Result of the BiddingName ofProject

Construction of Ashuganj 400MW Combined Cycle Power Plant(East)

Bid ref. No. APSCL/MD/Pro ect-40OMW ast 201611437 Date: 05 Ma 2016

ADB Loan No. 3350-BAN: Power System Expansion & Efficiency ImprovementInvestment P ram

Im rovement Pro ect

Bidder whosubmitted theFirst Stage Bid

sl.No,

Name

I ISOLUX-ORASCOM JV

Consortium between China CAMC Engineering Co. Ltd. and China EnergyEngineering Group Guangdong Power Engineering Co., Ltd

3 Sarrsung C&T Corporation

The Consortium of Hyundai Engineering Co., Ltd., Hyundai Engineering andConstruction Co., Ltd & Posco Daewoo Corporation.

5 China Tianchen Engineering Corporation

6

7Consortium of Larsen & Toubro Limited and Inelectra S.A.C.A. (L&T-Inelectra Consortium)

8 Consortium of CMEC & NEPCII

9 Daewoo Engineering & Constmction Co., Ltd. (Daervoo E&C)

l0 Lotte Engineering & Construction Co., Ltd.

ACCIONA Infraestructuras S.A-METAL CONSTRUCTIONS OF GREECE.S.A. (METKA)

t2 TECNICAS REUNIDAS S.A

13. Consortium SEC-AEN

SEPCO III ELECTRIC POWER CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION(SEPCO IID

The Consortium of China National Elcctric Engineering Co., Ltd and ChinaEnergy Engineering Group Guangdong Electric Power Design Institute Co.,Ltd.

16.Harbin Electric Intemational Co., Ltd. And Jiangsu ETERN Co., Ltd. JointVenture (HEI-ETERN JV)

t7 Essar Projects India Ltd and BJN group

l8

l9 Joint Venture ofLTL Holdings (Pr.t) Ltd and LTL Projects (Pvt) Ltd.

20.China National Technical Import & Export Corporation and China NationalCorporation for Overseas Economic Cooperation Consortium (CNTIC-CCOEC Consortium)

Consortium of Alfanar Construction, Shanahan Engineering and PowerMech Project Limited

lq_Page I oJ 5

IDB Loan No. BD-0184: 400MW Ashuganj (East) Porver Plant Efficiency

2.

1.

CONSORTIUM " DURO FELGUERA S.A. / DONGFANG ELECTRICINTERNATIONAL CORPORATION"

11.

14.

15.

ENKA INSAAT VE SANAYI A,S.

2t.

Bidder whoseFirst Stage bidwas Non-responsive andthe reasons forNon-responsiveness

sl.No.

NamcReasons for Non-Rcsponsiveness

I ISOLUX-ORA.SCOM JV

Bidder does not fulfill theSpecific Experience Criteria Setforth in the bidding documcntVolume I of 3, Section-3:Evaluation and QualificationCriteria, Clause 2.4.2 (a).

2

Consortium between China CAMCEngineering Co., Ltd. And China EnergyEngineering Group Guangdong PowerEngineering Co., Ltd

Bidder does not fulfill the eligiblebidder Sct forth in the biddingdocument Volunrc I of 3,Section- l: lnstructions toBidders, Clause ITB 4.3.

3 China Tianchcn Enginecring Corporation

Bidder does not fulfill theSpecific Experience Criteria Set

forth in the bidding documentVolume I of 3, Section-3:Evaluation and QualificationCriteria, Clause 2.4.2 (a).

4 Consortium of CMEC & NEPCII

Bidder does not fulfill the eligiblebidder Sct forth in thc biddingdocument Volume I of 3,

Section- l: Instructions toBidders, Clause ITB 4.3.

5

The Consortium ofChina National ElectncEngineering Co., Ltd and China EnergyEngineering Group Guangdong ElcctricPower Design Institute Co., Ltd.

Bidder does not fulfill the eligiblebidder Set forth in the biddingdocument Volume I of 3,Section-l: Instructions toBidders, Clause ITB 4.3.

6 Essar Projects India Ltd and BJN group

Due to incompleteness offinancial status and the lack ofthebid with regard to completeness inall, and not providing the output,heat rate guarantees the Bidderdoes not considered as eligiblebidder Set forth in the biddingdocument Volumc I of 3,Section-l: [nstructions toBidders, Clause ITB 24.1

1Joint Venture of LTL Holdings (Pvt) Ltdand LTL Projects (Pvt) Ltd.

Bidder does not fulfill theSpecific Experience Criteria Setforth in the bidding documentVolumc I ol 3, Section-3:Evaluation and QualificationCriteria, Clause 2.4.2 (a).

8

Consortium of Alfanar Construction,Shanahan Engineering and Power MechProject Limited

Bidder does not fulfill thcSpecific Experience Criteria Setforth in the bidding documentVolume I of 3, Section-3:Evaluation and QualificationCriteria, Clause 2.4.2 (a).

Ea--

Page 2 oJ 5

Bidder rvhosubmitted theSecond StageBid

sl.No.

\ame

I Samsung C&T Corporation

2 CONSORTIUM " DURO FELGUERA S.A. / DONGFANG ELECTRICINTERNATIONAL CORPORATION"

3 Consortium of Larsen & Toubro Limited and Inelectra S.A.C.A. (L & T-InelectraConsortium)

4 ACCIONA Infraestructuras S.A-METAL CONSTRUCTIONS OF GREECE.S.A. (METKA)

TECNICAS REUNIDAS S.A

6 Consortium SEC-AEN

7 SEPCO III ELECTRTC POWER CONSTRUCTION CORPORATTON (SEPCOIII)

tt Harbin Electric International Co., Ltd. And Jiangsu ETERN Co., Ltd. JointVenture (HEI-ETERN JV)

ENKA INSAAT VE SANAYI A.S

10. China National Technical Import & Export Corporation and China NationalCorporation for Overseas Economic Cooperation Consortium (CNTIC-CCOECConsortium)

Bidder who didnot submit theSecond StageBid

I The Consortium of Hyundai Engineering Co., Ltd., Hyundai Engineering andConstruction Co., Ltd & Posco Daewoo Corporation.

2 Daewoo Engineering & Construction Co., Ltd. (Daewoo E&C)

3 Lotte Engineering & Construction Co., Ltd

Bid prices as

read out at bidopening

NameRe ad Out Price

Foreign Currency Local CurrencyI Samsung C&T Corporation us$ 139,091,954.00

+

€ s2,6t5,412.00

BDT2,665,427,037 .00

2 CONSORTIUM "DUROFELGUERA S.A./DONGFANGELECTRIC INTERNATIONALCORPORATION"

us$ 88,926,399.58

+

e 9t,721,612.68

BDT2,281,200,504.71

Consortium of Larsen & ToubroLimited and Inelectra S.A.C-A.

1l!4!TJnelectra Consortium)

e t67,764,100.00

4 ACCIONA hrfraestructuras S.A-METAL CONSTRUCTIONS OFGREECE, S.A. (METKA)

us$ 97,948,986.00+

€ I15,175,184.00

BDT2,871,628,665.00

5 TECNICAS REUNIDAS S.A US$ 103,694,2149.00

+

e 1n,921,565.00

BDT786,423,234.00

6 Consortium SEC-AEN us$ l I1,338,416.88+

€ 53,000,000.00

BDT2,662,7 59,88t.25

W_ Pase j ol5

5.

9.

sl.No.

J. BDT2,230,500,000.00

Bid prices as

read out at bidopening

sl.No.

NameRead Out Price

Foreign Currency Local Currency,7 SEPCO III ELECTRIC POWER

CONSTRUCTIONCORPORATION (SEPCO NI)

us$ 150,336,009.00 BDT3,700,324,599.00

8 Harbin Electric International Co.,Lrd. And Jiangsu ETERN Co., Ltd.Joint Venture (HEl-ETERN JV)

us$ I 14,3 16,752.00+

€ 46,530,698.00

BDTI ,543,689,591.00

9 ENKA INSAAT VE SANAYI A.S. us$ 27s,756,533.00+

e 25,348,621.00

BDT367,200,000.00

l0 China National Technical Import &Export Corporation and ChinaNational Corporation for OverseasEconomic Cooperation Consortium(CNTIC-CCOEC Consortium)

us$ 108,047,640.00

+

€ 48,860,335.00

BDT918,824,360.00

Name andevaluated pricesof each bid thatwas evaluated

sl.No.

NameCorrected Bid

Price inequivalent BDT

Evaluated BidPrice in BDT pcr

KWI Samsung C&T Corporation t9,433,292,297 .29 BDT 166,293.37

2 CONSORTIUM " DUROFELGUERA S.A./ DONGFANGELECTRIC INTERNATIONAICORPORATION"

18,775,I49,708.88 BDT 115,032.18

Consortium of Larsen & ToubroLimited and Inelectra S.A.C.A.(L&TJnelectra Consortium)

18,906,939,372.81 BDT I 14,577.71

4 ACCIONA Infraestructuras S.A-METAI CONSTRUCTIONS OFGREECE, S.A. (METKA)

22,3t3,8t3,159.62 BDT 122,286.04

5 TECNICAS REUNIDAS S.A 2t,650,179,697 .26 BDT 121,048.21

6 Consortium SEC-AEN 17,166,698,861.45 BDT I I1,007.34

7 SEPCO III ELECTRIC POWERCONSTRUCTIONCORPORATION (SEPCO il)

16,170,696,545.55 BDT 108,35 t.ti6

IJ Harbin Electric Intemational Co.,Ltd. And Jiangsu ETERN Co., Ltd.Joint Vcnture (HEI-ETERN JV)

15,65 I ,606,328.46 BDT 107.230.85

9 ENKA INSAAT VE SANAYI A.S 25,7 60,96t,269.10 BDT 129,609.08

t0. China National Technical Import &Expon Corporation and ChinaNational Corporation for OverseasEconomic Cooperation Consortium(CNTIC-CCOEC Consortium)

14,738,293,724.37 BDT 105.134.72

Exchange Rate: I USD = BDT 82.95, I EURO: BDT 99.4041

(Source: Selling Rale ofSonali Bank Limited, Bangladesh; Date: 27 November 2017)

w..-,Page 4 oJ 5

3.

Bidder whoseSecond StageBid was rejectedand the reasonsfor rejection

Name Reasons for Rejection

SEPCO III ELECTRICPOWERCONSTRUCTIONCORPORATION(SEPCO ND

The bidder has changed their Guaranteed Net ElectricalOutput and Net Heat Rate during the clariflcation stageafter 2nn Stage Bid Submission which are materialdeviation. This newly offered output and heat rate in theclarihcation and confirmation will affect the quality andperformance of plant and services which is notacceptable according to ITB 43.2 in the biddingdocument Volume I of 3, Section-l: Instructions toBidders. Though it fulfills the requirement of theemployer and does not changes the competitive positionof the bidders if accepted yet the bid should beconsidered non-responsive.

Winning Bidder Nanre China National Technical Import & Export Corporationand China National Corporation for Overseas EconomicCooperation Consortium (CNTIC-CCOEC Consortium)

Contacted Price USD 108,047,640.00

Euro 48,860,335.00

BDT 918,824,360.00

Total (Equivalent USD) t77,676,838.t5

Duration of theContract

36 Months

Summary Scope ofthe Contract

Demolition & Disposal of existing plants, SitePreparation, Development and Detailed Engineering,Design, Manufacture/Procurement, Inspection &Testing, Custom Clearance, Delivery to site,Construction of related Civil Works, Installation,Inspection, Testing, Pre-commissioning,Commissioning, Performance Test and OperationalAcceptance on tumkey basis of Ashuganj 400 MWCombined Cycle Power Plant (East) (the facilities),complete in all respect having a guaranteed net output of420.00 MW at site conditions (35'C, 1.013 bar,98o/urelative humidity) including 2 (two) years DefectLiability Period of the facilitics.

ffiPage 5 of 5