Public Disclosure Authorized RP1 36 - World Bank · 2016. 7. 17. · °F\lakit *WOLDIYA Scale 20 Km Abay Engineering 2. RAP; Woreta - Woldiya Final Report EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Introduction

$Page 1: Public Disclosure Authorized RP1 36 - World Bank · 2016. 7. 17. · °F\lakit *WOLDIYA Scale 20 Km Abay Engineering 2. RAP; Woreta - Woldiya Final Report EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Introduction$
RP1 36Volume 8

THE FEDERAL DEMUCRATIC REPUBLIC OF ETHIOPIA

Ethiopian Roads Authority

Preparation of Resettlement Action Planfor

Woreta-WoWdiya road

.. '

~ r $ L _ _ _ _

*rt '6b2i f :f

4 8USv:2376 1. A hb ?I

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

RAP; Woreta - WoldiyaFinal Report

Table of Contents

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ...................................................... 3

1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ....................................................... 32. DESCRIPTIONS OF PROJECT ROAD . . .................................................... 11

2.1 Background ....................................................... 112.2 Socio-economic Benefit ...................................................... 12

3. LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT PROCEDURES ................... 123.1 Scope of Land Acquisition and Resettlement .................................................. 12

Properties to be affected ...................................................... 144. SOCIO ECONOMIC CHARACTERISTICS . ..................................................... 20

4.1 Demography ...................................................... 204.2 Human and Natural Resources of the Project Areas ........................ ................ 204.3 Economic Activity ...................................................... 214.4 Implications for the project ................. ...................................... 21

5. POLICY, LEGAL AND INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK .. 225.1 Policy Framework ....................................................... 225.2 Legal Framework ....................................................... 235.3 Institutional Setting ....................................................... 24

6. PROJECT RESETTLEMENT POLICY ...................................... 256.1 General Approach ...................................................... 256.2 Principles of Compensation ....................................................... 25

7. RELOCATION AND RECONSTRUCTION ...................................................... 297.1 Relocation and Resettlement of Private Households ..................... .................. 307.2 Reconstruction of Physical Infrastructure ...................................................... 31

8. COST ESTIMATE AND BUDGET .......................................... 329. INCOME RESTORATION ....................................................... 3510. PARTICIPATION AND CONSULTATION ...................................................... 37

10.1 The Public Consultation Process .......................... ............................. 3710.2 Public Participation, Consultation and commitments .................... ................. 37

11. GRIEVANCES AND APPEAL ...................................................... 3812. INSTITUTIONAL ORGANISATION ........................................ 39

12.1 Organizations to be involved in the RAP Implementation ............................... 3912.2 Responsibilities ...................................................... 40

13. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE ....................... ............................... 4014. MONITORING, EVALUATION AND REPORTING . ...................................... 43

14.1 General ...................................................... 4314.2 Internal Monitoring ...................................................... 4314.3 Extemal Monitoring and Evaluation ....................................................... 44

Abay Engineering 1


ANNEX:

Annex 1 - Structures & Public UtilitiesAnnex 2 - Method of ValuationAnnex 3 - MapsAnnex 4 - Impact Considerations, Woldiya TownAnnex 5 - Names of Affected house ownersAnnex 6 - Affected Agricultural, grazing land &TreesAnnex 7 - Compensations for Affected housesAnnex 8 - Commitments of the Officials (Minutes of meeting -in Amharic)Annex 9 - Minutes of meeting - PAPsAnnex 10- Photo Album

Abay Engineering 2


LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

1. AAOV - Average Annual Output Value

2. ADLI - Agricultural Development Led Industrialization

3. PAP - Project Affected Person

4. CoR - Center of Road

5. DMS - Detail Measurement survey

6. EMB - Environnemental Management Branch

7. EIA - Environmental Impact Assessment

8. ERA - Ethiopian Roads Authority

9. ha - Hectare

10. NGO - Non Governmental Organization

11. RAP - Resettlement Action Plan

12. RoW - Right of Way

13. RoWB - Right of Way Branch

14. RRA - Rural Roads Authority

15. RSDP - Road Sector Development Program

16. SAF - Social Assistance Fund

17. SIA - Social Impact Assessment

1 8.WRC - Woreda Resettlement Committee

Abay Engineering 3


Woreta-Woldiya Road Project

Figure 1: Location Map

l

,/

WORETA Debre TaborG---,O- ~Agreet WODY

Nefas WOLDIYA

Bahir Dar Mewcha Dessie

Addis Ababa

Abay Engineering


Figure 2: Major Towns Affected; Woreta-Woldiya

Debre

WORETA Nefas Agreet°F\lakit *WOLDIYA

Scale

20 Km

Abay Engineering 2


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Introduction

This resettlement action plan is prepared for affected people by the Woreta - Woldiyaroad rehabilitation and upgrading project. The owner of the projects and theimplementing agency of the resettlement action plan is Ethiopian Roads Authority(ERA). The plan is prepared through a consultative process with key stakeholders; ERAand the affected people in a short period of time. The report identifies people to beaffected due to the project , cost estimate for the properties affected, implementationschedule, possible resettlement sites where necessary etc.

Project Description and Justification

Woreta - Woldiya road extends approximately 300 km due east from Woreta town to thetown of Woldiya. It is currently a gravel surfaced road. The road is sub-divided into 2contracts; Contract -1 (Woreta- Agreet), Contract-2 (Agreet-Woldiya). Refer fig. 1 andfig. 2 for location of the road.

The road links the three major roads taking from the centre to the north of the country .Itis also the shortest route to the ports on the eastern side for the Amhara and TigrayRegions. The road serves agricultural centres of the South Gonder & North Wollo Zones

The road currently is badly corrugated in areas and rutted in isolated stretches. Blowingdust has always been a health hazard to the local people and damage to crops. Theupgrading of the road to asphalt standard has socio- economic benefit, will alleviate thedust problem and enhance safety aspects along the route. Traveling time will be less andsafety will be improved markedly.

Description of Project Area & Social Aspects

There are 17 small towns along the project road. However, there are only five towns withpopulations of more than 5,000 including Woreta and Woldiya that are the beginning andthe terminating points of the project road respectively along the road shown in the map.The small village of Agreet is also included in the map, as it is the end of Contract- 1 andbeginning of Contract -2.

The project area is density is about 100 people per sq. km. The terrain is comprised of flat(96 km), rolling to hilly (60 km), mountainous (114 km). The remaining 30 km are inurban centers.

The Economy

In the Project area, the predominant economic activity is agriculture. The project areagrows subsistence crops mainly cereals, pulses and trees. Livestock is also an important

Abay Engineering 3


economic activity. Cattle, sheep and goats are the main livestock. The areas is weakeconomically and food deficit occurs from time to time.

There are no big industries, but some cottage industries in weaving activities exists inthe Woldiya town and the vicinity

Human resourceLabor is plentiful. The average household size is five. 50% of the population is under 40years old, indicating a high birth rate. Employment is almost exclusively agriculture inthe project area with limited opportunity in petty trades. Other occupations includeshops, transportation, town laborers.

Land tenure:All land belongs to the state. Each household have their own private land holding (useright) and uses it privately. In addition households in common use grazing lands. Landcan not be sold or bought. It can be redistributed by the local government / kebele farmersassociation in some cases. However, redistribution is not encouraged these days due tolimited size.

In practice descendents inherit the land use right. Given the fact that population isincreasing land per capita is decreasing. At present the average land holding is about 0.5hectare per household. Land re-allocation is possible but without enough land it isdifficult to achieve any goal.

Agricultural landThe land is generally degraded and poor, with an average cereal yield of 10 quintals per/hectare. But there are limited fertile areas and irrigated lands. All arable land iscultivated and there is a shortage of agricultural land.

Grazing LandGrazing lands are usually not cultivated and are used in communally for grazing.Livestock is the second important economic activity after agriculture.

Housings and other structuresHouses in the project area are owned privately or by the Kebele Administration. KebeleAdministration is the governmental structure at the lowest level. The majority of thehouses are mud houses with wood walls. There are some hollow block, brick houses andstone houses.

Leizal Framework

The Ethiopian Roads Authority has been re-established by Proclamation 80/1997.In the powers and duties of The Authority;

Article 6.No.17 states; Determine the extent of land requtired for its activities in theadjacency as well as surrounding of highways and conditions of

Abay Engineering 4


use of such land by others.

Article 6.No. 18 states; Use free of charge, land and such other resources and quarrysubstances required for the purpose of construction andmaintenance of highways, provided, however, that it shall paycompensation in accordance with the law for properties on theland it uses.

ERA, has the responsibility for overall planning of the national network development andmaintenance and construction of trunk and major link roads while the responsibility ofrural roads construction and maintenance has been decentralized and given to the regionalstates having their own Regional Government Rural Roads Authority (RRA).

The new organizational structure of ERA has incorporated:

* Environment Management Branch (EMB) which is expected to be responsible forthe carrying out of Environmental Impact Assesment (EIA) and Social ImpactAssesment (SIA) of road sector activities.

* The Right of Way Branch (RoWB) is responsible for the implementation of theexpropriation/compensation operations.

ERA is the implementing Agency of the resettlement action plan.

Potential Impacts & Mitijiation measures

Contract 1 (Woreta - Agreet)

204 households will be affected in both rural and urban areas, of these, 26 householdswill relocate on a new plot of land. The 204 households are located in:

* 3 towns and other villages along the 150 km of the road alignment.* Investigations undertaken during field visit revealed that most households wish

to be relocated in close proximity to their existing property* 178 of the affected houses can be built on owner's land

178 households will be able, and will prefer, to reconstruct their houses on their currentplot thereby precluding the need for new sites. Households will receive cashcompensation for both the land they lose and the replacement cost of the buildings andstructures 26 households in urban areas will move away from their old premises. Localadministrators will assist them in relocation of new sites.

Loss of agricultural land is marginal. Only strips of land along the existing road areaffected. This impact is both temporary and permanent but the individual owners andoccupiers have not been identified yet due to time constraints and road designs whichmay be changed later. Total land loss (see table 3.3 and 3.4) and identification of and

Abay Engineering 5


compensation to individual farmers will be done in the ROW report before mobilizationand prior to constructions. The cost of compensation for loss of strips of land is includedin the budget.

Persons who are affected by loss of fences have not been identified but compensation forfences is included in the budget. This identification will be done during the mobilizationphase and documented in the ROW report.

Contract 2 ( Agreet - Woldiya)

284 households will be affected. The number includes affected people in urban and ruralareas excluding the town of Woldiya. 37 households will relocate to new plot of land.In most cases the relocation is within their own premises. These households are locatedin:

* 2 towns and other villages along the 150 km of the road alignment.* Most of the affected houses can be built on owner's land

247 households will be able, and will prefer, to reconstruct their houses on their currentplot thereby precluding the need for new sites. In these cases, households will receivecash compensation for both the land they lose and the replacement cost of the buildingsand structures. 37 households in urban areas will move from their old premises. Woreda& Kebele administration will assist them in relocation of new sites. Loss of agriculturalland is marginal. Only strips of land along the existing road are affected. As in Contract1, this impact is temporary and permanent but has not been identified yet due to timeconstraints and road designs which may be changed. Total land loss (see table 3.3 and3.4) and identification of and compensation to individual farmers will be done in theROW report before mobilization and prior to constructions. The number of farms affectedhas been established but the name of the individual farmers has not yet been collected.

Persons who are affected by loss of fences have not been identified but compensation forfences is included in the budget. This identification will be done during the mobilizationphase and documented in the ROW report.

Woldiya Town:

The road impact is high in this town. 52 households will be affected. All of them havetheir houses affected partially or fully. About 50% of the houses belong to Kebele andtenants are living in the house. These houses are public property & are usually old,poorly maintained and very low in rent. They can not be built in the premises of theexisting houses. It is envisaged compensation be paid o the Kebele and the Kebele rebuildthe houses on different sites.

The Kebeles has agreed to build the houses and avail them for the tenants.

Three sites have been identified with the Kebele Officials.

Abay Engineering 6


Table 1. Summary of Key Impacts

QuantilesItem Contact -1 Contract -2 Total

(Includes Woldiya town)No. of Affected 204 284 488households (HH)*No. f Project Affected 1020 1420 2440peopleThereof: No. ofhouses to be relocated 26 37 63(away from theirexisting location)

Source: - Field investigation and enumeration- Information from kebeles & local people- Data analysis and estimates- Average household size is 5 persons

Cost Estimates

The costs include compensation for houses, agricultural land, trees, infrastructures andother allowances.

Table 2. Resettlement /Rehabilitation Budget

Road Project: Woreta - Woldiya

Summary of costs

Item Descriptions Cost in Birr1. Land Acquisition (only property, crops, 882,495.00

labor)2. Houses and fences 5,479,625.003. Relocation and other allowances 306,600.004. Public utilities (water pipes, electric and 109,750.00

telephone poles)

5. Trees, 1,693,800.006. Coffee Bushes & other cash crops 253,200.00

Total 8,725,470.007. Monitoring 87,254.70

0 BASIC COST (1-7) 8,812,724.708. Administrative cost (3% of basic cost) 264,381.749. Contingencies (15% of basic cost) 1,321,908.71

Grand Total 10,399,015.15

Abay Engineering 7


Implementation Schedule

The prime objective in formulating this programme was to ensure that compensation forhouse acquisition is disbursed in time to enable affected households to construct ahabitable dwelling before demolition commences - a minimum of 3 months and amaximum of 5 months will be available.

The programme also makes provision for a series of activities before construction toensure AP participation and consultation. The timing of these activities is such as to allowthe executing agency to respond to practical and useful suggestions made by PAP and torespond to, and resolve grievances. The duration for implementation is about a year.Refer to Table 13. 1, bar chart, Resettlement Schedule.

The milestones are Pre-qualification of Contractors and Award of Contract. There is aperiod of 10 months between the two events. The main activities to be accomplishedduring this period are:

* Land distribution for relocation* Compensation to PAPs* Construction of new houses* Moving people to the relocation sites* Income restoration measures* Services like water and electricity

Abay Engineering 8


Resettlement Action PlanWoreta - Woldiya

Table 13.1: Synchronized Road Project Implementation and Resettlement/Rehabilitation Action Plan

No. ASKS MonthsNo. _____________,_______ASKS_________ _ Ml |M2 |M3 |M4 |M5 |M6 |M7 |M8 M9 |M1O M M12

1 Pre-qualification of Contractors2 ERA Request budget for resettlement3 ERA Obtains budget for resettlement4 Land Acquisition and Resettlement: Preparation

4.1 Establish Woreda Resettlement Committee (WRC)4.2 Conduct Right of Way (ROW) survey -------

4.3 Conduct Detailed Measurement Survey (DMS)

4.4 Confirm compensation rates and options through meetingswith WRC and inform the amount for each AP

5 Land Acquisition and Resettlement: Implementation5.1 Identification of individual PAPs in rural areas5.2 Provision of land - - -

5.3 Payment of compensation to PAPs5.4 Construction of new houses ,

5.5 Installation of utilities (electricity, water, phone lines) =-=

6 Selection of Contractor and Contract Awarding

7 Mobilization8 Consultation -- _

9 Monitoring

Abay Engineering 9


Monitoring & Evaluation

The overall objective of internal monitoring is to ensure that resettlement implementationis in accordance with the approved RAP. This can be carried out internally andexternally

Internal

Internal monitoring will be the overall responsibility of the resettlement implementationagency, ERA. Kebele and township level reports will be prepared on a monthly basis sothat prompt action can be taken, if necessary, by higher-level officials without adverselyaffecting the resettlement execution.

ERA will provide quarterly reports to the internal monitoring section of ERA.

These reports should include: name of reporting agency, date of reporting, details on theimplementation of the resettlement programs scheduled for that year, reasons for anydelays, problems encountered, corrective actions and their results, and problems that needto be resolved at a higher level.

ExternalThe objectives of the external monitoring and evaluation are to:

* Establish whether, after the land acquisition and resettlement activity iscompleted, the welfare levels of those affected were restored and sustained;

* If not, identify why not;* Assess the overall efficiency, effectiveness, impact (including behavioral

responses) and sustainability of the policy and practice of land acquisition andresettlement on this project; and

* Deduce lessons for future projects

The general methodology will involve a mix of one-on-one questionnaires administeredto households, and participatory rural appraisal (PRA) techniques repeated on a six-monthly or yearly basis during the resettlement and construction activities associated withthe project.

Abay Engineering 10


2. DESCRIPTIONS OF PROJECT ROAD

The road is located in the northern part of the country in Gondar and Wollo Zones of theAmhara Regional State (See Figure 1 & 2 in annex 3 - maps). The Woreta - Woldiyaroad extends approximately 300 km due east from Woreta town to the town of Woldiya.It is currently a gravel surfaced road. Woreta lies about 630 km north- west of the capitalAddis Ababa and Woldiya lies 520 km north- east of Addis Ababa.

The road is sub-divided into 2 contracts; Contract -1 (Woreta- Agreet), Contract-2(Agreet-Woldiya) It links the agricultural rural areas and historical site of Lalibela to theRegional capital of Bahrdar. Main agricultural centres served by the road are DebreTabor and Nefas Mewcha. Currently due to completion of Woldiya - Mile road recently,it is the shortest route to the ports on the eastern side like Djibouti. At the time of the fielddata collection it has been observed that quite many heavy duty trucks are shuttlingalong this route which is not the usual in the past few years.

Hence the road is currently badly corrugated in some areas and rutted in isolatedstretches. In the mountainous sections the curves are sharp and the gradients are steep.The steep gradients of roads coupled with the very tight bends, have caused many heavyvehicles to overturn on the the mountain passes.

The steep cut slopes are highly eroded in the mountain pass sections. Blowing dust hasalways been a health hazard to the local people and crops . Hence all people interviewedexpressed that the project is very much needed by them in order to control theseproblems which worsen the poverty they are in.

The proposed project activity involves upgrading of the road to asphalt standard. Theroad way width is 7 meters, except in mountainous sections where it could be less. Thereare limited changes in alignment at about 20 points. There are also a number of borrowareas and quarry sites.

The upgrading of the road will alleviate the dust problem and enhance safety aspectsalong the route. Travelling time will be less and safety will be improved markedly.

2.1 Background

The Road Sector Development Program (RSDP) of Ethiopia prepared by Ethiopian RoadAuthority (ERA) has as its strategic objective the reduction of adverse social effects ofthe many road projects which are planed for implementation.

Previous experiences revealed that road projects have adverse social effects. Inrehabilitation / upgrading projects the impacts are caused by widening, temporarydiversions, borrow areas, etc. Unless the adverse effects are mitigated they lead tonegative socio-economic and environmental impacts.

Abay Engineering 11


As a policy ERA has set out that social impacts of road projects will be addressed bytaking measures to ensure the affected people are provided sufficient resources andopportunities. In line with the above policy, a resettlement action plan is required for theWoreta- Woldiya Road Project

The project involves upgrading of the Woreta -Woldiya gravel road to asphalt standard,affecting people which has been established in early 1980s when the gravel road wasmade operational.

This report is the draft resettlement plan for the project.

2.2 Socio-economic Benefit

The project is expected to have the following socio-economic benefits:

* Reduced travel time on improved road

* Increased economic growth due to better transportation for agricultural products

* Improved opportunities for cash cropping

* Reduced transport and agricultural input costs.

* Improved environmental conditions and avoidance of dust hazard

* Better job opportunities on the project

* Improved non-agricultural employment activity

* Improved access to markets, schools and health facilities

* Easy access, people can open their eyes towards outside.

* Facilitate information industry

All the above will contribute to improving the standard of living of the poor and impactfavorably on women and contributes to the economic development of the area in general.

3. LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT PROCEDURES

Resettlement, land acquisition and income rehabilitation for the project will be handled inaccordance with the Ethiopian law, relevant regulations, and the World Bank policy onInvoluntary Resettlement Policy; OP 4.12.

3.1 Scope of Land Acquisition and Resettlement

Rural areas

The upgrading of the road to asphalt standard does not involve any widening ofcarriageway-width. However the provision of shoulders and side drains will increasewidth of road In addition camp sites, borrow area and detours will require more land.

Abay Engineering 12


The acquisition of the land will affect houses and strips of land along the roadalignment.

In principle ,after road construction nobody is allowed to build houses within the right ofway, which is considered 30 meters wide. ERA maintenance section is responsible to seethat nobody builds anything within this area. However , it seems there was no effortmade to stop people from building in the area.

Urban areas

In all village and townships along the road, people build their houses on road sides forbetter access and business advantages.

Hence it has now been difficult to maintain the designated Right of Way (RoW) width,30 m because the impact will be high.

In both rural and urban areas, 425 households can rebuild their new houses on their ownplots. For 63 households which will relocate to new land, the kebeles will provide landfor them (see signed contract in Annex).

Measures to Reduce Adverse Impacts

The usual RoW of ERA is 30 m. The road width to be asphalted varies from 7 metersin rural areas to 10 meters in urban centers. Shoulders and drains will be about 3 meters.However working space dunng construction & future requirements need more width thanthis.

In order to minimize the negative impacts, the right of way will be reduced to 20 metersin densely populated areas.

Eucalyptus and coffee trees

Trees play a vital role in land and water conservation, erosion protection and also shadefor animals and humans. Trees are also economic goods mainly used for constructionmaterials. In Woreta - Woldiya project area trees are grown widely for sale Within 15meters of RoW , practically no trees will be affected. Wherever there are plenty of treesto be affected the right of way will be reduced.

Building and Houses

Regarding buildings and other structures, people have settled and are living within thedesignated right of way width (30 m) since the construction of the road ( Some are said tohave been compensated in the past). The current project will only upgrade the existingroad to an asphalt road.

Abay Engineering 13

RAP; Woreta - Woldiya

Final Report

Due to shortage of land, the problem of building within the right of way has been theresince the gravel road construction. In order to reduce the impacts, the ROW will bereduced to 20 meters in towns.

Cultural Heritage areas

There is a church at aboutl30 km from Woreta close to the road. There is also an electrictower at about 16 meters from the retaining wall of the church. Shifting of the towerwould not be easy as it is at the edge of a deep canyon. During construction care will betaken not to affect the church and during operation proper traffic management will beestablished to avoid accident and preserve the church

Properties to be affected

* Land: Agricultural, grazing and residential.Land required permanently and temporarily (i.e. during the constructionperiod only).

* Trees: mainly eucalyptus trees.* Crops* Housing, categorized by type of construction: e.g. concrete, hollow block,

mud with iron sheets or thatched.* Structures and fixtures: e.g. Fences, water points, sign/teaching walls* Infrastructure: e.g. power lines, telecommunication lines, and pipelines.

The people living along the project road are organized in seven administrative Woredas,more than 41 Kebele adminstraions. There are five towns with population higher than5000 people and about 17 small towns/villages with populations less than 5000.

Households Affected

The households affected include those losing mainly houses , fences and verandah.agricultural land. In rural areas of the project the people are affected partially. In urbanareas where land holdings are very small the impact is higher.

Table 3.1 Key Impacts; Woreta -Woldiya

I | Contract -1 Contract -2 (including Total

Abay Engineering 14


Woldiya town)

No. of Affected 204 284 488

households

No. of project affected 1020 1420 2440

people

Thereof: No. 26 37 63

households to be

relocated (away from

their premises)

Houses and buildings:

488 households will be affected by relocation due to the project in all the aboveWoredas and towns. The houses are scattered over a wide area of 300 Km of the roadlength.

The houses are of different categories. The houses are mainly residential. There arehowever a few exceptions which include offices, restaurants and other business.

The houses are either privately owned or Kebele Houses. Kebele is the lowest level of thegovernment's structure and these houses are those which have been nationalized by theprevious government and hence they are public property. These houses are usuallyexceptionally low in rent , poorly maintained and some times shared by two or morefamilies. The houses include hollow block, masonry and mud plastered wooden wallswith thatched roofs or having corrugated iron sheet roof . The usual size of the thatchedones is about 20-30 m^2 and they are the least cost per unit since all construction materialis locally available.

The impact in Alember (previously known as Amed ber)town is more than other townsexcept Woldiya. Towns like Gedober, Woinye and Debot, Agreet and Debrezebit has anumber of houses affected. Most of the house owners have space at the back to rebuildthe new houses.

Table 3. 2: Type of houses and affected area (m2 )

Abay Engineering 15


Final Report

Corrugated Corrugated Thatched roofs andWoreda/Town Iron Sheet and Iron Sheet and mud

Stone wall Cor. S; mud wallmudplasteredwall walls

Number (mi) Number I (m2) Number (in)

Contract No. 1Meket - - 23 548 16 524

Geregera - - 3 82 - -

Lay Gayint - - 31 330 6 119Nefasmewicha - - 13 197 - -

Farta - - 6 144 10 202Debretabor 2 160 14 158 0 0Kimirdingay - - 1 16 - -

Fogera 44 972 - -

(Amedber) (35) (839)Total 2 160 170 3286 32 845Affected Houses: 204

_ _ _ _ _ _ I T__ I _ _ _ _ I T_ _ T 7 _

Contract No. 2Woldiya 5 364 52 1893

Gubalafto - - 89 1629 63 1476Giden 18 281 13 290Meket - - 34 462 10 241Total 5 364 193 4265 86 2007Affected Houses : 284

Names of owners and other details are shown in Annex 5.

Farm land, Grazing land, Tress and Cash crops

Stnps of land (two to three meters on both the left and the right side of the road) which is usedfor farming , grazing and trees will be affected. The loses are in seven different WeredasLaygayint, Farta, Fogera, Gubalafto, Wadla, Meket. Grazing land will also be affected fordetour, camp construction and quarry. Except for quarry sites other losses will be temporary.

Large number of eucalyptus trees, are also affected particularly in Laigaint and Farta Woredas.Extensive traditional irrigation exists around the town of Sanka (Contract 2). Due to high valueof irrigated land and shortage of land in general the impact is made to be less due to reducedRoW as discussed above. Irrigated cash crops like coffee, banana, sugar cane and hops (gesho)trees will be affected and compensated.

Eucalyptus trees as well as coffee trees are in family holdings. The loss of eucalyptustrees will not imply a loss of fuel wood as eucalyptus trees are primarily used as

Abay Engineering 16


construction timber and not as fuel wood. Even so, it is the trees in a small strip of landthat will be affected as mentioned above not the whole.

Compensation for loss of land is 10 times the Annual Average Output Value(AAOV) asexplained in page 26 compensation standards.

Contract No. 1

Table 3.3 Affected Land and trees

Farm land EucalyptusName of Woredas Rain fed

(Ha)* No. Of Grazing land No. of trees farms(Ha)* s * (Ha) N.otre farms

Meket 1440 21

Laygayint 12 5 1040 4 1 7050 100

Farta 8 55 712 3.75 8010 114

Fogera 6 25 521 0.6 540 8

Total 27.3 2273 8.45 17040 243

*Ha - 1O0 m x lOOm = I OOOOm

* Individual farms have been identified but not names due to shortage of time, will be

identified during implementation

Contract No. 2

Table: 3.4 Affected trees and lands

Name of Farm land Ecualyptus Cash cropsWoredas trees Coffe Sugar cane Banana Gesho

Rain fed Traditional Grazing Sugar-Ram_fed Irrigation land (Ha) No. No. o Coffe No. of cane No. o Banana No.of Gesho No.of

(Ha) Nof (Ha) No.of farms (No) farms (Ha) farms (No) farms (No) farmsfarms farms

Gubalafto 7.25 604 01 0 C 3342 48 1649 82 2 65 106 510 26 490 16

Meket 27 5 2292 0 0 4 6 28509 407 0 0 0 0

Walda 1.5 125 05 20 0 7569 108 ( 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Total 36.25 3021 0.6 24 4 6 39420 1649 82 2.65 106 510 26 490 16

* Individual farms have been identifled but not names due to shortage of tinme, will be

identified during implementation

List of affected land and trees , by wereda, are shown in Annex 6.

Abay Engineering 17


Public Infrastructures and minor structures

These include different type of structures like; fences, electric poles , telephone poles, water

pipes, water points, sign boards etc. The listings is shown in Annex. 1

The fences are of different types. This includes dry stone masonry (DSM), Mudmortar masonry(mmm), Cement mortar masonry ( Cmm), Wooden and Barbedwire(BW). The electric and telephone poles are all wooden and considered to bedamaged while shifting. The sign boards are hollow block walls of about 3x4 m fixedon road side to create awareness among people regarding family planning issues.Water points are communal water taps fixed into a masonry structure and usuallyfenced.

Abay Engineering 18


Table 3.5 Summary of key effects Woreta - Woldiya

Impacts Woldiya Gubalafto Giden Meket Wadla Lay gayint Farta Fogrea Total

Agricultural Land; 7.25 0 27.5 1.5 12.5 8.55 6.25 63.55(ha)No. of farms 604 2292 125 1040 712 521 5294Traditional 0.6 0.6Irrigated Land(ha)No. of farms 4 0 20 24Communal 0 4.6 0 4.1 3.75 0.6 13.05Grazing land; (ha)Housing loss(Nos.) 57 152 31 86 50 33 79 488Structure and 120 15 2250 1800 800 1680 20 6685Fixtures(Nos)Trees (Nos) 3342 29949 7569 7050 8010 540 56460

No. of farms 48 428 108 100 114 8 806Coffee tree(No.) 1649 1649No. of farms 82Sugar cane (Ha) 2.65 2.65No. of farms 106Banana (No.) 510 510No. of Farms 26Hop (No.) 490 490No. of farns 16

Abay Engineering 19


4. SOCIO ECONOMIC CHARACTERISTICS

4.1 Demography

There are a number of small towns along the project road. However, there are only fivetowns with populations of more 5,000 along the road, including Woreta and Woldiya thatare the beginning and the terminating points of the project road respectively. Thepopulation of these towns are:

Towns Population

* Woreta - 20,500* Debre Tabor - 30,450* Nefas Mewcha - 14,653* Felakit - 6,513* Woldiya, (300 km) - 33,259

The density of project area is about 100 people per sq. km. The terrain is comprised offlat (96 km), rolling/ hilly (60 km), mountainous (114 km). The remaining 30 km are inurban centres ranges from flat to hilly. The major crops growing in the area are cerealsand pulses.

The road links the agricultural & rural areas of the Amhara region. Main agriculturalcentres served by the road are Debre Tabor and Nefas Mewcha. These centres are linkedto the external areas of Bahir Dar and Desse by means of this road. It is also the shortestroute from the Northern parts of the country to Djibouti sea port.

4.2 Human and Natural Resources of the Project Areas

Human resource

Labour is plentiful. The average household size is 5. 50% of the population is under 40years old, indicating a high birth rate. Employment is almost exclusively agriculture inthe project area with limited opportunity in petty trades. Other occupations includeshops, transportation, town labourers. This fact is important in assessing impact of landloss on affected households.

As land is scarce and labour plentiful employment of the population over 15 years isabout 40 %. The overall dependency rate is high. Over 70% of the population over 6years does not have any education. Under 30 % have gone to primary education or above.

Abay Engineering 20


Natural resources

Land tenure.

All land belongs to the state. Land can not be sold or bought. It can be redistributed bythe farmers associations. Farmers have use right on their holdings. Grazing land iscommonly shared by the community.

In practice descendents inherit the land use right. Given the fact that population isincreasing land per capita is decreasing. At present the average land holding of theproject area is about 0.5 hectare per household.

4.3 Economic Activity

The predominant economic activity is agriculture. There are no industries in the projectarea. The project area grows subsistence crops mainly cereals, pulses and trees. Livestockis also an important economic activity. Cattle, sheep and goats are the main animals. Thearea is weak economically. The average annual income of the farming household isabout 1200.0 birr.

4.4 Implications for the project

Attitude towards the road:

Almost all households consider the project would bring advantages in facilitatingtransportation of their produce, themselves and agricultural inputs.

About 95% of Affected households in rural areas ,will lose small strips of farmlandduring construction. They will therefore be given cash compensation for temporary lossof income. For the minority that may permanently lose land to borrow pits or camps,they will be compensated with land from the farmers association in consultation withERA and Kebele Administration.

Peoples preferences:

If houses are affected almost all owners would like to build a house close to their housesto be affected since they prefer to be close to their relatives, social grouping, locationaladvantage of the current location etc For those who will be left with limited area theywill be compensated for the lost properties and given comparable land for the samepurpose. The local Officials have agreed to realize this as far as possible.

Abay Engineering 21


Vulnerable Groups:

In this RAP Vulnerability is defined as the situation of a PAP having one or more ofthe following situation

* Old and people living by themselves who will not be able to start a new houseeven with the compensation money

* Tenants who live in kebele houses will get compensation of 3-6 monthes rent.

* Sick , mentally ill and disabled people will be unable to cope with the impactswithout assistance

5. POLICY, LEGAL AND INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK

A review of policy, legal and institutional framework of the road sector in Ethiopia isgiven here.

5.1 Policy Framework

The policy of Agricultural Development led Industrialization (ADLI) has the mainobjective of improving agricultural productivity of small holder agriculture and relatedindustrialization based on increased provision of domestic raw materials to the industrialsector. These objectives the Road Sector Development Program (RSDP) of the EthiopianRoads Authority (ERA) are set and being implemented in order to assist theachievements targeted in the ADLI .

Resettlement! Rehabilitation Policy Framework of ERA.

The major policy framework document related to the project with respect to resettlementis Resettlement/ Rehabilitation Policy Framework of ERA. The aim of this documentis stated as PAP should be:

* compensated for loss of assets at replacement cost,* given opportunities to share project benefits,* and be assisted in case of relocation and/or resettlement.

The aim should be to improve or at least sustain living conditions prior to projectoperations resettlement.

The mitigation of adverse social impacts on road projects is subject to the operationalprocedures of ERA's guideline and World Bank policy requirements.

Abay Engineering 22


World Bank Requirements:

World bank requirements regarding involuntary resettlements are detailed in OperationalProcedure 4.12 on Involuntary Resettlement. The policy has the following objectives andprinciples:

* Involuntary resettlement should be avoided where feasible.* Where population displacement is unavoidable, it should be minimized by

exploring all viable options.* People unavoidably displaced should be compensated and assisted, so that

their economic and socialfuture would be generally as favorable as it wouldhave been in the absence of the project.

* People affected should be informedfully and consulted on resettlement andcompensation options.

* The absence of a formal legal title to land by some affected group should notbe a bar to compensation

* Particular attention should be paid to women and other vulnerable groups,and appropriate assistance provided to help them improve their status.

* As far as possible, involuntary resettlement should be conceived andexecuted as a part of the project.

* Land occupation will begin only after full compensation.

5.2 Legal Framework

The legal framework in Ethiopia for resettlement and compensation is addressed in thecivil code.

Under the Constitution 40 (3), all land in Ethiopia is vested in the State. Land can not bebought or sold but can only create user-rights.

Article No.40 states that The Government could acquire land from legal holders for useof public interest, as long as compensations are paid.

Article 44 No.2 states:

All persons who have been displaced or whose livelihoods have been adverselyaffected as a result of state programs have the right to commensurate monetary oralternative means of compensation, including relocation with adequate stateassistance.

In the civil code it is also established: (Articlel460-1488)

Those who have legitimate entitlements over immovable shall be properly and

Abay Engineering 23


directly notified of the eminent expropriation.

Compensation shall be paid before execution of expropriation

The signing of credit agreement by The Ethiopian Government and World Bank hasmade The World Bank OP 4.12 on involuntary resettlement a binding document.

The Ethiopian Roads Authority has been re-established by Proclamation 80/1997.In the powers and duties of The Authority;

Article 6.No.17 states; Determine the extent of land requiredfor its activities in theadjacency as well as surrounding of highways and conditions ofuse of such land by others.

Article 6.No. 18 states; Use free of charge, land and such other resources and quarrysubstances requiredfor the purpose of construction andmaintenance of highways, provided, however, that it shall paycompensation in accordance with the law for properties on theland it uses.

5.3 Institutional Setting

The Ethiopian Roads Authority, ERA, has the responsibility for overall planning of thenational network development and maintenance and construction of trunk and major linkroads while the responsibility of rural roads construction and maintenance has beendecentralized and given to the regional states having their own Regional GovernmentRural Roads Authority (RRA).

The new organizational structure of ERA has incorporated:

* Environment Management Branch (EMB) which is expected to be responsible forthe carrying out of EAs and SIAs of road sector activities.

* The Right of Way Branch (RoWB) is responsible for the implementation of theexpropriation/compensation operations.

ERA is the implementing Agency of the resettlement action plan.

Abay Engineering 24


Final Report

6. PROJECT RESETTLEMENT POLICY

6.1 General Approach

Policies to compensate those losing land or property to the proposed road upgradingproject are based on a combination of the above-mentioned laws and regulations and theBank policy and requirements relating to involuntary resettlement.

The primary objective of the land acquisition and resettlement action plan (RAP) is torestore the income and living standards of the affected persons within a short period oftime after resettlement and with as little disruptions as possible in their own economicand social environment. Particular attention will be given to the needs of the poorest andvulnerable groups to be resettled. The RAP for this project has been prepared with this asthe guiding principle. The requirement for involuntary resettlement has been considered.

6.2 Principles of Compensation

According to the legal and policy requirements of the Government and the World Bank,the principles of the compensation and entitlements established for the project are asfollows:

* That compensation and entitlements provided to PAP are adequate to at least maintain

their pre-project standard of living, with the prospect of improvement;

* Land should be compensated for land whenever possible

* Land temporarily occupied and period of disruption are kept to a minimum;

* All PAP, legal and illegal, are taken into consideration and accounted for;

* Per capita land holding after land acquisition is sufficient to maintain livelihood

standards;

* Where land allocation per capita is not sufficient to maintain livelihood, other income

generating activities are provided for;

* All PAP's are adequately informed on eligibility, compensation rates and standards,

livelihood and income restoration plans, and project timing; and

* No land acquisition will take place prior to satisfactory compensation and

resettlement of the PAP.

Abay Engineering 25


Table 6.1 Land Acquisition and Resettlement Principles and Approaches

Principles Approaches

Involuntary resettlement should be Resettlement issues have been consideredminimized where feasible from economic, for project alternatives during projectengineering, social and environmental design stage, which could minimizeaspects. land acquisition and resettlement.

2. Plans should be prepared for those PAP identified and their land, buildingsdisplaced. and other assets enumerated during project

design; socio-economic survey conductedto assess impact and propose mitigationmeasures.

3. PAP should receive compensation for all Replacement land will be provided; cashlosses, including assets and livelihoods compensation for land, houses andregardless of land tenure status. auxiliaries, crops, etc. in accordance with

existing procedures; RAP includesprovisions for other assistance.

4. PAP should be informed of and Meetings with PAP, village leaders, localconsulted on resettlement and governments and host communities werecompensation options. held; household interview and

socioeconomic survey of PAP wereconducted. Information campaigns throughthe local media and meetings to inform thePAP and host communities will be madeavailable through township governments,village committees and public institutionsand companies. This process will continuethroughout the planning andimplementation stages.

5. Resettlement should be an integral part Environment and resettlement aspects wereof project design. No land acquisition considered as major factors for thewill take place prior to the satisfactory selection of the project scheme, includingcompensation and resettlement of PAP. the minimization of land acquisition and

house demolition and avoidance of good-quality farmland, major infrastructurefacilities, industrial enterprises, townshipand residential areas, and mining, forestry,tourist areas. Project schedule willtake into account land acquisition andresettlement timetables.

Abay Engineering 26


6. Resettlement program to be monitored An independent agency will be engaged,by the Government and WORLD BANK under terms of reference acceptable to

WORLD BANK, to monitor the landacquisition and resettlement plan and toreport on it to the Government andWORLD BANK.

6.3 Compensation Eligibility

All PAP and organizations losing land, buildings/houses, crops or sources of income willbe compensated or rehabilitated according to the types and amount of their loses(permanent or temporary) at replacement cost. All PAPS, legal and illegal, are taken intoconsideration and accounted for.

The cut-off date for compensation eligibility has been set as Jan 1, 2003. A carefulcount and identification of the existing properties and affected persons has beenconducted together with local officials. Any person who construct a house or a structurein the right of way after the cut-off date will not be eligible to compensation or subsidies.The date has been made public to the people and to the local officials. The WeredaAdministration has also informed the Kebele Administration and the people.

Compensation will not be paid for any structures erected, or trees planted purely for thepurposes of gaining additional compensation after the cut off date.

Compensation will be paid for public building, public houses like kebele houses as wellas private house owners. Also due compensation will be paid for public utilities,telephone and electricity poles as well as water pipes. ERA has a long experience indealing with these issues.

ERA, legal division together with the environmental monitoring branch and weredacompensation/rehabilitation committees will oversee the implementation of thecompensation to the PAPs.

All transitional and moving allowances and compensation for temporary land loss willbe directly paid to those affected.

Compensation, both small and large am.ounts, will be paid either in cash or by check,following the agreement with the individual PAP's. Disbursements will be ensured byERA and will take place in the presence of the Compensation Committees as well as thespouse or spouses of the individual PAP.

Compensation Standards

The following paragraphs describe the compensation standards to be adopted for thisRAP.

Abay Engineering 27


Compensation for Loss of Strips of Land

The main compensation (90%) to be paid for land is for strips of land to be takentemporarily during road construction. The average loss of land per farmers is 10 %. Thisis because as the project involves upgrading of existing road strips of land 2-3 meterswide along the road will be affected. Average loss of land by a farmer is estimated as 3mwide x 40 m long ( assuming an average holding of 25 m x4Om.).

Temporary loss of strips of farm land will be compensated with cash- the equivalent ofincome lost for not cultivating and harvesting from the land. Permanent loss of strips ofland will be compensated by land. In extreme cases where land for land compensationwill not be possible cash compensation will be paid, at a rate equivalent to 6 times ofAverage Annual Output Value (AAOV) of previous three years. The computation of theAAOV is shown in Annex 2.

Local officials have agreed to provide land if in any way possible. But it is also clear thatAgricultural land is scarce. Signed minutes of meetings are attached in Annex 8.

Resettlement subsidy: These will be paid on the basis of 3 times the AAOV .Standingcrop compensation one times AAOV.

Total compensation payable to the affected land owning households is equivalent to 10times AAOV. Grazing land is collectively managed by the farmers associations.Compensations for grazing land will be paid on the basis of 5 times the AAOV

Compensation for Houses/buildings and Fixtures

Houses/buildings and fixtures losses will be directly and fully compensated atreplacement cost free of demolition expenses and salvaged materials and replacementplot. The monies paid directly to the PAP.

Tenants of affected houses/buildings will be assisted of a rent contract at the same termsof the rent before. The quality and quantity of space will also be of the same standard. Inaddition all tenants will be entitled to 3-6 month rent at local pnce and a relocationallowance.

Relocation allowances for households (RsO)

In addition to the compensation for houses and land, relocation allowances will be paid.These relocation allowances cover rehousing/ relocation costs, including costs of movingall household items and any salvageable materials to the new house, or from the rentedhouse to new houses (moving allowance). These allowances which are estimated to 300birr per household or 60 birr per project affected people,whichever is more, will bepayable to each project affected people.

Abay Engineering 28


To avoid temporary housing between the old and the new accommodation, the PAPswho would need relocation would be rehoused during bid evaluation or at least threemonths before the contract award.

Crops Losses

All project affected farmers will directly receive full compensation in cash for the cropsloss at 1 times the AAOV. Crops compensation will be not be included in the calculationof the cultivated land fee

TreesCompensations for eucalyptus tree will be based on size, yield and market price. Threetimes cutting is considered. Coffee and fruit trees will be compensated by consideringage and five year AAOV.

Compensation for Loss of Business

Businesses affected will be compensated for temporary loss of business. This includesshops, bars, hotels, garages, fuel stations, mills etc. The compensation amount will bebased on estimated profit and on inventory of purchase orders from for the last sixmonths and be established by the compensation committee.

The transition allowance for a commercial business moving from its old buildings to newones will range from 2-20 times RsO i.e 300 Birr depending on the size of the business.Small shops in rural areas are taken as small businesses. Large businesses are mainlythose affected by the the realignment at Woldiya town which includes hotels ,fuel stationetc. Those businesses not included in these two categories are taken as medium. Thetransitional allowance will be paid on a monthly basis for up to 6 months from the date ofrelocation from the original premises. The exact amount to a particular business loss willbe determined by the compensation committee before implementation.

Vulnerable Households

Special attention will be paid to the vulnerable groups, defined as those alreadyexperiencing hardship (e.g. through sickness, lack of labour, age, tenants) or whose lossof land /property could lead to such hardship. In order to ensure that resettlement is nomore difficult or inconvenient for these vulnerable groups as it is for the rest of the PAPcommunity.

7. RELOCATION AND RECONSTRUCTION

Abay Engineering 29


7.1 Relocation and Resettlement of Private Households

Woreta-Woldiya - Contract 1 (Woreta - Agreet)

Based on the current design 204 households will be affected in both rural and urbanareas There are about 10 % of households losing more than 30% of their properties.These households are located in:

* 3 towns and other villages along the 150 km of the road alignment.* Investigations undertaken during field visit revealed that most households wish to

be relocated in close proximity to their existing property* 178 of the affected houses can be built on owner's land

178 households will be able, and will prefer, to reconstruct their houses on their currentplot thereby precluding the need for new sites. In these cases, households will receivecash compensation for both the land they lose and the replacement cost of the buildingsand structures.

26 households whose livelihood depends on small business have to be moved to othersites. These will be given pockets of land with comparable size & locational advantagefor building their houses by the local authorities.

Meetings and discussions were held with local officials in all towns and areas where thereis impact. They have agreed to provide land. Minutes of meeting (in Amharic) attached inannex -8.

PAPs who need to be relocated have agreed to move to other sites and cash compensationfor the affected houses. The replacement cost of the house will include cost of material,labour and supervision cost. If the owner is involved in the building of his house his timeis paid for.

Woreta-Woldiya - Contract 2 (Agreet - Woldiya)

284 households are affected. The number includes affected people in urban and ruralareas excluding the town of Woldiya. 95% of the relocation is within their own premises.These households are located in 2 towns and 8 small towns/ villages along the 150 kmof the road alignment.

247 households will be able, and will prefer, to reconstruct their houses on their currentplot thereby precluding the need for new sites. In these cases, households will receivecash compensation for both the land they lose and the replacement cost of the buildingsand structures.

Abay Engineering 30


37 households whose livelihood depends on small business have to be moved to othersites. These will be given pockets of land with comparable size & locational advantage84or building their houses by the local authorities as agreed in the minutes of meeting (inAmharic) attached in annex -8.

Woldiya Town:

The road impact is high in this town. Following the current road design and based onright of way of 20 meters, 52 houses will be affected. About 50% of the houses belong toKebele.The town has a Development plan. Inconformity exists between the road designand that of the Development plan. Some issues raised by the municipality are discussed inannex -4

The consultant has followed ERA design in assessing the impacts. The impacts of themaster plan compared with ERA design are discussed in Annex. 4. ImpactConsiderations; Woldiya

Many houses are kebele houses and the residents can not build a house. They have to berelocated. 22 households are living in Kebele houses. These households will be paid 3-6months rent compensation. The Kebele will be compensated for its affected buildingsin order for them to build new houses.

Three sites (Site 1,2 & 3) have been identified with the Municipality Officials each with asize of 2, 1, 0.5 hectares respectively. The sites are located within the town of woldiya ata distance of about 0.1- 2 km from their current location. The sites identified are shown inmap and discussed in Annex 4.

The officials have agreed to build houses for the tenants to rent, with the compensationmoney, within 6 months of receiving compensation for buildings.

7.2 Reconstruction of Physical Infrastructure

Power and communication lines affected by the project will be re-constructed priorto the demolition of the existing facilities in order to ensure continuous service.Responsibilities for re-constructing the water, power and telecommunications lines andcables will lie with the respective agencies and be responsible for their re-establishment.

Abay Engineering 31


Final Report

8. COST ESTIMATE AND BUDGET

The compensation rates proposed in this estimate have been derived from discussionswith the local people and review of other resettlement costs. The cost of replacement isthe basis for estimation which includes the cost of labor and materials. The costs includecompensation for houses, agricultural land, trees, infrastructures and other allowances.

Land, houses, fences, trees and some infrastructures will be affected by the project.Regarding houses the data collected includes the type and floor area. Inclusion of moreparameters such as age, ceiling, floor type etc makes the relative value of each housemore precise. However due to short time available such details are not included. Howeverthe compensation committee will make detail inspection and measurement.

For instance for corrugated iron sheet roofed and wood + mud walls the unit rate of 500Birr might be varied between 400-600 Birr/m2 . This is because although the financeallocated could be sufficient enough to replace the properties lost for each PAP,grievances do arise by comparing what one gets with respect to the other. Compensationsfor Houses are shown in Annex 7.

Estimation of trees is made by allowing additional 2 - 3m of space on both sides of theroad since the existing clear space is about 14 - 16m in areas where eucalyptus trees arewidely grown. Average of size of rafters and three times cutting is assumed in costing.

Table 8.1 Summary of Resettlement /Rehabilitation Budget

Road Project: Woreta - Woldiya

Summary of costs

Item Descriptions Cost in Birr10. Land Acquisition (only property, crops, 882,495.00

labor)11. Houses and fences 5,479,625.0012. Relocation and other allowances 306,600.0013. Public utilities (water pipes, electric and 109,750.00

telephone poles)14. Trees, 1,693,800.0015. Coffee Bushes & other cash crops 253,200.00


BASIC COST (1-7) 8,812,724.7017. Administrative cost (3% of basic cost) 264,381.7418. Contingencies (15% of basic cost) 1,321,908.71

Grand Total 10,399,015.15

Abay Engineering 32


Table 8.4 Cost Estimate, Road Project; Woreta - WoldiyaContract - I (Woreta-Agreet)

Properties ITypes Quantity I Unit Unit Price I Amount

1.Land acquisition (only property, crops, labor)1. 1 Agricultural land permanent loss( Rain fed) 27.3 Ha 12900 0 352,170 00

1.2 Irrigated land Permanent loss 0 Ha 20000.0 0.001.3 Grazing land Permanent loss 8.45 Ha 6000.0 50,700 00

Sub Total 402,870.002.Houses2.1 Houses CI + stone/HB 190.0 m^2 1500.0 285,000.00

CI+wood+Mud 3779.0 m^2 500.0 1,889,500.00Thatch/Hidmo 952.0 m^2 100.0 95,200.00

Sub Total 2,269,700.002 2 Fences DSM 1370 M 30.0 41,100 00

Wood 1100 M 15.0 16,500.00Cmm 10 M 250.0 2,500 00Mmm 100 M 50.0 5,000 00Barbed wire 140 M 0 0 0 00

Sub Total 65,100.003. Relocation & other allowances3.1 Relocation allowance

Sub Total 204 H.H 300.0 61,200.003.2 Tenant allowance Private 10 H H 300 0 3,000.00

Kebele 9 HH 300.0 2,700 00Sub Total 5,700.00

3 3 Busmess loss allowance Small 19 HH 600 0 11,400.00Medium 11 HH 3000.0 33,000 00Large 0 HH 6000.0 0.00

Sub Total 44,400.00

4. Public Utilities El. Poles 55 No 150 0 8,250 00Tel.poles 0 No 100 0 0.00Transformers 0 No 1000.0 0.00Pipeline 1.5 Km 15000.0 22,500.00Waterpoints 0 No 2000.0 0.00Sign boards 6 No 1000 0 6,000.00

Sub. Total 36,750.00

5.Eucalyptus Trees 17,040 No 30.0 511,200.00

5. Coffee Bushes& other cash crops 0 No 0 0Sub Total 511,200.00


BASIC COST _ 3,430,889.20

8. Administrative cost(3% of basic cost) 102,926 68

9. Contingencies(15% of basic cost) 514,633 38

Grand Total 4,048,449 26

Abay Engineering 33


Table 8.5 Cost Estimate, Road Project ; Woreta -WoldiyaContract - 11 (Agreet - Woldiya)

Properties Types Quantity unit Unit Price Amount

l.Land acquisition (only property, crops, labor)1 1 Agricultural land permamnent loss( Rain feed) 36.25 Ha 12,900.0 467,625.001.2 Irrigated land Permamnent loss 0.6 Ha 20,000 0 12,000.001.3 Grazing land Permanent loss 0 6,000 0 0.00

Sub Total 479,625.0021.Houses Cl+Stone / HB 349.0 m^2 1500.0 523,500.002.1 Houses Cl+wood+Mud 4665.0 m^2 500.0 2,332,500 00

Thatch/Hidmo 2211.0 m^2 100.0 221,100.00Sub Total 3,077,100.00

2.2 Fences DSM 345 m 30 0 10,350.00Wood 3575 m 15.0 53,625 00Cmrn 15 m 250 0 3,750.00mmm 0 m 50 0 0.00

Barbed wire 0 m 0 0 0 00

Sub Total 67,725.003. Relocation & other allowances3.1 Relocation allowance 284 H.H 300 0 85,200 00

Sub Total 85,200.003.2.Tenant allowance Private 5 H.H 300 0 1,500.00

Kebele 22 HH 300.0 6,600 00Sub Total 8,100.00

3 3 Business loss allowance Small 40 HH 600.0 24000.00Medium 14 HH 3,000 0 42,000 00Large 6 HH 6,000.0 36000 00

Sub. Total 102,000.004. Public Utilities El Poles 213 No 150.0 31,950 00

Telpoles 78 No 100.0 7,800.00Transformers 5 No 1,000.0 5,000 00pipeline 1.75 Km 15,000 0 26,250.00Water points I No 2,000 0 2,000 00Sign boards 0 No 1,000.0 0 00

Sub Total 73,000.005.Eucalyptus Trees 39,420 No 30 0 1,182,600.006 Coffee Bushes& other cash crops 1,649 No 100.00 164,900.006.1.Sugar cane 2 65 Ha 20000.00 53,000.00

6.2.Banana trees 510 No 50.0 25,500.00

6.3. Gesho trees 490 No. 20 0 9,800.00

Total 5,328,550.00

7. Monitoring 53,285.50BASIC COST 5,381,835.50

8. Administrative cost (3% of basic cost) 161,455.079. Contingencies (15% of basic cost) 807,275.33

Grand Totall 6,350,565

Abay Engineering 34


9. INCOME RESTORATION

The overall objective of income restoration is to ensure that all PAP losing their means oflivelihood to the project are able to at least maintain their pre-project levels of incomeand living standards.

The payment of a substantial portion of compensation funds to individuals will place aconsiderable responsibility for income restoration on PAP themselves. There is likelihoodthat funds will be devoted to productive activities as well as house improvements.Individuals questioned during the field survey showed a marked preference for investingin off-farm activities, e.g. small businesses, trading, transportation.

Others would expand agricultural and livestock production. Additionally, somehouseholds are likely to use funds to provide their offspring with a better educationindicating a more far-sighted view of the future well being of their household.

PAP's will develop a wide range of approaches to the use of the compensation funds thatthey receive. These approaches will become clear in the months following their receipt of thefunds. ERA and the Kebele compensation committee will closely monitor PAP'scommitments and establish revise compensation mechanisms if necessary.

Reconstruction of Irrigation Structures

For those with traditional irrigation in the rural areas, the canals nearby the road will beconstructed properly for example lining of the canals which is beneficial to thecommunity.

Relocation Plots for houses

As agreed in the minutes of meeting with the officials, lands will be given to thoseaffected people who have to be relocated. Sites have been identified in urban centers forrelocation of houses. Refer figure and Photos in Annex 4 &10 respectively.

Business loss allowance

Business loss allowance due to shifting in location is considered for those whosebusiness are to be affected. The amount will be determined based on the past six monthesProfit.apart from the compensation for the houses.

Follow up

Follow up, assistance and advice by the local administration regarding the use &management of funds will be useful in this regard as agreed in the minutes of meetingattached.

Abay Engineering 35


Final Report

Employment in the Project Activities

The construction of the road will create a large number of temporary construction jobsand a small number of permanent employment opportunities. Farmers welcome theconstruction-related job opportunities as providing an additional source of cash incomethat will assist them in restoring their livelihood.

Priority will be given to the PAP when recruiting Project personnel and constructionworkers. Company managers will liaise with local leaders to facilitate this process.Priority will be given to PAP losing all or a large proportion of their land.

Gender Issues

The project recognizes the major role played by women in the project area economy andin the households. The future welfare of women affected by loss of land and property isimplicit in the compensation and other measures adopted in this RAP. Women will beeligible, on an equal basis, for all compensation payments, and other assistance beingproposed. They will also qualify, again on an equal basis as men, for temporary andpermanent employment associated with expressway construction and operation.

Vulnerable households

The vulnerable households belong to two main categones: a) poor households; includingmentally ill, sick, disabled, old etc and b) households losing a large proportion of theirland but without the labor resources or technical expertise necessary to re-establishthemselves.

In order to ensure that the living standards of these households are maintained afterresettlement, the EA and local governments have taken the following measures:

* Provide vulnerable households with higher compensation rates

* Give vulnerable households priority in gaining employment;

* Provide labor and technical assistance for the relocation and house reconstructionactivities of households composed by persons with physical difficulties such asthe elders, the disabled or the mentally ill.

Abay Engineering 36


.0. PARTICIPATION AND CONSULTATION

0.1 The Public Consultation Process

The majority of the affected population were aware of the project during the study of theresettlement plan. The socio-economic survey revealed a high degree of support for thescheme.

Concerns were also raised relating to:

* Receiving fair compensation* Minimizing land acquisition; and* Ensuring adequate land allocation and

livelihood restoration.

ERA's Resettlrment and Rehabilitation Policy Framework clearly states thatcompensation should be adequate. A number of safe guard measures have been taken inthe policy to ensure that PAPs receive fair compensation.

a) Disclose the RAPs and make them available to concerned weredas. Executivesummary will be disclosed in amharic.

b) PAPs will be members of compensatiori committeesc) Compensation can only be paid under the written consent of the PAP,d) There is and there will be a grievance mechanism to help PAPs voice their

concern and file their cases

Surveys of affected households and discussions with village leaders was undertaken.These surveys were undertaken in about 40 villages and 7 Wereda Administrationoffices in Woreta- Weldiya.

Series of meetings with representatives from all affected villages (leaders and farmers) todiscuss and obtain preferences on the preferred methods of compensation and incomerestoration has been conducted. Numerous meetings with government officials was alsoconducted.

0.2 Public Participation, Consultation and commitments

Consultation were undertaken in the month of January, 2003, information wascommunicated and the opinion of the affected people recorded. It was taken up again inMarch 8-15, confirmation agreements attained and attached in the annex.

PAPs who receive compensation for houses have agreed to build houses and within 3 - 5months of receiving the compensation.(refer annex -9)

Abay Engineering 37


The local officials have agreed to provide plots for building of houses possible sites forrelocation of houses have also been identified. They have also agreed to inform the cutoffdate of January 1, 2003 in collaboration with other stakeholders (see annex 8, the officialspromising to provide land).

The local officials will also assist vulnerable people, the old and the highly affected groupby providing prionty in selection of plots and mobilizing volunteers.

The methodologies used for consultation include:

* Discussions with affected people on household basis to seek their agreement onspecific entitlements

* Surveys of affected people* discussion with local authonties* meetings with affected people

The principal activities to be undertaken are:

* Publication and dissemination of Information, summarizing the policies,entitlements, compensation standards and rates, grievance procedures andresettlement/ land acquisition programme;

* Formal village meetings relating to land acquisition and compensationdisbursement; and

* The Detailed Measurement Survey conducted, to measure and agree the finalrequirements for land, property and other acquisition, from each affectedhousehold.

11. GRIEVANCES AND APPEAL

To ensure that the PAP have avenues for redressing grievances related to any aspect ofland acquisition and resettlement, procedures for the redress of grievances should beestablished for the project. The objective is to respond to the complaints of the PAPspeedily and in a transparent manner. The mechanism is designed to be easily accessible,transparent and fair.

As far as possible, the objective will be to avoid the need to resort to complicated formalchannels to redress grievances. It is considered that by resolving grievances within theproject's administrative structures, not only will the process be more effective andefficient, but also progress of the project is less likely to be affected.

In order to ensure that the interests and assets of the affected enterprises and individualsare not invaded or damaged, grievances and appeals should be reported according to thefollowing procedures:

Stage 1: Grievance issues should always be settled amicably. The first person to contact

Abay Engineering 38


Final Report

is ERA's ROW agent and he will report to the compensation committee in orderto settle the matter. If any person is still aggrieved by any aspect of theresettlement and rehabilitation program, he / she can lodge an oral or writtengrievance with the Kebele Administration. In case an oral complaint is made, itshould be wntten on paper by the village unit and processed. The KebeleAdministration must resolve the issue within one month.

Stage 2: If the aggrieved person is not satisfied with the decision taken in Stage 1, he/shecan bring the complaint to the attention of the Wereda Administration Officewithin one month from the date of the receipt of the Stage 1 decision.

Wereda will reach a decision on the complaint within one month.

Stage 3: If the aggrieved person is not satisfied with the decision of the wereda he / shecan bring the complaint to the attention of the Zone Administration within onemonth from the date of the receipt of the Stage 2 decision. The Zone will reach adecision on the complaint within two month.

Stage 4: If the AP is still dissatisfied by the decision, he/she can appeal to the Court, atappropriate level.

PAP can make and appeal on any aspect of the resettlement and rehabilitation program,including compensation rates offered. Detailed procedures for redress of grievances andthe appeal process will be publicized among the PAP. The grievance procedures will beoperative throughout the entire construction period.

12. INSTITUTIONAL ORGANISATION

12.1 Organizations to be involved in the RAP Implementation

Resettlement Committee should be established in the different Wereda administrationoffice, with the overall responsibility for the coordination, planning and implementationof land acquisition and resettlement activities. Administrative costs are provided to coversome of their costs.

The Wereda Resettlement Committee (WRC) is responsible for coordinating allresettlement activities in its area of jurisdiction. The actual implementation of landacquisition and resettlement work will be carried out by local administration & ERA.

The Kebele Administration Office & the PAPs will participate in valuation ofcompensation, survey of properties and disbursement of compensations.

Abay Engineering 39


12.2 Responsibilities

The WRC has tle following responsibilities:

* Monitor the disbursement of funds;* Guide and monitor the implementation of resettlement;* Coordinate activities between the various organizations involved in resettlement;* Monitor resettlement activities;* Review monitoring reports;* Prepare progress reports* Provide the resettlement budget.

ERA* Implement RAP* Take measurements* Disbursement of compensation

Kebele!Village administration committee

* Allocate land* Participate in surveys* Addresses grievance

13. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE

The prime objective in formulating this programme was to ensure that compensation forhouses and other properties is disbursed in time to enable the affected households toconstruct a habitable dwelling before demolition commences - a minimum of 3 monthsand a maximum of 5 months will be available.

Discussions with PAP's indicate that a new house in a rural area can be built within 3months if all the materials have been assembled. This time span is therefore adequate.The programme also makes provision for a series of activities before construction toensure AP participation and consultation, namely:

The milestones are Pre-qualification of Contractors and Award of Contract. There is aperiod of 10 months between the two events. The main activities to be accomplishedduring this period include:

* Land distnbution for relocation* Compensation to PAP's* Construction of new houses

Abay Engineering 40


* Moving people to the relocation sites* Income restoration measures* Services like water and electricity

The timing of these activities is such as to allow the executing agency to respond toPractical & useful suggestions and grievances made by PAP.

Abay Engineering 41

RAP;-Woreta - WoldiyaFinal Report

Resettlement Action PlanWoreta - Woldiya

Table 13.1: Synchronized Road Project Implementation and Resettlement/Rehabilitation Action Plan

No. TASKS Monthso. __________________________________ _ Ml |M2 |M3 |M4 |M5 |M6 |M7 |M8 IM9 IM10 IM11 |M12>>

1 Pre-qualification of Contractors

2 ERA Request budget for resettlement

3 ERA Obtains budget for resettlement

4 Land Acquisition and Resettlement: Preparation4.1 Establish Woreda Resettlement Committee (WRC)

4.2 Conduct Right of Way (ROW) survey ,

4.3 Conduct Detailed Measurement Survey (DMS)

4.4 Confirm compensation rates and options through meetingswith WRC and inform the amount for each AP

5 Land Acquisition and Resettlement: Implementation5.1 Identification of individual PAPs in rural areas __,-_'-l

5.2 Provision of land --5.3 Payment of compensation to PAPs --------------------

5.4 Construction of new houses , -

5.5 Installation of utilities (electricity, water, phone lines) -- -2

6 Selection of Contractor and Contract Awarding

7 Mobilization8 Consultation

9 Monitoring ___

Abay Engineering 42


14. MONITORING, EVALUATION AND REPORTING

14.1 General

It is a requirement of the World Bank that loan projects that result in resettlement beproperly monitored and evaluated. In order to ensure that the implementation of the landacquisition and resettlement plan in accordance with the requirements, monitoring ofimplementation, both "internal" and "external", will be carried out during and after theimplementation of the Project.

The "internal" and "external" elements will be combined to provide an assessment ofboth the process of RAP implementation (e.g. disbursement of funds, settlement ofgrievances, progress on house relocation and land redistribution and the extent to whichthe primary objective of the RAP, e.g. the maintenance or enhancement of the currentsocial and economic conditions of all PAP, are achieved in the years following theacquisition of their land or property.

14.2 Internal Monitoring

The overall objective of internal monitoring is to ensure that resettlement implementationis in accordance with the approved RAP. Specific objectives are to:

* Check the achievement of milestones in the acquisition and resettlementprocess, including preparatory phases, against the planned time schedule andbudget;

* Ensure that the channels of communication and consultation between theadministrators and affected persons have been established andoperationalized;

* ensure that compensation payments due to affected persons are paid in fulland in a timely manner;

* Verify that the processing of grievances has taken place within the set timelimits; and

* Closely watch the adherence to lawful, approved allocation of acquisition andresettlement money so as to ensure the absence of corruption.

Internal monitoring will be the overall responsibility of the resettlement implementationagency, ERA.

Because prompt action reduces escalation of problems, and in the longer run savesmoney, the emphasis will be on promptly resolving issues at local level with

Abay Engineering 43


Final Report

interventions by higher-level officers only when absolutely necessary. Village andtownship level reports will be prepared on a monthly basis so that prompt action can be

taken, if necessary, by higher-level officials without adversely affecting the resettlementexecution.

ERA will provide quarterly reports to the internal monitoring section of ERA. Thesereports should include: name of reporting agency, date of reporting, details on theimplementation of the resettlement programs scheduled for that year, reasons for anydelays, problems encountered, corrective actions and their results, and problems that needto be resolved at a higher level.

14.3 External Monitoring and Evaluation

The objectives of the external monitoring and evaluation are to:

* Establish whether, after the land acquisition and resettlement activity iscompleted, the welfare levels of those affected were restored and sustained;

* If not, identify why not;* Assess the overall efficiency, effectiveness, impact (including behavioral

responses) and sustainability of the policy and practice of land acquisition andresettlement on this project; and

* Deduce lessons for future road projects in Ethiopia.

Methodology

The general methodology will involve a mix of one-on-one questionnaires administeredto households, and participatory rapid appraisal techniques (PRA) repeated on a six-monthly or yearly basis during the resettlement and construction activities associated withthe project.

The household surveys will concentrate on the changes in economic activity, incomesand other social conditions of individual households. Key indicators will include:

* Household composition,* Pre-acquisition rights over land,* Size and condition of house,* Accumulated assets,

Aannual income,* Relative mix of productive activities,

This survey will provide a series of socio-economic indicators, which can subsequentlybe monitored in order to evaluate the success of the resettlement and income restorationprocess.

Abay Engineering 44


Final Report

In addition, the baseline survey, undertaken as soon as possible after the DMS will askquestions on:

* household plans to do when confronted with the impending loss of land and/orhousing;

* the extent and effectiveness of the dissemination of information on compensation* standards and options, acquisition processes and restitution measures.

The baseline survey will also ask an open-ended question about the farmers' anticipationsand apprehensions regarding the impending land acquisition and resettlement process.

The PRA surveys will be conducted at the village level and will consist of similarindicators to those described above but focusing on the village as a whole. The objectiveis to provide a wider assessment of the effectiveness of the resettlement process than ispossible from the surveys of individual households. These surveys will involve focusgroup discussions and key informant interviews.

Experience shows that these surveys can provide a greater understanding of changes insocio-economic conditions that can be obtained from household interviews. In contrast,the household interviews are more suitable for providing a set of quantifiable indicators,which can be compared over time.

Subsequent surveys will use the same format but with greater emphasis given to thechanges that have occurred since the baseline survey was undertaken, the actual timing ofcompensation related activities (signature of contracts, disbursement of funds,identification of new housing sites, construction of new buildings, effectiveness ofgrievance procedures, and on general levels of satisfaction/ dissatisfaction with theresettlement process.

Both household and PRA surveys will be designed to distinguish between changes thatare attributable to involuntary resettlement and loss of land and those that result fromexternal factors.

Abay Engineering 45


REFERENCES

1. ERA, Compensation payments

2. ERA, Environmental Impact Assessment Guideline Document

3. ERA, Environmental Procedures Manual

4. ERA, Resettlement/Rehabilitation Policy Framework

5. World Bank, OP4. 12 Involuntary Resettlement (December 2001)

6. ERA, Seven Roads EIA study

7. ERA, Seven Roads Feasibility Study

8. ERA, Draft Road Sector Development Programme II

9. ERA, Executive Summary (Environmental Impact Assessment of Woldia-Worotaand Adigrat - Shire)

10. ERA, Land Acquisition Report (Woldiya -Woreta)

11. ERA, Environmental Impact Analysis of the Five Roads selected fromrehabilitation and/or upgrading/Debremarkos-Gonda)

12. ERA, EIA of the five roads selected from rehabilitation and/or upgrading(Summary Report)

13. ERA, Environmental Assessment Report (Woreta - Woldiya)

14. EEPC, Resettlement plan (Gilgel Gibe Hydro power project)

15. The Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic ofEthiopia.

16. ERA, Re-establishment Proclamation.

17. ERA, Environmental Impact Assessment Woreda- Woldia Annexure D)

Abay Engineering 46


Final Report

List of consulted Local Officials and Administrators

S/N Name Woreda Kebele/Town Position1 Major Fantahun Kiflie Woldiya Woreda Administrator2 Ato Desaleng Wodajie Woldiya Woldiya Town Manager3 Ato Desalegn Tarekegn Woldiya Woldiya Expert in Town Admin.4 Ato Gobena Abate Guba Lafto Woreda Administrator5 Ato Tsega Araggie Guba Lafto Woreda Vice Admin.6 Ato Bayayew Amar Guba Lafto Woreda Admi. Executive7 Ato Aweke Tikuyie Guba Lafto Woiyenyie Kebele Administrator8 Ato Habitamu Terefe Guba Lafto Debot Kebele Administrator9 Ato Moges Bihonegn Gidan - Woreda Admi. representative10 Ato Bekele Tsigie Gidan - Woreda Admi. Executive Mem.11 Ato Atinafe Bedilu Wadla - Woreda Administrator12 Ato Mussie Woddie Wadla - Woreda Admi. Executive Mem.13 Ato Alelegn Fantayie Mekete - Woreda Administrator14 Ato Melake Nibabe Mekete - Woreda Admi. Executive Mem.15 Ato Abebaw Sisay Mekete - Woreda Admi. Executive Mem.16 Kese Wodajie Teferi Mekete 01 Geregera Kebele Administrator17 Ato Asefa Endalew Mekete 01 Geregera Kebele Admi Executive Mem.18 Ato Fenta Belete Mekete 01 Geregera Kebele Admi Executive Mem.19 Ato Wodajie Tegegn Mekete Debre Zebite Kebele Admi. Ececutive Mem.20 Ato Asnke Sendekie Mekete Debre Zebite Kebele Admi Executive Mem21 Ato Tsegayie Mulatie Mekete 03 Kebele Administratore22 Ato Dejenie Mengistu Lay Gayint - Woreda Administrator23 Ato Addis Yaregal Lay Gayinet - Woreda Admi. Executive Mem.24 Ato Melake Alemu Lay Gayinet Nifas Mewicha Town Manager25 W/ro Missa Gebreyes Lay Gayinet Nifas Mewcha Town Vice Manager26 Bezawereke Amare Lay Gayinet Nifas Mewcha Town Admi. Executive Mem.27 Fikadie Endalew Lay Gayinet Nifas Me. (01) Kebele Administrator28 Officer Gobew Asfaw Lay Gayinet Nifas Me. (01) Kebele Adm. Executive Mem.29 Ato Mulate Melkamu Lay Gayinet Checheho Kebele Administrator30 Genen Azeze Lay Gayinet Checheho Kebele Admi. Executive Mem.31 Ato Tesifa Adan Lay Gayinet Gobe Gobe Kebele Administrator32 Ato Wegaye Getaneh Lay Gayinet Gobe Gobe Kebele Vice Administrator33 Ato Nega Derese Farta Woreda Administrator32 Ato Mulugeta Yalew Farta Woreda Vice Administrator33 Ato Ebabeyie Asfaw Debere Tabore Debre Tabore Town Major34 Ato Melekie Gesese Debere Tabore Debere Tabore Town Manager35 Assefa Leyew Debere Tabore Debere Tabore Town Admi. Executive Mem36 Getinet Tesfaw Debere Tabore Debere Tabore Town Admi. Executive Mem37 Nega Godana Debere Tabore Debere Tabore Town Admi. Executive Mem38 Mahitem Abaye Debere Tabore Debere Tabore Town Admi. Executive Mem

Abay Engineering 47


Final Report

39 Wale Zewidu Debere Tabore Debere Tabore Town Admi. Executive Mem40 Ato Zewidu Abeje Debere Tabore Debere Ta. 01 Kebele Administrator41 Gebeyanesh Dejenie Debere Tabore Debere Ta. 01 Kebele Admi. Executive Mem.42 Esubalew TTesfayie Debere Tabore Debere Ta. 01 Kebele Admi. Executive Mem.43 Wagayie Yimere Debere Tabore Debere Ta. 01 Kebele Admi. Executive Mem.44 Tangute Guaddie Debere Tabore Debere Ta. 01 Kebele Admi. Executive Mem.45 Ato Worku Bayie Fogera Worda Administrator46 Ato Akele Fentie Fogera Woreda Admi. Executive Mem.47 Ato Taddese Meselu Fogera Woreda Admi. Executive Mem.48 Tsegaw Alem Fogera Woreda Admi. Executive Mem.49 Ato Zubeyer Abubekere Fogera Alemebere Kebele Vice Administrator

Abay Engineering 48

ANNEX- 1Structure &Public Utilities

Road Project -- Woldiya -WoretaContract - II

Strutures and fixtures affectedFences Public Infrastructure

Woreda Chainage Dry stone Mud Cement Wooden Barb El Poles Tel.poles Trans- Pipeline Water Signmason Mortar mas Mortar mas Wire formers points boards

(kmi(m ) (m) (m) (m) No (No) (No) (km) (No) (No)Woldia 0-3 0 0 0 0 143 78 5 1

Gubalafto 03-63 30 0 15 75 0 10 0 0 0

Gidan 42-56 15 0 0 __ 0 0 0 0

Meket 63-148 200 0 0 1800 0 60 0 0 0.75 1

Wadla 106-132 100 0 0 1700 0 ___ 0 0

Toa 345 0 15 0 213 78 5 175 1 0Contract I

Fences Public Infrastructure

Woreda Chainage Dry stone Mud Cement Wooden Barb El.Poles Tel poles Trans- Pipeline Water Signmason. Mortar mas Mortar mas Wire formers points boards

(km) (m) (m) (m) (m) (m) No (No) (No) (kin) (No) (No)

Meket 148-163 0 250 0

Laigaint 163-217 0 800 15 0 5 2

Farta 217-260 1350 100 10 50 140 30 1 4_ _______10 0

Fogera 260-291 20 .____- _Total 1370 100 10 1100 140 55 0 0 15 0 6

ANNEX - 2Valuation Method

Methods of Valuing Annual Average OutRut Value (AAOV) per hectare

A. Farm land/ Cereals

The approach has tried to minimize the negative effects on the families to be affected.

The calculation below has been made in order to allocate sufficient funds to fully compensate

households who will be adversely affected during the project implementation. The

compensation committee together with the affected households will decide the details and

actual compensation to be received by each household.

The major crops both in Woreta weldeyia are Teff, Barely and Sorghum. For the

compensation Teff is taken.

The computation is done on a hectare based return calculation. The amount of inputs (labor,

oxen power, seed, pesticide etc) has been calculated. The amount of yield on local way of

farming is estimated. The price of the product per kg is collected from the area. This finally

changed to return calculation. The way of calculation mentioned above is indicated in the

table below taking Teff as the major crops.

TABLE: Cost and return per hectare for Teff with out using Fertilizer inputs on good soil

I_ _ Years -

No ITEM UNIT 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

1 COST1 1 Oxen PH 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15

Price 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12

Value 180 180 180 180 180 180 180 180

12 Seed Kg 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30

Price Birr 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3

Value 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90

1 3 Pesticides Lumpsum 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150

14 Sacks 5 6 6 6 7 7 7 7

1 5 Tools 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20

1 60 Land Tax 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50

Total Cost Birr 495 496 496 496 497 497 497 497

2 RETURN

IYield QT 5 6 6 6 7 7 7 7

Abay Engineering

Price Birr 270 270 270 270 270 270 270 270

Gross Return Birr 1350 1620 1620 1620 1890 1890 1890 1890

Net Return Birr 855 1124 1124 1124 1393 1393 1393 1393

Annual Average Otuput Value per hectares (Birr) - 1290

Thus based on the above calculation a farmer can get birr 1290 per hectares. This amount is

taken a compensation for lost farmland. In the project area from 6 to 10 years annual

production compensation is paid. In this case, we used the following norm for the

compensation.

* A land fee for 6 year annual crop loss

* Residence subsidy for 3 year

* Outstanding crop loss 1 year.

A 10 year compensation. Based on this a compensation will be 12,900 for a hectares of land.

Using this method, the total compensation required is calculated in each project.

Cereal crops: The dominant crop in the area is Teff and barely sorghum. Thus a

compensation plan is consider Teff in calculation.

Sugarcane: It is a cash crops in the area. Its revenue is calculated as 5,756 per hectares. It is

estimated that 2.65 hectares will be lost in Woldiya - Woreta road in Contract No.2. (See the

method of calculation per hectare return in the table below.)

TABLE: Cost and Benefit per hectare for sugar cane

Years

No ITEM UNIT 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

1 COST

1 1 Labor MD 15 5 5 5 5 5 5

Price 6 6 6 6 6 6 6

Value 90 30 30 30 30 30 30

1 2 Seed No (10,000)

Price Birr 0 25 0 0 0 0 0 0

Value 2500 0 0 - 0 0 0 0

1 3 Urea Qt 0 25 0 00 0 35 0 40 0 40 0 40 0 45

Price Birr 270 270 270 270 270 270 270

Value 68 0 95 108 108 108 122

Abay Engineering

DAP Qt 0 25 0 0 3 0 40 0 40 040 45

Price Birr 280 280 280 280 280 280 280

Value 70 0 98 112 112 112 126

1 5 Tools 50 50 50 50 50 50 501 60 Land Tax 50 50 50 50 50 50 50

Total Cost Birr 2828 130 323 350 350 350 378

2 RETURNYield No 0 9000 8000 7500 7000 7000 6500Price Birr 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

Gross Return Birr 0 9000 8000 7500 7000 7000 6500

Net Return Birr -2828 8870 7678 7150 6650 6650 6123

Average net return per Hectare 5756

Trees:

The major trees in the project area are eucalyptus. It is a major source of income for the farmers.Especially it uses very much for the farmers, in dry season when crop production falls anddrought,occur. This tree used different purposes. It uses for house construction, fuel wood, as ashade etc.' More over the cost of production is insignificant. Thus, the loss is estimated by usingthe current price of Birr 10 per single tree of average size tree in the area.

However the tree is used or cut an could be marketed 5 to 6 times every 7 years. Therefore if

the on average 3 times is compensated.

Grazing land: In this part of the impact loss similar projects compensation has been adapted.

Thus, a housing project in Addiss Ababa, " Addis Mender Yebet Sira Mahber, Yeka Taffo" it

paid Biri', 12,111 per hectares for good grade grazing land. In this project the grade is less

than this, and thus, it is estimated to pay Birr 6000 for hectare of grazing land.

Abay Engineering

ANNEX- 3

MAP

Abay Engineering

Figure 1: Location Map; Woreta - Woldiya

WORETA Debre Tabor

WOR >A a .Agreet n /I Nefas WOLDIYA

Bahir Dar Mewcha Dessie

Addis Ababa

Abay Engineering

Resettlement Action PlanWoreta - Woldiya Draft Report

Figure 2: Major Towns; Woreta - Woldiya

Debre* ~~Tabor

WORETA Tb Nefas A reetMewcha c- e 9WOLDIYA

Felakit

Scale

20 Km

Abay Engineering

Annex 4: Impact Considerations Woldiya Town

Impact Considerations: Woldiva Town

Woldiya town is the Zonal Capital of North Wollo and one of the end points of theroad. It is here that the road meets the most eastern route to the North (Route Al Addis- Mekele). The road meets this trunk route at an angle less than 150 in between (seedrawing No JD-004). The development plan of the town assumes a ROW of 30m asERA but 20m on the Northern side and 10m on the Southern side of the road incontrast to 15m each on both sides by ERA. However the existing clear space betweenbuildings across the road is as low as about 14m at some sections and it has an opendrain on both sides.

If ROW of 30m, the realignment at the junction (refer Drawing No. JD - 004) and themaster plan are to be considered the impact is about 102 houses which are used forcommercial and residential purposes will be affected. Over 60% of these houses belongto the kebeles. Due to large impact this option (option - 1) is not considered afterdiscussion with ERA.

If the ROW is reduced to 20m, to minimize the impacts, about 52 houses will beaffected by the project including the realignment at the junction (option 2). Though thedata for both options are available, the RAP cost has included only impacts of option 2for Woldiya town. Three sites are selected for possible resettlement as per the ToR, thelocation and features of which is discussed here under.

Notes on land acquisition report/design at Woldiya:

* The ERA design has impacts only at the realignment whch is the junction* Pavement width is about 7m as shown on the map (JD- 004) which is included in

the land acquisition report 1.* This RAPs has identified more No. of houses which are only upto 10m away from

the center line apart from the ones identified on the Drawing JD-004* The municipality has requested for inclusion of round about at the junction to

minimize the current accidents at the area.

Potential Resettlement Sites

Woldiya town is the area where the impact is relatively higher. To mitigate the impactsusualfRow of 30m is reduced to 20m after discussion with ERA. The open ditches onboth sides of the road can be piped or covered type to effectively utilize the limitedarea. Accordingly about 52 houses will be affected. Out of this about 22 houses belongto the kebele. Some of these are residential houses which can be relocated to theproposed three sties. Those who are losing their land totally and having largecommercial houses say hotels can be allowed to rebuild on sites of kebele houses,which, are residential and needs relocation. For all private and kebele houses which are

Annex 4: Impact Considerations Woldiya Town

used for residential purposes three sites are selected for resettlement having thefollowing features. (They are shown on 1: 50,000-scale map attached).

Site No. 1 - This site is about 100m from the road and lies within the town and thenearest to the affected peoples houses. It can accommodate about 10houses. Due to its location provision of water, power telephone etc willnot be a problem. Access road exists to the site.

Site No. 2 - This site 1i es about one km North of the affected site. It can accommodateabout 12 - 15 houses. The site is within the built up area and henceprovision of infrastructure will not be a problem as site NO. 1: Floodcoarse at the back of the site needs a retaining wall.

Site No. 3 - This site is selected incase may people are to be displaced. The site liesSouth of Woldiya town & belong to peasants. The area is under study bythe municipality to convert it to urban area. Between the Gatira river andfeeder road about 2 ha of land exists which can accommodate more than100 households. Due to the possible imnpacts on the peasants this site isless desirable than the above sites.

Annex 4Identified sites for Resettlement of PAP's

5~~~~~ - .) _ *- 1._ -

s ~I . .

' v ; ; ~~ '< S V- ^ - WOLDIYA

---... ~ ~ -, - . .-. .- ...

-; s ~ - ' ' - .'

_ *, -- -- 'C-'--' j *-

1 . i: <¢ . .:i. , -. - ---I --

6 - - J -

Resettlement Action Plan StudyField Data Takeoff Sheet

Annex-5: List of Names of affected house owners / TenantsWoreda Weldiya

Affected Persons Background Property to be Affected Distance

S.No Kebele/Locality . -Ho sirig Units from theAffected Person Sex Age Educa Occup. Family Healt Sta. Owner Other center of

_____ ~~~~Size _____ Ship Tpe Service Area m2 the Road

1 02 W/ro Askale Gobena F 72 Illi. Merchant 14 Aged P Corr +m Hotel 100 20m away

2 03 Ato Endris Mohammed M 20 7 Merchant 5 Good P Corr +m Business 22 1Om away3 03 W/ro Enfentaw Mekuriya F 60 1l1i. Merchant 6 Good P Corr +m Business 50 1Om away4 03 W/ro Aberash Wendimu F 30 Ili. Merchant 3 Good P Corr +H.B Business 58 1Om away5 03 W/ro Wagaye Berhanu F 30 10 Merchant 7 Good P Corr +H.B Business 40 10m away

6 03 Ato Aminu Mohammed M 34 11i. Merchant 6 Good P H Block Shop 14 1Om away7 03 Hagi Ahmed Hagi M 90 lli. No 23 Aged P Corr +m Business 52 1Om away8 03 W/ro Enat Abebe F 80 Ilii. Merchant 8 Deceased P Corr +M Business 22 1Om away9 03 W/ro Engida Gebru F 60 lil No 5 Good P Corr +M Residence 56 10m away10 03 Ato Abate Mola M 30 10 Driver 3 Good P Corr +M Office 120 1Oim away11 03 W/ro Mayda Kefa F 29 9 No 1 Good P Corr +M Residence 40 1 Om away12 03 W/ro Kebebush Enmiaw F 40 12 Merchant 8 Good P Corr +M Business 14 1 Oi away13 03 W/ro Tsehay Ayalew F 35 Illi No 5 Good P Corr +M Residence 28 lOi away14 03 W/ro Desse W/rufael F 65 _iii No 2 Good P Corr +M Residence 40 lOi away15 03 Ato Mezgebe W/yohanes M 65 R &W No 8 Good P Corr +M Residence 42 lOm away16 03 Sheh Hasen Mohammed M 60 lIli No 3 Good P Corr +M Shop +R 40 lOm away17 03 W/ro Zemzem Alto F 37 illi No 8 Good P Corr +M Residence 36 lOm away

Households to be Relocated to New Site

1 02 W/ro Menbere Fente F 35 12 Merchant 6 Good P H Block Fuel Station 98 27m away2 02 Ato Neguse Takele M 50 R &W Merchan 12 Good P Corr +H B Shopes & Ohter 96 25m away3 02 Ambasel Trading Corr +m Business 242 35m away4 02 Ato Shimeles Wagaye M 68 1Ili. Merchant Good P Corr +m Hotel 122 20m away

5 03 W/ro Alganesh Desta F 70 1Ili Merchant 2 Good P Corr +m Business 22 1Om away

6 03 Ato Haylea Neguse M 40 12 Merchant 12 Good K Corr +m Shop 22 1 Om away7 03 W/ro Abebech Amare F 20 7 Merchant 5 Good P Corr +m Business 28 1 Om away8 03 W/ro Abebech Amare F 50 _Il Merchant 5 Good K Corr +i Business 24 _ 10i away9 03 W/ro Anguach Mekonen F 50 Ili Merchant 6 Good K Corr +m Business 28 A Oi away

Resetlement Action Plan StudyField Data Takeoff Sheet

Woreda WeldiyaAffected Persons Background Property to be Affected Distance

S.No KebelelLocality Housing Units from theAffected Person. . Sex Age Educa. Occup. Family HealtSta. Owner cen te Other te ofta. wner Type Service Area m2~ te

Size __ _ _ _ Ship _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ the Road

10 03 W/ro Fatima F 50 li1i No 3 Deceased P Corr +H B Shop 66 10m away11 03 W/ro Zewde Ibrahim F 65 lii No 4 Aged P H Block Resident 84 10m away12 03 W/ro Zenebu Habte F 60 lii. Merchant 2 Good K Corr +m Resident 22 7m away13 03 W/ro Tsigereda Beyene F 33 12 No 7 Good K Corr +m Resident 24 7m away14 03 Absent K Corr +m Business 24 7m away

15 03 W/ro Tiruye Mekonnen F 40 IlIIi No 6 Good K Corr +m Resident 24 7m away16 03 Ato Mola Lyabeyn M 65 R &W Merchant 11 Good K Corr +m Business 30 7m away

17 03 W/ro Aster Teferi F 36 12 Merchant 3 Good K Corr +m Business 30 8m away

18 03 W/ro Beletu Amare F 25 8 No 5 Good K Corr +m Resident 30 8m away

19 03 W/ro Aisha Kerebea F 55 Illi No 3 Good K Corr +m Shop 28 1 Om away

20 03 W/ro Tirfnesh Gezahegn F 50 IlIi. Merchant 4 Good K Corr +m Com. C 30 1Om away21 03 Ato Minilik Abegaz M 35 12 Merchant 4 Good K Corr +m Resident 36 1Om away22 03 W/ro Mulu Berihun F 38 lli Merchant 2 Good K Corr +m Resident 30 1 Om away

23 03 Sisay Shiferaw M 30 12 G Emplo 3 Good K Corr +M Residence 20 1Om away24 03 W/ro Wagaye Shumye F 70 Illi. No 2 Aged P Corr +M Residence 68 1 Om away

25 04 W/r Webishet Aligaz F 54 R &W Merchant 3 Good K Corr +M S Shop 8 1 Om away

26 03 Ato Marye Desse M 70 lii No 8 Aged K Corr +M Residence 40 1 Om away

27 03 Ato Tazebe Belay M 50 12 G Emplo 8 Good K Corr +M Business 26 1 Om away

28 03 W/ro Werknesh Mola F 40 1Ili No 4 Good K Corr +M Sho 26 1 Om away

29 03 W/ro Endayew Endalew F 62 Illi No 5 Good K Corr +M Shop 32 1Om away30 03 Ato Getachew Mola M 19 iliI No 3 Good K Corr +M Residence 28 1Om away31 03 Ato Mezgebe W/yohanes M 65 R &W No 8 Good P Corr +Mas Shop 28 1 Om away32 03 Ato Jemal M 30 10 Merchant 1 Good P Corr +M Shop 24 1 Om away33 03 W/ro Zeyniya Husen F 50 1Ili No 1 Good K Corr +M Residence 22 1 Om away

34 03 W/ro Belaynesh Ali F 50 Ilii Merchant 1 Good K Corr +M Residence 34 1 Om away

35 03 Tiruka Meles F 60 Illi No 4 Good k Corr +M Residence 26 . 10m away

Annex 6: Agricultural land, grazing land and trees affected by woredas and KebelesWoldiya - Woreta ( Contract-1

REGION: Amhara

Farm land Cash crops and TressKebele Rain feed Irrigation Grazing Eucalyptus Coffee Sugarcane Banana Hope

(Ha) |(Ha) land (Ha) (No) (No) (Ha) (No) (No)

Woreda: Meket8 95011 4901

Total 14401

Woreda :Laygayint19 __ = 1100,17 1000 _ _ _ _

16 500 _ __

13 15 0.1 7002 1 5 0.25 150_

2 1150Sahlit(08) 2 5 0 75 650

Damot(09) 1 75 1.75 800

Titir6(03 3 25 1.25 1000

Total , 12.5 0 4.1 7050 0 0 0 0Woreda: Farta

Argadidim 1 0.5 4000Atasifatra 2 25 0 75 2000

Azwir 2.05 1 500Sahir 0 5

Magera/Kanat 0 75 0 75 150CAba Aregay 0 25 0 75 550

Kolengh 1GasayTsegur 0.75 400

Debretabor(Town) 410

Total 8.55 0 3.75 8010 o o o 0Woreda: Fogera

Tuhanazagena 1 75 0 5Wej 3 0 05 210

Senko 1.5 0.05Amedber/Alembere _ | 330

Total 6.251 0 0.6 5401 ol ol 0 0| Sub,Total 27.3 0 8.45 17,0401 0l 0l 0l 0

Annex 6: Agricultural land, grazing land and trees affected by woredas and KebelesWoldiya - Woreta (Contract-2)

REGION: Amhara

Farm land Cash crops and TressKvebele Rain feed Irgation Grazing Eucalyptus Coffee Sugarcane Banana Hope

(Ha) (Ha) land (Ha) (No) (No) (Ha) (No) (No)

Woreda: GubalaftoMehal Mechare(09) 260

.10 _ 336GedoBer 09 210

Geshober(017) _ 500 400 0 75 210 135Debot(016) 21 480 360 04 100 240Eyela(012) 1.2 280

Chibna(011) 07 220Zefe(031) 11

Anova 326Woinye(014) 01 730 889 1.5 200 115

Adisge 1 25Total 7.25 0 1 0 3342 1649 2.65 510 490

Woreda: Meket34 02

Adsge(33) 1Estayish (32)rural 2 500

31 3530 3.5 1.25 210

Hamusit(029) 4 1.25 56028 4 1 250

Kone(013) 1.25 5029 075_20 35 0 35 1250i7 1 25 1300

<^.19 1 25 0 3 20014 0 75 02 370022 1 0 25 3002 7601 829'8 0.5i3 0 25 28003 5400'4 10,400

Total 27.5 0 4.6 28,509Woreda .Wadla

13 05 025 5922 460

,..20 1 1 1 130017 1 0 25 97019 78014 _ _ _ 4000 T I

Total 1.5 0.5 0 7569 0 0 0 0cSub Total 36.25 0.6 4.6 39,420 1649 2.65 510 490

Annex 7: Compensations for houses

Wereda:-__ ___________ Fogera

S.No Kebele /locality Affected Person Houses

.___ _____________ Type Service Area M 2 Unit Price Amount /Birr/

1 Alembere (01) Ashagrie Worku Corr +M Resid 9 500 4500

2 Alembere (01) Husen Guangule Corr +M Resid. 24 500 12000

3 Alembere (01) Tesfayle Molla Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

4 Alembere (01) Fikaddie Assefaw Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

5 Alembere (01) Lakew Mesele Corr +M Resid 32 500 16000

6 Alembere (01) Absent Corr +M Resid. 14 500 7000

7 Alembere (01) Fanta Jember Corr +M Resid 12 500 6000

8 Alembere (01) Yekeba Amesh Corr +M Resid. 12 500 6000

9 Alembere (01) Desitaw Tesfahun Corr +M Shop 10 500 5000

10 Alembere (01) Tadele Damittie Corr +M Resid 12 500 6000

11 klembere (01) Bereded Asifaw Corr +M Resid. 50 500 25000

12 Alembere (01) Amisalu Abreha Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

13 Alembere (01) Vibay Tegayie Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

14 Alembere (01) Muluken Azen Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

15 Alembere (01) Absent Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

16 Alembere (01) Tesifa Workineh Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

17 Alembere (01) Birhan Debelkie Corr +M Resid 30 500 15000

18 Alembere (01) Ergoyie Issa Corr +M Shop +R 21 500 10500


20 Alemrbere (01) Tarekegn Issa Corr +M Resid. 21 500 10500

21 Xlembere (01) Kasaw Tesfu Corr +M Shop +R 40 500 20000


23 Alembere (01) Alemayehu Bezabeh Corr +M Shop +R 45 500 22500

24 Alembere (01) Ambaw Engedaw Corr +M Shop +R 15 500 7500

25 Alembere (01) Issa Dawd | Corr +M Shop +R 65 500 32500

26 - lembere (01) Kassaw Teshager Corr +M Store 48 500 24000

27 Alembere (01) Tarekegn Gebar Corr +M Shop +Sto 75 500 37500

28 Alembere (01) Sale FerJe Corr +M Resid. 9 500 4500

29 Alembere (01) Workitale Goshu Corr +M Resid 24 500 12000

30 lembere (01) Nurehusen Abdela Corr +M Resid 28 500 14000

31 Alembere (01) Absent Corr +M Resid. 15 500 7500

32 Alembere (01) Absent L Corr +M Resid 15 500 7500

33 Alembere (01) Seyidu Mohamed | Corr +M Resid. 35 500 17500

34 Alembere (01) Shashie Tayie Corr +M Resid 18 500 9000

35 Alembere (01) Ayalew Zerihun Corr +M Shop +R 30 500 15000

36 4lembere (01) Telela mekonen Corr +M Resid 34 500 17000

37 Alembere (01) Amisalu Abreha Corr +M Resid. 16 500 8000

38 Alembere (01) Ambaw Engidaw Corr +M Shop +R 12 500 6000

39 Alembere (01) Sinedu Gebirie Corr +M Resid. 24 500 12000

40 Alembere (01) Missa Asmar Corr +M Resid 24 500 12000

41 Ilembere (01) Haji Aweke Siraje Corr +M Resid. 30 500 15000

42 Vlembere (01) Teseffa Shiferaw Corr +M Resid 35 500 17500

43 Alembere (01) Biyabes Alemayehu Corr +M Resid 30 500 15000


45 Alembere (01) Sinddie Wondime Corr +M Resid 24 500 12000

46 Alembere (01) Addissie Mesifen Corr +M Resid 24 500 12000

47 Alembere (01) Tegayie Bayie Corr +M Resid. 108 500 54000

48 Alembere (01) Emahoy Tegegn Beza Corr +M Resid 42 500 21000

49 Alembere (01) Yayenie Shifaw Corr +M Resid. 24 500 12000


51 Alembere (01) Adimas Abitew Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

52 Alembere (01) Wondale Abeje Corr +M Resid 35 500 17500


54 Alembere (01) Amaled Ayalew Corr +M Shop 34 500 17000

55 Alembere (01) Wondmnegn Kasahun Corr +M Store 34 500 17000

56 4lembere (01) Assefash Arega Corr +M Resid 24 500 12000

57 Alembere (01) Zeyinu Zewedu Corr +M Resid 24 500 12000

58 Woji Worke Agegn Corr +M Resid 26 500 13000

59 Woil Amedie Bigale Corr +M Resid 30 500 15000

60 Woji Absent Corr +M Resid. 15 500 7500

61 Woji Bereded Desalegn Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

62 Wojp Maru Ahemed Corr +M Sop +R 25 500 12500

63 - oip Absent Corr +M Resid. 12 500 6000

64 Woji Worku Belay Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

65 Wojl Yeshanew Muhamed Corr +M Resid 22 500 11000

66 Woji Rahimet Ahemed Corr +M Resid. 20 500 10000

67 Woji Shibabaw Kebede Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

68 Kojl Endalegn Adan Corr +M Resid. 22 500 11000

." I I I Total 90550

Annex 7 Compensations for houses

Woreda: Woldiya

Houses

S.N Kebele/Locality Affected Persons

Type Service Area m2 Unit Price Amount /Birrl

1 02 Wlro Menbere Fente H Block Fuel Station 95 00 150C 142500 00

2 02 Ato Neguse Takele Corr +H E Shopes & Ohter 96 00 150 144000 0o

3 02 Ambasel Trading Corr +m Business 242 00 500 121000 0

4 02 Ato ShimelesWagaye Corr +m Hotel 122 o0 500 61000 oc

5 02 Ilro Aselak Gobena Corr +nm Hotel 100 00 500 50000 oc

6 03 Ilro Alganesh Desta Corr +m Business 22 00 50s 11000 0o

7 03 Ato Haylea Neguse Corr +rn Shop 2200 50o 11000 00

8 03 Ato Endris Mohammed Corr +m Business 22 00 500 11000 00

9 03 Wlro Abebech Amare Corr +m Business 28 00 500 14000 00

10 03 Nlro Abebech Amare Corr +m Business 24 00 500 12000 0

11 03 Wlro Anguach Mekonen Corr +m Business 28 00 50C 14000 00

12 03 Ilro Enfentaw Mekuriya Corr +m Business 50 00 500 25000 00

13 03 Ilro Aberash Wendimu Corr +H E Business 58 00 1500 87000 00

14 03 Wlro Wagaye Berhanu Corr +H E Business 40 o0 50s 20000 00

15 03 Ilro Fatima Corr +H Shop 66 00 500 33000 00

16 03 to Aminu Mohammed Corr +H _ Shop 14 00 500 7000 0o

17 03 Ilro Zewde Ibrahim Corr +H B Resident 84 00 1500 126000 0o

18 03 Ilro Zenebu Habte Corr +m Resident 22 00 500 11000 0o

19- 03 Wlro Tsigereda Beyene Corr +m Resident 2400 500o 12000 00

20 03 Absent Corr +m Business 24 00 500 12000 0o

21 03 Wlro Tiruye Mekonnen Corr +m Resident 24 80 500 12400.00

22 03 Ato Mola Lyabeyn Corr +m Business 30 00 500 15000 00

23 03 Ilro Aster Teferi Corr +m Business 30 00 500 15000 0o

24 - 03 Ilro Beletu Amare Corr +m Resident 3000 50s 15000 0o

25 03 Hagi Ahmed Hagi Corr +m Business 52 00 50s 26000 0o

26 03 Ilro Aisha Kerebea Corr +m Shop 28 00 50s 14000 00

27 03 Ilro Tirfnesh Gezahegn Corr +m Com C 3000 500s 15000 00

28 03 Ato Minilik Abegaz Corr +m Resident 36 00 5001 18000 00,

29 03 WIro Mulu Berihun Corr +m Resident 30 00 50C 15000.00

30 03 Ilro Enat Abebe Corr +M Business 22 20 500 11100 00

31 03 Sisay Shiferaw Corr +M Residence 20 00 5001 10000 0o

32 03 N/ro Engida Gebru Corr +M Residence 56 00 500 28000 0O

33 03 Ato Abate Mola Corr +M Office 120 00 500 60000 00

34 03 Wlro Wagaye Shumye Corr +M Residence 68 00 500 34000 00

35 03 I/ro Mayda Kefa Corr +M Residence 40 00 500 20000 00

36 03 Ato Marye Desse Corr +M Residence 40 00 50C 20000 0O

37 03 W/ro Kebebush Enmiaw Corr +M Business 14 00 50C 7000 00

38 03 Ato Tazebe Belay Corr +M Business 26 00 50C 13000 00

39 03 N/ro Werknesh Mola Corr +M Shop 26 00 500 13000 0O

40 03 W/ro Endayew Endalew Corr +M Shop 32 00 500 16000 0O

41 03 Ato Getachew Mola Corr +M Residence 28 00 500 14000 00

42 03 W/ro Tsehay Ayalew Corr +M Residence 28 00 500 14000 0O

43 03 N/ro Desse W/rufael Corr +M Residence 40 00 500 20000 0O

44 03 Ato Mezgebe W/yohane Corr +M Residence 42 00 500 21000 00

45 03 Ato Mezgebe W/yohane Corr +H 8 Shop 28 00 1500 42000 0O

46 03 Ato Jemal Corr +M Shop 24 00 500 12000 0O

47 03 N/ro Zeyniya Husen Corr +M Residence 22 00 500 11000 00

48 03 W/ro Belaynesh Ali Corr +M Residence 34 00 500 17000 0O

49 03 Sheh Hasen Mohammed Corr +M Shop +R 40 00 50C 20000 00

50 03 N/ro Zemzem Alto Corr +M Residence 36 00 500 18000 00

51 - 03 W/ro Tiruka Meles Corr +M Residence 26 00 500 13000 00

52 03 W/ro Webeshet Aligaze Corr +M Residence 8 00 500 4000 00

Total 1512500


Wereda:Gubalafto

HousesS.No Kebele /locality Affected person

Type Service Area M 2 Unit Price Amount IBirrl

Mehale1 Mecharie Demeke Melaku Cor +M Shop 16 500 8000

Mehale2 Mecharie Mohamed Umer Cor +M Shop 16 500 8000

Mehale3 Mecharie Workinesh Molla That +M Resid. 8 100 800

Mehale4 Mecharie Tsehanesh Wolle That +M Resid 9 100 900

5 Golla Mecharie Debetew Iyasu That +M Resid 9 100 900

6 Golla Mecharie Belaynesh Kassa That +M Resid 25 100 2500

7 Gedo Bere Degu Yimer That +M Kichen 12 100 1200

8 Gedo Bere Mengistu Yimer Cor +M Resid 24 500 12000

9 Gedo Bere Dessalegn Kassaw That +M Resid 20 100 2000

10 Gedo Bere Molla Teshale That +M Resid 24 100 2400

11 Anioba Dequ Kasaw That +M Resid 40 100 4000

12 Anaba Biretalu aweke That +M Resid 20 100 2000

13 Anoba Sete Brihanu That +M Resid. 22 100 2200

14 Woyneyie Geditu Brihan That +M Resid 30 100 3000

15 Woyneyie Brihan Molla That +M Resid. 36 100 3600

16 oyneyie Dejenie Sitotaw That +M Resid 40 100 4000

17 Wbyneyie Fasika Milashe That +M Resid 40 100 4000

18 o6yneyie Amare Sitotawe That +M Kichen 12 100 1200

19 Woyneyie Sileshi Seyoum Cor +M Shop 9 500 4500

20 Wayneyie Worku Tayie Cor +M Shop + R 32 500 16000

21 Wbyneyie Tameralech Mekonen Cor +M Resid 24 500 12000

22 Wyneyie Gebeyaw Addis That +M Resid. 18 100 1800

23 \i6oyneyie Gelachew Siraje That +M Resid. 18 100 1800

24 Woyneyie Tegegn Assefa Cor +M Resid. 30 500 15000

25 Woyneyie Gashaw Belete Cor +M Resid. 34 500 17000

26 oyneyle shagrie Getachew Cor +M Shop+ R 21 500 10500

27 ayneyie Molla Shumlyle Cor +M Resid 15 500 7500

28 Woyneyie Worku Demeke Cor +M Resid. 24 500 12000

29 Woyneyie Agaza Zewdu Cor +M Resid 60 500 30000

30 Woyneyie serate Asmamaw That +M Resid. 32 100 3200

31 Woyneyie Guziguaze Niguse Cor +M Shop + R 30 500 15000

32 Woyneyie Hayelu Desalew Cor +M Shop + R 30 500 15000

33 Woyneyie Mulugeta Redie Cor +M Shop + R 25 500 12500

34 Woyneyie H/Eyesus Aragie Cor +M Shop 6 500 3000

35 Woyneyie Mekuria Iyasu That +M Resid. 18 100 1800

36 Woyneyie Melaku Semaw Cor +M Shop 10 500 5000

37 Woyneyie Sirale Mohamed Cor +M Resid 34 500 17000

38 Woyneyie Simegn Tefera Cor +M Resid 30 500 15000

39 Wcyneyle Biyabeyine Gedefaw Cor +M Resid 32 500 16000

40 _yneyie Tsehayinesh Melles Cor +M Resid 18 500 9000

41 Voyneyie Mulu Werashu Cor +M Resid 24 500 12000

42 woyneyie Senayet Msfine Cor +M Resid 28 500 14000

43 Woyneyie Guangule Ayalew Cor +M Resid 26 500 13000

44 Woyneyie Lisanie Tsigie Cor +M Bar 42 500 21000

45 Wbyneyie Zenebe Worku Cor +M Resid 24 500 12000

46 Woyneyie Nure Kasa Cor +M Resid 45 500 22500

47 Woyneyie Mulu Kasa Cor +M Resid 20 500 10000

48 Woyneyie Ibriahim Said Cor +M Resid. 18 500 9000

49 Wbyneyie eshaw Yasine Cor +M Resid. 16 500 8000

50 Voyneyie Gedamu Assefa Cor +M Shop + R 28 500 14000

51 Woyneyie Eshetu Zelelew Cor +M Shop + R 46 500 23000

52 Gesho Bere Nedajie Meles Cor +M Shop 42 500 21000

53 Gesho Bere Mabrie Sisaye Cor +M Resid 40 500 20000

54 Gesho Bere Fiseha Kebede Cor +M Shop 42 500 21000

55 Gesho Bere Zelaleme Demeke Cor +M Resid 44 500 22000

56 Gesho Bere Ambache Tassew Cor +M Resid 50 500 25000

57 Gesho Bere Mebrie Desal Cor +M Resid. 16 500 8000

58 Gesho Bere Demissie Asmirie Cor +M Resid. 18 500 9000

59 Debot serate Mariyie That +M Kitchen 12 100 1200

60 Debot Etagegn Tebeje That +M Resid 12 100 1200

61 Debot Merichie Tesfaw That +M Kitchen 9 100 900

62 Debot Yalfale Werota That +M Resid. 30 100 3000

63 Debot Chanie Zegyie L Cor +M Resid. 20 500 10000

64 Debot Sitotaw Degu That +M Kitchen 12 100 1200

65 Debot Bisettegn Neggashe Cor +M Resid 38 500 19000

66 D6bot Hayleyes Shiferaw That +M Kitchen 9 100 900

67 Debot Belaynesh Simegn That +M Resid 28 100 2800

68 Debot Abebe Zegeyie That +M Resid 50 100 5000

69 Debot Ayalew Kassie That +M Resid. 95 100 9500

70 Debot Bitew Molla That +M Resid 20 100 2000

71 Debot Enananu Terefe Cor +M Resid 40 500 20000

72 Debot Acheneme Munayie Cor +M Resid 28 500 14000

73 Debot Emahoye Tekay Cor +M Resid 44 500 22000

74 Debot Emaway Retta That +M Resid 20 100 2000

75 Q6bot Abebu Retta That +M Resid 18 100 1800

76 Debot Alemu Belay Cor +M Resid 20 500 10000

77 Debot Aleme Berihune That +M Resid 18 100 1800

78 Debot Merecho Tesfayie That +M Resid 12 100 1200

79 Debot Aseres Ashagrie Cor +M Resid 16 500 8000

80 Debot Desalegn Assefa Cor +M Resid. 22 500 11000

81 Debot Alemie Addisu That +M Resid. 12 100 1200

82 Debot Zewdinesh Shiferaw Cor +M Resid. 18 500 9000

83 Debot Adugna Achameyelehe Cor +M Resid 24 500 12000

84 Debot Molla Tamen Cor +M Resid. 32 500 16000

85 Debot Atalu Abat Cor +M Resid 20 500 10000

86 Debot Me. Fikadu Kebede Cor +M Resid 28 500 14000

87 Debot Endale Abuneh Cor +M Resid 24 500 12000

88 Debot Derebaw Abuneh Cor +M Resid 24 500 12000

89 Debot Wendimu Terefe That +M Resid 30 100 3000

90 Debot Taddese Guangule That +M Resid 25 100 2500

91 Debot Yeshi Mekonen That +M Resid. 18 100 1800

92 Debot Genzebe Tewer That +M Resid 28 100 2800

93 Debot Merigeta Tesfa Taddese Cor +M Resid 28 500 14000

94 Debot Yiferu Gelagay Cor +M Resid. 12 500 6000

95 Debot Genzebe Yiferu Cor +M Resid. 18 500 9000

96 Debot Mekoya Yiferu Cor +M Resid 18 500 9000

97 Debot Aber Teref Cor +M Resid. 24 500 12000

98 d3bot Minale Dejen Cor +M Resid 12 500 6000

99 Debot Fentaw Ewenie Cor +M Resid. 12 500 6000

100 Debot Fikere Addis Belay Cor +M Resid. 12 500 6000

101 Debot Addisu Negash That +M Resid. 18 100 1800

102 Debot Mesfine Dejenie That +M Resid. 18 100 1800

103 Debot lemu Lema Cor +M Resid. 45 500 22500

104 Debot Alem Berihun That +M Resid. 45 100 4500

105 Debot Abebe Ayalew Cor +M Resid. 25 500 12500

106 Debot Yshihareg Ayalew That +M Resid 25 100 2500

107 Debot Ale Dejen That +M Resid 26 100 2600

108 Debot Dessalegn Assefa That +M Resid. 42 100 4200

109 Debot Sisay Dubale That +M Resid 46 100 4600

110 Debot Yimegnushale Biru Cor +M Resid 18 500 9000

111 Debot Marta Goshu That +M Resid. 20 100 2000

112 Debot Degu Wodajenew That +M Resid. 18 100 1800

113 Debot Getachew Ewenie Cor +M Resid 25 500 12500

114 Debot Tariku Yimam That +M Resid 12 100 1200

115 Debot Memir Geze That +M Resid 20 100 2000

116 Debot Melaku Chufa Cor +M Resid 24 500 12000

117 Debot Abat Guangule Cor +M Resid. 25 500 12500

118 Debot statkie Teshom Cor +M Resid. 25 500 12500

119 Debot Megenagn dejene Cor +M Resid 18 500 9000

120 Debot Molla Kebede Cor +M Resid 28 500 14000

121 Debot Takele Mekonen Cor +M Resid 28 500 14000

122 Zoffie Buziyie Feten That +Sto Resid 20 100 2000

123 Zoffie Simoen Rega That +Sto Resid 20 100 2000Total 1064100

Annex 7: Compensations for housesWereda: Giden

S.No |Chain. Kebele /locality Affected person HousesType Service Area M2 Unit Price Amount

IBirri1 Eyela Besifat Gizaw Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

2 Eyela Yirdaw Mengistu Corr +M Resid 42 500 21000

3 Eyela Abebe Winie Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

4 Eyela Webite Sisay That +Sto Resid 25 100 2500

5 Eyela Wodaje Miretu Corr +Sto Resid 20 500 10000

6 Eyela Chanie Gugsa Corr +Sto Resid 24 500 12000

7 Eyela Debetew Iyasu That +Sto Resid 25 100 2500

8 Chebena Molla Aragie That +Sto Resid 32 100 3200

9 Iy Chebena Kasy Getu That +Sto Resid 20 100 2000

10 Chebena Maerege Mengistu Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

11 Chebena Ashagrie Assefa Corr +M Resid 36 500 18000

12 Chebena Asiresaw Semahagn Corr +M Shop +R 36 500 18000

13 Chebena Kasayie Dejen That +Sto Resid 20 100 2000

14 Chebena Desale Mengistu That +Sto Kithen 6 100 600

15 Chebena Wodajo Yimere Corr +Sto Resid 24 500 12000

16 Chebena Tesfa Mesele Corr +Sto Gri mil 38 500 19000

17 Chebena Getta Sitotaw That +Stc Resid 40 100 4000

18 - Chebena Endalew Demeke That +Sto Resid 20 100 2000

19 Chebena Kasa Adan Corr +Sto Resid 20 500 10000

20 Chebena Aragaw Habtam Corr +Sto Resid 24 500 12000

21 Chebena Fanta Asegie Corr +Sto Resid 22 500 11000

22 . Chebena Mebit Lebase Corr +Sto Kithen 6 500 3000

23 = Chebena Desale Tenaw That +Sto Kithen 6 100 600

24 Chebena Menbere Woldie That +Sto Resid 20 100 2000

=___ _____ _______________________________ Total 199900


Wereda:Meket

Remark/S.No Kebele /locality Affected persons

Type Service Area M 2 Unit Price AmBorurnt

1 033 Haftame Addisu That +M Resid 20 100 2000

2 032 Tesfayie Dejen Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

3 032 Desalegn Adane Corr +M Resid 18 500 9000

4 032 - Etenesh Sisay Corr +M Guar H 8 500 4000

5 Estayish (031) Sheh Mudesire Alahe Corr +M Resid 30 500 15000

6 Estayish (031) Besifate Ayalew Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

7 Estayish (031) Yalew Desale Corr +M Resid 24 500 12000

8 Estayish (031) Mesele Kasaw That +Sto Resid 45 100 4500

9 Estayish (031) Kereme Worke Abera Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

10 Gashena Addan demissie Corr +M Garaje 40 500 20000

11 022 Mulu Ashagrie Corr +M S Shop 9 500 4500

12 022 Eshetu Molla That +M Resid 75 100 7500

13 022 - Fikere Bezabeh rhat +m :'itchen 9 100 900

14 Arbit (020) Mulugela Ayalew Corr +M Kitchen 9 500 4500

15 Arbit (020) Wondinew Chekole That +M Kitchen 12 100 1200

16 Arbit (020) Desita Sitotaw Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

17 Arbit (020) Gejef Gubay Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

18 Arbit;(020) Workie Ayele Corr +M Shop 12 500 6000

19 Arbit (020) Ehitie Alelegn Corr +M Shop 16 500 8000

20 Arbit (020) Tsefa bayle Corr +M Resid 26 500 13000

21 Arbit (020) Tamen Fetene Corr +M Resid 22 500 11000

22 Anchibe (019) Tseganew Mekonen 'That +M Kitchen 12 100 1200

23 Anchibe (019) Teferi Hailu That +M 5Resid 74 100 7400

24 Anchibe (019) Dejen Teferi Corr +M S. Shop 8 500 4000

25 Anchibe (019) Yenigus Mokonen Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

26 Anchibe (019) Assefa Alemu Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

27 Anchibe (019) Etalem Miskie That +M Resid 30 100 3000

28 nchibe (019) Wosen Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

29 014 sinakew Miretie Corr +M Kitchen 8 500 4000

30 014 Mamdie Tadele Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

31 Geregera (02) Belaynesh Abaye Corr +M S Shop 8 500 4000

32 Geregera (02) Etenat Amar Corr +M Shop +R 36 500 18000

33 Geregera (02) Assefa Endalew Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

34 Geregera (02) Aseferie Beyen Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

35 Geregera (02) Taddese Berihun Corr +M Resid 28 500 14000

36 Geregera (02) Abebe Getu Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

37 Geregera (01) Geses Miheret Corr +M Gri Mill 50 500 25000

38 Geregera (01) Absent That +M Resid 30 100 3000

39 03 Woletesilassie Tarek That +M Resid 30 100 3000

40 03 Fiker Tureneh That +M Resid 30 100 3000

41 Agreet (04) Ayenew Assefaw Corr +M Resid. 22 500 11000

42 Ag1reet (04) Maserrie Getahun Corr +M Shop +R 25 500 12500

43 Agreet (04) Mulate Sitotaw Corr +M Resid 75 500 37500

44 Agreet (04) Mer Worku Corr +M Resid 40 500 20000

45 Berekeza (08) Habite Shumetu Corr +M Resid. 30 500 15000

46 Berekeza (08) Nigat Alli Corr +M Resid 40 500 20000

47 Berekeza (08) Abera Asnak That +M Resid 25 100 2500

48 Berekeza (08) Tiruneh Belew Corr +M Resid 42 500 21000

49 Berekeza (08) Meaza Shummie Corr +M Resid 30 500 15000

50 Berekeza (08) Atalel Abera That +m Resid. 36 100 3600

51 Berekeza (08) Kes Dagnaw Miretu That +m Resid 34 100 3400

52 Berekeza (08) Alemitu Feleke T-hat +m Resid 25 100 2500

53 Debrezebit (011) Birrie Mengistie That +m Resid 60 100 6000

54 Debrezebit (011) Etalem Dagnew Corr +M Resid 36 500 18000

55 Debrezebit (011) Ashafrie Demissie Corr +M Shop +R 44 500 22000

56 DebVezebit (011) Wondiyie Birhan Corr +M Resid. 30 500 15000

57 Debrezebit (011) Buzayehu Molla Corr +M Resid 35 500 17500

58 Debrezebit (011) Bizuy;e Tarekegn That +m Resid 60 100 6000

59 Debrezebit (011) Yekaba Tiru That +m Resid 35 100 3500

60 Debrezebit (011) Getenet Alemenew T'hat +m Resid. 32 100 3200

61 Debrezebit (011) Tesfayie Assefa Corr +M Resid 18 500 9000

62 Debirezebit (011) Asimamaw Zewiddie Corr +M Resid 40 500 20000

63 Debrezebit (011) Tihunie Mengistu Corr +M Resid. 22 500 11000

64 Debrezebit (011) Akelu Gedamu That +m Resid. 18 100 1800

65 Debrezebit (011) Yimegnushal Engida That +m Resid. 24 100 2400Total 642100


Wereda:Laygayint

Houses

S.No Kebele /locality Affected person

Type Service Area M 2 Unit Price Amount IBirrI

1 Checheho (019) Geta Molla Corr +M Resid 49 500 24500

2 Checheho (019) Nigus Gelasew Tha +M Resid 30 100 3000

3 Checheho (019) Tiruyie Teshom Tha +M Resid. 30 100 3000

4 Checheho (019) Deribew Belay -Corr +M Resid 30 500 15000

5 Checheho (019) MebiratuGelay Corr +M Resid 25 500 12500

6 Checheho (019) Misgan Gelaw Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

7 Checheho (019) Yidenke Beyen Tha +M Resid 25 100 2500

8 Checheho (019) Mwayie Assefa Tha +M Resid 25 100 2500

9 Checheho (019) Tizazu Turyie Tha +M Resid 25 100 2500

10 Checheho (019) Fenta Shibeshi Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

11 Checheho '019) Alemu Shumie Tha +M Resid 20 100 2000

12 Checheho (019) Kegne Negatu Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

13 Checheho (019) Taddese Gebrie Tha +M Rcsid 30 100 3000

14 NifaseLMewcha (01) Melake Tegegn Corr +M Resid 9 500 4500

15 Nifase Mewcha (01) ShigenbiSh Beyen Corr +M Resid 9 500 4500

16 Nifas.Mewcha (01) Setargie Adimas Corr +M Shop +R 12 500 6000

17 Nifase Mewcha (01) Aleme Dessie Corr +M Resid 9 500 4500

18 Nifas~e,IMewcha (01) Zeweditu Seyoum Corr +M Resid 8 500 4000

19 Nifase Mewcha (01) Kasa Leyew Corr +M Resid 8 500 4000

20 Nifase'Mewcha (01) Shumeyie Abate Corr +M Resid 15 500 7500

21 Nifase Mewcha (01) Fantahun Molla Corr +M Resid 8 500 4000

22 Nifase'Mewcha (01) Fantayie Ayele Corr +M Resid 16 500 8000

23 Nifase Mewcha (01) Fasil Atnafu Corr +M Resid 16 500 8000

24 Nifase Mewcha (01) Zewedie Alene Corr +M Resid 18 500 9000

25 Nifase Mewcha (01) Alebacchew Kassie Corr +M Resid. 18 500 9000

26 Nifase Mewcha (01) Misgan Guangule Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

27 Nifase Mewcha (01) Nigussie Woreta Corr +M Resid. 20 500 10000

28 Nifase Mewcha (01) Emahoy Tekuam Corr +M Resid 18 500 9000

29 Nifase Mewcha (02) Telecommunication Corr +H B G H 8 1500 12000

30 Gogob (01) Getu Asnake Corr +M Resid 8 500 4000

31 Gogob,(01) Desitaw Teferi Corr +M Resid 8 500 4000

32 Gogob-(01) Dargew Sisay Corr +M Resid 12 500 6000

33 Gogob (01) Tiruyle Alebachew Corr +M Resid 15 500 7500

34 Gogob (01) Arega Sintayehu Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

35 Gogob,(01) Dessie Kiberet Corr +M Resid 18 500 9000

36 Gogob (01) Tesifa Adan Corr +M Resid. 24 500 12000

37 Gogob (01) Yenigusish Adugna Tha +M Resid 30 100 3000

Total 270000

Annex 7. Compensations for affected houses

Wereda:Farta

HousesS.No Kebele /locality Affected person

Type Service Area M Unit Price Amount IBirrl

1 Aregedidim Tesfayie Nigussie Corr +M Grin Mill 42 500 21000

2 Aregedidim Abebaw Teshom That +M Tyre Rep 9 100 900

3 Aregedidim Amiha Berelie Corr +M Resid 16 500 8000

4 Aregedidim Abebaw Atalel That +M Resid 20 100 2000

5 Aregedidim Baddie Mebratie That +M Resid 25 100 2500

6 Atasifatire Esubalew Mebratie That +M Kithen 15 100 1500

7 Gasay Tirualem Wondimu Corr +M Shop 72 100 7200

8 Gasay Asefa Haile Corr+M Resid 16 500 8000

9 Gasay Fekadie Turuneh Corr +M S Shop 9 500 4500

10 Gasay Ashagrie Alemu Tnat +M Resid 50 100 5000

11 Gasay Mandefro Gebeyehu Corr +M Shop +R 40 500 20000

12 Azawer Nega Demissie That +M Resid 48 100 4800

13 Azawer Walelign Demeweze Triat +M Kithen 18 100 1800

14 Wedebiko Endeshaw Tsehay Triat +M Kithen 14 100 1400

15 Wedebiko Arega Derese I hat +M ';ithen 6 100 600

16 Debre Tabore (01) Mulugeta Molla Corr +M S Shop 6 500 3000

17 Debre Tabore (01) Alebachew Dagnie Corr +M S Shop 6 500 3000

18 Debre Tabore (01) Woreku Cherie Corr +M Resid 35 500 17500

19 Debre Tabore (01) Getachew Biyadeg Corr +M Resid. 15 500 7500

20 Debie Tabore (01) Alemenesh Webie Corr +M Resid 30 500 15000

21 Debre Tabore (01) Yalebonesh Assefaw Corr +M Resid. 30 500 15000

22 Debre Tabore (01) Askal Fiseha Corr +M Resid 30 500 15000

23 Debre Tabore (01) Enhabitua Dubale Corr +M Resid 20 500 10000

24 Debre Tabore (01) Gashaw Tegegn Corr +M Resid 18 500 9000

25 Debre Tabore (05) Muchie Meles C(orr +M Tea Ro 78 500 39000

26 Debre Tabore (09) Deres Damitie Corr +M S Shop 6 500 3000

27 Debre Tabore (09) Ayale Belay Corr +M S Shop 6 500 3000

Total 229200

Documents

Public Disclosure Authorized RP1 36 - World Bank · 2016. 7. 17. · °F\lakit *WOLDIYA Scale 20 Km Abay Engineering 2. RAP; Woreta - Woldiya Final Report EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Introduction