78

Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan
Page 2: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Pune Branch of WIRC of

the ICAI

Pune Branch of WIRC of

the ICAI

Page 3: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Issues relating to TDS compliance with

special reference to special reference to SECTION 234 E

CA Chandrashekhar V. Chitale

Issues relating to TDS compliance with

special reference to special reference to SECTION 234 E

CA Chandrashekhar V. Chitale

Page 4: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan
Page 5: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Issues relating to TDS

compliance

Issues relating to TDS

compliance

Page 6: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Application for No TDS

• Section 197

• No TDS or Lower TDS

• Application in Form No. 13• Application in Form No. 13

• Can it be made before commencement

of Financial Year?

• Approval?

Application for No TDS

No TDS or Lower TDS

Application in Form No. 13Application in Form No. 13

Can it be made before commencement

Page 7: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Application for No TDS

• The assessee was entitled to file an

application for a certificate of deduction

at a lower rate even before the at a lower rate even before the

commencement of the financial year in

which that tax is to be deducted.

Indus Towers Ltd. v. ACIT (TDS)

(2014) 220 Taxmann 402 (Delhi)(HC)

Application for No TDS

The assessee was entitled to file an

application for a certificate of deduction

at a lower rate even before the at a lower rate even before the

commencement of the financial year in

which that tax is to be deducted.

Indus Towers Ltd. v. ACIT (TDS)

(2014) 220 Taxmann 402 (Delhi)(HC)

Page 8: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Application for No TDS

• 28AA. (1) The Assessing Officer, on an

application made by a person under sub

(1) of rule 28, may issue a certificate in (1) of rule 28, may issue a certificate in

accordance with the provisions of sub

(1) of section 197 for deduction of tax at

source at the rate or rates calculated in the

manner specified below :

Application for No TDS

(1) The Assessing Officer, on an

application made by a person under sub-rule

(1) of rule 28, may issue a certificate in (1) of rule 28, may issue a certificate in

accordance with the provisions of sub-section

(1) of section 197 for deduction of tax at

source at the rate or rates calculated in the

manner specified below :

…….. Contd.

Page 9: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Application for No TDS

• 28AA. (1)

• (i) at such average rate of tax as determined

by the total tax payableby the total tax payable

as reduced by the sum of advance tax

already paid and tax already deducted at

source, as a percentage of the payment

referred to in section 197 for which the

application under sub-

been made; or

Application for No TDS

at such average rate of tax as determined

ble on estimated income, ble on estimated income,

as reduced by the sum of advance tax

already paid and tax already deducted at

source, as a percentage of the payment

referred to in section 197 for which the

rule (1) of rule 28 has

Page 10: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Application for No TDS

• 28AA. (1)

• (ii) at the average of the average rates of tax

paid by the assessee in the last three years;paid by the assessee in the last three years;

• whichever is higher.

Application for No TDS

at the average of the average rates of tax

paid by the assessee in the last three years;paid by the assessee in the last three years;

Page 11: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 201

• S.195 : TDS Failure

• If no income arose to recipient then notices to payer for TDS default u/s. notices to payer for TDS default u/s. 201 & disallowance under section 40(a)(ia)are bad

• Samsung India Electronics Pvt. Ltd. v.

DDIT (Delhi) (HC). www.itatonline.org

Interest S. 201

S.195 : TDS Failure

If no income arose to recipient then notices to payer for TDS default u/s. notices to payer for TDS default u/s. 201 & disallowance under section

Samsung India Electronics Pvt. Ltd. v.

DDIT (Delhi) (HC). www.itatonline.org

Page 12: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 201

• Order cannot be passed after 4 years

have elapsed

• Time limit is counted from the • Time limit is counted from the

assessment year and not from he date

of survey

• STATE BANK OF INDIA vs. ACIT

• (2007) 106 ITD 589 (Mumbai)

Interest S. 201

Order cannot be passed after 4 years

Time limit is counted from the Time limit is counted from the

assessment year and not from he date

STATE BANK OF INDIA vs. ACIT

(2007) 106 ITD 589 (Mumbai)

Page 13: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 201

• Valuation of perquisite

• Standard rent charged without exception

• No perquisite considered• No perquisite considered

• The employer is expected to act

honestly and fairly. Unless any inference

can be drawn that the employer did not

act honestly and fairly, it cannot be said

that he has not deducted proper tax

Interest S. 201

Valuation of perquisite – furniture

Standard rent charged without exception

No perquisite consideredNo perquisite considered

The employer is expected to act

honestly and fairly. Unless any inference

can be drawn that the employer did not

act honestly and fairly, it cannot be said

that he has not deducted proper tax.

Page 14: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 201

• Require - a broad picture of estimated

income, which is subjected to tax. The

Department must show on record, that Department must show on record, that

non-deduction of tax at source was mala

fide on the part of the employer.

• Therefore, no interest charged u/s 201

• STATE BANK OF INDIA vs. ACIT

• (2007) 106 ITD 589 (Mumbai)

Interest S. 201

a broad picture of estimated

income, which is subjected to tax. The

Department must show on record, that Department must show on record, that

deduction of tax at source was mala

fide on the part of the employer.

Therefore, no interest charged u/s 201

STATE BANK OF INDIA vs. ACIT

(2007) 106 ITD 589 (Mumbai)

Page 15: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 201

• Where action of assessee for not

deducting tax at source on conveyance

allowance paid to employees was based

on bona fide belief, assessee on bona fide belief, assessee

be treated as assessee in default liable

to interest under section 201(1A)

• CIT v. I.T.C. Ltd.

• (2013) 263 CTR 241 (All.)(HC)

Interest S. 201

Where action of assessee for not

deducting tax at source on conveyance

allowance paid to employees was based

on bona fide belief, assessee could noton bona fide belief, assessee could not

be treated as assessee in default liable

to interest under section 201(1A)

(2013) 263 CTR 241 (All.)(HC)

Page 16: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 201

• Deduction under ss. 80G and 80GGA not admissible u/s. 192

• AO justified in charging s. 201 int.• AO justified in charging s. 201 int.

• Evidence of filing of returns by the employees and payment taxes

• AO shall reduce int. u/s. 201

• MAHENDRA TEC. INTER COLLEGE115 ITD 411 (All)

Interest S. 201

Deduction under ss. 80G and 80GGA not admissible u/s. 192

AO justified in charging s. 201 int.AO justified in charging s. 201 int.

Evidence of filing of returns by the employees and payment taxes

AO shall reduce int. u/s. 201

MAHENDRA TEC. INTER COLLEGE

Page 17: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 192

• S 192 – No proof for LTA

• Assessee held in default

• L&T 221 CTR 620 (SC)

• Annual Salary TDS Circular

• Also for, Medical Exp. Reimbursement

Interest S. 192

No proof for LTA

Assessee held in default

(SC)

Annual Salary TDS Circular

Also for, Medical Exp. Reimbursement

Page 18: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 192

• S 192 – Deduct tax at average rate

• No Deduction Uniformly

• S 193(3)• S 193(3)

• VINSONS 89 ITD 267 (Mum)

• Grasim Industries 92 TTJ 944

Interest S. 192

Deduct tax at average rate

No Deduction Uniformly – Interest?

89 ITD 267 (Mum)

Grasim Industries 92 TTJ 944

Page 19: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 192

• Is employer responsible for misuse of lunch coupons?

• Reliance Industries Ltd.

• 308 ITR 82 (Guj)

Interest S. 192

Is employer responsible for misuse of lunch coupons?

Reliance Industries Ltd.

Page 20: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 192

• A receives salary from XYZ Ltd.

• A also receives salary from PQR

• Is XYZ Ltd. liable for shortfall of TDS • Is XYZ Ltd. liable for shortfall of TDS for not considering PQR salary?

• Woodward Governor India Pvt. Ltd.

• 295ITR 1 (Del)

Interest S. 192

A receives salary from XYZ Ltd.

A also receives salary from PQR

Is XYZ Ltd. liable for shortfall of TDS Is XYZ Ltd. liable for shortfall of TDS for not considering PQR salary?

Woodward Governor India Pvt. Ltd.

Page 21: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 194A

• Do discounting charges fall under the definition of “interest”?

• DCIT v. Cargill Global Trading (I) (P) Limited [2009] 34 SOT 424

Interest S. 194A

Do discounting charges fall under the definition of “interest”?

DCIT v. Cargill Global Trading (I) (P) Limited [2009] 34 SOT 424

Page 22: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 194A

• Discounting charges of bills of exchange –is not in the nature of interest for purposes of TDS u/s 194A interest for purposes of TDS u/s 194A or disallowance u/s 40(a)(ia)

• ITO v. M K J Enterprises Ltd.

(Kol.)(Trib.) www. itatonline.org

Interest S. 194A

Discounting charges of bills of is not in the nature of

interest for purposes of TDS u/s 194A interest for purposes of TDS u/s 194A or disallowance u/s 40(a)(ia)

ITO v. M K J Enterprises Ltd.

(Kol.)(Trib.) www. itatonline.org

Page 23: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 194C v. 194I

• Fixed vehicle charges for transportation of employees

• AO – 194 I - Cir. 715 dated 8• AO – 194 I - Cir. 715 dated 8

• Judgment – 194C -

passengers by any mode of transport

• Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority v ACIT (10 taxmann.com 233) (Ahmbd Trib)

Interest S. 194C v. 194I

Fixed vehicle charges for transportation of employees

Cir. 715 dated 8-8-1995Cir. 715 dated 8-8-1995

Carriage of goods passengers by any mode of transport

Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority v ACIT (10 taxmann.com

Page 24: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 194H

• Can discount on supply of SIM cards and recharge coupons be termed as “commission”?

• No Sale of Goods

• Vodafone Essar Cellular Limited

• (332 ITR 255)

Interest S. 194H

Can discount on supply of SIM cards and recharge coupons be termed as

Vodafone Essar Cellular Limited

Page 25: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 194H

• Product Discount Scheme

• TDS does not apply to all sales promotional expenditure. promotional expenditure.

• Applies if principal & agent relations

• Sale of Goods

• CIT v. Intervet India Pvt. Ltd.

(Bom.)(HC); www. itatonline.org • Also, CIT v. Mother Dairy India Ltd. (2013) 358 ITR 218 (Delhi)

Interest S. 194H

Product Discount Scheme –

TDS does not apply to all sales promotional expenditure. promotional expenditure.

Applies if principal & agent relations

CIT v. Intervet India Pvt. Ltd.

(Bom.)(HC); www. itatonline.org CIT v. Mother Dairy India Ltd. (2013) 358 ITR 218 (Delhi)

Page 26: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest S. 194I

• Infrastructure claims paid to franchisees vs. ‘Rent’ u/s 194I

• CIT vs. NIIT Ltd.

• (184 Taxman 472) (Del.)

Interest S. 194I

Infrastructure claims paid to franchisees vs. ‘Rent’ u/s 194I

(184 Taxman 472) (Del.)

Page 27: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

26 AS TDS Mismatch

• TDS allowed in the year of income reporting

• CPC allows credit based on Form No 26AS

• No specific guidance to resolve mismatch• No specific guidance to resolve mismatch

• Approach jurisdiction AO to resolve

• He usually sends ball to the CPC

26 AS TDS Mismatch

TDS allowed in the year of income reporting

CPC allows credit based on Form No 26AS

No specific guidance to resolve mismatchNo specific guidance to resolve mismatch

Approach jurisdiction AO to resolve

He usually sends ball to the CPC

Page 28: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

26 AS TDS Mismatch

• Instruction No. 5/2013 F.No.275/03/2013IT(B), dated 8.07.2013

• The CBDT instructions for processing of • The CBDT instructions for processing of Income-tax returns and giving credit for TDS thereon in the case of TDS mismatch

• Based on Court On its Own Motion v. UOI and Ors. (W.P. (C) 2659/2012 & W.P. (C) 5443/2012 dated 14-3

26 AS TDS Mismatch

Instruction No. 5/2013 F.No.275/03/2013-IT(B), dated 8.07.2013

The CBDT instructions for processing of The CBDT instructions for processing of tax returns and giving credit for TDS

thereon in the case of TDS mismatch

Court On its Own Motion v. UOI . (W.P. (C) 2659/2012 & W.P. (C)

3-2013)

Page 29: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

26 AS TDS Mismatch

• When assessee approaches AO with

requisite details and particulars in the form

of TDS certificate agaof TDS certificate aga

said AO will verify whether or not the

deductor has made payment of the TDS in

the Government Acco

has been made, credit of the same should

be given to the assessee.

26 AS TDS Mismatch

When assessee approaches AO with

requisite details and particulars in the form

gainst any mismatch, the gainst any mismatch, the

said AO will verify whether or not the

deductor has made payment of the TDS in

count and if the payment

has been made, credit of the same should

be given to the assessee.

Page 30: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

26 AS TDS Mismatch

• The AO may also, if deemed necessary,

issue a notice to the deductor to compel

him to file correction statement as per him to file correction statement as per

the procedure laid down

26 AS TDS Mismatch

The AO may also, if deemed necessary,

issue a notice to the deductor to compel

him to file correction statement as per him to file correction statement as per

the procedure laid down

Page 31: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

26 AS TDS Mismatch

• Citicorp Finance (India) Ltd vs. ACIT (ITAT Mumbai)

• TDS mismatch with Form No. 26AS• TDS mismatch with Form No. 26AS

• Credit was denied by the AO

• Held: AO not justified in denying credit for TDS because the TDS is not reflected in the computer generated Form 26AS

26 AS TDS Mismatch

Citicorp Finance (India) Ltd vs. ACIT

TDS mismatch with Form No. 26ASTDS mismatch with Form No. 26AS

Credit was denied by the AO

Held: AO not justified in denying credit for TDS because the TDS is not reflected in the computer generated Form 26AS

Page 32: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

26 AS TDS Mismatch

The AO is not justified in denying TDS credit on

the ground that the TDS is not reflected in the

computer generated Form 26AS.

In Yashpal Sahwney 293 ITR 539 (

noted the difficulty faced by taxpayers in getting

credit of TDS. Held : even if the deductor had not

issued a TDS certificate, still the claim of the

assessee has to be consid

evidence produced for deduction of tax at source

26 AS TDS Mismatch

The AO is not justified in denying TDS credit on

the ground that the TDS is not reflected in the

computer generated Form 26AS.

293 ITR 539 (Bom) has

noted the difficulty faced by taxpayers in getting

. Held : even if the deductor had not

issued a TDS certificate, still the claim of the

sidered on the basis of the

evidence produced for deduction of tax at source

Page 33: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

No TDS

• Tax cannot be recovered from payer if already recovered from payee

• NO – S. 191• NO – S. 191

• However, interest u/s 201(1A) and penalty u/s 271C can be charged

• Interest u/s 201(1A) up to tax payment by the deductee

• Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverage P. Ltd. v CIT (293 ITR 226)

No TDS

Tax cannot be recovered from payer if already

However, interest u/s 201(1A) and penalty u/s

Interest u/s 201(1A) up to tax payment by the

Cola Beverage P. Ltd. v CIT

Page 34: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

No TDS

• TDS obligation depends on law prevailing on date of payment and is not affected by retrospective amendmentretrospective amendment

• No disallowance u/s 40(a)(i) r.w.s. 9(1) (vii) if that law did not require TDS

• DCIT v. Virola International (Agra)(Trib.) www. itatonline.org

No TDS

TDS obligation depends on law prevailing on date of payment and is not affected by retrospective amendment-retrospective amendment-

No disallowance u/s 40(a)(i) r.w.s. 9(1) (vii) if that law did not require TDS

DCIT v. Virola International (Agra)(Trib.)

Page 35: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Interest on TDS Refund

• S.244A : Refunds – Interest source – Deductor entitled to interest on refund of excess TDS from date of refund of excess TDS from date of payment. [S. 156, 195, 240, 244]

• UOI v. Tata Chemicals Ltd.

• (2014) 267 CTR 89(SC)

Interest on TDS Refund

Interest – Deduction at Deductor entitled to interest on

refund of excess TDS from date of refund of excess TDS from date of payment. [S. 156, 195, 240, 244]

UOI v. Tata Chemicals Ltd.

(2014) 267 CTR 89(SC)

Page 36: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

S. 199

• Credit for TDS given to person in whose hands income is assessable

• Since income is assessable in hands of AOP • Since income is assessable in hands of AOP credit for the TDS shall also be granted only to the AOP and cannot be granted to the assessee. (A.Y. 2008-

• ITO v. Amee Hosang Mistry

• (2014) 29 ITR 397 (Mum.)(Trib.)

S. 199

Credit for TDS given to person in whose hands income is assessable

Since income is assessable in hands of AOP Since income is assessable in hands of AOP credit for the TDS shall also be granted only to the AOP and cannot be granted to the

-09)

ITO v. Amee Hosang Mistry

(2014) 29 ITR 397 (Mum.)(Trib.)

Page 37: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Non Compliance

Non Compliance

Page 38: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Consequences of DefaultsConsequences of Defaults

Page 39: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Consequences of Defaults

• MSEB Case

• Recovery

• Levy of Fees• Levy of Fees

• Interest

• Penalty

• Prosecution

• Disallowance

Consequences of Defaults

Page 40: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

MSEB Case

• Total TDS - Rs. 1,61,605

• TDS Made and Paid in Time

• TDS Certificates – Delay in Issuing• TDS Certificates – Delay in Issuing

• Penalty – Rs. 1,31,70,600

• Pune ITAT Exhonoutated

MSEB Case

Rs. 1,61,605

TDS Made and Paid in Time

Delay in IssuingDelay in Issuing

1,31,70,600

Pune ITAT Exhonoutated48 ITD 414 (Pune)

Page 41: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Levy of Fees

NEW PROVISION – SECTION 234E

For Delay / Failure to Deliver TDS / TCS For Delay / Failure to Deliver TDS / TCS

Statements

Fees Rs. 200 per day

To be paid before delivering Statement

Applicable from July 1, 2012

Levy of Fees

SECTION 234E

For Delay / Failure to Deliver TDS / TCS For Delay / Failure to Deliver TDS / TCS

To be paid before delivering Statement

Applicable from July 1, 2012

Page 42: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

STATEMENTSSTATEMENTS

Page 43: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

S. 200 (3)

(i) A Tax Deductor and

(ii) An employer

after paying TDS to Governmentafter paying TDS to Government

Prepare such statements for such

period as may be prescribed and

deliver to the prescribed income

authority or person authorised

S. 200 (3)

(i) A Tax Deductor and

after paying TDS to Governmentafter paying TDS to Government

Prepare such statements for such

period as may be prescribed and

deliver to the prescribed income-tax

authority or person authorised

Page 44: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

S. 200 (3)

• The statement shall be in prescribed

(i) Form

• (ii) Verification• (ii) Verification

• (iii) Particulars

and

• (iv) Furnished within prescribed time

S. 200 (3)

The statement shall be in prescribed

and

(iv) Furnished within prescribed time

Page 45: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

S. 206C (3)

Person collecting tax shall, after

paying the tax collected to the the

Central Government within the Central Government within the

prescribed time, prepare prescribed

statements for prescribed period

and deliver to prescribed income

authority or authorised person.

S. 206C (3)

Person collecting tax shall, after

paying the tax collected to the the

Central Government within the Central Government within the

prescribed time, prepare prescribed

statements for prescribed period

and deliver to prescribed income-tax

authority or authorised person.

Page 46: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

S. 206C (3)

The statement shall be in prescribed:

(i) Form

(ii) Verification (ii) Verification

(iii) particulars

and

(iv) Furnish within prescribed time

S. 206C (3)

The statement shall be in prescribed:

Furnish within prescribed time

Page 47: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Form for Statements

• TDS:

• Salary – Form No. 24Q

• Non-resident – Form No. 27Q • Non-resident – Form No. 27Q

• Others – Form No. 26Q

• TCS – Form No. 27EQ

Form for Statements

Form No. 24Q

Form No. 27Q Form No. 27Q

Form No. 26Q

Form No. 27EQ

Page 48: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Time for Statements

• Due Dates for Quarterly Returns

Quarter Ending

April - June 2014

July - Sept 2014

Oct. - Dec 2014

Jan - March 2015

Time for Statements

Due Dates for Quarterly Returns

On or before

July 15, 2014

October 15, 2014

January 15, 2015

May 15, 2015

Rule 31A /31AA

Page 49: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Delay in Statements

The statements :

If furnished

or not furnished

Fees

Are payable

Delay in Statements

The statements :

If furnished belatedly

furnished

Fees

Are payable

Page 50: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

S. 234 E

234E - Fee for defaults in statements

• Where a person fails to deliver a

statement within the time statement within the time

prescribed, he shall be liable to pay,

by way of fee of Rs. 200 per dayduring which failure to file

or (2) TCS statements

S. 234 E

Fee for defaults in statements

Where a person fails to deliver a

statement within the time statement within the time

prescribed, he shall be liable to pay,

Rs. 200 per dayduring which failure to file (1) TDS

or (2) TCS statements continues

Page 51: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

S. 234 E

• The amount of fee shall

the amount of tax deductible or

collectible, as the case may becollectible, as the case may be

• Fee shall be paid before delivering

TDS (S. 200) or TCS (S 206C)

Statement

S. 234 E

The amount of fee shall not exceed the amount of tax deductible or

collectible, as the case may becollectible, as the case may be

Fee shall be paid before delivering

TDS (S. 200) or TCS (S 206C)

Page 52: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

S. 234 E

• The Fees shall apply to a statement

for tax deducted at source or tax

collected at source, as the case collected at source, as the case

may be, on or after the 1st day of

July, 2012

S. 234 E

The Fees shall apply to a statement

for tax deducted at source or tax

collected at source, as the case collected at source, as the case

may be, on or after the 1st day of

Page 53: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

NoticeNotice

Page 54: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Notice Notice - 1

Page 55: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Notice Notice - 2

Page 56: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Notice Notice - 3

Page 57: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Notice Notice - 4

Page 58: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Intimation

Under Section 200A

Intimation - 1

Under Section 200A

Page 59: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Intimation Intimation - 2

Page 60: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

ACTION PLANACTION PLAN

Page 61: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

ACTION PLAN

•Points for Defence

•Application for •Application for

Rectification

•Appeal

ACTION PLAN

Points for Defence

Application for Application for

Rectification

Page 62: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Points for Defence

•No time limit for TDS

Statement processing Statement processing

under section 200A

Points for Defence

No time limit for TDS

Statement processing Statement processing

under section 200A

Page 63: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Points for Defence

•Fees are charged for

rendering of servicesrendering of services

•What service is

rendered?

Points for Defence

Fees are charged for

rendering of servicesrendering of services

What service is

Page 64: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Saving Points

•Section 200A does not

cover ‘fees’ under cover ‘fees’ under

section 234E

Saving Points

Section 200A does not

cover ‘fees’ under cover ‘fees’ under

section 234E

Page 65: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Points for Defence

• Section 234E(3):

• Fees to be paid before • Fees to be paid before

delivering statement

• How can it be demanded

afterwards?

Points for Defence

Section 234E(3):

Fees to be paid before Fees to be paid before

delivering statement

How can it be demanded

Page 66: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Points for Defence

• No mechanism for recovery

of ‘fees’ under section 234Eof ‘fees’ under section 234E

• Who has authority to

recover?

Points for Defence

No mechanism for recovery

under section 234Eunder section 234E

Who has authority to

Page 67: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Points for Defence

• File statements ‘after’ TDS

payment within prescribed time

limit.limit.

• Where is requirement to file

statement if TDS is paid after

due date?

Points for Defence

File statements ‘after’ TDS

payment within prescribed time

Where is requirement to file

statement if TDS is paid after

Page 68: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Points for Defence

• Without payment of TDS,

statement cannot be filed.

• How to file TDS statement, • How to file TDS statement,

when payment is not made?

• How to perform impossible?

Points for Defence

Without payment of TDS,

statement cannot be filed.

How to file TDS statement, How to file TDS statement,

when payment is not made?

How to perform impossible?

Page 69: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Points for Defence

• File statements ‘after’ TDS is paid.

• Delay is served with interest

• How can there be double

punishment for same offence?

• Case of penalty for tax audit

where no accounts were kept

Points for Defence

File statements ‘after’ TDS is paid.

Delay is served with interest

How can there be double

punishment for same offence?

Case of penalty for tax audit –

where no accounts were kept

Page 70: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Points for Defence

Cir No. 07/2014 / F. No. 275/27/2013

• CBDT has received several petitions from Deductors /collectors regarding TDS/TCS statements due to late furnishing of the TDS/TCS statements due to late furnishing of the Book Identification Number

• Due date extend u/s 200(3) to 2012-13 and 2013-14. No fees applicable.

• Is it not discriminatory?

Points for Defence

F. No. 275/27/2013-IT(B)/4.3.14

CBDT has received several petitions from GOVT./collectors regarding delay in filing of

due to late furnishing of the due to late furnishing of the Book Identification Number

Due date extend u/s 200(3) to 31-3-2014 for F.Y. No fees applicable.

Is it not discriminatory?

Page 71: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

ACTION PLAN

Stupid Question Has a Foolish Answer

ACTION PLAN

Stupid Question Has a Foolish Answer

Page 72: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

ACTION PLAN

•Application for

RectificationRectification

•Appeal

ACTION PLAN

Application for

RectificationRectification

Page 73: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Application for Rectification

•Section 154

•Rectification of mistake •Rectification of mistake

apparent from record

Application for Rectification

Section 154

Rectification of mistake Rectification of mistake

apparent from record

Page 74: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Application for Rectification

• Within 4 years from the end

of F.Y. in which order is of F.Y. in which order is

passed

• To the officer making order

• Format?

Application for Rectification

Within 4 years from the end

of F.Y. in which order is of F.Y. in which order is

To the officer making order

Page 75: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Appeal

•Section 246A

•To CIT(A)•To CIT(A)

•Within 30 days of

receipt of order

Appeal

Section 246A

Within 30 days of

receipt of order

Page 76: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Appeal

•Form No. 35

•Appeal fees•Appeal fees

•Grounds of Appeal

•Statement of Facts

Appeal

Form No. 35

Appeal feesAppeal fees

Grounds of Appeal

Statement of Facts

Page 77: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Appeal

• Application for Rectification

&&

• Appeal

• Can be made simultaneously?

Appeal

Application for Rectification

&&

Can be made simultaneously?

Page 78: Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI - PuneICAI - Pune Branch ...puneicai.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/S-234-E-Presentation-14-6... · Pune Branch of WIRC of the ICAI. ... • Hindustan

Intermission

It was a C. V. Chitale & Co. presentation!

Intermission

It was a C. V. Chitale & Co. presentation!