2
 Responsible Professionals and Ethical Corporations The engineering industry has been at the forefront of the develop ment of corpo ration s in recen t years . This is due to the increasingly shifting of the markets for its goods and services towards the developing world and the core act ivities of the eng ine erin g indust ry tha t req uire man y indivi dua l to wor k together. Th e two main st ages in the development of  engineering as a profession were identified by Edwin T. Layton, Jr. which is: !" increase demand for infrastructure and services and #" demand for engineers burst out. The corporate control underlies the primary ethical dilemmas confronted by engineers as suggested by Layto n. $n this topic, the different forms of cor pora te res pon sibilit y are dis cus sed and some ethical dilemmas are encountered. Professions $n Engineering Ethics, %rofessions are defined as those forms of work involving advanced e&pertise, self' regulation and concerted service to the public good.  (dvanced E&pertise ' acquiring theoretical knowledge and ref ined ski lls from an e&t ens ive formal training) education *elf'regulation ' professional societies has a certain degr ee of autonomy in the regulat ion of thei r  practice which were allowed by the public %ublic +ood ' occupation serves some aspect of the common good Moral Committed Corporation  (n ethical work climate leads to more trust in the company, str onger commit men t fr om empl oyees, low er  absenteei sm and tur nov er rates, hig her profitabi lity and produ ctivity , and a more positive attitud e to work and good conduct.  (n ethical climate also reduces employee misconduct. *everal studies have found a positive relationship between the ethical climate in a company and ob satisfaction. Larger corporations characteri-ed by more intense competition and profit' making pre ssu res face a greater cha llen ge in maintaining an ethical climate. Corporate Social Responsibility *ocial espo nsibi lity /ovement has outstretched consideration to product quality, the well'being of workers, the wider community and the environment since !0123s and also, of whi ch is ref lec ted in the *ta keh older The ory . es pon sib le corporations also strive to be good neighbors by supporting local schools, cultural activities, civic groups and charities. *takeholder Theory: 45orpo ration s have respo nsibi lities to all gr oups that have a vi tal st ake in the corpor at ion incl ud ing empl oy ees, custo mers, dealers, suppliers, local communities, and the general public.6 The social responsibility movement was attacked by /ilt on 7ri edman, a 8ob el Laurea te eco nomist , in a famous essay 4The *ocial esponsibility of a 9usiness is to $ncrease $ts %r of its .6 e arg ued that the sole responsi bi lit y of the management is to satisfy the desires of the stockholders while conforming to the basic laws of society but his view is ultimately self'defeating. ;hen the public perceiv es corporation s as having wider social commitments, it is more willing to cooperate and purchase products from socially responsible corporations. Thus, the moral roles of engineers and their corporations are symbiotic and it is essential for engineering and corporations, in their maor dimensions, to be morally aligned. Senses of Corporate Responsibility $n dealing with corporate responsibility, the senses of responsibility of an individual which revolve around obligations, accountabili ty , the vi rtu e of being conscienti ous, and pra isew orth iness and blameworth ine ss are also app lied . 5or porations, as defined, are communities of individuals, struct ur ed wi thin legal fra meworks . Th us, the senses aforementioned apply for corporations, too. 5orporations have responsibilities oblig ations " ust like individuals. $n addition, corporations have internal structures consisting of policy manual and flowcharts assigning responsibilities to individuals. The unity of a corporation is e&pressed when these individuals act in accordance with their assigned responsibilities. 5orporations are accountable to the general public, to thei r empl oyees and cust omer s, and to thei r  stockh old ers. The act ions of the cor pora tion are perfor med by individual s and subgroup s within the corporation, according to how the flowchart and policy manual specifies areas of authority. 5or por ations manifest the virtue of res pon sibilit y consc ientious" when they rout inel y mee t their obligations. 5orporations could also be blameworthy if they are accou ntable for a wrong doing and prais eworth y if they are accountable for right conduct. en ce, these per tain to the moral responsibility of a corpo ration. 5ausa l responsib ility and legal respo nsibil ity are distinct from moral responsibility. 5ausal responsibility consists simply in being a cause of some event. Leg al respon sibili ty consists simply wha t the law requires. Engineers has the immense ca pacity to help prov ide benefits to the society but it also has similarly large capacity to be used to cause harm. (s an engineer, it is cr ucial to understand this dual natur e of the profession and to be vigilant regarding our own role and that of our employers so that we ma&imi-e the cha nces of a pos itiv e con tri but ion to soc iet y. $n essence this is what it means to be a soci al ly responsible engineer.

Responsible Professionals and Ethical Corporations

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

ethics

Citation preview

Responsible Professionals and Ethical CorporationsThe engineering industry has been at the forefront of the development of corporations in recent years. This is due to the increasingly shifting of the markets for its goods and services towards the developing world and the core activities of the engineering industry that require many individual to work together.The two main stages in the development of engineering as a profession were identified by Edwin T. Layton, Jr. which is: (1) increase demand for infrastructure and services and (2) demand for engineers burst out. The corporate control underlies the primary ethical dilemmas confronted by engineers as suggested by Layton. In this topic, the different forms of corporate responsibility are discussed and some ethical dilemmas are encountered.

Professions

In Engineering Ethics, Professions are defined as those forms of work involving advanced expertise, self- regulation and concerted service to the public good. Advanced Expertise - acquiring theoretical knowledge and refined skills from an extensive formal training/ education Self-regulation - professional societies has a certain degree of autonomy in the regulation of their practice which were allowed by the public Public Good - occupation serves some aspect of the common goodMoral Committed CorporationAn ethical work climate leads to more trust in the company, stronger commitment from employees, lower absenteeism and turnover rates, higher profitability and productivity, and a more positive attitude to work and good conduct.An ethical climate also reduces employee misconduct. Several studies have found a positive relationship between the ethical climate in a company and job satisfaction. Larger corporations characterized by more intense competition and profit-making pressures face a greater challenge in maintaining an ethical climate.Corporate Social ResponsibilitySocial Responsibility Movement has outstretched consideration to product quality, the well-being of workers, the wider community and the environment since 1960s and also, of which is reflected in the Stakeholder Theory. Responsible corporations also strive to be good neighbors by supporting local schools, cultural activities, civic groups and charities. Stakeholder Theory:Corporations have responsibilities to all groups that have a vital stake in the corporation including employees, customers, dealers, suppliers, local communities, and the general public.The social responsibility movement was attacked by Milton Friedman, a Nobel Laureate economist, in a famous essay The Social Responsibility of a Business is to Increase Its Profits. He argued that the sole responsibility of the management is to satisfy the desires of the stockholders while conforming to the basic laws of society but his view is ultimately self-defeating. When the public perceives corporations as having wider social commitments, it is more willing to cooperate and purchase products from socially responsible corporations. Thus, the moral roles of engineers and their corporations are symbiotic and it is essential for engineering and corporations, in their major dimensions, to be morally aligned.Senses of Corporate ResponsibilityIn dealing with corporate responsibility, the senses of responsibility of an individual which revolve around obligations, accountability, the virtue of being conscientious, and praiseworthiness and blameworthiness are also applied. Corporations, as defined, are communities of individuals, structured within legal frameworks. Thus, the senses aforementioned apply for corporations, too. Corporations have responsibilities (obligations) just like individuals. In addition, corporations have internal structures consisting of policy manual and flowcharts assigning responsibilities to individuals. The unity of a corporation is expressed when these individuals act in accordance with their assigned responsibilities.

Corporations are accountable to the general public, to their employees and customers, and to their stockholders. The actions of the corporation are performed by individuals and subgroups within the corporation, according to how the flowchart and policy manual specifies areas of authority. Corporations manifest the virtue of responsibility (conscientious) when they routinely meet their obligations.

Corporations could also be blameworthy if they are accountable for a wrong doing and praiseworthy if they are accountable for right conduct.Hence, these pertain to the moral responsibility of a corporation. Causal responsibility and legal responsibility are distinct from moral responsibility. Causal responsibility consists simply in being a cause of some event. Legal responsibility consists simply what the law requires.

Engineers has the immense capacity to help provide benefits to the society but it also has similarly large capacity to be used to cause harm. As an engineer, it is crucial to understand this dual nature of the profession and to be vigilant regarding our own role and that of our employers so that we maximize the chances of a positive contribution to society. In essence this is what it means to be a socially responsible engineer.The words "ethical climates" relate to the general feel of an organization as it relates to ethics. All organizations operate with some type of ethical climate. When leaders in an organization demonstrate and demand highly ethical behavior, an organization likely feels like it has an ethical climate. When leaders and employees routinely make unethical decisions, an unethical work climate exists.