61
Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, reheating (and Unified DE/DM) EDUARDO GUENDELMAN, PHYSICS DEPARTMENT, BEN GURION UNIVERSITY, BEER SHEVA, ISRAEL. TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS

Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, reheating (and Unified DE/DM)

EDUARDO GUENDELMAN, PHYSICS DEPARTMENT, BEN GURION UNIVERSITY, BEER SHEVA, ISRAEL. TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS

Page 2: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

initial singularity.

2)subsequent inflation and reheating followed by a

3) transition to the present very slowly accelerated phase (as compared to the inflationary phase), Do all this while addressing the , 4 ) small cosmological constant problem and the DM/DE question 1) relates to the consistency of theory while 3) is by now a well established observational fact 4 ) is by now a well established observational fact

Page 3: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

WHY INFLATION?

Does not have anything to say about initial singularity, but addresses other problems in modern cosmology:

1) why the universe is so homogeneous and isotropic, while the standard model (before inflation) told us that the present observed universe consisted of many causally disconnected pieces, the so called horizon problem

2) Why the universe is so nearly spatially flat?.

1) is solved by starting from a very small region where everything was causally connected and inflating it.

2) The inflation naturally flattens any starting space.

Page 4: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

The cosmological constant Problem

Huge differences in scale between inflationary vacuum energy density and present energy density…..

Furthermore, we have to understand the transition between these two hugely different phases of the universe while also creating hot matter in the process (the Big Bang so to speak)

Page 5: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

SUMMARY OF OUR RESULTS

Here we will see how a unified picture of inflation and present dark energy can be consistent with a smooth, non singular origin of the universe, represented by the emergent scenario, presenting an attractive cosmological scenario, which include reheating. For the late universe the DM is considered. This is achieved by considering two non Riemannian measures or volume forms in the action. The motivation is:

Page 6: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 7: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 8: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 9: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

v

Page 10: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

The interpretation of this is an

Alternative realization of a non Riemannian measure, from a mapping of two spaces. Ideas from where can we get 4 scalars, for example from Cederwall and collaborators , to realize duality, by doubling of space time, adding “twiddle” coordinates which are scalars w/r to the “normal space” . We then can define a “brane “ where the twiddle coordinates are a functions of un-twiddle coordinates and Jacobian from the mapping defines measure of integration,

Page 11: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

There is also an infinite dimensional symmetry of the action as long as the

measures stay linear in the action, then , for example in the formulation where our

We can shift each of the 4 scalars by an arbitrary function of the lagrangian that multiplies it in the action. If symmetry is preserved in QM, then also the structure will be preserved by QM corrections.

Page 12: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 13: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 14: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 15: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

Before going further , let us point out also that the Unimodular theory is a

very special case of a Two Measures Theory

Page 16: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 17: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

The variation with respect to the H three index potential tells us, that on shell, up to a proportionality constant, the second measure is the Riemannian measure (the square root of the determinant of the metric). The 2 part of the action has been used in the past for (i) string, super-strings, branes and super-branes, (ii) modified measure formulations of supergravity.In this case the analogous of the H field is crucial to implement supersymmetry. In case of the extended objects the proportionality constant between the measure and the Riemannian measure represents the generation of a dynamical tension of the extended object.

Page 18: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

SCALE INVARIANCE: for this we choose

Page 19: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 20: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 21: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 22: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 23: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 24: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 25: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 26: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 27: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

Interesting feature of the effective potential in the case no R^2 terms

are introduced, which is that the bump showed in the picture raises above the first flat region (relevant for the early universe) as much as the second flat region (relevant for the present universe) is above zero! . There is a hint of the present universe which appears in the early universe.

For the other sign, we get a shape similar to that of the Starobinsky model, which provides a good description of inflation, but now, the new thing is the additional flat region that can take care of the present dark energy!, see:

Page 28: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 29: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

This shape is of interest in that it

addresses in a sense the cosmological constant problem, the old cosmological constant, due to the fact that we get a perfect square in the numerator of the effective potential………

Page 30: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 31: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 32: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

WE OBTAIN THE SEE-SAW FORMULA FOR PRESENT

VACUUM ENERGY DENSITY

Page 33: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

It is interesting to notice that although the two constants of integration indivi-

dually violate scale invariance, the combination which appears in their contribution to the asymptotic value of the effective potential in one of the flat regions

is scale invariant

Page 34: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 35: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 36: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 37: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 38: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 39: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 40: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 41: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

The problem of the transition from the Emergent Phase to Inflation

Page 42: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

The reheating problem, adding fields

The model described before has a problem in principle when we discuss ¨The reheating problem¨, that is how do we get to a hot universe after inflation, the problem arises because the potential that connects the inflationary vacuum with the dark energy vacuum is vey soft, the evolution of the scalar field phi itself will not give rise to much particle creation because there will not be strong oscilla-tions about a minimum, we need to for example

Page 43: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

to add to the model a scale invariant field (the sigma field) for pre reheating

Page 44: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

This we have studied with Ramon Herrera. Now (work in progress),

with Ramon and Pedro Labraña, with the same model to create sigma particles, the preheating, using the fact that effective mass of the sigma is time dependent, through its phi dependence. Reheating is the decay of the sigma to fermions.

For simplicity we take epsilon=b=0, then

Page 45: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 46: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 47: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 48: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 49: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 50: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 51: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 52: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

More effects related to reheating

In this model are being studied with Ramon Herrera, effect of decays of the sigma particles into fermions, etc.

For consistency, alpha has to be big, and thatrequires the ratio of tensor perturbations toscalar perturbations to be small, see next slide.

Page 53: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

A detailed analysis of CMB CONSTRAINTS has being performed.

CMB, RESULTS

Page 54: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 55: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 56: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 57: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 58: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 59: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the
Page 60: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

v

Page 61: Quintessence, NON SINGULAR COSMOLOGIES , pre-reheating, … · TALK BASIC2020, STELLA MARIS BAHAMAS. Subject of this talk: The origin of the universe, if possible 1) avoiding the

Etc.…….. summary

• In the non Riemannian measures models Spontaneous breaking of scale invariance can lead to a unified picture of early inflation and Late very small dark energy.

• For these unified early inflation and Late very small dark energy reheating requires addition of extra fields , for example the sigma fields with time dependent mass producing preheating and fermions to which they decay, producing reheating, NO (OR VERY SMALL) PRIMORDIAL GRAVITY WAVES ARE PREDICTED.

• In the non Riemannian measures models, DARK ENERGY/DARK MATTER UNIFICATION IS VERY NATURAL.