Upload
janaagraha
View
218
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
1/13
Proper URban Electoral Lists
P U R E
RESULTS OF JANAAGRAHA’SRESEARCH WORK TO ASCERTAINTHE QUALITY OF THE VOTER LISTIN DELHI
January 2015
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
2/13
HOW THE ERRORS WERE
CAPTURED...
To capture the errors in Delhi’s voter rolls,
A voter list survey was done:
Voter-list Survey
• Voter list used as a sampling base
• Try to nd citizens on the list at their address
• Citizens not found at address listed require deletion. Could be
because:
• Citizen has shifted
• Citizen is dead
• Citizen is disenfranchised (in prison)
• Citizen is repeated on list
• Errors with registration details captured for citizens found
• Addresses not found in some cases
For the survey, 3210 citizens were approached in 408 Polling Parts spread across 8 Assembly Constituencies; a total effective sample size of 2971 was achieved afteraccounting for refusals and ‘door locked’. The ACs were a proportional mix of inner and outer as well as geographically spread across Delhi. Sampling was done in arandom manner to ensure valid representation of the 18+ voter population. The condence level of the sample is 95% with an interval of 1.8%. Research was undertakenusing electoral rolls published in October 2014. The sample was cross-checked with the summary revisions published on the 5th of January 2015 and the ndings wererevised on the basis of alignment with the revised rolls.
% Deletions
% Address not found
% Errors with registration details
% No ErrorS
Voter list hygiene factors
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
3/13
Extent of correctionsdone by the ECIAccording to the study, a certain proportion of
deletions were required to the rolls. The databelow highlights this requirement, compared to the
proportion of deletions made by the ECI in the last
summary revisions.
1. Deletions include shifted/dead/disenfranchised/repeats and address not found
2. Based on 96,640 deletions noted by the CEO, Delhi, Chandra Bhushan Kumar; Source - “89 thousand cases of multiple
entries found in Delhi electoral rolls” - Available: http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-89-thousand-cases-of-multiple-
entries-found-in-delhi-electoral-rolls-2050013 (accessed date - 22/01/2015).
3. Study samples were derived using the October 2014 ECI rolls
4. Based on ECI summary revisions that were published on the 5th of January 2015
5. The survey found 5 citizens at their address (correctly) who, after the summary revisions, are now marked as ‘Shifted’.
The ECI also corrected 3 from the samples as ‘duplications’ which we have accounted for as corrected.
As per study
sample (N)3Out of sample, number
corrected in the ECI
Summary Revision4
% of sample
corrected
989 245 2.4%
221 2 0.9%
DELETIONS¹
ERRORS
WITH DETAILS
Summary Revisions
DELETIONS¹
% Deletions
done2
0.7%
% Deletionsrequiredin Delhi
32.5%
The study was done on the basis of voter rollspublished on October 15, 2014 but summaryrevisions were published by the ECI on
January 5, 2015.
Sample CorrectionsTo accommodate for these revisions, the study sample was
cross checked against revised rolls and ndings were adjusted
accordingly
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
4/13
11%Addressnot found
7%Errors withregistrationdetails
60%No Errors
22%Deletions
Repeats:
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
5/13
3%Addressnot found
4%Errors withregistrationdetails
69%No Errors
24%Deletions
Repeats: 0%
Shifted: 22%
Deceased: 2%
Disenfranchised (in prison): 0%
Trinagar Assembly
ConstituencyWhat does this MEAN forvoter NUMBERS inTRINAGAR?¹
1,63,851
number of REGISTEREDVOTERS in TRINAGAR²
Deletions: 38632
Address not found: 5328
Errors with registration details: 6661
No Errors: 113230
Repeats: 0
Shifted: 35967
Deceased: 2664
Disenfranchised (in prison): 0
Voters to be Deleted³
43,960
= 20,000
1. Percentage of errors projected to the voting population ofTrinagar
2. Proportional calculation for Trinagar made using data from thenal Summary Revisions, 2014 projected to total Delhi voterpopulation from Election Commission of India, Jan 2015
3. Includes shifted, dead, repeated, disenfranchised and addressnot found
* Due to rounding, percentages may not sum to 10 0%
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
6/13
13%Addressnot found
14%Errors withregistrationdetails
50%No Errors
22%Deletions
Repeats: 0.5%
Shifted: 21%
Deceased: 0.5%
Disenfranchised (in prison): 0%
What does this MEAN forvoter NUMBERS inGANDHI NAGAR?¹
1,68,788
number of REGISTEREDVOTERS in GANDHI NAGAR²
Deletions: 37945
Address not found: 21371
Errors with registration details: 24424
No Errors: 85048
Repeats: 872
Shifted: 36200
Deceased: 872
Disenfranchised (in prison): 0
= 20,000
Gandhi Nagar Assembly
Constituency
1. Percentage of errors projected to the voting population ofGandhi Nagar
2. Proportional calculation for Gandhi Nagar made using data fromthe nal Summary Revisions, 2014 projected to total Delhi voterpopulation from Election Commission of India, Jan 2015
3. Includes shifted, dead, repeated, disenfranchised and addressnot found
* Due to rounding, percentages may not sum to 100 %
Voters to be Deleted³
59,316
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
7/13
19%Addressnot found
3%Errors withregistrationdetails
53%No Errors
25%Deletions
Repeats: 1%
Shifted: 24%
Deceased: 1%
Disenfranchised (in prison): 0%
OKHLA Assembly
ConstituencyWhat does this MEAN forvoter NUMBERS inOKHLA?¹
2,62,261
number of REGISTEREDVOTERS in OKHLA²
Deletions: 66319
Address not found: 48986
Errors with registration details: 9043
No Errors: 137913
Repeats: 2261
Shifted: 61797
Deceased: 2261
Disenfranchised (in prison): 0
Voters to be Deleted³
1,15,304
= 20,000
1. Percentage of errors projected to the voting population of Okhla2. Proportional calculation for Okhla made using data from the
nal Summary Revisions, 2014 projected to total Delhi voterpopulation from Election Commission of India, Jan 2015
3. Includes shifted, dead, repeated, disenfranchised and addressnot found
* Due to rounding, percentages may not sum to 10 0%
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
8/13
9%Addressnot found
2%Errors withregistrationdetails
67%No Errors
23%Deletions
Repeats: 0%
Shifted: 22%
Deceased:
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
9/13
14%Addressnot found
13%Errors withregistrationdetails
56%No Errors
17%Deletions
Repeats: 0%
Shifted: 16%
Deceased: 1%
Disenfranchised (in prison):
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
10/13
7%Addressnot found
6%Errors withregistrationdetails
78%No Errors
9%Deletions
Repeats: 0%
Shifted: 9%
Deceased:
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
11/13
15%Addressnot found
9%Errors withregistrationdetails
55%No Errors
22%Deletions
Repeats: 0%
Shifted: 21%
Deceased: 1%
Disenfranchised (in prison): 0%
PALAM Assembly
ConstituencyWhat does this MEAN forvoter NUMBERS inPALAM?¹
2,26,649
number of REGISTEREDVOTERS in PALAM²
Deletions: 48942
Address not found: 33793
Errors with registration details: 19810
No Errors: 124103
Repeats: 0
Shifted: 47194
Deceased: 1748
Disenfranchised (in prison): 0
Voters to be Deleted³
82,735
= 20,000
1. Percentage of errors projected to the voting population of Palam2. Proportional calculation for Palam made using data from the
nal Summary Revisions, 2014 projected to total Delhi voterpopulation from Election Commission of India, Jan 2015
3. Includes shifted, dead, repeated, disenfranchised and addressnot found
* Due to rounding, percentages may not sum to 10 0%
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
12/13
5%Addressnot found
6%Errors withregistrationdetails
56%No Errors
33%Deletions
Repeats:
8/20/2019 PURE Electoral Roll Lists - Delhi
13/13
Overview
TRINAGAR
ROHINI
GOKALPUR
OKHLASANGAM
VIHAR
GANDHINAGAR
PALAMR K PURAM
Deletions 22% 24% 22% 25% 23% 17% 9% 22% 33%
Addressnot found
11% 3% 13% 19% 9% 14% 7% 15% 5%
Errors withregistration
details
7% 4% 14% 3% 2% 13% 6% 9% 6%
No errors 60% 69% 50% 53% 67% 56% 78% 55% 56%
D e l h i
T r i n a g a r
G a n d h i
N a g a r
O k h l a R
K
P u r a m
G o k a l p u r
R o h i n i
P a l a m
S a n g a m
V i h a r
How do the assembly
constituencies compareto each other?