22
" #$%"&’ () *’% +%"&% " #$%&’(’)"$* $%#+$, +- +./%$0",’+)/ 12$’)3 ,4% 5676 ,-. /0112* 82)% 59: 5676

Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"!#$%"&'!!()!*'%!+%"&%!

!

!

!

! !

!

!

!

!!

"!!#$%&'(')"$*!$%#+$,!+-!+./%$0",'+)/!!

12$')3!,4%!5676!,-.!/0112*!

!

82)%!59:!5676! !

Page 2: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"!

!

!

#$%&!'&!()*&!+*,(-.'/0-!1(-0*/2!/3*!1/.**/14!/3*!)'.514!'&+!(/3*.!)6780-!)8'-*1!'.*!'&!0,)(./'&/!

9'-080/2! 9(.! )6780-! +01-6110(&! '&+! )(80/0-'8! ).(-*11:!! ;3*2! '.*! 0&! 7.0*9! '! )6780-! 9(.6,! /3'/! /3*!

-0/0<*&! -'&! -(,,'&+**.=! /3*! >*&*.(10/2! '&+! *,)'/32! ?0/3! ?30-3! 16-3! 9'-080/0*1! '.*! ,'+*!

'@'08'78*!01!'&!0&+*A!(9!9.**+(,:!

!

!"#$%&'#$('"&')&$*+,-./$01)-2$345")6-$&2$0+'+7+!

"#$$%&&''!(#)!&*'!"#$$#+,'-.&*!#(!"-+-/-!01!"-+-/-/$89::9;$9$<#0#!#$9=:$

!

!

!

B(6!+(!&(/!3'@*!/(!-3((1*!7*/?**&!1/.(&>4!*99*-/0@*!)(80-0&>!(.!/3*!36,'&!.0>3/1!')).('-3:!

B(6!-'&!,'..2!/3*!/?(:!

!

2'$#+3&)-&%+4!)'35'6&!(#)!)%4*&37!8!*9$-+!)%4*&3!-55)#-6*!&#!5#.%6%+4!5)#&'3&!!

>?$3&)'"$@+.A)+,-'"+.B$0&,,)""--$&'$%4,+'$!)C1"5/$DEE:$

!

!

!

C1!'&! 0&+*)*&+*&/!(71*.@*.! 9(.!DDEC!(&!/3*!1/.**/1!(9!;(.(&/(!+6.0&>!/3*!FGHI!16,,0/4! $!

?'1!'15*+!72!'!)(80-*!(990-*.!?3'/!$!?'1!+(0&>!1/'&+0&>!(&!/3*!10+*?'85!!"#:!!$!*A)8'0&*+!/3'/4!

805*!30,4!$!?'1!0&!/3*!7610&*11!(9!>6'.+0&>!!"#$%&$!.0>3/1:!!

$00*($%4,+'$!)C1"5$F&')"&.$

34'-$DG/$DE9E$

$

$

$

$

Page 3: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

H!

!

Page 4: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

J!

!

HIH0>JKLH$<>FF(!MN$

;3*!!#'#()#'*!"#$%&$*+,*-)."%/*#'(*0$&&(+1/*>6'.'&/**1!*@*.2(&*!0&!D'&'+'!/3*!.0>3/!/(!9.**+(,!(9!

*A).*110(&!'&+!/3*!.0>3/!/(!)*'-*968!'11*,782:! $/!'81(!>6'.'&/**1!/3*!.0>3/!(9!'88!)*.1(&1!/(!7*!9.**!

9.(,!'.70/.'.2!+*/*&/0(&!'&+!6&.*'1(&'78*! 1*'.-3!'&+! 1*0<6.*:!;3*1*!-(&1/0/6/0(&'8! 807*./0*1! $!'&+!

/3*! 80,0/1! /3*2!)8'-*! (&! >(@*.&,*&/! '&+! )(80-*! $! '.*! /3*! 9(6&+'/0(&1!(9! (6.! 9.**! '&+!+*,(-.'/0-!

1(-0*/2:! ;3*!FHI! K6,,0/! +0+! &(/! '6/3(.0<*! (.!?'..'&/! /3*0.! 161)*&10(&:! D(&1/0/6/0(&'8! >6'.'&/**1!

,'//*.!7*-'61*4!'1!01!(9/*&!1'0+4!?0/3(6/!/3*,4!%*@*&!/3*!,(1/!+*,(-.'/0-!1(-0*/2!-(68+!'88!/((!*'1082!

9'88!).*2!/(!/3*!'761*1!'&+!*A-*11*1!(9!'!)(80-*!1/'/*:&"!

!

$/!01!/3*!()0&0(&!(9!/3*!D'&'+0'&!D0@08!E07*./0*1!C11(-0'/0(&!/3'/!)(80-*!-(&+6-/!+6.0&>!/3*!FHI!K6,,0/!

?'14! '/! /0,*14! +01).()(./0(&'/*4! '.70/.'.2! '&+! *A-*110@*:! ! $&! (6.! @0*?4! +*1)0/*! 0&1/'&-*1! (9!

-(,,*&+'78*! '&+! ).(9*110(&'8! -(&+6-/4! /3*! )(80-0&>! '&+! 1*-6.0/2! *99(./14! *1)*-0'882! '9/*.! LMN!(&!

O6&*!HP!'&+!O6&*!HQ4!9'08*+!/(!+*,(&1/.'/*!-(,,0/,*&/!/(!'()(*(+,--(&1/0/6/0(&'8!@'86*1:!!

!

;3*!-(&+0/0(&1!9(.!1(,*!(9!/3*!)(80-0&>!).(78*,1!/3'/!?*.*!*A)*.0*&-*+!+6.0&>!/3*!16,,0/!?*.*!1*/!

+6.0&>!/3*!).*)'.'/(.2!1/'>*:!!;301!.*)(./!(6/80&*1!1(,*!(9!/3*!0116*1!/3'/!6&+*.,0&*+!/3*!1*-6.0/2!

*99(./1:!R(.!*A',)8*4!/3*!8'-5!(9!/.'&1)'.*&-2!16..(6&+0&>!/3*!+*10>&'/0(&!(9!/3*!1*-6.0/2!)*.0,*/*.!

(,-(-%./0123-4567&-18*-95-:2,/)*86,9()*2);,-(,-95-9<8-,35.8-5=-,8(63<-()*-,82>/68-.5486,-()*?-2)-5/6-

@0*?4! /(!'&! 0&')).().0'/*!61*!(9!/3*! /3*1*!)(?*.1:! !;3*! 8'.>*!&6,7*.!(9!)(80-*!(990-*.1!+6.0&>! /3*!

?**5!8*'+0&>!/(!/3*!FHI!>*&*.'/*+!7(/3!'!161)0-0(&!(9!?'1/*+!.*1(6.-*1!'&+!'!1*&/0,*&/!(9!)(/*&/0'8!

0&/0,0+'/0(&:!!O6&*!HP!.*).*1*&/1!'!/6.&0&>!)(0&/:!!!S0+*1).*'+!).()*./2!+','>*!?'1!-(,,0//*+!72!'!

-(3(./!(9!@'&+'81! 0&! /3*!+(?&/(?&!(9!;(.(&/(!(&!/3'/!+'2:!S*!-(&+*,&!/301!-.0,0&'8!'-/0@0/2!'&+!

'-5&(?8*+>*!/3'/!0/!?'..'&/*+!'!.*1)(&1*!72!)(80-*:!;3*!.*1)(&1*!?30-3!)(80-*!).(@0+*+4!3(?*@*.4!

?'1!6&).*-*+*&/*+4!+01).()(./0(&'/*!'&+4!'/!/0,*14!6&-(&1/0/6/0(&'8:!!

!

T@*.!/3*!&*A/!JP!3(6.14!(@*.!UII!)*()8*!V)(110782!-8(1*!/(!"IIIW!?*.*!'..*1/*+!72!)(80-*!$!/3*!8'.>*1/!

,'11G'..*1/! 0&! D'&'+0'&! 301/(.2:! N*+0'4! 36,'&! .0>3/1! ,(&0/(.14! ).(/*1/(.1! '&+! )'11*.1G72! ?*.*!

1-(()*+! 6)! (99! /3*! 1/.**/1:! X*/'0&*+! )*()8*! ?*.*! &(/! '88(?*+! /(! 1)*'5! /(! '! 8'?2*.! (.! /(! /3*0.!

9',080*1:!!C.70/.'.2!1*'.-3*1!(--6..*+!0&!-(6&/8*11!8(-'/0(&1!'-.(11!/3*!-0/24!0&!,'&2!0&1/'&-*1!1*@*.'8!

508(,*/*.1!9.(,!/3*!FHI!16,,0/!10/*:!!M*'-*968!).(/*1/1!?*.*!@0(8*&/82!+01)*.1*+!'&+!9(.-*!?'1!61*+:!!

$&!'&!*99(./!/(!8(-'/*!'&+!+01'78*!"IIG"LI!@'&+'814!/3*!)(80-*!+01.*>'.+*+!/3*!-(&1/0/6/0(&'8!.0>3/1!(9!

/3(61'&+1:!!!

!

$&!).*)'.'/0(&!9(.!/301!.*)(./4!/3*!DDEC!+01)'/-3*+!(@*.!LI!36,'&!.0>3/1!,(&0/(.1!/(!,'5*!90.1/G3'&+!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"!! O61/0-*!D(.2!(9!/3*!K6).*,*!D(6./!(9!D'&'+'!0&!-2!@:!3%+$$&44!!#"UUI%!"!K:D:Y:!HZ"4!)'.:!"Z!

Page 5: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

Z!

!

(71*.@'/0(&1!(9!/3*!)(80-*!).*1*&-*!'/!FHIG.*8'/*+!+*,(&1/.'/0(&1!/3.(6>3(6/!/3*!?**5:!T6.!.*)(./!

3<65)2318,- 9<8- 2)32*8)9,- 9<(9- 9<8- ''@A+,- </,'&! .0>3/1!,(&0/(.1!?0/&*11*+! /3.(6>3(6/! /3*! 16,,0/!

'&+4!?3*.*! 0&+0-'/*+4!.*)(./1!?*!3'@*!.*-*0@*+!9.(,!,*,7*.1!(9!/3*!)6780-!'&+!3'@*!@*.090*+!'&+!

9(6&+!/.61/?(./32:!!;3*.*!'.*4!(9!-(6.1*4!,'&2!*A',)8*1!(9!@*.2!-(,)*/*&/!'&+!).(9*110(&'8!-(&+6-/!

(&!/3*!)'./!(9!)(80-*!(990-*.1!/3.(6>3(6/!/3*!?**5!?30-3!?*.*!&(/*+!72!(6.!,(&0/(.1:!S*!-*./'0&82!

'-5&(?8*+>*! /3'/! /3*! )(80-*! 9'-*+! '! +0990-68/! /'15:! [(&*/3*8*114! D'&'+0'&1! '.*! *&/0/8*+! /(! )(80-0&>!

/3'/! +(*1! &(/! 6&+*.,0&*! -(&1/0/6/0(&'8! @'86*1:! ! ! \&9(./6&'/*824! ?*! -(&10+*.! /3'/! /3*! '761*1!

-3.(&0-8*+!0&!/301!.*)(./!*A-**+!/3*!/3.*13(8+!(9!'!9*?!01(8'/*+!0&-0+*&/1:!$&!(6.!@0*?4!/3*2!.*).*1*&/!

0&1/'&-*1!(9!0&')).().0'/*!)(80-0&>!/3'/!-'&&(/!10,)82!7*!1?*)/!'?'2!'1!/3*!FHI!*&+1:!!;3*2!+*,'&+!

'--(6&/'7080/2:!!

!

;3*! DDEC! 01! -'880&>! (&! '88! 8*@*81! (9! >(@*.&,*&/! /(! /'5*! 0,,*+0'/*! '-/0(&! /(! -(..*-/! 1(,*! (9! /3*!

?*'5&*11*1!0&!/3*!8*>'8!9.',*?(.5!16..(6&+0&>!)6780-!(.+*.!)(80-0&>!0&!D'&'+':!$/!'81(!+*,'&+1!/3'/!

0&+*)*&+*&/!0&]60.0*1!7*!-(&+6-/*+!0&/(!1*@*.'8!'1)*-/1!(9!/3*!)(80-0&>!+6.0&>!/3*!FHI!K6,,0/:!!

!

$&!)'./0-68'.4!?*!'15!9(.^!

!

": Y*)*'8! (.! 10>&090-'&/! ',*&+,*&/! (9! /3*! 5678)9* :+$;/* 5$+%&9%)+'* <9%* /(! ,**/! 7'10-!

-(&1/0/6/0(&'8!1/'&+'.+1!

H: S0/3+.'?'8!(9!'88!-3'.>*1!8'0+!6&+*.!/3*!5678)9*:+$;/*5$+%&9%)+'*<9%!

J: $,)8*,*&/'/0(&!(9!-(&168/'/0(&!'&+!/.'&1)'.*&-2!.*]60.*,*&/1!9(.!.*>68'/(.2!).(-*11*1!

Z: C)(8(>2!9.(,!/3*!T&/'.0(!>(@*.&,*&/!9(.!/3*!).(-*11!61*+!/(!'+()/!/3*!+*10>&'/0(&!)6.16'&/!

/(!/3*!5678)9*:+$;/*5$+%&9%)+'*<9%!!

L: $,)8*,*&/'/0(&!(9!7*//*.!>60+*80&*1!9(.!/3*!*1/'78013,*&/!(9!1*-6.0/2!)*.0,*/*.1!

P: Y*>68'/0(&!(9!&*?!-.(?+!-(&/.(8!/*-3&(8(>0*1!).0(.!/(!/3*0.!61*!'&+!+*)8(2,*&/!

Q: D(,)*&1'/0(&!9(.!7610&*11!(?&*.1!'&+!9(.!)*.1(&1!?.(&>96882!'..*1/*+!

_: C,*&+,*&/1!/(!/3*!!$)1)'#8*!+(&!/(!,(+*.&0<*!'&+!7.0&>!6)!/(!-(&1/0/6/0(&'8!1/'&+'.+1!/3*!

).(@010(&1!.*8'/0&>!/(!7.*'-3!(9!/3*!)*'-*4!6&8'?968!'11*,780*1!'&+!.0(/1!

U: R688!0&+*)*&+*&/!0&]60.2!0&/(!/3*!'-/0(&1!(9!/3*!)(80-*!+6.0&>!/3*!FHI4!0&!)'./0-68'.^!

': ;3*!+01)*.1'8!(9!).(/*1/*.1!'/! /3*!+*10>&'/*+!+*,(&1/.'/0(&! 10/*! 2)-B/88)+,-C(67-(&!

K'/6.+'2!O6&*!HP/3!!

7: ;3*!+*/*&/0(&!'&+!,'11!'..*1/!(&!/3*!`1)8'&'+*!(&!/3*!&0>3/!(9!K'/6.+'2!O6&*!HP/3!!

-: ;3*! '..*1/1! '&+! )(80-*! '-/0(&1! (6/10+*! /3*! `'1/*.&! C@*:! +*/*&/0(&! -*&/.*! (&! /3*!

,(.&0&>!(9!K6&+'24!O6&*!HQ/3!!

+: ;3*!).(8(&>*+!+*/*&/0(&!'&+!,'11!'..*1/!(9!0&+0@0+6'81!'/!a6**&!K/:!S:!'&+!K)'+0&'!

C@*:!(&!/3*!*@*&0&>!(9!K6&+'24!O6&*!HQ/3!

*: ;3*!-(&+0/0(&1!(9!+*/*&/0(&!'/!/3*!`'1/*.&!C@*:!+*/*&/0(&!-*&/.*!!

Page 6: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

L!

!

!

$ $

Page 7: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

P!

!

KOJ!PQ>0JKPON$

$

;3*!!#'#()#'*!"#$%&$*+,*-)."%/*#'(*0$&&(+1/*>6'.'&/**1!*@*.2(&*!0&!D'&'+'!/3*!.0>3/!/(!9.**+(,!(9!

*A).*110(&!'&+!/3*!.0>3/!/(!)*'-*968!'11*,782:!$&/*.&'/0(&'8!,**/0&>1!'.*!'&!(--'10(&!9(.!)*()8*!/(!

*A).*11!/3*0.!'>.**,*&/!(.!+01'>.**,*&/!?0/3!/3*0.!8*'+*.1:!!;3*!3(1/!-(6&/.2!3'1!'!+6/2!/(!6)3(8+!

/3*!.0>3/!(9!)*()8*!/(!7*!3*'.+!'&+!/(!-(&>.*>'/*4!?308*!*&16.0&>!/3*!1'9*/2!(9!/3*!3(1/!-(,,6&0/2!

'&+!)(80/0-'8!8*'+*.1!>'/3*.0&>!(&!0/1!/*..0/(.2:!

!

T6.! .*)(./! '.01*1! 9.(,! /3*! 90.1/! 3'&+! (71*.@'/0(&1! ,'+*! 72! /3*! DD@A+,- </:()- 62;<9,- :5)2956,-

/3.(6>3(6/!;(.(&/(!+6.0&>!/3*!16,,0/4!'&+4!?3*.*! 0&+0-'/*+4! 9.(,!.*)(./1!?*!3'@*!.*-*0@*+!9.(,!

,*,7*.1!(9!/3*!)6780-!/3'/!3'@*!7**&!@*.090*+!'&+!9(6&+!/.61/?(./32:!;3*!&'..'/0@*1!).(@0+*+!3*.*!

.*).*1*&/!'!1,'88!1',)8*!(9!/3*!&(/*1!'&+!+'082!.*)(./1!72!(6.!,(&0/(.1:!!;3*!0,'>*1!?*.*!'81(!/'5*&!

72!/3*,!+6.0&>!/3*!-(6.1*!(9!/3*0.!,(&0/(.0&>:!!

!

S308*!/3*.*!?*.*!-*./'0&82!0&1/'&-*1!(9!@*.2!-(,)*/*&/!'&+!).(9*110(&'8!7*3'@0(.!(9!)(80-*!(990-*.1!

/3.(6>3(6/! /3*! ?**54! (6.! ,(&0/(.1! '81(! (71*.@*+! ,'&2! 0&1/'&-*1! (9! '761*! (9! )(?*.:! S*! 1'+82!

35)31/*8- 9<(9- 9<8- .65D2,25)- 5=- ,83/629E- (9- 9<8- FGH- I/::29- =(218*- 95- *8:5),96(98- '()(*(+,-

-(,,0/,*&/!/(!/.'&1)'.*&-24!9'0.&*114!'&+!-(&1/0/6/0(&'8!@'86*1:!!!

!

;301! .*)(./! 01! +0@0+*+! 0&/(! /3.**! )'./1:! R0.1/4! ?*! 90.1/! 7.0*982! ).*1*&/! /3*! 36,'&! .0>3/1! '&+!

-(&1/0/6/0(&'8! 8'?! 9.',*?(.5! /3'/! ,61/! 16))(./! )6780-! (.+*.! )(80-0&>:! K*-(&+4! ?*! (6/80&*! 1(,*!

1)*-090-! (71*.@'/0(&1!,'+*! 72! (6.!,(&0/(.1! '&+! /3*! -(&-*.&1! /3'/! /3*2! .'01*:! ! R0&'8824!?*! (6/80&*!

1(,*!-(&-8610(&1!'&+!.*-(,,*&+'/0(&1:!!

!

S*!?*8-(,*!-(,,*&/1!(&!/301!).*80,0&'.2!.*)(./:!!!

Page 8: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

Q!

!

K# $($%>F(O$!KR%J<$S!(FHTP!?$$

!

D'&'+0'&1! '.*! *&/0/8*+! /(! +*,'&+! /3*! 7*1/! )6780-! (.+*.! )(80-0&>! )(11078*! 9.(,! /3*0.! >(@*.&,*&/:!!

Y*-*&/! .*)(./1! (&!,'&'>0&>! )6780-! ).(/*1/1! 72! )(80-*! 3'@*! &(/*+! /3*! 0,)(./'&-*! (9! +*@*8()0&>! '!

9.',*?(.5!/3'/!-8*'.82!0+*&/090*1!/3*!0,)(./'&-*!(9!9.**+(,!(9!*A).*110(&!'&+!9.**+(,!(9!'11*,782!

0&!+*10>&0&>! /3*!)(80-0&>!1/.'/*>2:! ! $&!<(#=%)'.* %+*5$+%&/%! 9.(:-J86-K(L8,9E+,-'<28=- M),.83956(98-5=-

D(&1/'768'.24!'!.*)(./!/3'/!?'1!0116*+!'9/*.!'&!0&]60.2!0&/(!)(80-0&>!(9!/3*!FHI!,**/0&>!0&!E(&+(&4!

`&>8'&+!0&!HIIU4!/3*!90.1/!.*-(,,*&+'/0(&!.*'+1!'1!9(88(?1^!

$

Q-,&'5".+"-$-UVA)6)"$6&'5)7-.+")&'$&2$"1-$2+6)A)"+")&'$&2$V-+6-24A$V.&"-5"$"1.&4C1&4"$"1-$VA+'')'C$

V.&6-55$+'7$"1-$-U-64")&'$&2$"1-$&V-.+")&'$&.$&V-.+")&'5#$;3*!.0>3/!/(!9.**+(,!(9!'11*,782!)8'-*1!

(780>'/0(&1!(&!/3*!)(80-*:!;3*!1/'./0&>!)(0&/!9(.!/3*!)(80-*!01!/3*!).*16,)/0(&!0&!9'@(6.!(9!9'-080/'/0&>!

)*'-*968!'11*,782:!!b(?*@*.4!/3*!)(80-*!,'2!0,)(1*!8'?968!.*1/.0-/0(&1!(&!/3*!*A*.-01*!(9!/3*!.0>3/!

).(@0+*+!16-3!.*1/.0-/0(&1!'.*!8'?9684!3'@*!'!8*>0/0,'/*!'0,!V16-3!'1!/3*!0&/*.*1/1!(9!)6780-!1'9*/2!(.!

/3*!).(/*-/0(&!(9!/3*!.0>3/1!'&+!9.**+(,1!(9!(/3*.1W!'&+!'.*!&*-*11'.2!'&+!).()(./0(&'/*:!V):"IW!

!

$&!(6.!@0*?4!+*,(-.'/0-!)6780-!(.+*.!)(80-0&>!,61/!7*!7'1*+!(&!/3*!9(88(?0&>!!).0&-0)8*1^!

!

": K*-6.0/2!,*'16.*1!,61/!7*!+*@*8()*+!?0/3!'!@0*?!/(!*990-0*&/82!*&16.0&>!/3*!1*-6.0/2!(9!/3*!

>*&*.'8!)6780-4!/3*!+0>&0/'.0*14!/3*!).(/*1/(.1!'&+!1*-6.0/2!)*.1(&&*8H=!

H: K*-6.0/2! ,*'16.*1! ,61/! 7*! +*@*8()*+! 0&! /3*! -(&/*A/! (9! .*1)*-/! 9(.! '&+! ).(/*-/0(&! (9!

2)*2D2*/(1,+- 35),929/925)(1- 62;<9,?- 2)31/*2);- *8:536(923- ()*- */8- .6538,,- 62;<9,?- 9<8- 62;<9- 95-

).0@'-24!9.**+(,!(9!)*'-*968!'11*,782!'&+!9.**+(,!(9!*A).*110(&:!!

J: F(@*.&,*&/! '-/0(&1! /3'/! .*1/.0-/! 36,'&! .0>3/1! ,61/! 7*! &*-*11'.24! ,0&0,'882! 0&/.610@*4!

).()(./0(&'/*4!'&+!61*!/3*!8*'1/!9(.-*!)(11078*:!

Z: $&/*.&'/0(&'8! 1/'&+'.+1J! ?0/3! .*1)*-/! /(! )(80-0&>! 8'.>*! *@*&/1! 13(68+! 7*! '/! '! ,0&0,6,!

'+3*.*+!/(4!'&+!0+*'882!16.)'11*+:!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!H!! 0+$&).'*>)//)+'/*#'(*?'%&$'#%)+'#8*@$.#')A#%)+'/*<9%4!K:D:!"UU"4!-:!Z":!!J!! B')%&(*C#%)+'/*!+(&*+,*!+'(69%*,+$*D#E*F',+$9&1&'%*@,,)9)#8/4!V"UQUW!!JZ!\:[:!FCTY!K6)):!V[(:!ZPW=!\:[:!X(-:!

CcJZcZP=!G#/)9*5$)'9)=8&/*+'*%"&*B/&*+,*0+$9&*#'(*0)$&#$1/*74*D#E*F',+$9&1&'%*@,,)9)#8/!V"UUIW!\:[:!X(-!:!

CcDT[R:"ZZcH_cY*@:!"

Page 9: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

_!

!

KK$W$<@H0KSK0$0PO0H!O<$!HR(!QKOR$RDE$<H0>!KJM$(OQ$@P*K0KORN$

!

C:!Y`F\EC;TYB!DT[D`Y[K!

!

9# :'49.-&%#+3!;<5-+/%+4!=#.%6'!=#,')3!=-33'/!%+!>'6)'&!

!

N<8- ''@A- 2,- 35)386)8*- (05/9- 9<8- O)9(625- ;5D86):8)9+,- *832,25)- 95- .(,,- '! Y*>68'/0(&! 6&+*.! /3*!

5678)9*:+$;/* 5$+%&9%)+'* <9%H* 8*>018'/0(&! /3'/! ?'1! '+()/*+! 0&! "UJU4! (&82! '! 9*?!?**51! '9/*.! d.0/'0&!

+*-8'.*+!?'.!(&!F*.,'&2:!!;3*!&*?!Y*>68'/0(&4!,'+*!(&!O6&*!H&+4!908*+!(&!O6&*!"Z

/3!'&+!)678013*+!

(&!*GE'?1!(&! O6&*!"P/34!+*10>&'/*1! /3*! 1/.**/1!'&+! 10+*?'851! 0&10+*! /3*!)(80-*G*1/'78013*+! 1*-6.0/2!

.862:8986-(-%./0123-4567&-089488)-P/)8-GQ-()*-P/)8-GR?-GHQHS-!

!

;301!Y*>68'/0(&!*A)'&+1!)(80-*!)(?*.1!0&!/3*!'.*'!0&!'&+!16..(6&+0&>!/3*!1*-6.0/2!9*&-*:!!C1!'!.*168/!

(9!/3*1*!*A)'&+*+!)(?*.14!)(80-*!>'0&*+!/3*!'6/3(.0/2!/(!.*]60.*!0&+0@0+6'81!')).('-30&>!/3*!9*&-*!

/(!13(?!0+*&/090-'/0(&!'&+!167e*-/!/3*,!/(!1*'.-3*1:! !;3*!)6780-!?'1!&(/!&(/090*+!(9!/301!10>&090-'&/!

*A)'&10(&!(9!)(80-*!)(?*.1!6&/08!'9/*.!/3*!Y*>68'/0(&!-',*!0&/(!*99*-/4!(99*&+0&>!/3*!7'10-!).0&-0)8*!

/3'/!8'?1!(6>3/!&(/!/(!7*!)'11*+!0&!1*-.*/!'&+!,61/!7*!5&(?&!72!/3*!)6780-:!!;3*!Y*>68'/0(&!?088!&(/!

7*!)678013*+!0&!/3*!F'<*//*!6&/08!'9/*.!0/!?088!3'@*!7**&!.*@(5*+:!!

!

!C/! 8*'1/!(&*! 0&+0@0+6'8!?'1!+*/'0&*+4!'..*1/*+4!'&+!-3'.>*+!6&+*.! /301!<9%!7*-'61*!3*!+*-80&*+!/(!

0+*&/092!30,1*89!?308*!?'850&>!(6/10+*!/3*!6&1*-6.*+!9*&-*!).0(.!/(!/3*!16,,0/:!

!

;3*! DDEC! 01! '8'.,*+! 72! /3*! -(&/*A/! (9! /301! 8'?! '&+! '/! /3*! ,'&&*.! 0&! ?30-3! /3*! Y*>68'/0(&! ?'1!

)'11*+:! DDEC! 16>>*1/1! /3'/! /3*! 7.('+! )(80-*! )(?*.1! >.'&/*+! 6&+*.! /3*! <9%! '.*! 0&-(&101/*&/! ?0/3!

-6..*&/! D3'./*.! .*]60.*,*&/1:! $&! '++0/0(&4! ?*! 7*80*@*! /3'/! T&/'.0'&1! 3'@*! /3*! .0>3/! /(! 5&(?! '&+!

+*7'/*!/3*!1-()*!(9!)(?*.1!>.'&/*+!/(!8'?!*&9(.-*,*&/4!*@*&!/*,)(.'.082:!!M*()8*!?3(!?(.5*+!'&+!

80@*+!0&!/3*!@0-0&0/2!(9!/3*!)*.0,*/*.!3'+!/3*!.0>3/!/(!5&(?!/3'/!/3*2!&(!8(&>*.!3'+!'!.0>3/!/(!.*961*!/(!

+01-8(1*! /3*0.! 0+*&/0/2! /(! /3*! )(80-*:! K*-.*/0@*! ).(-*11*1! (&82! 1*.@*! /(! +0,0&013! /3*! )6780-! /.61/! 0&!

>(@*.&,*&/:!!

!

S*! 6.>*! /3*! >(@*.&,*&/! (9! T&/'.0(! /(! 0,).(@*! /3*! -(&168/'/0(&! .*]60.*,*&/1! '))80-'78*! /(! /3*!

'+()/0(&! (9! .*>68'/0(&1! '99*-/0&>! T&/'.0'&14! /(! ?0/3+.'?! '88! -3'.>*1! 8'0+! 6&+*.! /3*! 5678)9* :+$;/*

5$+%&9%)+'*<9%4!/(!',*&+!(.!.*)*'8!/3*!5678)9*:+$;/*5$+%&9%)+'*<9%!'&+!/(!')(8(>0<*!/(!T&/'.0'&1!9(.!

/3*!).(-*11!61*+!/(!'+()/!/3*!Y*>68'/0(&:!!!!!!

!

!

Page 10: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

U!

!

D# "#+&)#..%+4!?3'!#(!>5-6'!!

!

\&+*.!/3*!0+$&).'*>)//)+'/*#'(*?'%&$'#%)+'#8*@$.#')A#%)+'/*<9%4!/3*!YDNM!3'1!/3*!'6/3(.0/2!/(!/'5*!

%(..65.62(98-:8(,/68,?-2)31/*2);-35)965112);?-12:292);-56-.65<20292);-(338,,-95-()E-(68(-95-9<8-8T98)9-

'&+! 0&! '! ,'&&*.! 9<(9- 2,- 68(,5)(018- 2)- 9<8- 3263/:,9()38,&- 95- 8),/68- 9<8- ,83/629E- =56- ()-

%2)986;5D86):8)9(1-35)=868)38&S!!K6-3!1*-6.0/2!,*'16.*1!+(!.*1/.0-/!0&+0@0+6'8!-0@08!807*./0*1!'&+!,61/!

7*! .*'1(&'78*!'&+! 0&! -(&9(.,0/2!?0/3! /3*!!"#$%&$2Z! ! ;3*!CM`D! $&]60.2!D(,,0110(&! $&/*.0,!Y*)(./4!

?30-3!9(88(?*+!/3*!3*'@2!61*!(9!)(80-*!9(.-*!'/!/3*!C10'GM'-090-!`-(&(,0-!D(&9*.*&-*!0&!f'&-(6@*.!0&!

QUUV?-6835::8)*8*-9<(9-%W(X9-=/9/68-./0123-56*86-8D8)9,?-(-;8)865/,-5..569/)29E-,<5/1*-08-(==56*8*-

9(.!)*'-*968!).(/*1/*.1!/(!1**!'&+!7*!1**)S&L!;301!01!0&!'--(.+'&-*!?0/3!/3*!96&+',*&/'8!.0>3/!(9!'88!

D'&'+0'&1! /(! 9.**+(,!(9! *A).*110(&:!S308*! 7'..0*.1!,'2!7*!*.*-/*+! /(! '++.*11! 8*>0/0,'/*! 1*-6.0/2!

-(&-*.&14! 16-3! 7'..0*.1! ,'2! &(/! 7*! ,0161*+! 9(.! /3*! )6.)(1*! (9! 0&168'/0&>! /3*! >(@*.&,*&/! (.! 0/1!

>6*1/1!9.(,!-.0/0-01,!(.!)*'-*968!+011*&/:!

!

;3*!DDEC!3'1!7**&!-(&-*.&*+!/3'/!/3*!1*-6.0/2!).(/(-(81!*1/'78013*+!9(.!/3*!FHI!+0+!&(/!,**/!/3*!

1/'&+'.+!*1/'78013*+!72!N.:!b6>3*1!0&!/3*!CM`D!$&/*.0,!Y*)(./4!0&!/3'/!>.(6)1!/3'/!1(6>3/!')).(@*+!

.(6/*!,'.-3*1! 9.(,! /3*! )(80-*!$! 0&-86+0&>! /3*! ')).(A0,'/*82! "I4III! )*'-*968! +*,(&1/.'/(.1!?3(!

,'.-3*+!(&!K'/6.+'24!O6&*!HP!$!?*.*!>0@*&!.(6/*1!/3'/!?*.*!78(-5*+!9.(,!')).('-30&>!/3*!@0-0&0/2!

(9!/3*!(6/*.!9*&-*:!K6-3!'!?0+*!'&+!1671/'&/0'8!1*-6.0/2!-(.+(&!*99*-/0@*82!).*@*&/*+!/301!1671/'&/0'8!

*A).*110(&!(9!+011*&/!9.(,!7*0&>!1**&!(.!3*'.+!72!K6,,0/!+*8*>'/*1:!!

!

S*!.*-(,,*&+!/3'/!0&!/3*!96/6.*!/3*!9.',*?(.5!*1/'78013*+!72!N.:!b6>3*14!/3'/!014!/3'/!).(/*1/*.1!

,61/!7*!'99(.+*+!/3*!.0>3/!/(!7*!1**&!'&+!3*'.+4!7*!'))80*+:! !S*!'81(!.*-(,,*&+!/3'/!'!+*/'08*+!

8*>018'/0@*!9.',*?(.5!9(.!/3*!*1/'78013,*&/!(9!1*-6.0/2!)*.0,*/*.1!7*!+*@*8()*+:P!

!

=# :'49.-&%#+!#(!+',!&'6*+#.#4%'3!!

$/!01!*11*&/0'8!/(!/3(.(6>382!'&+!0&+*)*&+*&/82!/*1/4!*@'86'/*!'&+!.*@0*?!&*?!/*-3&(8(>0*1!/3'/!3'@*!

/3*!)(/*&/0'8! /(! -'61*!)3210-'8!3'.,!7&,+$&! /3*2!'.*!+*)8(2*+!'>'0&1/! /3*!>*&*.'8!)6780-:! !DDEC! 01!

-6..*&/82!.*]6*1/0&>!'&!0&e6&-/0(&!/(!).*@*&/!/3*!61*!(9!1(&0-!-'&&(&1!V8(&>!.'&>*!'-(61/0-!+*@0-*1!(.!

%@YAZ,&#-/)921-9<8E-<(D8-088)-.65.861E-98,98*-()*-(..65D8*S--N<8-2)L/)3925)-:/,9-08-<8(6*-08=568-

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Z!Tremblay v. Quebec (Attorney General); R. v. Knowlton, [1974] S.C.R. 443; Ogden Entertainment Services v. U .S.W.A., Local 450 (1998), 159 D.L.R. (4th) 340 (Ontario),

(Appeal Dismissed at C29462 June 1, 1998, 38 O.R. (3d) 448. 5 Commission for Public Complaints against the RCMP, APEC !Interim Commission Report, July 31,

2001 6 Wes Pue and Robert Diab, !"#$%&'$()$*&)&+(&)$,-.(/#$,-0#123$*&)&+&$4##+25,67.(/$81+#1$

,-.(/()95$:#9(2.&;(-), 28 Windsor Review of Legal and Social Issues 87

Page 11: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"I!

!

T-/(7*.!"1/:! !S*!3()*! /(!(7/'0&! /3*!-(,,0/,*&/!(9! /3*!;(.(&/(!M(80-*!'&+! /3*!T&/'.0(!M.(@0&-0'8!

M(80-*!9(.!'!7*//*.!.*>68'/(.2!9.',*?(.5!9(.!/3*!EYCX1:!!;3*!0&/*.8(-6/(.2!0&e6&-/0(&!(7/'0&*+!72!/3*!

DDEC!e61/!).0(.!/(!/3*!FHI!).(/*1/1!-(,)*88*+!/3*!;(.(&/(!M(80-*!K*.@0-*!/(!',*&+!0/1!).(-*+6.*!9(.!

61*!(9!/3*!1(&0-!-'&&(&1:!!DDEC!01!.*]6*1/0&>!'88!8(>1!(9!/3*!61*!(9!/3*!1(&0-!-'&&(&!+6.0&>!/3*!FHI:!!

!

d:!MTE$D$[F!DT[D`Y[K!

!

9# >'-)6*!-+/!>'%@9)'!=#,')3!!

*

R.**+(,!9.(,!6&.*'1(&'78*!1*'.-3!'&+!1*0<6.*!01!'!96&+',*&/'8!.0>3/!*&e(2*+!72!D'&'+0'&1:!\&8*11!

'!)*.1(&! 01!7*0&>! 8*>'882!+*/'0&*+!(.!'..*1/*+4!/3*!)(80-*!,61/!3'@*!'!?'..'&/4!(.!(/3*.!.*'1(&'78*!

>.(6&+14!/(!9(.-0782!1*'.-3!0&+0@0+6'81:!!!!

!

;3*!DDEC!-(&/0&6*1!/(!7*!-(&-*.&*+!/3'/!/3*!0&@(-'/0(&!(9!/3*!5678)9*:+$;/*5$+%&9%)+'*<9%!>.'&/*+!

/3*!)(80-*!/3*!'6/3(.0/2!/(!+*,'&+!/3'/!'&2!0&+0@0+6'8!*&/*.0&>!/3*!FHI!1*-6.0/2!)*.0,*/*.!167,0/!/(!

'!1*'.-3!$!*@*&!+6.0&>!/3*!)*.0(+!(9!/0,*!?3*&!/3*!9*&-*!?'1!8*9/!()*&:![(!96./3*.!7'101!?'1!&**+*+!

/(!*A*-6/*!/3*!1*'.-3!'&+!9'086.*!/(!)*.,0/!/3*!1*'.-3!?'1!>.(6&+1!9(.!'..*1/:!!

!

T6/10+*!(9!/3*!@0-0&0/2!(9!/3*!1*-6.0/2!)*.0,*/*.4!(6.!,(&0/(.1!(71*.@*+!121/*,'/0-!'&+!?0+*1).*'+!

1*'.-3*1!/3.(6>3(6/!/3*!?**5:!X(<*&1!(9! 0&1/'&-*1!?*.*!(71*.@*+!(9!)(80-*!1/())0&>!0&+0@0+6'81! 0&!

8(-'/0(&1!9'.!'?'2!9.(,!/3*!FHI!1*-6.0/2!)*.0,*/*.:!;3.(6>3(6/!/3*!?**54!(71*.@*.1!?'/-3*+!8'.>*!

>.(6)1!(9!(990-*.1!1/'/0(&*+!(6/10+*!/3*!*A0/1!9.(,!167?'2!1/'/0(&1!(.!'/!/3*!*&/.'&-*!/(!)6780-!)'.514!

+*,'&+0&>!/3'/!0&+0@0+6'81!?3(!*A0/*+!(.!*&/*.*+!167,0/!/(!'!1*'.-3:!;3*.*!'.*!6&-(&90.,*+!.*)(./1!

/3'/! 72! K6&+'2! )(80-*! (990-*.1! ?*.*! *@*&! 1/())0&>! '&+! 7('.+0&>! ;;D! 1/.**/! -'.1! 121/*,'/0-'882! /(!

-(&+6-/!1*'.-3*1:!T6.!,(&0/(.1!'81(!(71*.@*+!)8'0&!-8(/3*1!(990-*.1!-(&+6-/0&>!1*'.-3*1!(&!/3*!FHI!

?**5*&+:! $&! /3*! (@*.?3*8,0&>! &6,7*.! (9! (71*.@*+! 0&1/'&-*14! /3*! )(80-*! 1/'/*+! &(! 7'101! 9(.!

-(&+6-/0&>!/3*!1*'.-3:!!!

!

;3*.*!?*.*!1*@*.'8!0&1/'&-*1!?3*.*!,(&0/(.1!/3*,1*8@*14!(.!/3(1*!/3*2!?*.*!(71*.@0&>4!-8*'.82!'&+!

6&*]60@(-'882!1/'/*+!/3'/!/3*2!+0+!&(/!-(&1*&/!/(!7*0&>!1*'.-3*+:!!;3*!1*'.-3*1!).(-**+*+!+*1)0/*!'!

-8*'.!8'-5!(9!-(&1*&/:!!!!

!

;3*.*!?'1!6&-*./'0&/2!'1! /(! /3*!>.(6&+1! /(! e61/092! /3*1*!1*'.-3*1:! ! $&!1(,*! 0&1/'&-*14!,(&0/(.1!(.!

/3(1*! 7*0&>! 1*'.-3*+! '15*+! )(80-*! ?3'/! /3*! >.(6&+1! ?*.*! 9(.! /3*! 1*'.-3*1:! ! ;3*! '&1?*.1! >0@*&!

2)31/*8*?-%9<8-329E-2,-0/6)2);&?-%48-,8(63<-8D86E5)8-429<-(-0(37.(37-5)-9<8-4(E-2)95-(-.6598,9&?-()*-

,2:.1E-%1557-(9-9<8-;/E+,-,<269&-68=8662);-95-(-9G,<269-9<(9-68(*-[\]37-9<8-FGGH+S-'5),2*862);-9<8-1-'8*!

Page 12: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

""!

!

'&+!/3*!121/*,'/0-!&'/6.*!(9!=$)1#*,#9)&!088*>'8!1*'.-3*14!0/!'))*'.*+!/3'/!'9/*.!LMN!(&!K'/6.+'24!/3*!

-(&1/0/6/0(&'8!).(/*-/0(&!'>'0&1/!'.70/.'.2!+*/*&/0(&!'&+!6&.*'1(&'78*!1*'.-3*1!3'+!*99*-/0@*82!7**&!

161)*&+*+!'-.(11!+(?&/(?&!;(.(&/(:!;301!10/6'/0(&!3'1!'8'.,0&>! 0,)80-'/0(&1!9(.!-0@08! 807*./0*1!'&+!

)6780-!'--(6&/'7080/2:!!

!

;3*! 8'-5! (9! -8'.0/2! '1! /(! /3*! 1-()*! (9! /3*! 1*'.-3! '&+! 1*0<6.*! )(?*.1! -.*'/*+!,'&2! +0990-68/0*1:! ! $/!

).*-0)0/'/*+!-(&980-/1!/3'/!-(68+!3'@*!7**&!'@(0+*+:!!S*!.*-(,,*&+!/3'/!/3*!0116*!(9!1*'.-3*1!'&+!

1*0<6.*1!7*!'++.*11*+!0&!'&2!96/6.*!8*>018'/0@*!9.',*?(.5!+*'80&>!?0/3!)6780-!(.+*.!)(80-0&>:!!

!

!

D# A0'),*'.$%+4!-+/!B+&%$%/-&%+4!=#.%6'!=)'3'+6'!

!

$&!/3*!\g!O(0&/!D(,,0//**!Y*)(./!(9!HIIU4!'&(/3*.!0&+*)*&+*&/!>(@*.&,*&/'8!.*@0*?!(9!/3*!HIIU!

E(&+(&!FHI4!/3*!D(,,0//**!-(,,*&/*+!(&!/3*!.'/0(1!(9!)(80-*!/(!).(/*1/(.1!0&!/3*!9(88(?0&>!/*.,1^!!

:&*#$&*9+'9&$'&(*%"#%*=$+%&/%+$/*"#I&*%"&*)1=$&//)+'*%"#%*%"&*=+8)9&*#$&*/+1&%)1&/*"&#I4J"#'(&(*)'*

%"&)$* #==$+#9"* %+* =$+%&/%/H* &/=&9)#884* )'* E&#$)'.* $)+%* &K6)=1&'%* )'* +$(&$* %+* (&#8* E)%"* =&#9&,68*

(&1+'/%$#%)+'/2*:")8/%*E&*$&9+.')A&*%"#%*=+8)9&*+,,)9&$/*/"+68(*'+%*7&*=8#9&(*#%*$)/;*+,*/&$)+6/*)'L6$4H*

%"&*(&=8+41&'%*+,*$)+%*=+8)9&*9#'*6''&9&//#$)84*$#)/&*

%"&* %&1=&$#%6$&* #%* =$+%&/%/2* *M"&* 53C?* "#/* /"+E'*

"+E* ,&E&$* =+8)9&* 9#'* 7&* (&=8+4&(* #%* =$+%&/%/H* )'*

'+$1#8*6'),+$1H*#==#$&'%84*E)%"*/699&//2**:")8/%*%"&*

(&9)/)+'* #/* %+* %"&* &K6)=1&'%* 6/&(* 16/%* 7&* #'*

+=&$#%)+'#8* +'&* #'(* 16/%* (&=&'(* +'* %"&*

9)$961/%#'9&/* #'(* .&+.$#="4* )'* %"&* =#$%)968#$*

9)$961/%#'9&/H*=+8)9)'.*=$#9%)9&*+,*%")/*/+$%*9#'*"&8=*

%+* /6==+$%* =&#9&,68* =$+%&/%* #'(* 6="+8(* %"&* $)."%* %+*

=&#9&,68* #//&1784* #'(* E&* $&9+11&'(* %"#%* %"&*

#(+=%)+'* +,* %")/* #==$+#9"* 7&* 9+'/)(&$&(* 74* =+8)9&*

,+$9&/* )'* F'.8#'(* #'(* :#8&/H* E"&$&* #==$+=$)#%&2*

V)'.'!"_QW!*

N<8- ''@A+,- 36,'&! .0>3/1! ,(&0/(.1! .*)*'/*+82!

.*)(./*+! '&! (@*.?3*8,0&>! &6,7*.! (9! )(80-*! '&+!

1*-6.0/2!(990-*.1!/3.(6>3(6/!/3*!-0/2:!;3.(6>3(6/!/3*!

?**54! '&+! )'./0-68'.82! ).0(.! /(! K'/6.+'24! /3*! 13**.!

&6,7*.! (9! )(80-*! (990-*.1! -(,)'.*+! /(! /3*!

$! ?'1! ,(&0/(.0&>! '! +*,(&1/.'/0(&! /3'/!

?'1!>'/3*.0&>!'/!C88*&!F'.+*&14! 9'.!'?'2!

9.(,! /3*!FHI! 16,,0/! 10/*:! $&! 9'-/4! 0/!?'1!

R.0+'2!1(!/3*!16,,0/!3'+!&(/!*@*&!7*>6&!

2*/:! $! ?'/-3*+! '1! )(80-*! +*,'&+*+! /(!

1*'.-3! *@*.2! )*.1(&! ?3(! *&/*.*+! /3*!

)'.5! ?0/3! '&2! /2)*! (9! 7'>:! T&*! )*.1(&!

/(8+! /3'/! /3*! )(80-*! /3.*'/*&*+! /(! '..*1/!

3*.!09!13*!.*961*+!/(!167,0/!/(!/3*!1*'.-3!

'&+! /.0*+! /(! *&/*.! /3*! )6780-! )'.5:! $!

-(&/0&6*+!/(!?'/-3!'1!909/**&!)*()8*! 0&!'!

.(?! ?*.*! 1/())*+! '&+! 1*'.-3*+! '1! /3*2!

*&/*.*+!/3*!)'.5:!N(1/!)*()8*!?*.*!7(/3!

-(&961*+! '&+! 6)1*/! 72! /3*! 0&-0+*&/:! K(!

?'1!$:$

$

00*($%4,+'$!)C1"5$F&')"&.$

Page 13: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"H!

!

).(/*1/*.1!?'1!+01).()(./0(&'/*! '&+! -.*'/*+!'&!'/,(1)3*.*!(9! 0&/0,0+'/0(&:!N'&2! 0&1/'&-*1!?*.*!

.*-(.+*+!?3*.*!8'.>*!>.(6)1!(9!)(80-*!(990-*.1!$!(9/*&!&0&*!(.!/*&!$!16..(6&+*+!0&+0@0+6'81!/(!1*'.-3!

(.! 0&/*..(>'/*! /3*,! '1! /3*2! ?*.*! ?'850&>! '8(&>! 10+*?'851! (.! /3.(6>3! )'.51:! ! $&/*..(>'/0(&! (.!

1*'.-3*1!6&+*.!16-3!10/6'/0(&1!-'&&(/!7*!1'0+!/(!3'@*!3'))*&*+!?0/3!9.**!-(&1*&/:!!;3*!&6,7*.!(9!

)(80-*!+*)8(2*+! 0&! /3*1*! 10/6'/0(&1! '))*'.*+! /(!7*!7(/3!'!?'1/*!(9! .*1(6.-*1! '&+!'&!6&&*-*11'.2!

*1-'8'/0(&!(9!'!-(&9.(&/'/0(&'8!'/,(1)3*.*:!!!

!

M'./0-68'.82! +6.0&>! /3*! ?**5*&+4! )(80-*! ?*.*! ?*'.0&>! .0(/! >*'.! '&+! ?*.*! 1**&! ?0/3! ?*')(&1!

0&-86+0&>! /'1*.14! >6&1! 8('+*+! ?0/3! )*))*.! 1).'24! /*'.! >'1! >6&1! '&+! >6&1! /3'/! 13(/! 1(,*! 9(.,! (9!

).(e*-/08*:! !N'&2!(71*.@*.1! .*)(./*+! 1**0&>! 8'.>*! >.(6)1!(9!)(80-*!(990-*.1!?0/3(6/! /3*0.! &',*1!(.!

7'+>*!&6,7*.1!@01078*4!/361! 0,)*+0&>!/3*!.0>3/1!(9!/3*!)6780-!/(!,'5*!-(,)8'0&/1!'7(6/!'761*1!72!

1)*-090-!(990-*.1:!!!T&*!>.(6)!(9!,(&0/(.1!?'850&>!'8(&>!/3*!1/.**/4!9'.!9.(,!'&2!+*,(&1/.'/0(&4!?'1!

]6*1/0(&*+!72!)(80-*!(990-*.14!(&*!(9!?3(,!.*,(@*+!301!&',*!7'+>*!).0(.!/(!')).('-30&>!/3*,!'&+!

]6*1/0(&0&>! /3*,:! M(80-*! 0&! .0(/! >*'.! '81(! *&>'>*+! 0&! 0&/0,0+'/0&>! /'-/0-14! 0&-86+0&>! -8'//*.0&>! /3*0.!

7'/(&1!'>'0&1/!/3*0.!130*8+1!'&+!)(0&/0&>!>6&1!'/!)*'-*968!-.(?+1:!!!

$ $

M-4(,-:5)29562);- (- .8(38=/1- .6598,9- (9-B/88)+,- C(67- I5/9<- 1(98- 2)- 9<8- (=986)55)- 5)- I(9/6*(ES- C85.18-

4868-:2112);-(65/)*-()*-,5:8-.85.18-4868-,2992);-2)-(-12)8-(365,,-B/88)+,-C(67-'68,38)9S-\/69<86-*54)-

B/88)+,-C(67-'68,38)9-()*-2)-9<8! 0&/*.1*-/0(&!(9!D(88*>*!K/.**/!'&+!\&0@*.10/2!C@*&6*!36&+.*+1!(9!.0(/!

)(80-*!?*.*! 1/'/0(&*+:! K6++*&824! '! .(?!(9! .0(/!)(80-*! '+@'&-*+! /*&!,*/*.1!&(./3! /(?'.+1! /3*!).(/*1/:!

T&*!(990-*.!90.*+!'!?*')(&!(9!1(,*!50&+!'/!/3*!>.(6&+!-8(1*!/(!?3*.*!'!80&*!(9!).(/*1/*.1!?*.*!10//0&>:!

;3*! ?*')(&! -'61*+! ?30/*! 1,(5*! /(! .01*! 0&! /3*! '0.:! ;3*! )(80-*! /3*&! 0116*+! '&! '6+0(! ?'.&0&>! /3'/!

).(/*1/*.1!3'+!/(!+01)*.1*!76/! $!+(!&(/!5&(?! 09!*@*.2(&*! 0&! /3*!)'.5!-(68+!3*'.! 0/:!;3*!.0(/!)(80-*! 80&*!

/3*&!16++*&82!'+@'&-*+!'>'0&!'&(/3*.!/*&!,*/*.1:!M.(/*1/*.1!7*>'&!/(!1-'//*.:!;3*!)(80-*!-(&/0&6*+!/301!

'+@'&-*G?'0/G'+@'&-*!)'//*.&:!$!?'1!@*.2!-(&961*+!'1!/3*!).(/*1/!1**,*+!*&/0.*82!)*'-*968!'/!/3*!/0,*!

()*-B/88)+,-C(67-4(,-9<8-*8,2;)(98*-*8:5),96(925)->5)8^!

$

00*($%4,+'$!)C1"5$F&')"&.$

!

Page 14: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"J!

!

$

=# ?3'!#(!C#)6'$

!

DDEC! -(&+*,&1! /3*! 61*! (9! @0(8*&-*! 7(/3! 72!,*,7*.1! (9! /3*! )6780-! '&+! 72! /3*! )(80-*:! ! S*! '81(!

'-5&(?8*+>*! /3'/! /3*! )(80-*!,'2! '/! /0,*1! &**+! /(! *A*.-01*! 1(,*! 9(.-*! 0&! (.+*.! /(! *&16.*! )6780-!

1'9*/2:! ! $&!-'1*1!?3*.*!9(.-*! 01!&*-*11'.24! 0/!13(68+!7*!*A*.-01*+!,0&0,'882!'&+! 0&!'!,'&&*.!/3'/! 01!

).()(./0(&'8!/(!/3*!/3.*'/:!

!

\&9(./6&'/*824! DDEC!,(&0/(.1!?0/&*11*+!,'&2!'))'.*&/! 0&1/'&-*1!(9!)(80-*!610&>!,(.*! 9(.-*! /3'&!

?'1!&*-*11'.2!?308*!-(&+6-/0&>!1*'.-3*14!'..*1/0&>!0&+0@0+6'814!'&+!-(&/.(880&>!-.(?+1!$!)'./0-68'.82!

'9/*.!K'/6.+'2!'/!L!),:!N(&0/(.1!1'?!)(80-*!.0(/!80&*1!-3'.>0&>!0&/(!)*'-*968!-.(?+1!?0/3(6/!'6+078*!

?'.&0&>:!!;3*.*!?*.*!'81(!0&1/'&-*1!?3*.*!,(&0/(.1!(71*.@*+!)(80-*!13((/0&>!0&/(!)*'-*968!-.(?+1!

?0/3(6/!?'.&0&>:!!$&!/?(!(9!/3*!+0.*-/82!(71*.@*+!0&1/'&-*1!/3*!)(80-*!13(/!'!9(.,!(9!?30/*!)(?+*.:!!

$&!/3*!/30.+!0&-0+*&/4!'!)*'-*968!-.(?+!?'1!16..(6&+*+!(&!'88!10+*1!72!.0(/!1]6'+1!?3*&!)(80-*!90.*+!

/3.**!.(6&+1!(9!'!1(80+!).(e*-/08*!/(?'.+1!/3*!-.(?+:!!T&*!30/!'!,'&!?3(!3'+!/3.(?&!'&!*,)/2!)()!

-'&4!?308*!/3*!(/3*6-945-65/)*,-<29-:5)2956,+-023E318,?-068(72);-9<8-,.578,-5=-9<8-4<881,S!

!

!

!8"3#!D-))-&%0'!866#9+&E!>-&9)/-F!G9+'!HIE!HJKJ!!

!

<%*#$+6'(*NOPOO*=1*?*#1*$)()'.*14*7)9498&*(+E'*3%2*Q&+$.&*3%2**</*?*%6$'*&#/%*+'%+*R+/;)'H*?*/&&*%E+*/&%/*!*#*8+%*

!*+,*$)+%*=+8)9&*$6'')'.H*9"#/)'.*=&+=8&*E&/%*+'*R+/;)'*<I&2*M"&4*#$&*1+I)'.*K6)%&*,#/%*!*?*#1*E+$$)&(*%"&4*E)88*

;&&=*9+1)'.H*$6'')'.*%+E#$(/*%"&*=&+=8&*#'(*+I&$%#;&*%"&12*36((&'84*%"&4*/%+=H*%6$'*#$+6'(H*/%#$%*1#$9")'.*

"#$%&'()*&*+'#,-)&./((01)&2#,%3& &45(6&#,(&$7#**(,809&+0&*5(8,&)58(7-):&#0-& 7++%809&;/8*(&)$#,63&<&#0-&=& >+77+'&

%"&1*+'*+6$*7);&/H*#/*E&*/&&*S&I+'/")$&*%+*%"&*'+$%"H*%"&$&*)/*#*9)$98&*+,*1+6'%&(*=+8)9&H*)'*%"&*1)((8&*+,*%"&*

)*,((*&"()8-(&*5(&)*#-8/?3&&@(&,8-(&0+,*5&/A&B(C+0)58,(:&#0-&$/*&*5,+/95&2587+)+A5(,1)&'#7%3&45(,(&8)&#&A,+*()*&

"&#(&(*E&/%*+'*G8++$2*

*

:&*$)(&*E&/%*+'*G8++$H*/+1&%)1&/*96%%)'.*(+E'*/+6%"*%+*$)(&*,#/%&$*#'(*9#%9"*6=*E)%"*%"&*,$+'%*+,*%"&*=$+%&/%2**

:&*.&%*'&#$*%"&*,$+'%H*#'(*%"&'*%"&4*%6$'*/+6%"*+'*T+'.&2* *C+*I)+8&'9&*74*=$+%&/%&$/*+'*%"&*E#4*(+E'H*76%*

*5(6&'(,(&C#,8+/)76&$5#0*809&DA(#$(>/7&A,+*()*1:&D*5(6&%8$%(-&/)&+/*&+>&./((01)&2#,%1:*DE+80&/)13&&2,+*()*(,)&'(,(&

/A)(*&*5(6&5#-&"((0&,(?+C(-&>,+?&./((01)&2#,%3&*

*

U&$4*8)%%8&*=+8)9&*=$&/&'9&2**:&*/&&*+'&*/1#88*/&%*+,*$)+%*=+8)9&*(&=8+4)'.*+'*#'*&#/%*/)(&*/%$&&%2**<%*/+1&*=+)'%*

7&,+$&*:&88)'.%+'H*=$+%&/%* %6$'&(*E&/%H* #'(* %"&'* 96%* /+6%"*#.#)'*!* .+)'.* %+E#$(/* ,&'9&2* * 5$+%&/%&$/*.+%* %+*

/+6%"&$'* &(.&* +,*:&88)'.%+'H* 7&%E&&'* T+$;* #'(*G#4*!* "#8,* /%#'()'.* +'* %+=* +,* =8#%,+$1*#%*:&88)'.%+'H* "#8,*

(+E'* /%#)$/* #%* /%$&&%* 8&I&82* * 31#88* =+8)9&* =$&/&'9&* )'* ,$+'%* +,* ,&'9&2* * 5$+%&/%&$/* /#'.* @"* !#'#(#H* 9"#'%)'.*

=&#9&,68*=$+%&/%2* *-)+%*=+8)9&*E&$&*#%*:&88)'.%+'*#'(*T+$;2* *M"&4*1+I&(*&#/%* #8+'.*:&88)'.%+'*/%$&&%H*#* ,&E*

1+1&'%/*8#%&$*#*/&%*9+1&/*6=*/%#)$/*%+*%"&*E&/%*+,*6/H*+'%+*%"&*6==&$*=8#%,+$12**5&+=8&*E)%"($&E*K6)%&*K6)9;84H*

'+%*E#)%)'.*,+$*=+8)9&*8)'&/*%+*$&#9"*%"&12***

*

Page 15: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"Z!

!

5&+=8&*9+#8&/9&(*)'%+*.$+6=*+'*V)'.H*7&%E&&'*T+$;*#'(*G#42** * *Q$+6=*+,*=$+%&/%&$/*E#/*/6$$+6'(&(*+'*E&/%H*

/+6%"*#'(*&#/%*74*$)+%*=+8)9&2**3+8)(*76)8()'.*E#/*%+*'+$%"2**M"&4*E&$&*"&11&(*)'2*

*

5$+%&/%&$/*E&$&*/%#'()'.*)'*.$+6=2*36((&'84*=+8)9&*#%*&#/%&$'*&(.&*+,*7+W*,)$&(*/+1&*/+$%*+,*8#$.&*=8#/%)9J%4=&*

=$+L&9%)8&H*")%*.64*80&)*+?#$5&#,(#3&&2+78$(&>8,(-&*'+&?+,(&,+/0-):&58*&?6&"8%(&'5((7&#0-&<1)&"8%(&'5((73&&F,+%(&

/+1&*/=+;&/5&+=8&*$#'*#E#4*,$+1*%"#%*/)(&*+,*=$+%&/%2**:+1#'*E)%"*1&()#*=#//*#/;/*),*?*9#'*,)'(*E"#%*")%*1&H*

?*/#4*?*%")';*)%*E#/*=8#/%)9H*/"&/*/#4)'.*/"&*'&&(/*%+*/&&*)%2**?*L6/%*$6'2*-)+%*=+8)9&*1+I&(*98+/&$2**Q64*)'*=$+%&/%*

E)%"*#*1&.#="+'&*/#)(*E&*/"+68(*/)%H*/"+E*E&*E&$&*=&#9&,682**>+/%*+,*=$+%&/%&$/*/#%*(+E'2***

*

FI&'%6#884*=&$/+'*+'*8+6(/=&#;&$*/#)(*%"#%*"&*"#(*#*1&//#.&*,$+1*=+8)9&*!*E&*E+68(*7&*#78&*%+*8&#I&*%"$+6."*

E&/%*/)(&*+,*=$+%&/%2**5$+%&/%&$/*.+%*6=*#'(*E#8;&(*+,,2**3+1&*"&#(&(*'+$%"*+$*E&/%H*#E#4*,$+1*=$+%&/%2**@'&*

=#$%H*1#47&*"#8,H*%6$'&(*#'(*E&'%*/+6%"2**X*#'(*?*E&'%*'+$%"*+'*T+'.&H*E#8;&(*"+1&2*

!

!

!

X# L-33!8))'3&3!

!

;3*! DDEC! 01! *A/.*,*82! -(&-*.&*+! '7(6/! /3*!,'11! '..*1/1! /3'/! /((5! )8'-*! +6.0&>! /3*!FHI! K6,,0/:!!

C--(.+0&>!/(!/3*!,(1/!.*-*&/!,*+0'!.*)(./14!(@*.!UII!)*()8*!3'@*!7**&!'..*1/*+!$!/3*!8'.>*1/!,'11!

'..*1/! 0&! D'&'+0'&! 301/(.2:! ! DDEC!,(&0/(.1! (71*.@*+!,'11! '..*1/1! (--6..0&>! (&! /3*! `1)8'&'+*! (&!

K'/6.+'2! &0>3/4! '/! /3*! \&0@*.10/2! (9! ;(.(&/(! F.'+6'/*! K/6+*&/! \&0(&! (&! K6&+'2! ,(.&0&>! '&+! '/!

a6**&!K/:!S:!'&+!K)'+0&'!C@*:!(&!K6&+'2!&0>3/:!M(80-*!/'-/0-1!+6.0&>!/3*!FHI!0&-86+*+!7(A0&>!0&!8'.>*!

>.(6)1! (9! ).(/*1/(.1! '&+! (/3*.! ,*,7*.1! (9! /3*! )6780-! ?0/3(6/! '+*]6'/*! ?'.&0&>4! 9(88(?*+! 72!

121/*,'/0-!'&+!,'11!'..*1/1!(9!'88!(9!/3(1*!0&!/3*!'.*':!!;301!).'-/0-*!01!'!@0(8'/0(&!(9!-0@08!807*./0*1!'&+!

01!-8*'.82!-(&/.'.2!/(!/3*!D'&'+0'&!!"#$%&$1/!>6'.'&/**!(9!9.**+(,!9.(,!'.70/.'.2!+*/*&/0(&!(.!'..*1/4!

'&+! @0(8'/*1! 0&/*.&'/0(&'8! 36,'&! .0>3/1!&(.,1:! ! ;3*!\&0/*+!['/0(&1!b6,'&!Y0>3/1! D(,,0//**!3'1!

).*@0(6182! -.0/0-0<*+! '! D'&'+0'&! )(80-*! 9(.-*! 9(.! /3*!,'11! '..*1/! (9! ).(/*1/(.1! '&+! 3'1! 1/'/*+! /3'/!

'()(*(- %,<5/1*- 8),/68- 9<(9- 9<8- 62;<9- 5=- .861(&1! /(! )*'-*96882! )'./0-0)'/*! 0&! 1(-0'8! ).(/*1/1! 01!

.*1)*-/*+4! '&+! *&16.*! /3'/! (&82! /3(1*! -(,,0//0&>! -.0,0&'8! (99*&-*1! +6.0&>! +*,(&1/.'/0(&1! '.*!

(668,98*S&-!

!

;3*!FHI!1*-6.0/2!6&0/!9'08*+!/(!'+3*.*!/(!/301!1/'&+'.+:!b6&+.*+1!(9!)*.1(&1!?*.*!'..*1/*+!9(.!7.*'-3!

(9!/3*!)*'-*4! 0&-86+0&>!0&+0@0+6'81!?3(!?*.*!10,)82!?'850&>!+(?&/(?&4!/3(1*!?3(!?*.*!)*'-*96882!

).(/*1/0&>4!,*,7*.1!(9!/3*!,*+0'!?3(!?*.*!.*)(./0&>!(&!/3*!FHI!'&+!36,'&!.0>3/1!,(&0/(.1:!!!

!

K(,,-(668,9,-2)-68,.5),8-95-9<8-68(*2);-5=-9<8-%6259-(39&-(68-2)=68_/8)9?-0/9-:(,,-(668,9,-<(D8-088)-

61*+!72!)(80-*!/(!+01.6)/!-.(?+1:!!;3*!/3.*'/!(9!'..*1/!01!(9/*&!61*+:![(!+(67/4!)(80-*!,'2!&**+!/((81!

/(!,'&'>*!-.(?+1!/3'/!7*-(,*!6&-(&/.(88'78*:!![*@*./3*8*114!',*&+,*&/1!/(!/3*!!$)1)'#8*!+(&!'.*!

)838,,(6E- 95-062);- 9<8-51*- =(,<25)8*-()*-()92_/(98*-.65D2,25),-*8(12);-429<- %/)1(4=/1-(,,8:0128,&-

Page 16: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"L!

!

()*- %6259,&- 2)- 12)8- 429<! ,(+*.&! -(&-*)/0(&1! (9! 9.**+(,! (9! '11*,782! '&+! /3*! 0&/*.&'/0(&'8!

+*@*8(),*&/1!(&!/301!0116*:!!

!

S*! .*-(,,*&+! /3'/! /3*! N0&01/*.! (9! O61/0-*! 6&+*./'5*! /(! -.*'/*! '! -(,,0//**! /(! .*-(,,*&+!

,(+*.&0<'/0(&!(9!/3*!!$)1)'#8*!+(&!.65D2,25),-*8(12);-429<-%/)1(4=/1-(,,8:0128,&-()*-%6259,&S!

!

N<8-9551-/,8*-0E-.51238-95-8==839-:(,,-(668,9,-2,-9<8-3<(6;8-5=-%068(3<-5=-9<8-.8(38&S--K()E-.85.18-

4868-9<68(98)8*-429<-(-3<(6;8-5=-%068(3<-5=-9<8-.8(38&-(,-9<8E-4868-4(292);-2)-9<8-6(2)-(9-B/88&!K/:!

'&+!K)'+0&'!C@*:!(&!K6&+'2!&0>3/:!!;3*!+01-.*/0(&!(9!)(80-*!(990-*.1!0&!?0*8+0&>!/3*!)(11078*!-3'.>*!(9!

%068(3<- 5=- 9<8- .8(38&- 2,- 2)35:.(92018- 429<- 3/668)9- 35),929/925)(1- 68_/268:8)9,- 5=- =/)*(:8)9(1-

e61/0-*:!!d.*'-3!(9!/3*!)*'-*!01!/((!@'>6*!'!).(@010(&:!!$/!13(68+!7*!.*)*'8*+!(.!',*&+*+:!!!!

!

!

!$"%#&'())(*+,-&.//012*3&4(*1)5(6&712-&893&8:;:<!

!

>4*=#$%'&$*#'(* ?* ,+88+E&(*#*.$+6=*+,*=$+%&/%+$/* %+* %"&* ,$+'%*+,* %"&*C+I+%&8* "+%&8* +'*F/=8#'#(&*#'(*#/* %"&*

9$+E(*#//&178&(H*E&*7&.#'*%+*%#;&*'+%&/*+'*%"&*=+8)9&*=$&/&'9&*#'(*%"&)$*)'%&$#9%)+'/*E)%"*%"&*=$+%&/%+$/2*M"&*

=$+%&/%* E#/* 9+1=$)/&(* +,* /&I&$#8* "6'($&(* (&1+'/%$#%+$/* E"+*E&$&* 9"#'%)'.* /8+.#'/* )'* ,$+'%* +,* %"&* "+%&82*

5+8)9&*%"&'*&1&$.&(*+'*%"&*&#/%*/)(&*+,*%"&*/%$&&%H*78+9;)'.*+,,*#'4*$&%$&#%*,$+1*%"#%*/)(&2*>4*=#$%'&$*#'(*?*

%"&'*(&9)(&(*%+*1+I&*%+*%"&*+%"&$*/)(&*+,*%"&*9$+E(H*76%*74*%"&*%)1&*E&*"#(*=)9;&(*+6$*E#4*%+*%"&*+%"&$*/)(&H*

#'+%"&$*%&#1*+,*$)+%*=+8)9&*"#(*9+$(+'&(J+,,*%"&*E&/%&$'*/)(&*+,*%"&*/%$&&%H*&,,&9%)I&84*78+9;)'.*+,,*#'4*E#4*,+$*

14/&8,H*14* =#$%'&$H* =$+%&/%+$/* +$* #'4* =#//&$/74* ,$+1*(&=#$%)'.2*@I&$* %"&* '&W%* YO*1)'6%&/* +$* /+H* %"&* =+8)9&*

=&$)+()9#884*1+I&*,+$E#$(H*9+',)')'.*%"&*=&+=8&*%+*#*/1#88&$*/=#9&2*C+*#''+6'9&1&'%*E#/*1#(&*%+*%"&*9$+E(*

9#88)'.*+'* %"&1* %+*(&=#$%H* #'(*'+* /=#9&*E#/*1#(&* ,+$* %"&1* %+*(+* /+2* ?'* $&/=+'/&* %+* %"&*=+8)9&H* %"&* 9$+E(*

(&9)(&(*%+*/)%*(+E'H*%6$')'.*%"&)$*=$+%&/%*)'%+*#*=&#9&,68*/)%*)%2*!#88)'.*+'*%"&*9$+E(*%+*7&*K6)&%H*%"&*=+8)9&*1#(&*

%"&)$*+'84*#''+6'9&1&'%P*E&*E&$&*#88*6'(&$*#$$&/%2**

@I&$*%"&*'&W%*%E+*%+*%"$&&*"+6$/H*&I&$4*1&17&$*+,*%"&*9$+E(*%"#%*"#(*7&&'*9#6."%*)'*%"&*9+$(+'*E#/*#$$&/%&(2*

?* E#/* %$#'/=+$%&(* %+* %"&*1#;&/"),%* (&%&'%)+'* 9&'%$&* E"&$&H* #,%&$* E#)%)'.* +'* #* =$)/+'&$* 76/* ,+$* #$+6'(* ZO*

1)'6%&/H* ?*E#/*=8#9&(* )'*#*9&88*E)%"*N[*+%"&$/2*M"&*'&W%*N\*"+6$/*E&$&*#*9#/&J/%6(4* )'*=+8)9&* )'&=%)%6(&2*:&*

E&$&* .)I&'* %E+* ()W)&* 96=/* +,* E#%&$* +I&$* %"#%* =&$)+(H* E)%"* %"&* /&9+'(* 7&)'.* 6'($)';#78&2* M"&$&* E#/* '+*

()/9&$'#78&*=8#'*,+$*=$+9&//)'.*%"+/&*E"+*"#(*7&&'*#$$&/%&(H*#'(*&I&'*%"+6."*%"&*=+8)9&*E&$&*#E#$&*+,*%")/*

,#9%H*%"&4*1#(&*#7/+86%&84*'+*&,,+$%*%+*#(#=%*%"&)$*=++$*=8#'')'.*%+*$&,8&9%*%"&*$&#8)%4*+,*%"&*/)%6#%)+'2*:)%"+6%*

#'4*9+.&'%*=$+9&(6$&*%+*/=&#;*+,H*%"&*(&8#4/*,+$*E#%&$H*)',+$1#%)+'*#'(*&I&'*)'/68)'*E&$&H*)'*,#9%H*%#'%#1+6'%*

%+* (&')#82* M"&* =+8)9&* #8%&$'#%&(* 7&%E&&'* &)%"&$* ).'+$)'.* +6$* $&K6&/%/H* +$* /)1=84* (&,8&9%)'.* %"&1*E)%"* 8)."%J

"&#$%&(*7#'%&$* %"#%* 9#1&*+,,*#/*1&$&84* )'/68%)'.*.)I&'* %"&*.$#I)%4*+,* %"&* /)%6#%)+'* %"#%* %"&*(&%#)'&&/* ,+6'(*

%"&1/&8I&/*)'2**

!

Page 17: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"P!

!

!

!!="%#&'())(*+,-&.//012*3&4125(6&712-&8>3&8:;:<!

!

<%* ]P^N* =3?3:& ?6& ?+08*+,809& A#,*0(,& GBH& #0-& =& 5#-& "((0& '#7%809& '()*& +0& ./((0& I*3& @()*& >,+?& J)9++-(&

3%#%)+'2*:&*#$$)I&(*#%* %"&*3=#()'#*<I&2* )'%&$/&9%)+'H*#'(*9#1&*6=+'*#*.$+6=*+,* $+6."84*[OO*=&+=8&*!* /+1&*

=&#9&,6884* =$+%&/%)'.H* E")8&* 1+/%* 9)$98&(* #$+6'(H* /)1=84* +7/&$I)'.* #'(* %#;)'.* =)9%6$&/* +,* %"&* YOJY]* 8)'&* +,*

=+8)9&*+'*7)9498&/*E"+*E&$&*78+9;)'.*+,,*%"&*/+6%"*/)(&*+,*3=#()'#*<I&2*@I&$*%"&*'&W%*^]*1)'6%&/*%+*#'*"+6$H*E&*

E)%'&//&(*#*/%&#()84*)'9$&#/)'.*'617&$*+,*$)+%*=+8)9&*&'%&$*%"&*)'%&$/&9%)+'*#'(*78+9;*+,,*&#9"*/)(&*!*,$+1*%"&*

E&/%*/)(&H*%+*'+$%"H*#'(*,)'#884*&#/%2*M"&*#9%)+'/*+,*%"&*=+8)9&*E&$&*)'*$&/=+'/&*%+*'+*I)+8&'9&*%"#%*?*9+68(*/&&*

,$+1*%"&*9$+E(2*<*=+8)9&*"&8)9+=%&$*E#/*9)$98)'.*%"&*)'%&$/&9%)+'*%"&*&'%)$&*%)1&2*M"&*/6((&'*#'(*6''&9&//#$4*

76$/%*+,*$)+%*=+8)9&H*)'%)1)(#%)+'*#'(*8#%&$*78#';&%*#$$&/%/*E&$&*9+1=8&%&84*$&9;8&//*#'(*)'()/9$)1)'#%&2*

!

!

!G"%#&'())(*+,-&.//012*3&4(*1)5(6&712-&893&8:;:<!

!

>4* 1+')%+$)'.* =#$%'&$* #'(* ?* ,+88+E&(* %"&* 1#$9"* +,* #7+6%* [OO* =$+%&/%&$/* (+E'* T+'.&* 3%$&&%* #'(* +'%+* M"&*

F/=8#'#(&2**<*8)'&*+,*=+8)9&*+,,)9&$/*($&//&(*)'*$)+%*.&#$*E)%"*E"#%*#==&#$&(*%+*7&*%&#$*.#/*.6'/*,+$1&(*#*8)'&*#7+6%*

[OO1*E&/%*+,*T+'.&*3%2*+'*M"&*F/=8#'#(&2**M"&*=$+%&/%&$/*/%+==&(*)'*,$+'%*+,*%"&*=+8)9&*8)'&*#'(*9+'%)'6&(*9"#'%)'.*

*5(&780()&*5(6&5#-&"((0&$5#0*809&>+,&#)&7+09&#)&'(&5#-&"((0&>+77+'809&*5(?&*5#*&-#6K&G458)&8)&'5#*&-(?+$,#$6&7++%)&

78%(LH:& G2(#$(>/7&A,+*()*LH:& G@5+1)& )*,((*)M&J/,& )*,((*)LH:&#0-&)+&+03& *M")/*9+'%)'6&(*+'* ,+$*#7+6%* %E&'%4*1)'6%&/*

E)%"+6%*%"&*=+8)9&*8)'&*+$*%"&*=$+%&/%&$/*1+I)'.H*+$*#'4%")'.*1+$&*%"#'*9"#'%)'.*#'(*9"&&$)'.2**M"&'H*,$+1*%"&*&#/%*

+6%*+,*39+%%*3%2H*#*8)'&*+,*=+8)9&*+,,)9&$/*)'*$)+%*.&#$*,+$1&(*#8+'.*M"&*F/=8#'#(&*#'(*1#$9"&(*%+E#$(/*%"&*9$+E(2**

*M"&*+,,)9&$/*)'*7+%"*=+8)9&*8)'&/*7&.#'*1#$9")'.*/8+E84*%+E#$(/*&#9"*+%"&$H*98#%%&$)'.*%"&)$*7#%+'/*#'(*/")&8(/H*#'(*

/+*,+$9)'.*%"&*9$+E(*%+.&%"&$2* *M"&*=+8)9&*8)'&/*/%+==&(*E"&'*%"&4*E&$&*#7+6%*[O1*1&%&$/*#=#$%2* *M"&*=$+%&/%&$/H*

#'(* #'4+'&* &8/&* E"+* "#==&'&(* %+* 7&* +'* %"&* /%$&&%* +$* /)(&E#8;H* E&$&* '+E* 7+W&(* )'* 7&%E&&'* %E+* =+8)9&* 8)'&/H*

)'986()'.* 14* =#$%'&$* #'(* ?H* #'(* %"$&&* =&+=8&* E"+* "#(* 7&&'* /%#'()'.* +6%/)(&* +,* #* $&/%#6$#'%H* /1+;)'.2* *M"&*

=$+%&/%&$/*9"#'%/*E"&$&*1+$&*6$.&'%*#'(*1+$&*+,%&'*=&+=8&*9#88&(*+6%*+,&$5#0*(-&'8*5&G2(#$(>/7&A,+*()*LH&#*&*5(&

=+8)9&*8)'&/2**3&I&$#8*%)1&/*%"&'H*#'(*)'*%"&*%)1&*%"#%*,+88+E&(H*/1#88*.$+6=/*+,*+,,)9&$/*E+68(*/6((&'84*9"#$.&*)'%+*

%"&*9$+E(H*.$#7*/+1&+'&*#'(*=688* %"&1*7#9;*7&")'(*%"&)$* 8)'&2*@'&*=$+%&/%&$*9#88&(*+6%*%+*%"&* 9$+E(*%+*/#4* %"#%*

&I&$4+'&*/"+68(*/)%*(+E'H*E")9"*1#'4*()(2* *M"&*9$+E(*E#/*169"*1+$&*K6)&%H*#'(*E&*#88*E&$&*E#)%)'.2* *!#88/*#'(*

$5#0*)&"(9#0&)#6809:&GN(*&/)&9+LH:&#0-&+0(&A,+*()*(,&$#77(-&+/*:&GJ%#6:&=1C(&7(#,0(-&?6&7())+0:&=&'#0*&*+&9+&5+?(&

0+'LH& *<,%&$*#'*"+6$*+$*1+$&*+,*E#)%)'.*8);&*%")/H*#'*+,,)9&$*#''+6'9&(*%"#%*),*E&*$#)/&(*+6$*"#'(/*#'(*E#)%&(*E&*

E+68(*#88*7&*=&#9&,6884*#$$&/%&(2* *M")/*E#/* %"&* ,)$/%* %)1&*E&*"#(*"&#$(*#'4*9+116')9#%)+'/* ,$+1* %"&*=+8)9&2* *>4*

=#$%'&$*#'(*?*E#)%&(*,+$*#'+%"&$*%E+*"+6$/*+$*/+*7&,+$&*)%*E#/*+6$*%6$'/*%+*7&*=688&(*,$+1*%"&*9$+E(*#'(*#$$&/%&(2***

* *

Page 18: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"Q!

!

Y# "#+/%&%#+3!#(!6#+(%+'$'+&!-+/!.'4-.!)%4*&3!95#+!/'&'+&%#+!!

!

M.0(.!/(!/3*!FHI4!'!/*,)(.'.2!+*/*&/0(&!-*&/.*!?'1!*1/'78013*+!(&!`'1/*.&!C@*&6*!0&!N565)95+,-8(,9-

*&+!/(!3(61*!/3(1*!+*/'0&*+!(.!'..*1/*+!+6.0&>!/3*!16,,0/:!!;3*!*1/'78013,*&/!(9!/301!#(*"+9*-*&/.*4!

'&+!0/1!10>&090-'&/!10<*4!16>>*1/1!/3'/!)(80-*!'&/0-0)'/*+!,'11!'..*1/1:!!M(80-*!3'@*!'!+6/2!/(!*&16.*!/3*!

?*89'.*! (9! )*.1(&1! 3*8+! 0&! -61/(+2! '&+!

9'-080/'/*! /3*! *A*.-01*! (9! /3*0.! -(&1/0/6/0(&'8!

.0>3/14!0&-86+0&>!/3*!.0>3/!/(!-(&/'-/!'!8'?2*.:!!!!!

!

;?(!DDEC!36,'&!.0>3/1!,(&0/(.1!?*.*!',(&>!

/3(1*! 1?*)/! 6)! 0&! '! ,'11! '..*1/! '/! /3*!

`1)8'&'+*!(&!K'/6.+'2!&0>3/4!'&+!+*/'0&*+! 9(.!

(@*.! "_! 3(6.1! $! /3*! ,'e(.0/2! (9! ?30-3! ?'1!

1)*&/! '/! /3*! +*/*&/0(&! -*&/.*:! ! ;3*2! 3'@*!

+*1-.07*+! 7*0&>! )8'-*+! 0&! -'>*1!?0/3! -(&-.*/*!

98((.14!-3'0&!80&5!?'881!'&+!-*080&>1!'&+!'!10&>8*!

)(./'78*! /(08*/:! ! ;3*! -*881! @'.0*+! 0&! 10<*4! 76/!

,'&2!?*.*!(@*.-.(?+*+:!!!!;3*!'..*1/**1!?*.*!

5*)/! 0&! )8'1/0-! ?.01/! /0*1! /3.(6>3(6/! /3*0.!

+*/*&/0(&:!T&*!DDEC!,(&0/(.!+*1-.07*+!1**0&>!

'! 9*88(?! '..*1/**!?3(1*!?.01/! /0*1!?*.*!,6-3!

/((! /0>3/:! ! b*! .*)*'/*+82! '15*+! /3'/! /3*2! 7*!

8((1*&*+! 76/! /301! ?'1! (&82! +(&*! '9/*.! ,'&2!

3(6.1:!!!!

!

C8/3(6>3! ,'&2! 0&+0@0+6'81! ?*.*! +*/'0&*+! 9(.!

&*'.82!'!+'24!9((+!'&+!?'/*.!?*.*!1-'.-*:!!T&*!

DDEC!,(&0/(.!?'1!>0@*&!,0&0,'8!9((+!'&+!(&82!

.*-*0@*+! /?(! 1,'88! -6)1! (9! ?'/*.! (@*.! /3*! "_!

3(6.1!/3'/!3*!?'1!+*/'0&*+:!!T&*!-6)!(9!?'/*.!

?'1!2*88(?!0&!-(8(6.!'&+!3*!1'0+! 0/!?'1!10,)82!

&(/!+.0&5'78*:! !N(&0/(.1!'81(!+*1-.07*+! 1**0&>!

'..*1/**1! +*&0*+! &*-*11'.2! ,*+0-'8! '//*&/0(&!

9(.!3(6.14!0&-86+0&>!'--*11!/(!0&1680&:!!!!

!

C8/3(6>3! /3*! /*,)(.'.2! +*/*&/0(&! -*&/.*!?'1!

)'./!(9!/3*!FHI!1*-6.0/2!)8'&&0&>!9(.!1(,*!/0,*!

\)(&! 8*'.&0&>! /3'/! /?(! DDEC! ,(&0/(.1! 3'+!

7**&! '..*1/*+4! $! -'88*+! /3*! /*,)(.'.2!

+*/*&/0(&! -*&/.*! '/! P^"ZCN:! D(&1/:! hhhhhh!

'&1?*.*+!'&+!$!*A)8'0&*+!/3'/!$!?'1!-(6&1*8!/(!

/?(! 0&+0@0+6'81! ?3(! 3'+! .*-*&/82! 7**&!

'..*1/*+4!).(@0+*+!/3*0.!&',*14!'&+!1'0+!/3'/!$!

?'&/*+!/(!/.'-5! /3*,!+(?&:!K3*!/(8+!,*!/3'/!

%E5/6-=628)*,-4211-3(11-E5/-4<8)-9<8E-3()&?-()*-

36&>!6):!;3*2!&*@*.!+0+:!

!

C/! "I^HQCN4! $! -'88*+! '&(/3*.! &6,7*.! $! ?'1!

>0@*&! '&+! 1)(5*! ?0/3! D(&1/! hhhhhh:! b*! /((5!

+(?&!/3*!&',*1!(9!/3*!DDEC!,(&0/(.1!'&+!,2!

)3(&*! &6,7*.4! '&+! /(8+! ,*! /3'/! 3*! ?(68+!

3'@*!/3*,!-'88!,*:!!;3*2!&*@*.!+0+:!

!

$!-'88*+!D(&1/:!hhhhhhh!7'-5!'/!'.(6&+!"^JIMN4!

'&+! 3*! /3*&! *A)8'0&*+! /(!,*! /3'/! 3*! 3'+! &(!

0+*'! 09! /3*! /?(! )*()8*! $! &',*+! ?*.*! 0&! /3*!

9'-080/24!'&+!/3*!(&82!?'2!(9!90&+0&>!(6/!?'1!/(!

,(@*!',(&>!/3*!-*881!'&+!2*88! /3*0.!&',*:!b*!

/(8+!,*! /3'/! 3*! 3'+! +0+! &(/! 3'@*! '--*11! /(! '!

-(,)6/*.! +'/'7'1*! +(-6,*&/0&>! ).01(&*.!

0&/'5*14!'&+!/3'/!3*!+0+!&(/!5&(?!?3(!?(68+:!!

b*!1'0+! 0/!?'1!@*.2!+01(.>'&0<*+!+(?&!/3*.*:! $!

?'1! &*@*.! '78*! /(! 1)*'5! ?0/3! *0/3*.! (9! ,2!

-80*&/1! 7*9(.*! /3*2! ?*.*! .*8*'1*+! "_! 3(6.1!

8'/*.:!

$

X'@0+!Y(1*/$*-C+A$6&4'5-A$2&.$00*($

!

Page 19: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"_!

!

7*9(.*! /3*! 16,,0/4! ,'&2! (9! /3(1*! +*/'0&*+! 0&10+*! +*1-.07*+! '! /(/'8! 8'-5! (9! (.>'&0<'/0(&! '&+!

1671/'&/0'8!7'-58(>1!0&!/3*!).(-*110&>!'&+!.*8*'1*!(9!'..*1/**1:!!D(6./!1*.@0-*1!(990-*.1!?(.50&>!'/!/3*!

38)968-35/1*-)59-(),486-(668,988,+-_/8,925),-(05/9-4<8)-9<8E-45/1*-08-.6538,,8*-56-6818(,8*S- - M)-

1(,*!-'1*14!'!>.(6)!(9!'..*1/**1!?*.*!/(8+!.*)*'/*+82!/3'/!/3*2!?(68+!7*!.*8*'1*+!13(./824!(&82!/(!7*!

3*8+!9(.!1*@*.'8!,(.*!3(6.1!7*9(.*!).(-*110&>!7*>'&:!!

!

C..*1/**1!3'+!&(!())(./6&0/2!/(!61*!/3*!)3(&*!(.!'--*11!8*>'8!-(6&1*8:!!;301!01!'!1*.0(61!@0(8'/0(&!(9!

!"#$%&$* .0>3/1! '&+! 7'10-! ).0&-0)8*1! (9! 96&+',*&/'8! e61/0-*:! !N'&2! (9! /3(1*! +*/'0&*+! 0&! /3*! -*&/.*4!

0&-86+0&>! /3*!DDEC!,(&0/(.14!?*.*!&(/! -3'.>*+!?0/3!-.0,0&'8!(99*&-*1:! ![(&*/3*8*114!(6.!,(&0/(.1!

?*.*! )3(/(>.')3*+4! 167e*-/! /(! @0+*(! 16.@*088'&-*! /3.(6>3(6/! /3*0.! +*/*&/0(&4! '&+! (&*! ?'1!

0&/*.@0*?*+!72!)(80-*!?308*!7*0&>!@0+*(/')*+:! !K(,*!'..*1/**1!?*.*!'15*+!/(!).(,01*4!6)(&!7*0&>!

.*8*'1*+4!&(/!/(!)'./0-0)'/*!0&!'&2!FHI!).(/*1/1:!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*

*

*

!

Page 20: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

"U!

!

! !

Page 21: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

HI!

!

0PO0*><KPO$

M)-9<8-''@A+,-D284?-.51232);-*/62)>!/3*!FHI!K6,,0/!0&!;(.(&/(!'))*'.*+!*A-*110@*!0&!/3*!+'21!8*'+0&>!

6)!/(!/3*!K6,,0/:! !;3*!@*.2!30>3!&6,7*.!(9!)(80-*!(990-*.1!-.*'/*+!'&!'/,(1)3*.*!(9! 0&/0,0+'/0(&!

'&+!'81(!'!1*&1*!(9!?'1/*+!.*1(6.-*1:!!!

!

T&! K'/6.+'24! ?3*&! @'&+'801,! '&+! '-/1! (9! ).()*./2! +*1/.6-/0(&! (--6..*+4! )(80-0&>! /6.&*+! )6&0/0@*!

/(?'.+1!).(/*1/*.1:!!DDEC!'-5&(?8*+>*1!/3*!.51238-=5638,+-8T.1()(925)-9<(9-362:2)(1-818:8)9,-4868-

,0A*+! 0&! ?0/3! 8'.>*.! >.(6)1! (9! )*'-*968! ).(/*1/*.1:!!

;3*.*!01!&(!+(67/!/3'/!/301!?**5*&+!).*1*&/*+!'!@*.2!

+0990-68/!8'?!*&9(.-*,*&/!1-*&'.0(:!![*@*./3*8*114!/301!

+(*1!&(/!e61/092!'!,'11!161)*&10(&!(9!7'10-!-0@08!.0>3/1:!

$/! 01!)(11078*! /(! 9**8!(6/.'>*!'7(6/!'-/1!(9! @'&+'801,!

'&+! '/! /3*! 1',*! /0,*! .*-(>&0<*! /3*! 0,)(./'&-*! (9!

,'0&/'0&0&>! '! 9.**! '&+! e61/! 1(-0*/2! -(,,0//*+! /(!

9.**+(,!9.(,!'.70/.'.2!'..*1/!'&+!+*/*&/0(&! '&+!/3*!

).*16,)/0(&!(9!0&&(-*&-*:!!!$&!(6.!@0*?4!/3*!*A01/*&-*!

2)- N565)95- 5=- (- 35<569- 5=- 9<8- [01(37- 01537+- *58,- )59-

e61/092!'!161)*&10(&!(9!+*,(-.'/0-!.0>3/1!9(.!)*()8*!0&!

/3*!-0/2:!!!

!

T@*.! UII! 0&+0@0+6'81! 3'@*! 7**&! '..*1/*+:! ! b6&+.*+1!

3'@*!&(?!7**&! .*8*'1*+!?0/3(6/!7*0&>!-3'.>*+!?0/3!

'&2! -.0,0&'8! (99*&-*:! $&! @0*?! (9! /3*! 6&).*-*&+*&/!

&6,7*.1! (9! '..*1/14! /3*.*! .*,'0&! @*.2! 1*.0(61!

]6*1/0(&1!16..(6&+0&>!/3*!')).().0'/*&*11!(9!)(80-0&>!

/'-/0-1:!!;3*1*!]6*1/0(&1!+*,'&+!'&1?*.1:!

!

$/! 01!/3*!+6/2!(9!)(80-*!(990-*.1!/(!'-/!?0/3!9'0.&*11!'&+!*]6'&0,0/2!/(?'.+!'88!-0/0<*&1!0&!'--(.+'&-*!

?0/3! /3*! 8'?! (9! /3*! -(6&/.2:! ! ;3*! ).*16,)/0(&! (9! 0&&(-*&-*! '&+! /3*! ).(/*-/0(&! '>'0&1/! '.70/.'.2!

'..*1/1!'&+!+*/*&/0(&!'.*!'/!/3*!-(.*!(9!'!-(,,0/,*&/!/(!e61/0-*:! ! $&!(6.!@0*?4!/3*!1*-6.0/2!9(.!/3*!

16,,0/!?'1!0&'+*]6'/*!7*-'61*!0/!9'08*+!/(!6)3(8+!(6.!-(&1/0/6/0(&'8!-(,,0/,*&/1:!

!

;3*!DDEC!01!-'880&>!(&!'88!8*@*81!(9!>(@*.&,*&/!/(!/'5*!0,,*+0'/*!'-/0(&!/(!-(..*-/!/3*!?*'5&*11*1!0&!

/3*! 8*>'8! 9.',*?(.5! 16..(6&+0&>! )6780-! (.+*.! )(80-0&>! 9(.! 8'.>*! 1-'8*! *@*&/1:! $/! '81(!+*,'&+1! /3'/!

0&+*)*&+*&/! 0&]60.0*1!7*! -(&+6-/*+!?0/3! .*1)*-/! /(! 1*@*.'8!'1)*-/1!(9! /3*!)(80-0&>!+6.0&>! /3*!FHI!

K6,,0/:!!$&!)'./0-68'.4!?*!'15!9(.^!

C/!/3*!*&+!(9!/301!?**5*&+4!/3*!).*@'080&>!

9**80&>! $! 3'@*! 01! (&*! (9! 8(11:! ! S3*&!

K'/6.+'2i1!8'.>*82!)*'-*968!).(/*1/!/6.&*+!

6>824! @(0-*1! (9! +011*&/! ?*.*! 8(1/:!!

S0/&*110&>! 36&+.*+1! (9! )(80-*! (990-*.1!

'.(6&+! /3*! -0/24! ,2! )*.1(&'8! 1*&1*! (9!

1*-6.0/2! ?'1! 8(1/:! ! ! S3*&! )*()8*! ?*.*!

7*0&>!167e*-/!/(!.'&+(,!'&+!6&?'..'&/*+!

1*'.-3*1!'&+!+*/*&/0(&1! /(+'24! /3*0.! -0@08!

807*./0*1! ?*.*! 8(1/:! ! C&+! 90&'8824! ,(.*!

7.('+824! ,2! -(&90+*&-*! 0&! /3*! )(80-*! /(!

.*1)*-/! '&+! *&9(.-*! (6.! 8'?1! '81(!

1699*.*+!'!8(11:!!

!

00*($14,+'$.)C1"5$,&')"&.$

Page 22: Protecting Civil Liberties and Human Rights at the G20 · 9#! &+/3 /3!!! >(@*.&,*&/:!!!!!

H"!

!

!

": Y*)*'8! (.! 10>&090-'&/! ',*&+,*&/! /(! /3*! 5678)9* :+$;/* 5$+%&9%)+'* <9%* /(! ,**/! 7'10-!

-(&1/0/6/0(&'8!1/'&+'.+1!

!

H: S0/3+.'?'8!(9!'88!-3'.>*1!8'0+!6&+*.!/3*!5678)9*:+$;/*5$+%&9%)+'*<9%!

!

J: $,)8*,*&/'/0(&!(9!-(&168/'/0(&!'&+!/.'&1)'.*&-2!.*]60.*,*&/1!9(.!.*>68'/(.2!).(-*11*1!

!

Z: C)(8(>2!9.(,!/3*!T&/'.0(!>(@*.&,*&/!9(.!/3*!).(-*11!61*+!/(!'+()/!/3*!+*10>&'/0(&!)6.16'&/!

/(!/3*!5678)9*:+$;/*5$+%&9%)+'*<9%!!

!

L: E*>018'/0@*!9.',*?(.5!9(.!/3*!*1/'78013,*&/!(9!1*-6.0/2!)*.0,*/*.1!

!

P: Y*>68'/0(&!(9!&*?!-.(?+!-(&/.(8!/*-3&(8(>0*1!).0(.!/(!/3*0.!61*!'&+!+*)8(2,*&/!

!

Q: D(,)*&1'/0(&!9(.!/3*!7610&*11!(?&*.1!'99*-/*+!'&+!/3(1*!?.(&>96882!'..*1/*+!

!

_: C,*&+,*&/1!/(!/3*!!$)1)'#8*!+(&*/(!,(+*.&0<*!'&+!7.0&>!6)!/(!-(&1/0/6/0(&'8!1/'&+'.+1!/3*!

.65D2,25),-681(92);-95-%068(3<-5=-9<8-.8(38&?-%/)1(4=/1-(,,8:0128,&-()*-%6259,&!

!

U: R688!0&+*)*&+*&/!)6780-!0&]60.2!0&/(!/3*!'-/0(&1!(9!/3*!)(80-*!+6.0&>!/3*!FHI4!0&!)'./0-68'.^!

!

': ;3*!+01)*.1'8!(9!).(/*1/*.1!'/!/3*!+*10>&'/*+!+*,(&1/.'/0(&!10/*! 2)-B/88)+,-C(67-1(98-

'9/*.&((&4!K'/6.+'2!O6&*!HP/3!!

!

7: ;3*!+*/*&/0(&!'&+!,'11!'..*1/!(&!/3*!`1)8'&'+*!(&!/3*!&0>3/!(9!K'/6.+'2!O6&*!HP/3!!

!

-: ;3*! '..*1/1! '&+! )(80-*! '-/0(&1! (6/10+*! /3*! `'1/*.&! C@*:! +*/*&/0(&! -*&/.*! (&! /3*!

,(.&0&>!(9!K6&+'24!O6&*!HQ/3!

!

+: ;3*!).(8(&>*+!+*/*&/0(&!'&+!,'11!'..*1/!(9!0&+0@0+6'81!'/!a6**&!K/:!S:!'&+!K)'+0&'!

C@*:!(&!/3*!*@*&0&>!(9!!K6&+'24!O6&*!HQ/3!

!

*: ;3*!-(&+0/0(&1!(9!+*/*&/0(&!'/!/3*!`'1/*.&!C@*:!+*/*&/0(&!-*&/.*!!

!

!

!