PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015 ......The Informed Voter Project Don’t just Vote. Select! PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015 Wards K/W, K/E, H/E, H/W WAS YOUR CORPORATOR

The Informed Voter Project Don’t just Vote. Select!

PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015

Wards K/W, K/E, H/E, H/W

WAS YOUR CORPORATOR THE RIGHT CHOICE?

Don’t just Vote. Select!

Content Explanation Source

Attendance Total of General Body Meetings and Committee Meetings. Average attendance of 227 corporators = 77%

• www.Praja.org • RTI reply from BMC.

Corporator Fund Expenditure Status

Each corporator is entitled to two funds annually- (1) Corporator Fund, and (2) Development Fund.

• Entitlement- http://bit.ly/1PLOq2N • Corporator Fund Expenditure Data-

http://portal.mcgm.gov.in/irj/portal/anonymous/qlpurordcdetails. Average Expenditure of 227 corporators = 92.97%

• Development Fund info not included in this report.

Financial Year

Corporator Fund annual entitlement

Development Fund annual entitlement

2012-13 60 lakh 40 lakh

2013-14 60 lakh 40 lakh

2014-15 60 lakh 1 crore

Promise & Performance One-liners

Each corporator was asked the following questions in the interview conducted by MumbaiVotes- (1) Performance: Major work done in term so far (2) Promises: Plans for remaining part of term.

Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video/audio interview with MumbaiVotes.

Contact Details Phone number provided. Find more on website. Affidavit filed for candidature

CONTENT BRIEF & DATA SOURCE


PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATORS (CITY LEVEL ISSUES)

URBAN PLANNING EDUCATION ENVIRONMENT ROADS PUBLIC TRANSPORT

POVERTY ALLEVIATION HEALTH ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WATER SUPPLY SLUM IMPROVEMENT

₹


MUMBAI = 227 WARDS = 227 CORPORATORS

RULING COALITION

77

30

53

28

14 11 9

2 1 1 1 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

SHS BJP INC MNS IND NCP SP ABS RPI(A)

BSKP BRKP

NO

. OF

CO

RP

OR

ATO

RS

POLITICAL PARTIES


Questions SHS Response BJP Response

A plan will be made for more parking space No Response No Response

Plan shall be made to give concession and encouragement for those co-operative societies who keep their building premises clean.

No Response No Response

Graveyards will be made available with PNG gas (natural gas) to prevent excess use of wood and to stop pollution and bad smell.


In order to prevent diseases like Thalassemia, AIDS etc., blood testing services shall be provided at the Municipal Corporation's laboratory at very cheap rates.


All municipal schools will be repaired and have computer labs in the next three years. No Response No Response

Bus services like 'Fort-ferry' shall be started in the many parts of Mumbai city and suburbs. No Response No Response

Policy of developing 'Hawkers ground' shall be accepted. No Response No Response

Project affected citizens of Mumbai due to different municipal projects shall be given houses or compensation as per 'Ready-reckoner' for which 15 years inhabitation shall be the eligibility.


RULING COALITION PARTY PERFORMANCE A questionnaire* consisting of projects and plans promised in the Shiv Sena – Bharatiya Janta Party (SHS-BJP) 2012 MCGM Manifesto was first sent to the Shiv Sena and BJP spokespersons on April 26, 2015. Despite several follow-ups, this was the response we received-

* Few promises stated here. Questionnaire listed 117 promises extracted from SHS-BJP 2012 MCGM Manifesto.


PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT PARAMETERS

CORPORATOR’S CONTACT NUMBER LINK TO INTERVIEW

PROMISE: WORK TO BE DONE

PERFORMANCE: WORK DONE

ATTENDANCE

CORPORATOR FUNDS EXPENDITURE

QUALITATIVE Time Period: March 2012 – October 2015

QUANTITATIVE Time Period: March 2012 – March 2015


PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT IN 6 CLUSTERS

COVERED IN THIS REPORT: CLUSTER 1- Constituency Numbers 53-97 K/W: Andheri (W), Vile Parle (W), Jogeshwari (W) K/E: Andheri (E), Vile Parle (E), Jogeshwari (E) H/E: Bandra (E), Khar (E), Santacruz (E) H/W: Bandra (W), Khar (W), Santacruz (W)


0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

AT

TEN

DA

NC

E (i

n %

)

K/E Ward Corporators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

AT

TEN

DA

NC

E (i

n %

)

K/W Ward Corporators

ATTENDANCE

Below Average Above Average


ATTENDANCE

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

AT

TEN

DA

NC

E (i

n %

)

H/W Ward Corporators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

AT

TEN

DA

NC

E (i

n %

)

H/E Ward Corporators



0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

CO

RP

OR

ATO

R F

UN

D E

XP

END

ITU

RE

(in

%)

K/E Ward Corporators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

CO

RP

OR

ATO

R F

UN

D E

XP

END

ITU

RE

(in

%)

K/W Ward Corporators

CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE STATUS Below Average Above Average


CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE STATUS

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

CO

RP

OR

ATO

R F

UN

D E

XP

END

ITU

RE

(in

%)

H/W Ward Corporators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

CO

RP

OR

ATO

R F

UN

D E

XP

END

ITU

RE

(in

%)

H/E Ward Corporators



AREA: K/W Ward- Andheri (W), Jogeshwari (W), Juhu, Vile Parle (W) Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes

CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.

Changej Jamal Multani IND INFRASTRUCTURE: I have fulfilled 70% promises of working on beautification, health and Education.

OTHER: The rest 30% of the promises will be fulfilled in the remaining one and half years.

https://youtu.be/UAay6l4VPdc

9870477866/ 9987877866/ 8879997053

Raju Shripad Pednekar

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have started the Ma Sahib Ayurvedic Krida Maidan with zones for children, youth & senior citizens.

SANITATION: I will begin the Zero Garbage Campaign.

http://youtu.be/OEarEPibo2E

9820878555/ 9987814555/ 8879997054

Jyotsna Abhay Dighe INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have put up 156 light poles on the road.

OTHER: In the coming month I will I will go and meet the people, understand their problems and work for them.

https://youtu.be/R4dgMjqnePQ

9821321322/ 9869017046/ 8879997055

Yashodhar Padmakar Phanse

SHS

INFRASTRUCTURE: Most of the 16 gardens, playgrounds and I.G. plots have been developed.

INFRASTRUCTURE: The repairs of the remaining gardens, playgrounds and I.G. plots will be completed.

https://youtu.be/1PHyCptNFOQ

9821004312/ 8879997056



Devendra Shridhar Amberkar

INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have placed a proposal for widening of Captain Sahakar Road.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will construct a gymnasium, jogging track and cycling track in Tank Plot playground.

https://youtu.be/Qz7AcuJgxos

9322290027/ 9224519415/ 8879997057

Jyoti Jitendra Sutar

SHS

*Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9869190985/ 9819179913/ 8879997058

Vanita Kailash Marucha

INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I've developed the Dadabhai Naoroji garden and Janar Patel garden

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will convert the Hindu cemetery into a CNG-run Crematoria.

https://youtu.be/KX73fWB_RkI

9969224632/ 9869017646/ 8879997059

Sanjay Kashinath Pawar

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have widened and asphalted Bhai Bhagat Marg- the road on which my office is located.

*No reply* https://youtu.be/y5Q0sCeYPPw

9869033101/ 9757293122/ 8879997060

Mohsin Haji Haider INC INFRASTRUCTURE: Cama Road and Dadabhai Road have been reconstructed.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will widen J. P. Road and improve access to water for Gilbert Hill residents.

https://youtu.be/Pq0bxh5CF78

9833102708/ 9920664876/ 8879997061




Ameet Bhaskar Satam BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have built Mumbai's first vertical garden in the public space in my ward.

INFRASTRUCTURE: My plan to construct India's first beach board- walk to connect Juhu and Versova beaches is awaiting environmental approval.

https://youtu.be/zsMp0xQcIJU

9820347179/ 9930712998/ 8879997062

Dilip Ghanshyam Patel BJP SANITATION: I have worked towards the cleanliness, and safety of tourists in Juhu.

LAW AND ORDER: I will install security lights and CCTV for tourists’ safety.

https://youtu.be/OLLj-j5GDNU

9820175393/ 8879997063

Bhavna Ameet Mangela

IND INFRASTRUCTURE: I have made toilets in slums & improved garbage collection.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will build playground for slum children.

https://youtu.be/cFhg0AEADQA

9892183635/ 9004043567/ 8879997064

Binita Mehul Vora INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have developed and resurfaced many roads.

SANITATION: I aim to create a clean and hygienic Vile Parle.

https://youtu.be/zhHQqK1geXM

9820019472/ 9820954517/ 8879997065



AREA: K/E Ward- Andheri (E), Jogeshwari (E), Vile Parle (E) Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes


Ujjwala Shrikrushna Modak

BJP

*Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9820333203/ 8879997066

Manjiri Gurunath Parab

SHS

HOUSING: Due to my proposal drafted with the MLA, BMC has given 500 homes to the Project Affected Persons in Borivali.

*No reply* https://youtu.be/UAE4LAxDWlo

9969457170/ 8879997067

Anant Bhiku Nar

SHS

INFRASTRUCTURE: I have concretized roads and constructed Devidas Vitthal Sahasingikar Udyan.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will construct a sculpture park near PMGP colony

https://youtu.be/UAE4LAxDWlo

9702597025/ 8879997068

Shivani Shailesh Parab

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have set up a gym for senior citizens

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will try to set up as many such gym facilities in other gardens too .

https://youtu.be/ku9q8VT0vVw

9320671296/ 8879997069

Bhalchandra Gangaram Aambure

MNS

INFRASTRUCTURE: I have installed high mast lights in Maryadey Mamadawdey Chowk.

*No reply * https://youtu.be/-PFQJRXCPdg

9869360739/ 8879997070



Sandhya Sunil Yadav SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* -----

9820333203/ 8879997071

Sunita Janardan Elawadekar

SHS


Kesarben Murji Patel INC


Pramod Pandurang Sawant

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have built storm water drains and setup high mast streetlights

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will build toilets for slum dwellers

https://youtu.be/ZccTcFOCb3g

9820534960/ 8879997074

Sushma Kamlesh Rai INC

INFRASTRUCTURE: I have set up gyms in Bir Appuhamid and Lokbharti Gardens

SANITATION: I will work on cleanliness

https://youtu.be/KQCxUxm7JlA

9820006069/ 8879997075




Smita Subhash Sawant SHS SANITATION: I have worked on cleanliness in my ward.

MISCELLANEOUS: I will provide senior citizens with identity cards, ambulance & recreational facilities.

https://youtu.be/2YaOdDAi4mQ

9920132720/ 8879997076

Winnifred Baptist D'Souza

INC COMMUNITY AFFAIR, INFRASTRUCTURE: I have established balwadis for different communities, such as Walmiki Balwadi, Tamilian Balwadi and Saibaba Balwadi.

COMMUNITY AFFAIR: I will renovate the Catholic Community Cross in my village- Bamanwada.

https://youtu.be/9jYKpRqo3eY

9892525885/ 8879997077

Manisha Manohar Panchal

SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9167879277/ 8879997078

Shubhada Shashikant Patkar

SHS

INFRASTRUCTURE: In the last 3 years nearly 15 roads have been Renovated.

*No reply* https://youtu.be/Ha8IGl008kQ

9869903951/ 8879997079

Jyoti Parag Alavani

IND

INFRASTRUCTURE: I have repaired gutters, footpath and toilets.

HEALTH AND SANITATION: I will try to build more toilets and will follow up with the concept of a toilet in every house.

https://youtu.be/UAE4LAxDWlo

9702597025/ 8879997080



AREA: H/E Ward- Bandra (E), Khar (E), Santacruz (E) Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes


Snehal Suhas Shinde MNS SANITATION: I have initiated door-to-door garbage collection, directly by BMC vans.

INFRASTRUCTURE : I will install CCTV cameras in the underground subway.

https://youtu.be/bqEElIVTgeM

9820400436 8879997081

Sukhada Rahul Pawar MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have just started an MSDP project by constructing two storey toilets in D'mello compound and Subramaniam Nagar.

WOMEN & CHILD DVPT.: I will make available livelihood opportunities for the local women.

https://youtu.be/VSU7bWKyr2U

9702632294 8879997082

Sunaina Sanjay Potnis

SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview*

----- 7666717484/ 8879997083

Brian Francis Miranda

INC

SANITATION: Kalina Talav work which has been pending since 20 years is under process, and 75% of the work is done.

INFRASTRUCTURE: After the rainy season, the people shifted from CST road will be given another place.

https://youtu.be/CGbOg8LClN8

9322266097/ 8879997084




Ilyas Basheer Shaikh IND INFRASTRUCTURE: I have worked on the slum rehabilitation scheme and on the MHADA scheme.

LEGAL AFFAIR, INFRASTRUCTURE: I wish to make a Link Road for which I have approached the High Court to make a Link Road.

https://youtu.be/d3cDWvddF9g

9820793551/ 8879997085

Krishna (Mahesh) Dhondu Parkar

BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got nine main water pipelines installed.

SANITATION: In the coming month I will get a ground-plus-one structure constructed housing atleast 40 public toilets.

https://youtu.be/eBMN4o93wtE

9819084320/ 8879997087

Pooja Vishwanath Mahadeshwar

SHS ECONOMIC AFFAIR: I have made budget provision for a trauma centre, dialysis centre and NICU in V. N. Desai hospital..

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will make 11th Road of cement concrete.

https://youtu.be/JsYlOi_Wv9w

9869824264/ 8879997086

Deepak Ramachandra Bhutkar

SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: Nullah at Sadguru & MHADA were concretized.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will install a chimney at the crematorium to prevent asthma and breathing ailments.

https://youtu.be/Oa-VjL7AmN0

9820369193/ 8879997088




Anil Pandurang Doke SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have completed concretization of Nanasaheb Dharmadhikari and Sant Dnyaneshwar Marg.

INFRASTRUCTURE: A great problem facing Harmandir road is water logging for which a sewerage line project shall be begun in October.

https://youtu.be/zb09rlRNRs8

9869276723/ 889997089

Priyatama Sharadkumar Sawant

INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I got the approval for a nine inch pipline in Naupada

INFRASTRUCTURE: I wish that the slums go in for redevelopment that will improve the quality of life of the people.

https://youtu.be/PMH1qAZRgX8

9320461204/ 8879997090

Dr. Gulistan Ahrar Ahmad Shaikh

INC MISCELLANEOUS: Under the Right to Education I had filled approximately 500 to 600 admission forms out of which 250 to 300 forms were accepted and those children were inducted into good and reputed schools.

*No Reply* https://youtu.be/bzrJ3NWk6CE

9221639707/ 887997091


AREA: H/W Ward- Bandra (W), Khar (W), Santacruz (W) Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes


Geeta Bala Chavan MNS WOMEN & CHILD DVPT: I have set up a women’s self help group.

*No Reply* https://youtu.be/Y19wdnap5HU

9867660605/ 8879997092

Alka Subhash Kerkar BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I worked for the

improvement of roads and footpaths.

SANITATION: I would like to have

all the dustbins in my ward to be

removed for collection and

segregation of garbage to be

done on a larger scale.

https://youtu.be/

c5U-HOIOTfr

9820545333/

8879997093

Sunita Suresh Wavekar

INC WATER, INFRASTRUCTURE: 80% of water

problems solved and 50% of the 5

gardens are repaired.

INFRASTRUCTURE: I will

construct a foot bridge from Juhu

beach to Ram Mandir.

https://youtu.be/

KXgQhZPoiVA

9820545333/

8879997094

Asif Ahmed Zakheria INC SANITATION: I have been following up since the last almost 7 to 8 years for the beautification of the Bandra talav (lake) which now is seeing the light of day.

*No Reply* https://youtu.be/V2Cj1z3iPxk

9820125638/ 8879997095


AREA: H/W Ward- Bandra (W), Khar (W), Santacruz (W) Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video with MumbaiVotes


Karen Allen Cecilia D’mello

INC HEALTH & SANITATION: I have solved problems when it comes to garbage, road issues, drains.

HEALTHCARE: I am here to arrange for treatment of people denied healthcare access in public hospitals.

https://youtu.be/dJpoAU4Iy_g

9820577231/ 8879997096

Tanveer Ali Patel INC INFRASTRUCTURE: My focus has been on providing sanitation, cleanliness and better infrastructure like toilets, water lines, sewerage connectivity, pathways, drainage, solar lighting.

MISCELLANEOUS: I will enhance the various civic facilities affecting the people on a daily basis.

https://youtu.be/E_xkPBjO4mc

9022159964/ 8879997097


What this report won’t do… What can you do? Let them know that you are watching them!

SMS or call your corporator and let

them know- “I have read the

MumbaiVotes Report Card.”

Signup for regular updates for your

corporator’s promises & performance-

http://mumbaivotes.com/pages/newsletter/

You have the Right to Copy

(The MumbaiVotes ‘Copy Right’ Law)

- Share this report

- Share the videos

Make an issue about your issues-

Call/SMS your corporator and request

him/her to address your civic issues.

Like on Facebook: www.facebook.com/MumbaiVotes Follow us on Twitter: @mumbaivotes

Documents

PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015 ......The Informed Voter Project Don’t just Vote. Select! PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015 Wards K/W, K/E, H/E, H/W WAS YOUR CORPORATOR