37
7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015 http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 1/37 Working tog for a safer w Cavitation and Erosion on Marine Propellers Prepared by Dr Dmitriy Ponkratov, Senior Consultant, Fluid Dynamics Group, Technical Investigation Department 07 October 2015

Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

  • Upload
    kam-fc

  • View
    219

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 1/37

Working togfor a safer w

Cavitation and Erosion on Marine Propellers

Prepared by Dr Dmitriy Ponkratov,Senior Consultant, Fluid Dynamics Group, Technical Investigation Department07 October 2015

Page 2: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 2/37

Lloyd’s Register Ship Performance Group (SPG) 

ShipPerformance

Group

Fuelmanagement

team

Maintenancemanagement

team

CFD andhydro

optimisationteam

Measurementand

observationsteam

Navalarchitecture

and

engineeringteam

Fuels, lubes, emissionsand new technologies

Asset managementcondition

monitoring/maintestrategies

Technical andoperationaldesign/retrofit efficiency

Full-scale trials andmeasurement systemsdeployment

Propulsion and systemsoptimisation / logistics

planning and modelling

SPG: Meeting the challenges of

energy efficiency andenvironmental regulatorycompliance 

Page 3: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 3/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Model scale tests witnessing

• Resistance tests

• Propulsion tests

• Cavitation tests

• Erosion tests

• Paint tests

• Air bleeding tests

• Pressure pulses measurements

Page 4: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 4/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Cavitation tests at cavitation tunnels

First cavitation tunnel was built byin Newcastle in 1895

Page 5: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 5/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Cavitation tests

Page 6: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 6/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Cavitation tests at depressurised towing tank

Page 7: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 7/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Erosion tests at cavitation tunnel

Page 8: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 8/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Erosion tests at cavitation tunnel

Page 9: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 9/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Full scale measurements

• Cavitation observations

• Erosion inspections

• Sea trials measurements

• Pressure pulses measurements

Page 10: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 10/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Cavitation observations

Page 11: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 11/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Borescope Installation

Page 12: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 12/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Cavitation observations

Page 13: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 13/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Erosion inspections

Page 14: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 14/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Erosion due to Tip Vortex Cavitation

Page 15: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 15/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Erosion Inspection: Tip Vortex Damage from a Pre-Swirl Fin

Page 16: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 16/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Erosion Inspection: Monitoring Diver Inspections

Page 17: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 17/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Acoustic emission (AE) measurements

Page 18: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 18/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Acoustic emission measurements: Synchronised AE & Video

Page 19: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 19/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Thrust and Torque measurements

Page 20: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 20/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Rudder angle records

Page 21: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 21/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Shaft speed records

Page 22: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 22/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Computational Fluid Dynamic projects

• Hull form optimisation• Trim optimisation

• Cavitation modelling

• Erosion predictions

• Resistance predictions

• Performance predictions

• Other projects

Page 23: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 23/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Cavitation Erosion Prediction Semi cylinder

Page 24: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 24/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Cavitation-Erosion Prediction – Triangular Prism

Experiment

Maximum Impact Pressure

hear layer cavitation

Tip vortex

Maximum Erosive Potential

Maximum Impact Pressure

Page 25: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 25/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Case study 1 – Model scale hydrofoil NACA0015

• Computational domain identical to a

section of cavitation tunnel;• Conditions identical to cavitation tunnel

set up;

• Symmetry plane in the middle;

• Initial runs by RANS (K-Omega model);

• Final runs by DES;

• Trimmer mesh;

• 4 mill cells;

• Time step 1.0x10-6 sec

Page 26: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 26/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Case study 1 – Model scale hydrofoil NACA0015

Page 27: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 27/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Case study 1 – Model scale hydrofoil NACA0015

High Speed video frames from model test

CFD cavitation prediction

Solution time0.084415 s 

Solution time0.084825 s 

Solution time0.085595 s 

Solution time0.086245 s 

Soluti0.08

Page 28: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 28/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

High Speed video frames from model test

CFD cavitation prediction

Solution time0.084415 s 

Solution time0.084825 s 

Solution time0.085595 s 

Solution time0.086245 s 

Soluti0.08

Case study 1 – Model scale hydrofoil NACA0015

Page 29: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 29/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Case study 1 – Model scale hydrofoil NACA0015

Flow 

Modeltest paintremoval

Erosivefunction

N1

Erosivefunction

N5

Erosivefunction

N8

Flow 

Flow 

Flow 

Page 30: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 30/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Case study 2 – Ship scale containership’s rudder in wake 

Simulation conditions identical to shipsea trials;

• Initial runs by RANS (K-Omega model);

• Final runs by DES;

• Trimmer/ Polyhedral mesh

• 16 mill cells (11.5 mill in rotation part);

• Time step 0.001 sec

Page 31: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 31/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Case study 2 – Ship scale containership’s rudder in wake 

Stage 1.

Whole domain simulation with free surfacebut without cavitation.

Stage 2.

Aft part of the domain simulation withcavitation.

Symmetry condition on the wavy freesurface.

Page 32: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 32/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Case study 2 – Ship scale containership’s rudder in wake 

C d 2 Shi l i hi ’ dd i k

Page 33: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 33/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

• After the activation of cavitationmodel the hub vortex was observed;

• The tip vortex propagation was notresolved completely due to thecoarse mesh downstream ofpropeller blades.

Case study 2 – Ship scale containership’s rudder in wake 

C t d 2 Shi l t i hi ’ dd i k

Page 34: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 34/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Propeller 

Rudder 

Rudder 

Case study 2 – Ship scale containership’s rudder in wake 

Paint damage area 

Erosive Function№5  Erosive Function

Erosive Function

C t d 3 Shi l ll i k

Page 35: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 35/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Case study 3 – Ship scale propeller in wake 

Cavitation growth in the wake peak

C i i E i P di i

Page 36: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 36/37

Technical Investigation Department, 7 October 2015

Cavitation-Erosion Prediction

Page 37: Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

7/26/2019 Propeller Cavitation RINA Presentation 7 October 2015

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/propeller-cavitation-rina-presentation-7-october-2015 37/37

Lloyd’s Register and variants of it are trading names of Lloyd’s Register Group Limited, its subsidiaries and affiliates. Copyright © Lloyd’s Register EMEA. 2015. A member of the Lloyd’s Register group. 

Dr Dmitriy PonkratovSenior ConsultantTechnical Investigation DepartmentE [email protected] 

Lloyd’s Register EMEA 

Global Technology Centre, Southampton Boldrewood InnovationCampus, Building 175, Burgess Road, Southampton, SO16 7QF

Working togfor a safer w