15
| 1 RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION Amit Goyal Director – Sustainable Chemistry and Catalysis Southern Research IEA Bioenergy eWorkshop 2020

RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

| 1

RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER

PRODUCTION

Amit GoyalDirector – Sustainable Chemistry and

CatalysisSouthern Research

IEA Bioenergy eWorkshop 2020

Page 2: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

2

Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile

Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5%

Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai Kasei Corporation, Mitsubishi Chemical Corp., and

Ascend Performance Materials

ABS/SAN - Increasing at 5-6%

Acrylamide – increasing at 7-8%

Carbon fiber market (11-18%) is

increasing rapidly

Ref: IHS-Markit WPC 2017

Page 3: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

3

• Typical carbon fiber line produces 1000 MT/year

• A single line requires ~ 2200 to 2500 MT of Acrylonitrile

• 5000 MT ACN plant can supply 2 carbon fiber lines – most plants

operate at this capacity at a single location

• Low capex for first of kind plants

• Requires ~ 100 MT biomass per day

• Sugar transportation easier than hazardous acrylonitrile

This is why small scale ACN production plants are important.

Scale of ACN Production

Page 4: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

4

Technology Summary

Routes to ACN

Non-food sugar to acrylonitrile (ACN)

Renewable feedstock

Three-step thermo-catalytic process

C5

C6

Feedstock flexibilityValidated using commercial sugar hydrolyzates and C5/C6 sugar mix

Product meets critical performance attributes (CPA) for ACN

High performance CatalysisOne step sugar to C3,C2 chemicals. ~100% selectivity to acrolein. High purity ACN via ammoxidation (No HCN, CO2).

Process flexibilityReduced dependency on oil/gas. H2+NH3 requirement ~7% of biomass.

Cost and GHG reduction<$1/lb ACN production cost. GHG 95%

Page 5: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

5

H2

Glycols

Glycerol

Process Development

C5, C6

sugars

Biomass

Impurity

Removal

Sugar

Vendor Hydroxyacetone

Acrolein

Feedback on

impurity levelProduct

validation

Carbon fiber

BioACN

Air

NH3

Page 6: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

6

Different Phases of Development

Phase I - Laboratory scale

Catalyst Development

Phase II (Pilot scale) –Process scale up

Type of

reaction

Feed Pressure Desired products Productivity

(g/L/hr)

Production scale

up in phase II

Hydrocracking Sugar,H2 Pressurized Glycols*, Glycerol 180 60 – 100x

Dehydration Glycerol Atmospheric Acrolein,

Hydroxyacetone

290 650 - 975x

Ammoxidation Acrolein,

NH3, O2

Atmospheric Acrylonitrile 80-375 320 – 600x

Reaction summary

*Glycols are propylene glycol (PG) and Ethylene glycol (EG)

Page 7: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

7

15

Hydrocracking

Phase II Footprint

Decoupled pilot scale process with ~ 1kg/hr production capacity

Page 8: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

8

Catalyst Performance

Stable catalyst operation continuously for all reaction steps > 500 hours

2. Dehydration1. Hydrocracking

3. Ammoxidation –

Pilot scale results– All impurities present in the sugar hydrolyzateConversion %

bioACN Selectivity %

Page 9: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

9

Importance of Chemical Purity

SR produced BioACN

99.2% ACN

+

Balance acetonitrile, propionitrile and water. No

detectable metal.

Page 10: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

10

Water

Conversion

Polymer Concentration

Molecular Weight

Polydispersity

Rheology

Propionitrile

Conversion

Polymer Concentration

Molecular Weight

Polydispersity

Rheology

Acetonitrile

Conversion

Polymer Concentration

Molecular Weight

Polydispersity

Rheology

Acrolein

Conversion

Polymer Concentration

Molecular Weight

Polydispersity

Rheology

High Concern Low Concern Insignificant Insignificant

Detrimental: Causes significant deviation from baseline process*

High Concern: Causes some deviation from some baseline properties*

Low Concern: May cause minor deviation from baseline properties*

Insignificant: No deviation from baseline properties can be detected*

*Above undisclosed concentrations

Impact of Impurities on BioACN Properties

Impact of Impurities

Page 11: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

11

Fiber Morphology Comparison

No observable differences in fiber shape and structure

Control Fiber Bio-Mass PAN

Fiber

So

lva

y C

om

po

site

Mate

rials

Co

nfid

entia

l and

Pro

prie

tary

Page 12: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

12

Cost distribution

Production (MT/year)

5000 ACN

+

5800 PG

Sensitivity

Capital Investment

$ 15 – 19 million

(verified by independent

contractor)

Sugar key cost driver

Techno-Economic Assessment (TEA)

Variable cost analysis Equipment cost analysis

Page 13: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

13

LCA Assumptions: Biomass source: Corn Stover with 20% bulk moisture content

Biomass to sugar yield: 1 kg sugar (C5+C6) produced from 2.35 kg biomass

Biomass to ACN results in significantly less CO2 footprint than Crude to ACN

(0.29 versus 6.05 kg eq. CO2/ kg of product)

Individual

GHG

Life-Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Page 14: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

14

Phase II

Pilot study

completeEPC engaged

EPC detailed package design

begins (5,000-10,000 MT/yr

plant)

EPC basic

package

complete

First plant build

begins 5,000-

10,000 MT/yr

DOE- Phase II

$4.5 M

Pilot plant

complete

ACN Pilot plant

construction

started

Major Milestones

First commercial investment

First plant commercialization build begins

DOE funding received

2017 2018 2021202020192015-16DOE- Phase I

$2.3 M

completed

Commercialization Timeline

Page 15: RENEWABLE ACRYLONITRILE FOR CARBON FIBER PRODUCTION · 2020. 10. 20. · 2 Market Perspective - Acrylonitrile Total Production: 6.9 MMT/yr, CAGR of ~4-5% Major Producers: Ineos, Ashai

15

Acknowledgements

US Department of Energy

BETO Project officer: Mark Shmorhun

Southern ResearchAmit Goyal (PI)

Jadid Samad

Cytec SolvayJeremy Moskowitz (Technical Lead)

Billy Harmon

NJITZafar Iqbal (Lead)

Partners