9
", 07 14 1998 - - - 1.".1': 11111••11111 rA'at. .. 0IIid ... CASe NO: IlWooo.\\) 1 To lhe Hooonble Colllllllnllllle' of PI. I .... '11 mlllnallb:umtllls or l'llIlV lheftQf . ::t I. Nanw oralIIvcyinll pany(l6): 2. Nam.lllIllllllldtt$s I 8!DDdW!tz 4JBo-Mlrbd Wn:kIlD' .. - , 2 Rober! J. Knbkclo NIllllt: MtllllDlb. -- - J Oazy SdNIz . -- nOONS AlIdilkm.1 AOIllt(.) 01 .....,io\i ....lyli..' .It ...",,,! V", leN" -- 1!Il(I!<ctuAI PnlJl!'dr D.:D@m0'l! I 3. NlIIIUtlJ.lI ConveyllnC\': OM,'flte, - _. ---- 13\1\ ll, AIWlQll11lihUld o Stl1lrily 0 It!" .. .. _-- I o Oilier --_... - \) --- ... City: SI.lIll: 11..._ 7JI'; WIIll> I 6·12">11211·11-'111.\ & 4 AIkliIi.....I ...mcbl... I&IIdrNI""'1Il10l:t..-r' G]NI> 4. Arrtknlkm urpllh:lII Dumbc""s): If """"""... """ .... , .."', .... ". """""1'" ,-"' ..." .. """."" ,.,."., ... _- - --' A. ... 'IIIM NIl.lsl. II. ".lWnl 1'1...'" ---_...... -- - -_._- - _ .. . ----... -- - .._._-----_._--. ---- AUJiIB'Il:l1 n\lll1J..:n 0 QNIl ... -- .._. Vr> 5. N_l>lld "fpwty IDwlJom ''Gfll;\!l1l11ll! II. 1I111l11lo:r uf lUll! palenls IIlVOlvl'tl: I duclllllCnl.IIOl1hl N rnalll.'II: N-oIIJl\':_.____ MI!\IIIvl •• . --- 7. "'01"1 r ..... ('flt 1.2111')1: ." .................. U!M!ll-. .. -_. 0 I!htlll.... '11 ---"'-- Iwdlo;luttl P!IIlICI\l; IA'J);IlIB"'"L.. - .. GJ I\ulh.Jrit,"" II> Ill! J.:puo.il ;a.,\:\IUIII . _- -_ . Xireci .... 11m " Alglll1llllin BU;lI' _ .... -...- II -L'.-:U2L..-. - ---- ------------------_....... -. - .. IAll"'" "01'1,,_ "'rr ,,1 lhi, .... J>t II loy """",II Cily: .11..- ".11': flO.ClL- ;a.;\."PUFlU DO 'lOT "!>"E THIS SPACr. 9, SIOlIrmclll .nd .iplalu",·. To' ,hr r"'J' 'ifm! Aflll\\""II!C1' "".lllrlirl. ,hr ,.',m'hI';' ia 'n,.· eu"/ntln1" ..m' ,un .I,u.·h..,t '"'11)\' h II t "J/I.'r 'if,I..· ./4- '[bulIl"', C Dt - ...... «z-U-)'1'Ill -- ./7 ' Dille Nnlnr "I Pc",,,n Sir' Sil!NlI"" 'Ii uf -.:umDlblnll CUN .tint; I N. "'''·WII 't.p ."", -_..:.-_..-- -- ' .. -,-_. __.. __._... __.:.... __...._ ... ... __._. ............ __ ............ _ ... _.,._....__........- Dn fltl' drlarh 'hi!' f0r1iuft . M311 II' k 1\'\,:w,",,,'t1 'With U·I·,llll'llh·.l ' . .. '11 '·.'cnb ."d T .... .. I B" .. .\.Il .....nat.'lIl fO ., \",,,hl"atunI).t·. l;OZJI .. ,. Pubtia: hurtkn 1\'por1lftt. I'lf Ihi" ....\': th;" .. b 'f'-1;nJJl.:d Il> a\... .. Ah.)\I1 ;l·ll11inul' .. pet alIlI.:um-:nt tt, bl: l'd'\mtN. ' .... ,. ., dt-':lImt .., ",nd 4"'" \I:.r-4 m:wtIJ. .' ".'... :IJ1\J ft\'lcw",slhe ,.h\"\ll. \,'II)mmcnb Ihi5 bUnl\"R , ,.,.,im.le lO Ibc liS uno! Tra,km:ul. olr ... .". Offi,..: ,·r Inr"mMion S,'\cm<. 'J. \V.mintlon. ••nd '" II\< Illl",.·,oI .... U ..... RWPtl.,,, :,1 "'"itt'. 1\)651.00111. W.,hia!lun. I>.t'. JIJ5U.l ... ... :l: REEL: 9300 M492 DX29 Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 2 of 10 PageID #:6029

Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

",

07 14 1998- - -1.".1': 11111••11111 ~lT rA'at. ..11\.do~~0IIid ~...

CASe NO: IlWooo.\\)~

1 •To lhe Hooonble Colllllllnllllle'ofPI. I ....'11 mlllnallb:umtllls or l'llIlV lheftQf.

::tI. Nanw oralIIvcyinll pany(l6):

2. Nam.lllIllllllldtt$s 1"·llll.'tIY~ rart~lit:l): •I e:1~r 8!DDdW!tz 4JBo-Mlrbd Wn:kIlD' ..- ,~

2 Rober! J. Knbkclo NIllllt: MtllllDlb. I~-- -J Oazy SdNIz . -- IIII~AiIdJl~~ Ct!Jl)"!'RI~nOONSAlIdilkm.1 AOIllt(.) 01 •.....,io\i ....lyli..' .It...",,,! V", leN" --

1!Il(I!<ctuAI PnlJl!'dr D.:D@m0'l!I 3. NlIIIUtlJ.lI ConveyllnC\':

~~ As~lllnmcn. OM,'flte, - _. ----

S\lM~'loIl: 13\1\ ll, AIWlQll11lihUldo Stl1lrily A)!~~11ll'1Il0 C!uul~ It!" N~m... .._--

I o Oilier--_... -

\) --- ... City: ~blllmlm!l! SI.lIll: 11..._ 7JI'; WIIll>B.\ll,lll~m l>~,,': I 6·12">11211·11-'111.\ & 4 "'~2-'J~ AIkliIi.....I ...mcbl ... I&IIdrNI""'1Il10l:t..-r' Dv~~ G]NI>

~4. Arrtknlkm nu~t1~) urpllh:lII Dumbc""s):

If""""""..."""...., .."',...."."""""1'",-"'...".."""."",.,.".,..._----'A. ,.ul~nll\prl ...'IIIM NIl.lsl. II. ".lWnl 1'1...'"---_......_.-~._------- -- - -_._- - _..-._~.----...--._---~_._-_. -- - .._._-----_._--. ----

AUJiIB'Il:l1 n\lll1J..:n "~",,b<d'f 0 QNIl...-- .._.

Vr>

5. N_l>lld lIdd~,"fpwty IDwlJom '''I_pnlrlP.~ ''Gfll;\!l1l11ll! II. T\11~t 1I111l11lo:r uf 1II'II11~.II"I\" lUll! palenls IIlVOlvl'tl: IduclllllCnl.IIOl1hl N rnalll.'II:N-oIIJl\':_.____ MI!\IIIvl•• I~ ._~- --- 7. "'01"1 r..... 1~1 ('flt 1.2111')1: ." .................. U!M!ll-.1~lr"'lll.,..I"'~~':t'I!lJ)\/@h!QIII<l:~ -_. 0 I!htlll....'11

---"'-- Iwdlo;luttl P!IIlICI\l; IA'J);IlIB"'"L.. - ..GJ I\ulh.Jrit,"" II> Ill! ~~,'II'" J.:puo.il ;a.,\:\IUIII._- _._~. -_ .

Xireci AlftJr"'~,: .... ~ 11m " Alglll1llllin BU;lI' _.... -...- II flI.o",><IIl1lo'\'1IlIhl~

-L'.-:U2L..-. - ----------------------_.......-. - .. IAll"'" "01'1,,_ "'rr ,,1 lhi, ....J>t II Jt.'~)nr loy """",IICily: SUll~: .11..- ".11': flO.ClL-;a.;\."PUFlU

DO 'lOT "!>"E THIS SPACr.

9, SIOlIrmclll .nd .iplalu",·.

To' ,hr r"'J' 'ifm! Aflll\\""II!C1' "".lllrlirl. ,hrJ;'Tr.~";'·~,.',m'hI';' ia 'n,.· eu"/ntln1" ..m' ,un •.I,u.·h..,t '"'11)\' h II '11I~ t "J/I.'r

'if,I..·",i~-:I"ul.'."·I1IJJrlll. ./4-'[bulIl"', C Dt - ...... «z-U-)'1'Ill-- ./7 ' DilleNnlnr "I Pc",,,n Sir' Sil!NlI""'Ii uf Mltc~ -.:umDlblnll CUN .tint; I

Il~J8 N. "'''·WII 't.p ."", -_..:.-_..-- -- ' .. -,-_.__..__._...__.:....__...._..._-~-_ ...__._.............__............_..._.,._....__........-Dn fltl' drlarh 'hi!' f0r1iuft ~I~ •.

M311 tl'1~ulmn~, II' k 1\'\,:w,",,,'t1 'With I\.~VlroJ ~f'iH'r l"h\~t U·I·,llll'llh·.l ' .\~umlDb..hn,~r '11 '·.'cnb ."d T...."~m.J' ..~ I

B" .. .\.Il.....nat.'lIl fO.,\",,,hl"atun• I).t·. l;OZJI ..

,.Pubtia: hurtkn 1\'por1lftt. I'lf Ihi" ~nJ·rt' ~....\': th;".. b 'f'-1;nJJl.:d Il> a\....,a~.. Ah.)\I1 ;l·ll11inul'.. pet ~ ~alIlI.:um-:nt tt, bl: l'd'\mtN. ' ....1u.lin$I'n1~, . ., h"'\KW;"8-I~dt-':lImt.., ",nd ritlhnin~ 4"'" \I:.r-4 m:wtIJ. ~1 .'~ ~ ".'...mpl~dn! :IJ1\J ft\'lcw",slhe ,.;a"lpl~ ,,"I\~' ,.h\"\ll. S\.~~ \,'II)mmcnb rC',;)nJi,.~ Ihi5 bUnl\"R ~~ ,,.,.,im.le lO Ibc liS I'3I~nJ uno! Tra,km:ul. olr....". Offi,..: ,·r Inr"mMion S,'\cm<. I·K~-Inol'. 'J.\V.mintlon. O.C.!U~~I ••nd '" II\< Illl",.·,oI ~h.,~rncn' .... U.....¥~. P~pc"""Jh RWPtl.,,, :,1"'"itt'. 1\)651.00111. W.,hia!lun. I>.t'. JIJ5U.l ...

...~ :l:

PA~~~.,~..,REEL: 9300~~~-~Y~

M492

DX29

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 2 of 10 PageID #:6029

gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
Page 2: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

PATENT APPliCATION

ASSIGNMENt ANPAQREEMENT

for und in consideration 01 the :>UhI ofOne Dollar to till in Mild paid, and other good nndvaluable considerBtlon.lJi~ ,,--«ipl of which L.. hereby l\cknowlcdgcd. we.

Peter Strandwllz or Neenah, Wisconsin,Robert J. Knl.k"rn of Fori Way"t. IncUlIlba.

Gar)' Schulz 4)f Scbaumburg, mlnol~ IIIftd

Jan-Mlcbel Wytkolf of Schiliumbu~. 1111110111.

have sold. Il,~signcd nnd tr.msfem..d. ;Ind Ill> ht:reby sell. assign and IrJJlslbr unto

MOTOROLA, INC.. Il Odawllre corponlliun. huvinll II!> principal office In Schaumburg.Illinois. United Slalcs of Amenca. unt!

MEMOllVLlNK CORP•. Il Wi~llnsln I:lll'JlOtlltllln huvin$- II~ principal omc:u in UI 263 INon~m Rond. Unit 420. ,\wltl!)n. WI~{lOllln 541114. United Slales ot' Amerlcu

thuir su,·cessur:;.lI.",..I~ns. and Ic~ul h:l"rcllcnlullvl:lI, juinlly:lJ'ld "'qllllll~.lh~ "nllre rlghl,thle lindinterest for t~ Uni1ed SUlIl.'$ ofAnll:rio'a in lind tn cCl1ain invenlionll reMin!!. 10 improvcm....nt InSELF·CONTAINED WIREJ.t:SS ('AMERA DEVICE. WIIU:I.ESS CAMERA

SYSr..:M AND METHOD (Cml' (\11. RWOOO3tn, deM:ribcd. lIlu'lralcll ami claimed in anIlpplh:ll!iun l'or lA:1t1.~ PlIlentllt" l~' VIIiit'd Slale~ (lll\nlCril:lll:x~ul~1 by 1I~ 1m Ihe dallls indlculed

by our ~ignQlwe:l helnlY. Ln~et~r Wilh Ih~ enlire righl.lIlfe :lRd fnlell:~l. jlJfndy :tnd cquully.ln lindLo SliM applh:ulion. :lJ'ld in and tn LCI":Jli I';lleAl which may he iS~lIetll\poll Mild applicallDll. lind

upon any diVision. eJltellloinn. I:llnhnUillilln til n:ISSllC lherell!:

We h..'fCby ulso sdf. as-'1i!!n ;U!.llranlorcr Unll) lbe said MOTOROLA. INC. alltl

MEMORYl.INK ('ORP.••luinlly Illld \'qual\~" 'be enlire rillhl. ,llle IInll in'ern1 in Wld II' sait!illven.il)Q and in and to appliclllion~ I'\lr l..:llCr.- Palenllherelor in all c.,umriclo foreign 10 the United

Slates Ill'America. im:luding all ri1lhls under lilly UIltl utI inwrnlllinnal clln\'cnliun.'1 and tn:ulics inrespt.~1 Ilfsaki inv\lOlion 1I11d Mud "W1icu1,llIlS lor I.cIleJli Piltent in fo.\:i!!1l mUl1lrirs, und we

I'urthrr :Iuthllrize On: suit) MOTOROl·\.INC, and MEMORVI.'NK CORP.. 10 apply tilt leller,.,

P~lcml in foreir,n l:ountncs \IiretUy in illlllwn RlIIUc. ilntl tn claim priorily 01' ,he filing dlllc of Ihe

~:lid applicalion l"or lt~ltc(Jo PlIlent ..r the IInitl:d SlalCli 1)1' AmcriC'.J unller the provi~ions Ill' uny and

;]11 imenullionul conventions al1\lln:;Jtk'~.

We hereby uUlllori'/c und n'qU\'sl the Cummr..-sioner of Pillcnt~of the United Slall::; 1)1'Amelie" tI) is~u~,I..clleJliP.,1lenl up"n Ihe ;t1\m:.Sllid appl~Qtion, divi.'1inn. eXlcn.~ion, conllnualion (It

reislIue. 10 Ihe said MOTOROLA. INI " and MEMORYLINK CORP. for lhe sole u.o;e lmd behoof

of said ~.iOTnROl:A. INC, and MEMORYUNK CORP., their SUCL\:s.~\lrs. assigns llod IC!!111

H('ONHlIlJll·1 .

PATENTREEL: 9300 FnAl\1E: 0266

M493

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 3 of 10 PageID #:6030

gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
Page 3: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 4 of 10 PageID #:6031

Page 4: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 5 of 10 PageID #:6032

Page 5: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 6 of 10 PageID #:6033

Page 6: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

PATENT APPLICATION

ASSIGNMENT ANn AGBEEMIOO:

Por :lJld in consldcl1Ilion or Ihll slim ufOne DoUar to u.~ In hand paid. tind other good and. valuuble consldllratlon, Ille rceclpt ofwhich .Is hereby acknowledged. we,

Peter S.randwll~ or Neenah. Wisconsin,Robert J. Kniskern or Fort WII)'ne. Indiana.Gary Sehull of Sehallmburg, IUlnuls andJan-Michel Wycknrr of ~h.umburc, Illinois,

have sold. assigned und ltlU\."ferred•.md du htreby SOtII, as...ign IIIld 1I,llIsfer unto

MOTOROLA, INt.• 1I Delilware l:orpomtlnn. having lis prin¢iplll <'fficc In Schaumburg.Illinois. United Stnllls ofAmctlc.1, lind

MEMORVLlNK CORP.. a Wlscunsln corporlllion haVing it:. pnnl:ipnl office in at 2631

Nonhem Road, Unl1420, Aw1e10J1. Wiston.~n S4914. United SIDles ofAmericaIheir sUcceSSOr3, as.o;lgns, and Icgall\'presemulivCl', jolnlly and cqUllIJ)'. Ihe entire righI, IIlle andInlerest for lhc United StalC:I ofAl1ll!llcn in and 10 tenain Inventions rel:llinl! Ie) improvemenl InSELF·CONTAINED WIRELESS ('AMEBA DEVICE. WIRELESS CAMERA

SYSTEM AND METHOD (Case No BWOOO30I. de.'iCrlbed, illu~truted lind dnimcd in anappllcnlion for l.clttml Patent uflbe llnil..d Stules \)f t\merlcu eltt:CuIl:d hy u., lin the dllles indicliled

by (lllr signutulCs below. togdher wbl\ "Ie cnli~ right. title and.intet'C~I. jOintly lIIld equally. in and

10 said nppllc;ltion. und in lII1d 10 L:II~~ Pulenl whlcb may be issued ul'lIn !\llid nppliclilion. undupon any division. txlension. continuuti,," I>r rels-liut thereof.

We hl;rcby ul.liO sell. :lS!Iign and Iro!n)rcr unto ltu: .'IIIid MOTOROLA. INC, lind

MEMOR)'UNK. CORP•• jointly ami ~qIlQl/y.lhe entire rlghl. litle and mieresl in nnd to saidinvenuon·anti in and to QPPIiCllliolL'llrir l.etteTli Palenl therelllr in all to\lnlJi~ foreign to lhe United

Slates orAmeri.:a. including ull righh under any and all international c(.nVl:nlions und lrealies in

tespecl of :laid invention uml said :lpJllitatillns fot LelltTli PO.lIenl in foreign COlRllries. and we

funher QUlhOrilC the said MOTOROLA. INC. Qnd MEMORYlINK CORP.. to apply for leitersPotent in I(lteign counlrie.'~ directly in its uwn rnllm~. and 10 chum priori.y or Ihl: filing dale of Ihe

said ilpplicalion for Lenefs Patent of lhe United State:. of America under the proVision!> of lIny ood

all international conventions and trealie~

We heteby uUlhorizl: and nque:;1 the Commissioner tlf Patenl'luf Ihe IJpjled Stales of

America 10 issue Lellen P:uenl upon the aforesaid Ilppliclltion. division, elllcn!lion. continuation or

teissue. 10 .he s:ud MOTOROLA. 1f'C', U1L1 MEMORYllNK CORP.• for the sole use ood behoofof sard Mf)fOROLA,INC'. and MEMORYLINK CORP.• lheir ~iUcce~,.or". assigns IUld legal

HCO ("lll/'l~

. 1 •

PATENTREEL: 9300 FRAIv.lE: 0270

M497

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 7 of 10 PageID #:6034

gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
gvogt
Highlight
Page 7: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

representatives. to the lUll end of lIlu tel m ror which ~Ilid Letters Patent may be gronted. the seme

as they would have been held and enjoyed by \15 had this assignment not beenmade, und we

hereby authorize lUld rcque,t the equivalent nuthorilies in foreign countri~ tt' issue the patenls oftheir respccdvc countries to the said MOTOROLA. INC. and MEMORYUNK CORP. jointly lIJIdeqlially.

W..: ll8fee thllt, when requcsted. we wID, wllhoul chlll8e 10 $Aid MOTOROl.A. INC., but U1

Ill> cllpCnse: sign all papers, take nil rightful olUbs. IlJId do allllCts which l1llly be necessary.de:llrnbJe OJ convenlenl for lIeCuriJlg Mil QlIunlainlng palCnI., for said inventions in any nnd ull

countries and ror vesting tide theret,) in sum MOTOROLA. INC. and MEMORYLINK CORP.,their successors. Ull~lgnll amllepl n:pn'scntDllvClI or Jlominces.

We covenanI wilb Sllld MOTOROLA. INC. and MEMORYLINK CORP.. theirsuccessotll. ussigns and legal repre:lI:nluti\'Cs, thatlhll Jntercsll\fld property hereby conveyed is freefrom all priur llSsl~nmenl.l'rnnl, ml.J18.tgl:. license or other encumbrance.

Peter Slrandwil~ DATIi

(STATE OF

(COUNTY OF

1. _, 01 Nolllry Public in lind for Ibe COWIty and State aforesaid.do hereby cemf)' Ibut tbe same pelliUns whose~ are subscribed 10 the: foregoing instrument,Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and deliveredsaid Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury pcI lind deed for the uses and purpose~ therein set rOdlt.

Given under my hand and notnrial :.eaJ this _ day of_' 19 ~__

SEAL

HCD 6/1Wll-2-

Nl)tary Public

My commissIon expire:.:

PATENTREEL; 9300 FR.AlVIE; 0271

M498

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 8 of 10 PageID #:6035

Page 8: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 9 of 10 PageID #:6036

Page 9: Property, intangible® · 2015. 2. 3. · Ilppeared berOl~ me Ihls day in JlC"Oo IUId lICknowJcdBcd thallhcy signed. scaled and delivered said Instillment as their fl'tC and voJuntury

Case: 1:08-cv-03301 Document #: 315-48 Filed: 05/25/12 Page 10 of 10 PageID #:6037