Upload
tanisha-dickerson
View
26
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future. Abhay Deshpande RIKEN BNL Research Center. Stony Brook University April 2 nd , 2003. RIKEN BNL Research Center. Overview. NUCLEON SPIN (Quick review of the Past) Present status and open questions RHIC SPIN (Present) - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
Abhay DeshpandeRIKEN BNL Research Center
Stony Brook UniversityApril 2nd, 2003
RIKEN BNL Research Center
2
OverviewOverviewNUCLEON SPIN (Quick review of the Past)• Present status and open questions
RHIC SPIN (Present)• Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider at BNL• Status of RHIC as polarized proton collider • Recent results with polarized protons at RHIC • Long term perspective for RHIC Spin (pp)
Electron Ion Collider (EIC) at RHIC (Future)• Electron ring at RHIC• Physics at the EIC (mostly pol. e-p and some e-A)• Status & Plans
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
3
Parton Distributions
q
q
g
Nucleon
u u
d
averagehelicity quark)Qq(x 2,
differencehelicity quark )Qq(x 2,
fliphelicty )Qq(x 2,
(well known)
(moderately well known)
(unknown)
onDistributi Gluon)QxG 2,(
(moderately well known)
onPolarizati Gluon )QxG 2,((unknown)
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
4
Our knowledge of spin structure Our knowledge of spin structure functionfunction
F2
g1
Q2 (GeV2) Q2 (GeV2)10510 1021 10103
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
6
Nucleon Spin: Status & Open Nucleon Spin: Status & Open QuestionsQuestions
1/2=(1/2)+G+Lq+Lg
Proton Spin Puzzle remains unsolved!
constrained, need to measure G
SMC, B. Adeva et al. Phys. Rev. D 112002 (1998)
07.023.0)1,( 22
dxQx GeV
5.10.1
1
0
22 0.1)GeV 1,( dxQxgG
Gluon Spin Contribution:
Quark Spin Contribution:
1/2=(1/2)+G+Lq+Lg
Extensive uncertainty studies
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
8
Semi-inclusive DIS…Semi-inclusive DIS…
• In addition to the scattered electron, one measures in addition, the hadronic final state(s)
• Access to flavor separated parton distributions
• HERMES has the most significant data on these
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
9
RHIC Accelerator ComplexRHIC Accelerator Complex
BRAHMS & PP2PP (p)
STAR (p)
PHENIX (p)
AGS
LINACBOOSTER
Pol. Proton Source500 A, 300 s
GeVs
L
50050
onPolarizati%70
cms102 2132max
Spin Rotators
Partial Siberian Snake
Siberian Snakes
200 MeV Polarimeter AGS Internal PolarimeterRf Dipoles
RHIC pC Polarimeters
Absolute Polarimeter (H jet)
2 1011 Pol. Protons / Bunch = 20 mm mrad
RHIC accelerates heavy ions to 100 GeV/A and polarized protons to 250 GeV
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
10
RHIC PolarimetryRHIC Polarimetry
Beam’s View
Si #1
Si #2
Si #4Si #3
left right
down
up
Si #5
Si #6
Carbon filament target (5g/cm2) in the RHIC beam
Measure recoil carbon ions at q~90º
100 keV < Ecarbon< 1 MeVWave-Form Digitizer +FPGA high counting rates (~0.5
MHz) scaler measurement A ~ 310-4 in ~1 minute.
Carbon
ADC values
Arr
ival
tim
e (n
s)
E950 Experiment at AGS (1999) RHIC Polarimetry Now
ANL, BNL, Kyoto, RIKEN/RBRC & Yale Collaboration
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
11
Siberian SnakesSiberian Snakes
STARPHENIX
AGSLINAC
RHIC
Depolarizing Resonance:Spin tune = no. of spin kicksImperfection resonances: --magnet errors & misalignements Intrinsic resonances: --vertical focusing fields
Effect of depolarizing resonances averaged out by rotating spin by large angles on each turn
4 helical dipoles S. snake2 snakes in each ring -- axes orthogonal to each other
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
RIKEN/BNL
12
Successful Operation of the Successful Operation of the SnakeSnake
• Injection with Spin Flipped: Asymmetry Flipped
• Adiabatically Snake on: Horizontal polarization
• Accelerate equivalent to 180o rotation: 180o rotated
Successful SingleSnake Operation !
Blue Ring, Run 1 (2000-2001)
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
13
Polarization in Run 2 (2001-2002)Polarization in Run 2 (2001-2002)
Yellow Ring Blue Ring
First polarized collisions ever at Sqrt(s)=200 GeV
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
14
Why low polarization?Why low polarization?
10% 20% 30%
PAGS
PRHIC SourceImprovement
AGS power generator failure½ ramp up speed2x resonance effect
New AGSSNAKE2004-5
Ramp upSpead
Injection1st Year
Hot News:20th March 2003: ~42% and growing
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
15
Machine Performance Machine Performance ExpectationsExpectations
RUN #proton/bunch
[x109]#bunch Beta*
(m)
Emittance
(m)
Luminosity
1030 cm-2s-1
Pol.
(%)
2001-
2002
70 55 3 25 1.8 15-25
2002-2003
100 112 1 25 16 45-55
2005- ? 112 1 ? ? 70-80
Design 200 112 1 20 80 70
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
16
G :onPolarizati Gluon
RHIC spin programRHIC spin program
Production
),( 0 XgqggALL
Heavy Flavors
),( XbbccggALL
Direct Photon
)( XgqALL
Jet Photon )( XJetgqALL
STA
R +
P
HEN
IX
Spin Transversed
d
d
d
u
u
u
u , , ,
W Production
)( lL lWduA
STAR +PHENIX
STAR +PHENIX
:)Qq(x,ty Transversi 2
:A sAsymmetrie Single N
BRAHMS, STAR, PHENIX, Local Polarimeter
) () (
) (1reaction parton a A
x G
x GALL
pLL
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
17
PHENIX Detector Run 2 PHENIX Detector Run 2 Electrons & photons
( || < 0.35)
Charged tracks(Beam-Beam, Drift Chamber,
Pad Chambers)+
RICH rings+
EM Calorimeter clusters
Muons(1.2 < < 2.2)
Muon Identifier+
Muon TrackerApril 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
18
PHENIX Preliminary
Normalization error of 30% not shown.
On the way to On the way to G… G… 00 spectrum spectrum
PT spectrum over 8 orders of magnitudeComparison with NLO pQCD calculation--CTEQ5M PDFs--Potter, Knielh, Kramer (PKK) fragmentation functions--Uncertainty shown: = pT/2, 2pT
Consistent with data within scaledependence
PHENIX 0 cross section (Preliminary)From RHIC Run 2 (2001-2002)
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
19
PHENIX PreliminaryPHENIX Preliminary
µ+µ-e+e-
Br(J/l+l-) (total) = 226 36 (stat.) 79 (syst.) nb
(p+pJ/X) = 3.8 0.6 (stat.) 1.3 (syst.) µb
Total Cross section vs. the Total Cross section vs. the Color-Evaporation Model predictionColor-Evaporation Model prediction
• CEM Parameters are fixed by fitting low energy data• The result agrees with the CEM prediction at s=200GeV
Rapidity distribution compared Rapidity distribution compared with PHITHIA simulationwith PHITHIA simulation
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
20
STAR Performance
• Time Projection Chamber worked beautifully!
Au-Au Collision at STAR
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
21April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
Single spin asymmetries: L-RSingle spin asymmetries: L-R
Essential for proton spin orientation information at IPs
0 1 2 3 4 5Rapidity
STARFPD
0o CAL
BBC
PHE
NIX
MU
ON
PHE
NIX
CE
NT
RA
L
STA
R T
PC
pp2pp
E704 at Fermilab at s=20 GeV, pT=0.5-2.0 GeV/c: XF 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8PT
Possible Origins: Transversity, Higher Twist,Fragmentation, kT, Orbital. Etc.
22
12 o’clock 12 o’clock PHENIX test setup PHENIX test setup
Hadron Cal Base
Pb
Scintillator
W+Fiber Cal
Post-shower
EM Cal Base
PbWO4
Charge Veto
Neutron Veto
0
RIKEN-BNL Research Center + Kyoto + PHENIX
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
23
AsymmetriesAsymmetriesEMCal ZDC
EMCal EMCal
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
24
STAR Forward rapidity high xSTAR Forward rapidity high xFF 00 AANN
STAR FPD Preliminary DataAssuming AN(CNI)= 0.013pT=1.1 - 2.5 GeV/c
0.0
0.2
0.4
-0.20 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
AN
Systematic uncertainty + - 0.05
0 at s 200p p X GeV 0 at s 20p p X GeV Theory predictions
at pT = 1.5 GeV/c
Anselmino, et al.PRD 60 (1999) 054027.
Anselmino, et al.Phys. Lett. B442 (1998) 470.
Twist 3 effectQiu and Sterman,Phys. Rev. D59 (1998) 014004.
Y.KoikePaNic02
xF ~ E / 100 GeVApril 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
25
Asymmetries seen at RHIC so Asymmetries seen at RHIC so far…far…
0 1 2 3 4 5Rapidity
STARFPD
0o CAL
BBC
PHE
NIX
MU
ON
PHE
NIX
CE
NT
RA
L
STA
R T
PC
pp2pp
XF 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8PT
0
+10 ~ +20%
Charged+1%
Neutron -10%
~0 %
0 ~0%
… will be used to tune the spin rotators in Run 3!
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
26
Upcoming Run FY03Upcoming Run FY03
3 pb-1 and 50%Expectation
G will be probed
STAR JET
PHENIX Charged
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
27
RHIC vs. DIS Kinematic CoverageRHIC vs. DIS Kinematic Coverage
GeVs 200 :RHIC
prompt photon
Xecc
Xebb
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
28
W
Z
) , ( ) , ( ) , ( ) , (
) , ( ) , ( ) , ( ) , (2
22
12
22
1
22
21
22
21
W W W W
W W W W WL
M x u M x d M x d M x u
M x u M x d M x d M x uA
W Production in Polarized
pp Collisions Single Spin Asymmetry
GeV for dominates 20TpWImprovements in muon trigger under Study factor of 50 seems possible and sufficient
Backgrounds from decays of other hadrons produced in pp scattering constitutes the main background.1) Different energies of muons2) Different event topologies
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
29
1. Statistical errors for 800 pb800 pb-1-1
2. Flavor decomposition will reduce the uncertainty in current pol-PDF models.
GS95LO(A): Gehrmann and Stering (Z.Phys.C65(1995)461) BS: pol-PDF set by Bourrely and Soffer (PLB314(1993)132)
Flavor Decomposition
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
30
RHIC Spin Luminosity
Year CM Energy Weeks Int. Lum. Remarks
FY2002 200 GeV 5 5 pb-1(1/15) Single spin asymmetries and CommissioningFY2003 200 GeV 8(3) 9 pb-1 Gluon pol. with 0s & jets(?)
500 GeV ?? Machine Studies, identify Ws.
FY2004 200 GeV 8 160 pb-1 Gluon pol. with g + jet/ TT500 GeV 2 120 pb-1 First ubar,dbar pol. meas..
FY2005 500 GeV 8 480 pb-1 Gluon pol. with g+jet, g,jet+jet, heavy flavor, ubar, dbar pol.
200 GeV 2 48 pb-1 Gluon pol. with g, g+jet, heavy
flavor/TT
FY2006 500 GeV 5 300 pb-1 More statistics200 GeV 5(?) 120 pb-1
FY2007 (?) GeV 10 ?? More statistics
Collider Accelerator Department’s Projections (early ’02)
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
31
Global Analysis for nucleon Spin Structure Functions:
In near future we will have data from:-- Fixed target polarized DIS experiments (l-p scattering) NLO pQCD analysis exists (SMC, SLAC Exp.s & theoretical groups) Constrain polarized quark distributions well, polarized gluons largely
unconstrained. ( See detailed analysis: SMC, PRD 112002 (1998)) Adding eRHIC/EIC data is trivial and possible-- RHIC Spin data on various polarized pp interactions Additional constraints on polarized gluon distributions-- Should use all available data to get the best possible constraints on all
polarized parton distributions.-- Something like CTEQ/GRSV groups but for a global data set to
understand polarized parton distributions-- A. D., W. Vogelsang & M. Stratmann towards a “Global Analysis” See tremendous opportunity for a completely new venture. Will develop
this summer with many others joining us.
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
32
Summary & OutlookSummary & Outlook
• RHIC spin program has begun very successfully! -- Polarized protons were injected, accelerated, stored -- CNI polarimeters have measured non zero asymmetries
indicating polarization at 100 GeV proton beam energies -- Detectors operating - will be 100% completed in 2003-5 -- Single spin asymmetries (1% to 20%) have been measured
• Next run (Apr.03) promises: a first glimpse of G and
-- First trials of 500 GeV CM collisions and W’s produced
• A ~5 year run plan exists for the RHIC spin physics -- to explore G, transversity, q & qbar -- and also perhaps physics beyond SM(?)
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
33
The Electron Ion ColliderThe Electron Ion Collider
A high energy, high intensity polarized electron beam facility at BNL to collide
with the existing RHIC heavy ion and polarized proton beam
would significantly enhance RHIC’s ability to
probe fundamental and universal aspects of QCD
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
34
Deep Inelastic ScatteringDeep Inelastic Scattering
•Observe scattered electron/muon & hadrons in current jets•Observe spectator or remnant jet
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
35
Why Collider in the Future?Why Collider in the Future?
• Past polarized DIS experiments: FIXED TARGET• Collider has distinct advantages
• Better angular separation between scattered lepton & nuclear fragments
Better resolution of electromagnetic probe Recognition of rapidity gap events (recent diffractive physics)• Better measurement of nuclear fragments• Higher center of mass (CoM) energies reachable• Tricky integration of beam pipe – interaction region -- detector
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
36
EIC vs. DIS Facilities (I)EIC vs. DIS Facilities (I)
• New kinematic region
• Ee = 5-10 GeV
• Ep = 30 – 250 GeV
• Sqrt(s) = 20 – 100 GeV
• Kinematic reach of EIC x = 10-4 0.6 Q2 = 0 104 GeV
• High Luminosity L ~1033 cm-2 sec-1
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
37
EIC vs. Other DIS Facilities (II)EIC vs. Other DIS Facilities (II)
Variable beam energy
Variable hadron species
Hadron beam polarization
Large luminosity
TESLA-N
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
38
Scientific Frontiers Open to EICScientific Frontiers Open to EIC
• Nucleon Structure: polarized & unpolarized e-p/n scattering -- Role of quarks and gluons in the nucleon -- Spin structure: polarized quark & gluon distributions -- Unpolarized quark & gluon distributions -- Correlation between partons hard exclusive processes leading to
Generalized Parton Distributions (GPD’s)
• Nuclear structure: unpolarized e-A scattering -- Role of quarks and gluons in nuclei -- e-p vs. e-A physics in comparison
• Hadronization in nucleons and nuclei & effect of nuclear media
-- How do partons knocked out of nucleon in DIS evolve in to colorless hadrons?
• Partonic matter under extreme conditions -- e-A vs. e-p scattering; study as a function of A
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
39
Unpolarized DIS e-p at EICUnpolarized DIS e-p at EIC
• Large(r) kinematic region already covered at HERA but additional studies at EIC are possible & desirable
• Uniqueness of EIC: high luminosity, variable Sqrt(s), He3 beam, improved detector & interaction region
• Will enable precision physics: -- He3 beams neutron structure d/u as x0, dbar(x)-ubar(x)
-- precision measurement of S(Q2)
-- flavor separation (charm and strangeness) -- precision gluon distribution in x=0.001 to x=0.6 -- slopes in dF2/dlnQ2
-- precision photo-production physics -- exclusive reaction measurements -- nuclear fragmentation region measurements
http://www.bnl.gov/eic
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
40
Polarized DIS at EICPolarized DIS at EIC• Spin structure functions g1 (p,n) at low x, high precision
-- g1(p-n): Bjorken Spin sum rule better than 1% accuracy• Polarized gluon distribution function G(x,Q2) -- at least three different experimental methods
• Precision measurement of S(Q2) from g1 scaling violations• Polarized structure function of the photon from photo-
production• Electroweak structure function g5 via W+/- production• Flavor separation of PDFs through semi-inclusive DIS• Deeply Virtual Compton Scattering (DVCS) Gerneralized
Parton Distributions (GPDs)• Transversity• Drell-Hern-Gerasimov spin sum rule test at high • Target/Current fragmentation studies• … etc….
http://www.bnl.gov/eic
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
41
Spin structure function gSpin structure function g1 1 at low at low xx
~5-7 days of data3 years of data
A. Deshpande & V. W. Hughes EIC WS at Yale ‘00
Studies included statistical error & detector smearing to confirm that asymmetries are measurable. No present or future approved experiment will be able to make this measurement
At HERA At EIC/eRHIC
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
42
Low x measurement of gLow x measurement of g11 of of NeutronNeutron
• With polarized He3 or deuteron
• ~ 2 weeks of data at EIC w.r.t. ~ 3 yrs of HERA data
• Compared with SMC(past) & possible HERA data
• If combined with g1 of proton results in Bjorken sum rule test of better than 1% within a couple of months of running (G.Igo & T. Sloan, AD & V. Hughes)
EIC 1 fb-1
A. Deshpande & V. W. Hughes EIC WS at Yale ‘00
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
43
Polarized Gluon Measurement at Polarized Gluon Measurement at EICEIC
• This is the hottest of the experimental measurements being pursued at various experimental facilities:
-- HERMES/DESY, COMPASS/CERN, RHIC-Spin/BNL & E159/E160 at SLAC
• Large kinematic range of EIC allows measurements using:
-- Scaling violations (pQCD analysis at NLO) of g1
-- (2+1) jet production in photon-gluon-fusion (PGF) process -- 2-high pT hadro production in PGF
• Photo-production (real photon) kinematics at EIC -- Single and di-jet production in PGF
-- Open charm production in PGF
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
44
Photon Gluon Fusion at EICPhoton Gluon Fusion at EIC
• “Direct” determination of G -- Di-Jet events -- High pT leading hadrons • High Sqrt(s) at EIC -- no theoretical ambiguities• Both methods tried at HERA
for un-polarized gluon determination & both are successful!
-- NLO calculations exist -- H1 and ZEUS published
results -- Consistent with G
determined from scaling violation F2
Signal: PGF
BackgroundQCD Compton
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
45
G from Scaling Violations of gG from Scaling Violations of g11
• World data (today) allows a NLO pQCD fit to the scaling violations in g1 resulting in the polarized gluon distribution and its first moment.
• SM collaboration, B. Adeva et al. PRD (1998) 112002 G = 1.0 +/- 1.0 (stat) +/- 0.4 (exp. Syst.) +/- 1.4 (theory)• Theory uncertainty dominated by the lack of knowledge of
the shape of the PDFs in unmeasured low x region where EIC data will play a crucial role.
• With approx. 1 week of EIC data, statistical and theoretical uncertainties on G will be reduced by a factor of 3-5
-- coupled to better low x knowledge of spin structure -- less freedom for fits to depend on factorization & re-
normalization scale uncertainty
A. Deshpande, V. W. Hughes & J. Lichtenstadt EIC WS @ Yale’00
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
46
Di-Jet events at EIC: Analysis at Di-Jet events at EIC: Analysis at NLONLO
• Stat. Accuracy for two luminosities
• Detector smearing effects considered
• NLO analysis
A. De Roeck, A. Deshpande, V. W. Hughes & J. Lichtenstadt,G. Radel EIC WS, Yale’00
• Easy to differentiate different G scenarios: factor 3 improvements in ~2 weeks of data• If combined with scaling violations of g1: factors of 5 improvements in uncertainties observed in the same time.• Better than 3-5% uncertainty on G can be expected from EIC
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
47
Polarized PDFs of the PhotonsPolarized PDFs of the Photons
• Photo-production studies with single and di-jet
• Photon Gluon Fusion or Gluon Gluon Fusion (Photon resolves in to its partonic contents)
• Resolved photon asymmetries result in measurements of spin structure of the photon
• Asymmetries sensitive to gluon polarization as well… but we will consider the gluon polarization “a known” quantity!
Direct Photon Resolved Photon
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
48
Will measure the photon PDFs…Will measure the photon PDFs…• Stat. Accuracy
estimated for 1 fb-1 running (2 weeks at EIC)
• Single and double jet asymmetries
• ZEUS acceptance
• Will resolve photon’s partonic spin contents
Direct Photon Resolved Photon
M. Stratmann & W. Vogelsang EIC WS at Yale’01
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
49
A Case for EIC A Case for EIC • The polarized e-N facility at the EIC will enable the polarized DIS
studies of nucleons in a completely new x-Q2 that no other present or future facility will be able to access
• The measurements with variable Sqrt(s) & light polarized nuclei will include:
-- inclusive physics in DIS as well as photo-production regime -- semi-inclusive physics -- exclusive physics leading to DVCS, DES GPDs
• In addition a lot of spin measurements which would study target and current fragmentation for the first time in polarized DIS will be possible…
• And then there is an exciting un-polarized e-A physics program which proposes to measure partonic matter under extreme conditions….
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
50
A Case for EIC … for e-AA Case for EIC … for e-A
• Through its large luminosity, beam energy & beam species variability, the EIC will explore a new universal and fundamental aspects of QCD including looking for the new states of matter at high gluon densities….
• It is natural to assume that these measurements probe the initial conditions in the nuclei for parton distributions… as such this knowledge would be essential to fully understand the QGP which is being pursued at RHIC
• The e-A physics at RHIC will allow for the first time a large number of measurements which have never been performed beyond the fixed target regime… They will be at high energies where pQCD could be used reliably to understand the nuclear structure
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
51
Moving Towards EIC….Moving Towards EIC….• September 2001: EIC grew out of joining of two communities: 1) polarized eRHIC (ep and eA at RHIC) BNL, UCLA, YALE and people from DESY & CERN 2) Electron Poliarized Ion Collider (EPIC) 3-5 GeV e X 30-50 GeV polarized light ions Colorado, IUCF, MIT/Bates, HERMES collaborators
• February 2002: White paper submitted to NSAC Long Range Planning Review Received enthusiastic support as a next R&D project (see: US/DoE Nuclear Report on the Web)
• Steering Committee: 7 members, one each from BNL, IUCF, LANL, LBL, MIT, UIUC, Yale + Contact person
• February 2003: NSAC Subcommittee Recommendation!• ~20 (~13 US + ~7 non-US) Institutes, ~100 physicists + ~40
accelerator physicists• See for more details: EIC Web-page at “http://www.bnl.gov/eic”
(under construction)• Subgroups: Accelerator WG, Physics WG, Detector WG
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
52
Present Collider LayoutPresent Collider Layout• Proposed by BINP & MIT/Bates
presently being studied at BNL• E-ring is ¼ of RHIC ring• Collisions in ONE interaction region• Collision energies 5-10 GeV• Injection linac 2-5 GeV• Lattice based on “superbend”
magnets• Self polarization using Sokolov
Ternov Effect: (14-16 min pol. Time)
• IP12, IP2 and IP4 are possible candidates for collision points
p
e2GeV (5GeV)
2-10 GeV
IP12
IP2
IP4
IP6
IP8
IP10
RHIC
OTHER DESIGNS: Ring with 6 IPS, Linac-Ring, Linac-Re-circulating ring
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
53
A Detector for EICA Detector for EIC A 4 A 4 DetectorDetector
• Scattered electrons to measure kinematics of DIS• Scattered electrons at small (~zero degrees) to tag photo
production• Central hadronic final state for kinematics, jet measurements,
quark flavor tagging, fragmentation studies, particle ID• Central hard photon and particle/vector detection (DVCS)• ~Zero angle photon measurement to control radiative
corrections and in e-A physics to tag nuclear de-excitations
• Missing ET for neutrino final states (W decays)
• Forward tagging for 1) nuclear fragments, 2) diffractive physics
• The e-ring & the IR design The e-ring & the IR design Detector Design Detector DesignApril 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
54
Interaction Region Design….Interaction Region Design….
B. Parker’s (BNL) ProposalBudker/MIT Proposal
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
55
A time line for EIC…A time line for EIC…
“Predictions are very difficult to make, especially when they are about the future” --- A very wise man….
• Proposal/CDR0 by 2005• Expected formal approval 2005-6 Long Range Review• R&D money could start for hardware 2007• Construction of IR and Detector begin 2008• 3-5 years for staged detector and IR construction
without interfering with the RHIC running• First collisions (2010-2011)???
If any one knows how to do this earlier… -- I am listening.
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
56
Detector Design (I)… others Detector Design (I)… others expectedexpected
J. Chwastowski & W. Krasny EIC WS at Yale ‘00
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
57
Detector Design (I)… others Detector Design (I)… others expectedexpected
J. Chwastowski & W. Krasny
Integration with e-ring & IR design is crucial
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
58
Di-Jet at EIC vs. World Data for Di-Jet at EIC vs. World Data for G/G G/G
Good precisionClean measurement in x
range 0.01< x < 0.3Constrains shape of G(x)
Polarization in HERA much more difficult than RHIC.
G. Radel & A. De Roeck
EIC Di-Jet DATA 2fb-1
April 2nd, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
59
Parity Violating Structure Parity Violating Structure Function gFunction g55
For EIC kinematics
• Experimental signature: huge asymmetry in detector (neutrino)• Unique measurement• Unpolarized xF3 measurements at HERA in progress• Will access heavy quark distribution in polarized DIS
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
60
Measurement Accuracy PV gMeasurement Accuracy PV g55 at at EICEIC
Assumes:1. Input GS Pol.
PDfs2. xF3 measured by
then3. 4 fb-1 luminosity
Positrons & Electrons in EIC g5(+)
>> Issues for linac vs. ring design of EIC
J. Contreras, A. Deshpande & A. De Roeck EIC WS at Yale ‘00
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
61
Strange Quark Distributions at Strange Quark Distributions at EICEIC
• After measuring u & d quark polarized distributions…. Turn to s quark (polarized & otherwise)
• Detector with good Particle ID: pion/kaon separation
• Upper Left: statistical errors for kaon related asymmetries shown with A1 inclusive
• Left: Accuracy of strange quark distribution function measurements possible with EIC and HERMES (2003-05) and some theoretical curves on expectations.
E. Kinney & U. Stoesslein EPIC WS at MIT’01
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
62
Highlights of e-A Physics at EICHighlights of e-A Physics at EIC
• Study of e-A physics in Collider mode for the first time• QCD in a different environment
• Clarify & reinforce physics studied so far in fixed target e-A & -A experiments including target fragmentation
QCD in: x > [1/(2mNRN) ] ~ 0.1 (high x)
QCD in: [1/(2mNRA)] < x < [1/(2mNRN)] ~ 0.1 (medium x)
• …. And extend in to a very low x region to explore: saturation effects or high density partonic matter also called
by some as the Color Glass Condensate (CGC) QCD in: x < [1/(2mNRA)] ~ 0.01 (low x)
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
63
DIS in Nuclei is Different! DIS in Nuclei is Different!
Regions of:• Fermi smearing• EMC effect• Enhancement• Shadowing• Saturation?
Regions of shadowing and saturation mostly around Q2 ~1 GeV2
An e-A collision at EIC can be at significantly higher Q2
F2D/F2A
Low Q2!
E665, NMC, SLAC Experiments
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
64
Statistical Precision at EIC for e-Statistical Precision at EIC for e-AA
• High precision at EIC shown statistical errors for 1 pb-1
• Recall: EIC will deliver ~85 pb-1 per day
• NMC data F2(Sn/D)
• EIC’s Q2 range between 1 and 10 GeV2
• Will explore saturation region!
T. Sloan, EIC WS at Yale’00
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
65
Problems & Possible Solutions…Problems & Possible Solutions…• The “low x” problem: High energy behavior of hadronic
cross sections is one of the most intriguing of the problems… Intimately related to the high energy behavior of the parton densities.
• GDLAP & BFKL evolution of PDFs predict a rapid growth at high energies that violates the unitarity constraints.
• Perturbative QCD also provides a way out… the above evolutions exclude the interactions amongst the
partons themselves, which are argued to help keep the rapid rise of cross sections finite resulting in the saturation phenomenon
• These effects however have to be included explicitly (“by hand”) in the calculations (as the evolution prescriptions are linear and explicitly ignore these “cascades”)
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
66
The Saturation Region…The Saturation Region…
• As parton densities grow, standard pQCD break down.
• Even though coupling is weak, physics may be non-perturbative due to high field strengths generated by large number of partons.
• A new state of matter???
An e-A collider/detector experiment with high luminosity and capability to have different species of nuclei in the same detector would be ideal… Need the Electron Ion Collider at BNL
Signatures of the CGS/Saturation: F2s of nuclei, gluon densities….
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
67
Search for new physics:Search for new physics:
• Anomalous parity violation in jet production – Contact Interaction (Scale )
• CDF>1.8 TeV• D0 >2.4 TeV• RHIC Spin Reach ~3.3 TeV
– New gauge boson Z’
P. Taxil & J-M. Virey, Phys. Rev. D(55) 2457 (1999)
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
68
RHIC Spin Physics ProgramRHIC Spin Physics Program
• Spin Structure of Nucleon
>1/2=(1/2)+G+Lq+Lg G: gluon polarization q: Anti-quark polarization
> New Structure Functions• h1: transversity
•NEW tool to study hadronic processes•W,Z @500GeV
•flavor sensitive studies on the structure functions
•cc/bb•Production mechanism
•Spin in fragmentation•Parity,CP violating interaction?
•Test of pQCD •Use asymmetries sensitive ONLY to the higher orders (AN at high PT etc.)
?QCD triumph? or
?beyond ?
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
69
ProductionFlavor Heavy in G
a
AQQgg
LL
XQQpp
LL
xG
xG
xG
xG
xx
)(
2
2
1
1
21
)(
)(
)(
)(
)(
),(
charm
0 Dalitz
pT in GeV/c
Example: Single Electrons
1p
2p
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
70
Transversity Measurements at RHIC
)δq(x,Q
) (x,QgQxq
)(x,QFQxq ,
2
21
2
221
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
,(
,(
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
12
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
- -
diff.)(helicity ),
av.)(helicity , )
- -
(helicity flip!)
),( 2Qxq
helicity proton HH H
h h
On Transversity:
helicity quark h
H h H h
For non-relativistic quarks: ),(),( 22 QxqQxq
Differences provides information on rela-tivistic nature of quarks inside the proton
Soffer’s bound: ),(),(),(2 222 QxqQxqQxq iii
Not small! Possibly !ii qq
),( 2Qxq does not mix with gluons under evolution
First lattice QCD result: 09.056.0 sdu
S. Aoki, M. Doui, T. Hatsuda and Y. Kuramashi Phys.Rev. D56 (1997)433More recently: S. Capitani et.al. Nucl. Phys. B (Proc. Suppl.) 79 (1999) 548
Hard Scattering Amplitudes
Transversity distributions remain last unmeasured leading twist distributions
Incoming proton
probe
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
71
Present and Near Future Upgrades
XppAT
),(
,
:ionFragmentat
ceInterferen
STA
RP
HEN
IX
qqllppATT )( : YanDrell
ionFragmentat ceInterferen Jets, in Collins
: Photon Direct
func.) ionfragmentat func.-ondistributi O (
sObservable
Hq34 103105 TTA
production jet Inclusive
)( XJetppAT
: Jets in Effect Collins
EIC
GeVpb 200,320 1 sLdt EIC fb ,8 1 Ldt
PH
EN
IX
ionFragmentat ceInterferen
Jets in Effect Collins
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
72
Projected Asymmetry
pair vs TT pXpA )(
Small aymmetry below5% but good rate!
MeV MeV
GeV
GeV
950800
4
4
32
22
21
,
1
21
m
pp
E
pbLdt
TT
GeV) Tang 85.0,1(cos mA
)1010Tang sin(sinsincos A
(For 1 week of running)
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
73
Why e-A at a Collider?Why e-A at a Collider?
• Highest fixed target experiments in past: NMC & E665 used secondary muon beams & achieved Sqrt(s) ~ 30 GeV
• HERMES at DESY uses electron beam in gaseous targets but achieves very low Sqrt(s) ~7 GeV
• Solid state fixed targets… target fragments hard to measure Only inclusive measurements
• EIC with large luminosity 1033 cm-2 sec-1 Nucleon-1
~85 pb-1 /day• EIC with variable beam energies can provide:
Sqrt(s)~2060 GeV• EIC with variable species will allow any nucleus from D
to Gold to Uranium…! A detail study of A dependence is possible.
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
74
Hints of the Unusual in NucleiHints of the Unusual in Nuclei
• E866 at FNAL
• 800 GeV protons on fixed target A collisions
• Comparison of Drell-Yan di-muon production vs. production and then decay of J/and
• Nuclear medium clearly plays a role…
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
75
Recent results from RHIC….!Recent results from RHIC….!
Numerous interesting results from:
PHENIXPHOBOSSTAR
All pointing to the significant role the nuclear medium seems to play in nuclear collisions.
We are sure to see more dramatic results in the up coming d-A run…
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
76
Importance of high QImportance of high Q2 2 at low xat low x
• Before HERA for x ~10-4 Q2 << 2QCD
-- Strong coupling constant S(Q2) too large to make reliable pQCD predictions and comparisons with data
• Lack of data with sufficiently high Q2 a significant stumbling block for interpretation of the results from this region.
• At HERA Sqrt(s) ~300 GeV x~10-4 Q2 ~1-10 GeV2
• At HERA S(Q2) << 1 a good approximation… pQCD applicable
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
77
Experimental Hints of the Experimental Hints of the Unusual…Unusual…
• At high Q2 the gluon distribution is well behaved and understood (pQCD framework)
• Intermediate and low Q2 however things are different: Although fits accommodate data, interpretation is problematic
• Relation between sea quarks and gluons seems to break down
)/1ln())/ln(ln(exp~
),(ln/),(ln
22
2222
xQ
QxGQdQxFd
QCD
Is the pQCD approach breaking down? If so why?
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
78
High Parton Density Matter (I)High Parton Density Matter (I)
• For a fixed external probe the number of partons per unit area grows rapidly with increasing energy (decreasing x)
• QCD field strengths grow as (F)2 ~ 1/S
Small coupling large field strengths Non-linearities of theory manifest and significantly
change the effective properties of distributions at high energies
• Calculations indicate that the rapid rise of structure functions due to gluons will saturate (the rise will be tamed!) due to the collective properties of the medium
Perhaps as slowly as ln(1/x)
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
79
A Color Glass Condensate??A Color Glass Condensate??• At small x, partons are rapidly fluctuating gluons interacting
weakly with each other, but still strongly coupled to the high x parton color charges which act as random static sources of COLOR charge
Analogous to spin GLASS systems in condensed matter: a disordered spin state coupled to random magnetic impurities
• Gluon occupation number large, being bosons they can occupy the same state to form a CONDENSATE
Bose Einstein condensate leads to a huge over population of ground states
• A new “state of matter”(??): Color Glass Condensate (CGC) at high energy density would display dramatically different, yet simple properties of glassy condensates
E. Iancu, J.J-MarianL. McLerran,R. Venugopalan, et al.
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
80
Signatures of Saturation/CGC (I)Signatures of Saturation/CGC (I)• Structure functions F2(x,Q2), dF2/dlnQ2, dF2/dlnx
- dF2/dlnQ2 at fixed x at high Q2 is the gluon distribution - CGC vs. conventional pQCD predict very different - Gluon measurements using semi-inclusive… di-jet final states - EIC will differentiate them easily for protons and heavy nuclei
• Longitudinal structure function FL = F2 – 2xF1
- Provide independent gluon distribution measurement - Needs variable electron beam energy Possible at EIC
• Measurement of nuclear shadowing - Quark shadowing (F2
A/A*F2N) in fixed target experiments observed
- Gluon shadowing (GA/A*GN) indirect evidence only… pQCD at NLO - This is expected to be severe at low x and high Q2
- Ideal measurement for EIC
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
81
Signatures of CGC (II)Signatures of CGC (II)• Shadowing and diffraction: Relation between nuclear shadowing and diffraction will be
very different at high parton density media… EIC will study this systematically as a function of A of the nuclei.
• Hard Diffraction Large rapidity gap between current and target fragmentation
region. At HERA 7% cross section diffractive. In e-A at EIC, diffractive processes may contribute 30-40% to
the total cross section.
• Coherent & Inclusive vector meson production: For light vector mesons diff. Cross section. = 0.5 (inclusive) Heavy vector mesons this decreases…finally reaching 1/lnQ2
EIC will measure for different nuclei, Jcross sections
22 ;'*' QCDXMAXeAeAe
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
82
EICEIC AA & dA Physics at RHIC AA & dA Physics at RHIC
• Goal of RHIC is to discover & study the properties of QGP
• CGC has been dubbed as the “initial condition” for gluon distributions in nuclei
• A possible scenario: “QGP is formed when CGC shatters!”
• d-A physics is indeed complementary to e-A physics Differences here would come from experimental
differences and difficulties when one uses “e”, a better structure less probe, compared to “deuteron” as a probe to explore the high density nuclear matter…
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
83
Motivation: Past ExperienceMotivation: Past Experience
Historically, “spin” and “low-x/high-Q2” measurements have had high discovery potential.
Experimental surprises related to both of them have opened unexpected fields of physics and have led us in towards understanding nature that would have not been possible otherwise.
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
84
Motivation: Some spin Motivation: Some spin surprises…surprises…
• Stern & Gehrlach (1921) Space quantization associated with direction
• Goudschmidt & Ulhenbeck (1926): Atomic fine structure & electron spin magnetic moment
• Stern (1933) Proton anomalous magnetic moment 2.79 N
• Kusch(1947) Electron anomalous magnetic moment 1.001190
• Prescott & Yale-SLAC Collaboration (1978) EW interference in polarized e-d DIS, parity non-conservation
• European Muon Collaboration (1989) Spin Crisis/Puzzle• E704, AGS pp scattering, HERMES (1990s) Transverse spin
asymmetries (??)• RHIC Spin (2001) Transverse spin asymmetries (??)
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
85
Motivation: Some Low x Motivation: Some Low x SurprisesSurprises
• Elastic e-p scattering at SLAC (1950s) Q2 ~ 1 GeV2 Finite size of the proton
• Inelastic e-p scattering at SLAC (1960s) Q2 > 1 GeV2 Parton structure of the proton
• Inelastic mu-p scattering off p/d/N at CERN (1980s) Q2 > 1 GeV2 Unpolarized EMC effect, nuclear shadowing?
• Inelastic e-p scattering at HERA/DESY (1990s) Q2 > 1 GeV2 Unexpected rise of F2 at low x Diffraction in e-p
Saturation(??)
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
86
Drell Hern Gerasimov Spin Sum Drell Hern Gerasimov Spin Sum RuleRule
• DHG Sum rule:
• At EIC range: GeV few TeV
• Although contribution from to the
this sum rule is small, the high behavior is completely unknown and hence theoretically biased in any present measurements at:
Jefferson Lab., MAMI, BNL
S. Bass, A. De Roeck & A. Deshpande EIC/HERA WS Erice’01
• Inclusive Photo-production measurement
• Using electron tagger in RHIC ring Q2 ~ 10-6 10-2 GeV2
Sqrt(s) ~ 25 85 GeV
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
87
DVCS/Vector Meson ProductionDVCS/Vector Meson Production
• Hard Exclusive DIS process
• (default) but also vector mesons possible
• Remove a parton & put another back in!
Microsurgery of Baryons!
•Claim: Possible access to skewed or off forward PDFs? Polarized structure: Access to quark orbital angular momentum?
On going theoretical debate… experimental effort just beginning…
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
88
DVCS at EICDVCS at EIC
• DVCS recently observed at ZEUS, H1 & HERMES and Jlab.
• Experimental difficulties being understood
• Potential to get to partonic angular momentum
• Initial studies for EIC begun• Variable beam energy of e
and p beam at EIC will be of great help to explore all aspects of generalized parton distributions!
D. Hasell & R. Milner
5 GeV e X 50 GeV p at EIC
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
89
Relativistic Heavy Ion ColliderRelativistic Heavy Ion Collider
this is testRHIC accelerates heavy ion beams upto and polarized proton
beams to 250 GeV
Two large detectors PHENIX and STAR
have extensive Spin Physics Programs
PHENIX
STAR
GeVA 100
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future
91
RHIC Luminosity FY02RHIC Luminosity FY02
PHENIX 150 nb-1
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
1 3 5 7 9 111315171921232527293133
Days into run (from 12/20/01)
STAR 300 nb-1
Machine Luminosity300 nb-1 /week
Peak 1.8x1030 cm-2s-1
March 20th, 2003 Quest for Nucleon Spin: Past, Present & Future