59
1 PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy Cyclotron/Cyberknife The management of lung cancer: from 3D to SBRT EFEC 18/05/11

PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

  • Upload
    nat

  • View
    21

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

The management of lung cancer: from 3D to SBRT EFEC 18/05/11. PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy Cyclotron/Cyberknife. Plan. Introduction : RT2-D Definition SBRT (History) Technics and results 3-D Linac Rotational Radiotherapy - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

1

PY Bondiau PhD. MD.

Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France

High Precision Radiotherapy

Cyclotron/Cyberknife

The management of lung cancer: from 3D to SBRT

EFEC 18/05/11

Page 2: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

2

PlanPlan

• Introduction : – RT2-D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3-D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– SBRT linac– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

• Introduction : – RT2-D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3-D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– SBRT linac– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

RT3D

SBRT

TechniquesResultsT1 lung cancer

Page 3: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

3

PlanPlan

• Introduction : – RT2-D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3-D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– SBRT linac– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

• Introduction : – RT2-D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3-D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– SBRT linac– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

RT3D

SBRT

Techniques

Page 4: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

4

From 2-D to 3-D [1] 2-D planning era.From 2-D to 3-D [1] 2-D planning era.

– Surgical resection of stage I (T1-2, NO) NSCLC

• 5 year survival rates 60-70%

– Patients medically inoperable treated RT2-D

• Field of irradiation :– primary tumor and regional lymphatics in the ipsilateral

hilum and mediastinum.

– poorly tolerated (with limited pulmonary reserve).

• In a report from the Netherlands, limited “postage stamp”

– Limitations:

• in visualizing the target => difficult to reduce high dose

volume

• selection of beam directions,

• computational algorithms describing deposited dose.

– Surgical resection of stage I (T1-2, NO) NSCLC

• 5 year survival rates 60-70%

– Patients medically inoperable treated RT2-D

• Field of irradiation :– primary tumor and regional lymphatics in the ipsilateral

hilum and mediastinum.

– poorly tolerated (with limited pulmonary reserve).

• In a report from the Netherlands, limited “postage stamp”

– Limitations:

• in visualizing the target => difficult to reduce high dose

volume

• selection of beam directions,

• computational algorithms describing deposited dose.

Page 5: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

5

Result of 2-DResult of 2-D

• Duke experience 1980 1995

• 156 patients with Stage I medically inoperable

• non-small–cell lung cancer

• T1N0 54%, T2N0 46%

• Target– Median dose 64 Gy (50 to 80 Gy)– median size 3 cm (range 0.5 to 8)

• Overall survival – The 2- and 5-year was 39% and 13%

• Studies of dose escalation are warranted !

• Duke experience 1980 1995

• 156 patients with Stage I medically inoperable

• non-small–cell lung cancer

• T1N0 54%, T2N0 46%

• Target– Median dose 64 Gy (50 to 80 Gy)– median size 3 cm (range 0.5 to 8)

• Overall survival – The 2- and 5-year was 39% and 13%

• Studies of dose escalation are warranted !

Page 6: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

6

PlanPlan

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3-D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– SBRT linac– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3-D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– SBRT linac– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

RT3D

SBRT

TechniquesResultsT1 lung cancer

Page 7: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

7

Revolution of 3-DRevolution of 3-D

• Due to CT scan– EMI 1972

• Possibility to multi slice

• 2-D to 3-D

• Due to CT scan– EMI 1972

• Possibility to multi slice

• 2-D to 3-D

CONTOUR:CONTOUR: - Manual - Manual

- Automatic- Automatic

VOLUMES DEFINITIONVOLUMES DEFINITION

GTVGTV CTVCTV PTVPTV VTVT VIVI

Beam ABeam A Beam BBeam B

Beam CBeam C

PTV

Page 8: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

8

Patient

= ?

Contention

MEPTransfert

ContouringBalistic definition

DosimetryDRR

DosimetricCT scan

Mod

ifica

tions

?

Page 9: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

9

Multileaf CollimatorMultileaf Collimator

Collimator

SourceMLC

Page 10: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

10

From 2-D to 3-D: beamsFrom 2-D to 3-D: beams

Page 11: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

11

RT2-D vs RT3-D M.D. Anderson (2005)RT2-D vs RT3-D M.D. Anderson (2005)

• Materials/Methods: – 200 patients stage I radiotherapy alone– 85 pts 3-D conformal radiotherapy

• T1N0 64%, T2N0 36%, squamous cell carcinoma 46%, non-squamous histology 54%

• median dose 66 Gy (45–90.3 Gy), median follow-up 19 months (3–77 months)

– 115 pts 2-D group: median age 69 (range 44–88)

• T1N0 51%, T2N0 49%, squamous cell carcinoma 47%, non-squamous histology 53%

• median dose 64 Gy (40–74 Gy), median follow-up 20 months (1–173 months)

• Materials/Methods: – 200 patients stage I radiotherapy alone– 85 pts 3-D conformal radiotherapy

• T1N0 64%, T2N0 36%, squamous cell carcinoma 46%, non-squamous histology 54%

• median dose 66 Gy (45–90.3 Gy), median follow-up 19 months (3–77 months)

– 115 pts 2-D group: median age 69 (range 44–88)

• T1N0 51%, T2N0 49%, squamous cell carcinoma 47%, non-squamous histology 53%

• median dose 64 Gy (40–74 Gy), median follow-up 20 months (1–173 months)

2-year 5-year p

Overall survivals

3D 68% 36%

2D 47% 10% 0.001

Disease-specific survivals

3D 83% 68 %

2D 62% 29 % 0.008

Local-regional control rates

3D 77% 70%

2D 53% 34% 0.0006

Page 12: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

12

Dose escalationDose escalation

• Hayman (University of Michigan)

• 104 patients with stages I-III treated by 3-DRT

• Dose escalation as high as 102.9 Gy with acceptable

toxicity. – 53 patients had disease progression

• 52% failing distantly

• 8% failing both distantly and PTV

• 2% failing in a distant site, the PTV and a nodal region outside the PTV

• 35% failing within the PTV alone.

• Hayman (University of Michigan)

• 104 patients with stages I-III treated by 3-DRT

• Dose escalation as high as 102.9 Gy with acceptable

toxicity. – 53 patients had disease progression

• 52% failing distantly

• 8% failing both distantly and PTV

• 2% failing in a distant site, the PTV and a nodal region outside the PTV

• 35% failing within the PTV alone.

Page 13: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

13

Defining stereotactic body radiotherapy [1] Defining stereotactic body radiotherapy [1]

• Historical Developpement

– Lars Leksell Gammaknife

– Radiosurgery (1 fraction)

– 1967 Stockholm Karolinska Institut

• Radiosurgery

– High precision RT

– >100 converging mini-beam

– Target : 3 cm max

– millimetric accuracy

– Image matching PET/MRI and CT

– Mechanical accuracy => only intra cranial

• Historical Developpement

– Lars Leksell Gammaknife

– Radiosurgery (1 fraction)

– 1967 Stockholm Karolinska Institut

• Radiosurgery

– High precision RT

– >100 converging mini-beam

– Target : 3 cm max

– millimetric accuracy

– Image matching PET/MRI and CT

– Mechanical accuracy => only intra cranial

Page 14: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

14

Defining stereotactic body radiotherapy [2]Defining stereotactic body radiotherapy [2]

• Beams– From cobalt 60 (gammaknife)

• Specific collimators– Conventional linac

• Specific collimator or multileaf– Dedicated linac (novalis, CK)

• Specific collimator or multileaf

• Raise of image processing matching tools– Integrated image system– Automatic matching

• Real Image = T ( DRR )

• movement = T ( table or device )

• Image processing accuracy replace mechanical accuracy

• Emergence of extra cranial indication

• Multiple fractions

• Beams– From cobalt 60 (gammaknife)

• Specific collimators– Conventional linac

• Specific collimator or multileaf– Dedicated linac (novalis, CK)

• Specific collimator or multileaf

• Raise of image processing matching tools– Integrated image system– Automatic matching

• Real Image = T ( DRR )

• movement = T ( table or device )

• Image processing accuracy replace mechanical accuracy

• Emergence of extra cranial indication

• Multiple fractions

TT

II JJ

Page 15: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

15

Conventional RT

Conventional RT

70

RadiosurgeryRadiosurgery SBRTSBRT

?

Accuracy < cmAccuracy < cm

multiple fractionsmultiple fractions

Accuracy < mmAccuracy < mm

unique fractionunique fraction

Accuracy < mmAccuracy < mm

multiple fractionsmultiple fractions

Page 16: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

16

PlanPlan

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– SBRT linac– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– SBRT linac– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

RT3D

SBRT

Techniques

Page 17: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

17

Rotational radiotherapy [2]: TomotherapyRotational radiotherapy [2]: Tomotherapy

• FDA agreements for HI-ART in 2003

• Statif of 85 cm de diameter

• TomoHD

– TomoHD is a Hi-ART system

packageant

– new linac

– New detector

– Etc…

– system Hi-ART (2009) can be up

graded in TomoHD

– Mobile thomotherapy installed

in a truck

• FDA agreements for HI-ART in 2003

• Statif of 85 cm de diameter

• TomoHD

– TomoHD is a Hi-ART system

packageant

– new linac

– New detector

– Etc…

– system Hi-ART (2009) can be up

graded in TomoHD

– Mobile thomotherapy installed

in a truck

Page 18: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

18

Rotational radiotherapy [3]: VARIAN Rotational radiotherapy [3]: VARIAN

• Rapid’ Arc– On board imager (OBI) and cône beam CT (CBCT)– Image guided radiotherapy– IMRT 360° – treatment time divided by 8 conventional IMRT– Dedicated software (ECLIPSE) or not (VMAT)

• Treatment– OBI and CBCT: positioning of tumor– Image comparision with CT scan– Patient matching– Treatment :1 to 2 rotations of 360°– Continus IMRT (field and intensity)

• Results: publication

• Rapid’ Arc– On board imager (OBI) and cône beam CT (CBCT)– Image guided radiotherapy– IMRT 360° – treatment time divided by 8 conventional IMRT– Dedicated software (ECLIPSE) or not (VMAT)

• Treatment– OBI and CBCT: positioning of tumor– Image comparision with CT scan– Patient matching– Treatment :1 to 2 rotations of 360°– Continus IMRT (field and intensity)

• Results: publication

Page 19: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

19

Rotational radiotherapy [5]: ELEKTARotational radiotherapy [5]: ELEKTA

• Same technique as VARIAN Rapid’arc

• VMAT (Volumetric Modulated ArcTherapy).

• Modification of rotation speed, leaf position, and dose debit

• Fraction of 2mn

• Dedicated software ERG or Monaco Vmat

• Same technique as VARIAN Rapid’arc

• VMAT (Volumetric Modulated ArcTherapy).

• Modification of rotation speed, leaf position, and dose debit

• Fraction of 2mn

• Dedicated software ERG or Monaco Vmat

Page 20: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

20

PlanPlan

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– Linac SBRT– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– Linac SBRT– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

RT3D

SBRT

Techniques

Page 21: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

21

AXESSE (ELEKTA) AXESSE (ELEKTA)

– Conventional RT and SBRT

– High energy linac (4, 25 MV)

– Isocenter accuracy: < 1 mm

– Multileaf collimator (80 leaf)

– Cone Beam CT »

• Images– 2 XR at 90°

– 2 flat panel (40x40 cm, pxl ? mm²)

– Option VMAT

– Gating ABC « Active Breathing Coordinator »

– Conventional RT and SBRT

– High energy linac (4, 25 MV)

– Isocenter accuracy: < 1 mm

– Multileaf collimator (80 leaf)

– Cone Beam CT »

• Images– 2 XR at 90°

– 2 flat panel (40x40 cm, pxl ? mm²)

– Option VMAT

– Gating ABC « Active Breathing Coordinator »

Page 22: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

22

SBRT: Local controlSBRT: Local control

Page 23: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

23

Papers Pts Tumors Survival Doses (Gy) Toxicity

Takeda et al

63 (11NoPath)

Stade IA : 38Stade IB : 25

At 3 years :-Stade IA : 90% (p=0,09%)-Stade IB : 63% (p=0,09%)At 5 years without pathology : -Stade IA : 82% (p=0,10%)-Stade IB : 63% (p=0,10%)

50 Gy in 5 fr

Uematsu et al

45 (66 t)

Loc I (IA : 9, IB : 11, IIA : 3Loc II : 26

Rate of de Survival ( ?) : 75 % 30 to 75 Gy in 3 à 15 fr

Timmerman et al

55 Primitives : stade IAbdominal pressure

global Survival at 2 years  : 54% 60 to 66 Gy in 3 fr 20% (includes 6 possible grade 5 cases)

Onishi et al

245 Primitives :-Stade IA : 155-Stade IB : 90

SG at 3 years  : 56%, at 5 years 47%specific at 3 and 5 years  : 78%5 ans survival if BED ≥ 100 Gy : -Stade IA : 90%-Stade IB : 84%

18 to 84 Gy in 1 à 25 fr

5.4% lung1% oesophagitis1.2% dermatitis

Wulf et al 61 Loc I : 20 (IA : 2, IB : 10, IIA (T3) : 8Loc II :51

Primitives : Survival at 1 years  : 52% Survival at 5 years  : 18%Mets : Survival at 1 years  : 85%

26 to 37,5 Gy in 1 à 3 fr

P. Baumann2009

57 Abdominal pressure if neededPeripheral

3 year 60% 45 Gy/3 fr 26% grade 32% grade 4

F.B. Zimmerman

68 Peripheral or central 3 year 53% 24–40 Gy/3–5 fr 6% pneumonitis3% rib fracture

R.C. McGarry

47 Abdominal pressurePeripheral or central

24 Gy/3 fr escalating to 72 Gy/3 fr

11% lung2% pericardial

J.Y. Chang

27 4-D CT planningCentral or superior

40–50 Gy/4 fr 11% grade 2–3 pneumontis/pain

Page 24: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

24

Toxicity Toxicity

• Depends Modalities (?)

• Oesophagitis

• Dermatitis

• Pneumonitis

• Rib fracture

• Pericardial

• Chest wall pain

• Depends Modalities (?)

• Oesophagitis

• Dermatitis

• Pneumonitis

• Rib fracture

• Pericardial

• Chest wall pain

Page 25: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

25

RTOG 0236 [1]RTOG 0236 [1]

• A Phase II SBRT for Patients with Medically Inoperable Stage I/II Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer

• R. Timmerman JAMA. 2010;303(11):1070-76. – 59 patients T1-T2N0M0 non-small cell tumors (<5 cm) – not allow surgical treatment.– May 2004 to October 2006– data analyzed August 2009– 1 end point: 2-year actuarial primary tumor control– 2 end points: disease-free survival

• 55 evaluable pts with Median

follow-up of 34.4 months

• A Phase II SBRT for Patients with Medically Inoperable Stage I/II Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer

• R. Timmerman JAMA. 2010;303(11):1070-76. – 59 patients T1-T2N0M0 non-small cell tumors (<5 cm) – not allow surgical treatment.– May 2004 to October 2006– data analyzed August 2009– 1 end point: 2-year actuarial primary tumor control– 2 end points: disease-free survival

• 55 evaluable pts with Median

follow-up of 34.4 months

Page 26: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

26

RTOG 023 [2]RTOG 023 [2]

• Presented in 51th ASTRO an update of RTOG 0236– Only 1 primary tumor failure

– Estimated 3-year primary tumor control rate: 97.6%.

– Local-regional control rate: 87.2%

– Disease-free survival at 3 years: 48.3%

– Overall survival at 3 years: 55.8%

– median overall survival: 48.1 months.

– Primary tumour control at three years improved from 88 to 98%

• Toxicity– grade 3 in 7 patients (12.7%), grade 4 in 2 patients (3.6%)

• Conclusion– Median survival had not yet been reached (It had not been anticipated that this would happen)

– Patient follow up has been amended from a total of 4 years to include annual follow up

– Possibly be attributed to image-guidance techniques into the SBRT process.

• Presented in 51th ASTRO an update of RTOG 0236– Only 1 primary tumor failure

– Estimated 3-year primary tumor control rate: 97.6%.

– Local-regional control rate: 87.2%

– Disease-free survival at 3 years: 48.3%

– Overall survival at 3 years: 55.8%

– median overall survival: 48.1 months.

– Primary tumour control at three years improved from 88 to 98%

• Toxicity– grade 3 in 7 patients (12.7%), grade 4 in 2 patients (3.6%)

• Conclusion– Median survival had not yet been reached (It had not been anticipated that this would happen)

– Patient follow up has been amended from a total of 4 years to include annual follow up

– Possibly be attributed to image-guidance techniques into the SBRT process.

Page 27: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

27

PlanPlan

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– Novalis– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– Novalis– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

RT3D

SBRT

Techniques

Page 28: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

28

Vero [1]Vero [1]

• System launched ESTRO 2010 meeting

• MITSUBSHI and BRAINLAB collaboration

• Combination of versatile imaging capabilities

– real-time tumour tracking –

• Statif of 4.17 m (1.25 m) 11 tons– Linac 6MV,

– micro-multileaf of 60 leafs of 5mm at isocenter.

– Field of 15X15 cm

• O-ring can rotate ±60° about its vertical axis – isocentre accuracy of 0.1 mm.

• System launched ESTRO 2010 meeting

• MITSUBSHI and BRAINLAB collaboration

• Combination of versatile imaging capabilities

– real-time tumour tracking –

• Statif of 4.17 m (1.25 m) 11 tons– Linac 6MV,

– micro-multileaf of 60 leafs of 5mm at isocenter.

– Field of 15X15 cm

• O-ring can rotate ±60° about its vertical axis – isocentre accuracy of 0.1 mm.

Page 29: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

29

Vero [2]Vero [2]

• Imaging– Two orthogonal kV attached to the O-

ring at 30 i/s (fluoroscopy)– Cône Beam CT and software «

HYBRID ARC », VERO can do rotational IMRT

– Integrated ExacTrac infrared

• Specific software: BRAINLAB iPLAN

• Systems– 4 Vero in Japan

– 1 European installation : UZ Brussels University Hospital

– 300 patients already treated

• Publicated Results: no

• Imaging– Two orthogonal kV attached to the O-

ring at 30 i/s (fluoroscopy)– Cône Beam CT and software «

HYBRID ARC », VERO can do rotational IMRT

– Integrated ExacTrac infrared

• Specific software: BRAINLAB iPLAN

• Systems– 4 Vero in Japan

– 1 European installation : UZ Brussels University Hospital

– 300 patients already treated

• Publicated Results: no

Page 30: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

30

PlanPlan

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– Novalis– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– Novalis– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

RT3D

SBRT

Techniques

Page 31: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

31

1 - Patient Positioning1 - Patient Positioning

• Robotic couch– 3 rotations

– 3 translations

• Numeric X Rays– 2 sources of X Rays with 2 flat

panels at 90°

– Automatic.

– Discontinued

– 41 * 41 cm 1024 *1024 pxl

– Pxl : 0.4 mm²

• Robotic couch– 3 rotations

– 3 translations

• Numeric X Rays– 2 sources of X Rays with 2 flat

panels at 90°

– Automatic.

– Discontinued

– 41 * 41 cm 1024 *1024 pxl

– Pxl : 0.4 mm²

Page 32: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

32

Page 33: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

33

Page 34: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

34

Page 35: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

35

Page 36: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

36

Page 37: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

37

Page 38: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

38

Page 39: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

39

Page 40: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

40

Page 41: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

41

Page 42: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

42

Page 43: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

43

Fiducial or not?

• For small tumor (<1,5cm) near spine/mediastinum : we prefer fiducial– Endoscopic– CT scan

• For small tumor (<1,5cm) near spine/mediastinum : we prefer fiducial– Endoscopic– CT scan

Page 44: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

44

Mvt thorax/tumor Mvt thorax/tumor Mvt thorax/tumor Mvt thorax/tumor

X

Y

Z

Diodsthorax

Fiducials

Time

Page 45: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

45

Page 46: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

46

StudyStudy

• Stage I NSCLC (T1 or T2 N0 M0).

• Histology proven : Only ADK and SCC lesions were included.

• For mets : primitive tumor controlled and slow growing.

• Maximal diameter : 6 cm.

• No other concomitant or postradiation treatment

• Indication of CK : Clinical case discussion

• Exclusion if pulmonary atelectasis, infection or pneumonitisproblem of interpretation

• No MRI if no neurologic symptom

• Stage I NSCLC (T1 or T2 N0 M0).

• Histology proven : Only ADK and SCC lesions were included.

• For mets : primitive tumor controlled and slow growing.

• Maximal diameter : 6 cm.

• No other concomitant or postradiation treatment

• Indication of CK : Clinical case discussion

• Exclusion if pulmonary atelectasis, infection or pneumonitisproblem of interpretation

• No MRI if no neurologic symptom

Page 47: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

47

Treatments Treatments

• Millimetric margins

• Tumor tracking during breathing

• CTV=GTV+5mm

• Optical positioning system– « Synchrony » Software

• Treatment time: 45-75 min

• Millimetric margins

• Tumor tracking during breathing

• CTV=GTV+5mm

• Optical positioning system– « Synchrony » Software

• Treatment time: 45-75 min

50-75 Gy5 Fr

60 Gy / 3 F

Page 48: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

48

ResultsResults

• Median follow up 18.7 months

• Mean fraction duration 65 min (G4)

• First fraction longer than the others

• Median follow up 18.7 months

• Mean fraction duration 65 min (G4)

• First fraction longer than the others

Nb patient Nb Fr

3 1

78 3

5 4

42 5

Page 49: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

49

ResultsResults

• Distant reccurence 62 (46.97%)

• and 31 (23.48%) death

• Local recurrence 18 (13.64%)

• and 8 (6.06%) death

• Distant reccurence 62 (46.97%)

• and 31 (23.48%) death

• Local recurrence 18 (13.64%)

• and 8 (6.06%) death

Page 50: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

50

Evaluation at 2 years Evaluation at 2 years ((RECIst criteria)RECIst criteria)Evaluation at 2 years Evaluation at 2 years ((RECIst criteria)RECIst criteria)

During the year : 10 Distant progression,

2 death of other cause, 2 NA

CR 30 %

PR 38 %

ST 18 %

L prg 14 %

During the year : 10 Distant progression,

2 death of other cause, 2 NA

CR 30 %

PR 38 %

ST 18 %

L prg 14 %

86 %86 %86 %86 %

Page 51: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

51

CT : Time EvolutionCT : Time Evolution

16/02/07

31/07/07

30/11/07

16/04/08

02/10/08

28/03/07

Matched images

12/03/10

14/09/09

20/09/10

Page 52: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

52

PET evolutionPET evolution

24 January 08 05 January 10

Matched images

Page 53: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

53

LRI : Results [1]LRI : Results [1]

• Recurrences: – same lobe 88.2% (15) same lung 11.8% (2).

• Recurrences: – same lobe 88.2% (15) same lung 11.8% (2).

Previous treatment

CK treatment

Total

Page 54: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

54

Papers Patients Tumor Survival Doses (Gy)

Collins et al 24 Primitives :-Stade I : 15Mets  :-Dont 5 CBNPC

A 1 years  : Primitives : 87%Mets : 78%

45 to 60 Gy in 3 fractions

Pennathur et al 32 Loc I : 27 ( StI : 11, II : 2, III : 2, IV : 1-Recurence : 11Mets  : 5

A 1 year  : Primitives :-Stade I-IV : 61%-Stade I : 91%-Recurrence 89 %Mets  : 80%

20 Gy in 1 fraction

Christie et al 21 Stade I survival at 1 year : 90% 60 Gy in 3 fractions

W.T. Brown, 59 Peripheral or central 90% free from persistent or recurrent disease

15 to 67.5 Gy/1–5 fractions

van der Voort van Zyp

70 Synchrony respiratory tracking system

2 years 96% (60 Gy) or 78% (45 Gy) 45 or 60 Gy/3 fractions

Bondiau et al 53 (60T) 63% Stage I37% Metastatic lesion

2 years 86% 60 Gy in 3 fr or75 to 60 in 5 fr

Cyberknife resultsCyberknife results

Page 55: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

55

Comparison to surgeryComparison to surgery

• International Protocol Phase III

• J. Roth (MD Anderson)

• Randomisation : CK vs

surgery

– T1-2 N0 M0,

– PET?

– Margin discussion 1cm?

– Dose discussion

• International Protocol Phase III

• J. Roth (MD Anderson)

• Randomisation : CK vs

surgery

– T1-2 N0 M0,

– PET?

– Margin discussion 1cm?

– Dose discussion

Page 56: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

56

PlanPlan

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– Novalis– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

• Introduction : – RT2D– Definition SBRT (History)

• Technics and results– 3D Linac– Rotational Radiotherapy– Novalis– Vero– Cyberknife

• Conclusion

RT3D

SBRT

Techniques

Page 57: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

57

Nb beam Positioning Accuracy GTV irradiation DoseResults

LC

RT2D 6 Manual/ laser cm margin 66-70 30 % at 3

years

Conformal 3D 6-16 Manual/ laser cm Margin / Gating 66-70 60-70 % at 2

years

Rotational RT

Tomotherapy

Rapid arc

Vmat

360°

CT

(pxl>1,2mm²)

< cmMargin 66-70

Escalating dose study in progress

Accel/SBRT Novalis

Axess< 20 Beam 2 Xray

< mmGating ? 70-90% at 3

years

Vero Arc/Beam 2 Xray< mm

Tracking ? ? No

Cyberknife >1502 Xray

automatic< mm Tracking

150 Gy

BED

90-95% at 2 years

Compare Surgery

Page 58: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

58

Conclusion: SBRT Conclusion: SBRT

• Overall accuracy < 1 mm

• Breaks through in the treatment lung tumor

• Hypofractionation– 1-5 fractions (1 week)

– "Rapid return to normal life"

• Major interest ++ lung tumor Stage 1 ( # surgery) Standard

of care of patient medically inoperable?

++ after pneumonectomy

++ of the re-irradiation capacity : Lung?

Clinical research : stage III boost?

• Overall accuracy < 1 mm

• Breaks through in the treatment lung tumor

• Hypofractionation– 1-5 fractions (1 week)

– "Rapid return to normal life"

• Major interest ++ lung tumor Stage 1 ( # surgery) Standard

of care of patient medically inoperable?

++ after pneumonectomy

++ of the re-irradiation capacity : Lung?

Clinical research : stage III boost?

RTCT 2008on CK-CT scan 2010

CK 2010 RTCT 2008CK 2010

Page 59: PY Bondiau PhD. MD. Centre Antoine Lacassagne. Nice. France High Precision Radiotherapy

59

Merci

G. ANGELIER (PhD)K. BENEZERY (MD)J. THARIAT (MD)

G. PALAMINI (radiotherapist)B. GRANIER (Secretary)S. MARCHAL (CR) P.Y. BONDIAU (MD. PhD)