21
Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor Chief, Thoracic Oncology Vice Chair of Clinical Research September 13, 2018

Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

Radiation Therapy: The Promise of

Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for

Lung Cancer

Steven Feigenberg, MD

Professor

Chief, Thoracic Oncology

Vice Chair of Clinical Research

September 13, 2018

Page 2: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

2

Evolution of Radiation for Lung Cancer

Page 3: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

3

Early Stage Disease and the Challenges

from 15 years ago

Radiation is used when

surgery is too risky or is

refused

Standard is 7 weeks of

daily treatment

This can be a major

challenge for sick

patients

Treatment works about

70% of the time

What Can We Do to Improve the Standard of Care?

Page 4: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

4

Stereotactic Radiation

Page 5: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

5

Radiation Therapy is an outpatientTreatment:

Evolved over the last 15 years

Page 6: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

www.rtog.org 6

Lo

ca

l C

on

tro

l (%

)

0

25

50

75

100

Months after Start of SBRT

0 6 12 18 24 30 360

25

50

75

100

0 6 12 18 24 30 36

Patientsat Risk 55 54 47 46 39 34 23

Fail: 1Total: 55

/ / / / / /// / / // /// / / / / / // / // //// //

36 monthlocal control = 98% (CI: 84-100%) Initial goal

SBRT = 7 wks RT

What we found

SBRT >> 7 weeks

Less side effects

A real WIN WIN

Page 7: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

7

The Impact of Stereotactic Radiation

Stereotactic Therapy has dramatically

changed how lung cancer is managed

• Improving quality of life

– Reducing time at a radiation facility

– Reducing side effects

• Improving cancer outcomes

• In addition, …

Page 8: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

8

In the more advanced setting, …

Page 9: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

9

Tumor =CT =

PET =

Better Imaging has led to Major Benefits

Page 10: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

10

3 Dimensional Radiation

Page 11: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

11

Benefits in treatment Delivery:

Intensity Modulated Radiation (IMRT)

Page 12: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

12

RTOG 0617: Quality of Life• 3DCRT vs. IMRT:

• IMRT more commonly used for larger tumors (p<0.001), higher stage

disease (p=0.04)

• Greater decline in QOL at 12 months for 3DCRT (46% vs. 21%, p=0.003)

• For a given PTV volume, IMRT was associated with lower lung V20 (p=0.08),

lower heart doses (p<0.05)

• Heart dose predicted for survival (p<0.001)

• IMRT had fewer grade ≥3 pneumonitis (3.5% vs. 7.9%, p=0.0653) [adjusted

p=0.046]

• IMRT was associated with higher compliance with full dose consolidative

chemotherapy

• High volume centers had longer overall survival

• more likely to treat with IMRT (p=0.002) and had RT plans with lower mean

esophageal dose (p=0.03), lower median heart dose (p=0.006

Movsas B, et al. JAMA Oncol. 2016, Chun SG, et al. J Clin Oncol. 2017;Eaton RB, et al. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2016

Page 13: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

Coronal

Page 14: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

14

An NEXT Evolution of Change

Can We Do Better?

Why Protons Can be Superior to Photons

Page 15: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

15

PROTONS Delivery is Complex

Page 16: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

16

PROTONS Delivery is Complex

Page 17: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

17

Purple isodose line represents 5 Gy NOT 45 Gy

Page 18: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

18

Definitive Chemoradiation Case

Page 19: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

19

• RTOG 1308: Phase III Randomized Trial Comparing

Overall Survival After Photon Versus Proton

Chemoradiotherapy for Inoperable Stage II-IIIB

NSCLC

LA-NSCLC Proton Therapy Enrolling Studies

Page 20: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

20

Steven Feigenberg, MDAbigail T. Berman, MD

PENN Thoracic Radiation Oncology

Keith Cengel, MD, PhD

Samuel Swisher-McClure, MDWilliam Levin, MD

Page 21: Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic ...€¦ · Radiation Therapy: The Promise of Proton and Stereotactic Radiation for Lung Cancer Steven Feigenberg, MD Professor

21

’s