1
ranged from 2-3 years. The surgical intervention procedures were Submucous diathermy (25 patients), Turbinoplasty (85 patients), and Turbinoplasty with posterior turbinectomy (105 patients). The patients were followed up regularly every week for three weeks, then every three months for at least two years. Doctor assessment scale and patients’ assessment score were filled in during every visit until the end of the follow-up period and any remarks were recorded and dealt with accordingly. RESULTS: Nasal pack for one day was a standard protocol following surgery. Patients in group A (Submucous diathermy) were the last patients to record a better quality of breathing following surgery; 18 patients (72%) recording a better breath- ing 8 days after surgery compared to 70 patients (82.4%) in group B (Turbinoplasty) and 96 patients (91.4%) in group C (Turbinoplasty with Posterior Turbinectomy). Tendency for postoperative nasal bleeding was not significantly higher in any of the studied group (p-value 0.1). The overall patient satisfaction was significantly higher in group C than group B which was also significantly higher than group A (p-value 0.05). Doctor’s satisfaction came in accordance with patients’ satisfaction. CONCLUSION: Posterior turbinectomy with turbinoplasty gives a better surgical outcome and better patient satisfaction in cases of inferior turbinate hypertrophy than submucous dia- thermy or turbinoplasty alone. Prevalence of Allergens in a British Farming Population Aaron Trinidade, MRCS (presenter); Eva Papesch, MD, MRCS, DOHNS; Paul Leong, MB, BCh, BAO, FRCS OBJECTIVE: To determine the prevalence of environmental allergens in a British cereal farming population population. METHOD: Study Design: Retrospective chart analysis. When conducted: Over a staggered 3 year period, comprising a 2-year period (January 2003 - December 2005) and 1-year period (September 2008 - September 2009). Subjects Studied: The results of 1475 consecutive patients who underwent skin prick allergy testing over a 2-year period and of 640 consec- utive patients over a separate 1-year period were analyzed and compared. Setting: General population within a mixed cereal farming area attending a rhinology and allergy clinic in a district general hospital, UK. Outcome Measures: Positive skin-prick allergy test(s). RESULTS: Allergy to house dust mite was found to be most common (n526, 25%), followed by grass pollen (n519, 24%) and cereals (n429, 20%). Oilseed rape hypersensitivity was relatively uncommon, comprising only 2% of the popu- lation tested (n28). CONCLUSION: Despite living in an area rich in cereal crops, our population experiences allergens similar to other popula- tions. Interestingly, oilseed rape does not cause significant allergy, despite being commonly cited as a culprit, even in areas of high production. Recurrence Rate of Sinonasal Papilloma by Surgical Technique Paul Russell, MD (presenter) OBJECTIVE: Inverted papilloma is a relatively rare benign tumor that arises within the nasal cavity. These tumors are of particular importance because they tend to be locally aggres- sive and can occasionally be associated with malignancy. Treatment options can be generally classified into endoscopic resection and open resection that may include lateral rhino- tomy and maxillectomy. Advantages of endoscopic resection include employing a minimally invasive approach without external incisions. The concern with the endoscopic approach is that complete removal of the tumor may be difficult leading to an increase in recurrence rate. Our experience is that com- plete removal can in fact be accomplished endoscopically and may actually be enhanced due to improved visualization from magnification with the endoscope. To that end, we propose a comparison of the recurrence rates of the endoscopic approach versus open approach over a ten-year period at Vanderbilt Medical Center. METHOD: A retrospective analysis from the dates of June 30, 2000, until July 1, 2009, was undertaken for patients with the diagnosis of sinonasal papilloma by two providers in the divi- sion of rhinology at a single major academic institution. One hundred twenty patients were analyzed and were stratified based on surgical method employed, either open resection or endoscopic resection. Demographic data was collected and outcomes were measured including size of tumor, location, pathological subtypes, associated polyposis, complications, years of follow up, and recurrence rates. RESULTS: Endoscopic approach yielded a recurrence rate of less than five percent when compared to open approach. This finding was independent of size or location of tumor with fewer complications. CONCLUSION: Endoscopic resection yields substantially re- duced recurrence rates and fewer complications when com- pared to open resection. Endoscopic resection should be viewed as the procedure of choice for the management of sinonasal papilloma. RF-Surgery Versus Placebo for Turbinate Reduction Sophia Huennebeck (presenter); Karl Hormann, MD; Boris Stuck, MD OBJECTIVE: Aim of the study was to evaluate the efficacy and morbidity of bipolar radiofrequency (RF) surgery in the treatment of nasal obstruction due to hypertrophy of inferior turbinates. METHOD: 20 patients with isolated turbinate hypertrophy and nasal obstruction were included in this randomized, single- P135 Oral Presentations ORALS

Recurrence Rate of Sinonasal Papilloma by Surgical Technique

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Recurrence Rate of Sinonasal Papilloma by Surgical Technique

ranged from 2-3 years. The surgical intervention procedureswere Submucous diathermy (25 patients), Turbinoplasty (85patients), and Turbinoplasty with posterior turbinectomy (105patients). The patients were followed up regularly every weekfor three weeks, then every three months for at least two years.Doctor assessment scale and patients’ assessment score werefilled in during every visit until the end of the follow-up periodand any remarks were recorded and dealt with accordingly.RESULTS: Nasal pack for one day was a standard protocolfollowing surgery. Patients in group A (Submucous diathermy)were the last patients to record a better quality of breathingfollowing surgery; 18 patients (72%) recording a better breath-ing 8 days after surgery compared to 70 patients (82.4%) ingroup B (Turbinoplasty) and 96 patients (91.4%) in group C(Turbinoplasty with Posterior Turbinectomy). Tendency forpostoperative nasal bleeding was not significantly higher inany of the studied group (p-value � 0.1). The overall patientsatisfaction was significantly higher in group C than group Bwhich was also significantly higher than group A (p-value �0.05). Doctor’s satisfaction came in accordance with patients’satisfaction.CONCLUSION: Posterior turbinectomy with turbinoplastygives a better surgical outcome and better patient satisfaction incases of inferior turbinate hypertrophy than submucous dia-thermy or turbinoplasty alone.

Prevalence of Allergens in a British Farming

Population

Aaron Trinidade, MRCS (presenter); Eva Papesch,MD, MRCS, DOHNS; Paul Leong, MB, BCh, BAO,FRCS

OBJECTIVE: To determine the prevalence of environmentalallergens in a British cereal farming population population.METHOD: Study Design: Retrospective chart analysis. Whenconducted: Over a staggered 3 year period, comprising a2-year period (January 2003 - December 2005) and 1-yearperiod (September 2008 - September 2009). Subjects Studied:The results of 1475 consecutive patients who underwent skinprick allergy testing over a 2-year period and of 640 consec-utive patients over a separate 1-year period were analyzed andcompared. Setting: General population within a mixed cerealfarming area attending a rhinology and allergy clinic in adistrict general hospital, UK. Outcome Measures: Positiveskin-prick allergy test(s).RESULTS: Allergy to house dust mite was found to be mostcommon (n�526, 25%), followed by grass pollen (n�519,24%) and cereals (n�429, 20%). Oilseed rape hypersensitivitywas relatively uncommon, comprising only 2% of the popu-lation tested (n�28).CONCLUSION: Despite living in an area rich in cereal crops,our population experiences allergens similar to other popula-tions. Interestingly, oilseed rape does not cause significant

allergy, despite being commonly cited as a culprit, even inareas of high production.

Recurrence Rate of Sinonasal Papilloma by Surgical

Technique

Paul Russell, MD (presenter)

OBJECTIVE: Inverted papilloma is a relatively rare benigntumor that arises within the nasal cavity. These tumors are ofparticular importance because they tend to be locally aggres-sive and can occasionally be associated with malignancy.Treatment options can be generally classified into endoscopicresection and open resection that may include lateral rhino-tomy and maxillectomy. Advantages of endoscopic resectioninclude employing a minimally invasive approach withoutexternal incisions. The concern with the endoscopic approachis that complete removal of the tumor may be difficult leadingto an increase in recurrence rate. Our experience is that com-plete removal can in fact be accomplished endoscopically andmay actually be enhanced due to improved visualization frommagnification with the endoscope. To that end, we propose acomparison of the recurrence rates of the endoscopic approachversus open approach over a ten-year period at VanderbiltMedical Center.METHOD: A retrospective analysis from the dates of June 30,2000, until July 1, 2009, was undertaken for patients with thediagnosis of sinonasal papilloma by two providers in the divi-sion of rhinology at a single major academic institution. Onehundred twenty patients were analyzed and were stratifiedbased on surgical method employed, either open resection orendoscopic resection. Demographic data was collected andoutcomes were measured including size of tumor, location,pathological subtypes, associated polyposis, complications,years of follow up, and recurrence rates.RESULTS: Endoscopic approach yielded a recurrence rate ofless than five percent when compared to open approach. Thisfinding was independent of size or location of tumor withfewer complications.CONCLUSION: Endoscopic resection yields substantially re-duced recurrence rates and fewer complications when com-pared to open resection. Endoscopic resection should beviewed as the procedure of choice for the management ofsinonasal papilloma.

RF-Surgery Versus Placebo for Turbinate Reduction

Sophia Huennebeck (presenter); Karl Hormann, MD;Boris Stuck, MD

OBJECTIVE: Aim of the study was to evaluate the efficacyand morbidity of bipolar radiofrequency (RF) surgery in thetreatment of nasal obstruction due to hypertrophy of inferiorturbinates.METHOD: 20 patients with isolated turbinate hypertrophy andnasal obstruction were included in this randomized, single-

P135Oral Presentations

OR

ALS