be monitored per flight hour.

Almost 100 non-compliant ships were observed (8%) with a FSC value above the 0.2% thresh-

old. A detailed data-analysis revealed no significant difference between different ship types, nor

sizes, nor flag states. Not even the destination (inside or outside SECA) seemed to have an im-

pact on the compliance level, although it was observed that a higher incompliance level was ob-

served in shipping lanes at a certain distance from shore than in port entry zones.

The airborne MARPOL Annex VI monitoring and subsequent reporting of targeted vessels to PSC

resulted in a significant increase in the efficiency of port inspections (from 3 to 20%), but still a

lot of aerial monitoring observations failed to be confirmed by/during on board inspections.

The crew has gained a substantial amount of experience in the execution of airborne MARPOL

Annex VI monitoring flights with a sniffer sensor. At this stage 85% of the ship approaches pro-

duce a successful measurement. The experiences from the campaign were used in the further

development of the Best Practice Report on Airborne MARPOL Annex VI Monitoring by MUMM.

The sniffer installation in the Belgian aircraft OO-MMM is producing satisfying results; the IGPS

software has been installed on several computers including the on board mission computer. The

software has improved significantly since the start of the campaign, mainly the manual meas-

urement system is working very well, although some uncertainties on measurement accuracy

and the very occasional occurrence of unreliable FSC measurements are still a concern.

This ComMon experience has demonstrated that the airborne monitoring information can be

used very efficiently for the targeting of ship inspections in port. But future work is needed in

terms of both broad-scaled validation and inter-comparison campaigns and sensor standardiza-

tion, in order to improve the understanding, assessment and reporting of airborne monitoring

data, and to facilitate the use of airborne monitoring data as evidence to court.

Date

14.12.2016

Compliance monitoring pilot for MARPOL Annex VI

2

Index

Index ................................................................................................... 2

1 Introduction .................................................................................... 3

2 Material ........................................................................................... 3 2.1 BN Islander ............................................................................. 3 2.2 Sniffer sensor .......................................................................... 4 2.3 IGPS software .......................................................................... 4

3 Methodology ................................................................................... 5 3.1 Method of operation .................................................................. 5

3.1.1 Pre-flight checklist .......................................................... 5 3.1.2 Operational procedures (operators) .................................. 6 3.1.3 Flight procedures (pilots) ................................................. 7

4 Reporting to PSC ............................................................................. 7 4.1 Reporting method ..................................................................... 7 4.2 Reporting colour flags ............................................................... 8 4.3 Follow up of reported violations in Thetis-EU ................................ 8

5 Monitoring results ........................................................................... 9 5.1 Performed flight-time ................................................................ 9 5.2 FSC measurement results .......................................................... 9 5.3 Evaluation on project milestones .............................................. 14 5.4 Performed milestones during the Belgian Sniffer Campaigns ........ 14

6 SIOB ............................................................................................ 14

7 ILT ............................................................................................ 14

8 Health Aspects .............................................................................. 14

9 Media and press ............................................................................ 15

10 Lessons learned and future perspectives ...................................... 15

11 Conclusions ................................................................................... 17

Annex 1: Technical information OO-MMM platform ............................ 18

Annex 2: Technical drawing Sniffer .................................................... 20

Annex 3: IGPS print screens .............................................................. 21

Annex 4: List of participants .............................................................. 23

Annex 5: Map of surveillance area ..................................................... 24

Annex 6: Schematic view of a ship approach ..................................... 25

Annex 7: Overview of CompMon Flights ............................................. 28

Annex 8: List of all inspected ships .................................................... 30

3

1 Introduction

On the 1st of January 2015 the new sulphur content limits of the revised IMO Annex VI

relating to a reduction in the Fuel Sulphur Content (FSC) entered into force in the Euro-

pean SECA area, which consist of the North Sea and the Baltic Sea. Within the European

Union the new sulphur limits were ratified through the Council Directive 1999/32/EC of

26 April 1999, relating to a reduction in the sulphur content of liquid fuel from 1% to

0.1% sulphur in the Sulphur Emission Control Area (SECA).

In order to be able to address the issues concerning the enforcement of IMO MARPOL

Annex VI regulations, and more in particular the use of new, innovative techniques,

MUMM joined the CompMon network in 2014. In 2015 the CompMon network applied for

financing by the European Union funding program, Connecting Europe Facility (CEF).

The project with project name: “Compliance Monitoring pilot for MARPOL Annex VI

(CompMon)” with proposal nr: “2014-EU-_TM-0546-S” was submitted by the CompMon

partnership. The goals and specifications of the CompMon project have been defined in

the Grant Agreement (INEA/CEF/TRAN/M2014/1025268).

The Scientific Service “Management Unit of the North Sea Mathematical Models and the

Scheldt estuary (MUMM)” of the Operational Directorate Nature of the Royal Belgian

Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS) committed itself to perform 150 flight hours of

MARPOL Annex VI compliance monitoring in the period 2015-2016 for the CompMon

project, of which 25 flight hours were financed by the Netherlands Shipping Inspec-

torate for monitoring over Dutch waters.

The first monitoring effort was implemented during the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2015,

this campaign was organised by MUMM in the first two weeks of October 2015 (week

40-41). During that period 17 flight hours over sea were performed. Based on the suc-

cess of the first campaign MUMM has published a call for tenders to purchase an SO2

sniffer system for installation on board of the OO-MMMM surveillance platform. The

sniffer system was delivered in the second half of August 2016. From mid-August until

the end of November the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016 was organised.

2 Material

OD Nature has made the OO-MMM BN Islander surveillance aircraft available for the

execution of the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016. MUMM purchased an SO2 sniffer sensor

from FluxSense, the system was installed on board of the OO-MMM aircraft. During the

campaign the sensor was initially treated as loose equipment, but at the end of the

campaign an EASA certified installation rack was ordered from the company Airplus

Maintenance GmbH to permanently install the sniffer on board of the surveillance air-

craft in accordance with EASA rules.

2.1 BN Islander

Aircraft BN Islander OO-MMM (See Annex 1 for a technical specification sheet):

Equipped with remote sensing instrumentation (SLAR, IR, ECDIS, AIS, Camera’s,

Marine VHF);

Equipped with modern avionics (EFIS, Cockpitscreen with mirrored display of the

sniffer software, Stormscope, Satcom, TCAS, Weathermap);

Dedicated AIS and GPS antenna made available for the sniffer;

Black Carbon measurement device (provided by BIM).

4

2.2 Sniffer sensor

The sniffer sensor used during the campaign, developed by FluxSense, is capable of

measuring SO2 and CO2 concentrations in the exhaust plumes from ships. The supply of

the outside air to the SO2 sniffer sensor is established through a probe on the belly of

the aircraft and connected to the air-intake of the sniffer sensor through a flexible tube.

During the flights the sniffer sensor continuously measures SO2 and CO2 concentrations

in the outside air. The sniffer sensor determines the SO2 concentration in the ship ex-

haust by means of a UV fluorometer and the amount of CO2 concentration with an IR

radiometer, the FSC is calculated based on the ratio of these two gas measurements

(see Annex 2 for a technical drawing of the sniffer sensor).

2.3 IGPS software

For the sensor control and visualisation of the output of the sniffer, FluxSense devel-

oped a tailored IGPS software module. The software is fitted with nautical charts with

integrated AIS visualisation (positioning of ships). On the nautical charts the (AIS de-

tectable) ships are displayed with an indication of the modelled location of the smoke

plume based on the current wind conditions, this wind-information is provided by the

avionics board-computer through ARINC. The nautical chart with AIS and exhaust plume

location are also displayed on a cockpit screen in front of the pilots for strategical pur-

pose (see Annex 3 for some print screens of the IGPS software).

The sniffer sensor continuously measures the SO2 and CO2 concentrations in the outside

air, these concentrations are graphically displayed on the IGPS software. As soon as the

software measures a peak in these concentrations (when passing through a plume) the

IGPS software fully automatically calculates the FSC and links it to the inspected ship,

based on the modelled position of the ship exhaust plumes (see figure 15 of Annex 3).

In addition to the automatic FSC measurement, the FSC measurement is always done

manually as well, this can be done by selecting the peaks and the background values on

the graph window of the IGPS software and linking the result to a ship on the MAP win-

dow of the IGPS software (see figure 16 of Annex 3).

The FSC-measurements are provided with a resolution up to 0.001% but as this resolu-

tion gives a false sense of accuracy all measurements are rounded up to 0.01% in this

report.

The IGPS software includes the possibility to mark ships during flight, this information is

particularly useful for the pilots to strategically plan the ship monitoring. Furthermore

after conducting an FSC measurement, ships can be marked as compliant “Low”, non-

compliant “High”, or if no successful FSC measurement was made: “Not detected” (See

figure 17 of Annex 3).

The IGPS software is installed on the aircraft mission computer of the surveillance air-

craft (MOC) which is connected to the sniffer by Ethernet. Another laptop was used in

flight with the IGPS software. The operator behind the MOC is responsible for the selec-

tion of the ships and the communication with the pilots, the screen of the MOC is also

copied on the cockpit display of the pilots so that everything the operator shows on his

screen is visible to the pilots. In case a non-compliant ship is observed, the MOC opera-

tor is also responsible for composing the Flight Report. The operator operating the lap-

top is responsible for the FSC measurement after every ship approach.

All (manual) FSC measurements are written down. This is only done as a safeguard,

because all measurements are stored in a database together with the available AIS in-

formation, compliancy and comments. The records are easily accessible as CSV files for

post flight reporting and processing.

5

3 Methodology

The main participants for the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016 where: MUMM, FOD Mobili-

ty (Administration Environmental Inspection), ILT (Netherlands Shipping Inspectorate)

and Defence. A list of all Participants, including contact points used during the campaign

is available in Annex 4.

The MARPOL Annex VI compliance monitoring flights were executed over the Bonn

Agreement Quadripartite Zone of Joint Responsibility (QZJR), the shipping lanes towards

and coming from the Port of Rotterdam and the shipping lanes north of the Wadden-

Sea. The flights were executed with special emphasis on the Scheldt estuary/Scheur,

the shipping lanes to the port of Zeebrugge and Antwerp (WHTSS) and the Noordhinder

shipping lane (NHTSS). (see Annex 5 for a map of the surveillance area). The used

operation methods for the execution of the surveillance flights are described below.

3.1 Method of operation

The following method of operation was used for the organisation of the MARPOL Annex

VI surveillance flights during the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016:

3.1.1 Pre-flight checklist

The operation order and planning forwarded 1 week prior to the campaign;

Flight duration was set between 1 and 3 hours;

Per day 1 to 2 flights were be performed from 8 AM until 17 PM (UTC);

Detailed flight planning with routes and time was forwarded 24hr before take-off;

Sniffer sensor was calibrated before every first flight of the day, calibration gasses

(2 x CO2 and 1 x SO2) were stored in Ostend during the campaign;

1 hours before take-off, the Ground Power Unit (GPU) was connected to the aircraft

to power up the sniffer;

GPU was disconnected prior to the start-up of the aircraft engines, in the meantime

the sniffer was powered by an external battery (max 30 min).

After the engine start-up, the sniffer system was powered by aircraft power.

Figure 1 Installation of sniffer and calibration before take-off

6

3.1.2 Operational procedures (operators)

During the flight the console with IGPS software was operated by the first operator,

who was responsible for the ship selection and communication with the pilots;

Ships were selected randomly for inspection taking in regard following aspects:

o Only ships ‘en route’ were selected for monitoring;

o Only ships larger than 100m were selected for monitoring;

o The main focus was on ships in major shipping lanes (Traffic Separation

Schemes (TSS));

During the flight, a high performance laptop with the IGPS software was operated by

the second operator, who was responsible for the FSC calculations;

Sampling attempts (in line with the agreed ‘best practice’ procedures):

o In case of an unsuccessful measurement attempt, maximum 2 other at-

tempts were made. After maximum 3 unsuccessful measurement attempts,

the ship was abandoned. In case a successful, compliant measurement was

made during the first 3 attempts, the ship was abandoned. (= Minimum 1 at-

tempt in case of compliance)

o In case a successful, non-compliant measurement was made during the first

3 attempts, an additional confirmation measurement was made. Maximum 2

additional confirmation attempts were made to confirm the first non-

compliant measurement.

After the inspection of a ship, the FSC was written down with the name of the ship

and the ship was marked on the IGPS software as:

o Compliant (Low),

o Non-compliant (High),

o No result (Not detected).

Figure 2 Schematic overview of maximum number of sampling attempts

7

3.1.3 Flight procedures (pilots)

The following method of operation for the execution of the MARPOL Annex VI surveil-

lance flights with a Sniffer sensor was used:

All flights were operated from EBOS or EBAW;

Fuelling was done before or after every Sniffer flight;

General flight altitude was 500 ft between ship approaches;

Ships were approached at cruising speed (110 kts) and an altitude of 150-250ft.

Ships exhaust plumes were crossed at angle of around 90° at different distances

from the ship dividing from 200m to several hundreds of meters (see Annex 9);

The exhaust plumes were only crossed above the ship in case the wind vector was

the same as the ship vector, in that case the ship was overflown 150ft above the

ship height (ca 350ft);

A flight route was drafted before flight (cfr. flight planning) but the route was often

adjusted in flight for FSC measurements in neighbouring airspaces, therefore when

drafting flight plans to Belgocontrol a more extensive flight plan was filed.

See Annex 6 for the schematic view of the ship approaches depending on the speed

and direction of the vessel and the wind conditions.

4 Reporting to PSC

4.1 Reporting method

All observations of alleged MARPOL Annex VI violations were reported to PSC after

flight, through MUMM’s National Flight Report template. Flight reports were sent to the

Belgian Maritime Security Centre (MIK) and MIK forwarded the flight report to:

MUMM (SURV);

FPS Environment (DG5);

Administration environmental inspections (PSC - FPS Mobility);

NSI (ILT);

CompMon partners (during the joint SIOB campaign see further);

BONN Agreement (UK, NL or FR) National Focal point for observations made in

neighbouring waters.

All reported information on alleged non-compliance contained at least following

information:

Date and Time (UTC);

Name of targeted vessel;

Vessel position;

Country in which waters the alleged violation occurred;

IMO number of suspected vessel or MMSI;

Sulphur fuel content (SFC) as measured with the sniffer sensor and colour flag;

AIS information.

No radio contact was made with the non-compliant ships during the Belgian Sniffer

Campaign 2016.

8

4.2 Reporting colour flags

Based on the enforcement experience gained so far, a threshold-based, ‘colour flag’ sys-

tem was defined and used for the reporting of alleged MARPOL Annex VI violations to

FPS Mobility and ILT. The colour flags that were used for reporting during the 2016

campaign were a green, a yellow, an orange and a red flag. The ‘colour flags’ reporting

system which in fact reflects various degrees of likelihood of (non-) compliancy, takes

into account (1) the calculated FSC-value for a given vessel and (2) the level of accura-

cy/uncertainty of the specific measurement:

A green flag was given to all FSC-measurements below 0.15% (considered as com-

pliant);

A yellow flag was given to all FSC-measurements between 0.15 and 0.2 (considered

as possibly non-compliant, but still within the sensor uncertainty range);

The orange flag was given to all non-compliant FSC-measurements between 0.2%

and 0.4%, or where a first high non-compliance measurement (>0.4%) was not

confirmed by a next measurement, or when a plume couldn’t be linked to one ship

because of the presence of other ships and/or exhaust plumes nearby.

The red flag was only given to the non-compliant FSC-measurements of more than

0.4% (= more than twice the sensor threshold level). The result needed to be con-

firmed by a second measurement and absent of other ships and/or exhaust plumes

nearby.

Figure 3 Threshold system used by MUMM during the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016

4.3 Follow up of reported violations in Thetis-EU

All observations with a yellow, orange and red colour flag were considered as possible

violations and useful to report in near real time for the purpose of targeting ships for

inspection in port. All possible violations in Belgian waters were followed up by a Belgian

Environmental Inspection officer, all possible violations in Dutch waters were followed

up by a Dutch NSI officer. The Belgian Environmental Inspection was responsible for the

creation of calls in Thetis-EU for violations which occurred in Belgian waters, NSI was

responsible for the creation of calls for inspection in Thetis-EU for alleged violations

which occurred in Dutch waters. In case of observations of violations in neighbouring

waters others than the Netherlands, the Belgian Environmental Inspection was respon-

sible to create a call for inspection in Thetis-EU. All Flight reports for possible violations

were sent straight after landing (less than 1 hour after landing).

9

5 Monitoring results

5.1 Performed flight-time

In total 73 surveillance flights have been executed for MARPOL Annex VI monitoring

during the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016. On a total of 45 days in total 171:35 flight

hours have been performed, of which were 134:55 operational flight hours over sea (of

which 25 hours for ILT) and 37:40 non-operational flight hours for transit from and to

the aircraft base in Antwerp, for technical or for other reasons. In addition 23:25 engine

hours were performed for taxiing and start-up of the system, this brings the total per-

formed number of engine hours to 196:30. In Annex 7 an overview of the performed

flights is provided.

5.2 FSC measurement results

During the total time of the campaign 1390 different ships were monitored, see Annex

8 for a complete list of all monitored ships. For 1183 ships a successful FSC measure-

ment could be made (85.5%), for 207 ships no successful measurement could be made

(14.5%), this was because of one of the following reasons:

too many ships in the vicinity;

too low plume;

unstable concentration of CO2 or SO2 in atmosphere just before measurement;

too small ship to detect the plume.

Depending on the FSC threshold different compliance levels can be reported. In case an

FSC threshold of 0.15% (yellow flag) is used, 140 observed vessels can be categorised

as non-compliant, this corresponds to a compliance level of 88.6% and a non-

compliance level of 11.4%. In case an FSC threshold of 0.2% (orange flag) is used,

which seems more correct as approach, 98 non-compliant ships have been observed,

corresponding to a compliance level of 92% and a non-compliance level of 8%. If a FSC

threshold of 0.4% (red flag) is used, 32 ships are found to be non-compliant, this corre-

sponds to a compliance level of 97.4% and a non-compliance level of 2.6%.

Figure 4 General results of the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016 based on 3 FSC-Thresholds

All possible violations were reported to FPS Mobility. For 66 ships observed in BE, UK or

FR waters a call was made in Thetis-EU, in 14 cases the ship went to a Belgian port af-

ter observation and a PSC inspection was performed and fuel samples were taken. In 3

out of 14 cases, the fuel sample confirmed the airborne observation (20%), resulting in

an increase of efficiency in port from 3% (2015) to 21% (2016) based on airborne tar-

geting. For 42 other observations for ships not sailing to a Belgian Port, a call in Thetis-

EU was created by FOD Mobility, in 10 cases an inspection was executed in a SECA port,

resulting in 2 positive fuel samples (20%), it should be noted that less than 20% of the

reported vessels were actually inspected in port.

89%

3% 5% 3% Sniffer Campaign 2016

Green (0-0.15% S-Content)

Yellow (0.15-0.2% S-Content)

Orange (0.2-0.4% S-Content)

Red (>0.4% S-Content)

10

Table 1 Overview of airborne inspection results

Sulphur Content Number Average Maximum Percentage Percentage

Not Detected 209 0 0 14.5% 0.0%

Green (0-0.15% S-Content) 1093 0.06 0.15 75.8% 88.6%

Yellow (0.15-0.2% S-Content) 42 0.17 0.20 2.9% 3.4%

Orange (0.2-0.4% S-Content) 66 0.26 0.38 4.6% 5.4%

Red (>0.4% S-Content) 32 0.65 1.20 2.2% 2.6%

Total 1442 0.09 1.20 100.00% 100.00%

By analysing the results of the FSC measurements it was observed that the distribution

of the measured FSC corresponds very well with the distribution of the FSC measure-

ments in port. The average observed value is around 0.09%. Although the histogram

shows that the highest number of observations occur between 0.05% and 0.08% (30%

of all observations), most marine diesels and some Low Sulphur Fuel Oil (LSFO) have

concentrations in this range. A peak is also observed at 0, this is caused by ships sailing

on low sulphur marine diesel or boil off gases from LNG, the FSC for these fuels is so

low that it is falls below the detection limit of the sniffer sensor, in those cases the FSC

is rounded to 0.

Figure 5 Histogram (percentage) of observed ships corresponding to FSC intervals (FSC intervals are displayed on non-linear scale: until 0.15% FSC, intervals of 0.01% have been used, from 0.15% onwards, intervals of 0.05% have been used)

Figure 6 Number of observed ships with different FSC thresholds per Flag State

When comparing the flag state of the observed ships, no striking trends can be seen,

some flag states may have a higher non-compliance rate, but there seems to be no sig-

nificant difference. For Belgium a non-Compliance rate of 50% is observed, this is

caused by one specific shipping company that uses old ships (>20year old). These ships

only sail within SECA and have only LSFO on board, but for some reason these ships are

regularly detected with too high FSC. These false positives are probably caused by high

9 2 3 7 6 10 10 9 8 6 5 5 5 3 2 3 3 1 1 1 0.4 0.4 1

0.1 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.1 0

2

4

6

8

10

Per

cen

tage

of

ob

serv

atio

ns

Fuel Sulphur Content (%)

8%

11%

16%

5% 0% 53% 17% 17% 0% 0% 0% 8% 32% 9% 0% 0% 4% 100% 0% 21% 7% 5% 10% 100% 0% 0% 100% 0% 0% 0% 0% 12% 27% 0% 3% 11% 9% 8% 18% 0% 17% 0% 0% 11% 0% 0% 0% 100%

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

AG BB BE BM BS CH CN CW CY DE DK DZ ES FI FO FR GB GI GR HK HR IE IN IR IT JP KR KY LR LU LY MH MT NL NO PA PH PT SA SE SG TR UK US VC

Nr of ships Number of observed ships per Flag State Red (>0.4% S-Content)Orange (0.2-0.4% S-Content)Yellow (0.15-0.2% S-Content)Green (0-0.15% S-Content)% non compliant

11

NOx emissions that interfere with the SO2 measurements – it should be noted though

that such supposed false positives need to be further investigated e.g. through future

validation campaigns.

Figure 7 Plot of the min (left) average (line) and maximum (right) length (m) of the observed ships per FSC threshold

When comparing the ship size of the observed ships, again no significant difference is

observed. The only thing that can be mentioned here is that smaller ships (<100m) are

more difficult to monitor and seem to be more compliant. The average ship size in the 4

threshold categories is round 220m.

When comparing the destination of the observed ships, no significant difference can be

observed between ships sailing to a SECA port or a non-SECA port. It was expected that

a higher non-compliance level would be observed for ships sailing away from the SECA

(as ships sailing away may be in the assumption that no inspection will be carried out in

the next port of call), but the data does not seem to support this assumption. The des-

tination was derived from the destination written down in the AIS information, this part

of the AIS information is often not updated, therefore for this analysis, the destination

was compared to the course, if they did not correspond, the data was excluded.

Figure 8 Differentiations between ships sailing to SECA or Non-SECA port (based on the destination entered in AIS)

The ship type of the monitored ships is available on AIS and stored in the database after

an FSC measurement, mainly tankers (57%) and cargo ships (37%) have been ob-

served. When comparing compliance levels between tankers and cargo ships, a relative-

ly higher non-compliance level has been observed with cargo ships, but this is not a

significant difference. There seems to be a higher non-compliance level for passenger

ships, but as only 15 passenger ships have been observed again no strong conclusions

can be made. It can be concluded that there seem to be some differences in compliancy

rates when comparing ship types, but that these are not significant and clearly need to

be confirmed by future monitoring efforts.

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450Length (m)

Ship Size (Min-Average-Max)

200 87%

9 4%

14 6%

8 3%

Out of SECA

824 88%

32 3%

52 6%

24 3%

SECA

12

Figure 9 Comparison of compliance levels between ship types

When examining the spatial distribution of the FSC measurements it can be concluded

that, besides some isolated cases, the majority of the high FSC measurements

(FSC>0.4%) are observed in shipping lanes farther from port. For the medium FSC

measurements (0.2%>FSC>0.4%) no significant difference can be observed in the spa-

tial distribution. Furthermore it can be observed that the ship direction in the shipping

lanes (North or South) does not look like to have an impact on the FSC, this confirms

the results of the analysis of the vessel destination.

Figure 10 Map of all inspected ships with 4 thresholds

574 61

15 6

423

46 3

2

1 14 21 1

2

8 25 4 1 12

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Cargo Other Passenger Special Tanker

Red (>0.4% S-Content)

Orange (0.2-0.4% S-Content)

Yellow (0.15-0.2% S-Content)

Green (0-0.15% S-Content)

13

Figure 11 Zoomed map of all monitored ships in the Bonn Agreement Quadripartite Zone of Joint

Responsibility

Figure 12 Zoomed map of all observed non-compliant ships in the Bonn Agreement Quadripartite Zone of Joint Responsibility

14

5.3 Evaluation on project milestones

In the total framework of the project (2015-2016), 152 flight hours on task (over sea)

have been performed for the Sniffer campaign and 1595 ships had been monitored. This

is slightly more than the operational objective for MUMM for Activity 3 which consisted

of 1000-1500 monitored ships over 150 flight hours.

Table 2 Evaluation on dedicated milestones according to the Annex 1 of Grant Agreement CompMon Project Dedicated milestones in CompMon 2015 2016 Total

Flight Hours (on task) 50 100 150

Number of monitored ships 500 1000 1500

Performed milestones during the Belgian Sniffer Campaigns

Flight Hours (on task) 17 135 152

Number of monitored ships 153 1445 1595

6 SIOB

A joint campaign was organised by the CompMon Senior Board of Inspectors (SIOB)

from 22/08/2016-9/09/2016. During this campaign MUMM forwarded all flight reports to

the SIOB members by a dedicated e-mail alias (SIOB@naturalsciences.be).

7 ILT

The Netherlands Shipping Inspectorate organized an intensified period for compliance

monitoring in the period from 5 to 16 September in the Rotterdam area. During this

period following means were deployed:

Ca. 14 flying hours have been performed by MUMM (about 150 FSC measurements),

all observations were reported after flight to PSC@ilent.nl,

40 flying hours (327 FSC measurements) have been performed by Explicit with the

AS355 helicopter,

24x7 monitoring has been carried out at the Rotterdam harbour entrance by a fixed

sniffer of TNO,

In addition to the PSC Inspections, NSI utilised a Fuel Calculator to verify compliance

during the last sea leg.

8 Health Aspects

During the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016, air quality measurements were performed

inside the cabin and cockpit of the surveillance aircraft. The results of the measure-

ments were analysed in collaboration with BIM/IGBGE (owner of the black carbon sam-

pling device). The results of these measurements have shown that there is a negligible

health impact for the crew during MARPOL Annex VI monitoring flights, average expo-

sure values to black carbon seem to be even significantly lower during MARPOL Annex

VI inspection flights than during commuting. The average black carbon exposure is

slightly higher during sniffer flights than during normal surveillance flights (not signifi-

cant), but the black carbon exposure when commuting, or when at home (in Brussels) is

higher than during the sniffer flights.

15

Figure 13 Box Plot of average black carbon exposure during different activities

Figure 14 Break-down of Black carbon exposure during a typical working day

9 Media and press

A press event was organised on 16/11/2016 at the end of the Belgian Sniffer Campaign

2016, with the State Secretary for the North Sea, Mr. Philippe De Backer. The State

Secretary was invited that day to come on board of the aircraft during a MARPOL Annex

VI monitoring flight. A press document was drafted by MUMM and a short press confer-

ence was held on the tarmac to present the CompMon initiative and flight results. In the

afternoon two representatives from INEA participated on a second flight, with a demon-

stration of the sniffer and the execution of a MARPOL Annex VI monitoring operation.

10 Lessons learned and future perspectives

Following lessons learned and future perspectives could be drawn up from this cam-

paign:

The manual execution of the FSC measurements with the IGPS Soft-

ware is necessary for good measurements as the automatic calculation

often gives errors in either the FSC measurement or the assignment of

the plume to the correct ship.

0

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

14000

Home Driving Operation Flying Sniffer Fueling

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00

Driving Home (Brussels) Flight Tarmac

Fuelling

Fuelling

16

Finding the exhaust plume has drastically improved compared to 2015,

but still seems to be challenging in some cases or particular conditions,

often a second approach is necessary and even then it was not always

possible to get a successful measurement. Experiments with visualisa-

tion sensors (UV and IR) have been undertaken, but show limited suc-

cess so far, more research is necessary on this topic.

The warming up of the sensor with ground power and GPU combined

with an external battery to cope with short power-cuts proves to be

working very well.

We have experienced some communication problems with the email

communications with PSC, these issues should be avoided in future.

Timely reporting on a 24/7 basis is crucial: PSC inspectors reported that

currently there still is an issue of reporting versus plan-

ning/prioritisation of port inspections.

PSC alerts were successfully put in the Thetis-EU system by PSC in-

spectors, but so far no automatic feedback is possible, meaning that

every call needs to be looked-up manually for feedback.

It is currently not possible to add compliant ships in Thetis-EU, it would

be helpful to be able to mark ships in Thetis-EU if they were found to be

compliant, this would be valuable strategic information for PSC inspec-

tors in optimizing their inspection efficiency.

A threshold of 0.15% for reporting of individual incompliant ships to

PSC could be too low, and will probably have to be increased to 0.2%,

which is the sniffer threshold that is recommended for use by Flux-

sense. This deserves further discussion with the PSC authorities and

sensor developers. However, for reporting of compliant ships a thresh-

old of 0.15% seems appropriate and in line with the sensor technology.

The main need for future work is in the field of standardization and

validation of the different monitoring systems. It is necessary to pro-

vide uniform information about the accuracy of the FSC measurements

to PSC inspection services and other involved authorities, and standard-

isation and validation of sensors is also crucial in the long term, if the

sensor data are to be used as evidence to court.

Some older ships have been observed on a regular basis with high FSC

measurements, although they are only sailing in SECA and have no

HSFO on board. It is not clear yet what is causing these false positives,

but they have been observed by fixed stations and other surveillance

aircraft. The ships have no sludge or other incinerator on board that

could cause these errors. It could be caused by very high NOx meas-

urements. If this is the cause, an additional NOx sensor could improve

the data quality of the FSC measurements. Partly focussing future vali-

dation efforts on such vessels might also improve the understanding of

how these false positives are caused.

In some cases mineral oil particles may interfere with the FSC-

measurements, this may cause long tales on the SO2 graph. In those

cases, the FSC measurements should be treated with caution.

17

11 Conclusions

During the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016 from August to November 2016, MUMM has

successfully implemented airborne MARPOL Annex VI monitoring in the Bonn Agreement

Quadripartite Zone of Joint Responsibility and the Dutch waters. It was the first time

that this kind of operation was conducted on this large time and spatial scale in the

North Sea. The monitoring operations were part of Activity 3 of the CompMon project

funded by the European Union.

In 45 days of successfully conducting airborne measurements, 135 flight hours were

performed and ca 1400 ships were monitored of which for 1300 a good FSC measure-

ments could be acquired, this means that at one hour an average of 10 ships could be

monitored, this means that in 85% of the approaches a successful FSC measurement

can be made. Together with the flight hours from the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2015,

more than 150 flight hours over sea for MARPOL Annex VI monitoring were executed by

MUMM, by this MUMM completed its milestone for Activity 3 of the CompMon project.

The experiences from the campaign were used in the development of the Best Practice

Report on airborne MARPOL Annex VI monitoring which is a MUMM responsibility de-

scribed in Activity 4 of the CompMon project.

During the Belgian Sniffer Campaign 2016 almost 100 non-compliant ships were

observed (8%) with a FSC value above a 0.2% threshold. Data-analysis revealed no

significant difference between different ship types, nor sizes, nor flag states. Not even

the vessels’ destination (inside or outside SECA) seemed to have an impact on the

compliance level, although it was observed that a higher incompliance level was

observed in shipping lanes at a certain distance from shore than in port entry zones.

The sniffer is succesfully installed on the Belgian aircraft OO-MMM, the sniffer was first

installed as loose equipment with an approval from the CAMO, but during the campagin

an EASA certificied installation was procured. The IGPS software has been installed on

several computers including the mission on board computer and several dedicated high

performance laptops. The software has improved significantly since the start of the

campaign, mainly the manual measurement system is working very well, although some

uncertainties on measurement accuracy and the very occasional occurrence of

unreliable FSC measurements are still a concern. The combination with two operators

were one operator is responsible for the guidance of the pilots and the reporting and the

other operator for the FSC measurements was assesed very efficient. Reports were in

almost all cases send near real time, right after landing.

The airborne MARPOL Annex VI monitoring and subsequent reporting of targeted ves-

sels to PSC resulted in a significant increase in the efficiency of port inspections (from 3

to 20%), but still a lot of aerial monitoring observations failed to be confirmed by/during

on board inspections.

This COMPMON experience has demonstrated that the airborne monitoring information

can be used very efficiently for the targeting of ship inspections in port. But future work

is needed in terms of both broad-scaled validation and inter-comparison campaigns and

sensor standardization, in order to improve the understanding, assessment and report-

ing of airborne monitoring data, and to facilitate the use of airborne monitoring data as

evidence to court.

18

Annex 1: Technical information OO-MMM platform

1. Airborne platform

Model: Britten Norman Islander

Call sign: OO-MMM

Length: 10.9 m; wingspan: 14.02 m; height: 3.77 m

2 Lycoming engines (300 hp)

Mean cruising speed: 120 kts

Autonomy: 5 hrs

2. SLAR

Model: Terma SLAR 9000

Range: 20/20 nm (standard operations) up to 40/40 nm

Resolution on ground: 35m (20nm range); 75m (40 nm range)

With pixel per pixel georeferencing from Flight Management System (FMS)

3. IR sensor

Model: FLIR A645

Resolution: 650x480

FOV: 45°

F-value: 1

4. Video camcorder

Model: Sony FDR-FX7

Focal length (35mm equivalent): 37,4 -748 mm (16/9) 45,7-914mm (4/3)

Maximum resolution: 1080i

Optical zoom: x20

5. GPS Positioning and Flight Management System

Model GPS: Garmin GTN650 (x2)

Model FMS: Garmin G600

Data-export of coordinates, course, airspeed, groundspeed, windspeed and direction,

time, date, altitude (barometric), roll and pitch angle to control-unit

Built in Airband VHF radio-communication

1m accuracy

6. Still camera

Model: Nikon D7000

Lens: VR16-50mm

Model: Nikon D800

Lens: VR70-300mm

Image overlay with georeference from FMS

7. Control-unit

Model: Optimare Medusa System

Integration and control van sensors and sensor-images

equipped with ECDIS and Comar SLR200 AIS receiver

8. Radar altimeter

Model: Bendix King KRA405B

Data-export from barometric altitude to control unit

Accuracy: 1m

19

20

Annex 2: Technical drawing Sniffer

21

Annex 3: IGPS print screens

Figure 15 Graphical representation by IGPS software of the measured CO2 (magenta line) and SO2 (green line), automatically calculated FSC and link to corresponding ship

Figure 16 Graphical representation of SO2 (green) and CO2 (magenta) concentrations during

manual calculation of FSC, background concentration (grey shaded area) and peak (plume) concentrations (red shaded area) can be selected by moving the borders of the shaded

22

Figure 17 Print screen of the navigation map of the IGPS software showing the difficulties the IGPS software may encounter in a busy shipping area like the Belgian North Sea for the automatic calculation of the FSC and linking this to a monitored ship based on the modelled position of the ship exhaust plume (the coloured lines behind the ship represent the modelled position of the ship

exhaust plume, the blue-green bold line represents the track of the aircraft, the colour is an indication for the measured SO2 and Co2, the green colour means around the ship means the ship is marked as compliant, the magenta colour means the ship is marked to be listed for inspection,

the grey colour means that ship was inspected but that no measurement could be established)

23

Annex 4: List of participants

Name Title Organisation

Ward Van Roy Operator RBINS-OD Nature-MUMM

Maarten Van Cappellen Operator RBINS-OD Nature-MUMM

Kobe Scheldeman Operator RBINS-OD Nature-MUMM

Ronny Schallier Coordinator SURV RBINS-OD Nature-MUMM

Sigrid Maebe Public relations RBINS-OD Nature-MUMM

Wouter Swalus Health and Safety manager RBINS

Geert Present Captain Belgian Defece (COMOPSAIR)

Karl Magriet Captain Belgian Defece (COMOPSAIR)

Gilbert Witters Adj. Major Belgian Defece (COMOPSAIR)

Dries Noppe Commander Belgian Defece (COMOPSAIR)

Paul de Prest Commander/Poc defence Belgian Defece (COMOPSAIR)

Johan Mellqvist Point of contact FluxSense

Johan Ekholm Technical Expert FluxSense

Christophe Swolfs Legal Advisor FOD Mobility

Roland Vandenbussche Poc Environmental Inspections. FOD Mobility

Veerle De Rooster Poc Thetis-EU FOD Mobility

Bart Colaers Maritime Inspector FOD Mobility

Hilde Somers Maritime Inspector FOD Mobility

Sven Heyndrick Public relations FOD Mobility

Jasper Van Vliet Senior Advisor Netherlands Shipping Inspectorate

Tjitse Lupgens Senior Inspector Netherlands Shipping Inspectorate

MIK-NL (Den Helder) MIK NL Netherlands Coastguard Focal Point

Coordination Centre (Den Helder)

NL National focal Point Netherlands Coastguard Focal Point

Ann Van Praet Financial Manager Ostend Airport

Patrick Vandamme POC aircraft maintenance Lindsky

24

Annex 5: Map of surveillance area

25

Annex 6: Schematic view of a ship approach

Figure 18 Crosswind Scenario (Vw = Vs +90°)

Figure 19 Headwind Scenario (Vw = Vs + 180°)

Wind Vector

Ship Vector

Crosswind (Vw=Vs+90°)

Headwind (Vw=Vs+180°)

Tailwind Vw>Vs

Tailwind Vw<Vs

Tailwind Vw=Vs

26

Figure 20 Limited tailwind Scenario (Vw<Vs)

Figure 21 Strong tailwind Scenario (VS<VW)

27

Figure 22 Vertical plume scenario (Vw=Vs)

28

Annex 7: Overview of CompMon Flights

Date Flight Pilots Operators Routing UTC UTC Engine time

Flight time

SNIFFER ILT Transit Engine

27/06 16104 WTT WVR EBAW-EBZW 7:45 8:21 0:30 0:25

0:25 0:05

07/07 16106 WTT/DPT

EBZW-EBAW 14:06 15:00 0:54 0:30

0:30 0:24

10/08 16142 PST/NOP WVR EBAW-ETMN 6:15 9:09 2:54 2:40

2:40 0:14

11/08 16143 NOP/PST WVR ETMN-ETMN 13:10 15:04 1:54 1:30

1:30 0:24

12/08 16144 PST/NOP WVR ETMN-EBAW 12:10 15:40 3:30 3:10

3:10 0:20

18/08 16153 WTT/NOP WVR EBAW-EDXW 10:00 13:12 3:12 3:00

3:00 0:12

18/08 16154 NOP/WTT WVR EDXW-ESGP 14:10 16:34 2:24 2:20

2:20 0:04

19/08 16155 WTT/NOP WVR ESGP-ETMN 9:30 12:18 2:48 2:20

2:20 0:28

19/08 16156 NOP/WTT WVR ETMN-EBAW 13:10 16:16 3:06 2:55 1:45

1:10 0:11

20/08 16157 WTT/NOP WVR EBAW-EBOS 9:20 10:32 1:12 1:00 0:35

0:25 0:12

20/08 16158 NOP/WTT WVR EBOS-EBAW 13:30 15:18 1:48 1:40 1:30

0:10 0:08

21/08 16159 WTT/PST WVR EBAW-EBOS 9:20 10:38 1:18 1:05 0:50

0:15 0:13

21/08 16160 PST/WTT WVR EBOS-EBAW 12:45 14:21 1:36 1:30 1:10

0:20 0:06

22/08 16161 MAG/WTT KS EBAW-EBOS 10:00 11:36 1:36 1:25 1:05

0:20 0:11

22/08 16162 WTT/MAG KS EBOS-EBOS 13:30 15:12 1:42 1:30 1:30

0:12

23/08 16163 MAG/WTT KS EBOS-EBOS 9:10 11:16 2:06 2:00 2:00

0:06

23/08 16164 WTT/MAG WVR EBOS-EBOS 12:30 14:18 1:48 1:40 1:40

0:08

24/08 16165 PST/NOP KS EBOS-EBOS 9:15 11:09 1:54 1:45 1:35

0:10 0:09

24/08 16166 NOP/PST MVC EBOS-EBOS 13:30 15:18 1:48 1:40 1:40

0:08

25/08 16167 NOP/PST WVR EBOS-EBOS 13:00 15:36 2:36 2:25 2:25

0:11

26/08 16168 PST/NOP MVC EBOS-EBOS 8:50 11:08 2:18 2:05 2:05

0:13

26/08 16169 NOP/PST WVR+MVC EBOS-EBAW 11:30 15:12 3:42 1:40 1:20

0:20 2:02

28/08 16170 WTT/WIT WVR+MVC EBAW-EBOS 8:35 10:59 2:24 2:10 1:45

0:25 0:14

28/08 16171 WTT/WIT WVR+MVC EBOS-EBAW 12:40 14:34 1:54 1:45 1:35

0:10 0:09

29/08 16172 WTT/NOP WVR+KS EBAW-EBOS 10:20 12:14 1:54 1:45 1:35

0:10 0:09

29/08 16173 NOP/WTT KS+WVR EBOS-EBOS 14:20 16:32 2:12 2:00 2:00

0:12

30/08 16174 WTT/NOP WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 9:00 10:30 1:30 1:25 1:25

0:05

30/08 16175 PST/WTT WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 12:55 15:31 2:36 2:25 0:55 1:30

0:11

31/08 16176 PST/WTT KS+WVR EBOS-EBOS 9:05 10:59 1:54 1:45 1:15

0:30 0:09

31/08 16177 WTT/PST KS+WVR EBOS-EBAW 13:00 14:12 1:12 1:00 0:25

0:35 0:12

04/09 16178 PST/WTT RS+MVC EBAW-EBOS 8:45 10:57 2:42 2:00 1:45

0:15 0:42

04/09 16179 WTT/PST RS+MVC EBOS-EBAW 13:00 14:36 1:36 1:30 1:20

0:10 0:06

05/09 16180 NOP/PST WVR+KS EBAW-EBOS 8:30 11:36 3:06 2:50 0:30 2:05 0:15 0:16

05/09 16181 PST/NOP WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 13:20 14:50 1:30 1:25 1:25

0:05

06/09 16182 NOP/PST WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 9:15 12:03 2:48 2:45 0:30 2:15

0:03

06/09 16183 PST/NOP WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 13:20 14:50 1:30 1:25 1:25

0:05

07/09 16184 DPT/WTT WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 9:10 12:52 3:42 3:30 2:10 1:20

0:12

08/09 16185 WTT/DPT RS+MVC EBOS-EBOS 10:00 12:54 2:54 2:50 0:30 2:20

0:04

08/09 16186 DPT/VMR RS+MVC EBOS-EBOS 15:00 17:06 2:06 1:50 1:50

0:16

09/09 16187 DPT/VMR RS+MVC EBOS-EBOS 9:00 11:42 2:42 2:25 0:45 1:40

0:17

09/09 16188 DPT/VMR RS+MVC EBOS-EBOS 13:00 14:12 1:12 1:05 1:05

0:07

09/09 16189 DPT/VMR RS+MVC EBOS-EBAW 15:00 15:42 0:42 0:35

0:35 0:07

12/09 16190 DPT WVR+KS EBAW-EBOS 08:30 11:30 3:00 2:55 0:10 2:30 0:15 0:05

12/09 16191 MAG/NOP WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 13:30 15:12 1:42 1:30 1:30

0:12

13/09 16192 MAG/NOP WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 9:00 12:12 3:12 3:05 3:05

0:07

14/09 16193 DPT/PST MVC+RS EBOS-EBOS 9:20 11:56 2:36 2:35 0:40 1:55

0:01

14/09 16194 PST/DPT MVC+RS EBOS-EBOS 14:00 15:36 1:36 1:30 1:30

0:06

29

Date Flight Pilots Operators Routing UTC UTC Engine time

Flight time

SNIFFER ILT Transit Engine

15/09 16195 PST/DPT MVC+RS EBOS-EBOS 9:00 11:00 2:00 1:45 1:45

0:15

15/09 16196 DPT MVC+RS EBOS-EBAW 12:00 12:42 0:42 0:35

0:35 0:07

20/09 16198 VMR/DPT WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 09:10 11:16 2:06 1:50 1:50

0:16

20/09 16199 VMR/DPT WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 12:55 14:55 2:00 1:50 1:50

0:10

21/09 16201 VMR/DPT WVR+KS EBOS-EBAW 10:06 13:00 2:54 2:40 2:15

0:25 0:14

26/09 16202 PST/VMR WVR+MVC EBAW-EBOS 09:00 12:06 3:06 2:50 2:35

0:15 0:16

26/09 16203 PST/VMR WVR+MVC EBOS-EBOS 14:10 15:46 1:36 1:30 1:30

0:06

27/09 16204 PST/VMR WVR+MVC EBOS-EBAW 9:40 11:58 2:18 2:00 1:45

0:15 0:18

28/09 16205 NOP/WTT WVR+KS EBAW-EDVE 5:50 9:44 3:54 3:30

1:45 1:45 0:24

29/09 16206 NOP/WTT WVR+KS EDVE-EBAW 13:50 16:44 2:54 2:40

2:40 0:14

30/09 16207 WTT/MAG MVC+RS EBAW-EBAW 11:00 13:12 2:12 1:40

1:40 0:32

03/10 16208 NOP/DPT KS EBAW-EBOS 9:00 11:30 2:30 2:05 1:50

0:15 0:25

03/10 16209 DPT/NOP KS EBOS-EBOS 13:45 15:57 2:12 2:00 2:00

0:12

04/10 16211 DPT/NOP KS EBOS-EBAW 9:20 12:56 3:36 3:30 0:25 2:55 0:10 0:06

05/10 16212 WMR/DPT WVR+KS EBAW-EBOS 8:00 11:18 3:18 3:00 0:15 2:35 0:10 0:18

05/10 16213 DPT/VMR WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 12:50 14:56 2:06 2:00 2:00

0:06

06/10 16214 VMR/DPT WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 9:20 11:26 2:06 1:55 1:55

0:11

06/10 16215 DPT/VMR WVR+KS EBOS-EBAW 13:30 15:42 2:12 1:55 1:45

0:10 0:17

10/10 16216 PST/NOP MVC+KS EBAW-EBOS 9:15 11:09 1:54 1:50 1:40

0:10 0:04

10/10 16217 NOP/PST MVC+KS EBOS-EBOS 13:00 14:48 1:48 1:40 1:40

0:08

11/10 16219 NOP/PST MVC+KS EBOS-EBOS 9:20 11:02 1:42 1:30 1:30

0:12

11/10 16220 PST/NOP MVC+KS EBOS-EBOS 12:40 14:04 1:24 1:15 1:15

0:09

12/10 16221 DPT/VMR WVR EBOS-EBOS 11:00 13:06 2:06 1:50 0:40 1:10

0:16

12/10 16222 VMR/DPT WVR EBOS-EBOS 12:00 16:42 4:42 1:35 1:35

3:07

13/10 16223 DPT/VMR WVR EBOS-EBOS 11:00 13:00 2:00 1:45 0:45 1:00

0:15

13/10 16224 VMR/DPT WVR EBOS-EBOS 12:30 13:54 1:24 1:10 1:10

0:14

25/10 16226 VMR/PST KS+WVR EBAW-EBOS 13:40 15:46 2:06 1:55 1:45

0:10 0:11

26/10 16227 PST/VMR WVR+KS EBOS-EBAW 10:20 13:02 2:42 2:20 2:00

0:20 0:22

27/10 16228 NOP/VMR WVR+MVC EBAW-EBOS 12:05 14:17 2:12 2:05 1:50

0:15 0:07

27/10 16229 VMR/NOP MVC+WVR EBOS-EBOS 15:00 17:00 2:00 1:45 1:45

0:15

28/10 16230 NOP/VMR WVR EBOS-EBOS 9:10 10:58 1:48 1:35 1:35

0:13

28/10 16231 VMR/NOP MVC+WVR EBOS-EBAW 12:15 14:33 2:18 2:00 1:45

0:15 0:18

09/11 16232 VMR/NOP KS EBAW-EBAW 10:15 11:09 0:54 0:40 0:15

0:25 0:14

09/11 16233 VMR/NOP KS EBAW-EBOS 12:48 13:30 0:42 0:35

0:35 0:07

09/11 16234 NOP/VMR KS EBOS-EBOS 14:00 15:18 1:18 1:05 0:30

0:35 0:13

10/11 16236 NOP/VMR KS EBOS-EBOS 10:10 11:52 1:42 1:35 1:35

0:07

10/11 16237 NOP/VMR KS EBOS-EBAW 12:10 13:04 0:54 0:45 0:30

0:15 0:09

15/11 16238 NOP/DPT WVR+KS EBAW-EBOS 14:00 16:06 2:06 1:50 1:30

0:20 0:16

16/11 16239 DPT/NOP WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 8:39 9:45 1:06 0:50 0:50

0:16

16/11 16240 NOP/DPT WVR+KS EBOS-EBOS 13:15 14:27 1:12 1:00 1:00

0:12

16/11 16241 NOP/DPT WVR+KS EBOS-EBAW 15:00 16:00 1:00 0:55 0:30

0:25 0:05

21/11 16242 PST/NOP KS+WVR EBAW-EBOS 10:10 12:04 1:54 1:45 1:35

0:10 0:09

21/11 16243 NOP/PST WVR+KS EBOS-EBAW 13:20 15:50 2:30 2:15 1:55

0:20 0:15

29/11 16246 VMR/PST WVR EBAW-EBOS 10:30 12:30 2:00 1:45 1:35

0:10 0:15

30/11 16248 VMR/PST WVR EBOS-EBOS 9:20 10:38 1:18 1:15 0:05

1:10 0:03

30/11 16249 PST/VMR WVR EBOS-EBAW 14:00 15:48 1:48 1:35 1:15

0:20 0:13

19/12 16255 NOP/WTT EBAW-EBZW 9:50 10:20 0:42 0:30 0:12

23/12 16256 VMR/WTT EBZW-EBAW 15:10 15:40 0:48 0:30 0:18

Total

196:30 171:35 109:55 25:00 37:40 23:55

30

Annex 8: List of all inspected ships

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16156 19/08/2016 13:49:29 13:49:24 53.859833 6.47367 53.859933 6.473983 259 17.6 MAPTM LU 175 28 71 HIGH 0.35 Orange Out of SECA16156 19/08/2016 13:53:56 13:53:56 53.806871 6.233173 53.806475 6.232608 252 13.7 ANTWERP LR 222 30 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16156 19/08/2016 13:56:19 13:56:20 53.790568 6.09669 53.789945 6.095928 252 13.8 ANTWERP PT 334 41 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:11:47 14:10:21 53.549336 5.329591 53.555033 5.39335 67 11.1 BRAKE GERMANY PA 190 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:14:30 #N/A 53.595443 5.195858 53.595043 5.197685 251 10.1 SHEERNESS SE 170 24 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:15:26 #N/A 53.584071 5.142645 53.582758 5.144105 252 11.2 BURGAS PT 104 16 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:21:19 #N/A 53.46062 4.924416 53.460083 4.931866 66 17.1 ELBE IT 300 48 60 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:32:55 #N/A 53.250358 4.455511 53.246473 4.459583 205 14.9 GB SOU DE 366 48 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:42:02 13:08:35 53.014336 4.356956 53.01436 4.359153 29 15.7 BREMERHAVEN BM 245 32 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:50:09 #N/A 52.814353 4.223168 52.814 4.224333 20 12.8 BREMEN GERMANY NL 132 16 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:51:32 09:58:44 52.797616 4.168161 52.797651 4.168716 36 14 BREMERHAVEN DK 294 32 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16156 19/08/2016 14:53:32 #N/A 52.74964 4.146193 52.750233 4.1445 36 10.5 HOLLA AG 90 14 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16156 19/08/2016 15:04:31 #N/A 52.508728 3.845036 52.515298 3.851096 185 9.3 ROTTERDAM HK 400 59 71 HIGH 0.34 Orange SECA16156 19/08/2016 15:11:18 #N/A 52.324346 3.86388 52.325426 3.861991 349 13.3 KLAIPEDA CY 151 23 71 HIGH 0.25 Orange SECA16157 20/08/2016 10:06:12 15:03:05 51.461586 3.51713 51.460196 3.516253 159 10.8 ANTWERP CY 99 16 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16157 20/08/2016 10:12:03 15:10:32 51.409023 3.298051 51.40691 3.298058 95 17.1 VLISSINGEN PA 183 32 70 HIGH 0.15 Yellow SECA16157 20/08/2016 10:15:26 #N/A 51.401341 3.155123 51.399916 3.155765 84 17.2 ANTWERP PT 334 41 71 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16157 20/08/2016 10:17:43 #N/A 51.408078 3.057676 51.406745 3.058955 101 19.4 ANTWERP LU 300 42 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16157 20/08/2016 10:19:53 13:56:20 51.429556 2.966028 51.428323 2.966271 117 14.4 TEES UK FI 195 26 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16157 20/08/2016 10:28:29 #N/A 51.387341 2.759423 51.392216 2.763491 43 9.4 GHENT HK 200 32 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16157 20/08/2016 10:29:58 #N/A 51.355558 2.81404 51.354 2.813 91 10.2 FLUSHING GB 89 13 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16158 20/08/2016 12:45:54 09:25:01 51.364998 2.80994 51.367373 2.784375 264 11.1 LE HAVRE LR 366 48 72 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16158 20/08/2016 12:48:17 10:27:53 51.3708 2.717961 51.369678 2.715601 129 12.4 ANTWERP CY 113 20 84 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16158 20/08/2016 12:56:06 12:42:17 51.38829 2.616088 51.3707 2.593411 88 8.3 ANTWERP GB 282 32 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:00:20 #N/A 51.368893 2.524408 51.366833 2.522333 83 8.9 ANTWERP PA 172 28 73 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:05:00 MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:08:40 #N/A 51.53188 2.26517 51.525166 2.3065 40 13.5 ROTTERDAM KY 100 17 82 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:10:28 13:34:40 51.558238 2.335491 51.536855 2.293216 38 13.9 DE EME NO 200 32 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:13:30 10:06:22 51.61129 2.404411 51.6086 2.40235 40 12.7 STADE GERMANY PA 225 33 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:19:13 13:07:33 51.701928 2.278011 51.70112 2.275205 223 8.6 LES ESCOUMINS CY 186 23 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:21:09 13:09:25 51.723285 2.375978 51.71778 2.363701 223 13.3 SANTA MARTA LR 156 23 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:27:08 #N/A 51.801066 2.714483 51.799788 2.714326 73 14.2 ROTTERDAM SA 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:37:00 #N/A 51.648081 3.019918 51.645625 3.018461 221 13.1 ZEEBRUGGE SG 199 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:52:35 #N/A 51.44189 3.497785 51.418188 3.485408 262 13.9 LE HAVRE PA 337 46 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:53:56 #N/A 51.436995 3.574311 51.436825 3.571228 312 9.3 HAMBURG IT 176 31 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:56:20 #N/A 51.441535 3.650426 51.440501 3.645448 267 10.2 LE HAVRE LR 231 31 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16158 20/08/2016 13:57:43 13:48:54 51.416845 3.710636 51.415101 3.707558 164 8.4 GHENT HK 200 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16158 20/08/2016 14:01:22 #N/A 51.350558 3.863885 51.3487 3.858766 253 12.6 DAKAR MH 183 32 79 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16159 21/08/2016 09:51:44 #N/A 51.363348 3.907126 51.362453 3.904321 234 16.5 LE HAVRE LR 243 32 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16159 21/08/2016 09:55:58 10:27:53 51.402761 3.744681 51.401995 3.741206 302 9.4 VLISSINGEN PA 183 32 70 HIGH 0.15 Yellow SECA16159 21/08/2016 09:57:06 #N/A 51.418298 3.70618 51.416378 3.705501 151 11.7 STEENBANK MT 128 20 89 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16159 21/08/2016 10:01:28 #N/A 51.425623 3.549455 51.423551 3.547896 76 9.2 GHENT MH 180 30 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16159 21/08/2016 10:06:46 09:56:58 51.406633 3.364445 51.404783 3.364033 85 15.5 VLISSINGEN SG 162 26 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16159 21/08/2016 10:06:58 #N/A 51.406545 3.357258 51.409333 3.363833 263 14.2 SOUTHAMPTON PA 172 28 73 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16159 21/08/2016 10:12:24 13:06:43 51.38582 3.161193 51.382833 3.158566 134 15.3 ZEEBRUGGE SE 228 32 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16159 21/08/2016 10:15:00 MH 354 48 70 LOW 0.06 Green NA16159 21/08/2016 10:18:31 #N/A 51.375111 2.942793 51.373731 2.941908 72 12 ANTWERP LR 185 24 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16159 21/08/2016 10:21:51 10:06:22 51.355925 2.841685 51.358576 2.841568 79 16.7 ZEEBRUGGE FI 188 27 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16159 21/08/2016 10:33:44 10:12:20 51.320381 2.621988 51.357133 2.6034 273 ANTWERP MH 169 29 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:00:30 10:18:16 51.358023 2.76623 51.357066 2.763433 80 15 FLUSHING HK 174 28 89 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:03:02 10:21:31 51.36458 2.675765 51.362883 2.688283 85 11.8 ANTWERP NL 115 19 81 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:15:01 #N/A 51.538038 2.275003 51.528525 2.272416 43 12.6 ROTTERDAM MH 200 32 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:18:43 13:00:29 51.587983 2.156095 51.570936 2.155393 221 9.7 PANAMA-FLORIDA LR 155 26 70 LOW 0.01 Green Out of SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:23:57 #N/A 51.687456 2.337236 51.68163 2.287803 227 15.1 DUBLIN PT 141 22 71 LOW 0.04 Green Out of SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:23:59 13:14:31 51.688531 2.337253 51.686783 2.332433 226 14.6 LE HAVRE LR 278 40 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:24:38 13:17:44 51.709461 2.334546 51.704616 2.318753 219 9 ESPAS AG 99 14 70 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:25:23 13:23:09 51.733746 2.32777 51.732235 2.324066 220 10.1 MONTOIR KY 96 16 82 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:26:40 13:23:52 51.745971 2.353993 51.745266 2.351968 220 12.6 ROUEN PA 175 28 82 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:30:00 #N/A 51.821561 2.349588 51.795996 2.303688 228 13.3 SHEERNESS PT 130 22 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:34:31 #N/A 51.825303 2.592831 51.82395 2.58375 281 13.1 SANTANDER GI 143 22 70 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:37:04 #N/A 51.903018 2.619931 51.859183 2.5841 202 15.5 ZEEBRUGGE JP 200 32 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:38:52 13:28:35 51.925443 2.63274 51.920888 2.624276 221 17.4 ANTWERP PA 275 32 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16160 21/08/2016 13:44:23 13:34:28 51.791375 2.78871 51.7882 2.785975 71 15.8 ROTTERDAM AG 130 21 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16160 21/08/2016 14:05:08 13:35:47 51.446925 3.673001 51.441236 3.650251 260 11 GEBZE PA 294 32 70 HIGH 0.35 Orange SECA16160 21/08/2016 14:11:05 13:38:48 51.370933 3.93608 51.369746 3.923773 53 17.9 ANTWERP IT 211 32 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16161 22/08/2016 10:20:35 13:44:23 51.35067 3.870573 51.349301 3.869358 73 12.8 ANTWERP PA 294 33 71 HIGH 0.35 Orange SECA16161 22/08/2016 10:29:19 10:29:16 51.435908 3.677683 51.4345 3.676871 129 10.9 BS 183 32 Not Detected Not Detected NA16161 22/08/2016 10:34:43 #N/A 51.418501 3.468046 51.418316 3.466466 261 11.7 DA 480 BS 113 20 90 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16161 22/08/2016 10:36:48 10:20:34 51.399941 3.417211 51.407835 3.4166 87 13.3 ANTWERP CY 199 27 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16161 22/08/2016 10:45:02 10:20:34 51.388455 3.12799 51.39359 3.126888 101 15 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16161 22/08/2016 10:47:37 09:56:39 51.418738 3.096471 51.40803 3.066753 283 15.8 LIMASSOL LR 261 32 71 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16161 22/08/2016 10:55:49 10:34:05 51.38619 2.958918 51.385485 2.954013 257 15 BERRE LU 104 17 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16161 22/08/2016 11:05:03 10:36:17 51.396448 2.622203 51.396758 2.637101 211 10.5 MURMANSK GR 184 28 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16161 22/08/2016 11:08:19 10:44:02 51.377068 2.546471 51.38111 2.558195 55 8 VLISSINGEN GB 213 32 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16161 22/08/2016 11:13:53 #N/A 51.36412 2.40299 51.363701 2.401206 256 13.8 NAPOLI BS 171 27 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16161 22/08/2016 11:15:33 #N/A 51.356266 2.353203 51.354283 2.3481 254 15 ALGECIRAS LR 174 28 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16162 22/08/2016 13:50:37 #N/A 51.365858 2.572615 51.364706 2.571811 88 13.4 ANTWERP DZ 138 21 75 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16162 22/08/2016 13:55:00 PA 180 30 LOW 0.09 Green NA16162 22/08/2016 14:02:10 11:04:22 51.461001 2.184865 51.458851 2.179443 39 15.7 SILLAMAE GB 155 23 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:07:33 11:07:27 51.618635 2.153765 51.574933 2.12785 222 11.1 SGSIN xx 324 60 80 LOW 0.04 Green Out of SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:07:36 11:17:16 51.61869 2.156225 51.594948 2.123076 222 12.1 AVILES MT 180 30 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:12:52 14:11:43 51.592366 2.412513 51.583356 2.371478 40 15.4 KLAIPEDA HK 180 28 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:17:29 14:02:08 51.666266 2.501695 51.654201 2.474975 38 13.6 AMSTERDAM MH 183 27 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:18:16 #N/A 51.688976 2.491075 51.658375 2.43793 44 17.2 ROTTERDAM SG 369 51 72 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:22:00 14:05:56 51.782023 2.3995 51.758795 2.40752 224 8.7 LE HAVRE xx 277 40 71 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:22:54 14:06:29 51.79297 2.446526 51.779916 2.408798 227 11 TANJUNG BIN MALAYSIANO 228 32 80 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:25:49 #N/A 51.848338 2.573151 51.806475 2.518048 223 11.1 ANTWERP MH 144 22 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:27:53 14:11:43 51.90724 2.622391 51.876435 2.58101 222 9.1 ROTTERDAM HK 292 45 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:32:33 14:15:48 51.974391 2.659385 51.896408 2.620045 219 9.8 SAFI BS 190 24 70 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:33:32 14:14:27 51.995605 2.703175 51.954456 2.657121 222 17.1 SOUTHAMPTON US 243 32 79 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:35:37 14:21:01 52.043096 2.769821 52.040888 2.767673 220 11.4 TURBO LR 209 30 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:35:53 14:22:13 52.036716 2.777761 52.034533 2.775283 223 12.1 ITACOATIARA PA 180 32 83 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16162 22/08/2016 14:46:28 14:24:19 51.779496 2.788781 51.805716 2.784066 71 12.3 ROTTERDAM GR 229 37 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 15:04:30 14:26:37 51.381265 2.861195 51.366005 2.84903 87 16.5 ANTWERP MH 219 32 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16162 22/08/2016 15:04:44 14:30:04 51.377373 2.872126 51.375815 2.86779 259 11.8 BEZEE xx 199 37 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:21:13 14:32:03 51.324668 2.347501 51.323951 2.350721 63 10 ANTWERP GB 184 27 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:24:42 14:35:34 51.314696 2.226188 51.29225 2.264666 59 7.9 ANTWERP PA 200 32 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:26:51 #N/A 51.316785 2.125503 51.318398 2.128298 23 10.5 FREDRIKSTAD AG 107 18 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:33:33 14:45:08 51.358573 2.197098 51.31115 2.2382 96 5.8 ANTWERP DE 280 32 79 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:37:53 15:03:11 51.459556 2.156296 51.46073 2.18708 44 10.5 DORDRECHT GI 103 16 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:40:00 183 32 Not Detected Not Detected NA16163 23/08/2016 09:44:11 #N/A 51.594283 2.179568 51.579955 2.15346 221 13.5 JORF_LASFAR MOROCCO LR 229 32 70 HIGH 0.50 Red Out of SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:50:25 #N/A 51.63984 2.210326 51.58383 2.179986 217 13.1 LE HAVRE AG 94 13 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:52:19 09:21:12 51.643626 2.272111 51.647178 2.261438 126 16.3 ZEEBRUGGE BE 162 25 72 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16163 23/08/2016 09:54:44 09:26:44 51.61719 2.220036 51.602675 2.230983 219 14.6 ZEEBRUGGE CW 206 43 79 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:00:03 09:24:42 51.675261 2.450536 51.672466 2.450366 40 12.9 TALLINN MH 184 28 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16163 23/08/2016 10:06:29 09:37:15 51.734993 2.622018 51.71895 2.63385 145 15.5 ZEEBRUGGE PA 114 20 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:08:21 09:43:33 51.793298 2.628868 51.791575 2.649293 40 10.2 BAALSTA NL 92 14 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:12:21 14:27:18 51.893455 2.587168 51.89178 2.586131 219 14.2 NEWPORT NEWS PA 221 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:12:46 09:44:21 51.892113 2.570015 51.8825 2.63755 106 15.3 ROTTERDAM DK 197 26 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:15:00 09:53:37 51.942848 2.575738 51.942166 2.562716 99 13.1 ROTTERDAM NL 152 22 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:17:10 09:59:43 51.904475 2.652273 51.903166 2.650833 219 13.4 PASAJES CW 132 16 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:21:54 10:05:17 51.89603 2.755363 51.889056 2.745273 354 14.6 SABETTA NL 157 26 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:28:14 10:08:25 51.787323 2.957263 51.786415 2.954576 260 15 LA HAVRE NO 144 23 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16163 23/08/2016 10:29:28 10:12:14 51.765865 3.00392 51.765478 3.001178 281 18.5 DEWVN LR 275 33 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 12:39:14 #N/A 51.409803 3.006558 51.388078 2.974058 250 15.3 EG PSD SG 138 22 70 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16164 23/08/2016 12:39:47 10:11:22 51.408855 3.029058 51.389385 3.000065 56 8.7 GHENT LR 190 31 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 12:47:31 10:14:01 51.409523 3.392341 51.401865 3.344151 91 12.6 ANTWERP NL 119 16 79 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 12:51:49 #N/A 51.422941 3.54936 51.4218 3.551241 79 5.8 GHENT FI 197 32 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 12:52:57 10:21:24 51.41782 3.496263 51.417126 3.50251 83 11.9 ANTWERP NO 186 32 80 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 12:54:23 #N/A 51.419953 3.43045 51.416165 3.4665 80 18.2 ANTWERP LR 280 32 71 HIGH 0.21 Orange SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:07:22 12:37:29 51.770715 3.168073 51.768525 3.167823 241 7 ANTWERP LR 400 59 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:07:38 10:11:14 51.768753 3.155201 51.750788 3.211471 36 9.2 WILHELMSHAVEN MH 300 48 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:15:47 12:45:49 51.952516 2.881146 51.9496 2.883733 42 18.8 BREMERHAVEN DK 399 60 79 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:19:09 #N/A 52.038603 2.857761 52.023233 2.876583 257 19.8 SUEZ DK 399 60 79 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:20:45 12:52:53 52.002643 2.809443 52.002316 2.814083 229 12.7 FALMOUTH LR 292 45 79 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:23:21 12:47:50 51.97991 2.689355 51.986866 2.702633 220 14.3 PAJARITOS MH 182 32 80 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:29:50 12:47:50 51.835538 2.498873 51.836115 2.501998 222 11.6 TEMA MH 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:32:03 13:07:16 51.786558 2.421931 51.785016 2.422016 225 12.3 AMSTERDAM MT 110 17 82 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:34:28 #N/A 51.732253 2.341628 51.732333 2.344666 220 15.3 LE HAVRE FR 277 40 71 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:40:08 13:15:05 51.586131 2.343615 51.587053 2.348986 37 10.1 NIGG BAY NO 250 40 38 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:43:17 #N/A 51.51834 2.277613 51.535723 2.271966 41 14.7 HAMBURG LR 300 48 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:51:56 13:19:38 51.501653 2.666658 51.498383 2.669766 194 2.5 ZEEBRUGGE PA 198 32 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 13:58:41 13:22:41 51.365665 2.69543 51.365795 2.700668 79 12.8 ZEEBRUGGE MT 194 26 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16164 23/08/2016 14:00:46 #N/A 51.36328 2.76195 51.362033 2.764433 87 13.1 ANTWERP DE 280 32 79 HIGH 0.35 Orange SECA16165 24/08/2016 09:30:43 13:31:58 51.380176 2.855766 51.379886 2.89845 261 17.3 LIVERPOOL LR 209 30 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 09:31:51 09:31:44 51.36507 2.804696 51.363915 2.807738 91 9 SLUISKIL NL 88 13 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 09:34:25 13:33:54 51.392418 2.703963 51.384796 2.706696 166 9.5 ZEEBRUGGE LR 188 28 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 09:36:04 10:52:54 51.365635 2.645568 51.362731 2.649133 83 3.5 ANTWERP HK 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16165 24/08/2016 09:48:43 09:47:01 51.359501 2.155956 51.358258 2.157281 38 8.3 HAMBURG HK 300 50 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 09:59:05 09:53:45 51.262065 2.124471 51.246393 2.167748 59 11.4 ANTWERP PA 274 32 1 HIGH 0.28 Orange SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:00:55 09:54:04 51.249063 2.050563 51.251666 2.09975 39 11.5 SCHEVENINGEN ANCH.LR 229 32 81 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:05:34 10:04:11 51.330268 1.908808 51.297166 1.936166 38 11.5 ROTTERDAM FR 197 30 79 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:07:04 13:40:53 51.366253 1.88448 51.363116 1.8828 209 13.7 ALGECIRAS MT 134 20 80 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:09:45 11:19:27 51.379006 1.903255 51.359823 1.896401 212 17.4 BELFAST AG 153 24 79 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:10:08 #N/A 51.3821 1.922213 51.379995 1.921905 212 13.7 SETE NL 137 19 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:15:12 09:24:42 51.39686 2.07397 51.39749 2.078286 36 14.9 ROTTERDAM SG 333 48 70 HIGH 0.30 Orange SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:21:58 13:58:37 51.535055 2.049686 51.532538 2.028025 222 12.5 ABIJAN CY 149 26 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:23:13 09:29:26 51.532533 2.100435 51.522933 2.064783 223 16.2 LE HAVRE MH 152 27 80 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:26:03 10:13:07 51.592656 2.209895 51.589665 2.208525 226 18.3 ROTTERDAM CY 139 22 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:28:02 09:34:30 51.618921 2.296121 51.617573 2.297763 134 15.9 ZEEBRUGGE MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:36:50 10:17:07 51.718723 2.400683 51.682713 2.288021 305 13.7 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 HIGH 0.50 Red SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:45:39 10:20:03 51.587545 2.720275 51.591195 2.71119 191 7 ANTWERP BS 250 38 79 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16165 24/08/2016 10:53:43 #N/A 51.415791 2.928625 51.415131 2.929823 99 11.4 ANTWERP HK 183 32 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16166 24/08/2016 13:54:46 15:21:04 51.408053 2.946506 51.384595 2.963395 259 15 PORT SAID TRANSIT CY 199 27 79 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:08:08 10:06:24 51.787091 2.940226 51.786596 2.941696 30 10.5 ROTTERDAM SG 147 24 82 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:13:47 10:07:35 51.913388 2.968893 51.884183 2.973833 87 11.8 ROTTERDAM LR 250 44 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:24:46 #N/A 51.903356 2.623403 51.900896 2.605973 154 12.5 ZEEBRUGGE BS 148 25 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:29:30 10:13:01 51.828675 2.534838 51.82529 2.533628 221 15.5 GIBRALTAR LR 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:41:33 10:40:03 51.707935 2.522228 51.703616 2.55712 45 16.1 ROTTERDAM MH 270 42 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:42:27 10:22:19 51.687938 2.492768 51.689116 2.497086 41 13 SKAGEN GR 228 32 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:48:59 10:25:24 51.61695 2.40464 51.624728 2.446276 37 13.5 ROTTERDAM MH 252 44 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:52:13 12:54:23 51.636706 2.24716 51.6403 2.267633 223 13.7 CA MTR PA 177 32 84 HIGH 0.20 Orange Out of SECA16166 24/08/2016 14:57:08 10:44:02 51.57037 2.072363 51.59426 2.091908 127 14.1 VLISSINGEN LU 147 21 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16166 24/08/2016 15:02:50 10:44:46 51.46044 2.23348 51.461225 2.235486 26 13 SOUTHWOLD MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 13:20:00 10:50:00 LOW 0.00 Green NA16167 25/08/2016 13:26:16 10:52:54 51.442165 2.140131 51.443935 2.14504 42 14.7 ROTTERDAM SG 368 51 79 HIGH 0.90 Red SECA16167 25/08/2016 13:37:03 10:44:46 51.47497 2.023156 51.398 1.9345 212 13.9 LE HAVRE LR 280 32 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 13:38:26 10:36:17 51.499531 2.060725 51.463115 1.906516 224 14 LE HAVRE GB 282 32 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 13:38:31 14:06:17 51.501151 2.063285 51.473393 1.999588 211 13.9 EREGLI LR 229 38 70 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16167 25/08/2016 13:46:09 14:21:53 51.599486 2.35782 51.600325 2.35809 44 8.7 TEES UK GR 250 44 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 13:46:17 14:12:24 51.598321 2.364373 51.542266 2.280666 43 8.6 UST LUGA NO 249 43 80 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16167 25/08/2016 13:52:13 14:29:15 51.715675 2.536353 51.647413 2.446856 40 12 UST LUGA MT 244 42 82 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16167 25/08/2016 13:56:37 14:38:09 51.756646 2.364003 51.742778 2.373051 224 18.4 PORT SAID DE 366 48 71 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16167 25/08/2016 14:22:01 14:41:45 51.774286 3.240565 51.805766 3.310983 46 11.3 ANTWERP HK 294 32 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 14:31:11 14:41:45 51.584228 3.394608 51.647435 3.325533 150 12.9 ANTWERP NL 100 15 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 14:38:20 14:45:10 51.417296 3.476996 51.417226 3.474428 257 17.9 TILBURY PA 300 48 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 14:42:28 14:55:25 51.45252 3.530395 51.452801 3.526228 312 10.9 ROTTERDAM GB 170 27 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 14:43:10 14:51:43 51.444488 3.500391 51.422493 3.553921 77 9.8 ANTWERP CY 183 27 89 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 14:45:07 15:02:23 51.412563 3.43145 51.546743 3.419653 172 11.6 ANTWERP IT 236 36 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 14:58:30 12:47:50 51.449768 2.917623 51.447595 2.960908 306 15.7 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 14:58:56 13:21:34 51.445388 2.900293 51.385753 2.95964 255 11.3 SABETTA CN 156 36 70 LOW 0.12 Green Out of SECA16167 25/08/2016 15:03:29 13:34:40 51.417363 2.78308 51.41865 2.808633 69 7.9 WANDELAAR GR 229 37 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 15:06:42 13:36:40 51.348998 2.727815 51.355666 2.768 90 9.8 ANTWERP MH 178 28 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16167 25/08/2016 15:07:34 13:45:32 51.368811 2.703461 51.369028 2.701503 279 13.2 BEAUMONT USA LR 180 28 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16167 25/08/2016 15:08:24 13:42:51 51.39245 2.705333 51.393321 2.708263 89 10 NL TNZ BS 225 36 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:06:51 #N/A 51.358943 2.860756 51.3633 2.869416 82 12 GHENT MT 89 13 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:08:07 13:47:33 51.36777 2.818906 51.37573 2.884811 257 9.5 THISVI BG 153 22 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:08:35 14:20:47 51.366438 2.79781 51.366438 2.79781 269 11.6 LA PALLICE FRANCE MT 101 18 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:13:09 14:25:57 51.361218 2.586018 51.366705 2.624028 93 10.3 ANTWERP IT 136 20 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:13:30 14:37:14 51.363123 2.570381 51.364143 2.571445 101 5.7 ANTWERP MT 216 27 71 HIGH 0.19 Yellow SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:22:09 14:41:40 51.371113 2.160811 51.368098 2.168463 23 13.7 BROFJORDEN MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:26:14 #N/A 51.399341 2.156275 51.42222 2.139771 26 12.3 BREMEN GERMANY HK 181 30 79 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:38:10 14:29:37 51.131195 1.800116 51.151283 1.833295 50 11 ANTWERP HK 366 48 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:41:55 10:44:02 51.114211 1.765608 51.115533 1.76729 55 14 TERNEUZEN GR 147 23 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:51:27 14:53:54 51.329151 1.849563 51.330833 1.856566 209 16.5 BALTIMORE KY 200 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16168 26/08/2016 09:52:31 15:01:21 51.335978 1.883603 51.326886 1.867871 216 12.4 ALEXANDRIA LR 190 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:08:46 15:06:49 51.600828 2.16975 51.610166 2.168666 219 15 ANTWERP PA 199 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:10:55 09:06:50 51.638016 2.231426 51.597383 2.275451 105 17.5 MT 162 25 HIGH 0.18 Yellow NA16168 26/08/2016 10:11:34 09:05:47 51.654223 2.251108 51.654566 2.249383 224 9.1 PUERTO NUEVO BM 289 45 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:20:18 09:08:01 51.742265 2.370243 51.723833 2.353833 221 4.8 FAWLEY UK DK 183 27 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:21:45 09:11:43 51.780973 2.404338 51.780566 2.4051 133 8.1 OSTENDE BS 113 20 90 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:29:18 09:13:28 51.920635 2.641828 51.921116 2.632753 113 14.5 ROTTERDAM NL 152 22 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:29:49 09:21:27 51.90603 2.652226 51.906333 2.655566 101 16.2 ROTTERDAM DK 197 26 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:33:01 09:23:07 51.826501 2.674631 51.839666 2.666965 353 15.8 SABETTA NL 157 25 70 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:35:20 #N/A 51.851456 2.757161 51.8431 2.762983 144 12.7 ROTTERDAM MT 134 20 82 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:36:38 09:41:40 51.828753 2.720715 51.845108 2.726623 41 12.1 AMSTERDAM FO 144 23 81 HIGH 0.23 Orange SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:38:30 09:51:53 51.804035 2.80795 51.804045 2.810618 96 9.3 ANTWERP LU 104 17 82 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16168 26/08/2016 10:41:20 09:50:16 51.790838 2.932693 51.806183 2.892316 327 8.4 MT 144 23 LOW 0.04 Green NA16169 26/08/2016 13:42:54 10:44:02 51.377238 2.593428 51.377616 2.589 280 15 PCA_CANADA PA 225 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16169 26/08/2016 13:44:31 10:05:58 51.366375 2.516745 51.366333 2.520666 85 14.6 ANTWERP MT 294 32 71 HIGH 0.50 Red SECA16169 26/08/2016 13:51:48 10:05:58 51.337971 2.268833 51.339183 2.2658 294 11.9 BATON ROUGE / USA LR 243 42 80 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16169 26/08/2016 13:54:45 10:44:02 51.34573 2.124275 51.349331 2.124921 5 19.3 ROTTERDAM DE 332 44 79 LOW 0.07 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16169 26/08/2016 13:56:05 #N/A 51.373968 2.078718 51.375416 2.079925 344 20.4 FELIXSTOWE PA 275 40 9 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16169 26/08/2016 14:00:55 10:19:37 51.46432 2.217561 51.466483 2.219466 38 11.1 ROTTERDAM CY 105 16 89 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16169 26/08/2016 14:07:02 10:34:05 51.5609 2.307128 51.548181 2.316755 35 10.7 ROTTERDAM LR 229 38 70 HIGH 0.15 Yellow SECA16169 26/08/2016 14:08:48 10:14:01 51.577571 2.309425 51.577565 2.311298 40 5.2 AMSTERDAM PT 224 32 70 HIGH 0.35 Orange SECA16169 26/08/2016 14:24:45 10:11:22 51.412406 3.008436 51.41249 3.014121 97 14 ANTWERP HK 366 48 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16169 26/08/2016 14:35:33 10:32:32 51.393561 3.095958 51.413931 3.04897 286 14.9 BE 162 25 HIGH 0.20 Orange NA16169 26/08/2016 14:40:00 NL 85 14 LOW 0.07 Green NA16169 26/08/2016 14:45:00 NL 112 15 LOW 0.09 Green NA16169 26/08/2016 14:46:54 10:34:48 51.434881 3.611701 51.435843 3.611326 269 3.7 ROTTERDAM NL 137 19 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16169 26/08/2016 14:47:00 DK 123 20 LOW 0.05 Green NA16169 26/08/2016 14:49:47 10:33:54 51.384821 3.714886 51.383738 3.71605 149 12.2 ANTWERP PA 100 20 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16169 26/08/2016 14:50:26 10:38:22 51.37047 3.734168 51.369636 3.740013 125 15.1 ANTWERP NL 143 19 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16170 28/08/2016 08:58:19 13:42:50 51.357976 3.777883 51.356773 3.779101 115 16.9 ANTWERP PA 264 32 79 LOW 0.15 Yellow SECA16170 28/08/2016 08:59:05 13:44:32 51.366046 3.750305 51.365303 3.75019 121 16.5 ANTWERP LR 262 32 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:03:07 13:51:11 51.429021 3.618816 51.428283 3.620978 272 6.4 TEES UK GB 99 14 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:16:33 13:54:41 51.402276 3.129801 51.40147 3.128933 269 10.5 NEW ORLEANS USA PH 235 32 70 LOW 0.12 Green Out of SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:22:08 13:55:59 51.375983 2.952408 51.374863 2.949731 73 13.2 ANTWERP LR 180 28 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:37:23 14:00:23 51.334093 2.39255 51.332813 2.389386 68 5.6 ANTWERP LR 185 24 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:37:39 14:04:00 51.342233 2.387726 51.341116 2.384716 69 6.3 GHENT GR 183 27 81 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:43:18 14:07:28 51.435426 2.207186 51.433086 2.204908 18 15.9 ROTTERDAM HK 366 52 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:45:51 14:27:18 51.478596 2.205253 51.478161 2.212645 43 15.6 ROTTERDAM MH 200 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:46:05 #N/A 51.478276 2.196305 51.47489 2.188873 46 14.5 IJMUIDEN PA 292 45 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:50:48 14:49:48 51.523615 2.11753 51.52166 2.115115 224 10.7 ANTWERP CH 165 24 81 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 09:58:09 #N/A 51.651101 2.481498 51.651886 2.4801 40 17 ROTTERDAM AG 137 22 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:03:16 #N/A 51.781268 2.426118 51.766146 2.393551 224 10.5 VALLETTA LR 199 32 70 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:05:00 09:37:07 51.780628 2.473648 51.777446 2.465486 225 9.6 HK 254 43 70 LOW 0.00 Green NA16170 28/08/2016 10:08:30 11:00:12 51.820638 2.464938 51.806208 2.453403 220 13.2 SOUTHAMPTON MH 199 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:10:31 09:02:56 51.86484 2.5536 51.862833 2.550833 224 11.5 ANGOLA HK 330 60 80 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:14:28 09:16:27 51.815685 2.746345 51.813421 2.746098 67 15.4 ROTTERDAM MH 184 27 80 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:15:14 09:22:05 51.811213 2.788863 51.809771 2.789495 67 13.2 ROTTERDAM MT 128 20 81 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:15:41 #N/A 51.806483 2.812665 51.805246 2.811503 75 11.7 ROTTERDAM IT 96 17 81 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:21:40 14:12:42 51.7543 3.125286 51.753285 3.120721 274 12.9 TEES UK NL 176 24 71 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:23:38 09:43:03 51.763866 3.201603 51.75672 3.203293 20 17.9 GOTHENBURG MT 162 25 71 HIGH 0.32 Orange SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:38:37 09:45:16 51.481213 3.049381 51.482945 3.044303 221 12.3 ANTWERP DE 366 48 72 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16170 28/08/2016 10:41:11 #N/A 51.4089 3.0827 51.408166 3.077 289 15.2 SEGOT NL 184 25 71 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16171 28/08/2016 13:12:21 #N/A 51.678636 2.477645 51.675676 2.471893 39 14.3 MURMANSK GR 249 44 81 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16171 28/08/2016 13:15:13 #N/A 51.74858 2.384461 51.747666 2.381333 222 18 LE HAVRE FR 170 27 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16171 28/08/2016 13:21:48 #N/A 51.808195 2.729973 51.460088 2.655478 191 7.6 ANTWERP CY 183 27 80 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16171 28/08/2016 13:23:40 #N/A 51.843173 2.809938 51.812683 2.766883 68 12 ROTTERDAM GR 183 32 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16171 28/08/2016 13:28:20 10:03:05 51.997466 2.939066 51.980866 2.90345 41 15 ST PETERSBURG GR 244 42 89 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16171 28/08/2016 13:29:45 10:04:59 51.994201 3.016831 51.990518 3.01368 64 4.8 ROTTERDAM MH 292 45 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16171 28/08/2016 13:38:32 10:10:28 51.895135 3.236903 51.906566 3.262881 71 17.3 HVH GB 240 32 60 HIGH 0.28 Orange SECA16171 28/08/2016 13:44:15 10:14:25 51.751006 3.222531 51.768925 3.221775 198 12.1 ANTWERP PA 203 27 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16171 28/08/2016 14:00:45 #N/A 51.424305 3.0526 51.414926 3.006465 276 16.2 ROTTERDAM LU 300 42 79 HIGH 0.26 Orange SECA16171 28/08/2016 14:17:16 10:15:36 51.434053 3.613986 51.428563 3.575416 51 5.8 ANTWERP GI 161 25 9 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16171 28/08/2016 14:17:24 10:21:40 51.433753 3.621696 51.432656 3.617891 72 9.1 ANTWERP PA 199 32 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 10:40:18 10:38:20 51.370955 3.759453 51.347483 3.821068 270 11.7 BREMERHAVEN MT 229 34 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 10:44:53 10:44:02 51.421768 3.561236 51.423475 3.561761 77 7.9 TERNEUZEN SG 225 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16172 29/08/2016 10:56:09 #N/A 51.39157 3.134653 51.391815 3.139446 109 18 ZEEBRUGGE BE 162 25 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:08:05 13:12:21 51.383766 2.834056 51.370683 2.81875 266 13.5 GIBRALTAR LR 160 25 80 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:12:06 13:15:12 51.365568 2.641005 51.366616 2.6419 88 10.4 ANTWERP IT 90 14 81 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:14:47 13:05:37 51.366653 2.519213 51.36766 2.519805 86 11.2 ANTWERP NO 198 31 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:19:26 13:22:15 51.344605 2.301283 51.345758 2.29763 258 6.1 LONDON LR 300 48 79 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:22:36 13:27:31 51.278448 2.21526 51.298456 2.281768 59 13 WANDELAAR PT 190 32 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:26:55 #N/A 51.217533 2.024346 51.251238 2.089896 40 12.5 ROTTERDAM SG 369 51 79 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:27:40 13:34:48 51.209883 2.042258 51.207521 2.032805 61 14.6 ANTWERP LU 175 27 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:31:56 13:43:14 51.286263 2.195903 51.279683 2.18675 57 11.5 SLUISKIL PA 178 29 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:37:05 13:59:01 51.415801 2.129543 51.399283 2.12925 11 11.5 HAMBURG CY 229 37 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:39:43 10:37:30 51.455778 2.043468 51.411846 2.792255 238 13.8 LIMASSOL LR 262 32 71 LOW 0.13 Green Out of SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:39:48 #N/A 51.458226 2.042326 51.418521 2.812145 241 12.4 ANTWERP LR 184 27 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:40:13 #N/A 51.470585 2.044871 51.470878 2.041573 223 7.4 WANDELAAR PA 230 38 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:47:17 14:17:13 51.576311 2.322931 51.579448 2.32399 41 14.6 ROTTERDAM LR 330 60 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:50:44 11:04:59 51.643786 2.444881 51.63927 2.432586 43 16.1 ROTTERDAM HK 170 26 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16172 29/08/2016 11:52:14 10:56:06 51.60826 2.482583 51.412926 3.034128 273 9.6 SOUTHWOLD LR 241 42 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:29:08 #N/A 51.376565 2.890606 51.377173 2.887173 258 16.3 ES SDR MT 200 32 70 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:34:47 #N/A 51.40769 2.918003 51.419933 2.914383 272 16.3 BREMERHAVEN xx 199 32 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:35:21 11:19:27 51.413845 2.940706 51.414821 2.943383 96 13.2 ZEEBRUGGE PA 140 22 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:38:44 11:21:12 51.394801 3.07412 51.415791 3.042391 280 14.8 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:40:44 11:25:22 51.401065 3.080155 51.401566 3.080666 109 10.3 ANTWERP MT 115 19 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:47:45 #N/A 51.399483 3.10968 51.401711 3.106233 270 13.4 LIVERPOOL LR 257 32 71 HIGH 0.43 Red SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:49:51 11:23:54 51.405405 3.210458 51.406198 3.214355 82 14.8 ANTWERP SG 228 33 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:52:25 11:35:56 51.40776 3.333048 51.409666 3.310333 276 17.9 VIGO PT 134 22 79 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:53:12 11:47:12 51.40879 3.365971 51.404725 3.350546 84 11.9 ANTWERP SA 183 32 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:53:53 10:58:01 51.412093 3.393565 51.408616 3.358333 265 19 ANTWERP MT 161 25 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 14:54:27 11:40:09 51.412178 3.420735 51.412876 3.417095 261 17.5 YUZHNY MH 174 28 89 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:12:01 11:50:07 51.773601 3.181288 51.7775 3.1795 153 13 ANTWERP MT 179 27 70 HIGH 0.40 Red SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:17:30 16:01:10 51.797168 3.260345 51.802826 3.279371 222 8.3 ANTWERP HK 368 51 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:28:50 14:29:03 51.848088 2.956505 51.863443 3.03285 73 13.6 ROTTERDAM SG 369 51 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:34:03 10:44:15 51.83058 2.712693 51.827995 2.825425 300 17.2 ST PETERSBURG BS 180 26 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:38:50 14:35:06 51.907791 2.564011 51.847816 2.602916 223 15 BILBAO GB 133 20 70 LOW 0.12 Green Out of SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:41:51 14:34:43 51.898276 2.549356 51.89728 2.58011 220 13.5 JACKSONVILLE SG 147 24 82 HIGH 0.16 Yellow Out of SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:45:44 14:37:35 51.801505 2.432615 51.800121 2.430965 221 10 CORK NL 70 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:52:53 14:40:42 51.670276 2.272846 51.668933 2.269226 220 13.7 GIJON PT 135 22 79 HIGH 0.15 Yellow Out of SECA16173 29/08/2016 15:57:48 14:41:52 51.579348 2.098425 51.5933 2.1231 222 13.7 SOUTHAMPTON MT 295 36 60 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16173 29/08/2016 16:01:15 14:49:50 51.518648 2.237085 51.520333 2.2425 45 10.2 SOUTHWOLD LR 241 42 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:17:33 #N/A 51.38992 3.001775 51.391731 3.005481 55 18.1 ZEEBRUGGE LR 225 31 79 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:20:54 #N/A 51.400878 3.117951 51.400883 3.114633 267 10.8 MONGSTAD BE 180 30 81 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:21:41 #N/A 51.414968 3.095631 51.396966 3.11105 100 12.6 FLUSHING GB 228 32 89 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:22:18 14:53:06 51.420568 3.06745 51.420568 3.06745 311 18.5 BEZEE FI 180 24 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:23:48 #N/A 51.439076 2.998016 51.44038 2.9979 9 11.8 KLAIPEDA LR 225 32 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:25:06 15:10:08 51.454278 2.93937 51.452508 2.94027 147 15.6 TEES UK FI 195 26 79 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:28:30 15:31:04 51.509703 2.805695 51.507091 2.826355 310 15.2 PURFLEET MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:35:34 15:14:55 51.373226 2.608055 51.366333 2.63515 89 6.1 ANTWERP GB 170 27 71 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:37:13 11:25:22 51.38146 2.585358 51.380223 2.582696 271 9.7 LE HAVRE PA 264 32 79 HIGH 0.16 Yellow SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:43:09 14:06:17 51.334956 2.346405 51.327275 2.371945 59 9.3 ANTWERP LK 140 22 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:43:49 #N/A 51.340201 2.314548 51.338936 2.312228 251 11.9 SALTEND MT 128 19 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:47:30 15:51:01 51.408555 2.192785 51.4094 2.19235 13 13.8 HAMBURG MH 120 20 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:51:22 15:56:48 51.386468 2.117071 51.384766 2.13065 359 9.1 TEES UK GR 243 42 89 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:52:55 09:17:33 51.344811 2.136151 51.377395 2.114413 13.6 SKAW FOR ORDERS NL 180 30 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:53:42 16:01:10 51.323236 2.13544 51.35707 2.130793 11 14.7 HULL KY 147 24 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:55:53 09:20:51 51.268558 2.093008 51.31305 2.1286 22 15.6 ROTTERDAM PA 170 26 82 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:56:04 09:20:22 51.263948 2.0909 51.282333 2.112033 24 14 SASSNITZ CW 181 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 09:57:57 09:18:22 51.20748 2.081953 51.207733 2.084091 64 17 ZEEBRUGGE MT 196 26 79 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16174 30/08/2016 10:25:21 09:23:42 51.201303 2.875585 51.371808 2.703743 95 12.2 LR 181 30 Not Detected Not Detected NA16175 30/08/2016 13:04:40 12:54:23 51.43669 2.71538 51.391576 2.733538 337 13.1 EE MUU GB 213 32 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:15:20 09:37:07 51.745621 2.55286 51.745583 2.554533 38 7.4 TEES UK GR 243 42 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:17:04 09:34:42 51.767693 2.616673 51.739035 2.612556 43 14.3 ROTTERDAM JP 366 51 79 LOW 0.12 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16175 30/08/2016 13:17:05 09:37:07 51.767656 2.617556 51.768633 2.619333 40 14.4 KLAIPEDA BS 168 27 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:17:57 09:42:15 51.788693 2.634463 51.78915 2.63582 53 11.4 ROTTERDAM MH 225 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:20:50 #N/A 51.834648 2.74898 51.834621 2.750656 74 11.9 ROTTERDAM MT 121 16 80 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:28:51 14:23:10 51.882623 3.147646 51.88275 3.150133 74 14.6 ROTTERDAM PA 170 26 82 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:33:39 09:50:17 51.892013 3.38105 51.892451 3.382696 47 13.3 ROTTERDAM AG 141 24 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:40:26 09:51:49 51.957888 3.526221 51.958366 3.527296 82 8.3 ROTTERDAM LR 250 44 89 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:44:18 09:52:39 51.960985 3.668325 51.961068 3.660355 79 16.6 HOEK VAN HOLLAND GB 240 32 60 HIGH 0.30 Orange SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:51:15 09:54:20 51.971846 3.778598 51.972348 3.779103 80 18 NLEUR GB 152 22 70 HIGH 0.21 Orange SECA16175 30/08/2016 13:57:03 09:55:24 52.048568 3.652141 52.048645 3.659986 268 20.2 RDAMGBHRW NL 240 32 69 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:00:55 09:57:55 52.144726 3.560608 52.114033 3.6005 303 12.7 KLAIPEDA MH 178 28 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:08:52 #N/A 52.27144 3.875428 52.27218 3.875308 349 14.8 ST PETERSBURG MT 183 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:16:18 #N/A 52.3863 3.658583 52.390848 3.781433 37 13.3 KLAIPEDA LR 225 32 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:23:56 11:07:27 52.273026 3.3382 52.2845 3.373966 45 14.5 HAMBURG MH 120 20 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:26:30 09:50:17 52.223111 3.25437 52.222861 3.255791 44 14.3 SKAW FOR ORDERS NL 180 30 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:28:19 13:13:58 52.177096 3.295843 52.184836 3.295253 161 11 ANTWERP GB 144 23 80 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:31:42 13:17:03 52.088283 3.32202 52.094 3.314666 134 13 ROTTERDAM BS 277 46 80 HIGH 0.19 Yellow SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:37:19 #N/A 52.023275 3.089045 52.039625 3.100051 267 7.3 PORT JEROME DK 171 27 89 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:46:05 13:20:15 51.885725 2.735655 51.896803 2.77336 40 19.1 BREMERHAVEN IT 176 31 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:49:06 09:54:20 51.889198 2.59896 51.887896 2.597631 215 10.5 FLUSHING TR 290 45 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:49:51 13:33:38 51.8834 2.561523 51.882538 2.559733 220 11.2 TARRAGONA MT 176 31 80 LOW 0.04 Green Out of SECA16175 30/08/2016 14:53:20 13:40:19 51.814383 2.451416 51.813581 2.452595 220 12.1 LE HAVRE MH 256 43 80 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 09:46:10 13:34:48 51.726133 2.728785 51.704241 2.741248 188 9.3 ZEEBRUGGE BS 148 25 70 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 09:59:05 13:46:58 52.053223 3.068861 52.053316 3.0749 268 19.2 ROTTERDAM DK 197 26 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:00:36 13:59:14 52.025195 3.021266 52.0261 3.022266 51 14.3 UKCFOR ORDERS BS 182 32 80 HIGH 0.16 Yellow SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:03:49 14:08:50 52.030235 2.873751 52.029331 2.874101 267 12.9 ANTWERP LR 249 44 80 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:10:36 09:23:42 51.957315 2.635866 51.95655 2.635166 178 11.8 NEWPORT NEWS xx 154 26 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:11:14 14:23:10 51.940181 2.649966 51.939165 2.6483 217 15.6 LE HAVRE AG 222 32 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:13:13 09:51:49 51.886748 2.623561 51.884598 2.618051 225 22.8 ALGECIRAS xx 396 59 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:18:03 14:27:54 51.755708 2.657241 51.783718 2.668891 53 18.4 ROTTERDAM PA 300 48 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:20:15 14:30:31 51.730058 2.573678 51.743155 2.578676 49 15.7 ROTTERDAM FR 115 20 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:20:29 #N/A 51.724791 2.566695 51.726063 2.56704 39 12.8 ROTTERDAM MH 184 27 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:26:47 14:45:21 51.718436 2.375118 51.721333 2.392516 220 11.2 GB SOU PA 200 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:39:45 14:49:06 51.3478 2.391533 51.355013 2.353928 255 17.3 GB SOU BS 200 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:40:04 14:49:44 51.344488 2.407511 51.345166 2.409166 68 17.3 ANTWERP PT 240 32 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:44:26 14:52:23 51.374501 2.576635 51.390643 2.56183 52 5.7 ANTWERP MH 229 35 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:45:04 09:18:22 51.370991 2.602605 51.37836 2.567036 274 18.8 BEZEE FI 180 24 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16176 31/08/2016 10:45:20 #N/A 51.367053 2.614865 51.367293 2.615595 86 12.7 FLUSHING LR 154 25 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:16:11 13:14:44 51.407638 3.013131 51.412633 3.0039 93 12.4 ANTWERP US 243 32 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:16:30 ANTWERP 169 27 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:16:56 09:13:28 51.392173 2.986116 51.39134 2.983183 243 13.4 ANTWERP MT 216 27 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:25:27 #N/A 51.408101 3.330061 51.408605 3.32493 276 15.3 SOUTHAMPTON AG 169 24 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:26:31 #N/A 51.40365 3.379886 51.40395 3.3809 79 13.9 ANTWERP BB 138 21 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:28:19 #N/A 51.42137 3.458996 51.41009 3.389468 265 14.7 GBLIV LR 225 30 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:32:52 #N/A 51.427431 3.68142 51.430111 3.605118 77 6.3 ANTWERP MH 141 24 82 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:32:54 13:31:54 51.426635 3.682455 51.440203 3.655683 91 17.2 STEENBANK xx 301 48 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16177 31/08/2016 13:34:46 #N/A 51.374526 3.726353 51.393341 3.712178 356 12.1 MH 228 32 Not Detected Not Detected NA16177 31/08/2016 13:39:50 13:35:05 51.35284 3.842201 51.370206 3.74197 305 13.7 LE HAVRE PA 294 40 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 08:59:18 #N/A 51.435478 4.00632 51.435245 4.005093 122 13.9 ANTWERP MH 228 32 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 09:12:38 15:21:04 51.428938 3.596083 51.42835 3.60115 77 8.2 PA 203 25 LOW 0.00 Green NA16178 04/09/2016 09:13:53 10:40:03 51.425498 3.554131 51.422776 3.545691 87 11.2 ANTWERP SG 369 51 72 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 09:20:12 09:18:22 51.405045 3.321558 51.402971 3.320231 93 9.5 NL TNZ AG 90 15 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 09:20:31 10:44:15 51.405421 3.30818 51.405066 3.306155 95 15.3 ANTWERP BS 150 22 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16178 04/09/2016 09:26:27 #N/A 51.403368 3.081083 51.402691 3.080423 107 7 BEZEE xx 200 40 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 09:29:24 13:14:44 51.443165 2.983516 51.43825 2.993833 346 14.8 GOTHENBURG BE 162 25 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 09:35:16 09:13:28 51.359995 2.808493 51.359136 2.81531 91 11.6 FLUSHING SG 200 32 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 09:49:55 #N/A 51.329246 2.371385 51.330333 2.381416 53 10.3 GBSOUBEANR MT 294 32 74 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 09:58:42 #N/A 51.411938 2.044598 51.40737 2.053686 295 9.7 DUNKERQUE MT 194 28 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:02:44 #N/A 51.388361 1.89921 51.39 1.908905 224 11.3 FRLEH SG 366 48 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:05:17 #N/A 51.324505 1.857918 51.323833 1.855366 212 13.4 EASTHAM MH 120 20 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:12:16 13:31:54 51.17579 1.700526 51.1798 1.706078 222 14.7 BILBAO MH 162 23 81 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:13:40 #N/A 51.15802 1.656265 51.16294 1.658683 226 15.3 ECUADOR FOR ORDERSDK 183 27 80 LOW 0.04 Green Out of SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:16:12 13:35:05 51.125533 1.570588 51.122683 1.56295 228 15.5 MILNE INLET PA 225 32 79 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:22:44 #N/A 51.157113 1.881748 51.15665 1.8742 63 9.6 TEES UK SG 246 42 89 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:27:23 #N/A 51.245473 2.097218 51.243341 2.049781 42 17 FOR ORDERS DK 183 25 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:29:06 14:14:27 51.2374 2.186956 51.235975 2.17857 63 9.4 ANTWERP US 199 32 79 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:29:33 09:19:51 51.250981 2.186731 51.250873 2.183788 50 10.3 ANTWERP SG 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16178 04/09/2016 10:35:33 #N/A 51.30068 2.443741 51.315618 2.318816 53 15.9 ANTWERP MH 366 48 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:16:29 09:26:22 51.37014 2.52895 51.384495 2.571008 268 9.5 DUNKERQUE MH 169 27 70 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:17:03 09:28:46 51.366023 2.508895 51.368266 2.548016 102 11.7 FLUSHING SG 162 26 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:18:51 09:58:08 51.364103 2.447861 51.368888 2.527311 91 10.8 VLISSINGEN AG 138 21 70 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:18:59 09:47:19 51.363693 2.443798 51.364255 2.483526 78 14.5 ANTWERP HK 200 28 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:29:13 10:01:52 51.44597 2.172688 51.434953 2.156343 37 15.1 ROTTERDAM NO 185 28 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:29:38 14:23:10 51.451691 2.193581 51.452625 2.191596 39 14.7 ROTTERDAM MT 250 44 84 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:37:32 10:11:47 51.629431 2.239883 51.589108 2.149415 221 13.8 DUBLIN AG 153 24 71 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:37:38 10:13:07 51.631525 2.24317 51.571333 2.175 222 12.7 MONTOIR NL 117 18 71 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:37:47 10:16:09 51.634535 2.248185 51.606146 2.216231 218 8.9 DANANG xx 170 26 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:46:43 10:22:43 51.831965 2.622481 51.754383 2.4266 223 11 ALEXANDRIA MT 196 32 70 HIGH 0.25 Orange Out of SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:51:51 10:26:14 51.890463 2.855933 51.9008 2.8029 13 11.3 MALMOE / SWEDEN SE 228 32 70 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16179 04/09/2016 13:51:59 10:29:02 51.888065 2.861613 51.86934 2.779895 94 12 ROTTERDAM BS 255 44 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16179 04/09/2016 14:17:06 10:32:01 51.372376 3.951375 51.366946 3.912945 231 14.5 ROTTERDAM GB 282 32 72 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16179 04/09/2016 14:19:57 13:14:55 51.426001 4.05942 51.427098 4.026135 319 9.4 IT PVE MH 229 32 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16180 05/09/2016 00:09:30 MT 294 32 74 LOW 0.07 Green NA16180 05/09/2016 09:32:24 13:15:31 51.724901 3.1383 51.748716 3.183611 184 14.1 ZEEBRUGGE BE 162 25 72 HIGH 0.19 Yellow SECA16180 05/09/2016 09:32:24 13:15:58 51.724901 3.1383 51.716385 3.093423 213 1.3 ANTWERP xx 275 40 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 09:38:38 13:15:58 51.857326 3.282283 51.855891 3.281596 199 9.4 ANTWERP LR 169 26 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 09:47:41 #N/A 51.872498 3.094265 51.873141 3.094426 54 6 ROTTERDAM xx 265 32 71 HIGH 0.25 Orange SECA16180 05/09/2016 09:53:31 13:28:30 51.903936 3.383898 51.898203 3.378151 74 9.7 ROTTERDAM CY 94 12 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 09:56:42 13:29:34 51.926123 3.551905 51.919368 3.491398 59 12 ROTTERDAM US 292 32 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:01:14 10:07:35 51.932516 3.615055 51.93299 3.618141 242 0.4 ROTTERDAM MT 365 52 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:03:15 #N/A 51.946325 3.709855 51.947301 3.70948 13 11.2 ROTTERDAM AG 138 22 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:05:00 LOW 0.10 Green NA16180 05/09/2016 10:10:48 #N/A 51.9984 3.92222 51.998483 3.888333 84 9.4 ROTTERDAM BS 248 43 80 HIGH 0.30 Orange SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:12:38 13:50:41 52.010123 3.987321 51.998708 3.980665 98 10.2 ROTTERDAM MH 101 18 84 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:14:36 13:42:41 52.054535 3.933901 52.054228 3.936925 34 2.4 NL 129 22 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:20:00 LOW 0.06 Green NA16180 05/09/2016 10:28:50 13:49:36 52.434833 3.611633 52.4347 3.616528 89 12.4 AMSTERDAM DE 188 32 89 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:34:58 13:42:41 52.603995 3.481095 52.60307 3.47931 219 12.7 ALMERIA NL 126 15 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:37:12 #N/A 52.57352 3.415975 52.569791 3.409895 219 19.1 LE HAVRE PA 333 38 69 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:38:24 #N/A 52.537488 3.40043 52.53925 3.395616 215 14.6 SOUTHAMPTON MT 295 36 60 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:46:02 #N/A 52.40184 3.185065 52.526166 3.2475 245 16 FELIXSTOWE GB 166 25 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:50:12 14:27:18 52.280795 3.141333 52.332066 3.149 222 11.9 FELIXSTOWE DK 399 60 74 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 10:57:40 #N/A 52.110615 2.909655 52.108116 2.90645 212 15.2 ZEEBRUGGE CW 181 40 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16180 05/09/2016 11:03:39 09:46:13 52.017998 2.748633 52.0163 2.7464 224 14.7 RECIFE BS 190 28 79 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16180 05/09/2016 11:11:02 #N/A 51.810625 2.742303 51.833203 2.746026 118 8.9 ROTTERDAM NO 180 28 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:35:18 #N/A 51.371123 2.801548 51.367358 2.785548 273 11.4 LAGOS SG 185 32 89 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:35:26 09:55:18 51.368143 2.805575 51.367733 2.803866 265 11.7 SINES MH 184 28 80 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:36:29 #N/A 51.354436 2.793673 51.364403 2.785201 274 14.3 ZEEBRUGGE NO 183 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16181 05/09/2016 13:40:52 10:07:13 51.362486 2.621758 51.372925 2.630001 86 12.6 ANTWERP MT 180 30 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:42:46 #N/A 51.369938 2.664901 51.359283 2.67055 87 9 ANTWERP NL 110 17 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:44:29 10:14:13 51.365635 2.584705 51.364566 2.5857 83 7.9 ANTWERP LR 169 27 70 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:45:30 10:28:46 51.345186 2.555665 51.34422 2.556103 172 3.8 ANTWERP PA 147 24 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:47:12 10:34:57 51.366215 2.506926 51.364783 2.50855 83 7.4 ANTWERP CY 167 26 70 HIGH 0.92 Red SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:51:47 10:47:58 51.361821 2.504 51.366776 2.498198 67 8.6 ANTWERP SG 138 20 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 13:53:12 10:57:38 51.347718 2.441345 51.347966 2.4466 66 16.1 FLUSHING IT 176 31 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:05:21 #N/A 51.444621 1.957498 51.449051 1.95792 296 13.7 GIBUKLGP DE 272 40 70 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:10:23 13:34:11 51.325596 1.821511 51.324488 1.823073 204 6.1 FAWLEY UK SG 174 29 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:12:02 09:59:43 51.284265 1.823113 51.2828 1.822866 203 11 RIO GRANDE PA 179 28 79 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:17:59 #N/A 51.17957 1.661301 51.186948 1.66921 230 10.5 MILFORD HAVEN MH 183 28 89 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:20:27 13:33:48 51.192738 1.77335 51.23001 1.774411 217 10.9 ESALG PH 146 24 89 LOW 0.12 Green Out of SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:25:55 13:41:48 51.164968 1.904441 51.16872 1.893796 65 10.1 ANTWERP LR 277 40 70 HIGH 0.35 Orange SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:31:07 13:44:25 51.264501 2.095438 51.260553 2.087468 46 17.4 ROTTERDAM AG 155 23 79 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:33:05 #N/A 51.251095 2.185365 51.251946 2.188778 56 9.7 ANTWERP LR 190 28 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16181 05/09/2016 14:39:58 13:47:10 51.36142 2.45986 51.355786 2.446366 63 11.7 ANTWERP PA 180 30 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 09:28:55 09:28:53 51.405086 3.192510 51.404576 3.198463 82 13.2 ANTWERP DE 366 48 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 09:34:40 10:32:01 51.427830 3.451686 51.411065 3.395753 264 18.7 LE HAVRE MH 366 48 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 09:51:00 #N/A 51.741748 3.216960 51.737150 3.215953 185 10.9 BREMERHAVEN NO 200 36 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16182 06/09/2016 09:51:15 09:49:06 51.745886 3.206018 51.718333 3.204166 193 12.4 ANTWERP LR 208 30 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 09:53:12 09:53:05 51.807078 3.197370 51.805308 3.195286 209 2.8 ANTWERP MH 180 28 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16182 06/09/2016 09:58:44 #N/A 51.855238 2.959431 51.853938 2.960551 65 5.5 ROTTERDAM MH 250 44 81 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:03:13 10:00:00 51.877026 2.841163 51.822973 2.909993 75 10.9 ROTTERDAM SG 183 32 82 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:09:10 10:09:06 51.997996 2.725890 51.996206 2.724200 221 13.4 LAGOS MH 182 32 80 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:13:08 10:11:10 52.013531 2.831565 51.977721 2.813700 197 15.9 BEZEE BS 148 25 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:14:32 15:35:56 52.005443 2.883048 51.999266 2.835133 226 17.5 BILBAO GB 133 20 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:18:40 10:17:35 52.041688 3.076806 52.034356 3.024628 259 13.1 LEIXOES MT 190 32 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:21:34 10:21:31 52.133028 3.129765 52.132138 3.130943 44 11 HAMBURG MH 300 48 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:26:25 10:11:22 52.068118 3.290186 52.066616 3.285350 268 21.1 ROTTERDAM DK 197 26 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:28:16 10:27:38 52.024683 3.335348 52.023760 3.335243 175 14 ROTTERDAM GI 118 19 84 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:32:56 14:41:40 51.907988 3.311745 51.905666 3.311500 180 14 ANTWERP GB 170 27 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:38:04 10:38:04 51.936798 3.554336 51.936501 3.556201 73 12.1 ROTTERDAM AG 141 23 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:43:23 #N/A 51.987360 3.805556 51.987016 3.806216 43 7.1 ROTTERDAM MH 118 19 82 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:47:50 10:46:30 52.022901 3.977125 52.025516 3.929516 300 14.3 IMMINGHAM ES 210 27 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:48:32 #N/A 52.043438 3.961205 52.032750 3.964716 309 13 NL 142 20 LOW 0.00 Green NA16182 06/09/2016 10:50:12 10:49:58 52.073013 3.900315 52.073825 3.900701 11 12.8 AALBORG AG 129 21 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 10:54:29 #N/A 52.083015 3.758270 52.082943 3.757168 289 14.6 ROTTERDAM DK 183 27 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16182 06/09/2016 11:00:21 10:58:18 52.032356 3.690653 52.028796 3.728318 124 13.1 SE 170 24 Not Detected Not Detected NA16182 06/09/2016 11:04:38 #N/A 52.048725 3.484883 52.048000 3.482911 269 19.1 TRIESTE AG 151 22 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16182 06/09/2016 11:07:55 #N/A 52.037891 3.335705 52.036690 3.335893 188 12.5 NO 104 15 Not Detected Not Detected NA16182 06/09/2016 11:12:39 10:14:01 52.055873 3.116170 52.051566 3.135503 264 15 HARWICH NL 152 22 71 HIGH 0.38 Orange SECA16182 06/09/2016 11:25:47 13:46:58 51.884348 2.955458 51.883436 2.956458 99 13.6 NLEUR GB 152 22 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16182 06/09/2016 11:28:15 #N/A 51.831675 2.990005 51.841235 2.993375 74 9.2 ROTTERDAM AG 132 19 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 11:33:51 11:33:17 51.773360 3.151018 51.776071 3.140575 93 10.3 ANTWERP NO 144 23 84 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 11:34:32 09:53:05 51.759566 3.170316 51.758596 3.170226 140 9.4 ANTWERP MH 180 28 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 11:41:09 14:29:11 51.594085 3.122365 51.595133 3.122816 40 1.2 BRESKENS NL 85 13 33 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16182 06/09/2016 11:41:28 11:40:57 51.584458 3.126128 51.580116 3.100666 346 4.6 DREDGING AREA NL 82 12 33 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 13:37:06 #N/A 51.395053 3.097891 51.401263 3.088603 107 11 ANTWERP PA 399 54 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 13:38:58 10:46:30 51.40222 3.184391 51.40193 3.175553 82 17.4 ANTWERP MH 180 28 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 13:40:12 #N/A 51.407406 3.241245 51.407303 3.234471 80 13.1 ANTWERP MT 146 23 80 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 13:48:01 10:49:58 51.370286 2.9041 51.371126 2.905346 72 15.4 ANTWERP PT 178 28 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 13:50:51 #N/A 51.444001 2.843043 51.420895 2.864193 95 16.3 ZEEBRUGGE PA 199 32 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 13:57:32 10:58:18 51.55053 2.7012 51.5511 2.698413 198 10.6 GHENT PT 230 32 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:05:06 #N/A 51.588416 2.356086 51.59296 2.390648 45 13.4 ROTTERDAM PA 199 32 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:05:53 #N/A 51.574048 2.331786 51.574283 2.334776 43 22.3 ROTTERDAM HK 368 51 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:08:54 10:14:01 51.502913 2.28853 51.53164 2.311268 43 13.9 ROTTERDAM SA 223 32 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:10:55 13:46:58 51.509025 2.269268 51.509065 2.27046 40 12.7 HAMBURG LR 199 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:15:42 #N/A 51.42273 2.157355 51.472501 2.211346 42 14.1 ROTTERDAM MT 182 27 89 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:20:59 11:33:17 51.335408 1.962555 51.337111 1.965721 37 14.8 FELIXSTOWE LU 277 40 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:33:02 09:53:05 51.355446 2.487716 51.356978 2.472313 71 18 BEZEE FI 180 24 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:41:23 14:29:11 51.371095 2.9001 51.371721 2.906416 73 15.1 ANTWERP SG 199 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:42:00 LR 228 32 LOW 0.06 Green NA16183 06/09/2016 14:31:00 14:25:53 51.33944 2.394231 51.380645 2.172101 22 15.1 DK SKA PA 178 28 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16183 06/09/2016 14:42:37 11:40:57 51.385316 2.952738 51.384973 2.94823 259 13.3 CRISTOBAL BS 158 23 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16184 07/09/2016 09:19:27 09:19:25 51.382898 3.160203 51.378778 3.165636 130 9.3 ZEEBRUGGE CN 195 41 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 09:20:00 MT 162 25 71 LOW 0.05 Green NA16184 07/09/2016 09:26:51 09:26:23 51.595728 3.047821 51.591733 3.047733 181 14.9 ZEEBRUGGE BE 162 25 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16184 07/09/2016 09:40:02 Na 51.841573 3.067523 51.820153 3.076318 212 1.8 ROTTERDAM LR 300 48 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 09:39:03 09:31:23 51.822563 3.096906 51.722653 3.227826 15 7.5 ROTTERDAM PT 178 28 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 09:46:26 09:46:28 51.947526 2.791308 51.946961 2.798226 73 17.2 HAMBURG HK 368 51 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 09:49:13 09:49:11 51.921801 2.66066 51.9188 2.658183 220 12.8 DUNKERQUE MT 123 16 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 09:50:30 09:50:07 51.905411 2.606028 51.908 2.612733 222 12.3 EG PSD PA 174 28 79 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16184 07/09/2016 09:55:00 MT 178 30 LOW 0.05 Green NA16184 07/09/2016 10:10:48 10:08:31 51.93396 3.466995 51.928333 3.392166 77 11 AMSTERDAM CY 181 27 89 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:17:13 10:11:37 51.951388 3.576738 51.947748 3.552575 71 12.3 ROTTERDAM SG 182 27 89 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:18:16 10:12:56 51.959471 3.625198 51.95656 3.616968 72 10.6 ROTTERDAM LR 277 40 70 HIGH 0.28 Orange SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:20:07 10:20:01 51.979973 3.709615 51.97895 3.710466 64 6.8 ROTTERDAM LR 283 32 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:21:21 10:21:05 51.986875 3.76282 51.985061 3.761555 51 9.7 ROTTERDAM LR 262 33 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:26:44 10:25:22 52.142956 3.799075 52.12382 3.775266 177 13.2 ROTTERDAM NL 210 32 72 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:31:10 10:34:42 52.256275 3.909283 52.358833 3.967 316 12 HUNTINGTON GB 187 28 80 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:29:52 Na 52.223498 3.88386 52.228213 3.882111 350 11.7 HAMBURG SG 369 51 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:38:24 10:36:23 52.378545 3.831633 52.377708 3.830818 244 13.9 ROTTERDAM MT 182 27 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:47:14 10:46:16 52.487853 3.897505 52.510076 3.917483 10 6.8 HAMBURG HK 366 52 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:46:57 10:42:40 52.493235 3.908451 52.455215 4.033363 61 6.6 AMSTERDAM IT 255 43 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:51:46 10:51:04 52.413323 3.712426 52.422216 3.743016 77 11.9 AMSTERDAM PA 180 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:55:06 10:52:52 52.39404 3.555778 52.414 3.615 45 8.8 BRAKE GERMANY NL 90 15 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:57:41 10:54:49 52.398475 3.569851 52.39963 3.573348 60 8.4 AMSTERDAM SG 228 32 80 HIGH 0.31 Orange SECA16184 07/09/2016 10:58:00 UK 276 46 LOW 0.03 Green NA16184 07/09/2016 11:14:45 11:14:08 52.055533 3.345465 52.064983 3.345 189 16.2 ANTWERP PA 190 32 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:17:18 11:15:58 52.05109 3.216113 52.050488 3.21773 268 15.3 HARWICH NL 152 22 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:18:39 11:18:37 52.031308 3.155831 52.030435 3.154888 254 8.9 PORT JEROME DK 171 27 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:26:20 Na 51.885778 3.029815 51.885716 3.03275 91 18 ROTTERDAM DK 197 26 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:29:37 11:32:28 51.891885 2.904723 51.891426 2.90793 95 14.3 NLEUR GB 152 22 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:36:58 Na 51.94089 2.745098 51.940616 2.74817 80 7.1 HAMBURG IT 236 39 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:39:35 11:41:13 51.904466 2.627648 51.895866 2.550766 211 14 FLUSHING KR 292 45 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:39:13 11:39:13 51.912291 2.641388 51.909553 2.638821 225 13.8 TARANTO xx 229 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green Out of SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:44:17 11:43:25 51.828375 2.543985 51.827528 2.544533 222 14.4 MT 128 19 LOW 0.04 Green NA16184 07/09/2016 11:48:23 11:47:53 51.77491 2.647381 51.774463 2.6495 65 8.1 ROTTERDAM MT 183 27 89 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:50:27 Na 51.737795 2.571735 51.738798 2.574485 43 15.7 KOTKA NL 173 25 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:54:57 11:51:06 51.660313 2.434456 51.72835 2.59725 44 12.1 ROTTERDAM SG 293 40 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:55:10 11:53:07 51.654821 2.428711 51.685136 2.532533 42 16.1 ROTTERDAM DE 333 48 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:55:12 11:55:08 51.653886 2.428131 51.654328 2.43132 41 12.7 UST LUGA BS 225 32 79 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:55:58 11:55:56 51.631831 2.417173 51.632175 2.418941 39 10.8 AMSTERDAM MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 11:57:25 Na 51.599768 2.397503 51.618766 2.422133 42 12.3 ROTTERDAM PA 186 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 12:02:56 Na 51.616086 2.237265 51.616201 2.229283 276 20 BEZEE FI 180 26 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16184 07/09/2016 12:04:06 12:00:55 51.598263 2.205981 51.596936 2.205571 221 16.5 SANTOS LR 170 26 90 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16184 07/09/2016 12:07:08 12:06:42 51.535423 2.271148 51.537006 2.271891 39 7.9 ROTTERDAM xx 288 45 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16184 07/09/2016 12:16:17 12:14:29 51.324236 2.388103 51.3235 2.359138 58 11.4 GHENT HK 174 30 70 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 12:22:12 Na 51.403711 2.645463 51.403025 2.646323 149 5.1 GHENT PT 230 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16184 07/09/2016 12:29:50 12:28:03 51.376298 2.939311 51.373755 2.932056 71 16 ANTWERP PA 274 32 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 10:40:06 Na 51.412971 3.027791 51.411271 3.028896 103 15.2 TEES UK FI 195 26 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16185 08/09/2016 11:01:57 11:01:06 51.703815 3.186128 51.694823 3.202056 18 12.3 ROTTERDAM MH 183 32 89 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 11:13:41 Na 51.895798 2.947313 51.895205 2.94799 107 13.3 NLEUR GB 152 22 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16185 08/09/2016 11:22:44 Na 51.93917 3.317145 51.937425 3.316383 45 12 ROTTERDAM IT 243 42 81 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16185 08/09/2016 11:27:00 11:25:45 51.940228 3.253323 51.893505 3.280038 73 14.4 ROTTERDAM MT 139 20 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 11:36:38 Na 52.220815 3.35325 52.223333 3.3515 59 10.6 AMSTERDAM NL 132 17 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 11:43:34 11:40:01 52.256746 3.452205 52.155796 3.414923 121 19.7 ROTTERDAM FI 158 22 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 11:58:46 11:53:17 52.502336 3.843558 52.50085 3.844163 89 8.7 IJMUIDEN NO 291 48 70 HIGH 0.21 Orange SECA16185 08/09/2016 12:09:49 Na 52.591888 3.466651 52.590586 3.464288 219 12 NIKOLAYEV HK 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16185 08/09/2016 12:03:50 Na 52.48773 3.69069 52.48843 3.691103 21 14 BREMERHAVEN MH 180 28 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16185 08/09/2016 12:11:07 12:10:27 52.571348 3.428051 52.580666 3.437666 220 12.7 BEJAIA ALGERIA MT 117 18 89 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16185 08/09/2016 12:15:17 12:14:14 52.49779 3.466266 52.495438 3.468355 191 17.7 ANTWERP PA 232 32 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 12:20:22 12:17:32 52.413285 3.458301 52.418891 3.454708 191 20 ZEEBRUGGE SE 190 26 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 12:29:27 12:29:20 52.300683 3.119936 52.298378 3.117605 215 13.5 PORTSMOUTH BS 192 28 60 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 12:35:00 112 17 LOW 0.01 Green NA16185 08/09/2016 12:45:03 12:44:11 51.885791 3.204708 51.890466 3.184995 84 12.2 ROTTERDAM MT 182 27 80 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16185 08/09/2016 12:50:00 DK 197 26 70 LOW 0.05 Green NA16185 08/09/2016 13:03:26 12:59:00 51.529178 3.110041 51.605408 3.162843 191 17.3 ANTWERP JP 366 51 79 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16186 08/09/2016 15:19:43 Na 51.364358 2.730266 51.356811 2.853031 87 18 BEZEE FI 180 26 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16186 08/09/2016 15:33:11 Na 51.357028 2.347385 51.367388 2.435066 253 9 US PHL NL 172 25 70 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16186 08/09/2016 15:32:57 Na 51.351268 2.351826 51.35637 2.365856 252 12 BRAEFOOT BAY UK GR 173 28 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16186 08/09/2016 15:41:06 15:38:07 51.490211 2.20168 51.486283 2.215575 44 15.2 ROTTERDAM PT 300 40 79 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16186 08/09/2016 15:47:34 15:45:09 51.443285 2.105575 51.4265 2.0975 47 15.5 ROTTERDAM IT 246 42 81 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16186 08/09/2016 15:55:56 15:54:55 51.654028 2.081256 51.661633 2.057198 52 14.8 EMDEN PT 130 22 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16186 08/09/2016 16:00:28 15:57:11 51.600491 2.107473 51.603441 2.070651 205 11 DONGES DE 178 28 89 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16186 08/09/2016 16:05:45 16:04:39 51.651891 2.257675 51.607213 2.240886 119 14.6 VLISSINGEN MT 147 22 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16186 08/09/2016 16:09:06 12:29:20 51.740303 2.365218 51.69817 2.31842 218 11.3 PORTSMOUTH BS 192 28 60 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16186 08/09/2016 16:33:19 16:30:02 51.836298 2.922493 51.835295 2.922511 71 18.1 ROTTERDAM SG 368 51 70 HIGH 0.17 Yellow SECA16186 08/09/2016 16:38:48 16:10:00 51.700093 2.885578 51.698833 2.286166 218 11 NOVOROSSIYSK HR 281 48 80 HIGH 0.24 Orange Out of SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:20:33 Na 51.386518 2.76752 51.37855 2.726283 266 7.7 BATON ROUGE / USA GB 228 32 89 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:19:50 09:19:29 51.367453 2.784513 51.366763 2.782463 272 10.8 UST LUGA MH 256 43 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:22:51 09:16:05 51.455948 2.770196 51.407205 2.776918 63 13.5 ZEEBRUGGE PA 140 22 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:28:42 Na 51.651521 2.725466 51.648503 2.725898 168 16.3 ZEEBRUGGE FI 153 24 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:35:47 09:32:44 51.851481 2.744653 51.78065 2.6969 68 11.2 ROTTERDAM PA 124 20 81 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:38:21 09:38:21 51.886865 2.75869 51.880865 2.752245 42 11.7 POLICE BS 190 24 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:45:41 Na 51.833961 2.934565 51.813471 2.86506 277 12.1 NO GLO MH 182 26 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:49:41 09:48:35 51.920823 3.095491 51.890485 3.076718 76 12.1 ROTTERDAM DK 397 56 74 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 09:57:27 09:56:59 52.041016 2.963433 52.029316 2.951426 42 11.6 AMSTERDAM HK 289 45 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:01:07 10:00:28 52.101451 2.865193 52.10364 2.872311 222 12.7 NEMRUT TURKEY MH 190 32 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:05:53 10:05:41 52.174638 2.709766 52.169555 2.705163 17 15.4 TALLINN LR 330 60 80 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:08:27 Na 52.203001 2.645378 52.191238 2.666381 243 12.2 PURFLEET GI 144 24 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:16:36 10:15:43 52.23785 3.068138 52.231143 3.028818 216 15.8 GR THI AG 152 22 79 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:28:45 Na 52.39725 3.538055 52.393148 3.557903 283 9.7 GINA KROG OF BS 249 44 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:38:56 10:37:48 52.15066 3.517783 52.151726 3.533545 296 10.2 SKAW DK 183 27 89 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:43:53 10:40:03 52.094191 3.555826 52.106926 3.54772 119 11.5 TEES UK FI 163 26 79 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:51:39 10:48:27 52.070883 3.332815 52.069786 3.330396 268 14.2 HARWICH NL 152 22 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16187 09/09/2016 10:59:21 10:58:17 51.916078 3.50502 51.926985 3.50561 82 8 ROTTERDAM MH 250 44 80 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16188 09/09/2016 13:30:28 Na 51.358531 2.734853 51.357766 2.736133 94 9.4 GHENT PA 186 32 82 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16188 09/09/2016 13:31:56 Na 51.37222 2.671901 51.37227 2.66828 282 4.7 FLUSHING PA 119 18 84 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16188 09/09/2016 13:35:25 13:33:46 51.393226 2.646496 51.4056 2.647116 171 5.3 ANTWERP MH 228 32 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16188 09/09/2016 13:48:44 13:47:52 51.318911 2.232366 51.307128 2.242236 99 19.8 ANTWERP PA 294 32 70 HIGH 0.46 Red SECA16188 09/09/2016 13:52:46 13:51:17 51.33623 2.156261 51.341485 2.152193 23 19.4 DE LOW 0.08 Green NA16188 09/09/2016 13:57:00 Na 51.347833 2.002051 51.348611 2.003973 43 12 GB IMM PA 180 28 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16188 09/09/2016 14:03:16 Na 51.276276 1.855376 51.258526 1.872586 46 10 WILHELMSHAVEN MT 292 45 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16188 09/09/2016 14:06:59 14:04:25 51.285481 1.825845 51.289466 1.832626 220 12.7 NEW ORLEANS USA MH 229 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16188 09/09/2016 14:10:14 14:10:10 51.334653 1.966686 51.331833 1.964333 35 12.4 GDANKS POLAND MT 281 48 80 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 08:55:06 08:53:43 51.402811 3.717375 51.402381 3.711086 350 8.7 DUNKERQUE LR 206 28 79 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 08:58:27 08:58:23 51.429451 3.568871 51.428906 3.567540 255 8.1 ANTWERP MH 250 44 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:00:53 09:00:47 51.488470 3.490933 51.488630 3.489440 312 11.6 PT 230 32 LOW 0.08 Green NA16190 12/09/2016 09:08:26 09:08:22 51.622745 3.170093 51.624413 3.171775 15 20.9 ROTTERDAM US 292 31 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:10:39 09:10:32 51.697415 3.156966 51.694581 3.155458 190 14.4 ZEEBRUGGE MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:32:04 09:31:45 51.979788 2.889063 51.978666 2.889833 39 11.5 BREMERHAVEN NO 229 33 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:27:27 09:23:24 51.927998 2.672896 51.922626 2.670170 222 12.5 ROTTERDAM SG 368 51 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:36:31 09:34:47 52.035265 3.032030 52.029366 2.974466 38 15.2 BREMERHAVEN LR 294 32 71 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:44:12 09:43:01 51.972748 3.349575 51.945925 3.325246 184 11.9 ANTWERP LU 277 40 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:49:35 09:46:22 52.052725 3.304505 52.052456 3.302066 268 11.4 US BAL MT 292 45 70 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:57:05 Na 52.041746 3.389136 52.050455 3.394888 208 8.8 ANTWERP MT 134 22 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 09:59:42 09:55:17 52.064308 3.332000 52.064055 3.330741 269 11.4 ISLE_OF_GRAIN SG 184 28 80 HIGH 0.90 Red SECA16190 12/09/2016 10:05:51 Na 52.078593 3.623603 52.077246 3.620525 260 12.9 ANTWERP SG 183 27 80 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 10:07:00 GB 144 23 80 LOW 0.05 Green NA16190 12/09/2016 10:10:40 10:10:21 51.995901 3.805220 51.995161 3.805863 76 8.6 ROTTERDAM SG 182 27 89 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 10:16:56 10:15:19 52.058845 3.892851 52.024193 3.907183 110 13.8 ROTTERDAM PA 399 54 71 HIGH 0.15 Yellow SECA16190 12/09/2016 10:17:02 Na 52.061200 3.890050 52.005078 3.878718 82 12.7 ROTTERDAM PA 304 40 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 10:21:20 Na 52.153978 3.750570 52.092633 3.815250 258 9.7 MH 170 27 Not Detected Not Detected NA16190 12/09/2016 10:25:13 10:25:10 52.150485 3.558265 52.149980 3.557113 283 9.8 BROFJORDEN MT 182 27 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16190 12/09/2016 10:35:24 10:34:37 52.380521 3.221785 52.380883 3.240733 213 11.3 FELIXSTOWE DK 399 60 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16190 12/09/2016 10:47:54 10:47:36 52.118210 2.891941 52.118623 2.895720 223 11.4 HUELVA SPAIN PH 169 27 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16190 12/09/2016 11:00:33 10:59:50 51.861738 3.055031 51.861633 3.037816 73 12.7 ROTTERDAM PT 295 32 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 13:42:52 13:42:05 51.388668 2.998398 51.387866 2.995123 55 11.4 ANTWERP PT 118 19 82 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 13:44:47 13:44:47 51.3955 2.993445 51.395006 2.992916 242 15.4 ARZEW NO 250 45 80 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16191 12/09/2016 13:48:10 13:48:21 51.424443 2.850263 51.421068 2.86194 271 13.7 ZEEBRUGGE CW 206 43 79 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 13:49:30 13:49:21 51.413426 2.787541 51.412101 2.785703 232 14.6 ANTWERP MH 300 48 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 13:54:15 13:52:05 51.357773 2.571065 51.371268 2.684248 88 5.9 ANTWERP LR 175 27 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 13:55:59 13:55:03 51.373433 2.49439 51.36655 2.535016 87 4.9 GHENT AG 190 32 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:01:22 08:53:43 51.359333 2.225093 51.359815 2.218406 295 12.8 DUNKERQUE LR 206 28 79 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:07:36 14:04:41 51.221975 2.086533 51.268 2.210166 58 9.1 ANTWERP LR 208 30 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:11:51 14:10:30 51.177773 1.905496 51.189618 1.966908 60 12.2 ANTWERP LR 265 32 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:12:21 14:11:18 51.170836 1.885393 51.179518 1.935991 66 10.8 ROTTERDAM MT 110 19 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:16:09 14:13:58 51.117601 1.744683 51.13985 1.8429 59 12.6 ANTWERP PA 152 27 83 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:18:01 14:17:42 51.105568 1.664696 51.106283 1.662783 321 12.8 MILNE_INLET CANADAHK 225 32 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:19:23 09:23:24 51.117863 1.614808 51.115496 1.611168 225 14.5 ROTTERDAM SG 368 51 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:22:08 14:21:02 51.063646 1.553111 51.074003 1.567871 288 18.2 CALAIS DOVER CALAIS MT 187 28 60 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:24:19 14:23:20 51.085503 1.469913 51.089461 1.498068 293 19.1 DOVER GB 213 32 60 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:25:50 Na 51.096216 1.398473 51.094086 1.400693 134 18.4 DOVER MT 165 26 69 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:30:23 14:29:17 51.039945 1.403788 51.039583 1.402888 230 15.4 CORK CY 151 24 71 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:35:45 14:35:37 50.989413 1.658838 50.988333 1.659833 126 19.5 DOVER GB 180 30 60 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:36:16 14:36:17 50.99598 1.680156 50.997 1.677 304 18.9 DOVER GB 180 28 60 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:38:10 14:38:09 51.0547 1.689471 51.056411 1.68928 44 12.2 UST LUGA LY 248 44 80 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:38:50 14:38:47 51.06424 1.719731 51.06505 1.719083 39 11 ANTWERP MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:40:15 14:39:51 51.102681 1.7456 51.103251 1.745213 45 13 GRANGEMOUTH ORDERSIT 170 28 84 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:46:10 14:46:09 51.03966 2.024475 51.040481 2.026235 78 18.5 DOVER GB 186 30 69 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16191 12/09/2016 14:47:04 14:46:52 51.049366 2.064036 51.049675 2.062208 261 22.7 DUNK:DOVER:DUNK GB 186 28 65 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:13:40 09:07:56 51.451943 2.992525 51.40893 3.05682 115 14 ANTWERP DK 199 30 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:13:31 09:06:56 51.448908 2.987335 51.399611 3.121875 85 17.1 ANTWERP LR 398 59 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16192 13/09/2016 09:14:23 09:10:26 51.468991 2.999595 51.452883 2.995103 217 14.9 ANTWERP PA 203 26 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:21:06 09:16:04 51.50818 2.954103 51.49329 2.86891 308 15.9 PURFLEET MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:19:07 09:16:43 51.500011 2.8847 51.474331 2.918068 139 16.4 TEES UK FI 195 26 79 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:28:28 09:24:30 51.58697 3.061303 51.485483 3.030533 217 14.3 ANTWERP CY 195 32 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:32:25 09:31:44 51.65884 3.227173 51.645566 3.202866 198 10.4 ANTWERP BE 180 30 81 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:35:20 09:33:51 51.688583 3.285946 51.68735 3.285266 145 11.8 EVERINGEN ANCHOR MH 184 27 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:39:42 09:38:02 51.758378 3.16672 51.728766 3.164433 269 13.3 MURMANSK GB 183 27 89 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:40:35 09:39:11 51.776998 3.147116 51.748816 3.156301 90 3.2 ANTWERP GB 95 18 89 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:48:28 Na 51.819731 2.749485 51.815 2.803666 72 10.5 ROTTERDAM NL 145 16 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:53:39 Na 51.879485 2.587075 51.882816 2.5818 223 11.9 MARIN MH 197 32 79 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:56:26 Na 51.814828 2.649568 51.815155 2.64908 40 14.5 ROTTERDAM GB 182 28 89 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:57:18 09:56:18 51.806588 2.683018 51.807933 2.673048 35 10.5 SKAGEN GR 249 44 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 09:59:28 Na 51.790683 2.678653 51.812 2.719833 38 11.7 HARNOSAND LR 127 20 70 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:02:13 09:59:36 51.785781 2.627251 51.782483 2.6708 72 12.7 DORDRECHT MT 123 16 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:01:36 Na 51.77842 2.603983 51.779 2.60695 41 18.2 BREMERHAVEN MT 295 36 60 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:04:33 10:03:48 51.74231 2.565743 51.749555 2.59397 40 10.5 HAMBURG MT 98 14 81 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:07:18 Na 51.742076 2.556025 51.742613 2.55762 40 15.2 RU VYS MT 229 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:08:47 Na 51.702578 2.538346 51.703016 2.539733 37 12.7 ROTTERDAM AG 93 12 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:11:45 10:11:49 51.670271 2.41981 51.669705 2.426443 40 15.2 BREMERHAVEN PA 396 59 71 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:15:24 10:14:26 51.646786 2.390968 51.635111 2.424855 39 15.1 GOTHENBURG MH 183 28 89 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:18:12 Na 51.655893 2.240985 51.654373 2.241338 224 10.8 TOULON MT 129 21 84 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:22:58 10:20:05 51.618365 2.204546 51.603238 2.218865 222 15.9 CA HAL PA 199 32 70 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:22:30 10:21:14 51.624908 2.190115 51.622516 2.191191 220 10.4 ES BIO MT 157 25 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:23:12 10:22:55 51.612201 2.199475 51.61011 2.198935 221 11.6 BILBAO LR 97 15 80 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:27:31 10:27:41 51.538005 2.09236 51.536283 2.092683 218 11.2 EASTHAM MH 120 20 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:34:57 10:32:43 51.43383 2.224115 51.492211 2.255171 36 13.1 AMSTERDAM LR 225 32 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:37:31 10:36:09 51.375631 2.165345 51.408146 2.19563 20 14.3 TEES UK MT 100 18 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:47:38 Na 51.197748 1.761851 51.246416 1.8688 44 17.8 HAMBURG MT 334 44 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:49:01 Na 51.176201 1.697453 51.174853 1.698546 228 12 FALMOUTH NO 290 44 81 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 10:50:21 Na 51.156928 1.633638 51.156223 1.634035 241 10 BARCELONA MT 109 17 82 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:01:18 10:59:50 50.994971 1.348941 51.0165 1.3585 230 17.9 FRLEH CN 279 40 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:02:28 10:56:18 50.981423 1.392628 51.055483 1.392545 230 13.1 DUBLIN IRELAND PA 177 30 79 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:07:47 Na 50.949451 1.54502 50.949546 1.547121 37 7.7 ANTWERP PA 237 32 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:09:15 11:08:50 50.984973 1.586195 50.98035 1.5802 47 14.2 ANTWERP MH 228 32 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:12:49 11:11:42 51.063586 1.68917 51.063888 1.692055 45 12.2 AMSTERDAM AG 153 23 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:15:51 11:15:44 51.126013 1.792586 51.125586 1.796376 58 13.2 ROTTERDAM JP 366 51 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:16:29 11:16:14 51.143243 1.79292 51.144215 1.798015 59 10.5 CROMARTY NO 223 56 79 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:21:07 11:20:30 51.20358 1.967121 51.200568 1.965461 56 13.2 EMDEN AG 128 18 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:24:39 11:23:05 51.235245 2.093501 51.2253 2.048666 31 13.4 NAKSKOV AG 130 16 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:26:55 11:26:27 51.253236 2.189301 51.249591 2.18411 52 11 VLISSINGEN CY 160 49 99 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:31:43 11:31:36 51.401523 2.132591 51.402123 2.134958 22 14.2 ROTTERDAM DK 171 27 89 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:34:47 Na 51.411115 2.12227 51.430183 2.094883 43 17.7 HAMBURG MT 334 44 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:41:19 11:41:19 51.36398 2.391843 51.362573 2.391018 248 19.3 SOUTHAMPTON SG 369 51 79 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:47:58 11:43:31 51.371391 2.505355 51.363206 2.56927 88 16.8 ZEEBRUGGE MT 194 26 71 HIGH 0.15 Yellow SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:48:23 11:47:02 51.38103 2.517098 51.375573 2.50878 270 14 FELIXSTOWE CY 141 22 72 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16192 13/09/2016 11:48:40 Na 51.38813 2.52371 51.380996 2.514701 274 12.2 LOME MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16193 14/09/2016 09:56:02 09:54:59 51.796731 2.638348 51.804066 2.633833 38 12.6 ROTTERDAM HK 333 60 84 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:02:17 10:02:08 51.912188 2.683325 51.91771 2.68408 223 16.9 GIOIA TAURO PA 274 32 1 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:02:35 Na 51.919985 2.690531 51.806476 2.829375 70 7.6 ROTTERDAM SG 184 28 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:06:46 10:05:31 52.015998 2.828068 51.992983 2.786466 222 10.3 SETUBAL GR 275 48 80 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:08:31 10:07:21 52.039483 2.897281 52.022708 2.846138 243 21 LE HAVRE LR 366 48 74 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:12:10 Na 52.14913 2.938435 52.13489 2.919333 222 13.5 TILBURY IT 210 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:17:41 10:16:08 52.098215 3.074943 52.098425 3.076243 37 14 LV LPX LR 175 27 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:23:07 10:20:18 52.177551 3.152926 52.131088 3.139933 41 12.5 BRAKE GERMANY SG 235 38 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:29:48 Na 52.387165 3.232898 52.387083 3.234066 7 13.7 FOR ORDERS BS 229 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:31:47 Na 52.43828 3.190258 52.436826 3.191641 182 9.8 ROTTERDAM DK 183 27 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:35:41 10:34:52 52.542511 3.175088 52.541248 3.163238 1 10.5 PRIMORSK BS 253 42 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:40:16 10:40:15 52.44274 3.280281 52.44065 3.280116 214 13.6 GB SOU SG 199 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:45:17 10:44:05 52.487805 3.352668 52.489933 3.3355 216 12.9 FOWEY NL 108 16 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:48:42 10:48:32 52.434016 3.442341 52.43324 3.442151 247 11.8 MONTREAL LR 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16193 14/09/2016 10:53:29 10:51:27 52.35603 3.424345 52.344115 3.421945 189 12.5 ANTWERP MT 203 32 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16193 14/09/2016 11:19:41 11:11:26 51.962658 3.656196 51.961945 3.65652 73 9.3 ROTTERDAM LR 299 48 74 HIGH 0.75 Red SECA16193 14/09/2016 11:34:06 11:32:02 51.69888 3.212578 51.73941 3.23223 21 12.2 BREMERHAVEN LR 281 32 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16194 14/09/2016 14:11:44 14:10:48 51.377503 2.83201 51.3667 2.809321 88 13.1 ANTWERP MH 186 28 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16194 14/09/2016 14:17:28 14:17:11 51.382778 2.591155 51.379836 2.59194 268 16.4 PEIRAIAS HK 368 51 71 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16194 14/09/2016 14:28:51 14:23:48 51.59714 2.503623 51.57682 2.545168 87 18.2 BEZEE FI 180 26 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16194 14/09/2016 14:34:17 Na 51.708866 2.521171 51.708293 2.523096 39 13.4 PLGDN PA 229 32 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16194 14/09/2016 14:43:47 14:40:31 51.650018 2.215998 51.650356 2.244568 215 9.4 DUNKERQUE CY 222 30 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16194 14/09/2016 14:52:47 Na 51.448651 2.001546 51.457066 2.009566 221 11.3 MALAYSIA BZ 186 30 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16194 14/09/2016 14:55:00 222 10.3 SETUBAL GR 275 48 80 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16194 14/09/2016 14:59:06 Na 51.379415 2.010321 51.379735 2.012466 45 9.2 ROTTERDAM HK 292 45 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16194 14/09/2016 15:05:49 Na 51.229705 1.831726 51.230333 1.8315 45 8.6 SKAGEN LR 249 44 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16194 14/09/2016 15:11:03 Na 51.252756 1.72023 51.277453 1.680316 15 12.5 EG CANGB FXT HK 400 58 71 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16194 14/09/2016 15:19:48 15:18:46 51.261246 2.138988 51.260976 2.139658 57 7.5 GHENT HK 183 27 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16195 15/09/2016 09:48:50 09:48:08 51.347726 2.163941 51.36885 2.1759 21 13.5 ROTTERDAM GR 249 44 81 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16195 15/09/2016 09:49:03 Na 51.347903 2.15262 51.348993 2.152446 21 9.5 ST PETERSBURG RU 119 13 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16195 15/09/2016 09:57:07 09:56:23 51.273418 1.804828 51.274183 1.813566 215 15.7 USEWR BS 200 32 79 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:00:49 09:58:19 51.254791 1.76635 51.235633 1.78445 237 4.8 LOME MH 228 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:08:39 10:07:58 51.458405 1.968676 51.455533 1.965066 221 15.9 GR PIR AG 183 32 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:15:07 Na 51.643411 2.03456 51.641315 2.03368 67 16.7 ZEEBRUGGE MT 152 24 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:21:42 Na 51.71537 2.328846 51.713526 2.328568 220 14.2 LE HAVRE NO 180 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:24:51 Na 51.7543 2.451436 51.726753 2.388743 219 10 FLUSHING PH 229 32 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:27:34 Na 51.81955 2.51467 51.796716 2.50915 222 13.1 DAKAR BS 228 32 83 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:31:45 10:29:39 51.857561 2.439465 51.857708 2.44167 83 13.9 NLEUR GB 152 22 70 HIGH 0.23 Orange SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:34:29 10:34:29 51.930161 2.488115 51.929783 2.492666 106 19.7 ROTTERDAM DK 197 26 79 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:34:14 10:27:51 51.92325 2.482895 51.814646 2.490696 223 8 PORT JEROME GI 105 16 80 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:45:17 10:44:19 51.916623 2.887306 51.941583 2.8958 58 14.7 ROTTERDAM TR 274 50 89 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16195 15/09/2016 10:51:20 10:49:23 51.809838 2.803196 51.809876 2.796666 75 17.9 ROTTERDAM PA 294 33 71 HIGH 0.19 Yellow SECA16195 15/09/2016 11:05:32 11:01:46 51.420776 2.79901 51.538578 2.762216 304 19.1 BEZEE FI 180 26 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16195 15/09/2016 11:05:35 11:05:17 51.419493 2.800253 51.418936 2.799456 245 9.1 HOUSTON MH 229 32 89 LOW 0.01 Green Out of SECA16198 20/09/2016 09:35:12 09:35:09 51.417218 2.801978 51.41715 2.802666 57 10.2 ANTWERP HK 189 32 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 09:40:56 Na 51.439766 2.712655 51.463195 2.718971 116 0.5 SINES PT 366 48 74 LOW 0.11 Green Out of SECA16198 20/09/2016 09:46:45 09:45:37 51.378763 2.608718 51.368368 2.637741 88 10 WANDELAAR PA 396 59 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 09:48:34 09:47:29 51.34795 2.543721 51.363481 2.576721 86 6.5 ANTWERP IT 177 31 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 09:54:54 Na 51.341028 2.407253 51.342866 2.410216 64 14.6 ZEEBRUGGE PA 199 32 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16198 20/09/2016 09:58:35 09:57:35 51.285208 2.308011 51.303875 2.33493 54 13.4 ZEEBRUGGE MT 194 26 79 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:04:45 10:04:37 51.38861 2.0743 51.3891 2.07285 292 14.9 ESTAR PA 170 26 83 LOW 0.11 Green Out of SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:05:20 Na 51.404681 2.077976 51.404433 2.0784 41 10 MO I RANANORWAY MT 190 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:08:58 10:06:34 51.431253 2.040103 51.431786 2.039613 317 9.5 PURFLEET GI 144 23 81 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:13:57 Na 51.331853 1.86433 51.331361 1.862426 214 16.6 MANAUS KY 147 24 80 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:13:20 10:13:02 51.334736 1.892696 51.333986 1.89121 210 16.4 LES ESCOUMINS MT 160 23 80 LOW 0.12 Green Out of SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:17:01 10:16:31 51.25342 1.799026 51.265351 1.799048 210 17.3 SAO FRANCISCO/BRAZILCY 185 24 70 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:23:23 10:21:22 51.131508 1.62582 51.128733 1.634461 235 18.5 BILBAO SA 223 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:32:24 10:30:43 50.995278 1.41299 50.986778 1.422446 227 15.4 GB SOU DPSCT SG 369 51 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:32:20 10:29:10 50.996363 1.410268 50.999143 1.413435 226 14.8 ISDEMIR PA 225 32 70 HIGH 0.21 Orange Out of SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:34:45 10:34:36 50.977476 1.519338 50.979666 1.520295 40 16.4 ROTTERDAM PA 366 51 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:35:53 10:35:30 50.988588 1.573395 50.989813 1.573816 44 8.1 FLUSHING BS 188 29 70 LOW 0.13 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16198 20/09/2016 10:41:20 10:41:07 51.101638 1.762646 51.102321 1.761738 54 10.3 ROTTERDAM MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:46:14 10:46:15 51.17283 1.951871 51.174146 1.953648 61 5.6 ANTWERP HK 294 30 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:45:01 10:44:58 51.163475 1.896531 51.164198 1.897643 61 8.4 AMSTERDAM MT 180 30 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16198 20/09/2016 10:53:02 10:52:57 51.33056 2.119148 51.332111 2.1191 4 11.4 ROTTERDAM SG 183 32 80 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:23:20 13:18:26 51.413683 3.003511 51.4129 2.992916 94 11.2 GHENT PA 225 32 70 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:28:55 13:28:51 51.395273 3.007981 51.39495 3.005816 243 12.6 NEW CASTLE. UK KY 183 32 82 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:29:48 Na 51.38663 2.971368 51.476666 3.034166 42 18.8 SEGOT NL 184 25 71 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:35:24 13:34:20 51.388376 2.723061 51.39821 2.756418 55 14.2 ANTWERP DE 281 32 HIGH 0.64 Red SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:39:31 13:37:54 51.367433 2.667548 51.375183 2.746046 126 12.4 ANTWERP GI 116 18 89 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:43:29 10:46:15 51.356425 2.477445 51.359886 2.474005 64 9.6 ANTWERP HK 294 30 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:43:34 Na 51.358218 2.474488 51.36448 2.5564 91 17.1 ANTWERP BS 228 38 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:52:33 10:35:30 51.310816 2.335061 51.311716 2.335995 52 12.5 FLUSHING BS 188 29 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:55:09 13:55:09 51.313963 2.20802 51.314628 2.209085 98 6.7 ZEEBRUGGE NL 148 36 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 13:57:20 13:57:19 51.32873 2.10435 51.327408 2.108293 128 18.8 BEZEE FI 180 26 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:01:58 13:59:07 51.361715 2.04566 51.360783 2.046161 140 5 GHENT PA 190 32 70 HIGH 0.52 Red SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:06:15 14:04:20 51.410395 1.990795 51.409213 1.982163 255 11.4 LE HAVRE LR 209 30 71 HIGH 0.33 Orange SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:08:08 14:08:05 51.408071 1.917056 51.407555 1.916526 212 11.6 CA SEI MH 299 50 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:11:28 14:09:17 51.456215 1.993436 51.418431 1.91828 214 12.4 NEW YORK GB 228 32 84 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:10:10 Na 51.435103 1.95447 51.420533 1.910225 208 11.8 LAVRION MH 80 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:18:27 Na 51.614766 2.21263 51.614333 2.211333 222 17.7 CRISTOBAL LR 134 20 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:19:26 14:19:23 51.639846 2.20594 51.639246 2.204496 224 10.6 SINGAPORE AG 116 17 70 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:22:39 14:22:09 51.705056 2.295353 51.702881 2.276661 226 15.4 FRLEH HK 260 32 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:24:45 14:23:58 51.66812 2.335285 51.661735 2.306938 221 16.6 SOUTHAMPTON US 243 32 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:28:24 14:28:24 51.751751 2.446093 51.751655 2.444173 223 11 SIDI KERIR LR 333 60 89 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:34:09 Na 51.796205 2.539028 51.79711 2.439038 222 14.5 PEMBROKE UK GR 173 28 80 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16199 20/09/2016 14:34:16 Na 51.793683 2.540976 51.821833 2.4675 221 11.3 JORF LASFAR IT 175 31 81 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:12:58 Na 51.353606 2.571441 51.364063 2.65681 91 9 ANTWERP MH 189 28 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:13:10 Na 51.35704 2.563046 51.360878 2.61056 94 7.8 ANTWERP xx 243 33 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:16:41 10:16:41 51.36678 2.534171 51.366625 2.53527 93 5.2 ANTWERP GB 183 32 89 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:26:50 10:26:49 51.361633 2.062155 51.361161 2.063606 125 16.8 ZEEBRUGGE FI 195 26 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:29:11 10:29:11 51.325036 1.975775 51.325558 1.977318 42 13.2 GB TEE MT 273 48 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:32:45 10:32:44 51.251861 1.862186 51.25245 1.8637 38 9.3 ROTTERDAM LR 292 45 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:36:12 Na 51.330341 1.864806 51.33 1.865333 217 13 PLYMOUTH UK BS 90 12 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:40:37 Na 51.431873 1.993706 51.430678 1.992851 218 17.2 BELFAST CY 151 24 71 LOW 0.11 Green Out of SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:46:32 10:46:31 51.508056 2.228333 51.509541 2.232051 42 14.9 ROTTERDAM SG 333 48 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:49:32 10:49:31 51.529968 2.122183 51.528813 2.12153 222 18.1 ROTTERDAM CY 139 22 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:50:58 10:50:58 51.532073 2.056746 51.531266 2.056243 223 12.8 NEMRUT TURKEY HK 254 43 70 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16201 21/09/2016 10:58:38 10:57:32 51.587655 2.207801 51.562233 2.18735 223 18.8 BILBAO GB 133 20 70 LOW 0.14 Green Out of SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:00:32 11:00:32 51.606048 2.171743 51.60531 2.171541 225 14.9 BR SSZZ PA 180 30 70 LOW 0.11 Green Out of SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:04:42 11:03:26 51.683655 2.216193 51.669475 2.166391 248 18 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:14:52 11:14:43 51.783091 2.441836 51.781333 2.4405 219 11.8 GIBRALTAR GR 245 42 81 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:18:52 11:18:51 51.875495 2.567345 51.87501 2.57256 85 17.8 HOEK VAN HOLLAND GB 240 32 60 HIGH 0.65 Red SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:30:17 11:29:09 51.899871 2.88321 51.898648 2.885205 107 15.7 NLEUR GB 152 22 70 HIGH 0.30 Orange SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:35:00 DK 196 26 79 LOW 0.13 Green NA16201 21/09/2016 11:39:17 11:39:16 51.85967 3.11522 51.85906 3.117226 69 8.1 ROTTERDAM PT 318 42 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:45:44 11:45:43 51.908701 3.298081 51.907346 3.298938 189 5.3 ANTWERP xx 275 40 71 HIGH 0.19 Yellow SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:56:00 11:55:24 51.67724 3.29333 51.68087 3.28492 146 13.3 ANTWERP IR 168 26 70 HIGH 0.16 Yellow SECA16201 21/09/2016 11:59:15 Na 51.642228 3.32822 51.699301 3.287063 328 13.9 HULL PT 123 17 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16201 21/09/2016 12:04:15 12:01:14 51.60111 3.384023 51.603565 3.381783 331 12.2 ANTWERP GI 144 23 81 HIGH 0.19 Yellow SECA16202 26/09/2016 09:49:46 09:43:54 51.435808 3.986868 51.435791 3.987805 66 9.9 ANTWERP LR 168 26 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 09:52:13 09:44:43 51.392393 3.91518 51.3633 3.907516 229 12.8 GIOIA TAURO GR 294 32 79 HIGH 0.23 Orange Out of SECA16202 26/09/2016 09:49:07 09:41:34 51.432265 4.005983 51.415826 4.031166 166 10.2 ANTWERP LR 200 30 79 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 09:59:08 Na 51.434385 3.600473 51.433616 3.600766 88 6.7 ANTWERP BS 177 22 69 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16202 26/09/2016 10:05:51 10:05:36 51.410101 3.296698 51.409908 3.294696 276 17.9 LR 261 32 LOW 0.07 Green NA16202 26/09/2016 10:12:27 10:11:42 51.519326 3.068031 51.520578 3.090466 223 15.1 ANTWERP HK 366 52 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 10:13:28 10:13:25 51.509545 3.025103 51.507943 3.025123 199 11.9 BE 162 25 HIGH 0.24 Orange NA16202 26/09/2016 10:28:38 10:28:35 51.842546 3.32245 51.843416 3.32211 29 16.3 BREMERHAVEN LR 300 48 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 10:30:55 10:30:21 51.839348 3.25989 51.843881 3.274101 203 4.7 ANTWERP LR 161 25 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 10:33:13 10:32:39 51.78625 3.225221 51.79085 3.240938 192 11.3 STEENBANK CY 113 20 84 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 10:45:54 10:42:58 52.058036 3.06596 52.06144 3.035523 270 10.8 xx 288 45 LOW 0.05 Green NA16202 26/09/2016 10:45:43 10:45:15 52.062471 3.069451 52.06385 3.07195 41 17.2 BREMERHAVEN GR 294 32 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 10:49:52 Na 52.028025 2.973811 52.029001 2.973923 41 11.8 IJMUIDEN MH 229 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16202 26/09/2016 10:59:02 10:59:04 52.118558 2.64082 52.117025 2.641541 186 9 PRAIA MOLE MH 225 32 79 HIGH 0.29 Orange Out of SECA16202 26/09/2016 11:04:07 11:02:36 52.196705 2.629653 52.196326 2.628783 1 7.5 TEES UK BS 248 43 81 HIGH 0.68 Red SECA16202 26/09/2016 11:00:35 10:57:00 52.14403 2.68121 52.1274 2.674516 24 5.1 WILHELMSHAVEN PT 295 32 79 LOW 0.17 Yellow SECA16202 26/09/2016 11:16:11 11:16:00 51.956186 2.593448 51.954168 2.59628 101 17.3 HOEK VAN HOLLAND GB 240 32 60 HIGH 0.45 Red SECA16202 26/09/2016 11:25:19 11:25:13 51.806493 2.492371 51.806833 2.492028 221 9.9 RAVENNA NL 123 14 70 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16202 26/09/2016 11:43:33 11:33:16 51.36818 2.620875 51.61225 2.479316 136 5.1 SKAW xx 185 30 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 11:43:05 11:43:03 51.380861 2.623515 51.379446 2.623235 59 9.7 GHENT LR 190 30 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16202 26/09/2016 11:54:15 11:54:16 51.403176 3.165968 51.40203 3.169071 84 14.7 ANTWERP PA 275 32 79 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:24:52 09:44:43 51.328096 2.26884 51.327416 2.268266 260 19 GIOIA TAURO GR 294 32 79 LOW 0.14 Green Out of SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:27:03 14:27:01 51.283185 2.276676 51.283266 2.27709 56 11.9 ANTWERP LR 225 30 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:31:45 14:31:44 51.285205 2.139688 51.286183 2.140333 33 15.6 MOERDJIK NETHERLANDSSG 120 20 83 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:38:18 Na 51.34938 2.094605 51.325731 2.177215 97 13.9 VLISSINGEN LU 147 21 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:37:48 14:37:42 51.339205 2.076396 51.339066 2.077266 128 14.8 ANTWERP GB 170 27 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:44:00 11:25:13 51.363205 1.876065 51.367446 1.879898 216 11.6 RAVENNA NL 123 14 70 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:44:29 14:44:29 51.360405 1.900558 51.359228 1.899431 211 15.2 DUBLIN GB 129 21 71 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:46:26 14:46:22 51.392435 1.903085 51.391163 1.902316 208 19.4 CO PBO VC 150 22 70 HIGH 0.94 Red Out of SECA16203 26/09/2016 14:57:24 14:57:23 51.542818 2.325546 51.542901 2.326453 44 13.3 ROTTERDAM GI 134 22 79 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:00:57 15:00:57 51.629066 2.237788 51.627686 2.235688 219 18.5 SOUTHAMPTON US 244 32 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:02:20 15:01:42 51.666518 2.245163 51.649331 2.223311 220 13.4 DK 130 20 LOW 0.07 Green NA16203 26/09/2016 15:02:28 15:02:16 51.666448 2.252088 51.665606 2.24985 221 13.2 CA BCO MH 225 32 70 LOW 0.12 Green Out of SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:03:42 15:03:38 51.68381 2.304278 51.68171 2.301941 222 17.5 LE HAVRE LR 222 30 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:07:09 15:07:08 51.663513 2.42253 51.664683 2.42415 40 12.1 AMSTERDAM PA 200 32 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:10:27 15:10:25 51.62557 2.44977 51.624715 2.446086 41 6.5 ROTTERDAM DE 366 48 74 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:21:35 Na 51.527153 2.74389 51.544818 2.74151 302 15.3 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:28:29 15:26:01 51.360163 2.823018 51.386521 2.733101 263 11.2 ANTWERP LR 184 27 80 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:27:01 15:26:57 51.366366 2.761061 51.36553 2.756641 267 10.9 SOUTHAMPTON SE 228 32 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16203 26/09/2016 15:30:30 Na 51.374366 2.864378 51.373818 2.863258 260 15.4 ORDER MEDITERQANIANPA 176 30 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16204 27/09/2016 09:59:21 09:59:10 51.380943 2.477578 51.380333 2.476333 251 10.9 NG LOS MH 195 32 89 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:01:29 10:01:26 51.341388 2.419595 51.341203 2.420411 63 13 GHENT LR 225 32 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:06:58 10:06:57 51.271985 2.208601 51.271916 2.209725 63 15.2 ANTWERP GB 184 28 89 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:11:48 10:11:37 51.369465 2.178616 51.371013 2.17593 25 12.1 UST LUGA LR 229 38 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:14:34 10:14:33 51.354751 2.071031 51.352395 2.072403 129 7.2 ZEEBRUGGE CW 217 43 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:26:43 10:26:43 51.659358 2.445793 51.65911 2.446718 44 11.6 ROTTERDAM PA 292 45 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:27:33 10:27:30 51.66898 2.47578 51.668933 2.477 39 14.8 ROTTERDAM GR 274 48 89 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:28:34 10:28:31 51.680428 2.517056 51.680395 2.518365 41 14.4 ROTTERDAM HK 183 32 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:35:55 Na 51.688851 2.75015 51.679066 2.731433 188 8.7 ZEEBRUGGE xx 199 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:43:51 10:42:59 51.890733 2.655241 51.880616 2.65432 10 12.4 FEISTEIN BS 276 46 80 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:44:39 10:44:39 51.898031 2.617078 51.89595 2.614983 218 12.8 BR SSZZ BS 176 31 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:45:30 10:45:27 51.907381 2.604051 51.906283 2.605733 110 18.2 ROTTERDAM DK 197 26 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:46:54 10:46:52 51.926701 2.655218 51.925425 2.654028 228 10 USG LR 225 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:49:27 Na 51.971576 2.751498 51.966991 2.749536 210 11.7 HAMBURG SG 333 48 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16204 27/09/2016 10:52:10 Na 51.927288 2.81303 51.808503 2.824815 74 14 ROTTERDAM DK 183 27 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16204 27/09/2016 11:11:37 11:11:36 51.539918 3.13719 51.539306 3.136588 221 14.3 ANTWERP PA 203 26 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16204 27/09/2016 11:17:24 11:14:35 51.50425 3.059073 51.503341 3.072425 49 20.4 BREMERHAVEN HK 294 32 70 HIGH 1.10 Red SECA16204 27/09/2016 11:30:14 11:30:09 51.44269 3.659966 51.441306 3.657935 267 14.3 SINES LR 366 48 79 LOW 0.13 Green Out of SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16205 28/09/2016 06:25:37 06:24:55 52.01821 3.99316 52.002666 3.973 103 17.6 FERRY HOOK HUMBERNL 212 27 62 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 06:29:12 Na 52.059803 3.859905 52.059868 3.858026 313 12 MAAS ANCHORAGE GI 149 22 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16205 28/09/2016 06:30:55 06:30:51 52.101896 3.909806 52.104498 3.909663 2 13.6 PT 140 23 LOW 0.09 Green NA16205 28/09/2016 06:37:30 Na 52.312356 4.069343 52.312333 4.067333 155 9.4 SCHEVENINGEN ANCH.NO 187 27 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16205 28/09/2016 06:43:44 06:43:42 52.455686 3.938148 52.454535 3.933476 79 6.7 AMSTERDAM HK 225 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 06:47:37 Na 52.544981 3.847676 52.545426 3.845386 41 17.5 HAMBURG MT 400 59 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 06:49:15 06:48:01 52.589743 3.887065 52.565565 3.85591 40 15.8 HK LOW 0.11 Green NA16205 28/09/2016 06:55:31 06:54:22 52.734176 4.106495 52.716965 4.1212 18 12.7 VYSOTSK RUSSIA GR 229 32 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 06:56:15 Na 52.731771 4.11759 52.731605 4.115251 36 9 BREMERHAVEN LR 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16205 28/09/2016 06:58:03 06:58:03 52.786528 4.165785 52.787351 4.165728 44 15.8 BREMERHAVEN LR 161 25 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 06:59:59 Na 52.846921 4.210443 52.847891 4.210025 26 11.1 BRAKE GERMANY CY 176 26 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:08:40 07:07:24 53.08785 4.278186 53.069506 4.223455 227 10.7 ROTTERDAM MT 300 48 72 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:11:23 07:11:22 53.148091 4.370058 53.14819 4.36864 228 12.4 ROTTERDAM GI 147 22 83 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:10:51 07:10:48 53.131935 4.35684 53.131586 4.354983 226 11.9 BEJAIA ALGERIA HK 176 29 70 LOW 0.13 Green Out of SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:14:13 Na 53.233015 4.440121 53.232498 4.436873 207 12.2 ANTWERP MT 203 32 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:21:03 07:20:59 53.39037 4.728065 53.390633 4.725683 63 8.2 ELBE IT 253 38 60 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:28:38 Na 53.56343 5.066835 53.563673 5.064616 251 11 ROTTERDAM CY 184 26 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:34:46 Na 53.637155 5.408871 53.625783 5.377833 251 13.7 BREMERHAVEN BS 176 31 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:38:31 07:38:28 53.67647 5.629493 53.675735 5.62298 256 15.8 ANTWERP xx 364 51 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:41:10 07:41:05 53.711043 5.76986 53.710466 5.764916 250 16.5 FELIXSTOWE GR 294 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:44:19 Na 53.65977 5.926428 53.658916 5.922033 73 7.8 BREMERHAVEN GB 199 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:45:39 07:45:31 53.676258 5.93987 53.67552 5.93371 72 12.8 HAMBURG HK 366 51 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:48:26 Na 53.759645 5.950003 53.744566 5.936431 258 9.5 BILBAO BS 190 32 79 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16205 28/09/2016 07:49:56 07:48:49 53.76739 5.955078 53.766973 5.949596 251 17.3 ROTTERDAM DE 336 42 79 HIGH 0.15 Yellow SECA16208 03/10/2016 09:57:45 Na 51.386851 3.705903 51.389938 3.714148 333 16.7 JP 199 32 LOW 0.13 Green NA16208 03/10/2016 10:07:43 Na 51.559836 3.410835 51.557678 3.414625 169 16.1 VLISSINGEN AG 141 23 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16208 03/10/2016 10:23:59 Na 51.921295 3.162675 51.912478 3.16416 12 4.7 ROTTERDAM PA 275 32 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 10:36:08 Na 51.88527 2.64262 51.906745 2.63275 235 13.3 FOS BS 179 28 70 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16208 03/10/2016 10:38:05 Na 51.875115 2.64694 51.873595 2.641436 204 7.1 ZEEBRUGGE SE 228 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 10:41:49 Na 51.867725 2.762298 51.869966 2.761983 34 10.8 MURMANSK HK 225 34 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16208 03/10/2016 10:46:37 Na 51.764286 2.72003 51.781013 2.758375 72 16.3 ROTTERDAM HK 366 52 71 HIGH 0.45 Red SECA16208 03/10/2016 10:46:44 Na 51.766573 2.722681 51.795955 2.771973 69 9.5 ROTTERDAM MH 183 30 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 10:55:58 Na 51.750121 2.595378 51.798201 2.618875 41 16.6 BREMERHAVEN US 292 32 72 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 10:57:00 UK 183 32 LOW 0.13 Green NA16208 03/10/2016 11:17:10 Na 51.423206 2.121046 51.498316 2.037566 223 13.4 LAS PALMAS HK 180 30 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:20:00 CW 181 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green NA16208 03/10/2016 11:12:19 Na 51.55916 2.09483 51.55924 2.09219 222 12.7 CO SMR MH 292 45 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:19:14 Na 51.372136 2.149715 51.416846 2.156348 41 17.5 HAMBURG LR 175 22 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:19:45 Na 51.36094 2.130553 51.364745 2.12888 4 10.6 GBSOUNLAMS BM 289 36 60 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:09:33 Na 51.564773 2.146238 51.605976 2.338776 292 18.1 BEZEE FI 180 24 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:23:36 Na 51.337031 2.23809 51.33878 2.235231 294 8.1 LONDON MH 300 48 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:24:59 Na 51.332073 2.29814 51.565056 2.338513 37 11.8 IMMINGHAM MH 228 32 80 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:26:44 Na 51.316276 2.374178 51.317928 2.346621 59 16.5 ZEEBRUGGE LR 199 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:29:00 Na 51.352341 2.46582 51.355778 2.463443 64 7 VLISSINGEN CY 160 49 99 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16208 03/10/2016 11:30:27 Na 51.361356 2.534561 51.362636 2.537348 99 13.5 WANDELAAR PA 152 23 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16209 03/10/2016 13:48:01 13:47:59 51.368038 2.637018 51.369826 2.640311 89 15 ANTWERP LR 262 32 71 HIGH 0.26 Orange SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:11:03 14:10:05 51.373856 1.876743 51.383008 1.871993 204 10.2 FOS BS 179 28 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:11:50 14:11:47 51.389308 1.899708 51.390143 1.898223 207 12.3 NECHOCHEA ARGENTINA MH 184 27 80 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:13:50 14:13:45 51.438908 1.927783 51.439333 1.927416 207 12.1 NEW YORK xx 185 32 80 LOW 0.01 Green Out of SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:22:45 14:22:41 51.54546 2.255978 51.549943 2.259968 40 13 SOUTHWOLD GR 333 60 80 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:26:03 14:25:53 51.600706 2.368545 51.603816 2.368933 43 11.1 LR 292 45 LOW 0.03 Green NA16209 03/10/2016 14:27:18 14:26:40 51.598535 2.404586 51.5929 2.395366 41 13.2 PA 183 32 LOW 0.08 Green NA16209 03/10/2016 14:29:21 14:28:30 51.636985 2.450891 51.630783 2.43505 40 12.3 ROTTERDAM CY 225 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:35:49 Na 51.786375 2.460923 51.786508 2.458751 222 15.4 ESVGO NL 149 22 71 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:37:36 14:37:35 51.826291 2.494833 51.827413 2.493113 222 13.1 LE HAVRE PA 333 50 69 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:40:58 14:40:55 51.900361 2.574476 51.903675 2.574425 355 14.6 VYSOTSK RUSSIA GB 183 27 89 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:44:49 14:44:00 51.93719 2.705821 51.934956 2.705945 6 18.6 ZEEBRUGGE JP 199 32 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:45:28 14:45:27 51.950026 2.694075 51.952078 2.691566 218 13.8 GB SOU SG 164 28 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:48:40 14:48:38 52.00143 2.801716 52.003533 2.801583 224 10.4 MH 169 29 80 LOW 0.14 Green NA16209 03/10/2016 14:50:05 14:49:45 51.97297 2.805 51.973931 2.804018 240 14.1 CORK AG 153 23 71 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16209 03/10/2016 14:54:10 14:54:11 52.051006 2.843453 52.054261 2.836035 264 19.6 RDAMGBHRW NL 240 32 69 HIGH 0.47 Red SECA16209 03/10/2016 15:03:05 15:03:03 52.032491 3.04663 52.037631 3.042951 266 13.3 SUEZ SG 368 51 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16209 03/10/2016 15:22:56 15:22:50 51.373535 3.169538 51.373793 3.17378 137 17.1 FI 153 24 LOW 0.06 Green NA16209 03/10/2016 15:28:09 15:28:06 51.38848 2.988506 51.389758 2.98594 246 12.7 STADE GERMANY KY 163 24 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16209 03/10/2016 15:30:37 15:30:30 51.418245 2.896518 51.421396 2.890975 275 16.8 LIMASSOL LR 262 32 71 LOW 0.14 Green Out of SECA16211 04/10/2016 09:37:53 Na 51.433918 2.925205 51.372973 2.922766 76 10.8 PA 177 32 LOW 0.06 Green NA16211 04/10/2016 09:37:47 Na 51.431565 2.92923 51.41534 2.941351 88 16 BEZEE LR 217 31 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 09:43:32 09:43:27 51.566136 2.689331 51.568355 2.691043 306 15.3 PURFLEET MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 09:51:06 09:51:01 51.798876 2.646903 51.799773 2.653578 41 14.5 EMDEN LR 199 32 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:01:30 10:01:29 51.843998 2.985303 51.843915 2.989436 70 9.7 ROTTERDAM PA 244 42 89 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:07:16 10:07:13 51.834905 3.219008 51.831303 3.225186 248 7.6 ROTTERDAM PA 275 32 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:08:57 10:08:53 51.874331 3.250508 51.873981 3.256343 88 7.7 ROTTERDAM LR 229 32 80 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:18:45 10:18:36 52.046276 2.845908 52.0438 2.8395 266 18.5 ROTTERDAM DK 197 26 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:22:39 10:21:31 52.110976 2.871323 52.089108 2.881185 220 14.6 ARATU BRAZIL SG 183 32 80 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:29:03 10:27:53 52.093471 2.584845 52.093553 2.59198 63 9.4 BREMERHAVEN HK 300 45 72 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:31:52 10:31:48 52.180236 2.609075 52.177333 2.612 183 14.2 NO STATFJORDGB FAWGB 257 45 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:37:14 Na 52.271493 2.796315 52.2703 2.798118 204 12.6 FOS CY 167 23 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:41:05 10:40:49 52.372865 2.705431 52.373633 2.710035 354 8.6 SOUTHWOLD BS 333 60 89 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:47:27 10:47:24 52.458083 2.928106 52.45915 2.933033 17 12.3 HAMBURG MH 175 28 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:55:48 10:55:44 52.620405 3.15605 52.618166 3.160166 165 18.8 ROTTERDAM MH 178 26 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 10:59:13 10:59:11 52.631951 3.269598 52.633466 3.274466 8 10.1 PRIMORSK SG 246 42 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:03:52 11:03:52 52.675255 3.425631 52.675205 3.430768 227 2 ANTWERP DK 294 32 70 HIGH 0.25 Orange SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:07:21 11:06:16 52.714136 3.479571 52.700821 3.503775 208 13.4 TURBO LR 210 30 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:20:01 11:20:00 52.600221 3.855423 52.60255 3.86629 50 18.5 PALDISKI FI 188 27 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:22:48 11:22:12 52.605361 3.845363 52.602063 3.850663 204 13.1 ROTTERDAM AG 153 24 79 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:26:48 11:26:10 52.547373 3.922598 52.558071 3.949823 30 12 AALBORG AG 129 21 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:27:03 11:26:56 52.540285 3.918235 52.543431 3.924343 31 16.4 HAMBURG AG 165 28 79 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:40:49 11:40:48 52.173801 3.494261 52.17398 3.501916 52 4.3 ROTTERDAM NL 210 32 72 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:42:23 11:42:10 52.125766 3.48898 52.124211 3.495291 121 11.3 ROTTERDAM PT 139 22 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:50:23 11:50:19 52.027295 3.11167 52.025833 3.115833 264 11.5 LE HAVRE MT 366 48 71 HIGH 0.40 Red SECA16211 04/10/2016 11:58:43 11:58:41 51.883691 3.05367 51.883616 3.057145 88 14.3 NLEUR GB 152 22 70 HIGH 0.30 Orange SECA16211 04/10/2016 12:04:44 12:04:44 51.917706 3.219921 51.917833 3.226 80 13.9 ROTTERDAM DK 196 26 79 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 12:08:30 12:08:30 51.910038 3.364908 51.911333 3.371333 359 6.8 ROTTERDAM US 292 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16211 04/10/2016 12:19:47 12:19:43 51.5781 3.396201 51.579666 3.398 334 12.9 NO 101 18 LOW 0.14 Green NA16211 04/10/2016 12:30:14 Na 51.38561 3.713568 51.3875 3.715833 316 10.7 BEGNE IT 229 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16212 05/10/2016 08:09:04 Na 51.363848 3.899548 51.399455 3.95545 16 13.8 ANTWERP JP 199 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16212 05/10/2016 08:11:27 08:11:32 51.354638 3.760796 51.353443 3.785456 121 12.2 ANTWERP PA 203 26 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16212 05/10/2016 08:17:34 Na 51.417081 3.467786 51.417506 3.503273 81 11 MT 147 22 LOW 0.07 Green NA16212 05/10/2016 08:20:00 Not Detected Not Detected NA16212 05/10/2016 08:21:57 08:21:56 51.406876 3.3018 51.40772 3.303286 278 17.6 LR 190 28 LOW 0.06 Green NA16212 05/10/2016 08:24:26 08:24:23 51.405358 3.207365 51.406918 3.217851 84 12.8 IT 196 31 LOW 0.14 Green NA16212 05/10/2016 08:25:41 08:25:38 51.404403 3.178671 51.404328 3.18444 81 13.4 xx 243 33 LOW 0.10 Green NA16212 05/10/2016 08:33:01 08:33:01 51.534535 3.092638 51.536418 3.102905 40 16 ROTTERDAM xx 277 40 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 08:36:09 08:36:05 51.59968 3.1562 51.595268 3.163048 190 18.3 HAMBURG PT 333 48 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 08:47:18 08:47:19 51.797375 2.63722 51.796915 2.640435 152 15.8 ZEEBRUGGE FI 153 24 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 08:51:25 Na 51.876628 2.74286 51.877486 2.748221 41 11.3 AMSTERDAM DK 176 29 89 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 08:54:35 08:54:24 51.894571 2.856621 51.893543 2.864495 130 10.2 STEENBANK PA 199 32 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16212 05/10/2016 08:57:35 08:57:32 51.85719 2.960465 51.858336 2.977163 75 19.2 ROTTERDAM LR 262 32 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:04:30 09:04:24 51.899625 3.231351 51.898296 3.23543 187 10.5 ANTWERP AG 138 21 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:07:21 09:07:18 51.901236 3.321601 51.902415 3.333855 69 13.3 ROTTERDAM SG 254 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:08:03 09:07:58 51.916565 3.340421 51.918633 3.357166 69 13.5 ROTTERDAM MT 300 49 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:10:42 09:09:14 51.935258 3.330101 51.93924 3.323428 192 16.1 FLUSHING BS 177 25 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:11:27 09:10:55 51.925583 3.356308 51.926811 3.34839 96 10.2 ROTTERDAM HK 225 32 79 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:12:00 163 24 LOW 0.08 Green NA16212 05/10/2016 09:17:41 09:17:16 51.953711 3.592968 51.952851 3.585731 70 8.9 ROTTERDAM NO 198 31 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:18:12 09:17:46 51.948746 3.613103 51.949445 3.619511 74 3.6 ROTTERDAM MT 184 27 80 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:20:52 09:20:51 51.966913 3.710078 51.968345 3.71707 54 6.8 ROTTERDAM GR 184 27 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:23:11 09:23:11 51.979255 3.784643 51.980083 3.79549 86 9.5 ROTTERDAM LR 262 32 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:27:45 Na 52.084866 3.628711 52.084261 3.635278 118 16 CY 141 22 Not Detected Not Detected NA16212 05/10/2016 09:36:29 Na 52.306265 3.783386 52.306226 3.787651 190 8.1 ROTTERDAM DE 139 22 9 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:41:11 09:38:40 52.363498 3.799446 52.362766 3.803316 193 10.8 ROTTERDAM HK 183 32 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:44:05 09:43:58 52.415591 3.869043 52.418 3.879333 10 11.8 BREMERHAVEN US 292 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:47:45 09:47:43 52.51757 3.903281 52.51655 3.907533 247 14.6 ROTTERDAM xx 170 26 82 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:52:10 Na 52.50528 3.688993 52.509611 3.7461 42 8.5 HAMBURG MH 159 26 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:54:52 Na 52.571498 3.569971 52.572666 3.575666 334 11.6 HANZE OIL FIELD NO 187 27 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 09:57:41 09:57:41 52.658231 3.548616 52.65599 3.552551 219 13.6 ANTWERP MT 203 32 79 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 10:00:06 09:59:51 52.617396 3.493288 52.615008 3.495893 217 12.7 MAJFL PH 180 30 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16212 05/10/2016 10:11:49 Na 52.264971 3.339636 52.29825 3.3597 48 12.6 PA 177 30 LOW 0.12 Green NA16212 05/10/2016 10:14:18 10:14:14 52.186558 3.327861 52.184976 3.334158 131 15.3 FI 163 26 LOW 0.06 Green NA16212 05/10/2016 10:17:10 10:17:10 52.173073 3.182638 52.174136 3.191766 45 13.1 HAMBURG IT 236 36 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 10:32:31 09:04:24 51.725173 3.21503 51.725191 3.22137 129 7.4 ANTWERP AG 138 21 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 10:35:00 LR 169 26 71 Not Detected Not Detected NA16212 05/10/2016 10:40:00 146 25 Not Detected Not Detected NA16212 05/10/2016 10:43:41 10:42:45 51.404565 3.216021 51.405236 3.211816 82 14.2 ANTWERP TR 184 25 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16212 05/10/2016 10:44:29 10:42:43 51.399741 3.193526 51.405268 3.223503 80 12.5 ANTWERP LR 185 24 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:09:37 13:07:57 51.363358 3.130951 51.362551 3.190626 131 11.4 ZEEBRUGGE BE 162 25 70 HIGH 0.16 Yellow SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:11:02 13:09:34 51.373415 3.114041 51.372986 3.160663 128 10 ZEEBRUGGE SG 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:10:51 Na 51.367978 3.116623 51.369261 3.126898 87 11 ZEEBRUGGE MT 152 24 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:13:38 13:12:03 51.400126 3.075691 51.400868 3.156656 81 15.1 ANTWERP PA 274 32 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:23:05 13:23:04 51.414635 2.52159 51.416868 2.531571 28 8.7 ANTWERP MT 183 32 80 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:28:02 13:28:02 51.350995 2.41925 51.351751 2.427203 67 14.6 ANTWERP MH 174 28 89 HIGH 0.21 Orange SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:26:05 Na 51.395426 2.504823 51.402516 2.6388 55 0.8 ANTWERP GI 183 32 81 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:36:50 13:36:45 51.331868 2.124701 51.333883 2.1305 2 11.8 RIGA MH 180 33 80 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:40:44 Na 51.221591 2.151161 51.242188 2.176635 57 15.9 BEZEE SG 164 28 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:43:06 13:42:18 51.228108 2.020455 51.236513 2.075935 45 13.8 LIEPAJA LR 175 27 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:48:02 13:44:53 51.187581 1.981851 51.179953 2.013283 65 11.8 GHENT GI 105 17 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:49:46 13:49:46 51.168108 1.898491 51.169878 1.906593 67 12.3 GHENT HK 183 32 80 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:51:50 13:51:47 51.204561 1.799788 51.208183 1.808793 44 14.2 AMSTERDAM GR 252 45 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:53:20 08:21:56 51.207851 1.722811 51.206453 1.729146 224 8.9 LIVERPOOL LR 190 28 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 13:56:22 13:56:18 51.240876 1.78333 51.238366 1.789441 214 17.5 FOR ORDERS MH 281 44 80 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:04:32 14:04:33 51.377161 2.01114 51.377031 2.020653 119 10.4 ANTWERP LR 180 30 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:06:00 14:06:01 51.402513 1.956391 51.401066 1.971166 121 15.1 SHEERNESS PA 199 32 70 HIGH 0.33 Orange SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:12:30 14:12:27 51.54614 2.087488 51.545333 2.09285 224 11.2 CLYDEBANK MT 144 23 80 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:23:19 14:23:12 51.665596 2.452655 51.668195 2.46479 43 8.6 FOR ORDERS LR 275 48 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:26:32 14:26:27 51.747645 2.372158 51.745683 2.378466 220 12.2 DONGES MH 250 44 81 LOW 0.12 Green Out of SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:38:52 14:38:53 51.429775 2.576238 51.429811 2.583611 23 ANTWERP PA 249 44 80 LOW 0.19 Yellow SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:42:06 14:42:03 51.355913 2.664305 51.356955 2.677273 62 9.6 ANTWERP PA 237 32 71 HIGH 0.18 Yellow SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:47:22 14:47:15 51.36507 2.775151 51.366178 2.780993 265 10.9 ZEEBRUGGE PA 162 38 70 HIGH 0.40 Red SECA16213 05/10/2016 14:47:57 14:47:54 51.368948 2.79402 51.369601 2.799541 256 10.1 ROSTOCK VIA NOK BE 142 21 81 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 09:40:27 09:40:21 51.413445 3.00305 51.414236 3.014713 109 13.7 ANTWERP HK 299 48 74 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 09:39:38 10:00:03 51.39234 2.991866 51.391051 2.990306 244 14.3 DONGES MT 171 28 80 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16214 06/10/2016 09:45:29 09:45:20 51.48309 3.035198 51.482788 3.034353 222 18.3 ANTWERP HK 368 51 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 09:47:17 09:54:13 51.511558 3.083701 51.512548 3.086508 38 12.8 HAMBURG TR 184 25 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 09:48:52 09:48:47 51.54281 3.115518 51.549568 3.129476 34 13.3 BREMERHAVEN PA 275 32 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:02:37 10:02:36 51.354196 2.734813 51.355328 2.740965 85 10.9 ZEEBRUGGE BS 148 25 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:03:54 10:03:56 51.384553 2.692353 51.384908 2.699556 155 8.7 ZEEBRUGGE PA 180 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:09:04 10:09:02 51.440911 2.542513 51.44058 2.545366 216 10.3 WANDELAAR HK 183 32 80 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:12:31 10:11:56 51.363961 2.389475 51.366333 2.4125 249 15.9 HOUSTON LR 227 32 80 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:19:35 10:19:29 51.470033 2.194986 51.474666 2.205 37 11.5 HAMBURG PA 183 30 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:22:09 10:22:04 51.514775 2.09763 51.514765 2.1029 220 14.1 WILMINGTON NC LR 185 24 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:23:20 10:23:19 51.537508 2.063743 51.536531 2.065751 222 11.2 FAWLEY UK MT 182 27 89 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:18:24 10:14:41 51.436301 2.20092 51.350213 2.252845 290 12.8 ZHUHAI MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:34:02 10:34:00 51.620463 2.32039 51.622986 2.32251 305 12.3 ZEEBRUGGE BE 162 25 72 HIGH 0.23 Orange SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:38:54 10:38:49 51.746245 2.365968 51.745306 2.370276 221 14.2 DEHAMESALG LR 286 40 71 HIGH 0.17 Yellow SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:46:59 10:46:59 51.749101 2.569265 51.751995 2.579193 37 9.1 MUUGA HK 199 32 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:49:53 10:49:52 51.786553 2.656081 51.790066 2.664816 44 10.9 ROTTERDAM LR 244 42 89 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:52:45 10:52:43 51.854806 2.588893 51.85358 2.591726 223 15.1 DONGES DE 199 32 89 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:55:10 10:54:16 51.899985 2.567531 51.8929 2.58404 220 15.1 PORT SAID MT 190 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16214 06/10/2016 10:58:53 10:58:51 51.789088 2.461076 51.786006 2.463895 222 20.2 SUEZ LR 399 59 71 LOW 0.13 Green Out of SECA16215 06/10/2016 13:35:00 LR 183 32 LOW 0.03 Green NA16215 06/10/2016 13:38:00 13:37:56 51.411 2.659061 51.410393 2.665505 134 10.4 FLUSHING MT 179 32 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 13:41:00 13:40:54 51.381775 2.529706 51.383988 2.5316 273 14 ALGECIRAS LR 160 25 84 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16215 06/10/2016 13:43:39 13:42:25 51.343938 2.415333 51.359023 2.480581 67 11.2 ANTWERP AG 145 23 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 13:48:33 13:45:22 51.321711 2.356603 51.3227 2.359383 55 8 AG 147 23 HIGH 0.17 Yellow NA16215 06/10/2016 13:53:59 13:53:56 51.42291 2.13878 51.423706 2.143011 28 13.2 ELBE LR 154 25 89 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 13:56:21 13:56:16 51.463646 2.192645 51.469668 2.20531 44 12.8 ROTTERDAM SG 368 51 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 13:57:46 13:57:38 51.502316 2.199513 51.505366 2.20765 38 12.6 IMMINGHAM MT 289 45 79 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:00:04 13:58:48 51.523851 2.26201 51.526711 2.267033 44 12.4 SLAGEN MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:07:37 14:07:35 51.654091 2.463848 51.655166 2.4676 40 12.7 TALLINN PA 183 32 80 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:10:12 14:10:09 51.695803 2.53643 51.69701 2.539528 40 13.8 ROTTERDAM AG 126 22 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:10:55 14:10:52 51.71683 2.527496 51.717868 2.53066 38 11.6 PORVOO MT 128 20 82 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:15:48 14:15:46 51.80362 2.463603 51.803181 2.4665 221 13.2 NEW YORK MT 183 32 80 LOW 0.11 Green Out of SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:17:54 14:17:53 51.848496 2.516451 51.847596 2.518051 224 12.9 LAVRION MH 184 27 80 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:27:10 14:27:05 51.83584 2.871015 51.835953 2.880015 82 12.4 ROTTERDAM LR 275 37 71 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:26:39 14:25:39 51.82825 2.853846 51.830276 2.82962 74 13.9 ROTTERDAM BS 186 32 89 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:28:45 14:27:05 51.836831 2.882318 51.836656 2.889193 84 12.4 ROTTERDAM LR 275 37 71 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:30:31 14:30:28 51.826966 2.93846 51.827353 2.945418 74 14.2 ROTTERDAM MT 139 20 71 LOW 0.18 Yellow SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:34:12 14:34:08 51.796646 3.019555 51.796701 3.022613 114 3.3 ANTWERP DE 177 28 89 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:44:34 14:44:38 51.614715 3.357535 51.611268 3.362891 145 13.2 ANTWERP SG 183 32 80 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:51:55 14:51:50 51.40712 3.29374 51.40975 3.291971 277 14.2 FELIXSTOWE PA 237 32 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:55:00 51.440911 2.542513 51.44058 2.545366 216 10.3 WANDELAAR HK 183 32 80 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16215 06/10/2016 14:56:10 14:54:19 51.42208 3.466938 51.412466 3.381566 262 15.8 BM 294 32 HIGH 0.15 Yellow NA16215 06/10/2016 15:02:14 15:02:12 51.393453 3.70906 51.395016 3.71135 354 14.1 NL 154 22 LOW 0.09 Green NA16215 06/10/2016 15:08:16 15:08:10 51.381153 3.941356 51.379636 3.937956 232 12.1 BREMERHAVEN PA 274 32 71 HIGH 0.16 Yellow SECA16216 10/10/2016 09:26:12 09:26:04 51.368123 4.106425 51.369036 4.111488 82 15.1 ANTWERP HK 294 32 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 09:34:52 09:34:51 51.417138 3.701356 51.415435 3.703333 145 12.7 DZ 138 21 LOW 0.04 Green NA16216 10/10/2016 09:35:55 09:35:52 51.416936 3.649868 51.417 3.6475 277 15.1 VIGO PT 134 22 79 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16216 10/10/2016 09:37:40 09:37:15 51.430811 3.574668 51.429233 3.592521 72 8 VLISSINGEN SG 164 28 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 09:37:47 09:37:45 51.430981 3.56944 51.430333 3.567333 257 13.9 ST PETERSBURG LR 170 27 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 09:41:33 09:41:32 51.505408 3.457663 51.506031 3.457148 310 13.1 GB ABD CY 92 16 80 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 09:48:17 09:47:48 51.566945 3.140761 51.566301 3.13994 213 15.6 ANTWERP LR 161 25 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 09:49:50 09:49:53 51.535756 3.10831 51.53424 3.104806 222 14.1 ANTWERP GI 116 18 89 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 09:50:54 09:50:52 51.518071 3.06877 51.51683 3.067605 221 18.3 ANTWERP NL 210 32 72 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:06:05 10:04:43 51.838095 2.92081 51.83864 2.9349 67 12.4 ROTTERDAM JP 175 28 82 LOW 0.07 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16216 10/10/2016 10:07:13 10:07:10 51.82842 2.862191 51.829221 2.864575 73 12.1 ROTTERDAM LR 154 26 79 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:13:50 10:13:51 51.748731 2.567311 51.753906 2.568675 41 17.7 HAMBURG GB 366 48 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:18:21 10:18:17 51.647481 2.413181 51.650051 2.414743 42 12 ROTTERDAM HK 225 32 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:20:06 10:20:04 51.59898 2.385423 51.6015 2.386983 40 14.1 DRAMMEN NL 174 26 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:20:56 10:20:52 51.597445 2.344786 51.599831 2.345205 38 13.2 UST LUGA MT 224 32 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:26:06 10:26:02 51.576953 2.108441 51.5765 2.10755 222 13 NG LOS BS 182 32 80 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:30:45 10:29:37 51.536646 2.161463 51.531516 2.124333 219 13.1 DUNKIRK MH 289 45 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:33:22 10:33:22 51.515726 2.241638 51.51692 2.241356 50 11.3 ROTTERDAM HK 292 46 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:36:09 10:36:10 51.49905 2.19037 51.500275 2.191725 40 11.4 BREMERHAVEN PA 177 29 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:39:33 10:39:34 51.44458 2.195311 51.445166 2.194283 39 10.5 DK CPH DK 134 19 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:40:53 10:40:49 51.439918 2.191455 51.439283 2.1897 348 10.6 ROSTOK PA 175 29 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:42:57 10:42:56 51.391881 2.183993 51.393771 2.183976 20 11 STADE GERMANY MH 223 32 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:44:23 10:43:29 51.351053 2.168525 51.370971 2.171471 16 14.8 ROTTERDAM LR 129 20 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:48:55 10:48:52 51.358241 2.391835 51.358743 2.390725 247 13.9 SINES GR 184 27 80 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16216 10/10/2016 10:52:52 10:52:50 51.384526 2.581003 51.385986 2.57998 19 8 MT 182 28 LOW 0.13 Green NA16216 10/10/2016 10:56:40 10:55:59 51.392128 2.759058 51.3968 2.7353 250 11.1 DONGES MT 179 32 80 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16217 10/10/2016 13:18:30 13:18:29 51.239581 2.129511 51.244431 2.135811 62 13.6 ANTWERP DE 182 30 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16217 10/10/2016 13:44:51 13:44:32 51.518761 2.253091 51.52308 2.261453 44 16.5 ROTTERDAM SG 369 51 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16217 10/10/2016 13:50:23 13:49:35 51.640701 2.229043 51.640616 2.2068 223 19.8 SOUTHAMPTON US 243 32 70 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16217 10/10/2016 13:52:20 13:51:16 51.638505 2.28239 51.62833 2.235238 224 15.2 SUEZ SG 368 51 71 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16217 10/10/2016 13:58:53 13:57:13 51.680405 2.516533 51.684833 2.517666 42 13.1 ROTTERDAM LR 269 32 71 LOW 0.15 Green SECA16217 10/10/2016 14:02:28 14:02:19 51.742083 2.443595 51.742 2.439183 223 10.8 GIBRALTAR GR 274 48 89 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16217 10/10/2016 14:03:54 14:03:25 51.755783 2.384476 51.752655 2.391675 222 12.7 ALGERIA PA 179 28 70 LOW 0.11 Green Out of SECA16217 10/10/2016 14:06:24 14:05:15 51.727495 2.362006 51.72525 2.326265 221 16.6 LE HAVRE xx 277 40 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16217 10/10/2016 14:11:37 14:10:07 51.810613 2.545493 51.800666 2.472666 227 13.8 ROTTERDAM DK 196 26 79 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16217 10/10/2016 14:14:36 14:14:26 51.797318 2.615633 51.799476 2.614556 282 12.5 DONGES MT 184 27 80 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16217 10/10/2016 14:30:20 14:29:05 51.371126 2.772545 51.385125 2.717535 255 13.1 BARCELONA MT 184 27 89 LOW 0.12 Green Out of SECA16217 10/10/2016 14:32:20 14:32:20 51.36472 2.877573 51.365966 2.880466 77 11.2 TERNEUZEN MT 176 31 82 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:34:31 09:33:37 51.404386 3.075545 51.40105 3.121683 87 17.6 ANTWERP IT 176 31 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:36:02 09:34:25 51.409691 3.055055 51.403693 3.090526 107 12.9 ANTWERP MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:36:05 09:35:23 51.408598 3.053016 51.40266 3.07871 107 15.4 TEES UK FI 195 26 79 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:36:39 09:36:02 51.40225 3.026296 51.406583 3.06425 103 13.6 ZEEBRUGGE JP 199 38 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:40:31 09:40:23 51.375555 2.835105 51.374373 2.832656 261 14.8 PURFLEET MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:41:24 09:41:20 51.369793 2.790733 51.367771 2.787236 262 14.5 FELIXSTOWE PA 304 40 72 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:43:45 Na 51.371531 2.690898 51.382638 2.707481 271 9.2 TARRAGONA MT 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:45:48 09:43:53 51.355926 2.618433 51.367155 2.70253 93 10.1 ANTWERP BS 228 38 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:55:00 09:54:57 51.393975 2.14388 51.395366 2.145633 5 14.1 KALININANGRAD SG 180 30 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:55:38 09:55:35 51.414876 2.142791 51.41525 2.14525 35 13.9 ROTTERDAM MT 182 20 89 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 09:56:28 09:56:28 51.43785 2.12713 51.440038 2.129023 29 13.4 AMSTERDAM SG 180 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:00:24 10:00:20 51.39855 1.959648 51.396826 1.96585 132 9.3 ANTWERP SG 254 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:02:31 10:01:18 51.415475 1.91968 51.414833 1.9205 208 11.3 SINES GR 249 44 89 HIGH 0.90 Red Out of SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:06:14 10:06:11 51.502583 2.010743 51.500916 2.010826 223 11.6 DALIAN CHINA GR 333 60 80 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:11:04 10:11:04 51.633478 2.079905 51.634916 2.084205 64 17.1 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:14:56 10:14:49 51.580501 2.138401 51.579516 2.137433 217 11.6 PUERTO BOLIVAR LR 292 45 70 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:18:18 10:18:11 51.551538 2.285238 51.552583 2.286266 42 13.1 FREDERICIA MH 183 32 89 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:23:43 Na 51.661638 2.277803 51.661091 2.279276 221 7.6 ANTWERP KY 163 24 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:25:16 10:24:33 51.693021 2.28152 51.67846 2.276483 221 16.4 STMARTA COLOMBIA VC 146 23 70 HIGH 1.20 Red Out of SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:27:49 10:27:45 51.692956 2.328606 51.691726 2.328453 227 12.6 WILLEMSTAD NL 143 19 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:31:01 10:30:58 51.77004 2.409338 51.76757 2.408411 225 11.3 FR URO PA 289 45 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:34:22 10:34:21 51.741436 2.547495 51.743236 2.554351 43 19.8 BREMERHAVEN xx 396 59 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16219 11/10/2016 10:36:01 Na 51.698785 2.512091 51.699485 2.515065 41 14 MURMANSK HK 225 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16220 11/10/2016 12:59:28 10:00:20 51.361745 2.554585 51.364031 2.599943 91 6.7 ANTWERP SG 254 32 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:00:22 13:00:15 51.379198 2.515101 51.378195 2.510786 261 19.5 SINES PA 366 48 71 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:08:09 13:07:01 51.553518 2.284655 51.555526 2.288783 39 15.6 HAMBURG PT 334 41 71 HIGH 1.06 Red SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:11:51 Na 51.592956 2.154886 51.592775 2.154165 220 12.3 GANDIA NL 132 16 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:14:21 13:13:28 51.617256 2.212986 51.591108 2.193578 206 15.4 AMBES BE 142 21 81 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:16:12 13:15:06 51.665925 2.263293 51.633668 2.229305 221 13.3 LE HAVRE LR 244 42 89 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:18:44 13:17:41 51.73277 2.328071 51.704116 2.299266 219 13.1 HALIFAX-CANADA GB 183 32 89 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:20:06 13:20:03 51.756893 2.34997 51.75607 2.348413 242 13 PORT KLANG MH 186 28 70 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:21:16 13:21:09 51.734988 2.38734 51.73325 2.385731 223 18.8 LE HAVRE FR 170 27 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:22:41 Na 51.750418 2.426198 51.746783 2.34645 225 10.4 US GULF LR 228 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:26:20 13:26:17 51.851663 2.519151 51.849866 2.516555 221 12.2 DONGES GI 167 26 80 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:27:21 Na 51.862275 2.566818 51.860711 2.56558 220 12.8 GHENT CN 225 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:33:22 13:32:38 51.913451 2.80857 51.905393 2.823001 129 12.5 ROTTERDAM GR 250 44 80 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:35:43 09:56:28 51.868981 2.709271 51.880216 2.728561 42 10.3 AMSTERDAM SG 180 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:36:43 13:36:42 51.836018 2.706696 51.8374 2.708183 24 10.9 AMSTERDAM SG 134 21 83 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:40:18 13:39:14 51.772906 2.634146 51.773536 2.635736 42 12.1 HELSINGBORG LR 150 22 79 HIGH 0.85 Red SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:43:31 13:43:27 51.706631 2.544605 51.708385 2.546478 44 13.2 ROTTERDAM LR 222 30 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16220 11/10/2016 13:45:03 13:43:47 51.70242 2.55915 51.70435 2.561883 37 12.3 ROTTERDAM MT 180 32 80 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 09:23:55 09:23:55 51.417146 2.918485 51.416876 2.92201 96 14.4 ANTWERP xx 243 33 71 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 09:26:12 09:25:03 51.46166 2.941528 51.459366 2.939033 306 16.5 PURFLEET BE 162 25 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 09:29:32 Na 51.395163 3.000056 51.396233 2.98622 251 9.9 NL VLI>RAMPION OWFNL 138 41 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16221 12/10/2016 09:34:46 09:34:43 51.541283 3.041548 51.539206 3.046131 192 15.1 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 09:52:45 Na 51.911806 3.575855 51.906591 3.564418 86 0.8 ROTTERDAM CY 129 20 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16221 12/10/2016 09:56:48 09:56:47 51.999708 3.519206 52.000183 3.523471 84 10.8 ROTTERDAM MT 274 48 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 09:58:29 09:56:47 52.00112 3.529885 52.000765 3.531456 83 10.8 ROTTERDAM MT 274 48 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:09:31 10:07:51 51.909471 3.32735 51.91011 3.33177 72 19.4 ROTTERDAM PA 332 43 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:11:46 10:11:45 51.898673 3.237405 51.899336 3.24194 75 6 ROTTERDAM CW 186 26 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:18:24 10:18:23 51.865275 3.024096 51.8655 3.026166 74 11.1 ROTTERDAM FOR ORDERSGR 245 42 81 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:21:41 10:16:58 51.872865 2.916638 51.880616 3.000911 86 7.7 ROTTERDAM BS 234 42 81 HIGH 0.20 Yellow SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:30:43 10:30:41 51.807785 2.47182 51.806771 2.473448 222 10.9 SAN NICOLAS SG 180 30 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:32:39 Na 51.745453 2.457993 51.803983 2.732406 72 9.2 ROTTERDAM PA 230 38 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:35:00 10:35:00 51.671443 2.474901 51.672566 2.478233 39 18.5 NL RTM DE 280 32 79 HIGH 0.51 Red SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:42:02 10:42:00 51.57616 2.664713 51.577215 2.665365 305 18.5 BEZEE<>GBTIL FI 180 24 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:48:45 10:44:16 51.504385 2.684958 51.5049 2.69185 127 4.2 BE ZEE SG 200 32 70 LOW 0.15 Green SECA16221 12/10/2016 10:57:33 10:57:32 51.375161 2.865465 51.375333 2.865333 262 14.7 LIVERPOOL LR 208 30 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 12:43:41 12:43:41 51.356738 2.794565 51.357716 2.799716 84 13.6 NL VLI FI 188 30 60 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 12:49:10 12:45:12 51.351948 2.707365 51.35169 2.752095 96 8.7 ANTWERP PA 228 32 82 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 12:51:29 12:49:27 51.36663 2.622985 51.357981 2.723378 121 10 ANTWERP BM 245 32 71 LOW 0.01 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 12:54:21 12:51:16 51.359261 2.487333 51.364078 2.637891 83 4 GBSOU TO BEANR DE 269 32 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 12:58:31 10:57:32 51.34866 2.247285 51.351166 2.25 296 12.2 LIVERPOOL LR 208 30 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:05:17 10:30:41 51.447238 1.950265 51.44581 1.95158 220 11.7 SAN NICOLAS SG 180 30 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:09:52 13:08:40 51.489933 1.991325 51.487501 1.995961 224 15.2 USDVV NO 200 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:18:01 13:17:57 51.535931 2.310695 51.538203 2.315815 38 15.6 NLRTM MH 270 42 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:22:50 13:22:50 51.621628 2.458608 51.624108 2.462301 39 13.4 ROTTERDAM AG 138 22 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:29:15 13:26:44 51.719565 2.370783 51.713946 2.387241 226 9.6 FOR ORDER BS 130 24 80 HIGH 0.44 Red SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:32:05 13:31:59 51.73656 2.39496 51.7359 2.395333 224 16.8 LE HAVRE GB 398 54 70 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:37:32 13:34:50 51.738078 2.378983 51.732396 2.355245 213 12.9 BR VIX DK 175 29 70 LOW 0.16 Yellow Out of SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:41:31 13:41:29 51.743345 2.549311 51.7448 2.552666 39 13.3 DERSK VIA NOC NO 110 14 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:37:50 13:34:50 51.736745 2.390671 51.732051 2.354881 213 12.9 BR VIX DK 175 29 70 HIGH 0.16 Yellow Out of SECA16222 12/10/2016 13:52:45 13:52:04 51.728558 2.748431 51.7415 2.733666 14.4 GRIMSBY PT 126 18 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16222 12/10/2016 14:05:07 14:05:05 51.380768 2.91703 51.38132 2.917161 260 15.7 LR 228 32 LOW 0.06 Green NA16223 13/10/2016 09:21:25 09:20:18 51.411648 2.772986 51.417066 2.801418 50 13.8 ANTWERP BS 225 36 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16223 13/10/2016 09:22:32 09:22:25 51.384925 2.74291 51.38418 2.750843 250 6.4 LE HAVRE xx 275 40 71 HIGH 0.30 Orange SECA16223 13/10/2016 09:23:54 09:23:50 51.395866 2.69665 51.395165 2.704285 258 8.8 BEANR>FRLEH PT 333 48 71 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16223 13/10/2016 09:27:08 09:22:25 51.385176 2.732585 51.38634 2.739761 298 6.1 LE HAVRE xx 275 40 71 HIGH 0.52 Red SECA16223 13/10/2016 09:46:44 09:45:44 51.868868 2.557868 51.867918 2.570433 123 13.2 HAMBURG LR 366 48 72 LOW 0.14 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16223 13/10/2016 09:50:35 Na 51.888303 2.589263 51.8911 2.569583 225 7.2 BE ZEE AG 183 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16223 13/10/2016 09:52:40 09:52:38 51.911151 2.662021 51.909988 2.667976 130 12.6 ANTWERP GB 144 24 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16223 13/10/2016 09:55:02 09:54:48 51.948755 2.578955 51.946236 2.58135 226 17.2 TILBURY CW 186 26 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16223 13/10/2016 10:03:13 10:03:11 52.041591 2.833268 52.041121 2.83846 267 11.6 TILBURY AG 141 22 71 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16223 13/10/2016 10:10:54 Na 52.092403 3.053583 52.0925 3.062166 39 11.4 BRAKE BS 199 30 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16223 13/10/2016 10:20:13 10:20:13 51.87318 3.110661 51.873416 3.116216 71 8.8 ROTTERDAM FOR ORDERSHK 244 42 80 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16223 13/10/2016 10:36:12 10:30:20 51.633543 3.096913 51.753921 3.213003 215 7.2 SLUISKIL MH 200 24 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16223 13/10/2016 10:43:44 Na 51.397415 3.108293 51.397286 3.115383 95 16.2 TEESPORT<=>ZEEBRUGGEFI 195 26 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16223 13/10/2016 10:48:27 10:48:23 51.361666 2.881691 51.361675 2.886335 88 14.5 VLISSINGEN GI 205 32 84 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16224 13/10/2016 12:47:05 12:46:58 51.357351 2.943178 51.35704 2.950798 90 15 ZEEBRUGE MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16224 13/10/2016 12:50:00 12:49:57 51.41179 3.001293 51.412716 3.005241 275 15.7 SUEZ CANAL HK 366 52 71 HIGH 0.22 Orange Out of SECA16224 13/10/2016 12:52:42 12:49:57 51.398843 2.974701 51.413473 2.986411 273 16 SUEZ CANAL HK 366 52 71 HIGH 0.22 Orange Out of SECA16224 13/10/2016 12:59:44 Na 51.367165 2.663175 51.361898 2.720568 91 8.5 ZEEBRUGGE FI 139 23 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16224 13/10/2016 13:06:46 Na 51.297546 2.272066 51.306893 2.29916 57 11.6 ANTWERP IT 156 26 81 LOW 0.15 Green SECA16224 13/10/2016 13:09:20 Na 51.276343 2.193285 51.293671 2.288731 58 16 BEANT SE 293 33 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16224 13/10/2016 13:10:54 Na 51.311728 2.123476 51.315133 2.129083 21 20.9 ROTTERDAM HK 210 30 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16224 13/10/2016 13:15:19 Na 51.363726 1.908388 51.362763 1.914061 208 7.1 TUZLA MH 250 44 81 LOW 0.13 Green Out of SECA16224 13/10/2016 13:16:58 Na 51.410406 1.904276 51.408766 1.908391 211 9.4 SINGAPORE PA 225 32 70 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16224 13/10/2016 13:21:51 Na 51.506216 2.029901 51.50515 2.0386 219 9.4 BE ZEE AG 183 32 70 HIGH 0.16 Yellow SECA16224 13/10/2016 13:28:54 Na 51.52392 2.263946 51.52662 2.28027 44 12.7 ROTTERDAM SG 368 51 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 10:27:14 10:27:11 51.403453 3.136966 51.401851 3.129391 266 15.2 PORT SAID HK 366 51 71 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16226 26/10/2016 10:28:37 10:28:32 51.40354 3.081526 51.401666 3.082666 106 15.2 BEZEE NL 184 25 71 HIGH 0.19 Yellow SECA16226 26/10/2016 10:38:43 10:38:18 51.364651 2.765536 51.36295 2.768733 87 13.6 ANTWERP BM 294 32 71 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 10:57:16 Na 51.239918 2.139908 51.234166 2.131598 57 13.2 ANTWERP MT 243 32 71 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:02:58 11:02:54 51.386438 2.140041 51.385846 2.136071 296 14.9 ARZEW ALGERIA NO 242 42 89 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:05:15 11:05:13 51.422266 2.182623 51.423783 2.180385 16 15.5 BREMEN LR 190 32 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:06:42 11:05:40 51.42369 2.160406 51.426015 2.159001 33 15.2 ROTTERDAM FOR ORDR MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:12:19 Na 51.499531 2.264501 51.486963 2.248446 41 6.6 RODAM LT ANCHORAGEGR 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:15:26 11:15:20 51.58337 2.363716 51.583348 2.36455 44 14.5 MAPTM-NLRTM PT 333 48 71 HIGH 0.28 Orange SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:25:36 11:24:30 51.792518 2.443313 51.762616 2.411783 221 10.4 BILBAO FOR ORDER GR 244 42 89 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:26:32 11:26:23 51.806395 2.484158 51.80511 2.480945 229 12.5 PORT SAID KY 89 LOW 0.01 Green Out of SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:27:04 11:26:51 51.823045 2.479363 51.821681 2.477106 220 10.2 MUMBAIINDIA PA 169 27 70 LOW 0.13 Green Out of SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:31:09 11:31:06 51.914611 2.60735 51.913165 2.606875 122 17.2 HOEK VAN HOLLAND GB 240 32 60 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:33:20 11:32:24 51.945971 2.573958 51.936976 2.554385 197 10.3 VITORIABRAZIL PA 177 28 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:34:38 Na 51.938563 2.6376 51.934093 2.601423 206 13.5 FLUSHING NL GR 173 28 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:37:54 11:37:50 51.987363 2.777235 51.986066 2.77545 194 13.6 TERNEUZEN GR 173 28 89 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:37:02 11:37:01 51.962393 2.76046 51.963003 2.758143 312 14.5 BRUNSBUTTEL NO 160 26 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:41:01 11:39:11 52.044853 2.897711 52.043585 2.895608 266 12.6 LIVERPOOL BM 183 32 89 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:41:43 11:41:42 52.02881 2.92218 52.027725 2.91628 261 19.7 ALGECIRAS MH 270 42 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:46:50 11:46:48 51.888506 2.953371 51.887186 2.953256 101 15 NLEUR GB 152 22 70 HIGH 0.50 Red SECA16226 26/10/2016 11:54:02 11:54:02 51.805975 3.204908 51.804635 3.203101 238 3.5 GHENT MT 190 29 70 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16226 26/10/2016 12:06:00 12:05:58 51.497445 3.472365 51.49595 3.472116 130 8.6 GHENT PA 169 27 70 HIGH 0.25 Orange SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:02:22 14:02:04 51.419445 4.030561 51.417575 4.03112 163 13.7 ANTWERP NL 176 24 71 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:05:12 13:58:24 51.401565 3.917805 51.396491 4.202225 114 11.8 xx 265 32 LOW 0.09 Green NA16227 25/10/2016 14:06:38 14:03:34 51.383858 3.859115 51.43688 3.99425 78 13.7 DEHAM>BEANR SG 333 48 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:11:38 14:10:52 51.443803 3.661108 51.42867 3.68552 129 13.2 ANTWERP MT 216 27 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:11:45 Na 51.440901 3.657465 51.440378 3.6602 93 10.2 GHENT HK 197 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:14:09 Na 51.43693 3.552458 51.431615 3.58524 257 11.3 LR 206 28 Not Detected Not Detected NA16227 25/10/2016 14:20:36 14:19:48 51.411938 3.258613 51.411831 3.255031 270 16.7 BELFAST NL 135 22 71 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:18:45 14:17:55 51.401446 3.343678 51.401446 3.343678 264 17.4 DOVER MT 152 23 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:27:28 Na 51.383381 3.108386 51.398505 3.114876 84 10.9 ANTWERP CY 183 27 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:32:48 14:32:50 51.362415 2.85977 51.361133 2.8637 91 13.6 BEZEE PA 188 28 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:34:03 14:34:03 51.362105 2.818993 51.361883 2.822666 91 11.5 ANTWERP HK 178 28 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:35:00 14:34:59 51.365745 2.803851 51.364816 2.809133 89 13.6 BEZEE PA 199 32 79 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:37:05 14:37:06 51.387443 2.742198 51.385648 2.73878 230 11 FELIXSTOWE xx 316 46 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:38:07 14:38:07 51.363578 2.740465 51.363333 2.74255 93 10.8 GHENT MH 200 24 70 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:40:40 14:40:37 51.383195 2.644225 51.381993 2.638641 265 12.7 GBSOU SG 369 51 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:52:43 14:52:42 51.593963 2.139708 51.59087 2.135933 221 16.3 DE EME>ES SDR PA 177 29 9 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:54:47 14:54:43 51.617315 2.188135 51.615591 2.18649 224 12.5 LE HAVRE GB 108 18 79 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:58:00 14:57:56 51.649028 2.22214 51.648121 2.22167 221 13.7 LE HAVRE MH 144 22 80 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 14:59:39 14:59:39 51.660791 2.294211 51.659368 2.29771 125 14.9 MT 162 25 HIGH 0.19 Yellow NA16227 25/10/2016 15:00:37 15:00:35 51.676648 2.275476 51.675458 2.274006 220 17 NO LOW 0.04 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 15:01:34 15:01:17 51.668996 2.229723 51.671013 2.236498 220 14.5 BS LOW 0.05 Green NA16227 25/10/2016 15:05:28 15:05:22 51.697655 2.291711 51.697008 2.290621 222 14.6 RIO GRANDE BRAZIL PA 146 24 89 LOW 0.04 Green Out of SECA16227 25/10/2016 15:06:45 15:06:43 51.683951 2.230975 51.682466 2.230108 222 14.5 FAWLEY MT 183 32 89 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 15:11:30 15:10:38 51.711906 2.336465 51.686083 2.330233 218 8.4 BE ZEE NO 229 32 70 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 15:12:38 15:11:50 51.712843 2.312255 51.718693 2.323086 221 15.8 SANTA MARTA GB 209 30 70 LOW 0.13 Green Out of SECA16227 25/10/2016 15:28:01 15:27:58 51.472493 2.878906 51.469335 2.882901 128 17.1 BEZEE<>GBTIL FI 180 26 79 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16227 25/10/2016 15:30:46 15:30:26 51.471231 3.016828 51.466483 3.011766 221 17.9 ANTWERP PA 274 40 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 12:39:05 Na 51.428626 3.575083 51.427433 3.5782 73 10 PA Not Detected Not Detected NA16228 27/10/2016 12:40:11 12:39:46 51.414283 3.53319 51.416728 3.53642 84 5.7 ANTWERP SG 171 27 89 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 12:40:55 12:40:52 51.417725 3.502243 51.416911 3.50001 79 8.1 PT AVE>BE ANR AG 146 18 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 12:51:23 12:51:22 51.521895 3.084088 51.5199 3.07965 221 15.2 ANTWERP GR 294 32 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:01:57 13:00:45 51.779366 3.269135 51.763891 3.230096 175 5.9 ANTWERP LR 262 32 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:10:29 13:06:33 51.916941 3.312375 51.926456 3.36389 77 17.4 HOEK VAN HOLLAND GB 240 32 60 HIGH 0.17 Yellow SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:16:20 13:16:14 51.87799 3.124036 51.878208 3.123445 71 13.3 ROTTERDAM MH 200 24 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:21:03 13:21:01 51.903446 2.930365 51.900625 2.928626 91 12.4 ROTTERDAM NL GR 250 44 82 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:24:11 13:24:10 51.9726 2.870708 51.973906 2.870306 40 19.7 IJMUIDEN PA 150 22 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:30:55 13:28:03 51.948893 2.667983 51.960066 2.675166 223 11.2 DE HAM > EG ALY LR 286 40 74 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:36:06 13:33:32 51.879716 2.580616 51.890181 2.582958 221 10.2 KATOGOUMA MT 300 46 70 HIGH 0.25 Orange Out of SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:37:53 13:36:09 51.849191 2.539216 51.861153 2.541385 221 8.7 LAS PALMAS FOR ORDERMT 274 48 80 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:42:01 13:41:56 51.836346 2.731538 51.836985 2.730078 40 14.4 MONGSTAD PA 183 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:45:18 13:45:16 51.784533 2.690823 51.78355 2.68915 63 13.5 ROTTERDAM BS 172 25 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:47:36 Na 51.791706 2.682996 51.7891 2.673133 62 15.7 ROTTERDAM PA 170 26 89 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 13:51:32 13:48:56 51.786445 2.644966 51.803341 2.643666 41 14 PRIMORSK NO 229 32 80 HIGH 0.66 Red SECA16228 27/10/2016 14:06:54 14:06:53 51.399563 3.018161 51.399166 3.017833 50 15.7 ANTWERP CY 135 23 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16228 27/10/2016 14:08:14 14:08:14 51.402453 3.085055 51.401041 3.084781 103 11.6 ANTWERP MT 175 32 80 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:08:48 15:07:32 51.410418 3.23496 51.408321 3.233558 80 17.8 ANTWERP LR 262 32 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:10:31 15:10:31 51.404343 3.167463 51.403725 3.163991 262 13.2 PORT SAID SG 183 32 81 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:12:37 16:27:20 51.379306 3.171353 51.380051 3.166448 316 15.6 LE HAVRE BS 339 38 60 Not Detected 0.07 Not Detected SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:14:23 15:14:22 51.398156 3.10414 51.397016 3.1039 105 12.8 ANTWERP MH 228 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:17:19 15:16:48 51.40767 2.985393 51.398393 3.007258 71 14.8 NLVLI SG 164 28 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:19:58 15:18:44 51.44162 2.927108 51.441986 2.923533 298 15.6 ZEE-PUR-ZEE BE 162 25 70 HIGH 0.25 Orange SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:24:19 15:23:54 51.372101 2.850203 51.373531 2.860031 262 15.3 PORTOCEL BR SG 198 31 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:25:50 15:25:05 51.36738 2.80562 51.367101 2.804206 256 11.1 DONGES MT 100 18 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:27:12 15:25:06 51.359828 2.831266 51.361666 2.833616 83 12.9 ANTWERP PA 182 32 80 HIGH 0.26 Orange SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:28:25 15:28:24 51.360498 2.785545 51.359683 2.784561 91 13.6 ANTWERP GB 183 32 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:41:25 15:41:17 51.494973 2.294496 51.494443 2.292248 34 12.5 ROTTERDAM DK 106 16 89 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:41:59 15:41:53 51.49641 2.269608 51.49546 2.267756 39 7.2 POOLE__ AG 82 11 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:45:13 Na 51.574971 2.327133 51.575245 2.330145 41 6.9 KALININGRAD RU 114 14 36 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:50:05 15:47:53 51.660356 2.501145 51.63651 2.43681 40 18.2 ST PETERSBURG LR 150 22 70 HIGH 0.76 Red SECA16229 27/10/2016 15:59:42 15:58:17 51.83844 2.506471 51.836833 2.5045 222 12.1 LE HAVRE LR 287 33 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:04:05 16:04:00 51.777513 2.70402 51.777786 2.704361 69 15.1 ROTTERDAM SG 368 51 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:07:20 Na 51.830715 2.857 51.830316 2.854706 292 9.6 LIVERPOOL IT 136 20 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:09:18 16:09:16 51.812225 2.802276 51.81154 2.802173 76 9.6 ROTTERDAM MH 252 44 80 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:12:13 16:12:10 51.738688 2.781338 51.739016 2.77875 266 12.5 AUGHINISH IE 136 22 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:19:15 16:19:14 51.546025 2.826655 51.54515 2.825666 137 6.7 ZEEBRUGGE<=>GRIMSBY PA 114 20 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16229 27/10/2016 16:21:03 16:21:00 51.513971 2.791325 51.511845 2.790751 124 14.1 NL VLIS<>GB DAGENHAMLU 147 21 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:25:36 Na 51.444711 2.682158 51.446546 2.694535 174 9.8 BE ZEE SG 164 28 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:28:43 16:27:20 51.372481 2.733428 51.385993 2.654336 266 16.7 LE HAVRE BS 339 38 60 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:31:37 16:31:34 51.374601 2.750065 51.37415 2.7452 276 9.3 BR SSZ LR 188 32 70 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16229 27/10/2016 16:31:20 16:29:09 51.37709 2.735466 51.377863 2.681095 271 18.8 ANTWERP MT 216 27 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16230 28/10/2016 09:42:36 09:40:47 51.291325 2.182411 51.304566 2.24255 75 8 ANTWERP LU 300 42 71 HIGH 0.17 Yellow SECA16230 28/10/2016 09:48:05 09:48:03 51.301245 2.118916 51.301833 2.117948 25 13.2 ROTTERDAM GI 137 22 89 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16230 28/10/2016 09:52:47 Na 51.30397 1.991521 51.305483 1.992533 60 14 AMSTERDAM IT 183 32 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16230 28/10/2016 09:59:01 09:57:14 51.460391 2.004825 51.427333 1.9451 266 15.4 ZEEBRUGGE<>SHEERNESSPA 114 20 70 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:01:26 10:01:22 51.521671 2.09278 51.521333 2.09 221 16.7 DAKAR LR 150 22 70 HIGH 0.46 Red Out of SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:11:15 10:11:12 51.643708 2.210686 51.643401 2.20773 224 12.4 CORNER BROOK AG 125 22 70 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:14:22 10:13:31 51.705288 2.332158 51.688263 2.292016 225 11 NEW ORLEANS MH 237 40 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:15:15 Na 51.71138 2.37285 51.7108 2.36992 221 9.5 DROGHEDA CY 118 15 70 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:18:38 Na 51.75079 2.413258 51.747633 2.378606 222 10 GHENT HK 225 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:21:21 Na 51.797061 2.439736 51.79678 2.437783 220 11.7 IEDUB MH 200 32 70 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:24:26 10:24:25 51.717338 2.52481 51.71865 2.523383 40 12.5 ARENDAL SG 143 23 70 HIGH 0.34 Orange SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:25:36 10:25:33 51.707028 2.574453 51.708686 2.573478 39 12.5 ROTTERDAM AG 153 24 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:42:32 10:42:30 51.39389 2.945366 51.393721 2.943105 263 8.9 LIVERPOOL LR 185 30 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16230 28/10/2016 10:44:01 10:42:12 51.383893 2.944058 51.373 2.8328 261 13.3 ES VGO NO 229 32 70 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:01:51 12:58:24 51.401968 3.013376 51.405648 3.060461 108 17.9 ZEE-PUR-ZEE BE 162 25 70 HIGH 0.25 Orange SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:01:48 Na 51.400375 3.013448 51.399416 3.138131 83 13.4 ANTWERP GB 183 27 89 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:01:47 Na 51.399845 3.013485 51.399035 3.015288 62 13.3 ANTWERP AG 99 16 80 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:03:03 13:02:37 51.438618 3.005721 51.438 3.003666 178 15.5 BEZEE MT 184 24 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:09:06 13:08:40 51.404631 2.785016 51.414593 2.790173 231 8.4 SANTOS BRASIL HK 180 30 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:14:14 13:11:50 51.3649 2.70465 51.366158 2.702793 90 7.2 ESALG>BEANR LR 286 40 71 HIGH 0.21 Orange Out of SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:18:23 13:17:35 51.393048 2.56617 51.394641 2.57643 216 8.2 ANTWERP xx 300 48 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:21:06 13:20:02 51.375013 2.544236 51.368515 2.576821 90 12.7 WANDELAAR.PL.ST. LR 230 36 84 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:30:13 13:29:14 51.415038 2.20508 51.417798 2.20331 21 13 DE RSK PA 177 29 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:34:55 13:34:53 51.550525 2.304635 51.5515 2.304166 43 14.5 TRAVEMUNDE DK 196 26 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:41:17 13:40:11 51.710693 2.31115 51.695581 2.270978 213 10.7 GN CKY GB 175 31 80 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:42:27 13:41:20 51.711896 2.357886 51.704841 2.316981 220 9.9 TR NEM MT 190 29 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:45:45 13:45:40 51.775728 2.466641 51.771433 2.441711 224 11.7 LORIENT SG 182 27 81 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:48:05 13:48:04 51.723498 2.548296 51.724513 2.5478 41 11 SKAW MT 183 28 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:48:48 13:48:39 51.726745 2.587908 51.727583 2.587461 39 10.3 SCHEVENINGEN NL 88 13 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:49:20 13:49:19 51.727126 2.616556 51.728466 2.615933 39 13.8 KARLSHAMN GI 92 15 82 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:51:53 13:51:32 51.780606 2.7128 51.783671 2.713975 68 15.6 ROTTERDAM PA 366 51 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:54:50 13:54:46 51.863165 2.748205 51.866745 2.746386 41 12.7 AMSTERDAM HK 183 32 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:55:56 13:55:33 51.893728 2.770056 51.889958 2.768363 43 14.5 YMUIDEN NETHERLANDS MT 229 32 79 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 13:57:44 13:56:43 51.861726 2.728696 51.891896 2.745601 44 18.6 DECUX SG 164 28 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 14:15:58 14:15:22 51.569378 3.401305 51.567626 3.410913 338 14.5 DEBRB CY 187 29 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 14:21:52 14:20:53 51.423138 3.508293 51.418666 3.472 260 12.6 BILBAO (SPAIN) BS 188 29 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16231 28/10/2016 14:22:24 14:22:24 51.426161 3.532398 51.425691 3.529815 261 12.9 ANTWERP PA 183 32 89 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 14:26:14 Na 51.383613 3.723335 51.383696 3.721338 317 15.4 BRAEFOOT UK GR 173 28 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16231 28/10/2016 14:26:52 14:26:47 51.36974 3.747631 51.37023 3.745856 299 13.5 PASAJES SPAIN MH 183 24 70 LOW 0.07 Green Out of SECA16236 10/11/2016 10:19:35 0.429791667 51.422285 2.846403 51.422063 2.85189 277 15.5 BEANR>GBFXT PA 237 32 79 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16236 10/11/2016 10:26:37 Na 51.375895 2.659161 51.3708 2.7936 262 11.8 PROVIDENCE MH 152 27 80 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16236 10/11/2016 10:28:55 0.436747685 51.398593 2.558583 51.398281 2.556701 242 11.9 ANTWERP GB 99 15 84 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16236 10/11/2016 10:38:34 0.442534722 51.287916 2.229206 51.309708 2.2855 67 18.4 BEANR HK 294 32 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16236 10/11/2016 10:39:49 0.444282407 51.265848 2.187931 51.267166 2.18449 350 7.7 ANTWERP BM 245 32 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16236 10/11/2016 10:42:16 0.44380787 51.285885 2.22317 51.279913 2.222868 60 8.7 ANTWERP LR 200 30 79 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16236 10/11/2016 10:53:21 0.453703704 51.48294 2.015278 51.481478 2.01231 219 11.4 ICDAS LR 190 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16236 10/11/2016 10:58:40 0.456759259 51.583293 2.17091 51.567133 2.123533 218 11.2 DEHAM>ESALG LR 286 40 71 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16236 10/11/2016 11:06:13 0.462337963 51.634653 2.403171 51.636401 2.41777 42 16.6 DE BRV JP 199 38 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16236 10/11/2016 11:09:48 0.465138889 51.707411 2.374395 51.705383 2.3717 224 11.3 NEW YORK MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16236 10/11/2016 11:21:42 0.473391204 51.571668 2.708398 51.569971 2.706011 192 7.8 WANDELAAR ANCHORAGELU 191 40 99 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16236 10/11/2016 11:29:09 0.478275463 51.427671 2.993381 51.426183 2.993441 122 15.6 TEESPORT<=>ZEEBRUGGEFI 195 26 79 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16236 10/11/2016 11:31:13 0.477719907 51.4398 2.994683 51.4369 2.992266 174 13.9 ANTWERP PA 277 40 71 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16238 15/11/2016 15:02:26 0.620925926 51.366763 2.574978 51.359378 2.575245 93 16.2 ZEEBRUGGE 705 MT 194 26 79 LOW 0.11 Green SECA16238 15/11/2016 15:18:07 0.637164352 51.375256 2.144941 51.3766 2.165683 20 14.1 AMSTERDAM MH 200 24 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16238 15/11/2016 15:19:41 0.638634259 51.396128 2.08641 51.396593 2.083078 291 13.2 PUNTA EUROPA IN 244 42 81 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16238 15/11/2016 15:23:48 0.64099537 51.451053 1.957008 51.446598 1.969155 211 11.5 SHANGHAI HK 337 48 70 LOW 0.10 Green Out of SECA16238 15/11/2016 15:26:02 0.643032407 51.399251 1.98691 51.396206 1.984575 136 13.7 ANTWERP BS 228 38 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16239 16/11/2016 09:07:03 0.378888889 51.346253 2.440665 51.358693 2.478716 64 14.2 VLISSINGEN MH 144 24 70 HIGH 0.15 Yellow SECA16239 16/11/2016 09:17:56 0.3871875 51.347241 2.154351 51.355866 2.158483 23 13.1 NORTH SEA FOR ORDER HK 333 60 80 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16239 16/11/2016 09:22:21 0.390509259 51.337428 1.990403 51.335991 1.985158 37 9 ROTTERDAM MH 289 45 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16239 16/11/2016 09:25:21 0.392604167 51.372721 1.875228 51.369545 1.869256 206 15.9 PORT CARTIER LR 292 45 70 LOW 0.03 Green Out of SECA16239 16/11/2016 09:27:14 0.393344907 51.415656 1.931543 51.394883 1.8874 204 14.6 ROUEN FRANCE PA 190 32 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16240 16/11/2016 13:15:05 0.549976852 51.36097 2.780983 51.359043 2.778556 83 15.4 ZEEBRUGGE FI 195 26 71 HIGH 0.26 Orange SECA16240 16/11/2016 13:21:30 0.5565625 51.373406 2.536935 51.370211 2.528768 78 3 BEANR GI 183 32 79 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16240 16/11/2016 13:32:51 0.562777778 51.471008 2.113708 51.46116 2.210036 41 14.7 ROTTERDAM MT 183 32 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16240 16/11/2016 13:35:37 0.566377315 51.492321 1.994566 51.491 1.991166 225 12.3 CORK MT 134 22 71 LOW 0.04 Green Out of SECA16240 16/11/2016 13:39:48 0.567546296 51.500098 1.896931 51.506533 1.89935 267 14 PURFLEET BE 162 25 70 HIGH 0.35 Orange SECA16241 16/11/2016 14:55:32 0.621168981 51.407573 2.998585 51.386791 2.959988 259 14.3 LE HAVRE xx 275 40 71 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16241 16/11/2016 15:04:21 0.627083333 51.424416 3.515166 51.41648 3.477105 81 17.7 ANTWERP HK 300 48 74 HIGH 0.15 Yellow SECA16241 16/11/2016 15:09:20 0.63150463 51.441996 3.674095 51.440981 3.666373 282 10.4 PIRAEUS MT 369 51 70 LOW 0.05 Green Out of SECA16241 16/11/2016 15:10:55 0.632488426 51.406181 3.735458 51.406525 3.729961 311 8.3 SCHEVENINGEN ANCHOR BS 264 42 80 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16241 16/11/2016 15:15:09 0.634918981 51.368646 3.91778 51.358836 3.896266 236 13.4 ANTWERP DE 281 32 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:29:13 10:29:00 51.38025 4.152131 51.379753 4.155768 45 14.9 BEANR LR 294 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:30:06 10:30:06 51.370596 4.113246 51.369985 4.114731 79 11.6 ANTWERP NL 135 22 71 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:31:30 10:31:23 51.380425 4.045078 51.37938 4.044658 321 16.1 PA LOW 0.05 Green16242 21/11/2016 10:33:49 10:33:51 51.402878 3.956658 51.402606 3.958041 13 11.4 ANTWERP HK 199 26 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:31:29 10:31:23 51.380191 4.045915 51.37938 4.044658 321 16.1 ROTTERDAM PA 304 40 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:40:10 10:40:05 51.4424 3.655978 51.440836 3.659716 82 15.7 BE_ANR HK 294 32 71 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:42:01 10:42:02 51.440688 3.566156 51.439728 3.567305 134 5.6 NL-RTM/BE-ANT DK 148 22 80 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:49:21 10:49:15 51.407316 3.2119 51.407256 3.214026 79 9.4 GHENT RU 180 23 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:53:38 10:53:24 51.52415 3.087156 51.518985 3.086743 223 12.9 ANTWERP STEENBANK HK 366 52 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 10:54:42 10:54:38 51.531996 3.043708 51.528646 3.043688 204 16.9 ZEEBRUGGE MT 162 25 71 HIGH 0.22 Orange SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:03:08 Na 51.547953 2.692408 51.54694 2.695105 185 13.8 ANTWERP GB 128 18 84 Not Detected Not Detected SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:09:20 11:09:17 51.624301 2.432773 51.6235 2.435 42 10.4 MT 134 22 LOW 0.09 Green16242 21/11/2016 11:10:25 11:10:24 51.610425 2.428561 51.609718 2.431306 46 11.9 NORDENHAM HK 229 32 70 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:12:09 11:12:06 51.584093 2.353345 51.583283 2.357816 46 11.3 ROTTERDAM PA 289 45 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:15:52 11:15:49 51.614321 2.169975 51.613091 2.17156 222 11.6 SAFI BS 190 23 70 LOW 0.09 Green Out of SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:16:39 11:16:36 51.60059 2.137626 51.597318 2.138821 217 13 FAWLEY MH 183 32 80 LOW 0.02 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:24:52 11:24:40 51.414155 1.900671 51.40822 1.90252 212 16.4 GB SOU SG 164 28 70 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:25:54 11:25:47 51.385976 1.888735 51.380001 1.89278 206 13.2 BILBAO MT 183 32 80 LOW 0.08 Green Out of SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:28:51 11:28:50 51.325718 1.942765 51.325166 1.948 33 13.4 UST LUGA RUSSIA LR 274 48 89 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:35:10 11:35:05 51.26722 2.159151 51.265838 2.16334 60 13.5 FLUSHING PA 292 45 70 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:44:02 11:42:58 51.388948 2.464845 51.374545 2.47199 254 9.6 CASABLANCA CY 140 23 71 LOW 0.13 Green Out of SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:44:10 11:43:33 51.39145 2.468671 51.378918 2.467103 253 17.7 BEZEE<>GBTIL FI 180 24 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:47:12 11:47:11 51.367031 2.577111 51.36607 2.578923 89 12.1 BEANR NL 136 19 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16242 21/11/2016 11:53:05 11:53:03 51.361036 2.829256 51.359845 2.831675 82 10.7 BE GNE PH 180 30 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 13:39:03 0.568784722 51.373628 2.454168 51.3714 2.453765 257 15.1 OPL SG 120 21 80 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 13:44:09 0.572210648 51.495478 2.222746 51.489416 2.232916 36 11.5 TESS IT 249 44 89 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 13:45:19 0.57306713 51.529485 2.25012 51.526235 2.263443 45 12.9 ROTTERDAM SG 369 51 71 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 13:50:26 0.576655093 51.707698 2.304655 51.704333 2.307383 220 13.2 BEJAIA SG 143 23 70 LOW 0.11 Green Out of SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:13:46 Na 51.787758 2.41859 51.77195 2.391433 226 12.2 FRNTE MT 144 23 80 LOW 0.00 Green Out of SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:17:46 0.595636574 51.795608 2.494238 51.79276 2.495971 225 15.3 FI LOW 0.13 Green

Flight Date Time (manl) Time (auto) Lat aircraft Long aircraft Lat ship Long ship COG SOG (kts)Destination Nationality Length Width Type Evaluation ManualS-Content ManualColour Flag Destination16243 21/11/2016 14:19:57 0.597164352 51.844685 2.497178 51.841688 2.49913 222 13.9 CARTAGENA.SP AG 145 24 80 LOW 0.02 Green Out of SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:21:54 0.5984375 51.895418 2.55649 51.890333 2.557733 218 9.5 RU LOW 0.09 Green16243 21/11/2016 14:24:01 0.599872685 51.924245 2.642693 51.922045 2.643028 240 13.7 MINDELO MH 183 27 89 LOW 0.04 Green Out of SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:26:25 0.601666667 51.968261 2.733138 51.966215 2.73695 140 13 SOLAN O/F -> NL RTM BS 235 42 80 HIGH 0.17 Yellow SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:28:44 0.603275463 52.021793 2.811031 52.01885 2.812766 215 13.1 NO HRY MH 170 27 70 LOW 0.00 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:37:44 0.609525463 52.031348 2.91854 52.02788 2.919113 265 13.3 CASABLANCA MT 171 27 70 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:41:24 0.612060185 52.026726 3.068643 52.02259 3.068335 263 19.3 FRLEH FR 277 40 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:49:23 0.617581019 51.904876 3.259053 51.903333 3.261833 77 10 ROTTERDAM MT 134 22 71 LOW 0.13 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:53:45 0.62025463 51.821396 3.203235 51.832071 3.218116 236 2.1 FISHING GROUNDS NL 126 17 30 LOW 0.06 Green Out of SECA16243 21/11/2016 14:56:38 0.622650463 51.74881 3.201721 51.746026 3.205696 133 9.8 VLISSINGEN AG 141 24 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 15:13:09 0.633020833 51.464241 3.515848 51.461953 3.519958 343 9.7 BREMANGER BS 188 29 70 LOW 0.18 Yellow Out of SECA16243 21/11/2016 15:24:14 0.641851852 51.362091 3.897723 51.360633 3.897866 232 16.9 TILBURY FI 153 21 79 LOW 0.04 Green SECA16243 21/11/2016 15:24:03 Na 51.358436 3.890088 51.357238 3.890426 236 11.6 SAVANNAH SG 183 32 89 Not Detected Not Detected Out of SECA16246 29/11/2016 10:57:57 10:56:59 51.428708 3.994583 51.422383 4.029733 327 12.1 MH 159 25 LOW 0.05 Green16246 29/11/2016 10:58:41 10:58:41 51.418446 3.964785 51.42025 3.96763 20 13.5 PA 294 32 LOW 0.10 Green16246 29/11/2016 11:08:38 11:06:37 51.434725 3.574455 51.435668 3.626761 73 12.4 ANTWERP HK 366 52 71 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 11:08:55 11:07:56 51.433275 3.56028 51.430221 3.606691 69 12 MT 144 23 LOW 0.10 Green16246 29/11/2016 11:13:06 11:14:17 51.406691 3.271015 51.4052 3.346166 81 19.5 DK 399 60 LOW 0.08 Green16246 29/11/2016 11:15:31 11:12:59 51.407821 3.3393 51.407663 3.338405 265 16.2 LE HARVE PA 294 32 71 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 11:18:38 11:18:35 51.372376 3.175156 51.372111 3.178026 141 10.5 JP 199 32 LOW 0.04 Green16246 29/11/2016 11:23:06 11:19:40 51.400213 3.150888 51.400838 3.153938 83 10.6 MH LOW 0.07 Green16246 29/11/2016 11:39:57 11:23:05 51.456455 3.002326 51.454016 3.0015 211 16.4 ANTWERP PA 274 40 79 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 11:40:29 11:26:55 51.395298 3.003561 51.396366 3.008288 62 17.9 ZEEBRUGGE MT 200 32 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 11:40:36 Na 51.366535 2.512271 51.386088 2.522323 258 8.9 BE ANT GB 296 37 71 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 11:44:58 Na 51.357001 2.50206 51.3714 2.511416 88 9.8 ANTWERP HK 171 27 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 11:45:04 Na 51.356336 2.495936 51.360816 2.4869 70 6.5 BEZEE PA 188 28 70 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 11:49:02 11:44:12 51.340278 2.358643 51.34689 2.3493 250 12.6 CH 165 24 LOW 0.03 Green16246 29/11/2016 11:59:42 11:48:59 51.274948 2.252853 51.275058 2.254238 58 19.4 ZEEBRUGGE MT 194 26 79 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 12:01:51 11:50:33 51.318228 2.229411 51.317971 2.233681 97 17.3 ZEEBRUGGE-PURFLEET BE 162 25 72 HIGH 0.20 Orange SECA16246 29/11/2016 12:04:23 11:59:41 51.530081 2.274156 51.530748 2.276635 50 10.1 IJMUIDEN BE 292 45 70 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 12:07:02 12:01:45 51.535136 2.303136 51.535366 2.304666 40 12.9 ROTTERDAM NO 185 28 81 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 12:10:00 Na 51.591333 2.373956 51.592503 2.370736 290 18.6 BEZEE<>GBTIL FI 180 24 79 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 12:12:00 Na 51.577458 2.401383 51.586771 2.397588 296 15 PURFLEET MT 152 24 70 LOW 0.14 Green SECA16246 29/11/2016 12:15:00 Na 51.452096 2.71543 51.4514 2.716986 233 2.1 BEZEE LR 200 32 70 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16248 30/11/2016 10:04:35 10:03:44 51.389813 2.694203 51.388408 2.68035 183 5 ANTWERP WANDELAAR LR 398 59 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA16248 30/11/2016 10:07:25 10:06:27 51.436323 2.69066 51.438973 2.671005 183 1.1 OUTER ANCHORAGE VLISNO 142 26 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16248 30/11/2016 10:10:11 10:10:19 51.401723 2.673266 51.405916 2.670216 122 0.1 ANTWERPEN BE 180 30 80 LOW 0.12 Green SECA16249 30/11/2016 12:11:52 12:11:09 51.390218 2.579336 51.383543 2.594948 269 15.3 PA 294 40 LOW 0.11 Green16249 30/11/2016 12:12:59 12:12:57 51.38347 2.532898 51.383583 2.529655 270 10.6 LR 190 28 LOW 0.10 Green16249 30/11/2016 12:14:38 12:14:26 51.356218 2.471311 51.356766 2.469063 65 6.9 ANTWERP PA 274 32 71 LOW 0.07 Green SECA16249 30/11/2016 12:16:50 12:16:52 51.336536 2.376813 51.336745 2.374615 64 5.8 ANTWERP MT 183 32 80 LOW 0.08 Green SECA16249 30/11/2016 12:17:53 12:17:49 51.346551 2.337798 51.346106 2.335335 254 10.1 ROTTERDAM. MH 184 27 80 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16249 30/11/2016 12:24:58 12:20:58 51.311496 2.225073 51.31287 2.257583 91 20.9 ZEEBRUGGE FI 195 26 71 HIGH 0.16 Yellow SECA16249 30/11/2016 12:26:53 12:26:16 51.338838 2.163096 51.322533 2.175116 98 15 ZEEBRUGGE FI 139 24 70 LOW 0.06 Green SECA16249 30/11/2016 12:34:58 12:31:18 51.469206 2.198256 51.479208 2.189101 48 12.6 ROTTERDAM GB 342 63 70 LOW 0.13 Green16249 30/11/2016 12:35:49 12:35:50 51.472575 2.243456 51.473861 2.243565 23 15.1 MUUGA ESTONIA PA 180 29 79 LOW 0.09 Green SECA16249 30/11/2016 12:39:52 12:39:51 51.563831 2.394388 51.564625 2.38989 279 18 BEZEE<>GBTIL FI 180 24 79 LOW 0.05 Green SECA16249 30/11/2016 12:42:16 12:41:04 51.608176 2.465856 51.602843 2.421096 44 12.5 PT 141 22 LOW 0.05 Green16249 30/11/2016 12:48:35 12:46:54 51.564793 2.712098 51.562908 2.707685 65 2.5 SG 164 28 LOW 0.13 Green16249 30/11/2016 13:04:37 13:03:42 51.418896 3.505765 51.417183 3.46185 259 10 MH LOW 0.09 Green16249 30/11/2016 13:05:47 13:05:19 51.409533 3.510643 51.4168 3.494416 80 14 TERNEUZEN PA 230 36 80 LOW 0.03 Green SECA16249 30/11/2016 13:10:31 10:03:44 51.3965 3.712941 51.39517 3.710346 177 10.8 ANTWERP WANDELAAR LR 398 59 70 LOW 0.10 Green SECA