1
BOOK REVIEWS Psychosomatic Medicine and Liaison Psychiatry: Selected Papers By Z. J. Lipowski. New York. Plenum Medical Book Company. 1985.453 pp. $39.95. • Z. J. Lipowski occupies a unique position within the field of consulta- tion-liaison psychiatry. An undisput- ed scholar with meticulously refer- enced papers, he has been the contem- porary historian of consultation- liaison psychiatry, sage editorial com- mentator on developments in psycho- somatic medicine, and conceptual synthesizer. He has made important contributions to our understanding of delirium and dementia via a number of important clinical studies. This publi- cation collects his contributions in one volume. The book is divided into four sec- tions. The first includes papers devot- ed to theoretical concepts within psy- chosomatic medicine. The second section is composed of two unpub- lished papers that review psychosocial reactions to physical illness. The third is devoted to physical illness and psy- chopathology, and the fourth to con- sultation-liaison psychiatry. Included is the three-part review of consultation psychiatry and psychoso- matic medicine published in 1967-68, which continues to be an essential se- ries to be reviewed and assimilated by all psychiatrists. Written almost two decades ago, these papers still chal- lenge the clinical investigator and practitioner who works at the interface between psychiatry and medicine. Problems of specificity, measurement and definition of body image, and the best approach to define psychosomat- ic medicine are all addressed in this triad. Fortunately, Lipowski's more recent article, "What does the word 302 'psychosomatic' really mean? A his- torical and semantic inquiry," is also included to help define this complicat- ed tenn. The author's classic paper, "Delirium, clouding of conscious- ness, and confusion," is another es- sential review. The volume also in- cludes a previously unpublished gem, "The concept and psychopathology of dementia," which presents an ele- gant historical account as well as the author's concise description of de- mentia ... Sensory and information overload: Behavioral effects" is im- portant in its review of both theoretical and clinical infonnation. In all, the seven previously unpublished papers included in this volume provide a rich source of new material for the reader. The two papers in Part 2 offer a ma- jor review of the broad range of ap- proaches to an individual's reaction to physical illness. Such reviews are unique in this age of computerized data retrieval by their magnificent or- ganization and scholarly bibliogra- phies that demonstrate to the student that literature searches should not be done by computer alone. The last section can be read and re- read to look at consultation-liaison psychiatry's political status at various points in time. Unfortunately, consul- tation-liaison psychiatry has not re- ceived the financial stability it merits. Lipowski does not shirk this problem, but directly examines the concepts and controversies of the field. In re- viewing the final papers, a series of commentaries on the past, present, and future status of consultation-liai- son psychiatry, the reader must take heart at the variety of clinical options that face us. Despite problems of funding and competition from other disciplines, such as liaison nursing and behavioral medicine, consulta- tion-liaison psychiatry has a large constituency to serve. Interestingly, in his closing paper, Lipowski calls for the integration of liaison psy- chiatry with geropsychiatry. The book provides a sense of excitement and hope. The author's el- egance and scholastic rigor should be a role model to all. This stands as an extraordinary volume by itself and is a wonderful follow-up to the author's important monograph on delirium. I Over the years, I have found that my reprints of the articles included in this book have been repeatedly 'penna- nently borrowed' by colleagues, stu- dents, and residents. With this in mind, the book should be carefully lo- cated within one's office to prevent its loss. Its scope, detail, and clarity of presentation make it important read- ing for psychiatrists, and it should be on the shelves of all medical libraries . TlwfTUJS N. Wise, M.D. Georgetown University REFERENCE 1. Lipowski ZJ: Delirium. Springfield, III, Charles CThomas, 1980. Handbook of Geriatric Psychopharmacology By Michael A. Jenike, Littleton. Mass, PSG Publishing, 1985, 167 pp, $20. • Dr. Jenike, who is co-director of the Geriatric Psychiatry Memory Disor- ders Clinic at Massachusetts General Hospital and editor of the monthly newsletter Massachusetts General Hospital Topics in Geriatrics has written an excellent handbook review- ing a variety of topics including al- tered drug metabolism; psychosis, rage, and violence; affective illness; anxiety; Alzheimer's disease and other dementias; insomnia; and diag- (continued) PSYCHOSOMATICS

Psychosomatic Medicine and Liaison Psychiatry: Selected Papers

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

BOOK REVIEWS

Psychosomatic Medicineand Liaison Psychiatry:Selected PapersBy Z. J. Lipowski. New York. Plenum MedicalBook Company. 1985.453 pp. $39.95.

• Z. J. Lipowski occupies a uniqueposition within the field of consulta­tion-liaison psychiatry. An undisput­ed scholar with meticulously refer­enced papers, he has been the contem­porary historian of consultation­liaison psychiatry, sage editorial com­mentator on developments in psycho­somatic medicine, and conceptualsynthesizer. He has made importantcontributions to our understanding ofdelirium and dementia via a number ofimportant clinical studies. This publi­cation collects his contributions in onevolume.

The book is divided into four sec­tions. The first includes papers devot­ed to theoretical concepts within psy­chosomatic medicine. The secondsection is composed of two unpub­lished papers that review psychosocialreactions to physical illness. The thirdis devoted to physical illness and psy­chopathology, and the fourth to con­sultation-liaison psychiatry.

Included is the three-part review ofconsultation psychiatry and psychoso­matic medicine published in 1967-68,which continues to be an essential se­ries to be reviewed and assimilated byall psychiatrists. Written almost twodecades ago, these papers still chal­lenge the clinical investigator andpractitioner who works at the interfacebetween psychiatry and medicine.Problems of specificity, measurementand definition of body image, and thebest approach to define psychosomat­ic medicine are all addressed in thistriad. Fortunately, Lipowski's morerecent article, "What does the word

302

'psychosomatic' really mean? A his­torical and semantic inquiry, " is alsoincluded to help define this complicat­ed tenn. The author's classic paper,"Delirium, clouding of conscious­ness, and confusion," is another es­sential review. The volume also in­cludes a previously unpublished gem,"The concept and psychopathologyof dementia, " which presents an ele­gant historical account as well as theauthor's concise description of de­mentia...Sensory and informationoverload: Behavioral effects" is im­portant in its review ofboth theoreticaland clinical infonnation. In all, theseven previously unpublished papersincluded in this volume provide a richsource of new material for the reader.

The two papers in Part 2 offer a ma­jor review of the broad range of ap­proaches to an individual's reaction tophysical illness. Such reviews areunique in this age of computerizeddata retrieval by their magnificent or­ganization and scholarly bibliogra­phies that demonstrate to the studentthat literature searches should not bedone by computer alone.

The last section can be read and re­read to look at consultation-liaisonpsychiatry's political status at variouspoints in time. Unfortunately, consul­tation-liaison psychiatry has not re­ceived the financial stability it merits.Lipowski does not shirk this problem,but directly examines the conceptsand controversies of the field. In re­viewing the final papers, a series ofcommentaries on the past, present,and future status of consultation-liai­son psychiatry, the reader must takeheart at the variety of clinical optionsthat face us. Despite problems offunding and competition from otherdisciplines, such as liaison nursingand behavioral medicine, consulta-

tion-liaison psychiatry has a largeconstituency to serve. Interestingly,in his closing paper, Lipowski callsfor the integration of liaison psy­chiatry with geropsychiatry.

The book provides a sense ofexcitement and hope. The author's el­egance and scholastic rigor should bea role model to all. This stands as anextraordinary volume by itself and is awonderful follow-up to the author'simportant monograph on delirium. I

Over the years, I have found that myreprints of the articles included in thisbook have been repeatedly 'penna­nently borrowed' by colleagues, stu­dents, and residents. With this inmind, the book should be carefully lo­cated within one's office to prevent itsloss. Its scope, detail, and clarity ofpresentation make it important read­ing for psychiatrists, and it should beon the shelves of all medical libraries .

TlwfTUJS N. Wise, M.D.Georgetown University

REFERENCE1. Lipowski ZJ: Delirium. Springfield, III, Charles

CThomas, 1980.

Handbook of GeriatricPsychopharmacologyBy Michael A. Jenike, Littleton. Mass, PSGPublishing, 1985, 167 pp, $20.

• Dr. Jenike, who is co-directorof theGeriatric Psychiatry Memory Disor­ders Clinic at Massachusetts GeneralHospital and editor of the monthlynewsletter Massachusetts GeneralHospital Topics in Geriatrics haswritten an excellent handbook review­ing a variety of topics including al­tered drug metabolism; psychosis,rage, and violence; affective illness;anxiety; Alzheimer's disease andother dementias; insomnia; and diag-

(continued)

PSYCHOSOMATICS