38
LC Paper No. CB(1)992/02-03(01) Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior Executives of Government-Funded Bodies Introduction In January 2002, the Chief Secretary for Administration announced that the Government would embark on a review of remunerations of senior staff of government-funded bodies. The review was conducted internally within the Administration, as a separate exercise from the consultancy study of remunerations of senior executives of ten selected statutory and other bodies. Findings of the consultancy study were reported to the Legislative Council in mid 2002. This report sets out the review results arising from the two-stage review of government-funded bodies. Objective 2. The internal review aims to ascertain whether the number, ranking and remuneration packages of senior executives of major government-funded bodies are appropriate in present day circumstances. A Steering Committee, chaired by the Chief Secretary for Administration, was set up to oversee the exercise. The main tasks of the Steering Committee include: (a) to determine whether the ranking and remuneration packages of the senior executives under study are appropriate in present day circumstances, drawing reference to the original policy considerations when these posts were first established; (b) to determine whether the number of staff employed at the top three tiers of the bodies under study are excessive; and (c) to determine the strategy to redress identified discrepancies with established policies or guidelines, or impropriety such as over- payment vis-à-vis comparable civil service ranks or market practices, as the case may be.

Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

LC Paper No. CB(1)992/02-03(01)

Report on Internal Review of Remunerationsof Senior Executives of Government-Funded Bodies

Introduction

In January 2002, the Chief Secretary for Administration announcedthat the Government would embark on a review of remunerations of seniorstaff of government-funded bodies. The review was conducted internallywithin the Administration, as a separate exercise from the consultancy studyof remunerations of senior executives of ten selected statutory and otherbodies. Findings of the consultancy study were reported to the LegislativeCouncil in mid 2002. This report sets out the review results arising from thetwo-stage review of government-funded bodies.

Objective

2. The internal review aims to ascertain whether the number, rankingand remuneration packages of senior executives of major government-fundedbodies are appropriate in present day circumstances. A Steering Committee,chaired by the Chief Secretary for Administration, was set up to oversee theexercise. The main tasks of the Steering Committee include:

(a) to determine whether the ranking and remuneration packages ofthe senior executives under study are appropriate in present daycircumstances, drawing reference to the original policyconsiderations when these posts were first established;

(b) to determine whether the number of staff employed at the topthree tiers of the bodies under study are excessive; and

(c) to determine the strategy to redress identified discrepancies withestablished policies or guidelines, or impropriety such as over-payment vis-à-vis comparable civil service ranks or marketpractices, as the case may be.

Page 2: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

2

Review Approach

3. The review adopted a two-stage approach. At Stage I of theexercise, relevant Bureaux conducted a brief examination of the staffing andfunding positions of all government-funded bodies under their purview.Based on the information collected by the Bureaux, the Steering Committeedecided on the bodies to be selected for detailed examination under Stage IIof the exercise. For each of these selected bodies, the responsible Bureauconducted in-depth review and made recommendations related to theremuneration arrangements for its top three-tier executives.

Stage I of Review

4. Over 300 bodies or groups of bodies were examined by relevantBureaux under Stage I of the review. The full list of these bodies is atAnnex A. The Steering Committee considered the Bureaux’ returns onthese bodies and decided that the following types of organizations should beexcluded from further stages of the exercise:

(a) 194 bodies or groups of bodies (Annex B) that are servicedentirely by civil servants and have not employed their ownexecutive staff e.g. appeal boards and advisory committees;

(b) 32 bodies or group of bodies (Annex C) that have not receivedany form of Government funding e.g. trust funds and registrationboards;

(c) 41 bodies or groups of bodies (Annex D) covering -

(i) bodies that receive only limited Government funds assubsidy for their administrative expenses and/orsecretarial service e.g. village offices and mutual aidcommittees;

(ii) cases where Government funds are for ‘procuring’specified services or activities e.g. management of Mai

Page 3: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

3

Po by the World Wide Fund for Nature and procurementof training places from the Outward Bound Trust;

(iii) organizations that are subject to special funding and/orremuneration policies or are already under separatereview, hence rendering a general review not appropriatee.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schoolsreceiving recurrent funding under specific rules;

(iv) cases where Government funds represent not more than50% of their operating and staff costs e.g. the FamilyPlanning Association and uniform groups; and

(d) 15 bodies or groups of bodies (Annex E) that have receivedonly capital or other non-recurrent financial assistance, i.e.without any recurrent subvention from the Government e.g. theOcean Park Corporation Board and the Hong Kong Arts Centre.

5. The Steering Committee took account of the outcome of the Stage Iexercise and decided that the 20 subvented bodies at Annex F should besubject to detailed examination under the Stage II review. These 20 bodieshave:

(a) received and relied on Government recurrent funding as theirmain source of income, i.e. the Government’s recurrentprovisions amount to more than 50% of their operating and staffcosts; and

(b) employed their own executive staff and derived separateremuneration packages for their senior executives.

Stage II of Review

6. During Stage II of the review, for each of the 20 selected bodies, theresponsible Director of Bureau was required to:

(a) examine the remuneration packages of senior executives at the

Page 4: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

4

top three tiers; and

(b) provide detailed information and assessment on theappropriateness of the remuneration policy and arrangementsfor its senior executives in present day circumstances.

The Bureaux’ returns provided the basis for the Steering Committee todetermine whether the number, ranking and remuneration packages of seniorexecutives in these bodies were appropriate, and whether actions should betaken to rectify irregularities so identified.

Review Findings

7. The 20 subvented bodies under the Stage II review were found to beemploying over 59,000 staff, including over 190 executives at the top threetiers of their respective organizational structure. Having considered thedetailed submissions from the relevant Directors of Bureaux, the SteeringCommittee agreed on the following broad findings for the 20 bodies:

Group I No change to the remuneration packages or seniormanagement establishment (13 bodies)

Group II Further separate reviews to be carried out (three bodies)

Group III Changes should be made to the remuneration packages orsenior management establishment (four bodies)

(a) Group Bodies – No Change

8. This group comprises 13 subvented bodies including: theOmbudsman, Duty Lawyer Service, Consumer Council, Guardianship Board,Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data, HK Academy for Performing Arts,HK Council on Smoking and Health, Society for the Aid and Rehabilitationof Drug Abusers, HK Applied Science & Technology Research Institute Co.Ltd., HK Jockey Club Institute of Chinese Medicine Ltd., HK ChineseOrchestra Ltd., HK Dance Company Ltd. and HK Repertory Ltd.

9. The Steering Committee accepted the recommendations of the

Page 5: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

5

responsible Directors of Bureaux (and the Director of Administration in thecase of the Ombudsman and Duty Lawyer Service) that the establishment,ranking and remuneration packages of senior executives in the 13 bodiesshould be appropriate in present day circumstances. The SteeringCommittee concluded that no change to the current remunerationarrangements for these bodies should be necessary in the context of theinternal review.

(b) Group II organizations – Further Separate Reviews

10. Three subvented bodies fall under this group: the Vocational TrainingCouncil (VTC), Employees Retraining Board (ERB) and Equal OpportunitiesCommission (EOC).

11. The Steering Committee noted that the existing remunerationpackages of the senior staff in the Vocational Training Council andEmployees Retraining Board comply with the ‘no better than’ principle underthe existing subvention guideline. In anticipation of the proposedestablishment of a Manpower Development Committee (MDC), originallyscheduled for 2003, the Steering Committee accepted the Secretary forEducation and Manpower (SEM)’s recommendation that the organizationalset-up and the staff remuneration packages for these two bodies should bereviewed in tandem. With the recent establishment of the MDC in late 2002,the SEM would conduct the review accordingly, having regard to theprogress of the taking over of the functions of the two bodies by the MDC.

12. The Secretary for Home Affairs (SHA) has examined theremuneration of the top three-tier executives of the Equal OpportunitiesCommission (EOC) and confirmed that the arrangements for staff at thesecond and third tiers were in order. However, the SHA has decided toconsider the remuneration arrangement for the Chairperson of theCommission in the light of the outcome of the current proposal to legislateagainst racial discrimination, as such legislation may have a significantimpact on the work of the Chairperson.

(c) Group III Organizations – Changes to be Made

Page 6: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

6

13. There are four subvented bodies in this group: the Hong KongPhilharmonic Society Ltd. (HKPSL), Hong Kong Arts Development Council(HKADC), Hong Kong Sports Development Board (SDB) and HospitalAuthority (HA). The Steering Committee accepted the recommendations ofthe relevant Directors of Bureaux as summarized below:

(i) HKPSL

14. The Steering Committee endorsed the SHA’s recommendation ofdowngrading three of its four Assistant General Manager posts (equivalentto MPS point 33-43) at the second tier to the third tier as Senior Managers(MPS point 27-32), leaving only one Assistant General Manager as deputyto the General Manager. This change would bring the managementstructure of the company more in line with three of the other performinggroups. The SHA would follow up the matter.

(ii) HKADC

15. Although the full cost of the remuneration package of the ChiefExecutive post was not higher than that of a D2 officer, the SteeringCommittee endorsed the SHA’s recommendation that the Council should beasked to split the salary component into base salary, cash allowance andgratuity in the next contract of the Chief Executive. Subsequently, theCouncil agreed and the salary component has been split into base salary,cash allowance and gratuity in the new contract of the Chief Executive.

(iii) SDB

16. The Steering Committee noted the SHA’s findings regarding theremuneration packages of four existing senior staff posts. The SHA wouldfollow up the matter and modify the remuneration packages for the seniorposts as appropriate.

(iv) HA

17. The Steering Committee noted the decision of the FinanceCommittee in 1991 regarding the remuneration of staff of the HA and therelevant provisions in the HA Ordinance. The Committee also noted thefindings of the Secretary for Health, Welfare and Food (SHWF) regardingthe existing remuneration packages of the HA and its proposal for changes.The Steering Committee endorsed the SHWF’s view that the new guidelines

Page 7: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

7

which the Steering Committee has derived separately for the control andmonitoring of remunerations of senior staff of subvented bodies should notapply to the HA.

Conclusion

18. With the support of the relevant Directors of Bureaux, the SteeringCommittee completed the internal review of remunerations of seniorexecutives of government-funded bodies in end 2002. For the majority ofthe bodies reviewed, the number, ranking and remuneration packages oftheir senior executives were found to be in order. For those cases wherefurther reviews should be conducted or changes have been proposed, theresponsible Directors of Bureaux undertook to take follow-up actions in atimely manner.

Administration WingFebruary 2003

Page 8: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

1

附件 AAnnex A

第㆒階段內部檢討涵蓋的機構/機構類別總覽(共 302)Full list of bodies/groups of bodies

covered by Stage I of Internal Review (302)

Administration Wing行政署

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱

1. Administrative Appeals Board 行政上訴委員會2. Independent Commission Against Corruption Witness Protection

Review Board廉政公署保護證人覆核委員會

3. Legal Aid Services Council 法律援助服務局4. Municipal Services Appeals Board 市政服務上訴委員會5. Panel of the Independent Commission Against Corruption Witness

Protection Review Board廉政公署保護證人覆核委員會小組

6. The Office of The Ombudsman 申訴專員公署7. Duty Lawyer Service 當值律師服務8. Disaster Relief Fund Advisory Committee 賬災基金諮詢委員會9. ICAC Complaints Committee 廉政公署事宜投訴委員會10.ICAC Advisory Committee on Corruption廉政公署貪污問題諮詢委員會

11.ICAC Operations Review Committee廉政公署審查貪污舉報諮詢委員會

12.ICAC Corruption Prevention Advisory Committee廉政公署防止貪污諮詢委員會

13.ICAC Citizens Advisory Committee on Community Relations廉政公署社區關係市民諮詢委員會

Page 9: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

2

Const i tu t ional Af fa irs Bureau政制事務局政制事務局政制事務局政制事務局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Electoral Affairs Commission 選舉管理委員會

Commerce , Indus try and Techno logy Bureau工商及科技局工商及科技局工商及科技局工商及科技局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Copyright Tribunal 版權審裁處2. Federation of Hong Kong Industries 香港工業總會3. Hong Kong Export Credit Insurance Corporation香港出口信用保險局

4. Hong Kong Science and Technology Parks Corporation香港科技園公司

5. Hong Kong Applied Science and Technology Institute香港應用科技研究院

6. Applied Research Council 應用研究局7. Hong Kong Jockey Club Institute of Chinese Medicine Company香港賽馬會中藥研究院有限公司

8. Appeal Board Panel (Entertainment Special Effects)上訴委員會委員團 (娛樂特別效果 )

9. Board of Review (Film Censorship) 審核委員會 (電影檢查 )10.Broadcasting Authority 廣播事務管理局11.Panel of Censors 電影檢查員小組12.Panel of Film Censorship Advisers 電影顧問小組13.Telecommunications (Competition Provisions) Appeal Board電訊 (競爭條文 )上訴委員會

Page 10: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

3

Civ i l Serv ice Bureau公務員事務局公務員事務局公務員事務局公務員事務局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Board of Directors of Surviving Spouses' and Children's, ThePensions Scheme尚存配偶及子女撫恤金計劃管理委員會

2. Board of Directors of Widows and Orphans Pension, The Scheme孤寡撫恤金計劃管理委員會

3. Pensions Appeal Panel 退休金上訴委員會4. Public Service Commission 公務員 用委員會

Environment , Transport and Works Bureau環境運輸及工務局環境運輸及工務局環境運輸及工務局環境運輸及工務局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Appeal Board (Air Pollution Control) 空氣污染管制上訴委員會2. Appeal Board (Noise Control) 上訴委員會 (噪音管制 )3. Appeal Board (Waste Disposal) 上訴委員會 (廢物處置 )4. Appeal Board (Water Pollution Control) 水污染管制上訴委員會5. Appeal Board Panel (Dumping at Sea) 上訴委員會 (海上傾倒物料 )6. Appeal Board Panel (Environmental Impact Assessment)上訴委員會 (環境影響評估 )

7. Asbestos Administration Committee 石棉行政管理委員會8. Country and Marine Parks Board 郊野公園及海岸公園委員會9. Dogs and Cats Classification Board 狗隻及貓隻分類委員會10.Endangered Species Advisory Committee保護稀有動植物諮詢委員會

11.Environment and Conservation Fund Committee環境及自然保育基金委員會

12.Society for the prevention of Cruelty to Animals (HK)香港愛護動物協會

13.World Wide Fund for Nature (HK)世界自然 (香港 )基金會14.Conservancy Association 長春社15.Hong Kong Bird Watching Society 香港觀鳥會

Page 11: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

4

16.Transport Tribunal 交通審裁處17.Drainage Appeal Board Panel 排水事務上訴委員會備選小組18.Architects Registration Board 建築師註冊管理局19.Builder’s Lifts and Tower Working Platforms (Safety) Ordinance –

Disciplinary Tribunal Panel & Disciplinary Appeal Board Panel建築工地升降機及塔式工作平台 (安全 )條例-紀律審裁委員團及紀律上訴委員團

20.Engineers Registration Board 工程師註冊管理局21.Landscape Architects Registration Board 園景師註冊管理局22.Planners Registration Board 規劃師註冊管理局23.Surveyors Registration Board 測量師註冊管理局

Educat ion and Manpow er Bureau教育統籌局教育統籌局教育統籌局教育統籌局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Appeals Board (Education) 上訴委員會 (教育事宜 )2. Board of Education 教育委員會3. Advisory Committee on Quality Assurance Inspection質素保證視學諮詢委員會

4. Advisory Committee on School Places Allocation學位分配諮詢委員會

5. Advisory Committee on School-based Management校本管理諮詢委員會

6. Advisory Committee on the Placement of Pupils安排學生入學諮詢委員會

7. Advisory Management Committee of the Hong Kong Teachers’Centre香港教師中心諮詢管理委員會

8. Board of Control – Grant Schools Provident Fund補助學校公積金管理委員會

9. Board of Control – Subsidized Schools Provident Fund津貼學校公積金管理委員會

10. Committee on Home-School Co-operation家庭與學校合作事宜委員會

11. Community Youth Club Council 公益少年團理事會

Page 12: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

5

12. Council on Professional Conduct in Education 教育人員專業操守議會13. Curriculum Development Council 課程發展議會14. Hong Kong School Drama Council 香港學校戲劇議會15. The Junior Secondary Education Assessment Committee初中成績評核委員會

16. The Primary One Admission Committee 小一入學委員會17. School Building Design Committee 校舍設計委員會18. Secondary School Places Allocation Committee中學學位分配委員會

19. Open University of Hong Kong 香港公開大學20. Council of Sir Edward Youde Memorial Fund尤德爵士紀念基金理事會

21. Education Scholarships Fund Committee 教育獎學基金委員會22. Hong Kong Council for Academic Accreditation 香港學術評審局23. Hong Kong Examinations Authority 香港考試局24. Non-local Higher and Professional Education Appeal Board非本地高等及專業教育上訴委員會

25. Schools receiving recurrent subvention under Code of Aid根據資助則例接受經常資助金的學校

26. Schools under Direct Subsidy Scheme, ESF schools, kindergartensunder KSS etc.屬於直接資助計劃的學校、英基學校協會屬下學校、屬於幼稚園

資助計劃的幼稚園等

27. Morrison Scholarships Trust Fund 馬理遜獎學基金28. Government Matriculation Maintenance Grants Selection Committee政府大學預科生活津貼遴選委員會

29. Hong Kong Rotary Club Students’ Loan Fund and Sing TaoFoundation Students’ Loan Fund Joint Selection Committee香港扶輪社暨星島基金貸款助學金遴選委員會

30. Schools under the caprut school rules31. UGC funded institutions 教資會資助院校32. Clothing Industry Training Authority 製衣業訓練局33. Construction Industry Training Authority 建造業訓練局34. Employees Retraining Board 僱員再培訓局35. Vocational Training Council 職業訓練局

Page 13: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

6

Economic Development and Labour Bureau經濟發展及勞工局經濟發展及勞工局經濟發展及勞工局經濟發展及勞工局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Advisory Committee on Travel Agents 旅行代理商諮詢委員會2. Air Transport Licensing Authority 空運牌照局3. Appeal Board Panel (Consumer Goods Safety)上訴委員團 (消費品安全 )

4. Appeal Board Panel (Electricity) 上訴委員會 (電力 )5. Appeal Board Panel (Gas Safety) 上訴委員團 (氣體安全 )6. Appeal Board Panel (Toys and Children's Products Safety)上訴委員團 (玩具及兒童產品安全 )

7. Consumer Council 消費者委員會8. Mercantile Marine Assistance Fund Committee商船海員援助基金委員會

9. Pilotage Advisory Committee 領港事務諮詢委員會10. Seafarers' Advisory Board 海員諮詢委員會11. Travel Industry Compensation Fund Management Board旅遊業賠償基金管理委員會

12. Disciplinary Tribunal Panel (Electricity)紀律審裁委員會 (電力 )13. Gas Safety Advisory Committee 氣體安全諮詢委員會14. Employees’ Compensation Insurance Levies Management Board僱員補償保險徵款管理局

15. Minor Employment Claims Adjudication Board小額薪酬索償仲裁處

16. Occupational Deafness Compensation Board 職業性失聰補償管理局17. Occupational Deafness Medical Committee 職業性失聰醫事委員會18. Occupational Safety and Health Council 職業安全健康局19. Panel of Arbitrators 仲裁人名單20. Pneumoconiosis Compensation Fund Board肺塵埃沉 病補償基金委員會

21. Pneumoconiosis Medical Board 肺塵埃沉 病判傷委員會

22. Protection of Wages on Insolvency Fund Board破產欠薪保障基金委員會

23. Safety Officer Advisory Committee 安全主任諮詢委員會24. Labour Advisory Board 勞工顧問委員會

Page 14: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

7

Financ ia l Serv ices and the Treasury Bureau財經事務及庫務局財經事務及庫務局財經事務及庫務局財經事務及庫務局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Banking Advisory Committee 銀行業務諮詢委員會2. Committee on Unit Trusts 單位信託委員會3. Council for the Hong Kong Society of Accountants香港會計師公會理事會

4. Deposit-taking Companies Advisory Committee接受存款公司諮詢委員會

5. Futures Compensation Fund Committee 期貨賠償基金委員會6. Insider Dealing Tribunal 內幕交易審裁處7. Insurance Advisory Committee 保險業諮詢委員會8. Investment-linked Assurance and Pooled Retirement Funds

Committee與投資有關的保險計劃及集資退休基金委員會

9. Occupational Retirement Schemes Appeal Board職業退休計劃上訴委員會

10.Securities Compensation Fund Committee 證券賠償基金委員會11.Takeovers Appeal Committee, The 收購上訴委員會12.Takeovers and Mergers Panel, The 收購及合併委員會13.Board of Inland Revenue 稅務委員會14.Board of Review (Inland Revenue Ordinance)稅務上訴委員會15.Advisory Committee on New Board – based Taxes稅基廣闊的新稅項事宜諮詢委員會

Home Affa ir s Bureau民政事務局民政事務局民政事務局民政事務局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Antiquities Advisory Board 古物諮詢委員會2. Appeal Board (Amusement Game Centres) 上訴委員會 (遊戲機中心 )3. Appeal Board (Bedspace Apartments) 上訴委員會 (床位寓所 )4. Appeal Board (Clubs (Safety of Premises))上訴委員會 (會社 (房產安全 ))

Page 15: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

8

5. Appeal Board (Hotel and Guesthouse Accommodation)上訴委員會 (旅館業 )

6. Appeal Board Panel (Amusement Rides (Safety))上訴委員團 (機動遊戲機 (安全 ))

7. Hong Kong Arts Centre 香港藝術中心8. Board of Management of the Chinese Permanent Cemeteries華人永遠墳場管理委員會

9. Board of Trustees of the Sir Edward Youde Memorial Fund尤德爵士紀念基金信託委員會

10.Brewin Trust Fund 蒲魯賢慈善信託基金11.Chinese Temples Committee 華人廟宇委員會12.Lord Wilson Heritage Trust 奕信勳爵文物信託

13.District Councils 區議會14.Equal Opportunities Commission 平等機會委員會15.Grantham Scholarships Fund Committee 葛量洪獎學金委員會16.Hong Kong Arts Development Council 香港藝術發展局17.Hong Kong Lotteries Board 香港獎券管理局18.Hong Kong Sports Development Board 香港康體發展局19.Li Po Chun Charitable Trust Fund 李寶椿慈善信託基金20.Ocean Park Corporation Board 海洋公園公司董事局21.Sir David Trench Fund for Recreation 戴麟趾爵士康樂基金22.Sir Murray MacLehose Trust Fund 麥理浩爵士信託基金23.Sir Robert Black Trust Fund Committee 柏立基爵士信託基金委員會24.Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts 香港演藝學院25.Heung Yee Kuk 鄉議局26.Office of the Commissioner for Personal Data個人資料私隱專員公署

27.9 uniformed groups 九個制服團體28.Rural Committees 鄉事委員會29.Mutual Aid Committees 互助委員會30.District Sports/Cultural Association 地區體育/文化協會31.Village Office 村公所32.Federation of Societies in Tsuen Wan District 荃灣區社團聯會33.HK Life Saving Society 香港拯溺總會34.HK Archaeological Society 香港考古學會

Page 16: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

9

35.Lord Wilson United World Colleges Scholarship Fund Council奕信勳爵聯合世界書院獎學基金理事會

36.Sir Jack Cater Scholarship Fund 姬達爵士獎學基金37.Ex-Chinese Public Dispensaries Fund 前華人公立醫局基金38.Hong Kong Award for Young People 香港青年獎勵計劃39.Agency for Volunteers Service 義務工作發展局40.Sports Federation and Olympic Committee of Hong Kong, China中國香港體育協會暨奧林匹克委員會

41.Hong Kong Chinese Orchestra Limited 香港中樂團有限公司42.Hong Kong Dance Company Limted 香港舞蹈團有限公司43.Hong Kong Repertory Theatre Limited 香港話劇團有限公司44.Hong Kong Philharmonic Society Limited 香港管弦協會有限公司45.Hong Kong Arts Festival Society Limited 香港藝術節協會有限公司46.Outward Bound Trust of Hong Kong 香港外展信託基金會47.Hong Kong PHAB Association 香港傷健協會48.Hong Kong Playground Association 香港遊樂場協會49.The Salvation Army 救世軍50.Chinese Young Men’s Christian Association of Hong Kong香港中華基督教青年會

51.Hong Kong Federation of Youth Groups 香港青年協會52.Hong Kong Young women’s Christian Association香港基督教女青年會

53.Boys’ & Girls’ Clubs Association of Hong Kong 香港小童群益會54.Caritas – Hong Kong 香港明愛55.Hong Kong Jockey Club Music and Dance Fund香港賽馬會音樂及舞蹈信託基金

56.Stamp Advisory Committee 郵票設計諮詢委員會57.Tung Wah Group of Hospitals 東華三院58.Po Leung Kuk 保良局

Page 17: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

10

Health , Wel fare and Food Bureau生福利及食物局生福利及食物局生福利及食物局生福利及食物局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Matilda and War Memorial Hospital 明德醫院2. Prince Philip Dental Hospital, The 菲臘牙科醫院3. Chinese Medicine Council of Hong Kong 香港中醫藥管理委員會4. Chinese Medicine Practitioners Board 中醫組5. Chinese Medicines Board 中藥組6. Chiropractors Council 脊醫管理局7. Hong Kong Academy of Medicine 香港醫學專科學院8. Queen Elizabeth Foundation for the Mentally Handicapped伊利沙伯女皇弱智人士基金

9. Council on Human Reproductive Technology 人類生殖科技管理局10.Dental Council of Hong Kong 香港牙醫管理委員會11.Emergency Relief Fund Committee 緊急救援基金委員會12.Guardianship Board 監護委員會13.Hong Kong Council on Smoking and Health 香港吸煙與健康委員會14.Hong Kong War Memorial Pensions Advisory Committee香港太平洋戰爭紀念撫恤金顧問委員會

15.Hong Kong War Memorial Pensions Appeal Board香港太平洋戰爭紀念撫恤金上訴委員會

16.Hospital Authority 醫院管理局17.Human Organ Transplant Board 人體器官移植委員會18.Medical Council of Hong Kong 香港醫務委員會19.Medical Laboratory Technologists Board 醫務化驗師管理委員會20.Midwives Council of Hong Kong 香港助產士管理局21.Nursing Council of Hong Kong 香港護士管理局22.Occupational Therapists Board 職業治療師管理委員會23.Optometrists Board 視光師管理委員會24.Pensions Assessment Board 恩恤金評議局25.Pharmacy and Poisons Appeal Tribunal 藥劑業及毒藥上訴審裁處26.Pharmacy and Poisons Board 藥劑業及毒藥管理局27.Physiotherapists Board 物理治療師管理委員會28.Radiation Board 輻射管理局

Page 18: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

11

29.Radiographers Board 放射技師管理委員會30.Residential Care Homes (Elderly Persons) Appeal Board安老院上訴委員會

31.Social Work Training Fund Committee 社會工作訓練基金委員會32.Social Workers Registration Board 社會工作者註冊局33.Supplementary Medical Professions Council 輔助醫療業管理局34.Environmental Advisory Service 生活環境輔導服務會35.HK St. John Ambulance 香港聖約翰救護機構36.The Family Planning Association of Hong Kong 香港家庭計劃指導會37.Hong Kong Red Cross First Aid Training Centre香港紅十字會急救訓練中心

38.Tung Wah Group of Hospitals Chinese Medicine Clinic東華三院中醫門診部

39.Caritas Hong Kong (Wong Yiu Nam Centre)香港明愛 (黃耀南中心 )40.Hong Kong Christian Service (House of the Rising Sun)香港基督教服務處

41.184 NGOs in welfare sectors 社會福利界 184 間非政府機構42.Fish Marketing Advisory Board 魚類統營顧問委員會43.Kadoorie Agricultural Aid Loan Fund Committee嘉道理農業輔助貸款基金委員會

44.Licensing Appeals Board 牌照上訴委員會45.Liquor Licensing Board 酒牌局46.Marine Fish Scholarship Fund Advisory Committee海魚獎學基金顧問委員會

47.Marketing Advisory Board 統營顧問委員會48.Veterinary Surgeons Board 獸醫管理局49.Agriculture Products Scholarship Fund Advisory Committee農產品獎學基金顧問委員會

50.Fish Marketing Organization 魚類統營處51.Vegetable Marketing Organization 蔬菜統營處

Page 19: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

12

Judiciary司法機構司法機構司法機構司法機構

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Advisory Committee on Legal Education 法律教育諮詢委員會2. Barristers Disciplinary Tribunal Panel 大律師紀律審裁團3. District Court Rules Committee 區域法院規則委員會4. High Court Rules Committee 高等法院規則委員會5. Judicial Officers Recommendation Commission司法人員推薦委員會

6. Panel of Adjudicators (Control of Obscene and Indecent Articles)審裁小組 (管制淫褻及不雅物品 )

7. Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal Panel 律師紀律審裁團8. Court of Final Appeal Rules Committee 終審法院規則委員會9. Criminal Procedure Rules Committee 刑事訴訟程序規則委員會10. Costs Committee 事務費委員會11. Admiralty Court Users’ Committee 海事法庭使用者委員會12. Criminal Court Users’ Committee 刑事法庭使用者委員會13. Civil Court Users’ Committee 民事法庭使用者委員會14. Judicial Studies Board 司法人員培訓委員會15. Mental Health Review Tribunal 精神健康覆核審裁處

Housing, Planning and Lands Bureau房屋及規劃地政局房屋及規劃地政局房屋及規劃地政局房屋及規劃地政局

Name of bodies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Appeal Board Panel (Lifts and Escalators (Safety))上訴委員團 (升降機及自動梯 (安全 ))

2. Appeal Board Panel (Town Planning)上訴委員會 (城市規劃 )3. Appeal Tribunal Panel (Buildings) 上訴審裁處 (建築物 )4. Authorized Persons Registration Committee認可人士註冊事務委員會

5. Authorized Persons Registration Committee Panel認可人士註冊事務委員會委員團

6. Disciplinary Board Panel (Land Survey)紀律審裁委員團 (土地測量 )

Page 20: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

13

7. Disciplinary Board Panel (Lifts and Escalators (Safety))紀律審裁委員團 (升降機及自動梯 (安全 ))

8. Metro Planning Committee 都會規劃小組委員會9. Rural and New Town Planning Committee鄉郊及新市鎮規劃小組委員會

10.Standing Advisory Committee (Oil Storage Installations)常務諮詢委員會 (貯油裝置 )

11.Structural Engineers Registration Committee結構工程師註冊事務委員會

12.Structural Engineers Registration Committee Panel結構工程師註冊事務委員會委員團

13.Town Planning Board 城市規劃委員會14.Contractors Registration Committee 承建商註冊事務委員會15.Contractors Registration Committee Panel承建商註冊事務委員團

16.Registered Contractors’ Disciplinary Board註冊承建商紀律委員會

17.Registered Contractors’ Disciplinary Board Panel註冊承建商紀律委員團

18.Authorized Persons’ and Registered Structural Engineers’Disciplinary Board認可人士及註冊結構工程師紀律委員會

19.Authorized Persons’ and Registered Structural Engineers’Disciplinary Board Panel認可人士及註冊結構工程師紀律委員團

20.Appeal Panel (Estate Agents Ordinance)上訴委員團 (地產代理條例 )

21.Appeal Panel (Housing) 上訴委員會 (房屋 )22.Estate Agents Authority 地產代理監管局23.Hong Kong Housing Authority 香港房屋委員會24.Housing Managers Registration Board 房屋經理註冊管理局

Page 21: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

14

Secur i ty Bureau保安局保安局保安局保安局

Name o f bod ies 機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱機構名稱

1. Appeal Board on Public Meetings and Processions公眾聚會與遊行上訴委員會

2. Correctional Services Children's Education Trust Committee懲教署人員子女教育信託基金委員會

3. Correctional Services Children's Education Trust InvestmentAdvisory Board懲教署人員子女教育信託基金投資顧問委員會

4. Customs and Excise Service Children's Education Trust FundCommittee香港海關人員子女教育信託基金委員會

5. Customs and Excise Service Children's Education Trust FundInvestment Advisory Board香港海關人員子女教育信託基金投資顧問委員會

6. Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Passports Appeal Board香港特別行政區護照上訴委員會

7. Immigration Tribunal 入境事務審裁處8. Long-term Prison Sentences Review Board長期監禁刑罰覆核委員會

9. Panel of the Police Witness Protection Review Board警方保護證人覆核委員會小組

10. Police Children's Education Trust Investment Advisory Board警察子女教育信託基金投資諮詢委員會

11. Police Children's Education Trust Management Committee警察子女教育信託基金管理委員會

12. Police Education and Welfare Trust Investment Advisory Board警察教育及福利信託基金投資諮詢委員會

13. Police Education and Welfare Trust Management Committee警察教育及福利信託基金管理委員會

14. Police Witness Protection Review Board警方保護證人覆核委員會

15. Post-Release Supervision Board監管釋囚委員會

16. Prisoners' Education Trust Fund Committee在囚人士教育信託基金管理委員會

17. Prisoners' Education Trust Fund Investment Advisory Committee在囚人士教育信託基金投資顧問委員會

Page 22: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

15

18. Refugee Status Review Board 難民身分覆檢委員會19. Registration of Persons Tribunal 人事登記審裁處20. Release under Supervision Board 監管下釋囚委員會21. Security and Guarding Services Industry Authority保安及護 業管理委員會

22. Independent Police Complaints Council投訴警方獨立監察委員會

23. Action Committee Against Narcotics 禁毒常務委員會24. Governing Committee of the Beat Drug Fund Association禁毒基金會監管委員會

25. Addiction Treatment Centre Appeal Board戒毒所上訴委員會

26. The Society for the Aid and Rehabilitation of Drug Abusers香港戒毒會

Page 23: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

1

附件附件附件附件 BAnnex B

因完全由公務員提供服務而不被列入第二階段內部檢討因完全由公務員提供服務而不被列入第二階段內部檢討因完全由公務員提供服務而不被列入第二階段內部檢討因完全由公務員提供服務而不被列入第二階段內部檢討

的機構的機構的機構的機構////機構類別機構類別機構類別機構類別(共共共共 194)Bodies / groups of bodies excluded from Stage II of the Internal Review

because they are serviced entirely by civil servants (194)

Name of Organizations組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱

1. Action Committee Against Narcotics 禁毒常務委員會

2. Addiction Treatment Centre Appeal Board 戒毒所上訴委員會

3. Administrative Appeals Board 行政上訴委員會

4. Admiralty Court Users’ Committee 海事法庭使用者委員會

5. Advisory Committee on Legal Education 法律教育諮詢委員會

6. Advisory Committee on New Board – based Taxes稅基擴闊的新稅項事宜諮詢委員會

7. Advisory Committee on Quality Assurance Inspection質素保證視學諮詢委員會

8. Advisory Committee on School Places Allocation學位分配諮詢委員會

9. Advisory Committee on School-based Management校本管理諮詢委員會

10. Advisory Committee on the Placement of Pupils安排學生入學諮詢委員會

11. Advisory Committee on Travel Agents 旅行代理商諮詢委員會

12. Advisory Management Committee of the Hong Kong Teachers’Centre 香港教師中心諮詢管理委員會

13. Agricultural Products Scholarship Fund Advisory Committee農產品獎學基金顧問委員會

14. Air Transport Licensing Authority 空運牌照局

15. Antiquities Advisory Board 古物諮詢委員會

16. Appeal Board (Air Pollution Control)空氣污染管制上訴委員會

Page 24: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

2

17. Appeal Board (Amusement Game Centres)上訴委員會 (遊戲機中心 )

18. Appeal Board (Bedspace Apartments)上訴委員會 (床位寓所 )

19. Appeal Board (Clubs (Safety of Premises))上訴委員會 (會社 (房產安全 ))

20. Appeal Board (Hotel and Guesthouse Accommodation)上訴委員會 (旅館業 )

21. Appeal Board (Noise Control)上訴委員會 (噪音管制 )

22. Appeal Board (Waste Disposal)上訴委員會 (廢物處置 )

23. Appeal Board (Water Pollution Control)水污染管制上訴委員會

24. Appeal Board on Public Meetings and Processions公眾聚會與遊行上訴委員會

25. Appeal Board Panel (Amusement Rides (Safety))上訴委員會 (機動遊戲機 (安全 ))

26. Appeal Board Panel (Consumer Goods Safety)上訴委員會 (消費品安全 )

27. Appeal Board Panel (Dumping at Sea)上訴委員會 (海上傾倒物料 )

28. Appeal Board Panel (Electricity)上訴委員會 (電力 )

29. Appeal Board Panel (Entertainment Special Effects)上訴委員會委員團 (娛樂特別效果 )

30. Appeal Board Panel (Environmental Impact Assessment)上訴委員會 (環境影響評估 )

31. Appeal Board Panel (Gas Safety)上訴委員會 (氣體安全 )

32. Appeal Board Panel (Lifts and Escalators (Safety))上訴委員會 (升降機及自動梯 (安全 ))

33. Appeal Board Panel (Town Planning)上訴委員會 (城市規劃 )

34. Appeal Board Panel (Toys and Children's Products Safety)上訴委員會 (玩具及兒童安全產品 )

35. Appeal Panel (Estate Agents Ordinance)上訴委員會 (地產代理條例 )

36. Appeal Panel (Housing)上訴委員會 (房屋 )

37. Appeal Tribunal Panel (Buildings)上訴審裁團 (建築物 )

38. Appeals Board (Education)上訴委員會 (教育事宜 )

39. Applied Research Council 應用研究局

Page 25: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

3

40. Asbestos Administration Committee 石棉行政管理委員會

41. Authorized Persons Registration Committee認可人士註冊事務委員會

42. Authorized Persons Registration Committee Panel認可人士註冊事務委員團

43. Authorized Persons’ and Registered Structural Engineers’Disciplinary Board 認可人士及註冊結構工程師紀律委員會

44. Authorized Persons’ and Registered Structural Engineers’Disciplinary Board Panel 認可人士及註冊結構工程師紀律委員團

45. Banking Advisory Committee 銀行業務諮詢委員會

46. Board of Control – Grant Schools Provident Fund補助學校公積金管理委員會

47. Board of Control – Subsidized Schools Provident Fund津貼學校公積金管理委員會

48. Board of Directors of Surviving Spouses' and Children's PensionsScheme, The 尚存配偶及子女撫恤金計劃管理委員會

49. Board of Directors of Widows and Orphans Pension Scheme, The孤寡撫恤金計劃管理委員會

50. Board of Education 教育委員會

51. Board of Inland Revenue 稅務委員會

52. Board of Review (Film Censorship)審核委員會 (電影檢查 )

53. Board of Review (Inland Revenue Ordinance)稅務上訴委員會

54. Broadcasting Authority 廣播事務管理局

55. Builder’s Lifts and Tower Working Platforms (Safety) Ordinance –Disciplinary Tribunal Panel & Disciplinary Appeal Board Panel建築工地升降機及塔式工作平台 (安全 )條例—紀律審裁委員團及紀律上訴委員團

56. Chinese Medicine Council of Hong Kong 香港中醫藥管理委員會

57. Chinese Medicine Practitioners Board 中醫組

58. Chinese Medicines Board 中藥組

59. Chiropractors Council 脊醫管理局

60. Civil Court Users’ Committee 民事法庭使用者委員會

61. Committee on Home-School Co-operation家庭與學校合作事宜委員會

Page 26: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

4

62. Community Youth Club Council 公益少年團理事會

63. Contractors Registration Committee 承建商註冊事務委員會

64. Contractors Registration Committee Panel 承建商註冊事務委員團

65. Copyright Tribunal 版權審裁處

66. Correctional Services Children's Education Trust Committee懲教署人員子女教育信託基金委員會

67. Correctional Services Children's Education Trust InvestmentAdvisory Board 懲教署人員子女教育信託基金投資顧問委員會

68. Costs Committee 事務費委員會

69. Council of the Sir Edward Youde Memorial Fund尤德爵士紀念基金理事會

70. Council on Human Reproductive Technology 人類生殖科技管理局

71. Council on Professional Conduct in Education教育人員專業操守議會

72. Country and Marine Parks Board 郊野公園及海岸公園委員會

73. Court of Final Appeal Rules Committee 終審法院規則委員會

74. Criminal Court Users’ Committee 刑事法庭使用者委員會

75. Criminal Procedure Rules Committee 刑事訴訟程序規則委員會

76. Curriculum Development Council 課程發展議會

77. Customs and Excise Service Children's Education Trust FundCommittee 香港海關人員子女教育信託基金委員會

78. Customs and Excise Service Children's Education Trust FundInvestment Advisory Board香港海關人員子女教育信託基金投資顧問委員會

79. Dental Council of Hong Kong 香港牙醫管理委員會

80. Deposit-taking Companies Advisory Committee接受存款公司諮詢委員會

81. Disaster Relief Fund Advisory Committee 賑災基金諮詢委員會

82. Disciplinary Board Panel (Land Survey)紀律審裁委員團 (土地測量 )

83. Disciplinary Board Panel (Lifts and Escalators (Safety))紀律審裁委員團 (升降機及自動梯 (安全 ))

84. Disciplinary Tribunal Panel (Electricity)紀律審裁委員會 (電力 )

85. District Councils 區議會

Page 27: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

5

86. District Court Rules Committee 區域法院規則委員會

87. Dogs and Cats Classification Board 狗隻及貓隻分類委員會

88. Drainage Appeal Board Panel 排水事務上訴委員會備選小組

89. Education Scholarships Fund Committee 教育獎學基金委員會

90. Electoral Affairs Commission 選舉管理委員會

91. Emergency Relief Fund Committee 緊急救援基金委員會

92. Endangered Species Advisory Committee保護稀有動植物諮詢委員會

93. Environment and Conservation Fund Committee環境及自然保育基金委員會

94. Fish Marketing Advisory Board 魚類統營顧問委員會

95. Gas Safety Advisory Committee 氣體安全諮詢委員會

96. Governing Committee of the Beat Drug Fund Association禁毒基金會監管委員會

97. Government Matriculation Maintenance Grants SelectionCommittee 政府大學預科生活津貼遴選委員會

98. High Court Rules Committee 高等法院規則委員會

99. Hong Kong Housing Authority 香港房屋委員會

100. Hong Kong Jockey Club Music and Dance Fund香港賽馬會音樂及舞蹈信託基金

101. Hong Kong Rotary Club Students’ Loan Fund and Sing TaoFoundation Students’ Loan Fund Joint Selection Committee香港扶輪社暨星島基金貸款助學金遴選委員會

102. Hong Kong School Drama Council 香港學校戲劇議會

103. Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Passports Appeal Board香港特別行政區護照上訴委員會

104. Hong Kong War Memorial Pensions Advisory Committee香港太平洋戰爭紀念撫恤金顧問委員會

105. Hong Kong War Memorial Pensions Appeal Board香港太平洋戰爭紀念撫恤金上訴委員會

106. Human Organ Transplant Board 人體器官移植委員會

107. ICAC Advisory Committee on Corruption廉政公署貪污問題諮詢委員會

Page 28: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

6

108. ICAC Citizens Advisory Committee on Community Relations廉政公署社區關係市民諮詢委員會

109. ICAC Complaints Committee 廉政公署事宜投訴委員會

110. ICAC Corruption Prevention Advisory Committee廉政公署防止貪污諮詢委員會

111. ICAC Operations Review Committee廉政公署審查貪污舉報諮詢委員會

112. Immigration Tribunal 入境事務審裁處

113. Independent Police Complaint Council 投訴警方獨立監察委員會

114. Independent Commission Against Corruption Witness ProtectionReview Board 廉政公署保護證人覆核委員會

115. Insider Dealing Tribunal 內幕交易審裁處

116. Insurance Advisory Committee 保險業諮詢委員會

117. Judicial Officers Recommendation Commission司法人員推薦委員會

118. Judicial Studies Board 司法人員培訓委員會

119. Kadoorie Agricultural Aid Loan Fund Committee嘉道理農業輔助貸款基金委員會

120. Labour Advisory Board 勞工顧問委員會

121. Legal Aid Services Council 法律援助服務局

122. Licensing Appeals Board 牌照上訴委員會

123. Liquor Licensing Board 酒牌局

124. Long-term Prison Sentences Review Board長期監禁刑罰覆核委員會

125. Lord Wilson Heritage Trust 奕信勳爵文物信託

126. Marine Fish Scholarship Fund Advisory Committee海魚獎學基金顧問委員會

127. Marketing Advisory Board 統營顧問委員會

128. Medical Council of Hong Kong 香港醫務委員會

129. Medical Laboratory Technologists Board 醫務化驗師管理委員會

130. Mental Health Review Tribunal 精神健康覆核審裁處

131. Mercantile Marine Assistance Fund Committee商船海員援助基金委員會

Page 29: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

7

132. Metro Planning Committee 都會規劃小組委員會

133. Midwives Council of Hong Kong 香港助產士管理局

134. Minor Employment Claims Adjudication Board小額薪酬索償仲裁處

135. Morrison Scholarship Trust Fund 馬理遜獎學信託基金

136. Municipal Services Appeals Board 市政服務上訴委員會

137. Non-Local Higher and Professional Education Appeal Board非本地高等及專業教育上訴委員會

138. Nursing Council of Hong Kong 香港護士管理局

139. Occupation Retirement Scheme Appeal Board職業退休計劃上訴委員會

140. Occupational Deafness Medical Committee職業性失聰醫事委員會

141. Occupational Therapists Board 職業治療師管理委員會

142. Optometrists Board 視光師管理委員會

143. Panel of Adjudicators (Control of Obscene and Indecent Articles)審裁小組 (管制淫褻及不雅物品 )

144. Panel of Arbitrators 仲裁人名單

145. Panel of Censors 電影檢查員小組

146. Panel of Film Censorship Advisers 電影顧問小組

147. Panel of the Independent Commission Against Corruption WitnessProtection Review Board 廉政公署保護證人覆核委員會小組

148. Panel of the Police Witness Protection Revew Board警方保護證人覆核委員會小組

149. Pensions Appeal Panel 退休金上訴委員會

150. Pensions Assessment Board 恩恤金評議局

151. Pharmacy and Poisons Appeal Tribunal 藥劑業及毒藥上訴審裁處

152. Pharmacy and Poisons Board 藥劑業及毒藥管理局

153. Physiotherapists Board 物理治療師管理委員會

154. Pilotage Advisory Committee 領港事務諮詢委員會

155. Pneumoconiosis Medical Board 肺塵埃沉 病判傷委員會

156. Police Children's Education Trust Investment Advisory Board警察子女教育信託基金投資諮詢委員會

Page 30: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

8

157. Police Children's Education Trust Management Committee警察子女教育信託基金管理委員會

158. Police Education and Welfare Trust Investment Advisory Board警察教育及福利信託基金投資諮詢委員會

159. Police Education and Welfare Trust Management Committee警察教育及福利信託基金管理委員會

160. Police Witness Protection Review Board警方保護證人覆核委員會

161. Post-Release Supervision Board 監管釋囚委員會

162. Prisoners' Education Trust Fund Committee在囚人士教育信託基金管理委員會

163. Prisoners' Education Trust Fund Investment Advisory Committee在囚人士教育信託基金投資顧問委員會

164. Protection of Wages on Insolvency Fund Board破產欠薪保障基金委員會

165. Public Services Commission 公務員 用委員會

166. Queen Elizabeth Foundation for the Mentally Handicapped伊利沙伯女皇弱智人士基金

167. Radiation Board 輻射管理局

168. Radiographers Board 放射技術管理委員會

169. Refugee Status Review Board 難民身分覆核委員會

170. Registered Contractors’ Disciplinary Board註冊承建商紀律委員會

171. Registered Contractors’ Disciplinary Board Panel註冊承建商紀律委員團

172. Registration of Persons Tribunal 人事登記審裁處

173. Release under Supervision Board 監管下釋囚委員會

174. Residential Care Homes (Elderly Persons) Appeal Board安老院上訴委員會

175. Rural and New Town Planning Committee鄉郊及新市鎮規劃小組委員會

176. Safety Officer Advisory Committee 安全主任諮詢委員會

177. School Building Design Committee 校舍設計委員會

178. Seafarers' Advisory Board 海員諮詢委員會

Page 31: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

9

179. Secondary School Places Allocation Committee中學學位分配委員會

180. Security and Guarding Services Industry Authority保安及護 業管理委員會

181. Sir David Trench Fund for Recreation 戴麟趾爵士康樂基金

182. Social Work Training Fund Committee 社會工作訓練基金委員會

183. Stamp Advisory Committee 郵票設計諮詢委員會

184. Standing Advisory Committee (Oil Storage Installations)常務諮詢委員會 (貯油裝置 )

185. Structural Engineers Registration Committee結構工程師註冊事務委員會

186. Structural Engineers Registration Committee Panel結構工程師註冊事務委員團

187. Supplementary Medical Professions Council 輔助醫療業管理局

188. Telecommunications (Competition Provisions) Appeal Board電訊 (競爭條文 )上訴委員會

189. The Junior Secondary Education Assessment Committee初中成績評核委員會

190. The Primary One Admission Committee 小一入學委員會

191. Town Planning Board 城市規劃委員會

192. Transport Tribunal 交通審裁處

193. Travel Industry Compensation Fund Management Board旅遊業賠償基金管理委員會

194. Veterinary Surgeons Board 獸醫管理局

Page 32: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

1

附件 CAnnex C

由於並無接受任何形式的政府撥款而

不被列入第㆓階段內部檢討的機構/機構類別(共 32)Bodies / groups of bodies excluded from

Stage II of the Internal Reviewbecause they have not received any form of government funding (32)

Name of Organizations 組織名稱

1. Architects Registration Board 建築師註冊管理局

2. Barristers Disciplinary Tribunal Panel 大律師紀律審裁團

3. Board of Management of the Chinese Permanent Cemeteries華人永遠墳場管理委員會

4. Board of Trustees of the Sir Edward Youde Memorial Fund尤德爵士紀念基金信託委員會

5. Brewin Trust Fund 蒲魯賢慈善信託基金

6. Chinese Temples Committee 華人廟宇委員會

7. Clothing Industry Training Authority 製衣業訓練局

8. Committee on Unit Trusts 單位信託委員會

9. Council for the Hong Kong Society of Accountants香港會計師公會理事會

10. Employees Compensation Insurance Levies Management Board僱員補償保險徵款管理局

11. Engineers Registration Board 工程師註冊管理局

12. Ex-Chinese Public Dispensaries Fund 前華人公立醫院基金

13. Futures Compensation Fund Committee 期貨賠償基金委員會

14. Grantham Scholarships Fund Committee 葛量洪獎學金委員會

15. Hong Kong Academy of Medicine 香港醫學專科學院

16. Hong Kong Lotteries Board 香港獎券管理局

17. Housing Managers Registration Board 房屋經理註冊管理局

18. Investment-linked Assurance and Pooled Retirement FundsCommittee 與投資有關的保險計劃及集資退休基金委員會

19. Landscape Architects Registration Board 園景師註冊管理局

20. Li Po Chun Charitable Trust Fund 李寶椿慈善信託基金

Page 33: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

2

21. Lord Wilson United World Colleges Scholarship Fund Council奕信勳爵聯合世界書院獎學金基金理事會

22. Matilda and War Memorial Hospital 明德醫院

23. Planners Registration Board 規劃師註冊管理局

24. Securities Compensation Fund Committee 證券賠償基金委員會

25. Sir Jack Cater Scholarship Fund 姬達爵士獎學基金

26. Sir Murray MacLehose Trust Fund 麥理浩爵士信託基金

27. Sir Robert Black Trust Fund Committee柏立基爵士信託基金委員會

28. Social Workers Registration Board 社會工作者註冊局

29. Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal Panel 律師紀律審裁團

30. Surveyors Registration Board 測量師註冊管理局

31. Takeovers and Mergers Panel 收購及合併委員會

32. Takeovers Appeal Committee 收購上訴委員會

Page 34: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

1

附件 DAnnex D

由於特別原因而不被列入第㆓階段內部檢討的機構/機構類別(共 41)Bodies / groups of bodies excluded from Stage II

of the Internal Review for special reasons (41)

I . 接受政府經常性撥款以提供特定服務、計劃項目或活動的組織Organizations receiving recurrent government funding for theprovision of specific services, programmes or activities

Name of Organizations組織名稱

1. Boys’ & Girls’ Clubs Association of Hong Kong 香港小童群益會

2. Caritas – Hong Kong 香港明愛

3. Caritas Hong Kong (Wong Yiu Nam Centre)香港明愛 (黃耀南中心 )

4. Chinese Young Men’s Christian Association of Hong Kong香港中華基督教青年會

5. Conservancy Association 長春社

6. Environmental Advisory Service 生活環境輔導服務會

7. HK Christian Service (House of the Rising Sun)香港基督教服務處

8. HK Red Cross First Aid Training Centre 香港紅十字會急救訓練中心

9. HK St John Ambulance 香港聖約翰救護機構

10. Hong Kong Archaeological Society 香港考古學會

11. Hong Kong Bird Watching Society 香港觀鳥會

12. Hong Kong Federation of Youth Groups 香港青年協會

13. Hong Kong PHAB Association 香港傷健協會

14. Hong Kong Playground Association 香港遊樂場協會

15. Hong Kong Young Women’s Christian Association 香港基督教女青年會

16. Outward Bound Trust of Hong Kong 香港外展信託基金會

17. Po Leung Kuk 保良局

18. Prince Phil ip Dental Hospital 菲臘牙科醫院

19. Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals 香港愛護動物協會

20. The Salvation Army 救世軍

21. Tung Wah Group of Hospitals 東華三院

22. Tung Wah Group of Hospitals Chinese Medicine Clinic東華三院中醫門診部

23. World Wide Fund for Nature, Hong Kong 世界自然 (香港 )基金會

Page 35: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

2

II. 接受政府經常性撥款以補貼行政開支及/或秘書服務的組織接受政府經常性撥款以補貼行政開支及/或秘書服務的組織接受政府經常性撥款以補貼行政開支及/或秘書服務的組織接受政府經常性撥款以補貼行政開支及/或秘書服務的組織

Organizations receiving recurrent government funding for subsidizingtheir administrative expenses and/or secretarial service

N a me o f Or ga ni za t i ons 組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱

24. District Sports/Cultural Association 地區體育/文化協會 25. Federation of Societies in Tsuen Wan District 荃灣區社團聯會 26. Heung Yee Kuk 鄉議局 27. HK Life Saving Society 香港拯溺總會 28. Mutual Aid Committees 互助委員會 29. Rural Committees 鄉事委員會 30. Sports Federation and Olympic Committee of Hong Kong, China中國香港體育協會暨奧林匹克委員會

31. Village Office 村公所

III. 正予檢討或須受特定撥款及/或薪酬政策所規管的組織正予檢討或須受特定撥款及/或薪酬政策所規管的組織正予檢討或須受特定撥款及/或薪酬政策所規管的組織正予檢討或須受特定撥款及/或薪酬政策所規管的組織

Groups of bodies which are currently under review or subject to aspecial funding and/or remuneration policy

Name of Organizations 組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱

32. NGOs in welfare sectors 社會福利界非政府機構 33. Schools receiving recurrent subvention under Code of Aid根據資助則例接受經常資助金的學校

34. Schools under Direct Subsidy Scheme, ESF, K/G under KSS etc.屬於直接資助計劃的學校、英基學校協會屬下學校、屬於幼稚園資助

計劃的幼稚園等

35. Schools under the caput school rules根據按位津貼學校規則接受津貼的學校

36. UGC funded insti tutions 教資會資助院校

Page 36: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

3

IV. 不超於不超於不超於不超於 50%的運作及員工開支由政府經常性撥款資助的組織的運作及員工開支由政府經常性撥款資助的組織的運作及員工開支由政府經常性撥款資助的組織的運作及員工開支由政府經常性撥款資助的組織

Organizations with no more than 50% of their operating and staffcosts financed by recurrent government funding

Name o f Organizat ions 組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱

37. Agency for Volunteers Service 義務工作發展局 38. Hong Kong Arts Festival Society Limited 香港藝術節協會有限公司 39. Hong Kong Award for Young People 香港青年獎勵計劃 40. The Family Planning Association of Hong Kong 香港家庭計劃指導會 41. Uniformed groups 制服團體

Page 37: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

附件附件附件附件 EAnnex E

由於只接受政府提供資本或其他形式的非經常性財政資助由於只接受政府提供資本或其他形式的非經常性財政資助由於只接受政府提供資本或其他形式的非經常性財政資助由於只接受政府提供資本或其他形式的非經常性財政資助

而不被列入第二階段內部檢討的機構/機構類別而不被列入第二階段內部檢討的機構/機構類別而不被列入第二階段內部檢討的機構/機構類別而不被列入第二階段內部檢討的機構/機構類別 (共共共共 15)Bodies / groups of bodies excluded from Stage II of the

Internal Review because they receive only capi tal orother forms of non-recurrent f inancial ass is tance from

Government (15)

Name of Organizations組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱組織名稱

1 . C on s t ru c t io n In d u s t r y T r a in in g Au th or i t y 建造業訓練局

2 . E s t a t e A ge n t s A u t h or i t y 地產代理監管局

3 . Fe d e r a t i o n o f Ho n g K on g In d u s t r i e s 香港工業總會

4 . F i sh M a rk e t in g O r ga n iz a t io n 魚類統營處

5 . H o n g K on g A r t s C e n t r e 香港藝術中心

6 . H o n g K on g Co un c i l fo r A c a d emi c A c c r ed i t a t i o n 香港學術評審局

7 . H o n g K on g Ex a mi n a t i ons Au th or i t y 香港考試局

8 .H o n g K on g Ex p or t C r e d i t In s u r an c e Co rp o r a t i on香港出口信用保險局

9 .H o n g K on g Sc i en c e a nd T e c hn o l o g y P a rk s Co rp o r a t i on香港科技園公司

1 0 .O c c u pa t i on a l D e a f ne ss C o m p e ns a t io n B o a rd職業性失聰補償管理局

1 1 . O c c u pa t i on a l S a fe t y a n d H e a l t h Co un c i l 職業安全健康局

1 2 . O c e a n P a r k C o rp o r t i on Bo a r d 海洋公園公司董事局

1 3 . O p e n Un iv e r s i t y o f H on g K on g 香港公開大學

1 4 .P n eum o co n i os i s C o mp ens a t i on Fu nd Boa r d肺塵埃沉 病補償基金委員會

1 5 . V e ge t a b l e M a rk e t in g O r gan iz a t i on 蔬菜統營處

Page 38: Report on Internal Review of Remunerations of Senior ...€¦ · review, hence rendering a general review not appropriate e.g. the UGC-funded institutions and those schools receiving

附件 FAnnex F

在第㆓階段內部檢討予以深入研究的機構 (共 20)Bodies subject to detailed examinationunder Stage II of Internal Review (20)

Name of Organizations組織名稱

1. Consumer Council消費者委員會

2. Duty Lawyer Service當值律師服務

3. Employees Retraining Board 僱員再培訓局

4. Equal Opportunities Commission平等機會委員會

5. Guardianship Board 監護委員會

6. Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts香港演藝學院

7. Hong Kong Applied Science and Technology Research InstituteCompany Limited (HKASTRI)香港應用科技研院有限公司

8. Hong Kong Arts Development Council香港藝術發展局

9. Hong Kong Chinese Orchestra Limited香港中樂團有限公司10. Hong Kong Council on Smoking and Health香港吸煙與健康委員會11. Hong Kong Dance Company Limited香港舞蹈團有限公司

12. Hong Kong Jockey Club Institute of Chinese Medicine Limited(subsidiary of HKASTRI)香港賽馬會中藥研究院有限公司

13. Hong Kong Philharmonic Society Limited香港管弦協會有限公司14. Hong Kong Repertory Theatre Limited香港話劇團有限公司

15. Hong Kong Sports Development Board 香港康體發展局

16. Hospital Authority 醫院管理局

17. Office of the Ombudsman申訴專員公署

18. Office of the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data個人資料私隱專員公署

19. Society for the Aid and Rehabilitation of Drug Abusers香港戒毒會

20. Vocational Training Council職業訓練局