7/24/2019 Protein Paper Review
1/1
CHEM-GA 3010 Fall 2015Review Assignment
Reviewer Name: Jonathan OswaldManuscrit title: Unraveling the
Mechanism of Protein Disaggregation Through
a ClpB-DnaK nteraction
!lease ran" t#e manuscrit acc$r%ing t$ t#e criteria &el$w
'mar" wit# an ()* !lease ta"e int$acc$unt t#at articles s#$ul%
re$rt unu&lis#e% w$r" t#at %escri&es new insig#ts
an%+$rc$ncetual &rea"t#r$ug#s $, aeal t$ t#e rea%ers#i $, t#e
$urnal
!ot suita"le for pu"licationin chosen #ournal
$uita"le for chosen #ournal
%owest Moderate &igh Top '(
$ignificance )
!ovelt* )
Broad interest )
$cholarl* presentation )
!lease res$n% t$ t#e ,$ll$wing'mar" wit# an ()
+es !o n Part
,re the conclusions adeuatel* supported"* the data.
)
,re the literature references appropriateand correct.
)
Do the contents #ustif* the length of themanuscript.
)
Rec$mmen%ati$n 'mar" wit# an ()Pu"lish without change
) Pu"lish after minor revisions
/econsider after ma#or revisions
Too preliminar* for pu"licationPu"lish elsewhere
Do not pu"lish
Other0
C$mments t$ t#e aut#$rs
+our paper does a thorough #o" investigating the interactions of
the proteins of1protein disaggregation23 using a revolutionar* !M/
method that allows fordetection of meth*l groups of particular
amino acids4 found m*self wonderingwhat the true significance of
this information was5 *ou presented the importanceof this
understanding in a wa* that suggested have a thorough understanding
of
this topic alread*2 forgetting to highlight the grand scheme
importance4 thin6what is highlighted is the importance of this !M/
techniue2 which can "e usedto stud* protein-protein interactions in
a new2 convenient manner4
